Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Legacy All Shorn Florence
Legacy All Shorn Florence
Legacy All Shorn Florence
nternstlons
Vol. 8, No.1
January 1984
•
etln
Women and Mission
I n his classic study on American Protestant Women in World
Mission, R. Pierce Beaver-the founding editor of this
journal-traced the contributions of American Protestant women
not just to look at the past and the great things that have been
done by our forebears, but to join in the creative tasks of mission
in the future, to share what Melinda Roper calls the "visions and
to the missionary movement from the nineteenth century. "Here is dreams of the coming of the reign of God in a particular culture,
the font," wrote Beaver, "of all organized women's activities in the time, and place."
churches and to some extent in the community." In this issue of
the International Bulletin, which focuses on "Women and Mission,"
all the articles have been written by women. On Page
In her address to a Catholic Mission Congress in Baltimore,
Melinda Roper, president of the Maryknoll Sisters, called attention 2 Faith and Pluralism in Global Mission Experience
to the need for missions to embrace diversity and communion in Melinda Roper, MM
many forms. This appeal is based on her experiences in a remote
Indian village in Mexico where, she recalls, "I began my romance 4 Roles of Married Women Missionaries: A Case Study
with the pre-industrial, pre-technological, pre-urban peoples of Joyce M Bowers
our globe."
Joyce M. Bowers tells of her participation in a project for re- 9 The Involvement of Roman Catholic Women in
thinking the roles of women in Lutheran missions, with the les- Mission since 1965
sons of history and of the women's movement behind them in the Mary Motte, F.MM
late 1970s. On the Catholic side, Mary Motte examines some of
the major changes for women in mission that came in the wake of 12 The First Protestant Missionary Effort: Why Did It
Vatican Council II. It may be too early to take an accurate measure Fail?
of all the changes that are still taking place, in both Protestant and Amy Glassner Gordon
Catholic circles, but it is crucial to take note of them for further
research, reflection, and action. 18 The Legacy of J. H. Oldham
Amy Glassner Gordon presents a ground-breaking study of Kathleen Bliss
what was actually the first Protestant missionary effort, in Brazil
in the 1550s. The whole enterprise lacked any prospects for perma- 24 The Legacy of Florence Allshorn
nence from the very start, for it was carried on by some 600 Eleanor Brown
Frenchmen-but no women!
In our continuing Legacy series, we have articles on two Brit- 28 Noteworthy
ish mission leaders whose careers had mutual influence. Kathleen
Bliss tells of the work of J. H. Oldham, whose contributions to the 30 Book Reviews
mission movement in this century are incalculable. Among his nu-
merous writings is a book that introduced the work of Florence 36 Fifteen Outstanding Books of 1983 for Mission
Allshorn to many readers, and it is her legacy that is introduced Studies
here by Eleanor Brown. The lessons that Florence Allshorn
brought to Christian mission workers-not in writings but in the 40 Reader's Response
experiences of life in St. Julian's Community-have only grown in
importance with the passage of time. 46 Dissertation Notices
With such accounts of pioneering contributions by women to
the work and study of the Christian mission, our readers are urged 48 Book Notes
of issionary Research
Material about Oldham
Bliss, Kathleen. "J. H. Oldham," article in Dictionary of National Biography. Martin, W. Lance. "Joseph Houldsworth Oldham: His Thought and Its De-
London: Oxford Univ. Press, 1981. velopment." Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Univ. of St. Andrews,
Clatworthy, Frederick James. The Formulation of British Colonial Education Policy. Scotland, 1968.
Ann Arbor, Mich.: Univ. of Michigan Press, 1971, passim. Rouse, Ruth and Stephen Charles Neill, eds. A Historyof the Ecumenical Move-
Eddy, George Sherwood. Pathfinders of the World Missionary Crusade. New ment, 1517-1948. Philadelphia; Westminster Press, 1954, passim.
York: Abingdon-Cokesbury, 1945, pp. 277-86. Visser It Hooft, Willem A. "Oldham Takes the Lead," chapter 8 in The Gen-
Hogg, William Richey. Ecumenical Foundations. New York: Harper, 1952, pas- esis and Formation of the World Council of Churches. Geneva: World Council
sim. of Churches, 1982.
Hopkins, C. Howard. John R. Mott, 1865-1955. Grand Rapids, Mich: Wm. B.
Eerdmans, 1979, passim.
Eleanor Brown
January 1984 25
the curriculum, but in her conception of what was the essential only published article, "Corporate Life on a Mission Station," she
purpose of the training. She enlisted the help of excellent lecturers, set out forcefully what she saw that failure to be:
and broadened the range of speakers on topics of the day; she de-
veloped the practical training-all things that are a usual part of The failures amongst missionaries are those who have lost the for-
training. Underlying all this was her burning conviction that the ward vital impulse, the life of the Spirit, because they have never
prime necessity was for the Christian witness to be real. Her years got through their own spiritual, personal and social problems. This
may be due either to the fact that they were the wrong kind to send
in Africa had shown her the inadequacy of conventional religion
out-people whose spiritual life was unreal-or because they have
up against the reality of conflicting personal relationships. This
become caught in the cog of the mechanical routine of too much
was by no means only a projection of her own experience. Her work, and have become exhausted and unable to deal with their
clear eyes had made her aware of what she called "the silent disas- problems. Failing to find success in their spiritual and mental life
ters" that went on in many missionary lives underneath all the they are seeking it by putting almost all their vitality into "the job."
hard work and the building up of successful institutions: the loss But womanhood may not do that. Womanhood means more than a
of vision, the hardening of attitudes, the acceptance of mediocre bright vision of success in a job; it means patience and longsuffering
standards. and the deepening of gentlenesses; it means going down into deep
places.
Florence Allshorn's first aim was to develop in her students
some real experience in holding together belief and action, theory In this article, much of which is relevant fifty years later, she
and practice: far more important to her than any technical or aca- goes on to speak of how, in training, the emotional life of the stu-
demic training (though she valued both) was that they should be dent has been left to take care of itself-"this queer hinterland
growing in their love for God and their capacity to live with their where there huddle the anxieties, timidities, antagonisms, self-
fellow students. She considered doctrine to be "of such importance deceptions, which somehow our spiritual life does not go deep
that it must not be separated from the rest of the programme. Its enough to touch." Florence was considerably ahead of her time in
position in this training is that it is related directly to the total ex- getting all the help she could from psychology, and some of the
perience of each person. The truths we know and teach must be books that are now considered classics were on her shelves soon
'proved upon the pulses.'" So pious words in chapel followed by after they appeared. But what she read only confirmed her grow-
complacent or contemptuous attitudes in conversation would meet ing conviction that any deep change in a person needs time. She
her quick challenge: lofty sentiments about beauty would be held was finding as the years went on that the year allotted to mission-
up against sloppy standards of practical work; new insights into ary training was only the first stage of a process. "You really can-
the great Christian truths emerged from discussion of some small- not do much in the initial training," she wrote to a colleague.
seeming argument or breakdown in the common life. "They have not come to the end of themselves; you can only gently
For many of Allshorn's students it was a revelation of the try to make them more real."
wholeness of life. Everything was to come under the discipline of The first furlough was crucial: watching her own students
Christ's two great commandments; but within that discipline there coming home after what was often a very testing first tour, Flor-
ence saw that as well as those who seemed satisfied with their life
and service, there were "those who had gone out on a big spiritual
adventure, but were rather immature in Christ and found they
could not cope." For these especially it was necessary to have time
"[Allshorn] was an artist rather for quiet thought and for guidance from someone further on, for
than a moralist in her approach regripping their vision in a deeper way.
But what was happening (what still happens) was that they
to people, and she had the were being plunged into a succession of courses, conferences,
meetings at which they had to give a "good" picture of their work,
patience of an artist as well as all conspiring to mask the things that were troubling them; so that
the artist's care for perfection." often they returned to the same situation no further along, more
likely than ever to be dominated by obvious needs, and to stop
growing-in Florence's eyes the only real defeat.
With her usual incisiveness Florence Allshorn wrote in a
was a sense of freedom, freedom to learn, to grow, to take risks, to memorandum:
rebel, to have fun. Florence's deep seriousness about basic issues
was balanced by an irrepressible gaiety: as one of her friends said, Some very clear thinking has to be done about what is real vocation.
unlike the self-conscious obedience that in many of us drains life If they go out primarily to do medical work then obviously the first
claim on their time when they come home is the renewal of their
of color, "her obedience put the colour into life, and enabled oth-
medical knowledge, and consultation with doctors who can help
ers to see a new world, informed by beauty and light." "Religion
them. If they go out primarily as ambassadors for Christ, then surely
to me really is a song," she said one day. She was an artist rather the first claim on their time and energies is this period of readjust-
than a moralist in her approach to people, and she had the patience ment to Him and fresh vision of Him, and nothing must be allowed
of an artist as well as the artist's care for perfection. "I do feel that to take its place.
