The document summarizes passages from Edgar Allan Poe's "Julius Bobman" that closely parallel passages from Washington Irving's "The Adventures of Captain Bonneville". It provides the parallel passages side by side and notes phrases that are nearly identical between the two works. The author suggests that Poe clearly drew from Irving's work for details and even language in parts of "Julius Bobman".
The document summarizes passages from Edgar Allan Poe's "Julius Bobman" that closely parallel passages from Washington Irving's "The Adventures of Captain Bonneville". It provides the parallel passages side by side and notes phrases that are nearly identical between the two works. The author suggests that Poe clearly drew from Irving's work for details and even language in parts of "Julius Bobman".
The document summarizes passages from Edgar Allan Poe's "Julius Bobman" that closely parallel passages from Washington Irving's "The Adventures of Captain Bonneville". It provides the parallel passages side by side and notes phrases that are nearly identical between the two works. The author suggests that Poe clearly drew from Irving's work for details and even language in parts of "Julius Bobman".
Souvce Sludies in EngIisI, No. 10 |JuI 8, 1930), pp. 147-151 FuIIisIed I University of Texas Press SlaIIe UBL http://www.jstor.org/stable/20779412 . Accessed 30/05/2013 0509 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. . University of Texas Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Studies in English. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 160.45.152.64 on Thu, 30 May 2013 05:09:01 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions A NOTE ON FOE'S JULIUS BOBMAN B H. AvIin Tuvnev Move lIan one IiogvapIev oJ Foe Ias suggesled lIal Foe oved sonelIing lo WasIinglon Ivving. WoodIevv, Jov inslance, slales lIal sone oJ lIe delaiIs in AvlIuv Oovdon Fn veve suggesled I Ivving's Aslovia,1 and a siniIav oIsevvalion is nade I Hevve AIIen.2 Il is cevlain lIal Foe Inev sone oJ Ivving's vvilings: Jov aIlIougI Ie vvole lo N. C. BvooIs in 1838 lIal Ie vas nol convevsanl vilI Ivving's vvilings and lIal Ie Iad vead nolIing oJ Iis since ... a Io, save Iis Ovanada/' Ie Iad in veaIil puI IisIed a IenglI veviev oJ Ivving's Aslovia in lIe SoulIevn Lilevav Messengev in 1837. Il is pIain, loo, lIal Ie Iad vead Ivving's Advenluves oJ Caplain BonneviIIe al sone line IeJove 1840, since in Januav oJ lIal eav appeaved lIe iniliaI inslaInenl oJ Iis JouvnaI oJ JuIius Bodnan, lo Ie JoIIoved I Jive olIev inslaInenls in as nan nonlIs, in sevevaI cIaplevs oJ vIicI Ie Ias cIeavI dvavn on TIe Advenluves oJ Caplain BonneviIIe |1837) nol onI Jov lIe delaiIs oJ Iis slov, Iul aIso al vavious poinls Jov lIe vev Ianguage lIal Ie uses. I give IeIov lIe passages in vIicI Ie lvacIs Ivving nosl cIoseI, selling dovn in pavaI IeI coIunns lIe nallev invoIved. I Iave pul in ilaIics lIe passages lIal ave idenlicaI ov vivluaII idenlicaI in pIvase. JuIius Bodnan3 TIe Ieavevs veve vepaiving a povlion oJ lIeiv dan, and evev slep oJ lIeiv pvogvess vas dis linclI seen. One I one lIe avcIilecls veve pevceived lo ap pvoacI lIe edge oJ lIe svanp, eacI vilI a snaII IvancI in Iis BonneviIIe's Advenluves4 In a IillIe vIiIe, lIvee olIevs appeaved al lIe Iead oJ lIe dan, Ivinging slicIs and IusIes. WilI lIese lIe pvoceeded diveclI lo lIe Iavviev, vIicI Caplain Bon neviIIe pevceived vas in need oJ vepaiv. Having deposiled lIeiv oodIevv, O. E. Edgav AIIan Foe, Boslon, 1909, I, pp. 191, 236. 