2013

Working Paper
Adhoc

11

16

22

37

47

64

72



1.

2.
,

.
3.



, .
4. .



.
5.
.
6. ,
,

.

7.
,
.
8.



.

.

.

,


.

,
.

.

,
.

, ,
.

,
. ,

.

,


.

,
.

,
.

:
o

,
.


.

25% .

,
, .

2013-14 .

15 25
, .

,

,

10

.

,

, , .

20%,
. 12,2% 2013
5,6% 2014
.

,
, , .

. .

, .

,
.


.

.
.

.

.

.

,
.

, .

.
,
.

10

1.

25


.

, .


,
.

.

9% 2016,

.
9%
.
9%
,
.

11

 2016
:
2016
()1

2,1 (
1 )

2,5

3,4

(ELA)5

11,4

EMTN Euro Medium Term Notes:

.




.
2

: . .

.
3

2021

2,4

, ,
.
5

2013 .

12


,
,
21 20136.

(ELA). :

.
:
o

1:
.


, ,

.
ELA ,
100 .

.

2:
/,
.
,
.

ELA.
.
6

http://www.ecb.int/press/pr/date/2013/html/pr130321.en.html

13



.
17,8
30 166% .
2,5%

4,15% ,
.

1,5
( 750 .)
.


.


.

3:
,
,

, ELA.

.
.

14

:
1.
,


.
2.
.

15

2.

.

,
.
.
Roger Bootle 7



.
:
20098,
49 ,
,
.
,
.
,
.

Bootle R., 2012, Leaving the euro: A practical guide, Capital Economics
European Central Bank Legal Working Paper Series No. 10 by Phoebus Athanassiou

(December 2009) Withdrawal and expulsion from the EU and EMU: Some Reflections

16

 Allen
Overy 20119.

:
o

,
,
.

50

72%
. ,
.

.

.

. ,
.

Ashurst 201210.

.

.

Allen and Overy (October 2011) The euro and currency unions

10

Ashurst (January 2012) Exiting the Euro the legal consequences

17

 ,

2012. 11

.


, 1992
1999,
.
,
, ,


.
:
.
o

: ,
,
15
21 . ,
,
,

.

11

Institute of International and European Affairs Working Paper Series No. 8 by Peader o

Broin (2012) The Euro Crisis: Orderly Default or Euro Exit

18

,
.

:

,
,
.

.
.
,
, .. .

,

, .

.

,
( )
( , ..).

, .

.

19


.


. ,

.

.

;
:

,
.
,

.

, ,
,
, .
,
.
.


.
.

.

20

 ,




.
.


.

1.
,
2. ,

.
3.

.
4.

.
5.
,
.

.
6.

21

3.

.
,
:

:
. 12 H Flassbeck13


. ,

12

, SOAS

13

Ex - Director of the Division on Globalization and Development Strategies of the United

Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) and State Secretary (Vice
Minister) from October 1998 to April 1999 at the German Federal Ministry of Finance
responsible for international affairs, the European Union and IMF.

22


.
,
,
. , ,

1.

, /
( 2) .
.
,
.

, .
.
, ,
,
.

, .

, .
,
.
.
.

.
. ,

23

 .
, ( 3).

1: - : H. Flassbeck
(November 2012) - The Systemic Crisis of the Euro - Causes and Therapies

2: % : H. Flassbeck (November
2012) - The Systemic Crisis of the Euro - Causes and Therapies

24

 3: : Societe Generale

,
.
.
,

. ,
.
, 2012
, .
( 100%)
.
, .
, ,
.
,
.
, ,
.

25

 ,
.
,
.

.
:


.
2008
. 2008,

120 121
. ,
.
,


.
.


, ,

.
,

,
.

26



4.
4: : H. Flassbeck (November 2012) The Systemic Crisis of the Euro - Causes and Therapies

,
, 28 29
2012
. 14
. ,
. , .
Eurogroup . .
:
o

- :

14

European Commision (November 2012) - COM(2012) 777 final, A blueprint for a deep and

genuine economic and monetary union

27

 .
( )
, .

,

.
o

:
.


.

,
,
.

:

( , (6)
, )
(2)

.
o

:
.

,
.

.
,

28



.


.
,

.

.


( ),
,
.

:
,


:


. 2010

.

..: 18,4
2010
4,4% 2013

29

 .
.

: 170% (
) 2011 10
173,5% .
2009
2010, 2012 6,6%
2013
4,6%.

:
.
,

.

.

17,5% 2011 2015.
15
24,3%
2012 2014.

:
2010 2011
10%.
25% - 1 2012
800 .
201116.

:
.