Protestantism works too much on a subconscious feeling of suspi-
cion-possibly because it is so concerned with sin-that it loses
the vision of the lovely thing a human soul really is."
Toward Community
It was just because of the possibilities Florence Allshorn saw
in the young women coming into training that she was able to It was largely her awareness of this need which led Florence All-
confront head-on not only their own weaknesses but what she felt shorn to resign from the Church Missionary Society training and
to be the unfaced failures of the mission field. "I believe our great to launch into the final, the hardest, and the most creative adven-
trouble is that we won't stir up courage to look at failure." In her ture of her life: the founding of St. Julian's Community in Sussex.
January 1984 27
needs and new insights; most of the present community never naughting more simply and readily with practice, you do know that
knew Florence "in the flesh"; but they still keep steadfast in their you are living in a new and fresh world: that at the root of you, in-
living witness to lithe peace that lies on the other side of conflict" stead of the old unease, the old feeling of guilt, the lovelessness,
and to the healing alchemy of love. there is a content happy shining, whatever comes. If God is love,
In Florence's last address, given when she was already ill, she and we were made to love as the stars were made to shine, then
spoke of something she had "proved upon the pulses": every creature is desirous of finding this disinterested love.
It is a hard way, but everyone who has known this "losing your life This faith lived out within a small company is the legacy of Flor-
to find it" tells us how, as the mind and desire go the way of self- ence Allshorn to all those who were and are willing to receive it.
Bibliography
Although Florence Allshorn wrote nothing specifically for publication,
some of her writings have been published.
Allshorn, Florence, "Corporate Life on a Mission Station." International Re- Oldham, J. H. Florence Allshorn and theStoryofSt. Julian 's. London: SCM Press,
view of Missions Vol. 23 (October 1934), 497-511. An address given at a 1951.
Church Missionary Society Conference. Also published as a separate Potts, Margaret I. St. Julian 's: An Experiment in Two Continents. London: SCM
pamphlet. Press, 1968.
- - . The Notebooks of Florence Allshorn. Selected and Arranged by a Mem-
ber of St. Julian's Community. London: SCM Press, 1957.
Noteworthy---------------------.
Meetings
The American Society of Missiology will hold its 1984 annual states. Not included are 162 overseas workers of Catholic Relief
meeting at Princeton Theological Seminary, Princeton, New Services who are working in 70 countries. Trends over the last
Jersey, June 22-24, on the theme "Third World Theologies and twenty-seven years can be seen from the following statistics:
the Mission of the Church." The Association of Professors of 1956 5,126 missionaries
Mission will meet June 21-22 at Princeton in conjunction with 1962 7,146 missionaries
the ASM. The ASMIAPM annual meeting in 1985 will be held 1968 9,655 missionaries
at Trinity Evangelical Theological Seminary, Deerfield, Illinois, 1976 7,010 missionaries
June 20-23, and in 1986 at North Park Seminary in Chicago, 1980 6,393 missionaries
June 19-22. Further information may be obtained from Wilbert 1983 6,246 missionaries
R. Shenk, Secretary-Treasurer of the ASM, Box 1092, Elkhart, The major sending groups are the Jesuits with 561 (671 in
Indiana 46515. President of the ASM for 1983-84 is William 1976), the Maryknoll Fathers and Brothers with 542 (676 in
Richey Hogg, Perkins School of Theology, Southern Methodist 1976), and the Maryknoll Sisters with 399 members (493 in
University, Dallas, Texas. 1976) serving abroad.
There are 1,533 serving in South America, 1,468 in Asia,
United States Catholic Missionaries 990 in Africa, 640 in Oceania, 650 in Central America, 517 in the
There were 6,246 Catholic missionaries from the United States Caribbean, 68 in the Middle East, and 34 in Europe. The indi-
serving abroad in 1983, according to the latest report in Mission vidual countries with the largest are Brazil (456), Peru (459), and
Handbook 1983, published by the United States Catholic Mission the Philippines (385). Copies of the report may be ordered from
Association. Counted in the annual survey are United States USCMA, 1233 Lawrence Street N.E., Washington, D.C. 20017.
citizens serving for at least one year outside the 48 contiguous Cost: $1.50 domestic; $3.00 overseas airmail.