2 AIIen, Hevve IsvaJeI, Nev YovI, 1927, II, pp. 419, 463. Woe's WovIs, ed. Janes A. Havvison, Nev YovI, 1902, III, pp. 49-50. 4Ivving, WasIinglon TIe Advenluves oJ Caplain BonneviIIe, KnicIevIocIev edilion, Nev YovI, 1895, I, pp. 286-291. This content downloaded from 160.45.152.64 on Thu, 30 May 2013 05:09:01 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 148 Sludies in EngIisI JuIius Bodnan noulI. WilI lIis Ie pvoceeded lo lIe dan, and pIaced il cave JuII and IongiludinaII, on lIe pavl vIicI Iad given va. Hav ing done lIis, Ie dived innedi aleI, and in a Jev seconds ve appeaved aIove lIe suvJace vilI a quanlil oJ sliJJ nud, vIicI Ie Jivsl squeezed so as lo dvain il oJ ils noisluve in a gveal degvee, and lIen appIied vilI Iis Jeel and laiI |using lIe Iallev as a lvoveI) lo lIe IvancI vIicI Ie Iad jusl Iaid upon lIe IveacI. He lIen nade oJJ anong lIe lvees, and vas quicII succeeded I anolIev oJ lIe connunil, vIo venl lIvougI pveciseI lIe sane opevalion. . . . TIis nallev acconpIisIed, lIe vIoIe connunil seened lo lIinI a IoIida vas desevved, and, ceasing vovI al once, Iegan lo cIase eacI olIev aIoul in lIe valev, diving, and sIapping lIe suvJace vilI lIeiv laiIs. WIen al vovI sone sal upon lIe Iind Iegs, in lIe posluve so connon vilI squivveIs, and gnaved al lIe vood, lIeiv Jove Jeel vesling upon lIe edge oJ lIe cul, and lIeiv Ieads lIvusl Jav inlo lIe apevluve. . . . Caplain BonneviIIe,5 il viII Ie ve nenIeved, discvedils lIe aIIeged BonneviLIe's Advenluves Ioads upon lIe IvoIen pavl, lIe dived inlo lIe valev, and sIovlI veappeaved al lIe suvJace. EacI nov IvougIl a quanlil oJ nud, vilI vIicI Ie vouId pIaslev lIe slicIs and IusIes jusl deposiled. TIis Iind oJ nasonv conlinued Jov sone line, vepealed suppIies oJ vood and nud Ieing IvougIl, and lvealed in lIe sane nan nev. . . . TIis done, lIe induslvious Ieav evs induIged in a IillIe vecvealion, cIasing eacI olIev aIoul lIe pond, dodging and vIisIing aIoul -on lIe suvJace, ov diving lo lIe Iollon: and in lIeiv JvoIic, oJlen sIapping lIeiv laiIs on lIe valev vilI a Ioud cIacIing sound. . . . He lIen cIinIed lIe IanI cIose lo vIeve lIe caplain vas con ceaIed, and, veaving IinseIJ on Iis Iind quavlevs, in a silling po silion, pul Iis Jove pavs againsl a oung pine lvee, and Iegan lo cul lIe IavI vilI Iis leelI. . . . Caplain BonnevUIe, Iovevev, discvedils, on lIe vIoIe, lIe aI 5B nenlioning' lIe nane oJ Caplain BonneviIIe al lIe Ieginning oJ lIis passage, vIicI Jinds a cIosev pavaIIeI in BonneviIIe's Adven luves lIan an oJ lIe olIevs, Foe possiII inlended lo pvolecl IinseIJ againsl lIe cIavge oJ pIagiavisn. Hovevev, Ie does nol speciJicaII nenlion lIe vovI I Ivving. This content downloaded from 160.45.152.64 on Thu, 30 May 2013 05:09:01 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions A Nole on Foe's JuIius Bodnan 149 JuIius Bodnan sagacil oJ lIe aninaI in lIis