Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mifid: Every Cloud Has A Silver Lining: Nvestor Ervices
Mifid: Every Cloud Has A Silver Lining: Nvestor Ervices
COM
£ 25 - UK, ROW
INVESTOR $ 43 - America
EUR35 - Europe, Mid-East, Africa
S ERVICES
JOURNAL
investor
Designer: Katerina Dimitrova (Katerina@ISJforum.com)
TOTAL NET CIRCULATION 11,188
Analysis for the Audit Issue Vol 3, No 14 distributed June 2006. Publisher: Justin Lawson (Justin.Lawson@ISJforum.com) intelligence partners
Source: AUDIT BUREAU OF CIRCULATIONS, www.abc.org.uk Chairman: Mark Latham (Mark.Latham@ISJforum.com)
C A C E I S i s r a t e d A A - b y S & P.
w w w . c a c e i s . c o m
will exceed US$3 trillion, with more than The deadline for MiFID
44% of transactional volume conducted Transposition at Level 3 is 31st
electronically. This is an increase from
If you are affected by, US$1.77 trillion in 2004. As the FX mar- January 2007. What can firms
or have an opinion on, ket grows and becomes more complex (as expect to see during the count-
any aspect of investor led by the hedge funds), how you trade down to MiFID implementation
services write to us... has never been more important. this year?
Alan.Duerden@ISJforum.com Kieran Fitzpatrick, Director, The deadline for transposing the MiFID
Strategic Solutions, Cognotec. measures (both Directive and Regulation)
into domestic law into each of the 31
The Impact of FX Trading by European states (27 EU member states
Hedge Funds Incoherent Commercial plus Gibraltar, Norway, Iceland and
Relationships -The Cost Lichtenstein) likely to be impacted will be,
The trading of FX as an asset class has con-
tinued to gain acceptance in recent years. IT systems, software and services occupy a somewhat appropriately, the 31st January
In fact, ClientKnowledge reported in 2006 huge proportion of budgets throughout the 2007. Many of the optimists foresaw con-
that around 25% of all daily FX volumes financial services sector. Each relationship siderable benefits for the early birds, and
are alpha generating trades, and with with an IT provider must therefore be care- they will gain from vital long-term com-
hedge funds accounting for the greatest fully structured, negotiated and managed to petitive advantage in servicing the
proportion of FX trades on the buy side, ensure this spend delivers concrete, meas- European Capital Markets. However, the
they are clearly leading the pack with their urable business results. doomsayers have already passed their
system requirements. judgement that a significant number of
In comparison to traditional traders, EU Member States will fail to meet the
hedge funds are unique in their demands. We need to structure transposition deadline, although it’s
remains to be seen whether Member States
Due to their experience and expectations commercial relationships representing significant liquidity flows will
from other asset classes (equity, energy
etc.) their trading strategies are inevitably with vendors and be among the laggards.
complex. They use algorithms, high levels service providers that Having worked hard to prepare for MiFID,
of automation, API connectivity, exe- the prospect of differential implementation
cutable streaming models etc; and with FX
reward success. across the Member States is a scenario no-one
volumes always increasing, banks need to wishes to see happen. Should a significant
keep up. All too often we see projects that overrun, number of member countries fail to meet the
They first need to provide the are over budget or fail to produce the bene- transposition deadline, this would raise
appropriate services to not only attract fits that were promised by vendors - or thorny issues for regulators and for firms who
sometimes, all three. have invested the time and trouble to be ready
Banks must increase Is this because IT vendors are unscrupu- on day one. With MiFID coming into EU law,
its predecessor – the Investment Services
technology spending lous and/or incompetent? Not
generally. In our experience, one of the Directive – will be repealed.
to help them main causes of project failure is
win the latency war. that the commercial relationship between Lack of harmonisation
client and vendor was not results in an uneven
new hedge fund business, but to also structured for success. Just as we do with
retain their existing hedge fund clients. As our employees, we need to
regulatory environment.
algorithmic trading becomes more com- structure commercial relationships with
monplace, banks must increase their level vendors and service providers that Lack of harmonisation as regards imple-
of technology spend to help them win the reward success. But as soon as we start mentation will result in an uneven regulatory
latency war. And secondly, they must talking about risk-reward, it environment, and one that is hardly con-
improve their own risk capabilities to becomes clear that each party is much ducive to the interests of governments or the
counter the increasing sophistication of happier to take on the latter than the end investors.
their clients and the competition. They former. With commercially pragmatic It is clear that firms are far from consistent in
can ill-afford to be pushed out of the mar- and IT-literate contract structuring and their preparations for MiFID. 14% of entities
ket by falling behind. negotiation it is possible to create a con- surveyed by Accenture last year indicated that
There really is only one way to achieve tractual framework for successful they were in the “highly-strategic or design”
these goals; through investment in their project delivery. Without it, you are sim- phase. These will be the entities who are likely
trading platform. Banks must implement ply producing a document that, at to shape the market infrastructure in Europe
truly scalable and highly available pricing best, will remain in the drawer and, at over next 5 years, yet at the time of the survey,
engines with genuine high performance worst, will become a millstone next to no firms were coding. 48% of entities
executable streaming capability, combined around the neck of your project. were already in the planning phase, yet 36% of
with a clear connectivity strategy. firms overall would see their efforts as tactical
According to research from TowerGroup, Tiffany Kemp, Managing Director, “tick the box” compliance.
by 2007, global FX daily average volumes Devant Limited. (Letters continue on page 83)
• EQUITIES
• FIXED INCOME
IT’S THE BEGINNING OF AN ERA...
• CORPORATE ACTIONS
• PRICING
• CLIENT/COUNTERPARTY
• INDICES
Enhance your efficiency and reduce your costs with the global financial
industry expertise of our knowledgeable team. The exciting new era of
outsourced reference data services is beginning – jump into the future
with Capco Reference Data Services.
NEWS - GLOBAL SNAPSHOTS
Your expectations are high. We meet them. BHF-BANK – your sub-custodian for
German securities.
access to SWIFT’s SWIFTNet ship with MFT as it expands ing a standardized reference
messaging system, with two the use of GFAS to support data repository for all financial
clients, Microsoft and GE. The more of its international fund instruments. The solution
testing demonstrated that ranges and distribution chan- centralizes securities master
both messages (FIN) and nels. data from multiple data
files (FileAct) were able to providers, cleans it, then
be exchanged between cor- Boca Raton - ClariFI, a publishes it to OpHedge’s
porates and banks. The new provider of software and internal securities and exotics
Standardised Corporate services focused on trading systems. OpHedge can
Environment (SCORE) serv- quantitative portfolio develop pricing solutions
ice has been developed to management and research around vendor data to suit
make it easier and more attrac- announced that the Axioma market hierarchies or tap into
tive for corporates to access Robust Risk Model is now inte- a ‘securities of interest’ list
SWIFT and enjoy secure and grated into ClariFI’s hosted on the real-time
reliable communications with ModelStation. The Axioma GoldenSource platform.
all of their banking partners. Robust Risk Model is provided OpHedge now has the
as an option for clients to flexibility to cost-effectively
"While RiskMetrics has Munich - Siemens Business select in ModelStation’s tailor data services for its
increasingly connected com- Services will support large Strategy Simulation, Portfolio clients.
munities of investors around portions of Deutsche Bank’s Optimization, and Risk and
financial risk, ISS' 20-year information technology for a Performance Attribution mod- New York - A new global
leadership in helping clients period of five years, managing ules. Axioma, Inc., a global partnership between SimCorp,
manage corporate governance the IT infrastructure in all provider of risk analysis and provider of asset management
and fiduciary risk represents a German branches, corporate portfolio rebalancing tools to software, and Spotfire,
perfect fit for RiskMetrics departments and additional the financial community. provider of enterprise analytics
Group as we grow." CEO locations in Italy and Spain. Integrating the Axioma Robust software – will bring enhanced
Ethan Berman will continue to The contract enables Deutsche Risk Model into ModelStation visual and data-analysis
lead RiskMetrics Group, while Bank to improve its IT while at eliminates the need to capabilities to SimCorp's
John M. Connolly will remain the same time reducing its manually move data between customers. SimCorp will
CEO of ISS and will assume costs, and is the latest addition the two solutions, improving integrate Spotfire DXPTM
the additional responsibility of to the long list of major IT clients’ portfolio construction enterprise analytics software
President of RiskMetrics contracts awarded to Siemens efficiencies and enabling them into its SimCorp Dimension
Group. Business Services by Deutsche to get alpha generating system, enabling asset
Bank in recent years. Siemens strategies into production managers to obtain and
TECHNOLOGY Business Services will support sooner. The Robust Risk visualize complex data more
New York - Orc Software, the 19,000 so-called thin clients for Model complements Axioma easily. The enhanced capability
global provider of technology the Deutsche Bank staff in Portfolio, the firm’s risk will be particularly helpful to
for advanced trading, market Germany, Italy and Spain. With analysis and portfolio rebal- firms using SimCorp
making and brokerage, has set a thin-client infrastructure, ancing software, which is also Dimension"s 'portfolio
new benchmarks for scalable, employees don’t have their integrated into ModelStation. manager’ screens, which are
multi-strategy trading based own PC, working instead on the key displays of investment
on Orc’s Liquidator solution keyboards and monitors that New York - OpHedge holding data in the system.
running on the Solaris 10 are linked to central servers on Investment Services, LLC, a SimCorp Dimension users will
Operating System (OS) as well which the programs are hedge fund operations/admin- now be able to present data
as Sun’s Sun Fire T2000 executed. istration service provider, has from these displays with
CoolThreads Server. gone live with the sophisticated color-enhanced
Performance testing results Luxembourg - Mutual Fund GoldenSource Securities & graphics, enabling them to
measured throughput at more Technologies, the specialist Products solution. This global detect significant trends,
than 5000 orders per second. transfer agency software, security master application hidden patterns, anomalies
Performance testing was car- services and consulting lays the foundation for the and biases hidden in the data
ried out on Sun’s SWaP metric company has agreed a new five company’s enterprise data more easily and to act upon
system. The formula Sun year contract with Schroders management (EDM) infra- them more quickly.
developed, SWaP = perform- Investment Management structure which is designed to
ance / (space x power), is a (Luxembourg) S.A to extend support the company’s growth
simple calculation that allows its use of MFT's GFAS Transfer and accommodate its strategic
any customer to run the metric Agency platform to support its data management services to
and use the results to compare global operations. The contract existing and future clients. The
systems from different vendors. confirms GFAS as Schroders' GoldenSource solution
core transfer agency system, enables OpHedge to stream-
London - JPMorgan Treasury sitting at the heart of their line its reporting and data
Services has announced that it Luxembourg and offshore fund management process by creat-
has successfully completed services operations. Schroders ing, maintaining and publish-
testing of SWIFT’s SCORE was keen to extend its existing
service, which gives corporates six year outsourcing partner- FREE NEWS DAILY AT WWW.ISJFORUM.COM
@01 2SfWO 7\dSab]` AS`dWQSa :W[WbSR Wa O V]ZRW\U Q][^O\g bVOb ^`]dWRSa ab`ObSUWQ RW`SQbW]\ O\R [O\OUS[S\b ]dS`aWUVb b] Wba OT¿ZWObSa W\QZcRW\U @01 2SfWO 7\dSab]` AS`dWQSa B`cab
eVWQV]^S`ObSaW\bVSC9bV`]cUVOP`O\QVOcbV]`WaSRO\R`SUcZObSRPgbVS4W\O\QWOZAS`dWQSa/cbV]`Wbg/ZZO`SZWQS\aSRcaS`a]TbVS@01b`ORS[O`YO`SUWabS`SRb`ORS[O`Y
]T@]gOZ0O\Y]T1O\OROO\R2SfWOb`ORS[O`YO\RQ]\RcQbbVSW`UZ]POZQcab]RgO\RW\dSab[S\bOR[W\Wab`ObW]\PcaW\Saac\RS`bVS@012SfWO7\dSab]`AS`dWQSaP`O\R\O[S
NEWS - ANALYSIS
part in the survey believed that October ‘supra’ alternative asset managers seeking
2007 was an unrealistic deadline. A year
later, however, a mere 16% of the firms sur-
to develop business with institutional
investors in the other, that generally SLIGHT
veyed by SunGard admitted to being
behind schedule, which perhaps points out
that the earlier misgivings could have been
prevented by a more efficient flow of
believe increased regulation will boost
inflows by providing the transparency and
integrity demanded by investors.
While some European countries, such as
RETURN
information from the FSA. Germany, are pushing for more The ghost of Amaranth
What should have been a period of disclosure in hedge funds, there is a more haunts hedge America, has
exciting change is thus turning into the ‘hands-off ’ approach being taken by US
biggest headache the investment services and UK regulators who are promoting the paradise been lost?
industry has experienced for some time. idea that sophisticated and wealthy
Lack of transparency has led to conser- investors know the risks associated with 2006 saw a record investment in Hedge
vatism throughout the industry, with firms investing in hedge funds and that unnec- Funds, with an average of $36.9 bn in each
unable to focus on the benefits simply essary risks are attached to changing hedge of the first three quarters. With this in
because they’re ill-informed. Like any new fund behaviour. mind, anyone can be forgiven for thinking
venture, MiFID is experiencing The thrust behind regulating hedge that 2006 was a successful year through-
out. The landscape, however, was decid-
teething problems that will probably funds is driven from a transparency
edly less than even.
disappear in time; the frustrating nature of angle, however the ‘light-touch’
Whilst some signs indicate high investor
these problems is that they arise, not regulatory approach to hedge funds has confidence – over half the respondents in
from any flaw within MiFID itself, but benefited the industry in Europe and the a recent Deutsche Bank survey stated they
from the poor communication US and stimulated the growth of this were happy to lock their money into a
surrounding it. investment instrument. Earlier this hedge fund for a two-year period or more
month, the – other signs suggest the market is slowing
Financial Times
Abudefduf saxatilis
Services provided by subsidiaries of The Bank of N.T. Butterfield and Son Limited.
LATIN AMERICAN HEDGE FUNDS
esoteric trading strategies, which in turn is front, regulations need to change in some Taking a step back from front line activ-
due to their relative lack of maturity. countries so that securities lending is ity and the anecdotal evidence, evidence
Investors will demand more complex allowed. Without securities lending, you with a harder edge to it comes from GFIA,
strategies in time. Miami is the regional can’t do shorts. Having said that, half the a Singapore-incorporated exempt finan-
capital for Latin America; there’s more of volume of Latin American shares is in cial adviser which has provided research
an interest in the continent as a region ADRs (American Depositary Receipts) so on hedge funds since 1998. GFIA, it is safe
here than there is in the major Latin you don’t need to borrow shares locally. to say, is an unparalleled source of infor-
American cities because of the large dis- You can short the ADRs, and borrow them mation on the industry in Latin America.
tances between them. Our INCA Fund is a from a prime broker. We can short ETFs Its research note on activity in the region,
long-short fund. We short shares where we too (exchange-traded funds). They are first published in July 2004 and published
think prices will fall. We are regional spe- very easy to borrow and make good liquid twice a year since, is a must-read for any-
cialists rather than industry specialists, but index shorts.” one looking for informed comment on the
we do have a bias towards certain indus- “Looking ahead, I believe the most subject.
tries. We like to buy franchise brand name important thing for Latin America is to In the most recent incarnation of the
companies because we think there is more have economic stability. Badly run report in July 2006, GFIA describes the
potential in them in Latin America than economies have been a long-term problem region as a sophisticated and rapidly
elsewhere. The fund started in May 2006, there, but governments and ruling admin- growing universe, with available capacity.
and is up 10% in a benign market (at the istrations today are doing a better job than Concentrated in fixed income and FX,
macro and trading strategies, Latin hedge
If ever a region deserved a reputation for funds offer non-correlated returns from a
liquid underlying opportunity set, it says.
long-term instability and volatility, Latin “At the margin, there’s increased interest
in equity strategies, and some incipient
America is thhat region. interest from global allocators.”
time of writing, late December 2006), rep- their predecessors. For 2007 and beyond GIFA identifies four major watersheds
resenting annualised growth heading we expect to see continued low inflation in for the hedge fund industry in Latin
towards 20%, compared with inflation Brazil, Mexico and Chile at least for the America:
that has dropped from hyperinflation lev- foreseeable future. This creates the oppor- 1. The end of hyperinflation in the early
els in the 1980s to a current average of tunity for interest rates to come down fur- 1990s and the growth of well developed
around 4.5%. ther, which encourages equity investment. indigenous investment banks with
“The majority of our outperformance A few years of low inflation and low inter- aggressive risk appetites. At that time,
comes from the long side of the equation, est rates will force investors to equity mar- the proprietary trading desks operated
thanks to rising equity markets, which is kets in order to achieve real returns. And as true hedge funds, having a noticeable
where we mostly invest. From Europe, we hedge funds will continue to grow as the impact on prices and volumes, though
have fund of hedge fund investors and importance of equity markets continues to there were few independent managers.
high net worth individuals, from the US grow. They won’t be the catalyst for it, but There was also a substantial technology
there is more interest from endowments, they will certainly benefit from it.” transfer from the US and foreign banks
such as universities and charitable organi- Fernando Jasnis and Andrew Cummins to the local houses.
sations. There’s not much interest from are co-portfolio managers of Explorador 2. After the Asian and Russian crises
corporate pension funds; they are less Capital Management, LLC, based in (1997/98) there was consolidation of
aggressive than endowments in pushing Buenos Aires. They manage a $55m hedge both the hedge fund and mutual fund
out the frontiers of investment.” fund that invests long and short in equity industries, and a strengthening of the
‘Have hedge funds been overhyped?’, we and fixed income in Latin America. “We banking system which led to an overall
asked. “There’s been a lot of publicity, also do special situation investing where reduction of leverage and systemic risk
nearly hysteria,” he answered. “It’s a hot we provide capital in situations with equi- in the financial system.
topic. I believe it’s a valuable asset class ty returns but fixed income risk. We seek 3. The dismantling or retrenchment of
with a long-term future, with characteris- to exploit opportunities that arise when foreign investment banks’ operations in
tics that other asset classes don’t have. assets are mispriced,” says Andrew the Brazilian pre-election (2002) which
There are a lot of marginal players in the Cummins. “This occurs because few hedge triggered a new harvest of managers,
field. Over time, only the good managers funds focus on the region and because most of them ex-proprietary traders,
will continue to attract investors. Others regional economic dependence on com- who transferred their skills into inde-
will be swept out of business.” modities creates volatility of asset prices. pendent hedge fund firms.
How can providers of asset services help We seek to harvest these opportunities 4. Economic strength derived from
the industry? “They have done a good job while mitigating some of the risks through commodity flows increases global inter-
in providing custody services in the hedging and a contrarian value approach. est in emerging markets; at the same
region, but need to be sure they can supply We have been investing in the region for a time a global search for investment tal-
good short inventory. As the industry decade and have an extensive network of ent and capacity, begins to attract inter-
grows and more players come in you need relationships that facilitates access to infor- national capital to Latin hedge funds.
a greater supply of shorts. On the broader mation and investment opportunities.” Latin America, says GIFA, is still an
16 INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL
You’ll Like the View
Client Servicing
Operational Compliance
Security & Audit
Performance Measurement
Marketing
Reporting
Leveraging more than 20 years of proven innovation, Advent Portfolio Exchange® is a next generation
portfolio management system that completely integrates portfolio accounting, reporting and client
relationship management. Using a fully relational database and sophisticated security and audit features,
Advent Portfolio Exchange®FDQKDQGOHERWK\RXUIURQWDQGEDFNRIÀFHRSHUDWLRQVDOOLQDVLQJOH
solution. And that’s a view you can appreciate every day.
Advent Portfolio Exchangee® - Ultimate Vision, from prospecting to reporting. Learn More:
www.adventemea.com/vision
+44 20 7631 9240
Copyright 2007 Advent Software, Inc. All rights reserved. ADVENT, ADVENT PORTFOLIO EXCHANGE, and the Advent logo are registered trademarks of
Advent Software, Inc. All other marks herein are those of their respective owners. Information subject to change without notice.
LATIN AMERICAN HEDGE FUNDS
under-represented region in the global years in Brazil and Mexico), with a variety
hedge fund industry. “With an estimated of other assets and their derivatives.