15

DG EcFin, European Commission Occasional Papers 123 (December 2012) - The

economic adjustment programme for Greece. First Review, pg 10

16

., 8

30

 24% 2012 55,4%

2012.
Marc17
38%
.

17

http://greece.greekreporter.com/2013/02/07/austerity-cuts-greek-household-income-38/

31

 : .
,
. 2011.

2013. 5
20%
.
,
, .

..: 1,6% 2011,

2012
1975 6,4%
18
5% . 2013
3,2%19.

: 93,4%
123,6%

2013.

5% .
2013 5,5%20

6,4%,
.

18

http://www.portugaldailyview.com/whats-new/statistics-agency-debt-tops-e200bn-gdp-

confirmed-at-6-4-in-2012
19

http://euobserver.com/economic/119729

20

http://www.irishtimes.com/business/economy/europe/portugal-court-rejects-austerity-

measures-1.1351938

32

:
.
,
6% .
21
23,4% 2011
2014. 485.

47,5% 924
.

:
2011 2012 15%22
2011 2013.23

: 15%
19%24,
37%. ,
50
10%25. 485
.

:
, 2010
.

21

DG EcFin, European Commission Occasional Papers 124 (Autumn 2012) - The Economic

Adjustment Programme for Portugal Sixth Review Autumn 2012, pg 43

22

..

23

.., 41

24

http://euobserver.com/economic/119729

25

http://www.portugaldailyview.com/whats-new/state-reform-50000-public-sector-jobs-lost-in-

last-two-years

33

 ,
.

,
.

..:
1% 2010
.
6, 2010
2007
2010
. ,
(bail out)

.

626-

26

DG EcFin, European Commission Occasional Papers 127 (Autumn 2012) - The Economic

Adjustment Programme for Ireland Autumn Review Autumn 2012, pg 43

34

: 44,5% 2008
122%,
.

.
30,9%

.

: ,
10%
,

11,5% 2013 2009, 27.

:
45
2008 2011, .
.

: 15%,
.
30%.

1.
.
2.
,
.
3.

, ,
.

27

., . 53

35

4. ,
.
,

.
5. ,

.
6.
,

.
7. ,
.
8. :
o

,
.

.

25% .

, .

36

4.

.
.

.

.
:

,
,
. Eurougroup 15

.

,( 6,6% )


.

.



,
.

37

 :
15
.
,
,
, .
, .

700% 350% :

( , )
.

,
,
, .

,


,

,
.
ELA ,

, ,
.

38

 .

,
. ELA

, .

ELA, .

:
,

, .

..:
8,7% 2013 3,9% 2014,
12,5% 2012.
.

,
9% (. )
(
700% 350%). 4,5%
. (
) 11,3%

17,8%
8,7% .
Mats Persson, Open Europe,

39

,
8% 28 .

: 10
, 4,1
.
3,4 2016,

:

28

1,4

0,6

http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/finance/matspersson/100023894/is-cyprus-turning-into-a-

zombie-economy/

40

0,4 ,
.
.

600
.
2013 8%

20% 1

.

2,5


.


.

109%
2013 2015 126,3%.
11,4 ELA

. 2,5
.
70%
. ,
ELA,
200%
.

ELA ,

.

.

41

,

.

,
.


.
600 . (8% )
2013

42

 ,

.

43

.


.
16% 2013 6,5% 2014
.
29,5%
2013 12% 2014.

.


. 15%
5%
.
.

,

.
.

44


, 0,48% .

,

, , .

:
PIMCO, 5,2% 2013 2,3% 201429
25% 2015.

,

.
,
2,5
.

: PIMCO
13,8% 2013.
14%
20%,
. 12,2% 2013
5,6% 2014
.

:
1.
2013-14 .
2.

29

, 28/1/2013,

PIMCO

45

3. 15 25
,
.
4.

.
5. ,

,

6.
.
7. 10

.
8.
,


9.

.
,

, ,
.
10. 20%,
. 12,2% 2013
5,6% 2014

.
11. ,
, , .
12.
.

46

5.

.

:

: , ,

:
: Barry Eichengreen,
Berkeley, "The breakup of the euro area"
.


.
, Paul Krugman,
Eichengreen,
.

47

 Krugman, ,
. :"
Eichengreen
.
.

."

15
2013.
15 ,

.
Matthew O'brien
The Atlantic "

"", ,
95% 90% 80%
."
:

. ,
International Institute of Finance
20%
25%
140% .

.
Financial Times
:
;
: .
,

48

 . , ,
. bail in
.
,
.
1 1,
5.000 ,
. .
, .
,

,
.
: Stern School New York
University, Nouriel Roubini 2011

.
, .
,
.

