Fragile Coalition in Greece Narrowly Backs Austerity

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/08/world/europe/greece- austerity- vote.html November 8, 2012

Angelos Tzortzinis for The New York Times

T he passage of sweeping austerity measures incited some of the most violent demonstrations in Greece in months.

ATHENS Amid some of the most violent demonstrations in Greece in months, the Parliament approved a sweeping set of austerity measures early Thursday that were aimed at keeping the country in the euro zone, but passage was so narrow that the governments continued stability remained at risk. After 14 hours of debate, the three-party coalition of Prime Minister Antonis Samaras held together to pass the measures, 153 to 128, after several lawmakers broke ranks. Eighteen members voted present, the equivalent of a blank vote, including 15 from the smallest coalition party, Democratic Left, which opposes the measures. There was one abstention. After the vote, six lawmakers were expelled from the governing coalitions Socialist Pasok party and one from the conservative New Democracy party The measures including sharp cuts to pensions, salaries and social services, as well as tax increases and increases in the retirement age to 67 from 65 are expected, but not guaranteed, to persuade Greeces foreign creditors to unlock 31 billion euros in aid, or about $40 billion, that the country needs to meet expenses. A vote on the 2013 budget to activate the austerity package is expected late Sunday. In presenting the austerity measures, which total 17 billion euros, to Parliament, Mr. Samaras acknowledged that the new cuts to pensions and salaries were unfair, but added that Greece was bound by the terms of its agreement with creditors. A lot of what were voting on today are measures we should have taken a long time ago, he said, adding that they would be the last, the last such cuts. Future adjustments, he said, would come from a crackdown on tax evasion and public sector waste. Mr. Samaras, however, is the third prime minister to promise the last cuts since Greece asked for a foreign bailout in 2010. The deep cuts, which have helped Greeces economy shrink 25 percent in recent years, are undermining the countrys social and political stability and the governments ability to carry out the structural changes. You cant rebuild institutions when youve cut down the salaries of people who work for them, said Alexis Papahelas, the managing editor of the Kathimerini daily. Thats the big problem the government and the country are facing. On the eve of the vote, nearly 50 employees of Greeces central bank resigned to protest the deep cuts to public sector salaries, while on Wednesday, Greeces Supreme Court ruled that cuts of up to 30 percent in judges salaries would violate the constitution. Parliamentary staff also threatened Wednesday to resign over their salary cuts, leading Mr.

Samaras to consider invoking executive authority to force them to stay on the job, according to a government official not authorized to speak publicly. Greeces troika of foreign lenders the European Commission, European Central Bank and International Monetary Fund have demanded that Greece reduce its budget deficit in exchange for more aid. Yet few believe that the measures will help improve the countrys economic health. Telling a whole people that they have to commit collective suicide to save the debt is not a policy, Zoe Kostantopoulou, a member of Parliament from the leftist Syriza opposition party, said in an interview, expressing a sentiment growing across the political spectrum. The reason why weve seen the economy implode much more rapidly than thought is that they grossly underestimated the impact that fiscal austerity of this magnitude would have on the Greek economy, said Simon Tilford, the chief economist at the Center for European Reform in London. Additional austerity is going to compound that weakness. He added that the slump in the economy was also making it harder for Greece to meet the troikas demands to reduce a mountain of debt. The whole strategy for Greece has failed, Mr. Tilford said. Its led to collapse in the Greek economy and the ballooning of debt so its an abject failure.. Stella Dimitrakopolou, a 29-year-old graphic designer who donned a surgical mask to ward off tear gas in Wednesdays demonstration, agreed. These measures are inhumane, she said. The young generation has no future, and older people have no money and the measures do not help society economically. Niki Kitsantonis contributed reporting