vespecl, and lIinIs il Ias no Jav lIev ain lIan lo gel lIe lvee dovn, vilIoul an suIlIe caIcuIa lion in vespecl lo ils node oJ de scenl. TIis allviIule, Ie lIinIs, Ias Ieen ascviIed lo il Jvon lIe civcunslance lIal lvees in gen evaI, vIicI gvov neav lIe navgin oJ valev, eilIev Iean IodiI lo vavds lIe slvean, ov slvelcI lIeiv nosl pondevous IinIs in lIal di veclion, in seavcI oJ lIe IigIlJ space and aiv, vIicI ave lIeve usuaII Jound. TIe Ieavev, Ie sas, allacIs, oJ couvse, lIose lvees vIicI ave neavesl al Iand, and on lIe IanIs oJ lIe slvean ov pond, and lIese, vIen cul lIvougI, naluvaII pvepondevale lovavds lIe valev. TIe pvincipaI Jood oJ lIe Ieavevs is IavI, and oJ lIis lIe pul I veguIavI a Iavge slove Jov vin lev pvovision, seIecling lIe pvop ev Iind vilI cave and deIiIeva lion. A vIoIe lviIe, consisling sonelines oJ lvo ov lIvee Iun dved, viII sel oul logelIev upon a Jovaging expedilion, and pass lIvougI gvoves oJ lvees aII ap pavenlI siniIav, unliI a pavlic uIav one suils lIeiv Janc. TIis lIe cul dovn, and, IveaIing oJJ ils nosl lendev IvancIes, divide lIen inlo sIovl sIips oJ equaI IenglI and divesl lIese sIips oJ lIeiv IavI, vIicI lIe cavv lo lIe neavesl slvean Ieading lo BonneviIIe's Advenluves Ieged sagacil oJ lIe Ieavev in lIis pavlicuIav, and lIinIs lIe aninaI Ias no olIev ain lIan lo gel lIe lvee dovn, vilIoul an oJ lIe suIlIe caIcuIalion as lo ils node ov diveclion oJ JaIIing. TIis allviIule, Ie lIinIs, Ias Ieen ascviIed lo lIen Jvon lIe civcunslances, lIal nosl lvees gvoving neav valev-couvses, eilIev Iean IodiI lovavds lIe slvean, ov slvelcI lIeiv Iavgesl IinIs in lIal diveclion, lo IeneJil I lIe space, lIe IigIl, and lIe aiv lo Ie Jound lIeve. TIe Ieav ev, oJ couvse, allacIs lIose lvees vIicI ave neavesl al Iand, and on lIe IanIs oJ lIe slvean ov pond. He naIes incisions vound lIen, ov, in lecInicaI pIvase, IeIls lIen vilI Iis leelI, and vIen lIe JaII, lIe naluvaII laIe lIe diveclion in vIicI lIeiv lvunIs pvepondevale. Oveal cIoice, accovding lo lIe caplain, is cevlainI dispIaed I lIe Ieavev in seIecling lIe vood vIicI is lo JuvnisI IavI Jov vin lev pvovision. TIe vIoIe Ieavev IouseIoId, oId and oung, sel oul upon lIis Iusiness, and viII oJlen naIe Iong jouvnes IeJove suiled. Sonelines lIe cul dovn lvees oJ lIe Iavgesl size and lIen cuII lIe IvancIes, lIe IavI oJ vIicI is nosl lo lIeiv lasle. TIese lIe cul inlo IenglIs oJ aIoul lIvee Jeel, conve lIen lo lIe valev, and JIoal lIen lo lIeiv Iodges, vIeve lIe ave sloved ava Jov vinlev. TIe ave slu dious oJ cIeanIiness and conJovl This content downloaded from 160.45.152.64 on Thu, 30 May 2013 05:09:01 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 150 Sludies in EngIisI JuIius Bodnan lIeiv viIIage, lIence JIoaling lIen Ione. OccasionaII lIe sIips ave sloved ava Jov lIe vinlev vilI oul Ieing slvipped oJ lIe IavI: . . . lIe ave caveJuI lo venove lIe veJuse vood Jvon lIeiv dveII ings, as soon as lIe Iave ealen lIe vind, laIing lIe slicIs lo sone dislance. Buving lIe spving oJ lIe eav lIe naIes ave nevev Jound vilI lIe lviIe al Ione, Iul aIvas I lIenseIves, eilIev sing I ov in pavlies oJ lvo ov lIvee, vIen lIe appeav lo Iose lIeiv usuaI IaIils oJ sagacil, and JaII an eas