$40bn of assets and 310 hedge funds, it “In equities, large caps are liquid, espe-
represents approximately 5% of the total cially ADRs traded in the U.S. For some
hedge fund universe. However, many sub- Latin names, turnover of ADRs surpasses
stantial managers still have available that of locally traded stocks by a wide
capacity and therefore the industry may margin. Also, the restructuring and con-
account for a greater proportion of cur- solidation that took place after the privati-
rent global hedge fund capacity.” sation cycle has opened doors for event-
“Brazil accounts for 51% of the region’s driven plays and capital structure arbi-
capital markets, has the most sophisticated trage; those doors are being kept open
onshore hedge fund industry, and hence is with increased corporate activity.
where managers are concentrated. There Generally we see a move, at the margin,
is a highly developed local banking and to an increased role for equity markets,
mutual fund industry (ICI recently esti- both as the Latin growth story becomes
mated that Latin mutual fund industry more apparent, and as low or falling inter-
amounts to $366.2bn of assets – Brazil est rates reduces the attractiveness of fixed
accounts for 82.8% of the region’s total, income investments.
and this in turn is equivalent to about 60% “Size varies across the spectrum of
of Brazilian GDP) as well as the micro- strategies, but macro funds are noticeably
Silver
Lining
Could MiFID change
the whole investment
landscape in Europe
creating, somewhat
inevitably, both
winners and losers?
who has the best overall execution.” for each instrument has yet to be put into
This means that firms looking to place place and that this will be essential if mul-
orders must now decide whether to access tiple venues are to be publishing the pre
prices and other aspects of best execution and post trade quotes.
from a single venue, the LSE for example, Another issue lies in publishing the
or with multiple ones. Mr Thornton prices of more complex instruments such
thinks that although initially investors as OTC derivatives. Mr Tattershall com-
may take the option of using one single ments: “With derivatives the picture
venue for convenience that eventually becomes more complicated as enough
there will be competition as regards speed, information must be provided so that the
efficiency and cost of trading as well as investor can establish where he or she can
over the actual price. get best value. Not easy when so much
For services providers able to provide a derivative pricing is done to suit the indi-
system handling this mass of data and vidual investor.”
present it in a user friendly, there will also Perhaps most significantly though is that
be opportunity. Their challenge is to pro- the pre and post trade transparency
vide brokers with the best execution infor- applies only to equities and those invest-
mation that they need as well as keeping ment houses whose main business does
track of all the orders and feeding execu- not include equities may decide to stop
tion and settlement data back to them- all trading them all together and thus cir-
as quickly as possible. cumvent these transparency requirements
Mr Hill comments that since the onus to of MiFID.
comply is on those doing the trading, Client classification is the third area
rather than the venues, whether to use reckoned to be challenging by industry
single or multiple venues is also an issue players. The directive is to divide clients
for them too. “Should firms just feed their into eligible counterparty, professional
prices through one venue and hope it does client and retail client and provide differ-
not go down or through many venues,” he ent levels of protection according to the
questions? “Clearly some will choose to go client’s classification. Although this is
than EUR1 million to accommodat e the with one venue and review that yearly and largely a logistical problem it adds to the
directive. at the other end some will go with many cost of the directive for firms. Indeed the
But most in the industry are agreed that venues and adapt as they go along,” he SunGard survey found that 36% of firms
best execution is the main area that will says, “and consequently it looks like best do not expect to be able to inform traders
change. Under the directive best execution execution will become a major differentia- of the classification of individual clients by
needs to be both demonstrated and evi- tor in the marketplace.” November 2007.
denced. Currently stock exchanges tend to
hold a competitive advantage when it There is general agreement that the simple
comes to execution on the basis of having
the best liquidity and of course the exist- burden of compliance on smaller local banks
ing trading platforms to support that liq-
uidity. Systematic internalzers, firms that
will be heavyy.
match trades internally also do well. Best execution links in with pre and post Mr O’Sullivan comments: “Firms will
The SunGard survey found that 18% of trade transparency for equities demanded need to carefully look at how they distin-
respondents expected their organizations by the directive. Brokers will now need to guish between bigger and smaller clients.
to know how to ensure best execution by avail themselves of systems to publish pre In reality it’s more a logistical exercise than
the end of 2006 and that 33% expect to be and post trading prices in pretty much real anything but still it will attract costs. For
able to carry out best execution by March time by November 1st, 2007. Seen as one as service provider the opportunities here are
2007. But 13% of firms do not expect to be the greatest areas of cost, it is also another to provide an easy way of doing this and
ready by the deadline of November 2007. potential area of great opportunity for serv- some brokers may find that in the process
Because firms will now be obliged to ice providers who will be able to leverage of doing it they will rationalize their client
obtain the best possible deal for clients, con- their critical mass to provide this cheaply. base or supplier base to gain the very best
sidering not just the price but also the cost Mr Gissings is one such provider: On the in terms of best execution.”
and speed of trading plus the likelihood of best execution front it is to become a Clearly then MiFID presents significant
settlement, then the market will become venue by publishing prices on behalf of opportunities for services providers able
fragmented in terms of execution venues. brokers and systematic internalisers for to make sense of it and offer firms systems
Richard Thornton, partner at SunGard investors to see. and the timeliness that they need to be
explains: “The best execution requirements Mr Hill comments that the EU has yet to able to compete effectively.
will need building into existing order man- specify what will actually need to be pub- But what are the implications in terms of
agement systems. It needs to be automated lished in the data fields specified in the how MiFID might change the shape of the
so that systems can decide where individu- level two guidance that has already come marketplace?
als’ orders should be placed depending on out. He also states that a single identifier So far no consensus has emerged on how
INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL 21
MIFID
the shape of the marketplace will change but if the threat of its existence forces the MiFID throws up is concerned. It well may
but there is general agreement that the sim- LSE to lower the cost of trading then the be that until the directive goes live, players
ple burden of compliance on smaller local seven banks will have achieved their aim. will need to content themselves with simply
banks will be heavy. Mr O’Sullivan for one Thornton comments: “MiFID frees up being compliant and taking an
thinks that local banks will find it difficult competition for best execution and the LSE evolutionary approach rather than worry-
to compete in the market and find the has already announced that it is to cut costs. ing about an endless list of ‘what ifs’ and
resources to update systems or install new This raises questions over whether Project looking for a single big bang solution. But
ones rather than relying on patching up Turquoise will ever be realized.” for service providers able to forsee and solve
legacy systems. Again this area of the market Clearly then the market is far from seeing problems as they arise at a cost
could prove profitable for services providers a complete picture as far as the vast array of acceptable to the market, the future looks
able to capitalize on critical mass at a price questions and strategic opportunities that undoubtedly rosy.
acceptable to such small banks.
Mr Thornton meanwhile thinks that
smaller investment banks should watch out
“MiFID frees up competition for best
for bigger ones looking to encroach on their execution and the LSE has already
territory. “Smaller specialist outfits may
assume that they are too small to be of announced that it is to cutt costs.”
interest to larger players but this will not be
A key element in MiFID’s successful imple- provide quick and efficient record keeping.”
the case especially as time goes on and there mentation is, of course, the reaction and atti- Indeed a recent survey by SunGard found
is a move towards the pan European listing tude towards directive from national regula- that nearly half of the 330 institutions in 22
of stocks,” he warns. tors. Although the UK has been key in push- countries surveyed thought that the support
Perhaps the biggest question mark lies in ing the directive through and already had from national regulators was either bad or
who will be able to offer the best execution much of the directive’s provisions in place, very bad.
and thus capture the most liquidity. Will the other countries whose financial sectors are Countries not being ready of course pres-
prestige of the big stock exchanges win out? less significant or less well developed have ents something of a problem for the
Will they gain even more by partnering been slower to react. In addition the directive European Commission since delaying the
with smaller local institutions or will they does not aim to be prescriptive, leaving each deadline would require an act of Parliament,
member state to interpret its terms. Critics which in itself would take up to a year to
face stiff competition from companies look- argue that 31 different interpretations of the obtain.
ing to compete on the cost of doing busi- directive could service only to further frag- Mr Thornton comments: “The deadline for
ness as well as offering superior overall exe- ment the European marketplace rather than transposition is the end of January and then
cution? unify it as intended. the deadline for implementation is
Mr O’Sullivan offers his view; namely that Alain Lesjongard, managing director and November. Moving this deadline would be
size will be the main issue: “What we’re head of compliance at the Bank of New York very complex and so unlikely. But the impact
probably looking at is an opportunity for points out that some national regulators of national regulators being tardy on the
the larger exchanges to capitalize on have consulted with industry much more transposition front is that banks will have
economies of scale. Midsized businesses or than others, thus making life easier for all less time to comply. The reality is that 95% of
concerned. “The French authorities have the information needed to be compliant is
exchanges need to achieve an innovative undertaken some consultation but not to the already there. It’s only the fine-tuning over
proposition and those opportunities will be same extent as the UK Financial Services file formats, for example, that is missing.
around product, combining traditional Authority (FSA) and I don’t think that the But has the whole timetable has been too
ones or effectively taking existing ones to a German regulator has consulted with its optimistic for such a complex area with so
new market segment or competing on cost,” industry at all. At the moment most people many vested interests and different develop-
he says. are aware of the bigger picture but have not mental stages?
Mr Tattershall thinks that MIFID will been told what they will need to actually Mr Thornton for one thinks that the cost of
challenge the dominance of local exchanges change or introduce by their regulators.” compliance is proving difficult for countries
and of larger brokers by making them com- Mike Hill, director of communications at whose financial markets are less well devel-
Gissings Software comments: “The EU states oped. “The danger is that MiFID will come
pete with other others able to execute are in various states of readiness. The Dutch down to a diluted lowest common denomi-
trades. “It’s all about the cost of the actual regulator for example has an English lan- nator solution. The risk to smaller institu-
trade rather than the price of the invest- guage website and has said that it will not be tions is that the cost of compliance will prove
ment,” he warns. ready to implement the primary legislation too much,” he says.
Project Turquoise is one early contender. until Jan 2008, a whole year late. The Italians For the UK MiFID should not be unduly
Seven banks; Citigroup, Credit Suisse, are saying August 2010 and so the question is painful. Indeed in many areas the UK FSA
Deutsche Bank, Goldman Sachs, Merrill how many will actually be ready?” has said that the directive does not go far
Lynch, Morgan Stanley and UBS have He continues: “A lot will depend on how enough and is seeking to be supra-equiva-
announced their intention to create a pro- each country actually writes its best execu- lent. An example of this is on bundled com-
tion policy. Extremes in interpretation could missions where the UK already allows for the
prietary exchange. Together the group prove difficult and lead to a patchwork quilt investor to know how the commission is
accounts for some 50 % of volumes on the rather than free passporting. Another impor- being split. Lesjongard comments: “In the
LSE. Such internalisation, where banks tant aspect is client classification. MiFID dis- UK most of the requirements of MiFID are
effectively net off trades internally, is already cusses this and allows clients to change their already embedded in legislation and the FSA
estimated to lose the LSE some 30 % or so classifications. This could prove to be an view is that MiFID should not compromise
of the marketplace. Whether the project will administrative nightmare and will thus pres- the existing legislative base. As always the
ever get off the ground remains to be seen ent opportunities for services firms that can devil is in the detail.”
Opportunity Knocks
With the deadline for MiFID compliance less than a year
away Steve Robson, Group Managing Director at
ea Consulting Group, talks about the necessity of managing
the People Side of Change (PSoC) to meet the challenge.
Steve Robson, ea Consulting Group
www.sifma.org/etrade
IN COOPERATION WITH
MIFID
post-trade transparency in a quantitative pose components provided that some basic MiFID deadline.
manner. It’s important to note that Article 21 rules are adhered to; for example, KYC There is a potential downside of the PPM
of the L1 text (as did CP154 before it) right- applied to both new and existing clients approach which needs flagging. It may cost
ly emphasized the need for best outcome could be linked with AML measures for firms something to implement in the short
overall via a process-driven approach and transactions. This would also need to be term to create seamless processes which can
thus advocated flexibility in permitting firms linked to the quality of best execution should be applied to most asset classes. While some,
to select the factors appropriate to their busi- the client demand flexibility in classification. possibly substantial, cost is inevitable, the
ness model and the instrument rather than There is even scope to apply benchmarks in model has some business advantages.
focus on one particular factor, such as price. their proper context – for example, to over- Processes linking the IOI, order and execu-
2. Pro-active Process Management (PPM): see the rebalancing and/or allocation of tion management can be linked and man-
Some industry observers believe that the trades, although it should be stressed that aged (and thus optimised), resulting in a
best option for implementing the best execu- these benchmarks would be internal to each greatly improved velocity of trading. There is
tion obligation would be for regulators to firm, and certainly not imposed. Such an also the potential (yet to be tested) to enable
adopt a principles-based approach based on approach could draw upon the valuable buy-side firms to compile a steadily improv-
intelligent ‘copy-out’ of the MiFID. Such an innovations already realised by TCA ing liquidity picture, but on the basis of
approach could, for example, allow firms to providers such as ITG/Plexus or Elkins greater trust of their brokers rather than via
attach weight to their extant proprietary McSherry. It will require considerable dis- the benchmarking route (which could lead
models by which intermediaries establish cussion as to its applicability, and runs the to more legalistic outcomes and withdrawal
and communicate their prices. Such an risk that such a modular approach is ide- of liquidity from some markets as men-
approach would also be popular with soft- alised. After all, many firms on the buy-side tioned above). There is thus an immediate
ware suppliers and network agents and suffer from makeshift KYC, AML, OMS and medium term benefit to both the investment
providers of market-led solutions (such as EMS architectures and whereas it looks intermediaries which can be passed on to the
reference data aggregation, normalisation implementable in a model form, it is highly end investors, which might not be the case in
and distribution services). There is plenty of debatable whether such as an approach “laissez faire” methods and will not be the
scope for firms to mix, match and re-pur- could be rolled out in time to meet the case if dealer-led markets are benchmarked.
2007
TOP SPEAKERS FROM:
FO EA IB
N 2 FA ION
BR XH
EW 00 S
R K IT
E
Lehman Brothers
Accenture Linedata Services Asset
Allianz Investmentbank Management
AG m.a.partners
BearingPoint Man Financial
Citisoft Markit
Charles River Mellon Financial
7th March 2007 • The Brewery, London Development Corporation
CQS Management Ltd MiFID Joint Working
Credit Suisse Group
Steffen Matthias Jean-Baptiste de Franssu DBFS Morley Fund
KEYNOTE Secretary General CEO DST Management
SPEAKERS EFAMA Invesco Europe DTCC Morgan Stanley
Eagle Investment Morgan Stanley
Systems Investment
THE ONLY INDUSTRY EVENT WHERE Why you should
Equipos Management
Morse
Ernst & Young
YOU CHOOSE WHAT TO ATTEND attend TSAM 2007: Euroclear Performa
FM Consult Pioneer Investments
MORNING
(I) BUT EN E
CE
IO ES
I M C
Princeton Financial
ES
I 400+ industry
IO T
TR RE AN
T
LO G
ER & IAN
NS
AT IV
Fortis Investments
M Y
EN
NO DIN
N
GI
AG ATA
AT U M
ER VAT
RU EG
FO RAT T
Systems
& EAS FOR
PL
EM
ST I
SK NA
CH RA
AN D
participants
OP ERI
M
SMPG
RI IO
M ER
TE T
CO
PwC
T
D
P
FX Market Space
M
OP
speakers
OF FR ON D
S E
Investors
(II) BUT EN CE
R TI ATE
(F AN GN
ON T
E
RT T
TI RA
FI ON S
IO T
G
TR RE AN
SimCorp
PO IEN
X) G
CH EI
IN
FO OLU GR
N
CE T
AT U M
D
AC RPO
HSBC Securities
I M
EX FOR
RE CL
I 30+ groundbreaking
S TE
Services
M ER
IN
w w w. t s a m . n e t (Ref: 884ISJ
MIFID
Moreover, the investment managers are not the general view seems to be that such retail and was considered beneficial by some sup-
excluded from participating in particular liq- investors will need to turn more to financial pliers. It was not identified as acceptable to
uidity opportunities, which was a major con- advisors or portfolio managers in the more many market practitioners (sell-side and
cern expressed by the IMA with regard to complex MiFID world. Given this existing market facilitators offered scant support for
prescriptive benchmarking. legal and institutional context, MiFID could it). There was a perception that it might be
3. “Laissez-Faire”: present a significant headache, with its focus attractive to select buy-side firms by some
There is another school of thought that on the investment required for real-time sell-side firms/suppliers. By contrast, Pro-
argues that MiFID is far too much stick and market quotes for best execution compar- active Process Management (PPM) proved
not enough carrot i.e. the costs of implemen- isons for the SSO to be acceptable to many buy-side firms
tation of its measures far outweigh any ben- Other markets such as Germany already (60% weight), with benefits for the end
investor and support for dynamic KYC and
efits to be gleaned. Although the rules are have some measure of best execution in (especially) market innovation. Electronic
95% certain today, the eventual costs to the place, although this does not apply to all market facilitators (68% weight) were partic-
industry and market users of the client clas- products traded OTC. In Germany as in ularly supportive, as were some sell-side
sification, best execution, order handling and France, there might be somewhat less focus firms and suppliers. The comfort level
record-keeping aspects of MiFID, it is on competition, and much more on avoiding behind laissez-faire was strongest among
argued, could result in significant costs, fragmentation of liquidity and avoiding suppliers. It was also noted for dealer-led
potentially in the range of $30-50 million for information leakage (market impact). markets. It was seen by many to be congru-
a typical European universal bank, and pos- Privacy is preferable in many member states ent with existing policies and a practical
sibly one tenth of that amount for many a and firms use various tools to ensure they implementation route meeting the MiFID
money manager or private bank. Taking stay in line with market prices. The CSSF in deadline, although some buy-side firms and
market facilitators disagreed. It was not
The client classification, best execution, order viewed as acceptable to regulators, nor was it
perceived to be particularly acceptable to
handling and record-keeping aspects of MiFID investors. Grey areas were strongest when it
came to assessing protection for the end
could
d result in significant costs potentially in investor and benefits for dealer-led markets.
the range of $30-50 million. Suppliers and market facilitators seemed gen-
erally more confident when answering the
account of these factors, it is very likely that Luxembourg is taking proactive steps to questions in this regard.
To close, at this point in time, the thinking
dealers would pass on to their clients the devise a pre-law to help investors in this area. is that best execution will be translated as a
increase in their costs, possibly via a com- The Dublin authorities have issued a very process, not monitored trade/trade in a
mission-based structure or possibly via pragmatic and workable paper which should dirigiste fashion. Both investment banks and
wider spreads for some asset classes if the raise the level of confidence there. But this asset managers will need the underlying data
measures represent a significant departure leaves more than 20 member states of pub- in order to evidence best execution practices
from current market practices – dynamic lishing significant works on the subjects of when called to evidence the same.
client categorisation is an excellent example client classification and best execution, and it Expediency and common sense judgement
of this. This school of thought might argue would be frankly presumptuous to assume calls are not going out of fashion – the prices,
that as a result, the imposition of “best exe- that they will follow the examples of lead sizes, timings etc. all have to relate to
cution” would actually cost investors more regulators in markets such as the UK, France executable transactions i.e. completed per the
than the current system. or Germany. It is clear that the “laissez-faire” size and other conditions stipulated by the
“Laissez-faire” schemes whereby firms do approach comes loaded with obvious disad- client. Both investment banks and asset
little to bring their systems in line with their vantages, such as the likelihood of some managers will also likely need to draw up
more developed competitors, will be a signif- form of sanction by the European policies to demonstrate the reasonable steps
icant reality for many firms unable or unwill- Commission or even the threat of legal to be carried out, especially for illiquid,
ing to commit compliance or system action from some firms who are exposed to fixed income and OTC-traded instruments
resources to keep up with MiFID. A large the costs of poor quality. Investment firms such structured products where the recording
percentage of these firms may rely on either who are inclined to follow this course of of the circumstances to the trade could be
the largesse or a relaxed approach to imple- action and implement minimal changes may seen as advantageous. Logically and legally, if
a firm’s quality of execution is likely to be
mentation on the part of some competent find that they are disadvantaged in the medi- open to doubt or challenge, then making a
authorities not having the headcount of um term. note of the circumstances and building in the
processes to monitor everything that hap- relevance of the factors at the time will
pens. In many member states, for example, Summary of Approaches to Best Execution: help mitigate disciplinary action. The degree
many client classification schemes differenti- The three forms of approach to evidencing of regulatory arbitrage which could well
ate only retail from professional, and there is best execution – benchmarking, pro-active occur post the Level 3 process will mark an
a modicum of best execution evidencing process management (PPM) and “laissez- important milestone as to whether best exe-
with a sole focus on price. The Italian market faire” are being debated by the BESG follow- cution is workable in practice and the func-
for example already enjoys reasonably low ing a survey of 50+ buy- and sell-side firms, tioning of markets across the EU becomes
execution costs and practitioners there see plus electronic market facilitators the better for it.
some risks in liquidity fragmentation for the and suppliers.
retail investors. With over 800 banks, and Prescriptive benchmarking was believed to
over 300 SSOs (organised trading systems), be somewhat more acceptable to regulators,
Cool Runnings
lmarinen is one of several pensions while the bond portfolio is 90% overseas.
I
Mr Laitinen is very proud of his team’s
insurance companies which compete “It has changed dramatically from the achievements here. “In 2002 we were a lot
for business to provide pensions for early 90s when the two main asset classes poorer than we are today and it was a
Finland’s workforce. were maybe 90% inland and 10% abroad,” good way to get some equity exposure into
Around 370,000 salaried employees and said Mr Laitinen. He thinks that interna- the markets when the risk based system
around 50,000 self employed enjoy pen- tional diversification of equities is now at wouldn’t have allowed it. We have been
sions insurance coverage from Ilmarinen. about the right level. Finnish and going to investment banks and others to
Contributions amount to around 21.5% European equities are managed mainly in- buy long dated option baskets and doing
of pay for companies, and an employee house, while US, Japanese and emerging the bond investment side ourselves. It was
contribution of 4.3% for those under the market equity exposure is managed exter- a good time to go into long term
age of 53. nally via pooled funds. call options - they have performed
Finland’s pension insurance companies Domestic bond allocations are limited by much better than bonds but not quite as
operate on a risk based system. They are the size of the local market, says Mr well as equity.”
allowed to choose their own asset Laitinen. “The Finnish domestic bond
allocation, within the framework of market is fairly small, the only major bor- CURRENCY MANAGEMENT
certain solvency capital rules. rower is the Finnish government and they Half of the currency exposure on the
“If we have very little solvency capital we are finding enough investors from abroad, equity portfolio is covered, and currency
are not allowed to have a very risky so we have had to diversify. It’s gone from risk is managed internally. This has not
portfolio, while if we have excess solvency maybe 60% domestic five years ago to less always been the case. “We have had a cur-
capital then we can choose our asset allo- than 10% domestic now.” rency overlay programme but we weren’t
cation more freely,” said Jussi Laitinen, too happy with it,” says Mr Laitenin.
chief investment officer at Ilmarinen. ALTERNATIVES “There was a lot of activity but very low
“That’s one way the regulator checks we Ilmarinen has been investing in hedge returns, so we decided to decrease activity
don’t have too much risk on our balance funds for six years, with an allocation of a bit but do it all in house.”
sheet, because if one pension insurance 1.5%, half of which is in funds of funds,
company in Finland fails the others will the rest in single strategies. Private equity CUSTODY AND SECURITIES LENDING
pick up the tab so that pensioners will accounts for 2% of the portfolio. Ilmarinen’s custody arrangements were
never lose their rights.” The risk grading system limits the allo- overhauled at the beginning of last year,
cation to these alternatives. If it were pos- when one global custodian, ABN Amro
INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO sible, Mr Laitinen would like to allocate Mellon was appointed to replace
Ilmarinen’s EUR22bn portfolio has a more to both private equity and hedge separate custodians for domestic and
slightly higher allocation to equities than funds. “They have very high risk points global equities and European bonds. The
its competitors, with about one third of its allocated to them so we have had to keep aim was rationalisation and
portfolio invested in equities, around 40% them lower than we would have like to. simplification of arrangements but it
in bonds, 10-12% in real estate, roughly Now after four good years our solvency has other unexpected, but welcome
10% in alternatives, and 4% in loans to capital is fairly high so we have been consequences.
sponsoring companies. The latter is a lega- adding our commitments in private equi- “It is easier to work with one
cy from when the system was established ty, but private equity companies have been counterparty and we saved quite a lot of
in the 1960s and companies were allowed paying back a lot of funds, so it has been money doing it. We almost halved our
to borrow back their pensions contribu- hard to get the allocation to rise.” custody costs, and we didn’t expect that,”
tions for internal investment, subject to One particular success story has been said Mr Laitinen.
backing from bank guarantees. Ilmarinen’s four year old internally The securities lending programme is
Over the years Ilmarinen has shifted its managed structured products managed by the custodian. Most lending is
investments away from a pure domestic programme. This accounts for around 4% on the equity portfolio but early last
bias to a more international one. The equi- of the portfolio, and is mainly capital year this was extended to bond
ty portfolio is now 60% invested abroad, guaranteed products. lending as well.
Best Practice
or Best Competition?
Institutional Investors are concerning themselves more and more
with ensuring that their current arrrangements are in line with best
market practice.
n.
Arti Sharma of Thomas Murray gives ISJ the lowdown
n the UK and European markets, the for Insurance Companies, the Ontario compliance comfort. Others have
ing the market has left institutional their own conclusions. structured as follows.
investors with limited choice. They have This is generally where the real shock
relied on colleagues in their respective Fees and Commercial Arrangements comes as institutions find that they have
industries to benchmark their services This is generally where the real shock been disadvantaged by the fee and com-
and fees. In the US market, the use of comes as institutions find that they have mercial arrangements in place. Normally
consultants is more developed and cus- been disadvantaged by the fee and com- the ancillary cost items such as interest
tody searches are more prevalent within mercial arrangements in place. Normally spreads, fx margins and securities lending
certain plan types. the ancillary cost items such as interest splits (pre/post transaction costs) have
With these changes in regulation, the spreads, fx margins and securities lending been ignored in the past and when taken
industry is being drawn to three distinct splits (pre/post transaction costs) have into consideration make a significant dif-
levels of provider evaluation and this been ignored in the past and when taken ference to the total cost of the custodian
reflects the importance of the various into consideration make a significant dif- relationship. This is validated by the cus-
stages in the lifecycle of a relationship ference to the total cost of the custodian todian providers many of whom will say
with a provider. While the UK and relationship. This is validated by the cus- that around 50% of their revenues come
European market has led the way in this todian providers many of whom will say from non-headline fees.
area, there is growing interest in Canada that around 50% of their revenues come
and US for benchmarking tools. from non-headline fees. 3. CUSTODIAN BENCHMARKING
Part of the reason that Thomas Murray
1. HEALTH CHECK 2. RFP REVIEW developed PROBE, was to support institu-
These reviews of the current arrange- Increasingly the findings from Health tional investors fulfil the Conduct of
ments take the form of a clear “Health Checks are so disturbing that they trigger Business rules from the FSA that came out
Check” that examines three critical ele- a full review of the custodial and related in 2001. These rules stated that not only
ments of a relationship with a provider: services arrangements. While the incum- should there be a process in place for
bent suppliers usually make strong com- appointing a custodian but also for ensur-
Service Level Agreement petitive proposals to retain the business ing the ongoing appropriateness of that
Custody & Related Services Agreement(s) the client relationship is sometimes dam- appointment. Thomas Murray has started
Fees and Commercial Arrangements aged beyond reasonable repair. to see a decrease in switching behaviour
Further, competitor custodians try to and clients were able to demonstrate that
Service Level Agreement add to the inducement to move by offer- they were still receiving best market prac-
The first step is to look at the Service ing
Level Agreement in order to understand fee
what services are being provided by the
custodian. Typically, the SLA is not very
In conducting structured and objective
well constructed and takes the form of a benchmarking, investors can feel confident
high level description of what services are
available but does not address the com- that they have mett their client and fiduciary
mitments that are required of both par-
ties. Increasingly investors are requiring
responsibilities.
that their SLA addresses all aspects of the
service, from consistency of relationship reductions, contributions and fee rebates tice. There are no comparative rules in the
management staff, through to disaster to facilitate the transition away from the Canadian and the US market.
recovery plans. incumbent. Commitments to provide Thomas Murray currently has over $675
support staff during the billion of assets under surveillance for
Custody & Related Services transition and beyond can make a major investment funds and asset man-
Agreement(s) persuasive argument against staying with agers using Private Custodian Ratings and
Next, the main agreement gives a full pic- the incumbent. Operational Benchmarking (“PROBE”).
ture as to the asset safety and risk min- While reviews can be time consuming It is more than just number crunching – it
imisation provisions in the relationship and costly, the pay back in terms of serv- is a custodian monitoring service.
and the extent to which the custodian ice improvements, access to new technol- Benchmarking service against the SLA is
bank/service provider will take responsi- ogy, reduced risk and increased asset safe- quite a clear cut activity but gathering
bility for losses and protect the client ty provisions as well as clear commercial universe data to ensure that service levels
from risks in the markets. Often the con- benefits can make a compelling case for do not slip below standards generally
tracts that have been signed present a taking a mandate to market. Investors are accepted in the market, is quite different.
variety of risk evasive clauses and many also saying that it has a salutary effect on Further, regulatory interest in bench-
agreements have unbelievable protections custodians as it shows that the business is marking, while not prescriptive, would
in favour of the service provider. When not necessarily with the custodian forever. suggest that structured ongoing compari-
challenged, the providers will generally In order to deliver maximum benefit, son with the market is seen as best market
say that there is never likely to be a situa- the RFP review is best when highly struc- practice.
tion in which such egregious clauses tured and clear on what the key buying Regardless of the client’s custody expert-
would be invoked and therefore there is criteria for the investor might be. Our ise, if their custodian knows they are
no cause for concern. Investors can form view is that the RFP review should be employing a knowledgeable, experienced
INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL 31
THOMAS MURRAY
third party to monitor the service deliv- that the UK market is now leading the
ery, it is more likely that the custodian will way when it comes to evaluating and
provide a superior service. monitoring custodians. As portfolio
values increase and custodian
FX BENCHMARKING competition for mandates accelerates,
In addition to operational benchmarking, investors are well advised to put in place
foreign exchange benchmarking can be sound evaluation, selection and monitor-
particularly relevant for small to medium ing tools.
sized funds that may be using their custo- The cost of implementing such tools
dian for a large percentage of their foreign and processes can be such that CFO
exchange execution. PROBE allows a approvals are required but the costs of not
client an inexpensive way of monitoring doing so can be such that CFO’s job
the custodian’s execution rates against retention could be reasonably
market rates. challenged by any reasonably informed
Record Currency Management, who has CEO or auditor.
been providing foreign exchange bench-
marking since 1983, has found that a tiny
minority of funds has currency trades
being executed in an effective manner
overall. The benchmarking component of
PROBE, provided by Record, examines
foreign exchange transactions executed by
the custodian. These transactions are
compared against Record's database,
which is one of the most comprehensive
records of dealable foreign exchange rates
worldwide. Foreign exchange bench-
marking will identify the effectiveness or
otherwise of the currency execution the
fund is receiving from its custodian.
SECURITIES LENDING
BENCHMARKING
Thomas Murray has partnered with
Spitalfield Advisors to provide securities
lending performance analysis as part of
the quarterly PROBE report. The
enhanced PROBE will enable pension
funds, asset managers and other institu-
tional investors who have mandated their
respective custodians to carry out securi-
ties lending on their behalf, to monitor THOMAS MURRAY (www.ThomasMurray.com)
their performance and the risks is a global firm specialising in the global securities
associated with the activity. industry and provides evaluation, rating (market
infrastructure & custodian) selection and monitor-
ing products and services to global, regional and
CONCLUSION domestic custodians and institutional investors
While the US market had led the way in worldwide. Arti Sharma is Senior Vice President,
the past with ERISA regulations, it seems Business Development, Americas.
Once labelled
the ‘sick man’
of Europe,
Germany is now
displaying healthy
economic
growth.
Left Behind?
Alan Duerden looks at the changing face of German custody.
34 INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL
COUNTRY PROFILE - GERMANY
investors to take full advantage of the asset stringent regulation by the German regu- custodian.”
class diversification that you have in mar- lator specifically around the different Gina Slotosch, Director of Custody
kets like the US or the UK. types of reporting that needs to be done Services, HSBC Trinkaus adds to this, say-
“To some extent, regulations have led to a for the sake of risk management. “For ing: “Growth is related to some regulatory
higher degree of flexibility for investors,” example, you are seeing custodians being changes, especially where IFRS was imple-
believes Moritz Ostwald, BHF-BANK. asked to provide risk management capa- mented. Clients are being asked to report
“Since the introduction of the Investment bilities around the monitoring of deriva- in a completely different way by the mas-
Act in 2004, for instance, KAGs are allowed tives and to support the stress testing of ter KAG’s in the German market or from
to outsource processes such as portfolio portfolios to do scenario calculations. the custodians.”
management and invest in a wider variety These are the sort of things that corporate Economically, Germany has a fairly risk
of investment vehicles including deriva- insurance companies and pension funds averse nature and a large portion of asset
allocation tends to move towards very
‘safe’ investments such as fixed income.
Germany has a fairly risk averse nature. Different sorts of structured products
A large portion of asset allocation tends to have been developed to try and give
investors exposure to other assert classes
move towards very ‘safe’ investments while still presenting ‘safe’ investments,
but these still have yet to take off. The
such as fixed income. German hedge fund industry has also
been less glamorous in terms of attracting
asset allocation than people would have
tives and hedge funds. On the other hand, need to be able to provide from a regula- thought in 2004 when that was launched.
the domestic regulators have become less tory perspective,” says Michelle “I think the general risk averse attitude is
flexible as well, as most of the regulations Grundmann, Branch Manager, ABN primarily driven by the fact that a lot of
are initiated by EU bodies.” AMRO Mellon in Germany. “Not every- the investment products are insurance
Rather than regulatory flexibility, service one has that capability in house, so some based and linked to guarantees, which by
requirements have also changed due to of that falls back onto the shoulders of the their nature do not allow a lot of risk tak-
Nordea Bank AB (publ)
Making it possible
COUNTRY PROFILE - GERMANY
ing because that guarantee has to be met. ing model that allows them to deliver their who will be next. I think those who are
This obviously takes part of the risk budg- services locally. “We have invested across going to dominate are more likely to be
et away. Coupled with that, the regulatory Europe in activities that have traditionally from the US, UK and French environ-
environment, although it has improved, is been done locally by local providers, so ment,” believes Ms Gruber.
still rather onerous and diminishes the our clients appreciate that if they appoint For German local custody, the challenge
ability to be more dynamic,” says Mr us as a depot bank then they can use the will be around what European regulation
Grundmann. same platform in Italy and Spain. in the future will look like. Target 2 securi-
There is an overtly serious, almost pes- Similarly, they can entrust hedge funds to ties is a big topic of discussion with the
simistic feeling behind the German mar- us in Germany, in Luxembourg, in Dublin European Central Bank and custodian
ket which some believe is the result of the and be confident that they will always get industry. This will potentially change
economic struggles that the country felt in consistent data,” explains Mr Grundmann. infrastructure, not only for German banks
the late 90’s and early 2000. Others argue From an institutional investor or fund but also the rest of Europe, bringing with
that this is just the German way, their administration point of view the biggest it large cost savings through efficiency,
mentality. opportunity comes from the increasing technical harmonisation and cross border
A turnaround in sentiment however has likelihood that there will be significant business.
been noticed over the past 18-months consolidation in the German depot bank Pension fund reforms and healthcare
with a stronger GDP and investors show-
ing a renewed confidence in the German
economy. “Last summer was really a turn- The classic German providers have
ing point,” believes Martina Gruber, Head
of Sales, Germany, Clearstream. “The soc- been losing mandates for the past three
cer championship really gave the Germans
a positive attitude and a lot of reforms that or four years.
had been outstanding for years and years
are now under way.” market. This will be facilitated by the abol- reforms, kick-started in the last 18-
Being more of a rugby man myself, it ishment of antiquated fee structures, months, will all come to fruition over the
does slightly turn my stomach to think increased market pressure through the next year and with the MiFID deadline
that an uncouth game such as football MiFID regulation and increased competi- closing in, there are a lot of initiatives
could have such an influence, not only on tion coming into the market by classic being implemented, and depending on the
a countries economy, but also on the dis- global custodians. outcome there is a big potential for the
position its inhabitants, but I can under- There are currently between sixty and growth of further business in Germany.
stand how a sporting event such as the seventy depot bank providers in Germany “The various EU initiatives are a major
World Cup could unite a country and and under these market pressures they will challenge for the European custody
renew its spirit and belief in itself. “I would have to decide whether they will invest providers and will tie up a lot of resources
say the climate is much more positive and massively in infrastructure or whether over the next few years,” believes Ostwald.
gives all types of investors a positive envi- they will try to minimise costs and focus “The Markets in Financial Instruments
ronment to invest in,” says Ms Gruber. on asset management which is their core Directive, for example, will definitely lead
“I would completely agree,” says business. German banks that are fulfilling to greater transparency and harmonisa-
Slotosch, “one and a half years back we their depot bank function will be put in a tion of the 25 or more different markets.
were the ‘sick man’ in Europe, but in 2006 position where they either ‘white label’ or Clients will benefit from these develop-
we achieved growth figures of 2.5% and outsource their custody function to one of ments and, in the long run, this might
went through a pension reform and the larger custodians, or just sell their result in stronger cross-border invest-
healthcare reform, so a lot of things are business altogether. ments in countries like Germany, for
changing.” Over the years the US custodians have instance, as these markets will then be
While market development in Germany shown their mettle in the acquisition more attractive.
as a whole is clear, the development of space in Germany. November 2002 saw While growth in Germany over the next
German ‘home-grown’ custodians, or State Street acquire a substantial part of few years will be evident, the pessimism
depot banks, seems to have been stymied Deutsche Bank AG’s Global Securities that under pins the market no doubt will
by this previous lack of dynamism and Services businesses, giving them a thwart the activity of its home-grown cus-
they have failed to capitalize on the accel- foothold not only in Germany but also in todians. Like a middle child dominated by
erated economic growth. The German Italy and Austria. its older siblings, German depot banks
market is dominated by foreign custodi- More recently, in 2005, The Bank of New have been somewhat bullied into a corner
ans, both from Europe and the US who York established BHF BNY Securities by their larger, stronger US and European
have taken advantage of the KAG structure Services GmbH as a jointly held subsidiary counterparts, and are putting up little
and diversifying allocation of assets. based in Frankfurt, with BHF-BANK and fight. The rate of acquisitions in Germany
On the custodial side, the shape of the The Bank of New York each holding a 50% does not look like it will slow and it is only
market has changed quite significantly. stake in the new company. The object of a matter of time before the number of tra-
The classic German providers have been the venture being to bring together BHF- ditional depot banks is squashed under
losing mandates for the past three or four BANK's expertise on the German market the weight of consolidation.
years to the likes of BNP Paribas, and The Bank of New York's international
StateStreet, ABN AMRO Mellon and experience, allowing clients to have a sin-
JPMorgan, who have been happily picking gle point of contact that coordinates all
up business from the domestic players. the required services on their behalf.
The more international custodians, the “The trend of consolidation will go on
likes of which have just been mentioned, and there will be more acquisitions
heavily benefit from using a global operat- throughout Europe, but it is hard to judge
WHAT ISSUE IS THE MOST TOPICAL WHAT NEW DEMANDS DID CLIENTS IMPOSE
IN YOUR MARKET? ON THEIR DIRECT CUSTODIANS IN 2006?
WHAT DO YOU ENVISAGE FOR 2007?
rom my point of view, foreign investors have not forgotten the
F Czech market as two new IPOs were recently made on the Prague
Stock Exchange. The main exchange PX index repeatedly broke its all-
T hroughout 2006, and over the past few years, our clients have
been shifting their European focus further east to Central and
Eastern Europe (CEE). Whilst 2006 saw increased activity across
time highs throughout December. Czech economic developments are direct custody and clearing (DCC) globally, the action was most
very promising. The Czech Republic has been successfully profiting pronounced in the CEE markets as a result of the substantial
from joining the EU nearly three years ago and the Czech currency is growth, both in terms of assets and in transactions, CEE countries
increasingly strengthening against both the USD and the EUR. have recently enjoyed. As a result, clients are eager to get into these
However, there continue to be some barriers that can discourage some markets and take advantage of the opportunities they present.
important institutional investors who are interested in investing on the The challenge custodians face is supporting the massive volume
Czech market. What barriers should foreign investors be aware of? increases across CEE whilst simultaneously expanding and
Firstly, so far, no Central Securities Depository has been established in
the Czech Republic. Currently, it is more a political than a business deci-
improving the product set to meet client needs. One of the ways in
sion and the six-month long post-election deadlock does not support a which Citigroup is responding to clients is through network
fast solution of this issue. Although the legal basis of a bi-level securities expansion. Over the past 14 months, Citigroup has opened three
register has been in place since 2004, precisely according to applicable new DCC branches across CEE - Slovakia, Israel and Cyprus -
Czech law, only beneficial accounts can be set up with the Central bringing our network to 49 markets, the largest in the world.
Securities Registrar (SCP). Some global custodians operating in the Market growth and client demand will continue to drive expan-
Czech market have decided to open an omnibus account on behalf of sion into new markets with CEE and the Middle East both posing
their name on the SCP’s books, whereas some more conscientious cus- interesting opportunities.
todians tend to open segregated (i.e. individual) accounts on behalf of Clients are not only demanding increased access to new markets,
their customers there to comply. In order to open an account with the but better service. Citigroup is constantly striving to put our
SCP, the global custodian utilizes a local custodian as their agent, as is clients first and as part of that effort our product set now includes
usual all over the world. However, under Czech law, there are strict doc- third-party on exchange clearing which enables broker-dealers to
umentation requirements, which usually represent no problem for trade in markets in which they do not have a local back office pres-
Czech entities. Nevertheless, these documentation requirements that ence. In 2006 this service was rolled out in Austria, Hungary and
result accurately from the Czech legal environment can be very cumber- Poland, enabling our clients to build direct exchange connectivity
some for foreign investors. For this reason, some foreign investors have for trading without incurring the fixed costs that can arise from
difficulties in complying with the requirements. Therefore, we make establishing a local clearing operation. We have also worked with
every effort to remove segregated accounts at the central level, along with clients to operate their own local depository accounts in Russia
the burdensome requirements. and Turkey. As clients explore more on-exchange activity, particu-
Secondly, the documents I mentioned above are also required when we
execute any corporate action on behalf of our client. CSOB custody rep- larly in response to the increasing demand for derivatives, we
resentatives have been negotiating with Czech issuers or their paying envisage more interest in this type of product enhancement in
agents to simplify these strict requirements but they insist on keeping 2007.
this practice. However, CSOB custody has initiated discussions with the As clients become more active in CEE, we expect them to look
Capital Market Supervisory Department of the CNB. The CNB’s posi- for more asset financing capabilities as alternative means of
tion seems to be favourable for both us as the local custodian and our expanding their activity without using increasing amounts of
clients. We strongly believe that our endeavour will be successful and that working capital. As a result, fails coverage will also become more
additional documents will no longer be required for the purposes of cor- important.
porate actions this year. CEE is the region to watch in 2007 as clients look to their custo-
However, in spite of the facts mentioned above, all CSOB custody staff dians to provide improved access, service and products to support
place enormous importance on providing foreign clients with the best their growth in this vibrant space.
quality services and they are committed to continuously improving the
level of all custodial operations in the Czech market.
JÖRG AMBROSIUS,
NORMUNDS VIGULIS, Managing Director,
Head of Treasury and State Street Bank GmbH,
Custody of Parex banka Germany
T hemarket
latest trends in the Baltic custody and fund administration
show that there are more foreign financial institutions T hestraightforward.
answer should definitely be no — and the reasons are quite
Whilst Central and Eastern European markets are
using the services provided by Riga Stock Exchange, therefore cash still relatively immature, they are growing at around 15 to 20 % annual-
agents are needed for the settlement of transactions. There are two ly — a rate far faster than more developed markets. With this level of
options they may use, first, full custody services within any of growth, asset sizes in many Central and Eastern European countries
Latvian Central Depository members or OMX as securities settle- could grow to be very attractive within the next 5 to 10 years. However,
ment agent and one of Latvian banks as cash agent. The Baltic cus- to have a significant presence in them at that stage, you may want to
todians are planning to broaden their services by also providing invest in them now.
safekeeping of Azerbaijani, Kazakh and Ukrainian papers. As a global custodian, State Street covers more than 100 markets and
Custody services still remain an additional platform for brokerage operates in 23 markets. Even if some markets are perceived not attractive
on a stand-alone basis, our multinational customers expect us to be there
to asset management products in the framework of one entity, as their service provider. Our market coverage via our sub-custodian net-
including ordinary securities account services, high level securities work allows local customers to benefit from our services as a global cus-
processing, sub-custodian services for international banks, brokers todian; however, for services such as NAV calculations for domestic
and funds, voting services, investment fund custody administration, funds, local regulation often demands a local provider.
pension fund custody administration, though global custody serv- Whilst each country has its own unique characteristics, there are some
ices for Baltic and CIS financial institutions and corporate clients generalisations that can be made. One pertains to the concentration of
are provided as well. asset pools. The top five to six asset owners in each market often repre-
The Pan-Baltic custody and fund administration market may be sent upwards of 50 % of all assets in the respective market segments.
characterized by several important trends. First, the importance of Consequently, success for foreign groups requires forging business part-
value added custody and fund administration services rises hand in nerships with at least one of the large local players. Another shared char-
hand with growing customer needs. A simple example, Parex banka, acteristic in these markets is that the local players tend to know one
besides such core services as securities safekeeping, settlements of another. Personal recommendations (“word-of-mouth”) do often sell a
good product quickly. Custody is a relationship-driven business, and it
transactions, securities deliveries, corporate actions, cash manage- takes time to build up credibility. That’s why we’ve cultivated a well-
ment and reporting provides its clients with value added services, established team of people who are dedicated to these markets.
including account management for each client, relationship man- A good illustration of the potential in Eastern Europe is Poland. It is the
agement and market information. sixth most populated member state of the EU and one of the most suc-
Second, in the current market situation it is crucial not only to cessful examples of the transition from a partially state-capitalist market
provide the direct access to the widest range of Baltic and foreign economy to a primarily privately owned market economy. The Baltic
depositories, but also to provide detailed fee structures, thus offer- States, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, also offer great opportunities. In
ing the lowest costs. terms of culture and background, the Baltics are similar to the Nordic
Third, the focus slightly shifts from institutional clients towards countries, and, like the Nordics, they have made the development of a
retail clients as development of retail custody services is closely con- pension industry a priority. The Baltics have strict pension regulations
nected to development of asset management services for retail that require all pension schemes to be fully funded, which — over time
clients. Developing retail custody products Parex banka is able to — means potentially large pools of assets.
Other countries that will become increasingly attractive in terms of
provide high quality custody platform for convenient use of broker- growing wealth include Hungary, the Czech Republic, Bulgaria, Romania
age and asset management products for example the settlement fees and Turkey. With nearly 50 % of its population currently under 20 years
for the deals executed on international markets are only EUR5-7 of age, Turkey could ultimately build one of the largest pension indus-
and the deals executed through Riga Stock Exchange are settled free tries in Europe. Some of the most interesting opportunities also are in
of charge. lesser-known markets such as Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan. Theses oil-
Moreover, Parex banka has the leading position in Latvia, repre- rich countries focus on building asset pools to back pension provisions
senting up to 40% of the Latvian pension pillars and investment as well as education and health services. State Street has already built a
funds safekeeping market as eight out of nineteen investment funds very successful custody position in Kazakhstan through word-of-mouth
registered in the Republic of Latvia use the services provided by marketing. What is clear in all these examples is this: the first movers will
Parex custody team. be dominant players in the years ahead.
TECHNOLOGY TRUST
FLEXIBILITY TAILOR-MADE
FLEXIBILITY
TRUST TAILOR-MADE
FLEXIBILITY
RELIABILITY
RELIABILITY
TAILOR-MADE TAILOR-MADE
FLEXIBILITY
TAILOR-MADE TRUST
FLEXIBILITY
RELIABILITY RELIABILITY
7Vc`B^aaZcc^jb
Bg6cYgoZ_HoVY`dlh`^
8jhidYn9ZeVgibZci
=ZVYd[8jhidYn9ZeVgibZci
6a#?Zgdoda^bh`^Z&((V
iZa# )-''*.-((-+
%'"(%)LVghoVlV
VcYgoZ_#hoVY`dlh`^5WVc`b^aaZcc^jb#ea
EdaVcY
HL>;I/7><7EAEL8JH BgBVg^jhoE¦d®h`^
HVaZhVcYGZaVi^dch]^eBVcV\ZbZci
IdegViZY'%%)!'%%*!'%%+Wn<adWVa8jhidY^Vc iZa# )-''*.-((.-
6bZbWZgd[B^aaZcc^jb<gdje bVg^jho#eadch`^5WVc`b^aaZcc^jb#ea
ANALYZE THIS... CEE CUSTODY
ERNST BOLLHALDER,
Member of the Executive
Committee, Head of Customer
Relations, SIS SegaInterSettle AG BANK AUSTRIA CREDITANSTALT
Foundations
of view. This diversity provides the depth and breadth of experi-
ence and talents to address our clients’ most complex needs,”
explains Mr Shah. It is also important that rotation in direction
within the same company can often shed new light on old prob-
lems. Mr Shah has had a wide and varied role within JPMorgan.
“I’m one of the long-time staff contributing through a new role.
When I joined JPMorgan ten years ago, I worked in the invest-
ment bank first as European Head of Derivatives Middle Office
and then as Global Head of Derivatives Collateral Management
Operations. I then moved to Worldwide Securities Services to run
Continuing ISJ’s the clearance and collateral management business prior to head-
CEO profile series we talk to ing up Global Custody.”
within the market place that gives mittees, as well.” set to leveraged funds and hedge funds,
JPMorgan the confidence to plan and One of the major driving forces behind which will include auto-borrow capabili-
react with success. “JPMorgan believes this expertise in technology is the amount ties, trade finance, and full STP and
that successfully meeting and mitigating JPMorgan is willing to spend on the issue. matching of short sell trades,” continues
regulatory challenges, particularly in the “We are investing more than $600 million Mr Shah. Indeed, it is not excellence in one
emerging markets, is what distinguishes per year to develop best-in-class technolo- area, but excellence in every sphere that
custody providers today. JPMorgan helps gy platforms in support of this compo- enables custodians to compete on a global
its clients interpret market regulations and nent-based framework. Many of our com- level. An obvious area that one must be
gain insights about best practices to oper- petitors are too small to make an invest- strong in is the ability to identify global
ate within the rules. But real success for ment of that size. Technology is one place and domestic trends before your
our clients (and others) is achieved when where our vast global resources make a competitors catch on. Mr Shah seems well
JPMorgan works with local market partic- real difference.” placed. “Many of the Asia-Pacific
ipants to lessen the regulatory challenges It is clear that STP cannot be under- countries offer significant growth oppor-
in the first place. JPMorgan has used its emphasised, neither for the industry or tunity. Australia, of course, is a market
extensive expertise and close partnerships JPMorgan. One of our top objectives year with strong growth because of the nation-
with market participants to streamline over year is to continuously improve our al retirement savings mandate. JPMorgan
is well positioned with the superannua-
tion funds and other asset accumulators in
“Investment in technology is crucial to support the country. Taiwan is another opportuni-
ty for JPMorgan because of our strong
the two biggest growth areas in the business.” local capabilities, global investor interest
in the market and the growth of asset
market practices.” For example, the clients’ STP rates,” Mr Shah explains. pools in country. The development of
Taiwan Stock Exchange (TSE) asked “Improving STP rates improves the quali- QDII in China provides an opportunity
JPMorgan to host a series of sessions ty of our service to our clients, and it for a global custodian like JPMorgan to
about its proposed market practices with reduces their (and our) operating risk. It provide cross-border services to the assets
its investor clients. The discussions also enables all parties to be more efficient. under management that can now be
enabled TSE representatives to meet with Our operations team takes increasing STP earmarked for foreign markets. We see
investors around the globe. This provided rates very seriously—from senior execu- India and Korea as other markets with
the Exchange with an opportunity to tives, to middle managers, to the staff opportunity.”
articulate its strategic direction. The TSE doing the heavy lifting. When I was visit-
used the investor feedback to refine some ing our processing centre in Bournemouth Going Forward
of its practices.” recently, the STP initiative was part of our But what of the future for JPMorgan?
review. It was an absolute pleasure to hear Mr Shah rounds up JPMorgan's approach
Technology & STP affect on business the passion of our ops managers as they to 2007. “JPMorgan has aggressive growth
For any business partnership to work effi- discussed how they were going to achieve targets for our 2007 global custody business.
ciently on a day-to-day basis, you have to the last remaining percentage points.” Much of our success will come
secure an efficient platform and frame- Having been invited down to the from our tight integration of other securi-
work for doing business. “Investment in Bournemouth centre during a press day, ties services, not just custody. JPMorgan
technology is crucial to support the two the drive was clear to see, STP is of utmost offers an unparalleled range of products
biggest growth areas in the business,” importance. “Straight-through processing and services for our clients such as fund
states Mr Shah. First, securities services is an area where JPMorgan’s industry accounting and administration, compliance
providers have to make significant invest- knowledge, experience and customer serv- reporting, performance measurement,
ment to support and automate the servic- ice play a key role. We have dedicated securities lending, foreign exchange, and
ing and reporting for alternative invest- teams who actively work with our clients short-term cash investments. This requires
ments. Second, as emerging markets’ to improve their STP rates. This includes staff with industry expertise and a
structure and regulation evolve and as addressing client behaviour, industry stan- significant technology budget to invest in
investor confidence in new instruments dards and our own systems and processes. the automation that will deliver these
grow, custodians will need to update their We work consultatively to help them services with consistent high quality to
technology to accommodate these market understand the impacts of adjusting their our clients. Because we are part of a
needs.” internal procedures. We quantify where diverse financial services firm that already
JPMorgan is also in effect outsourcing its transactions break down with root cause has the expertise in these areas, where
expertise to other areas as Mr Shah analysis, and we collectively analyze the appropriate we work with or look to hire
explains. “JPMorgan also leads in its com- issues from both sides. One client, a lead- staff from these other lines of business. A
mitment to developing global technology ing global fund manager, actually used our client’s choice to outsource does not just
industry standards that facilitate straight- model to drive their other custodians to present us with an opportunity to deliver a
through processing. Yawar Shah, improve their STP rates.” valuable service; it also allows us to get
JPMorgan’s Global Operations Executive closer to our clients and better understand
for JPMorgan Worldwide Securities Custody Growth & Growing Markets their needs.” If Mr Shah is correct,
Services is now chairman of SWIFT. “A second driver of growth for JPMorgan then JPMorgan will be setting the standards
JPMorgan sits on all major SWIFT com- will be our new state-of-the-art product for 2007.
ISJ Panel
Debate
Transfer
agency Ray Pepper
Mellon
Alec Hoffman
Etheios
Karine De Bondt
RBC Dexia
Paul O’Neil
State Street
Transformation?
Our panel of expert
transfer agents
debates technology
platforms...
Etienne Carmon David White Bill Hookings Pete Hudson
Caceis MFT Bravura Linedata
Bill Hookings, Head of Product Development (Rufus GTA), Bravura Ray Pepper, Managing Director, Transfer Agency, Mellon. With over
Solutions. Mr Hookings has over 32 years of experience in the IT 26 years experience within the Third-Party Administration industry,
industry. He was responsible for Rufus development from its inception Mr Pepper is responsible for managing the Transfer Agency business
in 1991 until 1996, and subsequently for establishing the Product in UK and Pune, India. He sits on the IMA Investment Fund
Development Group. He is now responsible for defining the future Operations Committee and is a founder member of the TPA Forum.
direction of the Rufus system.
Karine De Bondt is Head of Product Management-Shareholder
Etienne Carmon, Head of International Product Development, Services within RBC Dexia Investor Services Bank. Ms De Bondt
CACEIS. Mr Carmon joined CACEIS as Senior Product Manager for joined Dexia Fund Services in January 2005. In a her last position, she
the TA business in September 2005 and now heads International was in charge of the development and implementation of Vestima,
Product Development. He has previously held roles at EFA, Chase Clearstream’s order routing product.
Manhattan Bank and First European Transfer Agent.
Alec Hoffman, Associate Director, heading the Retail Fund Services Paul O’Neil, Senior Vice President, Head of European Shareholder
Practice, Etheios. Mr Hoffman has worked in the financial services Services, State Street Bank. Luxembourg S.A. Mr O’Neil assumed his
industry for fifteen years with spells in treasury, international banking current role in January, 2006. Based in Luxembourg, he is responsi-
and, for the past three years, in investment management systems. He ble for State Street’s European Shareholder Services (Transfer
has been involved in the preparation of a request for proposal (RFP) for Agency) business, which has operations in Luxembourg and Ireland.
a major provider of third party fund administration services. He has twenty five years of financial service experience primarily in
administration services with Boston Financial Data Services (BFDS).
Pete Hudson, Linedata Services, Head of Product Marketing UK.
Mr Hudson has responsibility for Product Strategy, Marketing David White, Client Services Director, Mutual Fund Technologies.
Communications and Customer Documentation. Over the past 20 Mr White joined the company from Aberdeen Asset Management
years, Pete has worked in a variety of roles for numerous software ven- PLC where he was head of Wholesale Marketing for UK and Europe.
dors within the Financial Services industry, including Misys and Prior to this he worked for Schroders PLC in the UK.
Thomson Financial.
Comment on the latest developments to brings less clarity and for MIFID, the TA efforts are to be made to implement best
affect the transfer agency industry in the industry remains unsure as to its effect on its practices.
past year. business. While RBC Dexia implemented the new ISO
As open architecture drives sales and trans- 20022 standards in 2005, we see that the take-
Hookings: There are four main areas of action volumes, Transfer Agents remain up is quite slow and that the number of coun-
development that could potentially impact focused on raising the STP rate and reducing terparties ready to communicate using such
the TA industry; Hedge Funds Regulation, the cost per transaction. norm are limited. Efforts need to increase in
Automation, Standardisation and Asia. Lately, there has been a shift in the type of this field, because as long as they are not wide-
With regard to regulation, 2006 has seen a product the Transfer Agent is required to han- ly adopted, the market will only extract limit-
number of small regulatory changes; though dle. Until recently, traditional “plain vanilla” ed benefits from these initiatives that are vital
none of which compare with the effort mutual funds were the norm, but in the last for the industry.
required to implement EUSD. MiFID still year the TA has been required to deal with an In parallel, fund promoters explore new
appears to have a minor effect on TA. increasing number of more exotic vehicles countries of distribution where the level of
We are beginning to see Hedge Funds inte- such as Hedge, Private Equity and Real Estate maturity can be variable and hence require
grating with the mainstream TA world; there funds, all of which have specialised transac- specific processes on the part of the transfer
is now a need to support larger investor bases tion processing requirements. agents. On the product side, an increasing
and to provide connection to Swift and other number of new complex funds are launched
STP hubs. Pepper: 2006 was a year of tremendous that call for specific functionality. It is typical-
Asia is also growing in importance; for cross change with a number of underlying themes ly the case for hedge funds or SICARs for
border funds based in Europe, the need for driving an evolution of the TA industry. example.
the capability to provide support to distribu- Straight through processing was a major talk-
tors based in Asia has become a priority. This ing point as transfer agency is still heavily Hoffman: Within the UK we have seen a rush
includes communicating with distributors in reliant on manual processes. We have seen to implement new wrap platforms while
their own language and time zone; it also much more industry collaboration this year existing fund supermarkets have continued to
extends to vetting, scanning and inputting and this is resulting in a push for standardisa- attract more investors. Consequently, UK TA
applications locally to increase accuracy and tion. Between the TAs and Fund providers have seen funds under administra-
timeliness. As a result the tier 1 TA’s are creat- Supermarkets, agreement has been reached to tion increase but the number of accounts and
ing local service centres to support this activ- adopt ISO messaging standards, and opera- transactions decrease (due to aggregation).
ity on behalf of their fund manager clients. tional focus has been on simplifying settle- This trend is likely to continue as more plat-
ment, potentially through a greater use of form providers come online.
O’Neil: Number one is managing growth, Crest and BACs. Adoption of STP has become standard. The
particularly in the main offshore centres in The year also saw an increase in consolida- fund processing principles published by the
Luxembourg and Ireland. The industry is tion, for example significant re-registration Investment Managers Association (IMA) at
heading for a second consecutive year of 30% campaigns by Fund Supermarkets resulting in the beginning of 2006 have laid down high-
growth in terms of fund values and even more aggregation. 2006 also saw an increase level guidelines on straight-through process-
greater in terms of transaction volumes, with in the sale of Structured Products as well as ing and efficiency objectives for the industry.
strong growth from Asia in particular.
Further consolidation of third party-distri- “Growth was set against a backdrop of
bution has meant we are spending an increas-
ing part of our time servicing the distributor continued regulatory change with MiFID
rather than the end investor in the retail sec-
tor. Also, institutional investors are investing
being a key item on everyone’s agenda.”
strongly into collective schemes. Platforms, the first tranches of Revenue allocated The acquisition of EMXCo by Euroclear may
fund supermarkets and the ‘wrap debate’ are accounts for Children’s Trust Funds, increas- eventually deliver the promise of integrated
all encouraging a trend towards fewer share- ing the scale in both these products types. order and settlement processing on an indus-
holder accounts on the register but more This growth was set against a backdrop of try standard platform. The ISO20022 stan-
transactions. continued regulatory change with MiFID dard for STP fund processing has started to
During 2006 we have seen an increased being a key item on everyone’s agenda, along make some impact but most large distributors
number of distributors participating in STP with continued AML legislation and COLL and TA providers have invested heavily in
initiatives reducing costs and delivering serv- conversions as well as the recent ISA reforms. trading via EMX and change is unlikely
ice benefits. Encouragingly, KYC/AML issues overnight.
are settling down although they still take time De Bondt: Developments in several areas In the cross-border European market
and carry considerable risk. have impacted and continue to impact the we have seen the growth of alternative funds,
transfer agency industry: these range from in particular hedge funds and funds of hedge
Carmon: Many factors continue to exert a changes in the regulatory framework, like the funds. As a result, there have been a
significant influence on the industry. A con- implementation of EUSD and MiFID, to number of acquisitions by major third party
stantly evolving regulatory environment in industry initiatives sponsored by bodies like administrators of hedge fund administrators
Europe forces the Transfer Agent to be nimble EFAMA or the FPSG. While the objective of and systems.
enough in terms of systems and business these initiatives is to evolve toward more stan-
structure to adapt and take advantage of dardization in Europe, we see that in practice, Hudson: The three areas where Linedata
changes. However, regulation complexity, the market is moving slowly and that more Services has seen the most demand are in
INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL 47
PANEL DEBATE - TRANSFER AGENCY
automation, regulation and asset coverage. general agreement to focus on standard mes- up to now, distributors were the senders and
The call for more automation has, in part, saging formats, with ISO being the preferred receivers of messages; the fund managers and
been driven by the ever increasing rise in route, and discussion with Crest and EMX fun promoters now enter the game as well.
transaction volumes, the need to automate who have now partnered up and exploration In addition to the reporting activity, where
complex fee calculations (including trailing into the use of BACs. The collaboration new templates need to be developed to cover
fees and performance fees) and the require- between different providers is very refreshing activities like trailers fees, for example, an
ment to integrate with external auto-dealing and demonstrates that the industry is deter- important area of development concerns the
systems such as EMX, FundSettle and mined to reduce the industry costs and risks provision of standardised standing data.
Vestima. as margins continue to get tighter. Initiatives are also ongoing in this field.
Changes in regulation have mainly touched
the European Transfer Agency industry, Hoffman: We are likely to see a continuing White: Our research indicates that there are
which has been affected by the likes of UCITS adoption of the ISO20022 standard for funds. two key areas of standardisation that will fea-
III, MiFID and COLL. The standard is being used by SWIFT, who are ture in TA in 2007: Firstly, improved business
The increase in KYC (Know Your Customer) pushing hard for its use among transfer continuity planning and execution to ensure
requirements have been highlighted even agents and platform providers in the UK. The that technology and infrastructure support-
more, especially when viewed in a legal con- standard has recently been updated to cater ing TA can recover quickly and consistently, in
text. for UK requirements such as ISA transfers. the event of a business continuity situation;
The variety of alternative funds now in use The recent acquisition of EMXCo by and secondly the requirement to deliver more
requires increased international knowledge, Euroclear should accelerate the take up of real-time, or near real time reporting, by
as well as a requirement to have integrated ISO20022 within the industry. It is likely that whichever medium the customer requests.
solutions that are truly cross-border and can Euroclear will enable use of the standard over
handle all aspects of their business. the EMX platform, providing backward com- Hookings: 2005 was the year when a consen-
patibility with the existing FIX standard cur- sus arose surrounding the need for standardi-
White: From a technology standpoint, there rently employed by EMX. zation and automation across Europe for the
are three key areas that spring to mind: In Europe, there is already significant adop- TA industry. 2006 has largely been a year of
agreeing on priorities, as well as how to move
“The variety of alternative funds requires forward.
We believe that 2007 will be the year in
increased international knowledge, as well as which we will see significant implementations
integrated solutions that are truly cross-border.” delivering automation based on ISO20022
standards. This still has a focus on order
1. The increasing significance of Platforms – tion of the old ISO15022 standard and we placement, however, and is not a full DVP
the popularity of fund supermarket and wrap would expect to see significant take up and type solution. The acquisition of EMX by
platforms has grown significantly during migration to ISO20022. The two major fund Euroclear opens the opportunity for proper
2006. The top four players in then UK alone trading and settlement platforms (FundSettle linkage of order placement and settlement to
now account for over £25 billion of assets. and Vestima+) are already migrating to become a reality, at least for the UK market,
2. Straight Through Processing – SWIFT, ISO20022. and we look forward to understanding their
Vestima, Fundsettle and EMX have all been plans in this area.
very active in the marketplace, increasing Carmon: The new SWIFT xml ISO20022 for-
market share, culminating in Euroclear’s pur- mat is now in the test phase among many O’Neil: Arguably one of the main develop-
chase of EMXCo in December. industry players, and CACEIS is an active par- ments has been the acceptance by more mem-
3. Legislation and other industry initiatives ticipant in the “early adopters” group. SWIFT bers of the community, particularly distribu-
– AML, IBAN and SOX form just a part of the is genuinely furthering the standardisation tors, that standardization in transfer agency is
initiatives that have impacted the European cause for its “big player” affiliates in the indus- important. Through initiatives co-ordinated
mutual fund marketplace in 2006. The need try. However a problem arises with the small- by EFAMA and applied by the local trade
for technologies and software to keep pace er distributors such as IFAs that are ineligible associations such as ALFI, IFIA and IMA, we
with these legislative and compliance devel- for SWIFT membership. They are remain have seen meaningful improvements in the
opments is paramount and increases year on with their proprietary formats so true indus- STP rates for fund message processing.
year. try-wide standardisation looks to remain elu- SWIFT have been very active with their con-
sive, despite SWIFT’s efforts. tinued focus on new message types for funds
What are the likely new developments within and the client bases of both FundSettle
the creation of standards in the TA space for De Bondt: So far, standards have mainly (Euroclear) and Vestima (Clearstream) are
2007? addressed the issues relating to dealing with increasing. Also, the expanding role of plat-
the implementation of the order, status and forms such as AllFunds in Spain, is now help-
Pepper: The focus for 2007 is likely to be the confirmation messages. ing market efficiency after a few years where
need for more standardization of the process- Reporting has been tackled as well, with the the set-up costs seemed to be outweighing the
es surrounding trading, settlement and recon- availability of statements (both for transac- actual day to day benefits.
ciliation. The TPAs, fund supermarkets and tions and holdings). Next steps will cover cash Additionally, we have made great strides
fund managers are certainly actively progress- flow reports, which represents a challenge, as over the last 12 months in standardizing cash
ing these issues with regular steering meet- it introduces a new type of counterparty in processing. We have done this by enhancing
ings, coordinated by IMA. This has led to a the ISO 20022 communication chain. Indeed, our technology, working with SWIFT and our
48 INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL
Global Access with Pinpoint Accuracy
To fully maximise global opportunities you need to access global markets. Ensure you
can always reach new clients, distributors and markets by choosing EFA as your
Transfer Agency service provider.
EFA services more than 1850 funds marketed in 40 different countries by more than
1000 distributors. We provide in-depth local knowledge combined with state of
the art technology for the highest level of quality and connectivity.
paying agents and finally by encouraging dis- new entrants to become established, particu- dard hub systems such as EMX and Swift.
tributors and investors to pay more attention larly in the area of web technologies and Some of the open architecture players have
to payment references. front-end platforms. invested here, however still too many rely on
Investment in technology continues apace the fax machine. Others have found that
Hudson: From Linedata Services’ perspective, and only those that are able to continually automating this piece is relatively easy using
we expect the 2007 trends to be more of the invest in functionality to meet the needs of an STP package such as our Babel product.
same, with similar drivers to those in 2006, new products, distribution and operational The final area is that of re-registration.
thus providing continued standardisation in a methods will succeed. Bigger open architecture players have
number of areas. required significant numbers of people to
Regulation will still be an important factor, Hudson: Open architecture is an absolute carry out the labour intensive process of man-
particularly within the EU, and automation of requirement within modern Transfer Agency ually re-registering holdings from a client’s
workflows will again prove to be a decisive systems. own name to the open architecture nominee
requirement. This will particularly apply to Alongside common standards, such as XML, accounts. Although progress has been made,
there is still no agreement in the industry on
“Common standards are more important how to automate the process.
now than ever before. The implications are Pepper: The major impact of open architec-
ture arrangements is the need for
those of greater automation, workflow and platforms/systems to deliver data to each
reducing costs.” other in a form that can be readily interpret-
ed. As this is often not the case, most TAs have
established functions to intermediate and
how our customers undertake business with open architecture is essential for sharing and ensure any issues are ironed out. This is par-
their end-clients e.g. Client statements and distributing information between core trans- ticularly important as the size of individual
use of the internet to extend on-line services fer agency systems and those of outside man- nominee transactions is increasing and as the
and the move away from paper-based agers, distributors etc. The use of common UK charging structures for TA are commonly
transactions. standards is more important now than ever transaction based it can result in a much
Cross-border business will continue to before. The implications are those of greater higher risk profile for handling these trades.
flourish and there will be a significant automation, workflow and reducing costs. Specific areas of focus for the open architec-
increase in the variety of fund categories, The better the connectivity, the better the ture providers and TAs surround the need to
which will require a move towards standardi- end-customer experience, which is an impor- hold and account for client money with dif-
sation of processes. tant aspect of the transfer agency business, as ferent rounding methodologies for dealing
this seems to be becoming a key differentiator and commissions; the need to support differ-
Comment on the impact of open architecture between businesses / services. ent dealing and settlement processes e.g.
arrangements on the transfer agency systems. paper, telephone, fax, electronic; and, asset
De Bondt: More and more clients indeed reconciliation processes (interfaces or MI
Carmon: Open architecture in combination require global support for their business. reports). In particular the perennial problem
with cross-border fund distribution contin- The emergence of new markets or sophisticat- for any nominee holder to keep unit group-
ues to drive up the transactions volumes for ed distribution patterns poses the question of ings (1&2) synchronised.
TA, at the same time as raising the complex- the global presence of providers. Being able to
ity of the service required. Open architec- serve clients locally - be it for their local fund Hoffman: Some transfer agency systems have
ture requires the TA to interface with many ranges or for their internal funds being dis- already been enhanced to enable administra-
third parties which is nothing new, however, tributed locally - becomes more and more a tion of fund supermarkets i.e. providing
the type of third party is changing. requirement. aggregation functionality to buy units from
Traditionally, interfaces were with the fund It is therefore essential to have a TA platform external fund managers. This has been rela-
manager or a bank selling only one fund that is flexible and allows the provider to tively easy for providers as the investment
range, but today, new actors such as fund accommodate the needs of clients in several vehicles and instruments (mutual funds, ISAs
supermarkets, life assurance companies and jurisdictions. etc) are already catered for by the core TA sys-
IFAs are selling diverse fund ranges to many tem. However, as transfer agents enhance
investors, creating what is known as the spi- Hookings: There are three main areas where their service proposition to include adminis-
der web or spaghetti model. Interfacing with Open Architecture has influenced TA tration for wrap providers and other types of
these new, multi-fund range providers is a providers. The first has been the need for TA platform, there will be a requirement to
significant challenge for the TA, whose IT providers to be able to handle external funds administer other types of investment vehicles
systems must be flexible enough to link in and run sub-registers in these funds. The and instruments (e.g. pensions, onshore and
with those of the new additions to the distri- major systems, including our own Rufus GTA offshore investment bonds etc.).
bution chain. system, have been enhanced to support these Up to now, the approach for developing
funds, providing controls and audit trails to these “super” administration platforms has
White: The emergence of open architecture match individual client orders to aggregated been to bolt on to the core TA system other
has certainly accelerated consolidation deals placed with the external fund promoter. proven systems that specifically cater for the
amongst the established brands, whilst at the The second area relates to the electronic required investment type and vehicle. Where
same time opened up new opportunities for placement of the aggregated order using stan- required, aggregation engines and consolidat-
50 INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL
PANEL DEBATE - TRANSFER AGENCY
ed views and reporting have been developed tributors – commission, trailer fees, consoli- providing global solutions that TA providers
across systems to support the open architec- dated investor reporting for example deliv- have to overcome?
ture platforms. The challenge for these com- ered through online communication tools. De Bondt: On the technology side, the key
ponent based architectures is to provide the Open architecture has also continued to factor is of course the TA platform as a whole,
efficiency and scalability required to support encourage outsourcing as many traditional in- including all interfaces to the external world.
The main characteristics of such a platform
“Open architecture has also continued to have to be flexibility and adaptability to be
able to face diverging requirements for differ-
encourage outsourcing as many traditional ent markets. But technology is not the only
solution. Expertise and knowledge is even
in-house transffer agents struggle to adapt important. In that respect, being present
to change.” globally and able to call on resources in local
markets is also an asset of importance.
the new breed of distribution platforms. Due house transfer agents struggle to adapt to White: The critical challenges facing technol-
to cost and risk considerations, it is unlikely change. In the new world, they need to deal ogy providers who want to offer a ‘Global’
that we will see full replacement of the tradi- with many funds not just their own and this solution for the wide range of markets, both
tional TA systems currently employed by the sets new operational challenges. Furthermore, new and mature are:
large providers. their own funds are now distributed though 1. A substantial and diverse range of function-
many channels, not just their own network, ality – solutions need to be all-encompassing
O’Neil: This continues to grow dramatically again setting new administrative burdens that in order to meet the regulatory, legal and
and for most fund promoters is the dominant increase their technology spending and chase reporting needs of the promoters and distrib-
method of selling their investment products. often scarce human resources. utors in each market.
At State Street/IFDS we have developed inte- 2. Availability – any modern day global trans-
grated and sophisticated tools to service dis- What are the technological hurdles in fer agency system must provide round the
Bravura Solutions is a publicly listed and leading global supplier of world class
software, hosted solutions and professional services.
Having recently acquired the Rufus GTA software from the Bank of New York,
and Babel Integrator from AB Prodata, Bravura Solutions now offer one of the
most functionally rich platforms on the market today.
Adelaide | Brisbane | Melbourne | Sydney | Auckland | Wellington | Edinburgh | London | Luxembourg | Manchester | Hong Kong | Bangalore | Johannesburg
B3612
Edinburgh +44 162 544 6500 | London +44 208 439 9500 | Luxembourg +352 261 0621 | Manchester +44 162 544 6500
PANEL DEBATE - TRANSFER AGENCY
clock availability servicing multiple time- zones, allowing users to operate in other time time but the requirements are increasing at
zones and markets. zones, whilst the funds operate in their own the same rate and the need to introduce new
3. System Performance – it is paramount that domicile time zone. technologies is always present. In addition to
systems can deliver the necessary processing the technologies themselves, the cost of
power to service the peaks and troughs of a Hoffman: The roll-out of global solutions is labour remains a challenge and most if not all
global business. greatly affected by the local functionality large technology providers have turned to the
required for each domicile and the jurisdic- use of lower cost development centres.
O’Neil: At State Street/IFDS we have made tions of the investors in the funds. In terms of the specific complexities of
great strides in this area during the last year or From a technology point of view, a truly international TA systems, these include items
so and have installations where this is working global system would be hugely complicated such as the need for new product features,
very effectively for our clients. The idea of and difficult to implement and maintain. We support of multi-currency and support of dif-
supporting Asian, The Americas and are, however, starting to see single systems ferent time zones and geographies.
European investors locally in their own lan-
guage and time zone but having it integrated
into a single operating model is very much “Whilst the core of TA is broadly the same
alive today. The use of advanced shareholder
recordkeeping and workflow tools has
across the globe, every domicile has its own
allowed us to build networks and create settlementt requirements and mechanisms.”
processes to meet the increasingly global
nature of fund distribution. that cater for both administration in the UK
domestic and in cross-border distribution of In recent years, the TA industry has clearly
Hudson: The technological challenge is in funds. moved from traditional TA services to a pro-
providing global solutions to handle increas- The ideal scenario is a global TA provider liferation of more sophisticated services that
ing volumes of transactions, standardisation that provides local expertise and utilizes the have evolved in the market. What do you
of processes, the ability to be a truly multi-lin- efficiencies of global systems but only where consider the TA value-added services to be
gual, multi-currency system, and being able to appropriate to meet local market needs. and how do you foresee these added-value
manage local rules within a global system. services evolving in the future?
Given that the average TA will handle a vari- Carmon: The principal technological hurdle
ety of fund products in multiple jurisdictions, for TA providers lies in developing a single Carmon: The two principal added value serv-
the TA system solution needs to strike a fine platform for transaction purposes, which is ices for the TA are centralising services and
balance between flexibility and uniformity of an essential factor in the reduction of costs those that support clients’ cross-border distri-
approach. linked to IT maintenance and development. A bution aspirations. Centralising services (such
central TA system also ensures the scalability as CACEIS’ Prime TA service), route orders
Hookings: We need first to define the terms of the platform. It is easier to upgrade and through a single gateway, simplifying the
‘international’ and ‘global’. With regard to TA expand the capacities of one platform than transaction process for distributors. Cross-
we would define international to mean a sys- upgrade multiple platforms or establish new border distribution support services, (such as
tem that supports many domiciles, but that ones. CACEIS’ European TA service) address the
needs a separate instance for each domicile. Interfacing represents another major tech- issues of investor position recordkeeping, dis-
However, there are still hurdles to overcome nological hurdle. The TA needs to interact tribution network management and fee cal-
in order to achieve this. with all the various types of distributors as culation.
Whilst the core of TA is broadly the same well as participants such as Prime TAs. STP Centralising services will need to evolve to
across the globe, every domicile has its own interfaces with Prime TAs have become essen- handle the more complex alternative prod-
settlement requirements and mechanisms, tial, due to the pressures of working with ucts.
regulatory reporting and, in the retail market, Alternative Investments, where orders can be Cross-border distribution support services
tax efficient products. An international system placed, cancelled and replaced in very short in Luxembourg are already fairly advanced.
should ideally support multiple currencies, time periods. The majority of settlement is already cross-
but can possibly pass with only one currency Finally, providing remote access to core border, which means Luxembourg TAs are
per instance; premium systems provide applications and setting up web access for used to different countries’ settlement
multi-lingual screens and paper outputs. information or transactional purposes are processes. The growth in cross-border distri-
Bravura Solutions define a Global TA system further challenges that need to be overcome. bution and open architecture will force
as one where a single instance can support domestic-only TAs to broaden their horizons.
multiple domiciles; there are three significant Pepper: TA providers and fund managers
extra capabilities required to support this. always need to ensure that there is a sensible De Bondt: TAs need to be in a position to sup-
Firstly, the system must be fully multi-cur- business case to provide a return on the sig- port their clients in their distribution strategy,
rency, preferably with integrated FX process- nificant system investments required to sup- which requires specific services to be provid-
ing. Secondly to meet regulatory require- port new developments. Obviously this does ed.
ments, the system must fully support data at times require a leap of faith but we have They range from the handling of retroces-
segregation, permitting individual users / seen many examples in the industry of devel- sions and commissions to the provision of
service centres to only view and update infor- opments that have not come to fruition or specific reporting as well as global distribu-
mation for which they have authorisation. failed to deliver a return on investment. It is tion support.
Finally the system needs to handle time true that technologies do get cheaper over Reporting has always been considered as
52 INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL
Marble. Masterful.
Mellon can give you creative solutions that allow you to organise
www.mellon.com
part of the standard offering, however, access contain comprehensive data has resulted in distribution and the trend for life and pension
to information is key and generates value not the TA database being used by other depart- companies to use more OEIC based fund
only for fund clients but also for their own ments e.g. Fund Accounting, Sales and structures to underpin their products, TA
clients, whether they are institutional or retail. Marketing. service providers must move into other
New technology allows providers to grant The increase in sophistication in the administration areas to attract new clients
easy and user-friendly access to information. approach of TA’s to investor relations has and retain their existing ones.
While standardisation if, of course, a must, it resulted in them being the customer-facing
cannot be to the detriment of flexibility. department within investment management Pepper: Of course TAs are expected to get the
firms. More on-line services are now available basic services right and therefore value added
White: Added value functionality’ seems to to distributors and investors and consequent- services are often seen as a key differentiator.
be the watchword for offering a complete ly more efficient management information. Increasingly TAs are being asked to provide
client service. No longer can mainstream The future of the TA industry is largely consultation on product design features and
administrators simply offer traditional dependent on technology and there is already distribution. We are seeing the need to help
record-keeping services. Clearly the more the ability to view details of investments and clients with STP solutions and lobby on their
niche players are focusing on offering a pre- portfolios on-line, at any time of the day or behalf for standardization and regulatory
mium service to their institutional and high night and from anywhere in the world. change. TAs have also introduced new servic-
net worth clients by offering more seamless es such as technical services e.g. Web creation
support for both classic and alternative prod- O’Neil: There is no doubt that this trend is and extended services to include things such
as support of fulfillment and distribution.
We have also seen the emergence of new
“The massive range of product and service services such as dedicated support for institu-
selections required across our client base tions/platforms - separate telephone lines and
dedicated contact names to establish working
and the markett as a whole cannot be relationship with the institution and delivery
of bespoke reports and MI, electronic con-
underestimated.” tract notes etc.
uct ranges. As more and more business is fully part of our industry and when we look to Discuss outsourcing and strategic partner-
being processed via STP, the requirement to the evolution of transfer agency servicing, it ships within the TA world.
offer a multitude of B2B services is now a pre- has been a complete revolution in the past ten
requisite and critically the move to real-time years. Indeed the original services of dealing De Bondt: There is indeed a trend going into
activity requires providers to offer all forms of and registration are almost taken for granted this direction which results from market evo-
confirmation back to the end broker and/or these days. For the leading transfer agents, lution, where pressure on costs and margins
customer ‘as it happens’. others services such as commission and fee are an incentive to consider outsourcing as an
processing, multi lingual and multi-currency alternative. The increasing complexity of new
Hookings: TA services are continually evolv- processing, call centres, automated workflow products, combined with new distribution
ing; what is accepted as traditional today tools, online reporting, service centres across markets, is also an element that plays a role in
includes services that only a few years ago the globe, are almost taken for granted. The the decision.
would have been viewed as value added. In massive range of product and service selec-
years past, a European TA’s main responsibil- tions required across our client base and the Hudson: As the variety of fund products and
ity was to maintain the fund register; today all market as a whole cannot be underestimated. the need for automation increases, both out-
major TAs would regard servicing the distrib- The functionality of our systems and the sourcing and strategic partnerships have
utor as one of their key responsibilities. experience of our people must keep pace, become extremely important within the TA
There are still a number of services to dis- requiring increasing capital investment and world. By aligning itself with the ‘expert’, the
tributors that are considered value added; a steadfast commitment. TA is given immediate access to the specific
key area is the calculation of management fee industry knowledge of the partner.
rebates (retrocessions). This still causes some Hoffman: The types of added-value provided Undoubtedly, the trend over the past 5-10
TA issues. Today, there is an extraordinary by TA service providers include call centres, years has been to outsource the TA side of the
number of methods fund promoters can web- enabled dealing and account servicing business, however, smaller companies in par-
invest to calculate the retrocession. for investors and distributors, fund supermar- ticular are no longer content with getting sec-
Connections to the various STP hubs have ket functionality and catering for other types ond best service from outsourcers who give
still not been implemented by all TA’s. of product such as DC pensions, child trust priority to their larger clients. These compa-
For the fund promoter, provision of funds and wealth management functions. nies are looking at bringing their systems back
flexible management information is often a TA providers will continue to enhance and in house to some extent. Moving the TA busi-
key requirement and the leaders in this field deliver web-based applications, either as ness to an Application Service Provider (ASP)
not only provide a comprehensive set of direct portals into their clients’ products or may be a potential alternative for many of the
canned reports and enquiries, but also offer a white-labeled open architecture platforms smaller firms who are looking to bring the
user friendly business intelligence tool to that support a variety of product types and expertise back in-house, but without the IT
allow the promoter to produce reports on providers. STP will play a major part in this overheads and running costs.
demand. offering.
Hudson: The need for modern TA systems to With the proliferation of platform-based Hookings: For some years, fund managers
have recognized that developing their own TA Pepper: Within the industry we talk a lot into the Asian or the Eastern European
systems requires continual investment; there- about partnerships and this is certainly what regions have established local call centres for
fore they have either outsourced their entire all TAs should aspire to have as TA services servicing clients from those regions. Local
administration to specialist Third Party can not longer be simply considered a com- call centres are well positioned to handle geo-
Administrators, or purchased packaged TA modity. graphically-close clients due to the availability
systems to support their in-house operations. Whilst all fund providers are different the of labour with the language skills required
Recently the TA world has become more key is to find a balance between the need for a and for Asia, similar time zones.
complicated; increasingly fund managers are low cost, generic and efficient service against In terms of partnerships, we are now seeing
looking for a single solution to support mul- the need to design more costly processes that TA’s persuaded to outsource parts of their
tiple domiciles across the globe. Pan are bespoke to give clients value added bene- business in return for client introductions in
European regulation, direct access to distribu- fits. It is certainly true that TA is a scale busi- the Asian or Eastern European markets. This
tors and IFAs, the Internet and STP hubs such ness as margins are low and it is necessary to “partnership” model looks to be a growth area
as Swift, EMX and NSCC have added to the ensure that volumes are as high as possible to in the future, making the outsourcing easier
complexity. justify IT development and operational effort. to swallow for the TA, by tempting them with
Progressively more, fund managers and the In the same way that asset managers out- new business in markets they are keen to pen-
specialist Third Party Administrators are source their TA as it's not their core compe- etrate.
looking to partner with international software tence, so too TAs outsource certain processing
solution providers (such as Bravura for exactly the same reason. For example, In 2007 what do you see as the main chal-
Solutions) who are committed to providing statement printing and mailing is usually best lenges and opportunities in transfer agency?
comprehensive global functionality into the outsourced, by the TA, to a dedicated bulk
long term. Further, the infrastructure printing organisation. Literature fulfilment is White: For 2007, I see the opportunities as
required to support the electronic distribu- another example of this. The important point being:
tion channels has led to an increased demand is that the TA manages all of these relation- 1. Continued growth of the Fund
for a hosted ASP style solution which can be ships with the other parties, so the asset man- Supermarket/Wrap model – platform busi-
shared across multiple Transfer Agents. ager need not concern themselves. nesses, such as FundsNetwork will increasing-
ly dominate the retail fund space becoming
Hoffman: In the UK, outsourcing of the TA O’Neil: Transfer agency lagged behind its the ‘Tesco’s’ of their generation.
function is almost universal. As the TA func- administrative siblings of custody and fund 2. Alternative investment markets becoming
tion itself becomes more detached from the accounting in terms of outsourcing in recent more mainstream. As the market for hedge
end investor, an in-house TA operation years but is beginning to pick up speed. There fund and structured products matures, so will
becomes less attractive and fund managers are
generally happy to offload their essentially
fixed cost TA operation to an outsource part- “Transfer agency is the most client sensitive
ner.
As the basic TA function becomes more
administrative service. When a fund promoter
commoditized, fund managers are more fre- entrustss you with looking after ‘their clients’,
quently looking for a “one stop shop” for all of
their asset servicing needs (custody, fund you must think ‘partnership’.”
accounting TA, investment operations etc)
rather than a best of breed TA provider who is a diminishing gap and the number of fund the increase in consolidation within the world
may not be able to fulfill the whole asset serv- promoters doing their own transfer agency of transfer agency as clients look for a one-
icing function. Where TA providers do not processing is declining. stop shop solution covering traditional and
have a one-stop shop facility, they tend to We have seen some very close partnerships alternative product ranges.
offer something similar though strategic develop between fund promoters and their 3. New markets – with the expansion of the
alliances (e.g. Capita using BNY for custody). transfer agents. We still believe that transfer EU and the explosive growth in India and
In Luxembourg and Dublin, outsourcing of agency is the most client sensitive administra- China there will be many new opportunities
the TA function is less common. This is not tive service and when a fund promoter and challenges for transfer agents from the
surprising since the range of services provid- entrusts you with looking after ‘their clients’, distributors and fund promoters who operate
ed tends to be more specialized and geared you must think ‘partnership’. The ability to in these new jurisdictions.
towards the specific distribution model of provide flexible service models, seamlessly
each fund. However, the growth in out- integrated into the client’s own business, has Pepper: The major message is the need for
sourced TA is growing rapidly in the two cen- been the key to growth. We continue to evolve continued change, continued standardisation
tres, driven by a desire to lower costs and by the model as it is critical to our client’s success. and continued investment. We are likely to
managers wanting to bring increasingly spe- see further consolidation with providers play-
cialized products to market as quickly as pos- Carmon: With no shortage of technically ing to their strengths. Price pressures are an
sible (and not wanting to build the capability qualified personnel and a significantly lower important factor for all TA businesses
in-house). Partnerships are also common in labour cost than their European counterparts, whether it is in the manufacturing, distribu-
these centres with, for instance, large US play- Asian countries have seen certain labour tion or administration space.
ers wanting to enter the market and teaming intensive parts of European and US TA busi- We will see activity resulting from regulato-
up with established market specialists. nesses successfully outsourced to them. ry change particularly MiFID and the ISA
Companies looking to expand their business reforms and we will continue to see new and
INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL 55
PANEL DEBATE - TRANSFER AGENCY
innovative products and fund structures. In are not on the radar for clients wishing to opportunity for existing systems in the mar-
summary it is a very exciting and challenging outsource or change provider. Other ket to evolve to meet these requirements.
time for the Transfer Agency industry. providers should gear up their sales and
marketing accordingly! O’Neil: The clear challenge is to continue to
Hookings: As previously mentioned, there PEPs and ISA rules are changing in the next support the growth of the industry and our
have been four areas of development in year and this will involve considerable sys- clients. We must continue to invest in tech-
2006; hedge funds, MIFID, Automation tems and operational changes for UK TAs nology, improving efficiency and reducing
and Standardisation and Asia. We see 2007 as with the cost burden falling on providers risk. However, there is also the labour short-
a year when solutions in these areas are under existing maintenance agreements. age in markets such as Luxembourg and
implemented. In Dublin and Luxembourg, further con- Ireland. We need to use human resources in
If we want to see a step change in the cost solidation in the TA space is very likely, in a other markets, to react more quickly to
of providing a TA service to fund promoters, market that is much more fragmented than clients and achieve economies of scale
through regional processing.
Product complexity will certainly be an issue The merging of mainstream and alternative
products will continue to be a challenge to
to deal with for the next few years. support the special features hedge funds, pri-
vate equity funds and real estate funds.
Product complexity will certainly be an issue
we must implement the Automation and the UK. Continuing growth in the cross-bor- to deal with for the next few years.
Standardisation solutions we have designed der market fuelled by retirement needs, the Regulation will also still be a challenge with
in 2006. There is still a significant amount of European fund passport and a growth in MIFID on the horizon and we are also
work required to make this a reality, not just alternative funds will ensure continuing watching the development of the order
in systems development, but also in working opportunities for providers. However, a routers, platforms and fund supermarkets as
with the distributors to get their support to desire for more cost-effective distribution of our clients need to support increasingly
utilise the solutions available. funds will result in the need for efficiencies complex distribution channels. Overall,
From a systems providers’ point of view, of scale and will lead to consolidation. however, we are optimistic about our
Asia is a rapidly growing market for which European transfer agency services and our
significant opportunities exist for systems De Bondt: The changes in the regulatory ability to support clients through these
that provide both flexibility, and the robust framework represent a major challenge changing market dynamics in a time of
management controls European systems together with the evolution of distribution unprecedented growth.
have developed in recent years. patterns as well as the emergence of new and
A system that can support UK, complex products. In order to be successful,
Luxembourg, Ireland and the major Asian providers will need to integrate all those
fund domiciles can be described as interna- changes but also increasingly focus on client
tional. If it can also provide full multi-cur- services and satisfaction. The day when the
rency, data segregation and time zone pro- role of the transfer agent was to process
cessing, it is well on the way to being a truly orders and carry out reconciliations are
global system. behind us. Providers need to be innovative,
both from a products and services point of
Hoffman: In the UK, TA providers must view, but also from a technology perspective
expend every effort to explore new opportu- and put client service on top of their
nities in a market that is veering towards priority list.
open architecture and platform-based distri-
bution. Hudson: The main challenges will be:
Undoubtedly, we will see further consoli- -Increase in the volume and complexity
dation in the UK TA provider market. The of trades
recent announcement that The Bank of New -Increase in regulation, especially within
York is to acquire Mellon will create a new the EU
“super” TA provider that will overtake IFDS -Standardisation of processes within an
as the largest in the UK. Although there are ever-expanding global fund marketplace
many challenges involved in merging the two Which will create opportunities such as:
TA operations (not least the rationalization -A decrease in operational costs
of a large number of administration loca- -Improved investor servicing
tions), the new provider will have a scale not -Comprehensive management information
seen before, which may trigger further con- Other changes in the market will see more
solidation involving smaller providers like deals going through fund supermarkets or
Capita, Northern Trust and BNP Paribas. wrap providers, and alternatives to current
The potential fallout of the BNY acquisition fund supermarket providers may also start to
may be several existing BNY or Mellon appear. We may also see more specialists in
clients looking for another provider or a alternative funds, which may lead to diversi-
period of time where both BNY or Mellon fication of the TA market. This provides an
Go forward. 8JUIDPOGJEFODF
8JUIVONBUDIFETPMVUJPOT
8JUIJOTQJSFEUIJOLJOH
8JUIMFBEJOHFEHFUFDIOPMPHZ
8JUIBUFBNPGFYQFSUT
TFDPOEUPOPOF7JTJUVTBU
XXXDJCDNFMMPODPN
(P
The Neo-
Conquistadors
As Spanish firms
expand abroad, can
Spain attract
enough foreign
investment
to remain a vibrant
onomy?
eco
Europe if it did not start improving incen- hire a worker in Spain than it is in the ment. Domestic confidence depends on
tives for foreign investment and private- OECD and twice as difficult to fire them growth, which will maintain a positive
sector research. It is perhaps the lack of (proving that it is always easier to get fired path.”
research and development that is than hired). On top of these difficulties it
dissuading not only foreign companies to can take an executive from a non-EU FRAGMENTATION MYTH DISPELLED
invest in Spain, but also persuading country over a year just to get a work per- Another area that Spain seems to be
Spanish companies to move out of the mit. All these factors combine to push doing well is de-fragmentising the finan-
country. Domestic R&D spending reached both the back and the front office out of cial industry. A common complaint has
EUR10 bn for the first time, but this is Spain and into more financially advanta- been the industry has been fragmented,
only 1.1 per cent of gross domestic geous arenas. Does this expansion show with a number of smaller institutions
product, whilst the European average for that Spanish companies have little faith in vying for power but lacking resources and
R&D is 1.9 per cent. In monetary figures, their country of origin? In the current eco- the know-how to compete on a Pan-
the drop in direct foreign investment has nomic climate, moving parts of your port- European and global level. After joining
been quite dramatic, with a fall from folio abroad is not seen as a lack of faith, the European Union in 1986, Spain opted
EUR38.2 bn in 2000 to EUR16.6 bn in but simply common sense because the for an extremely open policy regarding
2005. Statistics from World Bank also effects of an economic downturn will not competition, with little protection for ail-
paint a pretty black picture for any future be as far reaching if you put all your eggs ing businesses. This in turn has developed
investor. If you want to start up a business in one basket. Another incentive to invest a strong survival streak for Spanish com-
panies; either make it or you don’t. As two
The biggest problem is that of employing heads are better than one, it made sense to
consolidate. Iberclear, the Spanish Central
a workforce. Securities Depository, is a prime example
of recent positive integration as Soledad
in Spain, it takes 10 procedures and 47 overseas is that the tax system in Spain Lecube, Head of Coverage Financial
days. Compare this to the Organisation for aids investment abroad because goodwill Intermediaries, BNP Paribas states,
Economic Co-operation and acquired through foreign takeovers is tax- “Historically there has been two relevant
Development average that comes in at 6.2 deductible. Yet it’s not all doom and gloom platforms, one for fixed income linked
procedures and only 16.6 days. If you for foreign investment as Santander’s with the Bank of Spain, and the equities
wanted to set up an efficient and Research and Public Policy Department platform for settlement. These two plat-
competitive office in Spain, this time states, “There is no lack of foreign invest- forms have been integrated under one
frame may pose something of a problem ment into Spain. Spain is still receiving roof [Iberclear]. Iberclear has increased its
in a highly competitive market. However close to 2 per cent of GDP in FDI and, organisation over the past three or four
the biggest problem is that of employing a although competition from other destina- years and is now working far more effi-
workforce in Spain. According to World tions is increasing, we have important fac- ciently. Initiatives to integrate both plat-
Bank figures it is three times as difficult to tors to continue attracting foreign invest- forms is definitely the way that transac-
Credit Institutions’ Distribution of Foreign Assets by Geographic Areas, 2003 and 2005 (in percent)
tions need to be done and this has been in London, in order to trade shares
accomplished through SUC (Single efficiently, essentially creating a pre-cursor Number of financial institutions
Matching Model). Integration has also to MiFID.
been achieved for equities and the next
step is fixed income, due to be completed SHOULD THE BME BE WORRIE ABOUT
in February. The harmonisation of equi- MIFID?
ties and fixed income in the Spanish mar- With the exception of challenging
ket through a single window using the exchanges on trading activities, banks that
Swift Standard is nearly complete. The internalise their trades are no longer
next step will be to integrate both plat- expected to pass the trade information
forms from a systems point of view.” This onto the exchange. For example, Spanish
positive and affirmative platform should banks will have the option to publish the
serve the Spanish financial industry well in data through the Multilateral Trading
the coming years. Facility or a data vendor instead of the
BME or The Market for Financial Futures
REGULATION? and Options (MEFF) if they so wish.
Regarding regulation, Spain and MiFID Although exchanges are expected to has began to develop a common risk man-
seem not to be the best of bedfellows. remain the main source of liquidity, espe- agement tool in order to facilitate cost shar-
“Spain has been one of the first countries cially for equity shares, this greater trans- ing of Basel II implementation amongst its
to voice that we will not be compliant for parency of exchange cost will lead to members. In the end, CECA’s selection
the initial deadline of MiFID implementa- greater competition. Exchanges that are process led to 17 of the institutions opting
tion,” states Juan Briz, Head of Corporate seen to charge excessive fees could quickly for the acquisition of Sungard’s Bancware.
Communications for Securities Services in lose their market share unless the cost bal- Another problem, and one that is imme-
Spain for BNP Paribas. Spain’s retail finan- ance is readdressed. However according to diately noticeable but often overlooked, is
cial services market has shown it is active- Mr Briz, the BME understands that MiFID that of language. English is undoubtedly the
ly preparing for MiFID by teaming up is going to dramatically change the finan- language of business, yet according to many
with the UK Securities & Investment cial landscape and are launching a number in the industry Spain seems to lag behind
Institute (SII) in the development of a new of initiatives to improve their business compared to France and Germany in
qualification; The International Certificate position. Interestingly, no Spanish banks regards to the number of English speakers
in Financial Advice (ICFA) will be seem willing to join Project Turquoise, the in managerial positions. The positive aspect
launched on the 16th October of this year. trading platform backed by seven large is that action is being done. The Bank of
But in the institutional side, Spanish regu- investment banks. Spain is already making significant efforts
lators seem to want to control MiFID at Is this postponement of MiFID seen as a to improve the consistency between the
their own pace. According to Robert negative move within the industry? Spanish and English versions of their web
Nisbet of Gaesco, “Spain might be around According to Mr Briz “Postponing page and with the growth of Spanish acqui-
6 months late of MiFID, but at least it isn’t MiFID is not seen as something that is not sitions on English soil, things can only
as bad as other EU countries.” Indeed, var- going to damage the competitive position improve.
ious sectors of the Spanish market have a of the country. There is a strong concern It is hopeful that parallels will not be
lot on their plate due to MiFID states Mr from non-residential investors because the drawn between the prime ministers
Nisbet. The Spanish Stock exchange, Bolsa Financial Services Authority in the political implosion and Spain’s economic
de Madrid (BME) is worried about the UK is putting a lot of effort into MiFID situation. As Spain continues to conquer
lack of business that may occur due to the and they are surprised that our aboard, will there be enough investment
new legislation. In Portugal, when the operators in Spain are not moving as fast into Spain to balance fund this momentum,
national stock exchange joined the as the UK. However sometimes it is better or will the big banks simply outsource in
Euronext platform, brokers found it easier not to rush these things.” their entirety? Regarding regulation, whilst
Spain seems well set to take Basel II, there
are still many questions that need to be
Regarding regulation, Spain and MiFID answered before MiFID comes into place.
2007 should not only be an interesting year
seem not to be the best of bedfellows. for the prime minister, but also for the
Spanish economy.
to do business abroad. At the moment, it is Basel II seems to pose no problems for
expensive to trade Spanish stocks outside the larger financial institutions and the
of Spain. MiFID’s desire for transparency Bank of Spain seems well set to deal with
and cross-border efficiency by creating a the adoption of Basel II market risk
broader exchange network will stop this framework. In 2006 the central bank
nice little earner for the BME, something demanded that all Spanish banks improve
that the exchange will do its best to put off. their balance sheet management in order
Big banks in Spain are already making to comply with the new regulation frame-
their move, creating large pools of liquidi- work. As a result the Spanish
ty outside of Spain, most notably Confederation of Savings Banks (CECA)
www.santanderglobal.com
Excellen
lenc
ce, the art of
mastering demands
Brokerage, Custody, Fund Administration, Transfer Agency, Outsourcing and other dedicated services
Société Générale Securities Services, SGSS, provides a comprehensive portfolio of value-added financial services for investment
professionals: banks, financial institutions, asset managers and hedge funds. SGSS is committed to the ongoing pursuit of excellence
and increasingly personalized service within a technologically innovative environment.
www.sg-securities-services.com
Wider.
Closer.
Simpler.
This advertisement appears as a matter of record only and it should not be construed as an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities. These products may not be suitable for
every investor.
SECURITIES LENDING - AUCTION PLATFORMS
clear evidence that you can extract a premi- and proprietary trading clients satisfied. has forced top-quality lending programs to
um by providing a borrower with exclusive These firms can afford the exclusives. adapt to the changing needs of the market
access,” adds Chris Taylor, a senior manag- They also benefit second tier borrowers, through a stronger commitment to risk
ing director at State Street. “In fact, most firms which can’t get on the radar screens of management, technology and significant
investment in the infrastructure.
“Exclusives are a growing business Competition for business has forced the
traditional agent lender to enhance their
and here to stay,” service offering by adopting similar
approaches in their programmes, says Mark
auctions carried out using the auction plat- most of the biggest custodial lenders – State Fieldhouse. As auctions improve price dis-
forms are not in fact conducted as auctions Street, JP Morgan, Northern Trust, BGI, et covery and transparency, providing clients
but as sealed tenders with one or two al. Either credit is an issue, or the lenders with pricing reassurance is becoming a
rounds of bidding.” want them to maintain quite large mini- requirement. Traditional agents without the
“Auctions platforms are not of themselves mum borrowing balances in order to get an resources or the appetite to evolve with the
creators of value, so why drag someone else allocation of the more special stocks. The market will increasingly find themselves left
into the value chain,” asks Richard majority of the second tier firms don’t have behind. Who is really benefitting, the indus-
Thompson, head of product sales at BNP the sort of balance activity available to try or the customers? The client benefits, as
Paribas Securities Services. “We can offer them. Exclusives are a great way for them to they have yet another option available to
our clients a range of lending services such get access to a ready supply of hard to bor- them to meet their investment objectives
as agency, principal or combined pro- row stocks. and risk parameters. As the industry strives
gramme lending as well as auctions. But the Says Mark Fieldhouse Director of to become more transparent, the auction
truth is that not all portfolios are suitable Technical Sales at RBC Dexia: “Auction process adds to this by offering price dis-
for auction and if we don’t recommend an providers have injected more competition covery and transparency to the market, as
auction as a value proposition as part of our in the marketplace and overall, this is a pos- well as increasing the knowledge of the
normal client inter-action, we are not being itive thing for the industry as it strives to lender to make informed decisions.”
complacent: it’s because we don’t think become more transparent. We have seen an The use of auction platforms also raises
there is any value differential for the client evolution of securities lending over the past issues surrounding the risk profile of
over and above their existing arrange-
ments."
“Exclusives are a growing business and
“Auction providers have injected more
here to stay,” continues Bashful. competition in the marketplace and overall,
“The appetite from a dealer’s point of view
waxes and wanes depending on business this is a positivve thing for the industry as it
conditions, but the trend is generally
upwards. It’s simply a question of the slope
strives to become more transparent.”
of the increase. Demand for several years, as there are more available clients, in terms of counterparty and rev-
hedge fund business is increasing, so the routes to market to maximize lending enue. “In an exclusive all the borrowing is
need to have stocks available on exclusives is returns. The availability of multiple routes done by a given counterparty, which can
also increasing.”
The question of whether the business tak- Picking a Product
ing place on the auction platforms is incre- There are significant differences between the entirely different products and services, and were
mental business or simply many types of auction products being offered in created to serve entirely different customer bases
cannibalising new business depends on the market, says Chris Jaynes, President of so the threats they face are unique to each com-
whether the portfolio was already in a lend- eSecLending. The products themselves have pany,” Chris Jaynes continues. “The only item they
ing programme, he comments. “If so, then widely different degrees of sophistication and lev- really share in common is that they offer a differ-
there is no real new creation of els of service and support both pre and post the ent product than the traditional pooled agency
loans although the actual numbers auction. In addition the providers offering these lending process, which is the primary business
wouldn’t necessarily match one for one. products also have widely varying levels of experi- model used by custodial and third-party agents in
However, many exclusives are a ence, expertise, and commitment in managing the industry. While there are threats to any busi-
client’s first foray into securities lending as a auction processes. ness, these firms should continue to benefit from
whole, or into a new market. In that Three important factors for Beneficial Owners to industry trends as Beneficial Owners continuing to
case, the stocks most in demand will consider when differentiating between auction move away from a dependence on the traditional
actually increase the total amount on loan products and services are: The provider’s experi- pooled agency approach and increasingly utilising
without affecting anyone else’s balance.” ence, expertise and commitment to the auction exclusives, auctions and multiple routes to mar-
What impact are the auction platforms process; ket. The amount of business done through auc-
having? For lenders, it gives them another Provider independence & the potential for conflicts tions is significant and has been growing steadily
revenue generating opportunity to help of interest with existing pooled lending structures; for several years. eSecLending has auctioned well
keep their best clients (most attractive port- Levels of service and operational support both pre over $1 trillion in global equities and fixed income
folios). and post the auction process. securities since inception, with over $350 billion in
Top tier borrowers need a constant flow of “eSecLending, Equilend and SecfFinex offer 2006 alone.”
exclusives to keep their existing hedge fund
lead to concentration risk,” resumes lender is making a very simple choice here. In-side Negotiating
Bashful. “This can be looked at in several There is a risk that they lend out the port- One client, a senior trader at one of the UK’s top
ways. Lenders should have maximum folio in an exclusive that turns out to be less investment managers, gave his view, on the
exposure limits by borrower anyway. As than they could have received in normal condition that we guarantee anonymity. The
long as it is the maximum amount the bor- open market lending. They give up the outbreak of such shyness is slightly confusing,
rower can borrow, or is likely to borrow, it upside. The flip side is that they have a pre- but we agreed in the interests of hearing about
becomes a non-issue. Secondly, on many dictable revenue stream that is insulated the experience of a genuine end-user of auction
exclusives, the lenders bid out parcels sepa- from market events – in a quiet year they platforms and other ways to deliver exclusivity.
rately – by country or by region – rather may have earned less. Quiet years can “I use both eSeclending and SecFinex. I’ve done
than a total portfolio. Second best pricing occur as a result of general market activity 12 auctions so far, and my retro-analysis shows
can sometimes be awarded because the best being neutral or down, trading strategies that I haven’t yet lost out when comparing guar-
bidder is already doing too much business that are successful some years and not oth- anteed income with what I would have made in
with the lender, or has won other pieces of ers can have dramatic effects in the the market. In fact, I’m slightly ahead of the
portfolio. Another thing to look at is that demand for specific markets. It can occur game. That might be because we’re a tougher
realistically, the lender is always over-collat- as a result of people disinvesting from negotiator. I think we probably hold out for more
eralised so the only one with REAL expo- hedge funds, and so on.” than others do. eSeclending and SecFinex origi-
sure is the borrower. The lender has poten- The certainty of revenue that may be at a nally wanted 20-25% of the income we derived
tial exposure that will only become real premium to current market conditions from lending, but we pay nowhere near that. The
exposure in the event of a confluence of versus losing the upside in a very hot mar- first auction we did, with eSeclending, was
factors – the default of the borrower while ket is a topic that will surely continue to about 18%. With both, it is now down into single
figures. I also do exclusives off my own bat. I
“ There will always be room for an auction work out what I want beforehand, and I know
when auctions won’t deliver the money I want.
approach for the right client in the right “The main difference between the two, for me,
markets or assset classes. ” is that with SecFinex I must accept the highest
bid on offer, whether it meets my requirements or
not. With eseclending, I am not obliged to take
simultaneously having the portfolio of generate debate for the foreseeable future. the highest bid. We’ve also had a look at the new
stocks on loan versus the value of the col- There is an argument that with continuing facility being developed by ICAP, but would
lateral move in opposite directions to the strong volumes of mergers and acquisi- probably choose to use Equilend ahead of ICAP.
tune of at least 5% in a single day. And tions activity predicted in 2007, now might To be quite honest, I’m not sure we need another
even then, with all of those events occur- be a good time to consider market rates player in the market.”
ring at the same time, it is only then that instead of platform rates. But BoNY’s John
the first penny of exposure hits the lender. Arnesen concludes with one quiet but
“On the revenue side of the equation, the arresting observation. “The danger is that
Key Stats
3 PagesJaunes Groupe SA
lending data
from the Risk
Management
Association.
European Equities on Loan USD (mn) Pacific Rim Equities on Loan USD (mn)
The Cheque’s
for the supply side allowing uniqueness
and value to be focused in their products
and service and away from the secondary
function of billing.”
While eFee is a convenient and
handy utility, one of things that has been
Brave Hearts
ucts, often utilising wireless technology.
Keeping adrift of the full-scale adoption of
Wireless Router Application Platforms
expected in 2007, Mr Dunstan assures us
that “Bravura Solutions has strong WRAP
offering and is well positioned to take
advantage of the business opportunities
ravura Solutions was established in agency system has been integrated with presented.” Another factor driving growth
Outsourcing Minutiae more than just a place, the blend of off- “only 10-20% possess the qualifications
shore/onshore combinations is now gen- that are expected by the big companies.”
erally regarded as a highly efficient eco- Either their English skills are inadequate
$17 billion of IT services will go nomic model. For Chris Potts, CEO of or the knowledge they acquired at univer-
offshore by 2008 Rhyme Systems, companies in India have sity is insufficient.
completely acknowledged the popularity A large percentage of the top tier gradu-
$17 billion of US work will be be of offshore/onshore outsourcing combi- ates often leave India to work to work in
offshored in 2008 nations. “You are looking at something the west. The average worker in India has
already historically well established. In the a per captia income of $685 per annum;
$3.0-$4.6 billion of testing work past there have been vertical integration compare this to neighbours Indonesia and
is offshored models especially in manufacturing. For Thailand, with $1000 and $2700 respec-
example, a company would have its own tively. The lure of the high paying West to
$5.4 billion spent on business glass works, steel plants and even coal young, bright graduates is hardly surpris-
process outsourcing in Asia-
Pacific in 2004
India will keep hold of it’s outsourcing crown,
$50 billion will be spent on
offshore outsourcing by 2007
unless Indian outsourcing companies become
so big th
hat they in turn have to outsource.
1.2 million European jobs to go
offshore
mines to produce the end product, per- ing. It is important here to note a signifi-
100,000 jobs were lost to haps a car or a ship. This changed and ver- cant counter-argument to that of the
Chinese outsourcing in 2004 tical integration gradually fragmented as ‘brain-drain.’ Whilst it is undoubtedly true
companies or even countries become spe- that some of the top tier of technical skills
12,000 legal jobs were out- cialists at various processes or stages. This move to join Western companies abroad,
sourced in 2004 is much more cost-effective and econo- there is a significant trend for successful
mists will tell you that specialisation is the Indian ex-pats to return home. Mr Potts
15% of manufacturing companies way to optimise efficiency benefits. In states: “Many Indian companies lose skills
outsourced research and global economic terms, outsourcing of to their clients and into the territories
development in 2004 processes to specialist providers is there- abroad they are supporting, however
fore an inevitable trend rather than a fad.” many of them eventually return. Family
15% of Singapore IT companies Continuing with economic theory, it and culture is very important in the
outsource stands to reason that outsourcing to India region, and this means there is a reverse
will continue due not only to the amount brain drain, where people have moved
16 outsourcing megadeals of money that is flowing into the country abroad for ten to fifteen years and return
awarded in 2003, 12 in 2004, through the outsourcing industry, but the with added skills and expertise.”
11 in 2005 increased competition of outsourcing Another significant factor against out-
providers by both domestic and foreign sourcing to India is the implications of
19% of US businesses have some companies. To be able to offer cost-effec- such a high turnover rate. Turnover rate
offshore outsourcing strategy tive and efficient services in such a climate, often reaches 30% amongst IT providers,
only the best companies will
2.3 million banking jobs will be prevail. Presuming state Pay Pressure in India
offshored by 2010 intervention occurs only in
the provision of educated
25% of current tech jobs will be employees, then perhaps
outsourced to India by 2010 India will keep hold of its
outsourcing crown, unless,
25% of IT jobs will be offshored of course, Indian outsourc-
by 2010 ing companies become so
big that they in turn have to
81% of UK companies to increase outsource.
outsourcing in the next 2-3 years.
Against India
830,000 jobs to go offshore by However, can India sustain
the end of 2005. this growth in the long run?
According to a Deutsche
85% of outsourcing contracts to Bank Research article in
be re-negotiated. 2005, of the 150,000 gradu-
ates joining the existing total
of 1.75 million engineers,
Source: Deutsche Bank Research
74 INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL
Uniqueness.
sasimkt@sasiny.com l Tel +1.212.612.8700 l Fax +1.212.612.8885 l 12 East 49th Street, New York, NY 10017
Member NEW YORK STOCK EXCHANGE, NASDAQ, NASD, PRINCIPAL REGIONAL EXCHANGES, and SIPC
INDIA - OUTSOURCING
whist in call centres the rate can be as The most obvious but often overlooked
much as 50%. Companies have to offer problem until you are actually in India is
enticing pay and benefit packages in order the state of the infrastructure. Whilst the
to keep their employees, and as a result, government has finally realised the poten-
the more experienced members can expect tial of the outsourcing industry, which
rapid pay increases that are far greater in brings in around 25% of all export earn-
proportion than less qualified members ings, by providing regulation and tax
(see graph). In July Wipro Ltd and Satyam incentives. However “the infrastructure of
Computer Services Ltd posted profit the country is still inadequate and com-
warnings due to the hike in wage costs. It pares poorly with those available in other
will be interesting to see how these competing countries in the far east and
increases in wages affect the long term cost eastern Europe,” states Mr Mathias of Tata.
efficiency of outsourcing to India. “Most of these shortages (e.g power) are
There is also an increasing threat from met and paid for by the individual compa-
other markets, although the strength of nies themselves. This will continue to be
these threats is hard to define and there- an additional burden to the cost base.”
fore hotly contested. Pakistan, Bangladesh Another potential difficulty is that tech-
and Sri Lanka all have a significant pro- nology improves at an alarming rate and
ALTERNATIVE
INVESTMENTS In Partnership with:
HONG KONG
HEAR FROM INSTITUTIONAL LEADERSHIP:
Innovative Fund Managers & Investment Experts From Around The Globe
Joseph Marenda, Noboru Terada, Scott Lothian,
Senior Consultant, Former Executive Investment Officer, GPIF Head of Manager Research,
CAMBRIDGE ASSOCIATES WATSON WYATT
Jonathan Watkin,
Kha Loon Lee, Director, Ismail Dalla,
Head, CFA Centre for Financial Market Integrity, HONG KONG RETIREMENT SCHEMES ASSOCIATION Capital Market Consultant, WORLD BANK
Asia Pacific, CFA INSTITUTE Darren McShane, Giang Thanh Long,
Executive Director Investment Regulation, Researcher,
Masaharu Usuki, VIETNAM DEVELOPMENT FORUM (VDF) HANOI
Executive Research Fellow/CFA,PhD, MANDATORY PROVIDENT FUND SCHEMES AUTHORITY
NLI RESEARCH INSTITUTE John S Wisnioski,
Vanessa Wang, FSA, Chief Executive Officer, BASETEN CAPITAL
Dennis Chu, Retirement Business Leader, Asia (ex-Japan),
Managing Director, CAMBRIDGE ASSOCIATES LLC MERCER HUMAN RESOURCE CONSULTING Nicola Horlick,
Joint Managing Director,
Scott W. Chambers, Rebecca Dukes, BRAMDEAN ASSET MANAGEMENT LLP
Professor of Finance, LINFIELD COLLEGE V.P. University Advancement & Executive Director,
NEW MEXICO STATE UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION Stephen Po, Senior Director,
Tina F. Lemieux, HONG KONG SECURITES AND FUTURES COMMISSION
Managing Director, Gil Beltran,
CJ Kim, Korea Retirement Business Leader,
Hedge Fund and Broker Services, Undersecretary, Domestic Finance Group MERCER HUMAN RESOURCE CONSULTING
CHICAGO MERCANTILE EXCHANGE and Legislative Liaison, PHILLIPPINES
Salunkhe Jagadish,
Peter Douglas, Penny Ning Pan, Consultant, MERCER INDIA
Principal and Founder, Consultant, STIRLING FINANCE LIMITED
Wade Pfau, Associate Professor, Economics,
GFIA HEDGE FUND RESEARCH Lee Shyan Yuan, NATIONAL GRADUATE INSTITUTE FOR
Visit Tantisunthorn, Commissioner, TAIWAN**(TENTATIVE) POLICY STUDIES (GRIPS)
Secretary General, René Nuñez, Christophe Lee, CEO,
GOVERNMENT PENSION FUND Trustee, TEXAS PERMANENT SCHOOL FUND SHK FUND MANAGEMENT LTD.
For More Information About This Event, Please Contact: Brian Klebash at 212.901.1884
or bklebash@imn.org or Visit: www.imn.org/etm900/isjm
MiFID and that want to buy and sell, which is easier than
going through the exchanges.
