Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Catherine Glinskaya - Literacy Ethnography
Catherine Glinskaya - Literacy Ethnography
Glinskaya
Engl
1101
Mr.
Anthony
Borrero
11/27/12
Ethnography
Research
Revision:
How
Do
I
Become
a
Dancer?
When
we
were
children,
we
have
been
asked
who
do
we
want
to
become.
Many
of
us
answered
that
they
want
to
become
a
pilot,
a
doctor,
a
teacher
or
a
policeman.
Why
not
a
dancer?
In
fact,
a
question
that
now
appears
is
how
to
become
a
dancer
and
what
type
of
the
dancer
to
become?
There
are
various
styles
and
techniques
of
dancing,
offered
by
multiple
dance
schools
and
clubs.
I
chose
to
base
my
research
on
observations
of
49er
Charlotte
Dance
Sport
Club.
Through
the
research
I
will
trace
the
steps
of
learning
how
to
dance.
I
will
primarily
focus
on
the
procedure
and
daily
routine
of
the
Club
in
teaching
its
members
the
aspects
of
a
dance.
In
addition
to
that,
I
will
point
out
main
aspects
in
the
process
of
teaching
a
dance
for
Charlotte
Dance
Sport
Club
at
UNCC.
The
research
will
help
the
members
and
the
instructors
of
the
club,
as
well
as
any
dancer,
to
polish
their
dancing
and
training
skills.
Before
I
plunge
into
the
discussion
of
any
specific
dance,
I
would
like
to
speculate
on
the
thought
of
what
dance
itself
means.
Dance
is
an
inseparable
part
of
society.
It
has
become
an
aspect
of
its
identity.
Humanity
uses
dance
as
a
means
of
expressing
itself
and
as
a
means
of
experiencing
pleasure
and
enjoyment.
Therefore,
dance
may
or
may
not
convey
any
meaning
that
one
may
be
seeking
in
the
performed
movements.
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [4]: Word
choice.
Changed
from
benefit
to
help
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [5]: Spelling
correction
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [6]: Added
a
preposition
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [7]: Inserted
indefinite
article
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [8]: Changed
from
infinitive
to
gerund
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [9]: Corrected
sentence
structure
for
clarity
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [3]: Changed
sentence
structure
to
make
the
statement
clear
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [1]: The
main
five
points
I
focused
on
in
the
revision
are
as
following:
1.Sentence
structure
2.Word
choice
3.Citation
4.Articles
5.Comma
usage
Several
general
correction
were
also
made,
as
commented
throughout
the
revision.
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [2]:
Stated
that
it
is
a
revision
of
the
original
paper
Since humanity is in a constant state of change, so is dance. As a result, it has led to various forms and styles of dance. Within this research I would like to focus on Ballroom dancing. Ballroom dancing is usually referenced to International Standard and International Latin styles of dancing. In the United States, American style is also included in the scope of Ballroom dancing. (Wikipedia) International Ballroom is considered to be a cleaner, stricter and tighter dance style. It is more focused on the techniques, as opposed to American one. Therefore, one dancing International looks much better in comparison to one performing American style. (Bland) Cohen states that in the International Standard dance position the woman stands slightly toward the mans right side. This permits the couple to move on separate tracks. (Cohen, volume 1, 356) The mans right hand is placed outside the womans left shoulder blade. Her right hand is in his left. The woman places her left hand on the mans upper right arm. The elbows are held parallel to the floor, creating breadth in the couples outline. (Cohen, volume 1, 356) International Standard includes five ballroom dances: Waltz, Fox Trot, Tango, Quickstep, and Viennese Waltz. (Savoy, 1) The word waltz is derived from German wlzen, which means to turn, to revolve, to wander. (Cohen, vol 6, 359 ) The main characteristic of Waltz is the rise and fall movement, accomplished through yielding up- and-down motion by bending the knees. (Cohen, vol 1, 358) Cohen claims that the Viennese Waltz is the fastest of all the competitive dances (Cohen, vol 1, 358). It consists of left and right turns that are performed along the line directed counterclockwise around the ballroom. (Cohen, vol 1, 358). The Waltz can be observed in the Charlotte Dance Sport Club, which, along with other dances in its curriculum, teaches Waltz.
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [10]: Took out article, to convey the meaning of any dance, not one particular dance.