.
20 ,

. ,

Roubini, ''

- .
''.

.
,

.

49

 .


.
Eichengreen

. :
"
,
.


(
)
.
.
(default)

.
.


.".
Hans-Werner Sinn
Institute for Economic Research (ifo),
SPIEGEL .



.
.

50


.
,

. ,
,
.
.
, :
Krugman
,

.
Roubini,
.
()

()
,
10
()
' ',
. , ,
Roubini,
.

. , , 1933
69%.
,

,

51

 , .
,
,
Krugman
.
O'brien The Atlantic

.

, .
,

6% .
. ,

.

.

""

.
,


. ,
.

.
:

.

52

 Emergency
Liquidity Assistance .
' '
.

.

. .

.
Paul Volcker, Federal Reserve (
), ,
.
,
,
.


, .

.
.

.

.

53

:
1.

.
.
2.


3.

.
4.

.
5. ,
.
6.

.
7.
.

.

:

.

.
Tim Worstall Adam Smith Institute
Forbes: "
.

54

 ,
.
.
:
.
" .

, Krugman New York Times

: " (...),

,
"
Eichengreen
:
() "
" .
.
()
.
Jacques Delors "
".
:

:

55

30, ,

31

1.
.
2.

:
Eichengreen



/ /
.


.

30

781 2012 866

. 7,08 2012 7,6

2011
31

0,9 4

. 0,5
.
.

56

 .
.

1.



.

:
: Bootle
"Leaving the euro: a practical guide",
1:1 . ,
, ,

( ).
.
:

15 2013
(
-
).
: ,
32

32

57

.
6 .

.

, ,
.
( 87% 20
). ,
( )
1:1
.

.
:
2008.
:

.

6 .


.

58


1.

: 11 ,

George Soros
: "
.
.

".
Soros 20012002.

Mark Weisbrot Juan Antonio Montecino 2012.

" 3,5
, 2001
2002 .
5%
2002. 6
63% 90% 9 .
,
.
, .
.
, 12%
2002-2008 50% .
6
.

(....).

59

,
".

.
"
,

.

,
.
. ()
.
,
.
.
2003,
.

.

2001, 1998, 2008,
.


."
,
,

.
:
,

.

60

 ,
.


.

/ . ,

.
Milton Friedman

.
Friedman
.

.
,

, .

Bootle
,

.
,
40%, 30%
15%.


.
.
: "
(0,2% )
.

61

 . 10-15%
.
,
."
:
.
, 2002
70% 40%
3,4% 2004. 2008
18,6% 2009 3%
2010.

.
48%
30%
14%.

,

,



.

.
:
1.
,

.
2.
.

62


, .
3.
.

63

6.

.


.

.

.

.
:


,
.
.
, ,
, .


.
,
.

.

64


Gnther Oettinger.

33
.

, ,
.

- .


.

.


.

205034

33

, ,
,

COM (2011) 539

- :
, . 9
34

COM (2011) 885 - 2050

65

-
, .

.
.
,
.
..
.
,
, , ,

.
12 7-8
5%
4,8 140 35,
40 .
36
122
, ,
.

35

PwC (November 2011) Cuprus hydrocarbon opportunities, pg. 6

36

http://uk.reuters.com/article/2013/03/14/cyprus-natgas-exports-idUKL6N0C6AG520130314

66

Source: US Energy Information Administration PwC

:

.
, ,
,
.

.

37.

37

Memorandum of Understanding on Specific Economic Policy Conditionality ( 2013),

. 30: [] the plan should take account of the current uncertainty over the actual size of
domestic, offshore, commercially-viable, natural gas fields and possible changes in
international gas prices and demand, and appropriate data should be firmly based on
alternative world energy scenarios from an internationally-reputed organisation. The plan will
be based on an appropriate level of technical assistance on technical aspects in this context.

67


,
.

(consultation)
.


, ECOFIN IMF

.

.

..

, .

. ,
,
.


.
, ,
,
.
,


.

68


,
, .
8

.

.
, 2013
2019 1,35
270 . 120
.

( , )
2015 -2017.
3 , 12, 10% - 300
. ,
2017 2020 13,5
10% - 1,35 .
350 .

.

.

.
7 250
4000 .
400 .
2020
.

69



900 2020 5,3 2025
20 .

50% 15$ mBTU
7$ mBTU,
.

(, )
( )

.


.


.
, 2020

.

1.

2.

.
3.

70

.
4.
,

5.


.
6.

.
7.



.
8.
,
.

71

7.

.
,
.

.


.

( ,
. ).
.

,
, ,
, ,


.

72


,
.

.

.

73