Cr Quax moved the following amendment to replace d) seconded by : Cr Stewart d) development controls mixed housing suburban - that 7.

13 be amended to require an outdoor living space of 80sqm . Division A division was called for, voting on which was as follows: For: Against: Councillors: Cameron Councillors: Anae Brewer Arthur Anae Mike Lee Len Brown Calum Penrose Dr Cathy Casey Dick Quax Alf Filipaina Sharon Stewart Hon Chris Fletcher Wayne Walker Michael Goudie Ann Hartley Penny Hulse Des Morrison Richard Northey Noelene Raffills David Taipari Glen Tupuhi Penny Webster George Wood

Cr Brewer moved the following amendment seconded by Cr Stewart That in the Townhouse And Apartment Building Zone, there be a minimum parking requirement of at least one car-park per dwelling of two or more bedrooms, and in both the Mixed Housing Urban and Suburban zones there be a minimum of one park for studios and one bedrooms as is proposed, and at least two car-parks as a minimum for any new dwelling two bedrooms or more (not three bedrooms as is proposed) to help mitigate increasing car numbers and on-street parking problems. A division was called for, voting on which was as follows: For: Against: Councillors: Cameron Councillors: Dr Cathy Brewer Casey Sharon Stewart Sandra Coney Sir John Walker Hon Chris Fletcher Michael Goudie Ann Hartley Penny Hulse Des Morrison Richard Northey Noelene Raffills David Taipari Glen Tupuhi Penny Webster George Wood Cr Calum Penrose The division was declared lost by 3 votes to 13.

Cr Goudie moved the following amendment seconded by Cr Casey 1)In the Mixed Housing Urban zone, remove parking minimums for dwellings with fewer than 3 bedrooms. (2) In the Mixed Housing Suburban zone, reducing parking minimums from 2 to 1 space for dwellings with 3 or more bedrooms A division was called for, voting on which was as follows: For: Against: Councillors: Dr Cathy Councillors: Cameron Casey Brewer Michael Goudie Sandra Coney Ann Hartley Hon Chris Fletcher Penny Hulse Des Morrison Richard Northey Calum Penrose David Taipari Noelene Raffills Glen Tupuhi Sharon Stewart Sir John Walker Penny Webster George Wood The division was declared lost by 7 votes to 10.

Member David Taipari moved the following amendment seconded by Member Anahera Morehu That provision be made for Integrated Housing Development as a restricted discretionary activity in Mixed Housing Suburban zones within a precinct. Put carried A division was called for, voting on which was as follows: For: Against: Councillors: Anae Councillors: Cameron Arthur Anae Brewer Len Brown Sandra Coney Dr Cathy Casey Hon Chris Fletcher Michael Goudie Mike Lee Ann Hartley Calum Penrose Penny Hulse Dick Quax Anahera Morehu Sharon Stewart Des Morrison Wayne Walker Richard Northey Noelene Raffills David Taipari Penny Webster The division was declared carried by 12 votes to 8

Cr Hartleys Amendments MOVED by Cr MA Hartley, seconded Cr M Lee:

2. Amend to: Landuse controls, Maximum density

a. Amend the No density limit rule by replacing it with the following One dwelling per 250m2 , where the site has an area in excess of 1200m2, with a frontage of 20m for > 80% of the length of its side boundaries as a restricted discretionary activity

A division was called for, voting on which was as follows: For: Against: Councillors: Cameron Councillors: Anae Brewer Arthur Anae Sandra Coney Len Brown Hon Chris Fletcher Dr Cathy Casey Ann Hartley Alf Filipaina Mike Lee Michael Goudie Calum Penrose Penny Hulse Dick Quax Des Morrison Sharon Stewart Richard Northey Sir John Walker Noelene Raffills Wayne Walker David Taipari Penny Webster George Wood

Cr Coney moved and amendment seconded by Lee b) On sites of 1200m2 and with 20m frontage development can occur at a density of 1:200m2 as a RDA this to be subject to the test for notification A division was called for, voting on which was as follows: For: Against: Councillors: Cameron Councillors: Anae Brewer Arthur Anae Dr Cathy Casey Len Brown Sandra Coney Alf Filipaina Ann Hartley Hon Chris Fletcher Mike Lee Michael Goudie Dick Quax Penny Hulse Sharon Stewart Des Morrison Wayne Walker Richard Northey George Wood Calum Penrose Noelene Raffills David Taipari Penny Webster

The division was declared lost by 9 votes to 12.

a) development of 4 units or more will be assessed as a restricted discretionary activity (RDA) with design assessment. b) On sites of 1200m2 and with 20m frontage development can occur at a density of 1:200m2 as a RDA A division was called for, voting on which was as follows: For: Against: Councillors: Anae Councillors: Alf Arthur Anae Filipaina Cameron Brewer Michael Goudie Len Brown David Taipari Dr Cathy Casey Glen Tupuhi Hon Chris Fletcher Sandra Coney Ann Hartley Penny Hulse Mike Lee Des Morrison Richard Northey Calum Penrose Dick Quax Noelene Raffills Sharon Stewart Wayne Walker Penny Webster George Wood