An approach for long-term (either retrospective or prospective) Rn measurements is proposed that is based on the combination of the high radon absorption ability of some polycarbonates with their alpha track-etch properties. The detection limit is projected to be (10 Bq m for an exposure time of 20 yr.
An approach for long-term (either retrospective or prospective) Rn measurements is proposed that is based on the combination of the high radon absorption ability of some polycarbonates with their alpha track-etch properties. The detection limit is projected to be (10 Bq m for an exposure time of 20 yr.
An approach for long-term (either retrospective or prospective) Rn measurements is proposed that is based on the combination of the high radon absorption ability of some polycarbonates with their alpha track-etch properties. The detection limit is projected to be (10 Bq m for an exposure time of 20 yr.
E-mail address: pressyan@hotmail.com (D. Pressyanov).
Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research A 447 (2000) 619}621 Letter to the Editor Polycarbonates: a long-term highly sensitive radon monitor D. Pressyanov*, J. Buysse, A. Po$jn, G. Meesen, A. Van Deynse Laboratory of Nuclear Physics, University of Gent, Proeftuinstraat 86, B-9000 Gent, Belgium Faculty of Physics, St. Kliment Ohridski University of Soxa, 5 James Bourchier Blvd., BG-1164 Soxa, Bulgaria Received 4 August 1999; received in revised form 5 November 1999; accepted 29 November 1999 Abstract An approach for long-term (either retrospective or prospective) ```Rn measurements is proposed that is based on the combination of the high radon absorption ability of some polycarbonates with their alpha track-etch properties. The detection limit is projected to be (10 Bq m` for an exposure time of 20 yr. 2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. Keywords: Radon; Alpha tracks; Retrospective measurements; Polycarbonates At present radon, and especially ```Rn, is recog- nised as a human carcinogen and may be the most important source of internal exposure for members of the public [1]. Radon-222 gives rise to decay products: ```Rn ?''```B' &&&``Po ?'` ' && `"Pb @'`` ' && `"Bi @'`" ' && `"Po ?'"" ' &&&`"Pb @'``W' && `"Bi @'`B' &&`"Po ?'``B' &&`""Pb(stable). Inhaled short-lived progeny (the "rst 4 isotopes, after ```Rn) deposit on the bronchial tree and the emitted radiation (especially ) can cause malig- nant transformations in the target cells. Many stud- ies among miners have shown a direct relation between lung cancer and radon exposure, but risk estimates for the public are not complete and con- troversial. In the light of continuing e!orts to gain conclusive data for the risk, precise ```Rn-exposure estimates for periods of a year or more are highly desirable. The most popular methods for long-term retrospective exposure estimates, rely on glass-im- planted `"Pb/`"Po [2,3] determinations. Recent experience shows that the accuracy achieved by this approach is at best a factor of two [4,5]. Other recent methods are based on spongy materials that serve as volume traps [5]. Up to now this technique is time and labor consuming and sensitive only to high indoor exposures. In this letter we show that the high radon absorption ability of some polycar- bonates can be combined with their alpha track- etch properties to achieve precise long-term (either retrospective or prospective) radon assessment. The detection limit is projected to be (10 Bq m` for an exposure of 20 yr, provided the polycarbonate 0168-9002/00/$- see front matter 2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. PII: S 0 1 6 8 - 9 0 0 2 ( 9 9 ) 0 1 2 9 1 - 7 Fig. 1. The net track-density beneath 72 m removed layer of Makrofol foils as a function of integrated ```Rn concentration (MBq h m`). used is su$ciently free of alpha-radioactive impu- rities, not related to the absorbed ```Rn. The high radon-absorption ability of some poly- carbonates has already been reported in the litera- ture [6]. For the present experiments we used 0.3 mm thick foils (Makrofol DE 1-4, commercial product of Bayer AG, Leverkusen, Germany). This material has recognised track-etch properties [7]. The basic idea is to remove from the foil, after its exposure to ```Rn, a surface layer thicker than the range of the most energetic alphas of the ```Rn progeny. This is '64 m for the 7.69 MeV alphas of `"Po. If ``"Rn progeny are present, the removal layer should be '80 m for the 8.78 MeV alpha particles of ``Po. The tracks formed deeper are due to a source within the foil volume (assumed to be the absorbed ```Rn and its short- and long-lived progeny). In this way the in#uence of widely vari- able plateout of the ```Rn progeny on the surface is cancelled out and the track density is directly pro- portional to the integrated ```Rn concentration. To test this method Makrofol foils were exposed to arti"cially created integrated ```Rn concentra- tions within the 8.5}52 MBq h m` range. This range corresponds to an exposure over 20 yr to concentrations of the order 50}300 Bq m`. After- wards a 72 m surface layer was removed by a chemical pre-etching in 6 M KOH#ethyl alcohol (1:1 volume ratio) at 603C [8]. Furthermore, the foils were etched electrochemically for 2.5 h as de- scribed in Ref. [9] and the tracks were counted by an image analyser. Results are shown in Fig. 1, where the linear dependence between track density and integrated ```Rn levels can clearly be seen. To verify the absence of contributions from the plateout of the ```Rn progeny on the surface, other sets of foils were irradiated using 7.69 MeV -par- ticle #uxes in the 0}50 000 cm` range and were subsequently treated in the same manner. The ir- radiation source was prepared by taking air sam- ples on 0.3 m Millipore "lters from arti"cially created high ```Rn/```Rn progeny concentrations. The "lters were removed and set aside for 40 min to allow ``Po to decay, and then the di!erent foils were exposed to pure 7.69 MeV -source. Alpha #uxes for di!erent intervals of irradiation were estimated by -spectrometry. The results of this experiment showed no signi"cant di!erence in the track densities between irradiated and non-irra- diated detectors. Therefore, we conclude that the track densities in Fig. 1 are associated with absorbed radon within the polycarbonate volume and any dependence on particular behaviour of aerosols/```Rn progeny in room air (a serious obstacle for the glass-implanted methods) is thus cancelled out. At present polycarbonate foils are increasingly used in households, as indicated by an increase in the production of polycarbonates in recent years. Samples of foils made of Makrofol, Lexan or sim- ilar materials may be easily used for long-term prospective and retrospective radon measurements. Year-long measurements in the Laboratory of Nu- clear Physics at the University of Gent found negli- gible fading and constant track-etch properties of Makrofol over long time intervals. When the foils were kept in an `olda (radon-free) air for years, the background track density did not increase signi"- cantly. This indicates that this material is su$- ciently free of alpha-radioactive impurities that are not related to the absorbed radon, and therefore it could be used for year-long measurements. Numer- ical estimates, using the approach described in Ref. [10], showed that, for projected exposure periods of 20 yr, the detection limit of the present method is at typical outdoors levels 620 D. Pressyanov et al. / Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research A 447 (2000) 619}621 ((10 Bq m`). The deviation due to the growth of `"Po in the volume is less than 10% for a 20 yr exposure. Another bene"cial point is the possibility to calibrate the samples a posteriori. This promises to eliminate any potential bias due to the individual variation of radon absorption/track-etch proper- ties of di!erent types of polycarbonate foils. References [1] ICRP Publication 65. Protection against radon-222 at home and at work. Annals of the ICRP 23. [2] R.S. Lively, E.P. Ney, Health Phys. 52 (1987) 411. [3] C. Samuelsson, Nature 334 (1988) 338. [4] J. Cornelis, C. Landsheere, A. Van Trier, H. Vanmarcke, A. Po$jn, Appl. Radiat. Isot. 43 (1992) 127. [5] S. Oberstedt, H. Vanmarcke, Health Phys. 70 (1996) 222. [6] H. MoK re, L.M. Hubbard, Radiat. Prot. Dosim. 74 (1997) 85. [7] M. Urban, E. Piesch, Radiat. Prot. Dosim. 1 (1981) 97. [8] B. DoK rschel, B. Burgkhardt, J. Lewitz, E. Piesch, G. Streubel, Radiat. Prot. Dosim. 50 (1993) 5. [9] H. Vanmarcke, A. Janssens, Nucl. Tracks 12 (1986) 689. [10] L.A. Currie, Anal. Chem. 40 (1969) 586. D. Pressyanov et al. / Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research A 447 (2000) 619}621 621