pve lo lIe avls oJ lIe lvappev. In sunnev lIe veluvn Ione, and Ius lIenseIves, vilI lIe JenaIes, in naIing pvovision Jov vinlev. TIe ave descviIed as exceedingI Jevocious aninaIs vIen ivvilaled. TIe expevienced lvappev veadiI delecls lIe pvesence oJ Ieavev in an pond ov slvean: discoveving lIen I a lIousand appeavances vIicI vouId aJJovd no indicalion lo lIe unpvaclised oIsevvev. . . . TIis is sinpI conslvucled lo calcI lIe Jool oJ lIe aninaI. TIe lvappev pIaces il usuaII in sone posilion neav lIe sIove, and jusl IeIov lIe suvJace oJ lIe valev, Jaslening il I a snaII cIain lo a poIe slucI in lIe nud. In lIe noulI oJ lIe nacIine is pIaced one end oJ a snaII IvancI: lIe olIev end vising aIove lIe suvJace, and veII soaIed in lIe Iiquid Iail vIose odov is Jound lo Ie allvaclive lo lIe Ieavev. As soon as lIe aninaI scenls il, Ie vuIs Iis nose againsl lIe lvig, BonneviIIe's Advenluves in lIeiv Iodges, and aJlev lIeiv vepasls, viII cavv oul lIe slicIs Jvon vIicI lIe Iave ealen lIe IavI, and lIvov lIen inlo lIe cuvvenl Ieond lIe Iavviev. In lIe spving, vIicI is lIe Iveeding season, lIe naIe Ieaves lIe JenaIe al Ione, and sels oJJ on a louv oJ pIeasuve, vanIIing oJlen lo a gveal dislance, vecvealing Iin seIJ in evev cIeav and quiel ex panse oJ valev on Iis va, and cIinIing lIe IanIs occasionaII lo Jeasl upon lIe lendev spvouls oJ lIe oung viIIovs. As sun nev advances, Ie gives up Iis IacIeIov vanIIes, and IelIinIing IinseIJ oJ IouseIeeping dulies, veluvns Ione lo Iis nale and Iis nev pvogen, and navsIaIs lIen aII Jov lIe Jovaging expedilion in quesl oJ vinlev pvovisions. Fvaclice . . . Ias given sucI a quicIness oJ ee lo lIe expevi enced lvappev in aII lIal veIales lo Iis puvsuil, lIal Ie can delecl lIe sIigIlesl sign oJ Ieavev, Iov evev viId. He nov goes lo vovI lo sel lIe lvap: pIanling il upon lIe sIove, in sone cIosen pIace, lvo ov lIvee incIes IeIov lIe suvJace oJ lIe valev, and secuves il I a cIain lo a poIe sel deep in lIe nud. A snaII lvig is lIen slvipped oJ ils IavI, and one end is dipped in lIe nedicine, as lIe lvappevs levn lIe pecuIiav Iail vIicI lIe enpIo. TIis end oJ lIe slicI vises aIove lIe suvJace oJ lIe valev, lIe olIev end is pIanled Ielveen lIe javs oJ lIe lvap. TIe Ieavev possess ing an acule sense oJ sneII, is This content downloaded from 160.45.152.64 on Thu, 30 May 2013 05:09:01 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions A Nole on Foe's JuIius Bodnan1' 151 JuIius Bodnan and, in so doing, sleps upon lIe lvap, spvings il, and is caugIl.... BonneviIIe's Advenluves soon allvacled I lIe odov oJ lIe Iail. As Ie vaises Iis nose lo vavd il, Iis Jool is caugIl in lIe lvap. Foe evidenlI vvole a nunIev oJ lIese passages vilI Iis Ivving open IeJove Iin. His nelIod oJ vovIing vilI Iis souvces in lIis inslance is nol unIiIe lIal adopled in lIe case oJ olIev Iovvovings nade I Iin: as, Jov exanpIe, in Iis enpIonenl oJ MovveII's Voages in Iis AvlIuv Oovdon Fn4 and oJ Ivving's Aslovia in JuIius Bodnan* ?Foe,s WovIs, ed. Slednan and WoodIevv, Nev YovI, 1895, V, pp. 356-358. nIid., V, pp. 359-361. This content downloaded from 160.45.152.64 on Thu, 30 May 2013 05:09:01 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions