Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research Paper: Mahesh Godbole Role of Coaching and Use of ICF Competencies in Conflict Management
Research Paper: Mahesh Godbole Role of Coaching and Use of ICF Competencies in Conflict Management
Research Paper: Mahesh Godbole Role of Coaching and Use of ICF Competencies in Conflict Management
mahesh.godbole@hrpartnersindia.com
Complete your coaching model in the space below. Then email this document as an attachment to assessment@icoachacademy.com
Copyright 2006 International Coach Academy Pty. Ltd. Use is governed by the Terms and Conditions at http://www.icoachacademy.com
This
article
provides
thought
for
the
reader
on
how
can
the
skills
learned
in
Coaching
be
applied
for
resolving
conflict
in
a
group
which
is
working
towards
a
common
objective,
but
has
different
perspectives
and
engagement
drivers.
The
article
also
makes
a
case
that
the
the
ICF
competencies
to
coaching
are
an
appropriate
tool
to
deploy
in
conflict
Management
situations.
A
dictionary
meaning
of
conflict
is
conflict
verb
(used
without
object)
1.
to
come
into
collision
or
disagreement;
be
contradictory,
at
variance,
or
in
opposition;
clash.
2.
to
fight
or
contend;
do
battle.
Conflict
by
a
common
understanding
denotes
that
there
a
divergence
of
ideas
between
2
or
more
parties
as
to
how
they
see
moving
forward.
It
means
reaching
cross
roads
.Managing
conflict
means
resolving
the
disagreement
and
making
choice
on
which
path
to
take
A
conflict
can
at
times
be
also
between
oneself
when
choosing
between
alternatives
is
difficult,
specially
when
one
alternative
needs
to
be
jettisoned.
We
will
not
worry
too
much
about
this
in
the
present
context.
Here
we
are
more
interested
in
understanding
conflict
between
2
or
more
Individuals
or
groups
and
how
coaching
can
help
in
addressing
conflict.
In
order
to
to
do
that
let
us
look
at
what
conflict
actually
means,
what
are
points
of
origin
and
the
manifestation
of
conflict
as
is
seen
Conflict
is
a
felt
struggle
between
two
or
more
interdependent
individuals
over
perceived
incompatible
differences
in
beliefs,
values,
and
goals,
or
over
differences
in
desires
for
esteem,
control,
and
connectedness.
This
definition
emphasizes
several
unique
aspects
of
conflict
(Wilmot
&
Hocker,
2011).
1. Conflict
is
struggle
:-
It
is
the
result
of
divergent
forces
coming
together
and
the
need
of
those
divergent
forces
to
stay
together
for
a
period
of
time,
or
for
the
purpose
of
completion
of
a
task
or
an
action
2. Interdependence:-
There
needs
to
be
interdependence
of
parties
on
each
other.
If
the
same
is
not
required,
the
situation
will
not
stand
test
of
being
called
as
a
Copyright 2006 International Coach Academy Pty. Ltd. Use is governed by the Terms and Conditions at http://www.icoachacademy.com
conflict. Indifferent parties, with even extreme views cannot have conflict as they seldom need to work together 3. Differences:- In all types of conflict there are differences between parties that bring about a conflict. The differences can stem out of various origin points such as values and beliefs, needs and the role one needs to play Further conflicts can be based on Content or Relationships
Some
examples
of
Relationship
conflict
can
be
the
ones
arising
out
of
Issues
of
Esteem
:-
Stems
out
of
the
need
to
be
respected
and
given
space
as
one
thinks
his
position
demands.
In
Organisations
it
is
driven
more
by
power
and
Position
.
A
superior
can
feel
that
he
needs
to
be
heard
and
respected
at
work.
This
at
times
gets
carried
in
non
work
areas
as
well
.
There
is
a
need
of
control
amongst
all
of
us
and
the
degree
of
control
can
vary
from
time
to
time
and
situation
to
situation.
However,
this
degree
of
control
when
starts
trespassing
on
others
perceived
territory
conflict
can
result
Conflict
at
the
Content
Level
This
can
be
at
two
sublevels
Copyright 2006 International Coach Academy Pty. Ltd. Use is governed by the Terms and Conditions at http://www.icoachacademy.com
Values and Beliefs :- While we come to work together in teams and are supposed to perform certain predetermined tasks, we also bring a long list of values and beliefs we carry and use those as a tool to judge others. If we were mechanical in our work life and had no history, (baggage) possibly conflict could have been less. Goals and Objectives:- Many a time by design and in many organizations, goals for one group may and will conflict with goals of others. At a simple level one may see the goal of a Production Manager to have no down time and thereby wanting to have enough inventory and on the other level the role of a purchasing Manager is to keep as low inventory as possible. Is it possible that there will not be conflict every time they interact? On a more divergent level, there are various groups who work within the ecosystem of the Organisation who have clearly defined opposite views and positions on many things and yet need to work together.. Eg. The employee Unions and the Management. The question I have attempted to answer is how will Coaching help in Managing and Resolving conflicts in general and what ICF Competencies can be useful in coaching a group with conflict Management issues.. Let us first review the key Characteristics of a situation of a group where conflict is present Lots of emotions and areas of disagreement Most of the stakeholders very firm on their positions and genuinely believe that their prescription on way forward is appropriate. Unreasonable expectations from others Strong sense and understanding that this is not the right situation , but not willing to compromise Artificial postures leading to confusion on what is real and what is not. A very strong analysis on how the others position is not right . In most cases the group members know exactly how others should do their job. Willingness to make a move with realization that the team has to work together but not willing to make the first move for reconciliation.
Coaching
influence
on
the
above
1)Definition
of
Coaching
The
International
Coach
Federation
defines
coaching
in
the
following
way:
Professional
coaches
provide
an
ongoing
partnership
designed
to
help
clients
produce
fulfilling
results
in
their
personal
and
professional
lives.
Coaches
help
people
improve
their
performances
and
enhance
the
quality
of
their
lives.
Coaches
are
trained
to
listen,
to
observe
and
to
customize
their
approach
to
individual
client
needs.
They
seek
to
elicit
solutions
and
strategies
from
the
client;
they
believe
the
client
is
naturally
creative
and
resourceful.
The
coach's
job
is
to
provide
support
to
enhance
the
skills,
resources,
and
Copyright 2006 International Coach Academy Pty. Ltd. Use is governed by the Terms and Conditions at http://www.icoachacademy.com
creativity
that
the
client
already
has.
The
ICF
coaching
definition
suggests
that
coaching
is
partnering
with
the
client
and
the
job
of
the
coach
is
to
bring
the
best
out
in
the
client
from
the
skills,
knowledge
the
client
already
has.
This
cannot
be
more
truer
in
a
situation
where
there
is
conflict.
The
client
(group)
has
all
the
skills
,
knowledge
,
needed
to
resolve
the
issue,
they
are
probably
looking
at
the
problem
from
a
different
perspective.
If
the
coach
can
help
alter
the
perspective
there
is
every
possibility
that
the
client
can
look
at
his
individual
issue
as
a
opportunity
for
the
group..
Let
us
also
examine
the
ICF
defined
competencies
the
Coach
should
have
and
how
those
competencies
can
help
the
client
in
a
conflict
Management
Situation
A. Setting
the
Foundation
:-
The
coach
will
emphasise
and
demonstrate
the
ethical
standard
that
will
be
practiced
all
Through.
This
is
an
important
competency
as
in
a
conflict
coaching
environment,
no
one
individual
or
group
needs
to
be
felt
that
the
coach
has
mandate
for
others.
The
clarity
of
understanding
that
the
coach
is
not
an
Arbitrator
in
conflict
cases
will
also
help
immensely
for
building
a
non
threatening
environment
B. Co
creating
the
Relationship
:
A
successful
beginning
is
one
which
is
created
on
trust
and
intimacy.
By
achieving
this
the
coach
will
ensure
that
the
client
will
get
comfort
that
the
openness
in
the
relationship
is
non
threatening
and
will
not
be
misused
C. Communicating
Effectively
a. Active
Listening
:-
The
biggest
enabler
for
conflict
to
happen
and
continue
to
simmer
is
that
there
is
very
poor
listening
within
the
stake
holders.
The
Coach
who
listens
with
a
fresh
and
new
ear
and
an
open
mind
in
all
probability
be
able
to
start
thinking
in
the
speaker
as
he
is
being
listened
to
without
a
counter
argument
coming
b. Powerful
Questioning
:-
Active
Listening
can
allow
good
,
pertinent
questions
to
be
asked.
These
questions
can
go
to
the
basic
of
conflict
and
challenge
where
it
is
arisen
from.
In
a
real
conflict
situation
there
are
times
when
the
group
has
forgotten
the
source
of
conflict
in
the
first
place
and
are
holding
on
to
positions
even
if
the
source
has
become
irrelevant.
This
is
typically
true
in
Organisations
where
perceptions
are
Copyright 2006 International Coach Academy Pty. Ltd. Use is governed by the Terms and Conditions at http://www.icoachacademy.com
stronger than facts. (The reader can relate to this in case where mergers happen between Global companies , even after years which company employee behaves how, is a gospel truth. c. Direct Communication :- With a positive undertone can help in creating options and persuing the same D. Facilitating Learning and Results a. Creating Awareness:- These competency is by far the most powerful competency as it will enable the clients in a conflict situation to evaluate sources of information and come with multiple options. b. Designing Action :- The natural outcome will be designing an action plan based on changed perceptions and more clarity. c. Planning and Goal Setting:- The multiple interactions with various stake holders will enable the client individually as well as the group with setting goals which are more inclusive of divergent needs and thereby enabling more ownership d. Managing Progress and Accountability :- The coach will leave the implementing to the clients and allow them to share the fruits of the tree which they have planted together.
Summary
The
intent
of
this
article
is
to
bring
about
the
application
of
Coaching
into
areas
where
conflict
prevails
within
a
group
in
Organisations.
It
is
also
a
submission
that
conflict
ultimately
leads
to
progress
and
improvement.
The
basic
theme
is
that
conflict
is
inevitable,
it
is
good
and
it
needs
to
be
managed
in
a
way
that
it
acts
as
a
catalyst
for
progress
and
improvement.
It
is
a
seen
that
Organisations
in
many
cases
use
the
services
of
Mentors,
Counsellors
to
reduce
conflict
which
is
become
more
personal.
There
are
Organisations
which
engage
consultants
to
clear
the
bottlenecks
and
areas
where
conflict
has
become
systemic
and
needs
some
kind
of
surgical
(process)
intervention.
This
article
makes
a
submission
that
in
all
cases
conflict
needs
to
be
managed
and
used
well
and
not
seen
as
fundamentally
bad
and
avoidable.
Copyright 2006 International Coach Academy Pty. Ltd. Use is governed by the Terms and Conditions at http://www.icoachacademy.com
The solution for resolving conflict lie within the group or the individuals. Therefore in all cases , interventions like counseling, consulting may not be able to use the expertise of the group . Coaching, on the other hand will ensure that the final outcome is the result of the efforts and commitment of the group and therefore more permanent and acceptable.
Copyright 2006 International Coach Academy Pty. Ltd. Use is governed by the Terms and Conditions at http://www.icoachacademy.com