Professional Documents
Culture Documents
On New Social Movements and "The Reinvention of India"
On New Social Movements and "The Reinvention of India"
On New Social Movements and "The Reinvention of India"
n On January 26, 2003, the National Alliance of Peoples Movements (NAPM ! an "n#ia$ %i#e net%or& of social movements $ launche# the Desh Bachao, Desh Banao Abhiyan ('('(A, )ave the Nation, (uil# the Nation *ampai+n in Plachima#a in ,erala- After a t%o$month lon+ march, the campai+n en#e# in Ayo#hya in .ttar Pra#esh %here a National Peoples A+en#a %as #eclare#- /he campai+n ! inclu#in+ the location of its 0e+innin+ an# conclusion an# the a+en#a that %as #eclare# ! is very tellin+ in terms of the convulsions that are currently transformin+ "n#ian society- /he National Peoples A+en#a (NPA starts as follo%s1
/he A0hiyan %as launche# on January 26, 2003, from Plachima#a ('ist- Pala&&a# in
,erala, %ith a protest a+ainst the *oca$*ola factory as a sym0ol of the stru++le a+ainst 2lo0alisation- 3or over t%o months, the A0hiyan traverse# throu+h 45 states, participatin+ in over 360 lar+e rallies an# hol#in+ meetin+s an# #iscussions %ith activists an# or+anisations- "t conclu#e# at Ayo#hya on March 30 th 2003, %ith a call for reli+ious tolerance, secularism, opposition to the political$economic policy %hich lea#s to the #ominance of 2lo0al *apital as also a #etermination to strive for a 7ust an# sustaina0le alternative mo#el of #evelopment (NAPM, 20031 4 -
8aunchin+ the '('(A in Plachima#a, ,erala, %here *oca *olas rava+in+ of +roun# %ater resources constitutes a +rave testimony to the social conse9uences of neoli0eral restructurin+ an# conclu#in+ in Ayo#hya, the infamous site of the #emolition of the (a0ri Mas7i# in 4552 an# conse9uent out0rea&s of communal po+roms is nothin+ short of an e:plicit sym0olic positionin+ of the NAPMs stru++le to ;save< an# ;0uil#< the nation s9uarely at the centre of the transformative con7uncture %hich *or0ri#+e an# =arriss have referre# to as >the reinvention of "n#ia"n#ia, %rite *or0ri#+e an# =arriss (20001 :vi , >%as the su07ect of a particular, very #eli0erate act of invention in %hich a nation$0uil#in+ pro7ect %as crafte# for the soon$to$0e soverei+n an# in#epen#ent state 0y influential lea#ers of the nationalist movement4- /his invention %as characteri?e# 0y the ma&in+ of >a template for the invention of mo#ern "n#ia %hich consiste# of four >mytholo+ies of rule ! #emocracy, fe#eralism, socialism, an# secularism ! %hich provi#e# the national pro7ect of state$le#
1
"n#ians, many of %hom ha# 0een e#ucate# in @n+lish, most of them men %ho constitute# the *onstituent Assem0ly of 'ecem0er 45A6-
2 capitalist #evelopment %ith i#eolo+ical le+itimacy (i0i#1 24$22B see also *or0ri#+e, 4556 - (y the 4550s, the protracte# unma&in+ of this pro7ect ! stretchin+, accor#in+ to *or0ri#+e an# =arriss (20001 *hapters A an# 6 , 0ac& to the mi#$4560s ! ha# en+en#ere# ne% an# >vi+orous attempts to re$ima+ine the country, its economy an# society (i0i#1 :viii - .nli&e the invention of "n#ia on the eve of the Ca7, this is not a >consi#ere# process 0ut a process of >stru++le an# ne+otiation %hich has emer+e# from >the failin+s of the mo#erni?in+ mission of the Nehruvian state (i0i#- :viii , an# %hich is characterise# 0y a particular social fiel# of force- On the one han#, there are the >elite revolts of neoli0eral restructurin+ an# =in#u communalism, 0oth of %hich reflect an# are vehicles for the interests an# aspirations especially of the mi##le class an# hi+her$caste "n#ians (i0i#-1 :i: - On the other han#, there are multiple forms of >su0altern politics %hich represent >another lon+ history, that of resistance to the esta0lishe# or#er 0y those %ho have 0een the o07ects of oppression (i0i#1 :i: - /he forms of su0altern politics that *or0ri#+e an# =arriss sin+le out for scrutiny ran+e from %hat they call >empo%erment from %ithout ! i-e- constitutional provisions for 7o0 reservations, reservations of e#ucational places an# seats in political assem0lies, an# +enerally the e:tension of the franchise to #alits an# a#ivasis ! to >empo%erment from %ithin ! i-e- a ran+e of ne% social movements (N)Ms an# political parties that have recently emer+e# from these mar+inalise# communities, an# their increase# participation in electoral politics 2/he focal point of this article is precisely the role of N)Ms in the >reinvention of "n#ia, an# in particular, the %ay in %hich their politics are analy?e# an# represente# in aca#emic perspectives3- " focus on t%o &ey areas1 firstly, the assertion that "n#ias N)Ms represent voices of ;otherness< emanatin+ from 0eyon# the postcolonial #evelopment pro7ect an# articulatin+ a re7ection of this pro7ect, an# secon#ly, the ar+ument that N)Ms in "n#ia are most li&ely to have a positive impact upon the situation of mar+inalise# su0altern +roups if they see& empo%erment throu+h the li0eral #emocratic state- /he #iscussion is carrie# out in li+ht of empirical #ata from my o%n research on the character
2
3or relate# ar+uments, see Da#av (2000 , Jaffrelot (2000, 2003 , *or0ri#+e (2000 , Earshney (2000 , 3uller
an# =arriss (2004 , 3ran&el (2006 , *or0ri#+e, Filliams, )rivastava an# Eeron (2006 an# ,avira7 (2000 3
" %ant to note from the outset that " use the term ne% social movements strictly in a temporal sense to refer
to movements that emer+e# from the late 4560s on%ar#s- Attempts to #ra% fine lines 0et%een ol# an# ne% in social movement research is ar+ua0ly a futile en#eavour as in most cases the suppose#ly ;ol#< is present in the ;ne%< an# the suppose#ly ;ne%< is present in the ;ol#< ! %hether it pertains to +roups, issues, strate+ies, or i#eolo+ies (see for e:ample *alhoun 4553 - "n#ee#, )hahs (45GG overvie% of +rassroots mo0ili?ations in "n#ia 0rin+s out the #eep historical linea+e of most of the movements that authors such as Omve#t, Eanai& an# (asu #esi+nate as ;ne%<- 3orest #%ellers stru++les, for e:ample, +o 0ac& to the colonial era %hen forest le+islation %as intro#uce# 0y the (ritish, meanin+ that a movement such as *hip&o ha# #eep historical antece#ents (see also Can+an, 2000 - )ee )hah (4550, 2002 movementsan# Cao (2000 for instructive overvie%s of "n#ian social
3 an# tra7ectory of the Narma#a (achao An#olan (N(AB )ave the Narma#a Movement , one of the most %ell$&no%n an# important social movements to emer+e in "n#ia over the past t%o #eca#es- /he N(A emer+e# in opposition to the construction of a series of lar+e #ams on the Narma#a Civer in central an# Festern "n#ia- /he #am pro7ects %ill cause e:tensive su0mer+ence an# #isplacement, an# in the mi#$45G0s social action +roups %or&in+ %ith #am$affecte# adivasi (in#i+enous +roups an# +ra#ually also in caste =in#u farmin+ communities in Maharashtra, 2u7arat an# Ma#hya Pra#esh starte# an intense 9uestionin+ of the responsi0le authorities as to the prospects for fair an# a#e9uate resettlement an# reha0ilitation- (y the late 45G0s, several of these +roups ha# mer+e# into the pan$state or+anisation Narma#a (achao An#olan (N(AB )ave the Narma#a Movement %hich articulate# a stance of total opposition to the &in+pin in the pro7ect ! the )ar#ar )arovar Pro7ect ())P ! an# %hich further em0e##e# its campai+n a+ainst the ))P in a trenchant criti9ue of the #ominant mo#el of #evelopment in "n#ia (see (avis&ar, 4556B '%ive#i, 2006B Nilsen, 2006 an# forthcomin+ - " choose to frame my ar+ument this %ay 0ecause the N(A is particularly relevant to the ar+uments #evelope# in this article1 its politics relate #irectly to the postcolonial #evelopment pro7ect ! #ams, as Nehru famously #u00e# them, %ere posite# as ;the temples of mo#ern "n#ia< ! an# the "n#ian state ! the N(As strate+y of resistance has sou+ht to hol# the state accounta0le to constitutional principles, le+al co#es, an# norms an# stan#ar#s relate# to force# #isplacement- " start, ho%ever, %ith a 0rief overvie% of the emer+ence of N)Ms in "n#ia since the 45H0sIndia#s Ne$ S!"ial M!ve%ents f !% t&e '()*s t! t&e '((*s+ A , ief Ove vie$ /he Nehruvian nation$0uil#in+ pro7ect can 0e sai# to have 0een un#erpinne# 0y a truce line %hich ran 0et%een a >#evelopmental state %hich promise# to en# poverty an# 0ac&%ar#ness (*hatter7ee, 200A1 3H on the one han# an# #emo0ilise# an# co$opte# popular classes on the other- 3ollo%in+ the en# of the /elan+ana uprisin+ in 4564, su0altern social movements 0y an# lar+e remaine# 9uiescent an# ce#e# their autonomy to >the stron+ han# of the Nehruvian state (,at?enstein an# Cay, 20061 4A - /he ac9uiescence of social movements %as in turn compoun#e# 0y the fact that su0altern +roups #i# not en7oy unme#iate# access to the state apparatus an# the electoral process*on+ress rule 0y an# lar+e left local po%er structures intact an# poor social ma7orities thus remaine# #epen#ent upon local nota0les in accessin+ the state- /he result %as the failure to convert >the superior num0ers of the poor into a po%erful political resource (3ran&el, 20061 26 =o%ever, the eruption of the Na:alite revolt in Fest (en+al in 456H soun#e# the #eath &nell of su0altern ac9uiescence an# mar&e# the onset of a #eca#e in %hich "n#ia !
A much li&e the rest of the %orl# in the aftermath of the +lo0al uprisin+ of 456G (see Fatts, 2004 ! %itnesse# the emer+ence of ne% social movements that su07ecte# the e:clusionary an# e:ploitative #imensions of state$le# capitalist #evelopment to su0stantial criti9ue (Eanai&, 4550B Omve#t, 4553B ,amat, 2002B Cay an# ,at?enstein, 2006 - 'urin+ the early 45H0s in "n#ia, there occurre# >a su0stantial ra#icali?ation of youth I outsi#e the circles of the tra#itional left (Eanai&, 45501 456 , %hich in turn resulte# in the or+anisation of +roups an# mo0ilisation aroun# issues that ha# 0een ne+lecte# 0y the mainstream left- )i+nificant movements of the 45H0s %ere the *hip&o movement %hich champione# the livelihoo#s of forest$#%ellin+ communities in .ttar&han# (2uha 45G5B (asu 45GH , the ,erala 3ish%or&ers 3orum %hich or+ani?e# poor fisherfol& in ,erala a+ainst the #epre#ations %rou+ht on their livelihoo#s 0y mechani?e# tra%lin+ ((asu, 45GHB )hah, 45GG , an# the )hrami& )an+athana %hich or+ani?e# (hil a#ivasis in Maharashtra aroun# issues of a+ricultural %a+es, lan# control an# forest ri+hts ((asu 45GHB )hah 45GGB .pa#hyaya, 45G0 - Moreover, the 45H0s %itnesse# the mushroomin+ of various social action +roups ! a phenomenon that ,amat (20021 40 refers to as >the ne% +rassroots movement ! %hich came to i#entify the #ominant conception or i#eolo+y of #evelopment as the root cause of persistent poverty an# increasin+ ine9ualities in "n#ian society- /hese +roups particularly flourishe# in the %a&e of the @mer+ence, %hen the Janata +overnment encoura+e# >voluntary %or& an# the formation of voluntary or+ani?ations in the countrysi#e (i0i#-1 42 3rom the mi##le of the 45G0s, "n#ias N)Ms increasin+ly came to 0e involve# in a search for perspectives an# a+en#as that coul# serve as a unifyin+ platform for the #iverse stru++les that ha# emer+e# #urin+ the previous one an# a half #eca#es- 3or some movements ! li&e the ,erala 3ish%or&ers 3orum an# the )het&ari )an+athana ! this revolve# aroun# a##ressin+ +en#er relations an# feminist politicsB for others ! li&e the *hattis+arh Mu&ti Morcha ! it revolve# aroun# #evelopin+ a re#$+reen politics, i-e- a %or&er$peasant alliance aroun# the politics of social 7ustice an# environmental sustaina0ility (Omve#t, 45531 230$36 - As Omve#t points out, the attempts to for+e a common platform reache# a hi+h point %ith the National Cally A+ainst 'estructive 'evelopment in =arsu#, Ma#hya Pra#esh in )eptem0er 45G5, %here 0et%een 26-000 an# 60-000 activists from #ifferent social movements +athere# to #iscuss an a+en#a %hich coul# unite #ifferent stru++les a+ainst #estructive #evelopment pro7ects (i0i#1 265$60 Another crucial process that unfol#e# to%ar#s the en# of the 45G0s %as the increasin+ inte+ration of the politics of the N)Ms in a national fiel# of force characterise# 0y the onset of neoli0eral restructurin+ an# =in#u communalism- An important event in this process %as the ;man#ate of G5< ! i-e- the 45G5 elections that sent a ne% opposition force, the National 3ront coalition to po%er- /his +overnment 0orro%e# &ey themes from the social movements1 #ecentralisation, social 7ustice for 0ac&%ar# castes, an# promises
6 of remunerative prices an# #e0t relief for peasants #ominate# political manifestos (Omve#t 45531 2H3 - /he National 3ront +overnment %as thus a +overnment >electe# on a man#ate of chan+e an# %ith social movement 0ac&in+ 0ut it %as also >a fra+ile coalition +overnment mar&e# 0y factionalism %hich lac&e# the capacity for concerte# political action (i0i#1 2HA - /his 0ecame o0vious %hen Prime Minister E- P- )in+h #eci#e# to implement the recommen#ations of the Man#al *ommission on positive #iscrimination for lo%er caste +roups in 4550B as Omve#t points out, this %as >the one social movement issue that #i# not re9uire a ma7or political reformulation of the process of #evelopment (i0i#1 2G0 - "t #i#, nevertheless, turn out to 0e an e:plosive move1 it tri++ere# political protest 0y =in#u communalist forces across the country an# eventually le# to the #o%nfall of the )in+h +overnment (see 3ran&el 20061 6GG$5 - )imultaneously, the "n#ian economy %as mire# ever$#eeper in a cripplin+ fiscal crisis- /hus, %hen Narasimha Caos *on+ress +overnment assume# po%er in 4554, the floo#+ates of neoli0eral restructurin+ %ere opene# once an# for all (i0i#-1 650 3or some commentators, for e:ample (asu (45GH , Eanai& (4550 an# Omve#t (4553 , the failure of "n#ias N)Ms to #ecisively a#vance their a+en#a in the late 45G0s an# early 4550s puts the stamp of #efeat upon these movements- Det movement stru++les are still vi+orous in "n#iaB in#ee#, as neoli0eral restructurin+ pic&s up momentum, so too #oes popular mo0ilisation- Most recently this has 0een evi#ence# in the upshot of si+nificant movements an# net%or&s of resistance to the intro#uction of )pecial @conomic Jones in "n#ia- )urely, there is #ue reason for scholars to focus their +a?e on the characteristics an# #ynamics of the movements of su0altern social +roups as "n#ia enters the t%enty$first century, 0ut this also raises 9uestions a0out the aptness of the analytical perspectives %e #eploy- "n the remain#er of the article " hope to contri0ute to a #e0ate a0out this throu+h a critical #iscussion of aca#emic perspectives on t%o aspects of N)Ms in "n#ia ! the relationship 0et%een social movements an# the postcolonial #evelopment pro7ect, an# the relationship 0et%een social movements an# the stateA"ade%i" -e s.e"tives !n India#s Ne$ S!"ial M!ve%ents+ S!%e C iti"al Refle"ti!ns ,e/!nd Devel!.%ent0 NSMs and t&e -!st"!l!nial Devel!.%ent - !1e"t 3or some time no% it has 0een fashiona0le amon+ critics from the 9uarters of poststructuralism an# postcolonialism to posit "n#ias N)Ms as the 0earers of an authentic an# insurrectionary otherness that is mo0ili?e# in opposition an# from a position of e:teriority to the mo#ern #evelopment pro7ect- /hese perspectives typically
6 #ra% on @sco0ars (45561 43 ar+ument that ;#evelopment< is a #iscourse %hich relies >e:clusively on one &no%le#+e system, namely, the mo#ern Festern one an# thus #ictates >the mar+inali?ation an# #is9ualification of non$Festern &no%le#+e systems, an# that social movements in the +lo0al )outh #o not articulate >#evelopment alternatives so much as >alternatives to #evelopment, that is, the re7ection of the entire para#i+m alto+ether (i0i#1 246 A- 3or instance, in his analysis of N)Ms in "n#ia, Para7uli (45541 4G2 ar+ues that >KtLhe political si+nificance of these stru++les is that they challen+e the notion of the inte+rationist an# #evelopmentalist "n#ian state- /hey #o this 0y opposin+ a >counter#iscourse of >Ksituate#L &no%le#+e that is locata0le in time an# space, em0o#ie# in stru++le an# participatory in process to the >unmar&e#, #isem0o#ie#, unme#iate#, transcen#ent &no%le#+e of the #evelopmentalist state (i0i#1 4G6, 4G6 @lse%here he ar+ues that >the movements a+ainst 0i+ #ams, collieries, an# forest policies in Jhar&han# an# other parts of "n#ia are I +ainin+ conceptual maturity an# confi#ence to challen+e the %hole e#ifice of mo#ern resource mana+ement an# #evelopment as they >rene% an# reassert su07u+ate# tra#itions of &no%le#+e in a ne% situation (Para7uli, 45561 32$3 - )hiva an# Mies have ar+ue# a0out the %omen activists of the revere# *hip&o movement that >they e:pect nothin+ from ;#evelopment< or from the money economy- /hey %ant to preserve their autonomous control over their su0sistence 0ase, their common property resources1 the lan#, %ater, forests, hills (cite# in Can+an, 20001 3A - Alon+ similar lines, ,ala (20041 4A , ar+ues that throu+h its resistance to 0i+ #ams, the Narma#a (achao An#olan (see 0elo% pits >the live# space of a#ivasi an# peasant communities a+ainst >a space of erasure %hich is >the a0stract space of the state an# of transnational corporations=o%ever, fine$+raine# analyses of the cultural politics of resistance articulate# 0y precisely those movements +lorifie# as lo#estars that %ill +ui#e su0alterns on their %ay 0eyon# #evelopment su++est that these claims are erroneous- 3or instance, Can+an (4556, 2000 an# )inha (200A have 0oth carrie# out su0stantial research on popular mo0ili?ation in the /ehri$2ar%hal =imalayas ! home of the *hip&o movement in the 45H0s ! an# 0oth reach similar conclusions a0out the character of this mo0ili?ationCan+an (20001 222 ar+ues that movements in the re+ion ! an# in "n#ia more +enerally $ are most aptly un#erstoo# as >#eman#in+ their ri+hts to +reater access to a more +enerous i#ea of #evelopment- )inha (200A1 30G ar+ues alon+ similar lines %hen he su++ests that social movements ma&e recourse to the #evelopment pro7ect in articulatin+ >ne% political pro+rams an# creatin+ >ne% 0ases for social an# political life- /hese are
4
/he theoretical un#erpinnin+s, metho#olo+ical strate+ies an# su0stantive ar+uments of the post$#evelopment
perspective have 0een su0stantively critici?e# (see e-+- *or0ri#+e, 455GB ,iely, 4555B Nie#erveen Pieterse, 455G, 2000B Can+an, 4556, 2000B Moore, 455G, 2000 - " fin# myself in a+reement %ith =art (20041 66A %hen she ar+ues that these criticisms have >run their course in terms of hi+hli+htin+ the shortcomin+s of post$ #evelopment theory, an# " %ill not reiterate them here-
H assertions that " fin# to 0e 0orne out 0y the character of the N(As criti9ue of the #ominant #irection an# meanin+ of the postcolonial #evelopment pro7ect in "n#ia- Fhat is so stri&in+ a0out this criti9ue is that there is nothin+ in it to su++est a re7ection of #evelopment an# mo#ernity as such- Cather, the i#ioms that +ave meanin+ to the #evelopmental rationale of mo#ern "n#ia are use# as a point of #eparture for a criti9ue of the actual #irection of #evelopment, %hich has e:ploite#, e:clu#e#, an# mar+inalise# popular classes- 8et me illustrate %ith an o0servation from my fiel#%or&"n con7unction %ith the monsoon )atya+raha 6 of 2000, the N(A sta+e# a cele0ration of "n#ias "n#epen#ence 'ay on Au+ust 46- "n the a#ivasi villa+e of Nim+avhan (Maharashtra , "n#epen#ence 'ay 0e+an %ith the hoistin+ of 0oth the "n#ian fla+ an# the N(As 0anner 0y a veteran 2an#hian an# respecte# free#om fi+hter, )i##hara7 'ha##a- 3ollo%in+ the fla+ hoistin+, a confrontational event erupte#- /%o teachers %ere present at the ceremony- /hese teachers %ere employe# at local state$run schools, 0ut the reality %as that their teachin+ %as as a0sent as the schools they %ere suppose# to 0e runnin+- /he teachers %ere confronte# 0y a+itate# villa+ers an# activists %ho ar+ue# that their vocation amounte# to little more than pic&in+ up their payche9ues/his #ismal state of affairs %as then thro%n into sharp relief %ith the follo%in+ point on the pro+ramme1 the felicitation of youn+ a#ivasis %ho ha# fare# %ell in official schools after first havin+ complete# 0asic schoolin+ in the An#olans Jeevan Shalas ! literally ;schools for life< 0uilt an# run 0y the An#olan %ith a curriculum a#apte# to a#ivasi realities- 3ollo%in+ this, the cele0rations continue# in the near0y villa+e of 'om&he#i %ith the inau+uration of a micro$hy#el pro7ect- A chec&$#am ha# 0een constructe# on a small stream a#7acent to 'om&he#i, %hich, %hen com0ine# %ith a pe#al$po%ere# +enerator, provi#e# electricity to the villa+e for the first time ever- Fhereas the ))P threatene# to #isplace the villa+ers from their lan#s an# pro#uce costly electricity that %oul# only 0e availa0le to affluent an# pre#ominantly ur0an consumers, here %as a pro7ect controlle# an# e:ecute# at villa+e level that actually ha# the potential of #eliverin+ a tan+i0le improvement in peoples lives/hrou+h the cele0ration of "n#epen#ence 'ay, the N(A conveye# a narrative a0out its political pro7ect- "t %as a narrative, %hich reco+nise# the free#om stru++le an# the attainment of "n#epen#ence as fun#amental events an# achievements ! the presence of free#om fi+hters, the unfol#in+ an# hoistin+ of the "n#ian fla+, in#ee#, the very cele0ration of "n#epen#ence 'ay testifie# to this- =o%ever, at the same time it %as a narrative of a national pro7ect profoun#ly out of &ilter- /he ;tryst %ith #estiny<, in this narrative, ha# +one a%ryB the promises of free#om an# #evelopment have 0een hi7ac&e#
5
"n the N(As repertoire of contention, the term )atya+raha is associate# the annual protest events that too&
place #urin+ the monsoon months (June, July, Au+ust, )eptem0er every year from 4554 on%ar#s until 2002/he )atya+raha revolve# aroun# %as a 0ravin+ of the risin+ of the %aters of the Narma#a %hich set in %ith the monsoon rains an# the closin+ of the floo#+ates of the ))P-
G 0y elite interests an# thus 0etraye#, leavin+ lar+e sections of the population 0y the %aysi#e as outcasts- /his 0etrayal %as efficiently illustrate# 0y the contrasts evo&e# in the cele0rations1 the putri# con#ition of state schoolin+ versus the vivacity of the Jeevan ShalasB the #estruction %rou+ht 0y the ))P versus the 0enefits 0rou+ht to local communities 0y the micro$hy#el pro7ect- )imultaneously, the focus on the N(As constructive activities %as e:pressive of a political pro7ect of alternative #evelopment, %hich resonate# far 0eyon# the Narma#a Ealley- /he movement thus pro7ecte# itself as an a+ent on a mission to reinvent the i#eals of free#om an# #evelopment- A su0se9uent N(A press release state#1 >"n#epen#ence 'ay is so often a cele0ration of a countrys victory over oppression, 0ut in Nim+avhan, it ha# an a##itional meanin+ of the peoples continue# resistance a+ainst the in7ustice an# e:ploitation %ithin a nation (N(A, 2000 No%, " #o not, of course, la0our un#er the misconception that a closely orchestrate# protest event such as this an# the #iscourse of resistance that it conveys constitutes a perfect reflection of a uniform ;collective consciousness< that stretches out into every noo& an# cranny of the An#olan- =o%ever, it nonetheless testifies to an# un#erscores the essentially immanent character of movements such as the An#olan in that their oppositional pro7ects (a emer+e from the internal contra#ictions of the postcolonial #evelopment pro7ect an# (0 see& to a##ress these contra#ictions throu+h a criti9ue %hich reclaims an# reinvents its i#ioms of le+itimacy- Fhat is occurrin+, to paraphrase Mar:s seminal passa+e in The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Napoleon, is very much a process in %hich the spirits of the past are con7ure# up an# their names 0orro%e# in an effort to create somethin+ that has never yet e:iste# (Mar:, 45GA1 40 "n#ee#, #ra%in+ on )inha (200A , " %oul# ar+ue that movements such as the N(A are 0est conceive# of as su0altern appropriations of the postcolonial #evelopment pro7ect %hich for+e criti9ues of this pro7ect that are comprehensi0le on its o%n terms 6- "n this respect, then, " ali+n my ar+ument %ith that of *or0ri#+e an# =arriss (20001 235 %hen they ar+ue a0out N)Ms in the conte:t of >the reinvention of "n#ia that in their attempts to reinvent "n#ia, su0altern social +roups >still have re+ar# for the invention of "n#ia that %as propose# in the *onstituent Assem0ly- =o%ever, claimin+ an# appropriatin+ the #iscourses an# institutions of the he+emonic pro7ects of #ominant social +roups in the articulation of oppositional pro7ects %ill inevita0ly 0e an e:perience of 0oth ena0lement an# constraint, an# it is precisely this %hich is at the core of the ne:t set of reflections on the relationship 0et%een ne% social movements an# the state in >the reinvention of "n#ia6
"n#ee#, the #iscourse of resistance articulate# 0y movements such as the N(A can 0e sai# to 0e e:pressive of
the >para#o:ical unity in %hich >#evelopment I an# alternative #evelopment are #ialectically or+ani?e# oppositions %ithin the history of mo#ernity, to 0e seen less as mutually e:clusive 0ut as >oppositions that contain the other I (Fatts, 20001 A6, 60 -
In and2! A3ainst t&e State0 NSMs and t&e Indian State "n their #iscussion of su0altern politics in einventing !ndia, *or0ri#+e an# =arriss (20001
200$2 ta&e their point of #eparture in a num0er of recent criti9ues of the a0ility of the #emocratic process in "n#ia to a#vance the interests of su0altern social +roups- Fhilst reco+ni?in+ that "n#ian #emocracy is marre# 0y shortcomin+s, they nevertheless maintain its continue# relevance for su0altern politics1 >it is mislea#in+ to assume that people are al%ays empo%ere# in opposition to the state, or that they fail to see& po%er from %ithin state structures (i0i#1 20G - *or0ri#+e an# =arriss #emonstrate the continue# relevance of the state an# the #emocratic process for su0altern politics via a multitu#e of e:amples- 3or #alits an# a#ivasis, locate# at >the 0ottom of the social pile in "n#ia (i0i#-1 20G , a#vancement via the #emocratic process has ta&en the form of >empo%erment from %ithout (i0i#-1 240 in the form of constitutional provisions for 7o0 reservations, reservations of e#ucational places an# seats in political assem0lies, an# more +enerally the e:tension of the franchise to these +roups, secular e#ucation an# la%s aime# at the a0olition of caste$0ase# #iscrimination- )uch measures, they ar+ue, have not altere# the lives an# livelihoo#s of these +roups in a ma7or %ay, 0ut they have still ha# a si+nificant impact on >the terms of en+a+ement 0et%een "n#ias sche#ule# an# non$)che#ule# *ommunities 0y 0uttressin+ an a%areness of potential collective stren+th amon+ the )che#ule# communities an# improvin+ their 0ar+ainin+ position vis$M$vis #ominant +roups (i0i#1 240$44 Another process hi+hli+hte# 0y *or0ri#+e an# =arriss is that of the >empo%erment from %ithin that has 0een 0rou+ht a0out throu+h #alit an# a#ivasi movements that have >sou+ht po%er over the state rather than compensation from the state (i0i#1 242 - Most recently, such politics is evi#ent in the rise of the (ahu7an )ama7 Party ! a mainly #alit 0ase# party ! to state po%er in .ttar Pra#esh- *or0ri#+e an# =arriss stress that they #o not e9uate the electoral success of the ()P >%ith an improvement in the livin+ stan#ar#s of the poor (i0i#1 246 in .-P- 0ut the very fact that it happene# nevertheless implies that important chan+es are afoot- More +enerally, this is evi#ent in the >secon# #emocratic upsur+e (i0i#1 224$2B Da#av, 2000 in %hich )che#ule# an# (ac&%ar# caste an# class +roups are participatin+ more actively in electoral politics in a %ay %hich 0ypasses the me#itation of local elites an# %hich thus ma&es them a force to 0e rec&one# %ith for esta0lishe# political parties- /hey also call attention to ho% #emocracy is >an i#eal, %hich is approache# more or less closely accor#in+ to the 0alance of class forces in a society an# the nature of the state system an# ho% >"n#ias states, all of %hich have formally #emocratic political systems, #iffer si+nificantly in terms of the su0stance of their #emocracies ! accor#in+ to the 0alance of class po%er (*or0ri#+e an#
40 =arriss, 20001 222 - /he ar+ument, then, is that a political system characteri?e# 0y sta0le political parties en+a+e# in competition over the votes of su0altern social +roups are more li&ely to further processes of empo%erment of those +roups- "n#ee#, in "n#ia, it is >those states in %hich the lo%er castesNclasses are more stron+ly represente# politically KthatL have 0een the most successful in re#ucin+ poverty (i0i#1 223 ! %ith the left$of$ centre re+imes of ,erala an# Fest (en+al cite# as cases in point (i0i#1 226$H *or0ri#+e an# =arrisss #efence of the continue# relevance of the #emocratic process an# the state in turn has ramifications for their vie%s on the role of social movements in the realm of su0altern politics- )i+nificantly, they ar+ue that >it is mislea#in+ to suppose that citi?ens movements, N2Os an# community or+ani?ations I provi#e an alternative to the state (*or0ri#+e an# =arriss, 20001 203 - Cather, the presence of such movements an# or+anisations positively affect the 0alance of class forces so that #emocratic +overnment %or&s in favour of su0altern social +roups1 >Fe conten# that citi?ens movements are most effective %here they put pressure on the state to ta&e the part of the poor, or to protect the poor from some of the a0uses heape# upon them (i0i#-1 203 - No%, %hat " see& to 9uestion in these perspectives is not the assertion that the "n#ian state an# the #emocratic process constitute an ena0lin+ space for the stru++les of su0altern +roups- *ertainly, the ar+ument that >the failin+s of "n#ian #emocracy I shoul# not 0e ta&en as a si+n of the a0sence of #emocracy, or of the failure of "n#ias #emocracy to offer some forms of protection or a#vancement to the poor (i0i#-1 202 is an apposite one- A failure to ta&e this into account %oul# constitute a failure to reco+ni?e >the po%er of #emocratic political institutions an# their capacity to impose more e+alitarian #istri0utive re+imes on societies a+ainst reluctant capitalist classes (,avira7, 20001 5A ! a capacity %hich in turn flo%s from the relational an# con7unctural character of state po%er as such- )till, relational an# con7unctural #oes not e9ual infinitely mallea0le for all purposes an# all social +roups- /he state is, in essence, an institutional con+ealment of the fun#amental relations that un#erpin a #eterminate social formation, an# its %or&in+s are +eare# to%ar#s the repro#uction of those relations (Jessop, 45G2 - /his entails that there are certain intrinsic limits to the e:tent to %hich the state an# its structures of representation an# intervention can 0e harnesse# for the pursuit of oppositional pro7ects an# #esi+ns that run counter to the lo+ic of systemic repro#uctionB in short, the states structures of intervention an# representation %ill inherently have >une9ual an# asymmetrical effects on the a0ility of #ifferent social +roups to realise their interests throu+h political action (i0i#1 22A - /hese intrinsic limits ar+ua0ly come into vie% in actual en+a+ements 0et%een social movements an# the state, an# so " turn to the Narma#a Ealley once a+ainAs " mentione# a0ove, the tra7ectory of mo0ili?ation an# resistance in the Narma#a Ealley starte# %ith social action +roups %or&in+ on local #evelopment issues in
44 the #am$affecte# a#ivasi communities in 2u7arat, Ma#hya Pra#esh an# Maharashtra in the early an# mi#$45G0s- One of or+anisations %as the tra#e union ,he#ut Ma?#oor *hetna )an+ath (,M*) , %hich %as 0ase# in the su0$#istrict of Alira7pur in %estern Ma#hya Pra#esh- /he ,M*) emer+e# throu+h a process in %hich ur0an e#ucate# activists 7oine# han#s %ith villa+e communities in challen+in+ a con#ition %hich " refer to as everyday tyranny ! that is, a ran+e of violent, coercive, an# e:tortive practices mete# out 0y the local representatives of the state, i-e- the police, revenue officials, an# forest ran+ers (see Nilsen, 2006a1 *hapter G, 20060B see also (avis&ar, 4556 - @very#ay tyranny essentially revolve# aroun# local state officials e:actin+ 0ri0es ! 0oth in cash an# in &in# ! from a#ivasis in or#er to turn a 0lin# eye to their use of state$o%ne# forests for cultivation, tim0er an# fuel collection, an# other relate# livelihoo# activities- 'eman#s for 0ri0es %ere in turn un#erpinne# 0y a very real threat of violenceB as one ,M*) activist e:plaine# to me, if local police officers #iscovere# a villa+er %al&in+ alon+ the roa# carryin+ an a:e or a sic&le, they %oul# often 0rin+ the person to the police outpost %here he %oul# 0e 0eaten up an# then ma#e to pay a 0ri0e in or#er to avoi# criminal char+es@very#ay tyranny, then, %as a local state$society relationship far remove# from the li0eral$#emocratic i#eals of citi?enship enshrine# in the "n#ian constitution- "n#ee#, one coul# say that the local state in Alira7pur %as not encountere# as a set of a+encies an# functionaries that provi#e# services to an# %ere accounta0le to the citi?ens of a political community- On the contrary, a#ivasi >si+htin+s of the state (*or0ri#+e, Filliams, )rivastava an# EOron, 20061 6 %ere centre# on seemin+ly all$po%erful ;tyrants< %ho impose# a cruel re+ime of e:tortion upon their ;su07ects< %ith a heavy han#, an# %ho respon#e# to #efiance %ith violence an# coercion@very#ay tyranny, ho%ever, came to 0e challen+e# %hen ur0an, e#ucate# activists came into contact %ith the a#ivasi communities in the early 45G0s- "n a series of confrontations %ith local state officials, activists an# villa+ers pointe# out the ille+ality of coercion an# e:tortion- Fhereas the initial response %as one of violence ! several of the activists %ere 0eaten up severely ! the mo0ilisation process +athere# pace %hen activists an# villa+ers sta+e# a #harna in protest a+ainst the violent practices of the local representatives of the state outsi#e the su0$#istrict a#ministrative hea#9uarters in Alira7pur to%n- 8ocal an# state me#ia pic&e# up on the protest, an# it 9uic&ly 0ecame ne%s- As a response, the *hief Minister intervene# an# suspen#e# several forest +uar#s %ho %ere responsi0le for the 0eatin+ of one of the activists- A further protest action in the state capital of (hopal resulte# in the Ma#hya Pra#esh 3orest *onservator 0ein+ sent to Alira7pur to #iscuss the pro0lems that villa+ers face# in their encounters %ith local forest ran+ersB in the meetin+ he stresse# that forest ran+ers %ere not entitle# to #eman# 0ri0es, an# that any further malpractice shoul# 0e reporte# #irectly to him- "n the conte:t of %i#esprea# repression %hich rei+ne# in Alira7pur, this of course constitute#
42 a ma7or victory, an# it 0ecame the 0asis for further mo0ili?ation 0y the ,M*), in %hich the creation of an a%areness in the a#ivasi communities that they %ere 0earers of constitutional ri+hts an# as %ell as special entitlements vis$M$vis the "n#ian state %as a central strate+y an# &ey achievement (see also (avis&ar, 45561 456 /he result of the process, in turn, %as a profoun# transformation in the character of su0altern >si+htin+s of the state in Alira7pur1 %here a#ivasis ha# once seen state officials as %ell$ni+h all po%erful fi+ures, they came to see pu0lic servants %hose po%ers %ere le+ally circumscri0e# an# %ho %ere accounta0le to them as citi?ensB %here the villa+ers ha# once seen a state apparatus %hose activities centre# on the forceful e:action of tri0ute, they came to see an institution that %as suppose# to provi#e services an# safe+uar# ri+hts, an institution upon %hich they coul# ma&e ri+hts$0ase# claims an# #eman#s, an# an institution %hich they coul# participate in the runnin+ of- "t %as, then, a process throu+h %hich formerly su07u+ate# communities emer+e# as a+ents %ho coul# an# %oul#, competently an# assertively, >see& to en+a+e %ith the state as citi?ens, or as mem0ers of populations %ith le+ally #efine# or politically inspire# e:pectations (*or0ri#+e et- al-, 20061 43 - /he tra7ectory of the ,M*), then, is an apt e:ample of the %ay in %hich social movements can effectively an# successfully a#vance the empo%erment of su0altern +roups via the institutions an# i#eolo+ies of the state)o far, so +oo# ! 0ut if %e turn to the tra7ectory of the N(As campai+n a+ainst the )ar#ar )arovar Pro7ect, %e encounter a #ifferent scenario- "n 4550, the An#olan put forth the #eman# that the 2overnment of "n#ia shoul# or#er an e:tensive revie% of the ))P, assessin+ its technical feasi0ility, cost$0enefit e9uations, an# its social an# environmental impactsB #urin+ the course of the revie%, construction on the #am shoul# 0e halte#- "f the pro7ect %as foun# to 0e technically unfeasi0le or in violation of social an# environmental re+ulations, the N(A #eman#e#, it shoul# 0e a0an#one# H- /his, ho%ever, faile# to happen- /he tra7ectory of the #eman# for revie% e:hi0its a clear pattern1 at state level, promises to implement a revie% %ere first ma#e an# then rene+e# on #ue to internal #ifferences in the state +overnment, or simply not follo%e# up at allB at the fe#eral level also, promises %ere ma#e an# rene+e# on, 0ut here as a #irect conse9uence of the pressure levelle# 0y the 2overnment of 2u7arat- "n#ee#, even Prime Minister E- P- )in+h, %ho ar+ua0ly presi#e# on a ;social movement man#ate<, shie#
7
/he 0asic rationale for #eman#in+ a revie% seems to have 0een roote# in the &no%le#+e that the movement
ha# pro#uce# ! its rich 0o#y of counter$e:pertise (see Nilsen, 200601 chapter 40 ! a0out the pro7ect- "t %as clear to the An#olan that the %ei+ht of the evi#ence flatly contra#icte# the official claims that 7ustifie# the #am3urthermore, the evi#ence esta0lishe# that the pro7ect violate# a %i#e array of #omestic an# international norms, rules, an# proce#ures relate# to #am 0uil#in+- /his in turn su++este# that a revie% of the pro7ect %oul# in fact lea# to its a0an#onment- As '%ive#i (455H has pointe# out, this is very much a form of >7ury politics %hich presupposes an un#erstan#in+ of the state as a neutral ar0iter %hich can assess an# evaluate 0o#ies of evi#ence a+ainst or in favour of a ;#efen#ant< ! in this case the ))P ! in an in#epen#ent an# un0ri#le# %ay an# pass 7u#+ement on this ;#efen#ant< solely on the 0asis of this evi#ence-
43 a%ay from implementin+ a revie% in the face of the counter$mo0ili?ation sta+e# 0y *himan0hai Patel ! *hief Minister of 2u7arat an# a lea#in+ representative of the #ominant Pati#ar lan#o%nin+ classes in the southern an# central parts of the state- /he process culminate# in one of the N(As most spectacular an# #ramatic protest actions1 the Jan "i#as Sangharsh $atra (March of )tru++le for Peoples 'evelopment in 'ecem0erNJanuary 4550N541 si: thousan# people marche# from (a#%ani to%n in Ma#hya Pra#esh to%ar#s the ))P #am$site in 2u7arat- /he march %as stoppe# at the 0or#er to 2u7arat, an# a protracte# stan#off unfol#e# %here several activists %ent on a 24 #ay hun+er stri&e- /rue enou+h, the central +overnment announce# that a revie% %oul# 0e carrie# out, an# in 4553, follo%in+ further #ramatic actions 0y the N(A, a 3ive Mem0er 2roup (3M2 %as assi+ne# the mission of revie%in+ the pro7ect in 4553, 0ut its efforts %ere effectively un#ermine# 0oth 0y central politicians an# the 2overnment of 2u7arat/he report of the 3M2, %hich %as ma#e pu0lic in 455A an# lent cre#ence to the N(As case, %as lar+ely inconse9uential- /his occurre# even in a conte:t of fra+mentation at the top as, in 2u7arat, *himan0hai Patel ha# passe# a%ay an#, in MP the *on+ress an# 'i+vi7ay )in+h, 0ran#ishin+ a pro$civil society a+en#a an# ar+uin+ for a re#uction of the hei+ht of the ))P, ha# %on the state elections- /hrou+hout this tra7ectory, it is 9uite possi0le to tease out crac&s an# fissures in the state$system, 0ut the si+nificant #ynamic is that of the closin+ of the ran&s %hich occurre# at every 7uncture %here the push of the #ominant proprietary classes an# their representatives came to shoveA similar pattern can 0e foun# in the N(As en+a+ement %ith the )upreme *ourt"n May 455A, the N(A su0mitte# a case of pu0lic interest liti+ation a+ainst the ))P to the )upreme *ourt, claimin+ that the e:ecution of the pro7ect constitute# a violation of peoples 0asic ri+ht to life an# livelihoo#- An important part of the rationale for #oin+ so %as the fact that "n#ias )* ha# o0taine# a reputation for its pro$activist leanin+s G- An# the initial e:perience %ith the N(As case seeme# to confirm this- /he )* impose# a stay on the ))P in 4556, an# %hen senior Mem0ers of Parliament e:presse# their #ismay over the )*s me##lin+ in inter$state affairs #urin+ hearin+s in 455H, the )* staunchly refuse# to lift the stay on the #am- Once a+ain, then, a chasm can 0e i#entifie# in the state$ system- =o%ever, this chasm %as effectively 0rushe# asi#e %ith the )* ver#ict of Octo0er 2000, %hich state# that the ))P shoul# 0e complete# as 9uic&ly as possi0le, an# the clear statement accompanyin+ the ver#ict that the )upreme *ourt %as not to serve as an arena for contestin+ state #evelopment strate+ies- Once a+ain, the ran&s of the state$system ! ironically enou+h %ith a clear reference to the separation of state po%ers ! %ere close#, an# the closure %as in favour of #ominant social +roups8
=o%ever, as .pa#hyay (2000 notes, the pro$activist profile is most clear in relation to cases of a strictly
environmental character- "n cases %here P"8 have 0een file# to challen+e infrastructure pro7ects, the )* has consistently 0een that it cannot an# shoul# not interfere %ith such pro7ectsB the Narma#a case, then, e:emplifies a +eneral tren#-
4A "n these t%o encounters %ith the state %e have t%o very #ifferent outcomes to +rapple %ith- /he case of the ,M*) certainly illustrates the potential for empo%erment %hich resi#es in su0altern appropriations of %hat A0rams (45GG1 G2 calls the >state$i#ea ! i-e- the representation of the state as a coherent 0o#y e:ternal to society %hich neutrally ar0itrates in conflicts 0et%een e9uals- "t also #emonstrates that the >state$ system ! i-e- the >palpa0le ne:us of practice an# institutional structure centre# in +overnment (i0i#1 G2 ! is not a ti+htly suture# leviathan, an# that it may %ell 0e >ma#e to #o the 0i##in+ of "n#ias lo%er or#ers (*or0ri#+e an# =arriss, 20001 235 - "n the case of the An#olans stru++le for revie% of the ))P an# its turn to the )*, ho%ever, the state$system appears more as ;a committee for mana+in+ the common affairs of the 0our+eoisie<, an# the state$i#ea as an i#eolo+ical veil %hich >contrives to #eny the e:istence of connections %hich %oul# if reco+nise# 0e incompati0le %ith the claime# autonomy an# inte+ration of the state (A0rams, 45GG1 HH /he e:planation for these #ifferential outcomes must 0e sou+ht, " 0elieve, in the #ifferential character of the oppositional pro7ects pursue# 0y the ,M*) an# the N(A- /he ,M*) offensive a+ainst the every#ay tyranny of the local state ! si+nificant thou+h it %as for the communities involve# ! %as centre# on a claim to %hich the hi+her echelons of the state$system coul# conce#e %ithout un#erminin+ its o%n authority an# %ithout +oin+ a+ainst the interests of e:tra$local proprietary elites- "n#ee#, ce#in+ to the ,M*) #eman#s can 0e seen as an e:ercise in 0olsterin+ the state$i#ea as such- /he N(As campai+n a+ainst #am$0uil#in+, ho%ever, %as pitte# #irectly a+ainst the veste# interests of the proprietary elites of )outh an# *entral 2u7arat, %hose capacity to influence the %or&in+s of the state$system outshone that of the a#ivasis an# petty$commo#ity pro#ucers mo0ili?e# 0y the N(A in Ma#hya Pra#esh an# Maharashtra- /his can of course 0e rea# as testimony to *or0ri#+e an# =arrisss ar+ument that the e:tent to %hich su0altern +roups can ma&e claims on the state is su07ect to con7unctural fluctuations relate# to re+ional an# state$specific 0alances of class po%er- =o%ever, " %oul# ar+ue that in the case of the N(As anti$#am campai+n it is also possi0le to #etect constraints to su0altern claims$ma&in+ on the state %hich are of a more structural character- /his is so 0ecause the campai+n %as not only #irecte# a+ainst one particular #am$pro7ect- "t %as #eeply em0e##e# in a +eneric opposition to #am$0uil#in+ as a #evelopment strate+y, as %ell as a criti9ue of the %i#er mo#el of #evelopment of %hich this strate+y %as a part an# concerte# attempts to constitute a nation$%i#e alliance of social movements aroun# this criti9ue ! most clearly evi#ent in the National Alliance of Peoples Movements- /hus, the N(A levelle# a challen+e a+ainst one of the chief mo#alities throu+h %hich the "n#ian state has secure# the constitution an# repro#uction of capital accumulation in postcolonial "n#ia, namely, as *hatter7ee (45G6, 4553 has ar+ue#, throu+h a >passive revolution in %hich the &ey #evelopment strate+ies of the state have
46 in effect concentrate# pro#uctive resources in the han#s of the countrys #ominant proprietary classes- "n short, the oppositional pro7ect that crystalli?e# in the practice of the N(A came %ith ramifications %hich #efie# >the permanence of e:istin+ structures an# relations (,amat, 20021 46G an# the fun#amental centrality of state po%er in securin+ the repro#uction of those structures an# relations/hus, %hat " ar+ue for is that %hilst, on the one han#, it is in#ee# calle# for to ac&no%le#+e >the possi0ilities for empo%erment that mi+ht e:ist %ithin "n#ias polity (*or0ri#+e an# =arriss, 20001 23G , it is, on the other han#, e9ually imperative to +ive serious thou+ht to the limits that mi+ht e:ist to those possi0ilities an# %hat this entails in practical an# strate+ic terms for ne% social movements in contemporary "n#ia- Fhereas a full en+a+ement %ith these 9uestions transcen#s the relatively limite# parameters of this article, my imme#iate su++estion %oul# 0e to steer a course 0et%een the ultimately state$centric vie% of *or0ri#+e an# =arriss an# the anti$statism of post$#evelopment theory in terms of the strate+ic role of state po%er in social movement practice/he 0asic ar+ument a+ainst anti$statism %oul# then 0e this1 an a%areness of the limits to the chan+es that can 0e achieve# via the state$system an# the state$i#ea #oes not in any %ay translate into a principle# re7ection of any en+a+ement %ith the state- "f social movements are seen as #evelopin+ relationally an# historically vis$M$vis the he+emonic pro7ects of social movements from a0ove, an# the state$system an# the state$i#ea have fi+ure# so centrally in those he+emonic pro7ects as is the case in postcolonial "n#ia, then the tra7ectory of those movements %ill naturally ten# to involve some &in# of recourse to state$centre# practices, institutions an# i#eational representations- 2iven the con7unctural nature of state po%er, such recourse mi+ht also 0ear fruits- /his, ho%ever, #oes not entail positin+ interaction an# ne+otiation %ith the state as >the 0e$all an# en#$all of movement activity (2eo+he+an an# *o:, 20041 H Cather, it entails the a#vocacy of a position %hich e:plicitly see&s to ta&e account of 0oth the potential an# limits of political action %ithin the state$system- /his approach %oul# assert that social movements #o %isely in thin&in+ carefully a0out %hich 0ets to he#+e on the normal political process %ithin an institutionalise# social or#er an# %hich to place else%here- "n other %or#s, it %oul# a#vocate an instrumental rather than a committed en+a+ement5 %ith the state$system an# the state$i#ea ! i-e- an approach to interaction %ith the state 0ase# on limite# e:pectations of %hat can 0e +aine# an# a clear perception of %hat cannot 0e +aine# an# %hat is ris&e# in pursuin+ this avenue- "t also entails an a%areness that a challen+e to the principles of po%er from a0ove on %hich the capitalist state rests ! if it is to 0e pursue# at all ! is a 0et 0est he#+e# on the construction of a social movement pro7ect %hich see&s to #evelop the collective s&ille#
46 activity of su0altern +roups to the point %here it can successfully challen+e e:tant po%er structures an# their entrenche# institutional manifestationsC!n"ludin3 Re%a 4s "n this paper " have sou+ht to contri0ute to a #e0ate on aca#emic representations an# analyses of the character, role an# strate+ies of ne% social movements in the %i#er conte:t of thorou+h+oin+ structural chan+e in "n#ias political economy" starte# %ith a critical interro+ation of >post$#evelopment representations of the N)Ms as 0earers of otherness an# har0in+ers of an era 0eyon# #evelopment an# mo#ernity- /hrou+h a #iscussion of the character of the Narma#a (achao An#olans criti9ue of "n#ias postcolonial #evelopment pro7ect " asserte# that social movements shoul# 0e vie%e# as fun#amentally immanent forces in that they emanate from the internal contra#ictions of "n#ias postcolonial #evelopment pro7ect an# at the same time ten# to articulate their criti9ue of the #irection an# meanin+ of this pro7ect via its central i#ioms of le+itimacy- " then move# on to a #iscussion of the relationship 0et%een "n#ias N)Ms an# the state- "n contrast to *or0ri#+e an# =arrisss a#vocacy of movement strate+ies that pursue empo%erment an# process claims an# #eman#s via the state, " ar+ue# for a more #ifferentiate# vie% of the ena0lements an# constraints inherent to state po%er- " pursue# this ar+ument throu+h an analysis of the tra7ectory of the N(As stru++le a+ainst #ispossession- As much as the social action +roups that prece#e# the mo0ili?ation aroun# #am 0uil#in+ re+istere# consi#era0le successes in their use of the state an# its a+encies a+ainst local forms of oppression, the attempts 0y the N(A to push the state to act as a neutral ar0iter in the conflict have consistently faile# ! from the initial #eman#s for a state$le# revie% to the more recent attempts to secure a favoura0le 7u#+ement a+ainst the pro7ect from the )upreme *ourt- /his testifies to the systemic character an# limits of the An#olans campai+n a+ainst #am$0uil#in+1 it thrusts a+ainst a 0asal structure of proprietary po%er, an# this structure in turn constitutes the limit to the possi0ility for movements of actin+ throu+h the state an# its a+encies- 3or activists, this points in the #irection of optin+ for an instrumental rather than a committe# use of the state in the pursuit of emancipatory +oals/his is of course merely an initial contri0ution to a #iscussion, 0ut it is imperative that this #iscussion ta&es place- " fin# it har# to a+ree %ith *or0ri#+e, Filliams, )rivastava an# Eeron %hen they posit such stru++les as that %hich have unfol#e# in the Narma#a Ealley as someho% less important than the every#ay stru++les in %hich >men an# %omen see& to en+a+e %ith the state as citi?ens, or as mem0ers of populations %ith le+ally #efine# ri+hts or politically inspire# e:pectations- Fith the intensification of neoli0eral restructurin+ in "n#ia, conflicts over resource control are more than li&ely to
4H proliferate- "n#ee#, this is no%here more clearly evi#ence# than in the intro#uction of )pecial @conomic Jones, %hich %ill entail the sei?ure of at least half a million hectares of lan# in a process %hich >is nothin+ short of a cru#e form of primitive accumulation of capital (*han#rase&har, 2006 - Moreover, #ispossession seems to 0e increasin+ly un#erpinne# 0y a rea#iness to resort to violent coercion- Cecent e:amples inclu#e the shootin+ of 42 Mun#a a#ivasis %ho %ere protestin+ their #isplacement #ue to the construction of a ma7or steel plant at ,alin+a Na+ar in Orissa in January 2006, the &illin+ of three people in Manipur on 'ecem0er 4A 2006 as security forces opene# fire on protestors raisin+ #eman#s for resettlement an# reha0ilitation for #am oustees, an#, crucially, the &illin+ of at least 4A people in March 200H in Nan#i+ram, Fest (en+al ! a state hel# up 0y *or0ri#+e an# =arriss as an e:emplar of ho% left political parties actin+ throu+h the state can a#vance popular empo%erment ! in con7unction %ith popular protests a+ainst the ac9uisition of lan# for the esta0lishment of a )pecial @conomic Jone 0y the "n#onesian )alim 2roup ((anner7ee, 200H - "n this conte:t, the ;responsi0le< scholarship that *or0ri#+e et- al- (20061 *hapter 5 call for cannot %ith le+itimate reason an# +oo# conscience restrict the scope of its optic an# the #epth of its am0ition to an en#less multiplication of ethno+raphic an# historical #ecipherin+s of the cultural politics of molecular re%or&in+s of the postcolonial #evelopment pro7ect an# encoura+ements of a sustaine# 0elief in actin+ throu+h the state- "t must, at the very least, consi#er the possi0ility that social movements are immanent forces %ith the potential to transcen# an# transform the social formation in %hich they have emer+e# throu+h a #efinite su0version of the po%er relations that th%arte# the capacity of the #esi+ns for mo#ern "n#ia to #eliver on the promises of pro+ress for its social ma7oritiesREFERENCES A0rams, P-, 45GG, >Notes on the 'ifficulty of )tu#yin+ the )tate, Journal of %istorical Sociology, Eol- 4, No- 4 (anner7ee, )-, 200H, >Moral (etrayal of a 8eftist 'ream, Economic and &olitical 'ee#ly, April H (ar&er an# /yl#esley (e#s- , 2006, Alternative (utures and &opular &rotest ) *onference &apers, Manchester Metropolitan .niversity (asu, A-, 45GH, >2rassroots Movements an# the )tate1 Ceflections on Ca#ical *han+e in "n#ia, Theory and Society, Eol- 46, No- 6
4G (avis&ar, A-, 4556, !n the Belly of the "alley, 'elhi, O:for# .niversity Press*han#rase&har, *- P-, 2006, >Primitive Accumulation, 3rontline, Eol- 23, No- 20 *hatter7ee, P-, 45G6, Nationalist Thought and the *olonial 'orld, Ne% 'elhi, O:for# .niversity Press *hatter7ee, P-, 4553, The Nation and its (ragments, Princeton, Princeton .niversity Press *hatter7ee, P-, 200A, &olitics of the ,overned+ the 'orld, Ne% Dor&, *olum0ia .niversity Press *or0ri#+e, ), an# =arris, J-, 2000, einventing !ndia+ Liberali.ation, %indu Nationalism eflections on &opular &olitics in -ost of iver+ Tribal *onflicts over 'ater in the Narmada
and &opular Democracy, *am0ri#+e, Polity Press*or0ri#+e, )-, 4556, >3e#eralism, =in#u Nationalism an# Mytholo+ies of 2overnance in Mo#ern "n#ia, pp- 404$42H in )mith, 2-, e#-
*or0ri#+e, )-, 455G, >;(eneath the Pavement Only )oil<1 /he Poverty of Post$ 'evelopment, Journal of Development Studies, Eol- 3A, No- 6
*or0ri#+e, )-, 2000, >*ompetin+ "ne9ualities1 /he )che#ule# /ri0es an# the Ceservations )ystem in "n#ias Jhar&han#, The Journal of Asian Studies Eol- 65, No- 4 *or0ri#+e, )-, Filliams, 2-, )rivastava, M-, an# EOron, C-, 2006, Seeing the State+ ,overnance and ,overnmentality in !ndia, *am0ri#+e, *am0ri#+e .niversity Press *rush, J- (e#- , 45561 &o/er of Development, Ne% Dor&1 Coutle#+e
'%ive#i, C-, 455H, >Peoples Movements in @nvironmental Politics1 A *ritical Analysis of the Narma#a (achao An#olan in "n#ia, For&in+ Paper )eries No- 2A2, "nstitute of )ocial )tu#ies-
45 @sco0ar, A-, 4556, Encountering Development+ The -a#ing and 0nma#ing of the Third 'orld, Princeton, Princeton .niversity Press3ran&el, 3- et- al- (e#s- , 2000, Transforming !ndia+ Social and &olitical Dynamics of Democracy, O:for#, O:for# .niversity Press 3ran&el, 3-, 2006, !ndia1s &olitical Economy+ The ,radual 'elhi, O:for# .niversity Press 3uller, *- J- an# =arriss, J-, 2004, >3or an Anthropolo+y of the Mo#ern "n#ian )tate, pp4$30 in 3uller, *-J- an# (OneP, E-, e#s3uller, *-J- an# (OneP, E- (e#s- , 2004, The Everyday State and Society in -odern !ndia , 8on#on, =urst an# *ompany2uha, C-, 45G5, The 0n9uiet 'oods+ Ecological *hange and &easant %imalaya, (er&eley, .niversity of *alifornia Press =art, 2- ,2004, >'evelopment *riti9ues in the 4550s1 *uls de Sac an# Promisin+ Paths, &rogress in %uman ,eography, Eol- 26, No AJaffrelot, *-, 2000, >/he Cise of the Other (ac&%ar# *lasses in the =in#i (elt, Journal of Asian Studies, Eol- 65, No- 4 Jaffrelot, *-, 2003, !ndia1s Silent 8on#on, =urst an# *ompany Jessop, (-, 45G2, The *apitalist State+ -ar:ist Theories and -ethods , O:for#, Martin Co0ertson ,ala, P-, 2004, >"n the )paces of @rasure1 2lo0alisation, Cesistance an# Narma#a Civer, Economic and &olitical 'ee#ly, June 2, 2004,amat, )-, 2002, Development %egemony+ N,;s and the State in !ndia, Ne% 'elhi, O:for# .niversity Press,at?enstein, M- an# Cay, C-, 2006, >An# in the (e+innin+ there %as the Nehruvian )tate in Ca&a Cay an# Mary ,at?enstein, e#sevolution+ The ise of the Lo/er *astes in North !ndia , esistance in the evolution 234567884, Ne%
20
,avira7, )- (2000 1 >'emocracy an# )ocial "ne9uality, pp- GG$445 in 3ran&el, 3- et- al-, e#s,iely, C-, 4555, >/he 8ast Cefu+e of the No0le )ava+e1 A *ritical Assessment of Post$ 'evelopment /heory, The European Journal of Development esearch, Eol- 44, No- 4
,ohli, A- (e#- , 45GG, !ndia1s Democracy, Ne% Jersey, Princeton .niversity Press Mar:, ,-, 45GA, The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Napoleon, 8on#on, 8a%rence an# Fishart Moore, '- )-, 455G, >)u0altern )tru++les an# the Politics of Place1 Cemappin+ Cesistance in Jim0a0%es @astern =i+hlan#s, *ultural Anthropology, Eol- 43, No- 3Moore, '- )-, 2000, >/he *ruci0le of *ultural Politics1 Ce%or&in+ ;'evelopment< in Jim0a0%es @astern =i+hlan#s, American Ethnologist, Eol- 26, No 3NAPM, 2003, Ayodhya Declaration ) National &eople1s Agenda, #ocument o0taine# from NAPM activists, also availa0le at %%%-ai#in#ia-or+N#eshN#eclaration-html N(A, 2000, >)eptem0er 4H, *onclusion of Narma#a )atya+raha, Jalsin#hi an# 'om&he#i, press note receive# from Narma#a (achao An#olan Nilsen, A- 2-, 2006a, The "alley and the Nation ) The Dispossession and 3aculty of )ocial )ciences, .niversity of (er+en Nilsen, A- 2-, 20060, >;" Celease Dou 3ear< ! (uil#in+ )u0altern Po%er in the *onte:t of @very#ay /yrannyB in (ar&er an# /yl#esley, e#sNilsen, A- 2-, forthcomin+, The iver and the age+ Dispossession and esistance in the iver and the age+ A Study of
Narmada "alley, !ndia, forthcomin+ %ith .niversity of 2eor+ia Press Omve#t, 2-, 4553, einventing evolution+ Ne/ Social -ovements and the Socialist
24 Para7uli, P-, 4554, >Po%er an# ,no%le#+e in 'evelopment 'iscourse1 Ne% )ocial Movements an# the )tate in "n#ia, !nternational Social Science Journal, No- 42HPara7uli, P-, 4556, >@colo+ical @thnicity in the Ma&in+1 'evelopmentalist =e+emonies an# @mer+ent "#entities in "n#ia, !dentities, Eol- 3, No- 4$2 Peet, C- an# F- Fatts (e#s- , 2000, Liberation Ecologies+ Environment, Development and Social -ovements, 8on#on1 Coutle#+ePieterse, JN-, 455G, >My Para#i+m or DoursQ Alternative 'evelopment, Post$
'evelopment, Cefle:ive 'evelopment, Development and *hange, Eol- 25, No- 2 Pieterse, J- N-, 2000, >After Post$'evelopment, Third 'orld <uarterly, Eol- 24, No- 2 Can+an, =-, 4556, >3rom *hip&o to .ttaranchal1 'evelopment, @nvironment an# )ocial Protest in the 2arh%al =imalayas, "n#ia, pp- 206$226 in Peet, C- an# F- Fatts, e#sCan+an, =-, 2000, ;f -yths and -ovements+ Ne% 'elhi, O:for# .niversity Press Cao, M- )- A- (e#- , 2000, Social -ovements in !ndia, 'elhi, Manohar Cay, C- an# ,at?enstein, M- (e#s- , Social -ovements in !ndia+ &overty, &o/er, and &olitics, M', Co%an an# 8ittlefiel# )hah, 2- (e#- , 2002, Social -ovements and the State, Ne% 'elhi, )a+e Pu0lications )hah, 2-, 45GG, >2rass$Coots Mo0ili?ation in "n#ian Politics, pp- 262$30A in ,ohli, A-, e#)hah, 2-, 4550, Social -ovements in !ndia+ A Pu0lications evie/ of the Literature , Ne% 'elhi, )a+e e/riting *hip#o into %imalayan %istory ,
)inha, )-, 200A, >'evelopment *ounter$Narratives1 /a&in+ )ocial Movements )eriously, pp- 2G6$342 in )ivarama&rishnan, ,- an# A+ra%al, A-, e#s-
22
.pa#hyay, E-, 2000, >*han+in+ Ju#icial Po%er1 *ourts on "nfrastructure Pro7ects an# @nvironment, Economic and &olitical 'ee#ly, Octo0er 2G .pa#hyaya, A-, 45G0, >*lass )tru++le in Cural Maharashtra1 /o%ar#s a Ne% Perspective, Journal of &easant Studies, No- H Eanai&, A-, 4550, The &ainful Transition+ Bourgeois Democracy in !ndia, 8on#on, EersoEarshney, A-, 2000, >"s "n#ia (ecomin+ More 'emocraticQ, Journal of Asian Studies, vol65, No 4 Fatts, M-, 4556, >A Ne% 'eal in @motions1 /heory an# Practice an# the *risis of 'evelopment, pp- AA$62 in J- *rush, e#Fatts, M-, 2000, >456G an# all that I, &rogress in %uman ,eography, Eol- 26, No- 2 Da#av, D-, 2000, >.n#erstan#in+ the )econ# 'emocratic .psur+e1 /ren#s of (ahu7an Participation in @lectoral Politics in the 4550s, pp- 420$4A6 in 3ran&el, 3- et- al-, e#s-