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [11]: Inserted comma to add clarity in the meaning Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [12]: corrected the format of quotation signs, added indefinite article Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [13]: correction of word order Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [14]: took out comma Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [15]: Introduced the author of the quotation for better quote framing Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [16]: Broke down the citation
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [17]: Paraphrased and restructure the citation for more clarity
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [18]: Added the definite article Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [19]: Worked on citation to better implement that into the paper
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [20]: Inserted comma Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [21]: Rewrote the sentence for better transition of the ideas
By this token, I would like to introduce the Club upon which my research is based. The Charlotte Dance Sport Club is open for anyone who is interested in Ballroom Dancing. No experience or knowledge is required to be able to start the lessons. The President of the Charlotte Dance Sport Club, Willie Frazier, shares that the goal of the club is to teach people many different types of dance, be it Latin or Standard and to prepare them for current day social dancing outside of the club. Another purpose is to prepare willing students for dance competitions and have them compete all over the states. (Frazier) In addition to that the Club helps to build up the confidence in the performers, and, no doubt, offers to simply enjoy the dance. (Bland) To use effectively all of their time and resources, including instructors, the Charlotte Dance Sport Club divided the proficiency in dancing techniques into several levels. The first one to enter is Social level. There the instructors, who most of the time are advanced members of the club, teach the beginner basic steps, so the members can dance to the music. The second level is a Newcomer Team, where the beginner continues to learn basic steps, spreading the variety of dances and techniques. The opportunity to enter competitions opens on this level of proficiency, as the member is supposed to know enough to compete with others. The level up is a Bronze Team, where the basic steps are brushed in to more advanced techniques. I find that the main advantage of this level is the fact that the members are taught by professional coaches, who also teach the Silver Team, an even more advanced level of proficiency. (Charlotte, 6) When talking about the levels, it may seem that it is very hard to move up the ladder. It, definitely, requires a lot of work and patience, but, as Teghan Bland, a bronze member of the club, shared, no timeframe is set for one to learn all the routines required on each level. Its really just learning and getting down and feeling comfortable with
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [22]: Sentence structure. Indicated that the research is based on the club
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [24]: Inserted an article Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [25]: Changed the sentence structure and word order to add clarity
those
routines,
and
trying
them
out
in
competitions.
When
youve
learned
all
those
routines,
youve
basically
learned
your
level,
says
Teghan.
(Bland)
How
does
the
learning
occur
in
the
club,
then?
Based
on
my
observations,
an
extensive
amount
of
the
time
in
the
class
is
dedicated
to
learning
the
basic
steps,
especially,
on
the
beginners
level.
The
instructor
starts
with
the
basic
steps
of
the
dance.
In
Waltz
the
man
steps
forward
with
his
left
foot,
a
lady
steps
back
with
her
right
foot
on
the
count
four
and.
This
is
called
the
preparation
step.
Its
basic
purpose
is
to
help
the
dancers
to
feel
the
rhythm
and
to
start
the
dance.
After
that
move
the
pair
may
continue
on
dancing
the
basic
step,
where
the
man
steps
forward
with
his
right
foot,
and
the
lady
steps
back
with
her
left
foot
on
count
one.
The
knees
are
bent.
On
count
two
the
couple
is
making
a
move
that
helps
them
to
complete
a
half-turn:
they
are
stepping
to
the
side,
the
male
partner
with
his
left
foot,
the
female
partner
with
her
right
foot.
On
this
count
the
knees
of
the
partners
are
stretching
out,
allowing
the
performers
to
rise.
After
the
step
is
competed,
the
couple
finishes
the
move
by
bringing
the
stretched
out
(mans
right,
ladys
left)
foot
to
the
other
one
on
the
count
three.
In
this
position
the
knees
are
bent
again.
The
male
partner
starts
the
second
half
of
the
basic
step
with
his
left
foot,
by
stepping
forward,
the
lady
with
her
right
foot
by
moving
backwards.
The
man
uses
his
right
foot,
and
his
partner
uses
her
left
foot
to
step
aside
on
the
count
two
with
the
rising
movement,
and
on
the
count
three
both
feet
are
placed
together;
the
knees
are
bent.
(Harris,
340)
The
members
of
Charlotte
Dance
Sport
Club
practice
the
move
alone,
then
with
the
partner
until
the
movement
seems
to
be
settled
and
the
dancers
are
comfortable
with
performing
it.
A
couple
can
dance
just
this
basic
move
throughout
the
whole
dance,
but
in
that
case
it
becomes
a
boring
interpretation
of
the
Waltz.
Not
to
let
that
happen,
the
instructor
introduced
to
the
group
the
natural
turn.
With
its
help
the
dancers
can
move
around
the
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [38]: Article
change
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [39]: Article
change
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [36]: Restructured
the
sentence,
changed
the
word
usage
to
avoid
repetition
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [37]: Inserted
article
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [27]: Article
change
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [28]: Corrected
pronoun
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [29]: Added
clarity
to
the
meaning
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [30]: Added
article
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [31]: Article
correction
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [32]: Article
correction
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [33]: Article
correction
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [26]: Sentence
structure;
referenced
the
citation.
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [34]: Changed the article Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [35]: Added article
floor
with
more
ease,
using
the
ballroom
space
to
its
full
capacity.
As
Waltz
is
danced
along
the
ballroom
in
a
diagonal
manner,
there
is
the
time
when
the
dancers
reach
the
corner
of
the
ballroom.
Natural
turn
is
an
aid
for
the
couple
to
avoid
the
corner
and
continue
the
dance.
To
perform
this
move
the
male
partner
steps
forward
with
his
right
foot,
the
female
with
her
left
foot.
The
man
uses
his
left
foot
to
step
aside,
the
lady
her
right
foot,
like
in
the
basic
move.
But
instead
of
bringing
the
feet
together
on
the
count
three,
partners
step
aside,
turning
their
bodies
in
a
diagonal
direction.
This
move
is
called
close
change.
It
is
followed
by
the
natural
turn
itself,
where
the
lady
steps
forward,
toeing,
with
her
right
foot,
and
the
man
moves
backwards
with
his
left.
(Harris,
340)
A
couple
performs
it
twice,
changing
legs
accordingly,
so
they
turn
to
the
position
where
the
man
is
able
to
step
forward,
and
the
lady
to
step
back,
being
led
by
her
partner.
Once
the
natural
turn
is
completed,
a
couple
can
continue
to
dance
diagonal
along
the
ballroom.
During
my
observations
of
the
Charlotte
Dance
Sport
Club,
I
noticed
that
the
members
of
the
club
carefully
practice
the
same
move
again
and
again
alone,
and
then
paired
up
with
a
partner.
Why
is
so
much
time
spent
on
learning
techniques,
on
getting
the
move
settled
down?
Isnt
the
dance
about
expressing
emotions
and
talking
to
the
audience
through
body
movements?
Isnt
the
dance
about
having
connection
between
the
partners,
so
the
audience
reads
the
meaning
without
hearing
the
words
of
the
story
being
told?
Teghan
Bland
shares
her
viewpoint:
You
may
have
good
connection
and
fail
technique
wise.
She
asserts
that
some
partners
have
that
instinctive
chemistry
with
each
other,
but
most
of
the
time
the
connection
was
developed
through
extensive
practice.
Therefore,
I
can
state
that
techniques
are
the
main
aspect
of
dancing.
Moves
of
a
dance
can
be
compared
with
the
words
of
a
foreign
language
in
which
one
pursues
knowledge.
If
one
does
not
know
the
words,
they
are
not
able
to
speak.
Similarly,
if
one
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [45]: Sentence
structure,
change
the
word
order
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [41]: Word
change
to
avoid
repetition
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [42]: Word
change
from
as
to
like
for
clarity
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [43]: Inserted
the
article
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [44]: Word
choice
correction
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [40]: Deleted
the
comma
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [46]: Corrected spelling mistake Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [47]: Sentence structure. Rewrote to better introduce the quotation and make a better transition with the previous sentence
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [48]: Transition word change the more suitable Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [49]: Sentence structure
does not know the basic techniques, they are not able to dance. The president of the club shares in his interview: Drills are at the heart of dance. Sure, anyone can dance their favorite dance till the cows come home but without the proper technique one can never really improve to the point of being competitive. (Frazier) While teaching and polishing the moves of a dance, the instructors of Charlotte Dance Sport bring to attention other important aspect of a dance, such as understanding the body language of the partner. Dancing in a pair is viewed as a dialogue, where the man happens to have the leading part. (Green, 53) In Standard dancing, which includes Waltz, Tango, Quickstep, Fox Trot and Viennese waltz, the dancers are not looking at each other. Therefore, a female dancer should use body language to listen to her mate, paying close attention to his body movements and palm pressure. (Green, 53) The members of the Club call it a frame, which is a fixed position of the partners that helps them to be connected and improves the ability to feel the body movements. By pushing or pulling the female partners arm, the male partner asks her to do certain figures, or gives her a hint which direction he is intending to go. Correct interpretation of the partners movements is extremely important. Misinterpretation can lead to stumbled feet and a ruined dance, the same way misunderstanding in the dialogue can result in confusion and a spoiled relationship. During my observations of the Bronze level of the Charlotte Dance Sport Club I noticed several couples were still struggling to reach the connection level where they can understand each other without saying words. Another important aspect for the female partner is to learn how to let the male partner lead her into the move, and not try to control the flow of the dance. Based on the observations of the Charlotte Dance Sport Club, it seems to be very difficult to achieve, especially when the female partner knows the move better than the male dancer. Teghan supports this idea, saying when she dances with the partner of a lower level, and,
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [50]: Added not for clarity of the meaning
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [51]: Preposition change Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [52]: Changed from plural to singular
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [53]: Word selection change to avoid repetition
therefore,
he
does
not
know
the
figure
that
well,
she
is
tempted
to
lead
the
partner
into
the
move.
She
calls
that
a
back
lead.
It
is
not
beneficial
to
the
male
partner,
as
he
needs
to
learn
the
move
and
build
up
the
confidence
of
using
that
figure
and
confidence
in
controlling
his
partner,
therefore
the
direction
of
the
dance.
(Bland)
By
backleading
the
female
partner
takes
the
initiative
in
the
course
of
the
dance.
As
a
result,
the
male
partner
is
lacking
confidence
and
lags
behind
in
learning
the
technique.
After
observing
Charlotte
Dance
Sport
Club
as
an
ethnographic
group,
and
conducting
several
interviews
with
its
members,
I
can
indicate
that
the
Club
puts
emphasis
on,
first
of
all,
getting
the
techniques
down,
polishing
and
improving
the
performance
of
the
basics
of
the
dance.
The
basic
movements
are
compared
to
words
in
the
language.
If
one
does
not
know
the
words,
they
are
not
able
to
speak.
The
members
of
the
Club
also
underline
that
simply
knowing
the
techniques
is
not
enough.
They
should
be
put
together
to
dance
phrases,
as
the
words
are
put
into
sentences,
to
compose
a
dance.
Based
on
my
research
of
the
Charlotte
Dance
Sport
Club
and
interviews
with
its
members,
I
analyzed
the
importance
of
structuring
the
dance
and
breaking
down
the
proficiency
levels.
Breaking
down
the
dance
into
structural
parts
helps
the
dancers
to
learn
how
to
dance
more
effectively
and
in
a
short
period
of
time.
The
result
of
close
attention
to
the
dancers
on
all
levels
of
the
Club
is
a
marvelous
performance.
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [57]: Changed
from
the
research
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [58]: Changed
from
singular
to
plural
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [59]: Added
an
indefinite
article,
changed
from
shorter
to
short
for
clarity
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [56]: Inserted
the
definite
article
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [55]: Word
selection
to
avoid
repetition
Used
Sources:
Bland,
Teghan,
Personal
interview.
13
Nov.
2012
Charlotte
DanceSport
d/b/a/
49er
Social
&
Ballroom
Dance
Club
http://www.charlottedancesport.org/faq/
Cohen,
Selma
J.
International
Encyclopedia
of
Dance:
A
Project
of
Dance
Perspectives
Foundation,
Inc.
New
York:
Oxford
University
Press,
1998.
Print.
Frazier,
Willie.
Personal
interview.
20
Nov.
2012
Green,
E
R.
Four
Dance
Forms
I.
Dubuque,
Ia:
Kendall/Hunt,
1973.
Print.
Harris,
Jane
A,
Anne
Pittman,
and
Marlys
S.
Waller.
Dance
a
While:
Handbook
of
Folk,
Square,
and
Social
Dance.
Minneapolis:
Burgess
Pub.
Co,
1978.
Print.
Savoy,
Sharon.
Ballroom!:
Obsession
and
Passion
Inside
the
World
of
Competitive
Dance.
Gainesville,
FL:
University
Press
of
Florida,
2010.
Print.
Catherine 12/4/12 7:56 PM Comment [60]: Re-organized
the
order
of
cited
sources
by
alphabetical
order
to
follow
the
rules
of
citation