1000
1 0 0 0 I nve s t o r s a n d I s s u e r s E x p e c t e d t o A t t e n d
Major US Investors: Major US Issuers: Foreign Issuers and Investors
from the following markets:
Hedge Funds CDO Managers Latin America
Asset Managers Mortgage/Consumer Central & Eastern Europe and CIS
Insurance Companies ABS Issuers Western Europe
Pension Funds Asia
Meet Hundreds of Investors and Issuers Representing International Portfolios and Products.
Learn About the Newest ABS Products and Developments in the US and Emerging Markets.
Register Now to Attend Spring ABS 2007! If You Don’t,Your Competition Will.
BHF SPIRIT
We at ISJ work hard, we did hear you work
long hours too. What is your average work-
ing day like?
Usually I start at around 9 a.m. – the end is
open and depends on the daily workload.
Throughout the day I work on SLA’s and/or
RfP’s, and I communicate with our clients to
answer their inquiries. I am in meetings and
conference calls with clients and/or col-
leagues to analyse client requirements and to
set up individual service models. As we are
on business trips on a regular basis, I have to
arrange the meetings and all other aspects
ISJ speaks to Christine (agendas, presentations etc) and, of course,
Boehm of BHF-BANK, follow up afterwards and write call reports.
Additionally I am involved in the develop-
continuing the series of ment of our internet tool cds@web.
‘Meet the future’ profiles.
If you were given the opportunity to take a
sabbatical or year out what would you do?
I would write a book, I’ve already got a
In spring 2005 I got a phone call from Moritz migration. During the migration phase we story in mind – but the details are still secret.
Ostwald, Head of Sales and Relationship had to work with both system environments –
Management BHF-BANK (we already knew quite a challenging time and an important If you were named BHF-BANK employee of
each other from Deutsche Bank and State part of my career. the year, how and where would you cele-
Street as we worked together on an IT migra- brate?
tion project when Deutsche sold it’s global What do you enjoy most about your current
position at BHF-BANK? I would celebrate with my colleagues,
custody business to State Street) and the rest is friends and family at home or in a dis-
history … No, honestly - when he described People know each other – I always get imme-
diate support no matter which department I cotheque. A great big fantastic party…
the details of this job vacancy it was clear that
I should take up this exceptional opportunity contact, and the team spirit is amazing. At
BHF-BANK most of the colleagues have a lot What are your long-term goals for the
at BHF-BANK. future?
of experience in the securities services indus-
try. To work as a Relationship Manager was To keep well and fit, to have an interesting
Why did you choose your career initially? and challenging job but also enough time for
Obviously I was looking for a job which one of my objectives in the past -, now that I
hold this position I am enjoying everything family and friends.
offers a lot of interaction with other people.
During my schooldays I already worked in the about it.
hotel business in my free time. That is why I Who are your mentors / role models? THE ISJ MINUTE
originally choose a vocational training course With regard to business definitely my former
in this sector. Later on, I decided to deepen my CD or MP3? Both
boss at Deutsche Bank and State Street Attila Books or Films? Books
experience in the financial sector, so the new Demirci. He taught me the ropes in custody
target was clear: to get a job in the banking business and is now a good friend of mine Cocktails or Wine? Wine
industry. To complete my profile and to build who is ready to answer my calls 24/7. And of Theatre or Club? Club
a basis with regard to the banking sector I course I owe a lot to Cornelia Keth and Moritz Elvis or Johnny Cash? Elvis
completed additional occupational studies at Ostwald from BHF-BANK. Their advice has
the German Bankakademie. Now I have both: Nightts In or Nights Out? Nights Out
been indispensable – they believe in my Watching or Playing? Watching
a job with a commercial background and strengths and listen to my ideas – Moritz sup-
plenty of interaction with other people. ported my career in particular by offering this ISJ or FT? ISJ!
Describe your experience at previuos job to me. With regard to private life, my par-
employers / locations ents -, it’s unbelievable how they mastered
A global company like Deutsche Bank with their life.
international clients and employees – this was CHRISTINE BOEHM
quite interesting for a young country girl like Where do you see yourself in five years time?
me. I learned how to look after clients. The Married? (hopefully), mother? (maybe) – Title: Relationship Manager Custody,
working atmosphere in the client service unit but definitely working in the custody industry. Education: 2000-2004 vocational studies at the
As a relationship manager? In sales? In prod- German Bankakademie in banking and business
was outstanding. At State Street I made my administration.
first experiences as a team leader. I was respon- uct development or projects? There are many
Employment: 2000-2003 Client Service Officer,
sible for the Customer Service team covering opportunities and challenges – time will tell. Deutsche Bank, Global Securities Services, 2003 -
German institutional clients and international Basically I want to extend my knowledge, have 2005 Senior Customer Service Officer and later First
asset management mandates. Also, I was a good working atmosphere and the flexibility Line Manager, State Street Bank GmbH,
involved in a project in preparation for the IT to do things my way. 2005 to present BHF-BANK Aktiengesellschaft
un fu t
ts nd
co ge en
ac ed ev
ed o h rst
ag t fi
an ed ’s
m cat SA
di e U
de Th
Reiko Nahum
Chief Executive Officer
Amber Partners Customised.
: Yes! Please register me for the congress : Yes! Please send me the congress brochure : Yes! I am interested in sponsorship opportunities
Name: ..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Address: ..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Fax: ...............................................................................................................Tel:.............................................................................................................
Email:...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Event code: MAUSA/ISJ
www.hedgefundsworld.com/2007/mausa
MANDATES
HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL has appointed NORTHERN TRUST as its first global custodian, to provide custody, per-
formance measurement and securities lending services for the GBP£2.8bn pension fund. In addition, Northern Trust
Global Investments (NTGI), the asset management arm of Northern Trust, has been appointed as transition manager.
NORTHERN TRUST also announced that it has been appointed custodian for the EL PASO FIREMEN AND
POLICEMEN’S PENSION FUND, providing global custody, securities lending, benefits payment and foreign exchange
services for the $600 million fund, which serves more than 1,800 active and 1,300 retired firefighters and police offi-
cers.
MORGAN STANLEY has topped the advisory league tables compiled by Thomson Financial after winning the mandate
for Statoil’s $28bn takeover of NORSK HYDRO. The deal means that Morgan Stanley overtook its rival Citigroup in advis-
ing $479.3bn worth of deals in 2006 compared to the latter’s $473.4bn, Goldman Sachs, who advised Norsk on the
takeover, is currently third in the tables with £427.5bn.
NORTHERN TRUST has been reappointed as global custodian and asset servicing provider to THE PENSIONS TRUST,
a multi-employer occupational pension schemes for the charitable, social, educational, voluntary and not-for-profit sec-
tors in the United Kingdom. Following a comprehensive external review of services delivered since 1999, The Pensions
Trust renewed Northern Trust’s mandate to provide global custody, investment accounting, unitisation, performance
measurement, compliance analysis and securities lending for the GBP£3.6 billion (approximately USD $7.1 billion)
fund.
Letters (continued from page 4) each competent authority, while helpful, only http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/secme/
solves some of the issues. A consistent vision + 44 (0) 207 092 1239
The message that MiFID will yield hearty needs to be facilitated by CESR and common
benefits for the early has clearly yet to reach the standards and market practices agreed by the 20 March 2007, 3 days
masses, yet by Feb 1st 2007, firms will be left firms themselves in order to forestall confu- Investing in Infrastructure Assets
with a stark choice; whether to bite the bullet Embassy Suites Hotel, New York
sion post-November 1st 2007. Given the past T: +44 207 092 1224
and keep up with their more proactive rivals, record for harmonisation among Member http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/iiaa/con-
or whether to depend on other firms to help States around other directives, this author tact.stm
them fulfil functions such as best execution expects there to be significant transitioning
and order handling, client classification and acclimatisation activity occurring during 26 March 2007, 3 days
administration, transaction reporting or data 2008 until issues such as best execution and World Exchange Congress
management. A “wait and see” strategy will no client classification are stabilised and until the The Jumeirah Beach Hotel, Dubai
longer be an option. competent authorities network their systems http://www.worldexchangecongress.com/
There are two areas in particular where dif- +44 (0)2070 921 276
multi-laterally. November 1st 2007 will not be
ferential interpretation is likely to have costly the finishing line for eventual harmonisation
consequences for all concerned: of financial markets in Europe while so many 26 March 2007, 5 days
1) Firstly, it is assumed that transaction factors remain undecided, but the transposi- Asset Allocation Summit 2007
reporting will be implemented consistently as tion decisions will greatly impact the pacing of Sandton, Johnannesburg
it is presented as MiFID “Regulation” with that harmonisation. T: +27 11 463 6001
direct legal effect. The theory (expressed in http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/asset-
articles 25 and 32 of the Level 1 text) appears Dr Anthony W Kirby za/contact.stm
innocuous and requires firms to develop some Head of Risk, Regulation & Compliance, 27 March 2007, 3 days
intelligent routing to cope with the measures Capital Markets Absolute Return for Trustees
in the absence of an industry utility solution. Accenture Millennium Hotel Mayfair, London
However, at the time of going to press, the http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/art/
competent authorities had yet to agree the
exact fields which practitioners would need to
populate beyond the 23 base fields. This is
Dating +44 207 092 1224
27 March 2007, 3 days
because different competent authorities have Global Securities Hedge Funds World Espana 2007
The Westin Palace, Madrid
different uses for the information to be report-
ed (e.g. market abuse vs. prudential reasons). Services events http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/esp/
+44 207 092 1224
Some competent authorities are likely to 12 February 2007, 3 days
require firms to issue reports depending on the Alternative Beta - IRC Conference 23 May 2007, 3 days
location of the execution venue, whereas some The Landmark, London Hedge Funds World Asia 2007
might focus on where the terms of business are T: +44 (0)207 827 5972 Raffles City Convention Centre,
agreed and/or investment advice is offered. http://www.hedgefundsworld.com/2007/ Singapore
Urgent guidance by CESR is sorely needed, altbeta/ http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/fof%5Fs
otherwise firms will need to report transac- g/ T: +65 6222 8550
28 February 2007, 3 days
tions to multiple competent authorities and Hedge Funds World Australia
regulators will need to carry out expensive rec- The Westin, Sydney 3rd June 2007, 4 days
onciliations. Above all, standards are critical. T: +65 6322 2715 Funds World Middle East 2007
2) Secondly, the issue of the correct classifi- http://www.hedgefundsworld.com/2007/ Madinat Jumeirah, UAE
cation of clients under MiFID is showing hfw%5Fau/ http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/fwm/
every sign of becoming a free for all. There are (+65) 6322 2711
three categories of client classification under 05 March 2007, 4 days
Hedge Funds World Middle East
MiFID; Retail, Market Professional and Madinat Jumeirah, Dubai
Eligible Counterparty. The tests will need to 12 June 2007, 3 days
T: +44 207 092 1224 Hedge Funds World Global
be conducted each firm on the basis of each http://www.hedgefundsworld.com/2007/ Opportunities 2007
client’s suitability and appropriateness to hfwme/contact.stm Bridgewaters, New York
transact the instruments in the required man- http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/hfwgo/
ner. However, most member states maintain 1 646 839 4710
two-way classifications, and few regulators 06 March 2007, 3 days
stipulate how different clients might be classi- CDO World USA 2007
Bridgewaters, New York 18 June 2007, 3 days
fied in practice, even given home state guid- T: +44 20 7092 1263
ance. More worryingly, as things stand, clients Hedge Funds World Scandinavia 2007
http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/cdo The Grand Hotel, Stockholm
are entitled to change their classifications on http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/scandi/
request (and firms need to have the necessary 12 March 2007, 4 days +44 (0) 207 8275981
documentary evidence). If this measure goes Islamic Funds Asia 2007
through post-Jan 31st, there is every possibili- The Westin Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
ty of a “free for all” with clients shopping http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/iiasia/ 26th June 2007, 3 days
around for the best terms and most firms (+65) 6322 2736 ETF & Closed-End Funds World 2007
needing to make significant amendments to tbc, London
18 March 2007, 4 days http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/laa/
their systems. Securitization World MENA 2007
To conclude, it is clear that guidance from +44 (0) 207 092 1000
Shangri-La Hotel, Dubai
&
announced the
responsible for the Trust’s products and election of three
data and for the European nation-
development of als to its Board of
Deutsche Bank headed the Payments department. During Etheios recruit and place specialist con-
have also his career Steinbach has gained extensive sultancy staff for client projects. Ms.
announced the experience in payments. In 1985 he Solomons brings both recruitment and
appointment of became the head of the electronic pay- consulting skills that she will apply to
Barry Bausano and ments department at the then resource projects for clients and to grow
Jonathan Hitchon “Genossenschaftliche Zentralbank” or further the staff of Etheios. She has pre-
as Co-heads of GZB-Bank (cooperative central bank) in viously worked in Account and Contract
Equity Prime Stuttgart. Since then he has headed management, selection and allocation of
Brokerage, effec- increasingly large and complex payment resources. Most recently Ms. Solomons
tive immediately. divisions formed by mergers in the undertook new business development for
Bausano, previous- German banking world. Mr Steinbach is a high level finance clients in risk (opera-
ly Global Head of member of many significant national and tions, market and credit) compliance
Hedge Funds, will Barry Bausano international payment committees. (MiFID, SOX, Basel 2 and AML) and
be responsible for corporate governance - in both the UK
the client facing aspects of prime broker- Credit Suisse Group has announced that and Europe.
age while Hitchon, previously Global Leonhard Fischer, Chief Executive Officer
Head of Prime Services, will continue to of Winterthur, will be appointed Chief
lead the development of the platform’s Executive Officer of the Europe, Middle
award-winning product offering. Both East and Africa (EMEA) region. In this
Mr Hitchon and Mr Bausano have exten- role, Leonhard Fischer will report to
sive experience in the hedge fund indus- Oswald J. Grübel, Chief Executive of
try, on both the buy side and the sell side, Credit Suisse and will join the Executive
and will jointly Board of the bank. He will be based in
report to Yassine London and will assume his new respon-
Bouhara, Head sibilities on March 1, 2007. Michael
of Global Philipp, CEO of Obituary
Markets Equity, the EMEA region,
and Alan Cloete, will become
Head of Global Chairman of
Finance and Credit Suisse in
Foreign the EMEA region.
Exchange. In this new role,
Michael Philipp
will focus on
Jon Hitchon expanding the Seymour Martin Lipset, social scientist
On 1 May 2007, bank's strategic and scholar on the nature on democra-
Ben Haasdijk will call it a day and step client relationships cy, died on New Years Eve, 2006. One
down as Chairman of the Board of with a particular Leonhard Fischer of Mr Lipset’s most important contri-
Directors of Equens. His successor will be focus on the butions was the notion that ‘The more
Michael Steinbach, currently Deputy Middle East. He will also continue to play well-to-do a nation, the greater the
Chairman of the Board of Directors. Mr a key role developing strategy with chances that it will sustain democracy.''
Haasdijk joined Interpay’s Board of Leonhard Fischer and driving specific ini- Lipset showed that economic develop-
Directors in 1999 and has held the posi- tiatives in the EMEA region. Michael ment, thorough the development of the
tion of Chairman since 2004. He will Philipp will remain a member of the middle-class, the growth of voluntary
retire on 1 May. The Supervisory Board Executive Board and will continue to organisations and the spread of educa-
has nominated Mr Jan Sonneveld for report to Oswald J. Grübel. He will be tion, was a necessary requisite for a
membership of the Board of Directors of based in London and assume his new secure democracy to flourish. This
Equens as from 1 May 2007. Mr responsibilities on March 1, 2007. claim has been subject to extensive
Sonneveld is currently General Manager empirical examination, both quantita-
Risk Management. Michael Steinbach is Etheios, the inde- tive and qualitative, in the past 30
currently Deputy Chairman of the Board pendent invest- years, and while the correlation is not
of Directors and is responsible for ment management as liner as Mr Lipset suggested, a
Marketing & Sales, as well as Payments consultancy, strong causal relationship is certainly
Operations. He has been spokesman for announces the apparent.
the Board of Directors of appointment of
Transaktionsinstitut für Tania Solomons as
Zahlungsverkehrsdienstleistungen AG Manager of the A selection of the
(TAI) since July 2003. Prior to his Resourcing
employment at TAI in 2003 he was a Division. In this
appointments from
director of DZ BANK AG (Deutsche newly created role, WWW.ISJFORUM.COM
Zentral-Genossenschaftsbank), where he Tania will help Tania Solomons
Consultants
C: Professor Michael Mainelli,
Z/Yen helps organisations make better choices. Our name combines Zen and Yen -
Executive Chairman
“a philosophical desire to succeed” - in a ratio, recognising that all decisions are
E: michael_mainelli@zyen.com
trade-offs. Z/Yen’s mission is to be the foremost risk/reward management firm.
In the financial markets Z/Yen conducts numerous research projects on a variety of C: (Disaster Recovery and Project
wholesale and retail issues, as well as providing technical strategy, support and Management): Keith Ford,
prediction systems. Z/Yen’s renowned annual studies include: Senior Consultant
i. Global cost per trade benchmarks on equities, money markets and foreign E: keith_ford@zyen.com
exchange;
T: +44 207-562-9562
ii. Operational performance of broker ratings;
F: +44 207-628-6786
iii. Operational performance of client (buy-side) ratings.
W: www.zyen.com
The CACEIS Group is a partnership between the Investor Services business lines T: +33 1 57 78 10 78
of Crédit Agricole S.A. and Groupe Caisse d'Epargne. We rank among the top 10
custodians worldwide, with EUR 1,697 billion in assets under custody C: (France)
(30/6/2006). CACEIS provides a full range of services to institutional clients in Patrick Lemuet
France, Luxembourg, Spain and Ireland. These services include, global and local E: france@caceis.com
custody (safekeeping of listed and OTC assets) depositary/trustee services, T: +352 4767 2567
STP transactions (SWIFT), corporate actions and income collection, proxy voting, C: (International)
tax services, compliance and performance monitoring, flexible online reporting, José-Benamin Longrée
securities lending, matching, processing and settlement. We also have links to E: international@caceis.com
200+ UCITS registrars. Our network of sub-custodians provides a secure W: www.caceis.com
environment for your assets in over 70 markets worldwide.
www.dbs.com
DBS offers a full range of custodial services including securities safekeeping, settlement +65 6878-1830
of trades, corporate actions and market information updates. These services are
available in Singapore, Hong Kong, Indonesia, India, China (A-shares) and other select- +65 6878-4766
ed markets. DBS also offers short-term, highly liquid overnight facilities for its clients' Ms Low Swee Fun
accounts to earn daily interest on any excess funds. investorsvs@dbs.com
DBS Bank Ltd,
With over 20 years of experience in the custody business, DBS' strengths lie in its ability Global Transaction Services,
to provide quality services, in depth knowledge and expertise of the Asian markets, as Securities Services,
well as customized business solutions to support clients’ businesses. Its clientele 6 Shenton Way, #36-02,
comprises the global custodians, international central securities depositories, broker- DBS Building Tower 1
dealers, financial institutions, insurance companies, investment managers, private banks
and corporate. 068809 Singapore
DnB NOR is the largest and leading provider of Custody, Clearing and
T: +47 22 94 92 95
Remote Member Service in Norway In addition, DnB NOR provides a wide
F: +47 22 48 28 46
range of value added services to both Foreign and Domestic clients.
Contact: Bente I. Hoem
Through an Alliance solution with banks in Sweden, Finland and Denmark,
E: bente.hoem@dnbnor.no
DnB NOR can offer seamless regional products, which can be customized to
our client's needs.
W: www.dnbnor.com
Nordea is the leading financial services group in the Nordic and Baltic Sea region
and operates through three business areas: Retail Banking, Corporate and
Institutional Banking and Asset Management & Life.
T: +47 2248 6238 - The leading financial services group
Contact: Anne-Lise Kristiansen - A world-leading Internet banking and e-commerce operation
Head of Sub-custody and - The largest customer base of any financial services group in the region
Clearing - A leading asset manager in the Nordic financial market
- The most comprehensive distribution network in the region
E: anne-lise.kristiansen@nordea.com
Nordea is the leading custody services provider in the region. Nordea provides high
quality, tailor-made custody services for local and foreign investors dealing with
Nordic, Baltic or global securities.
RBC Dexia Investor Services offers a complete range of investor services to institu-
T: +44 (0) 20 7653 4096
F: +44 (0) 20 7248 3946
tions worldwide. Established in January 2006, we are equally owned by Royal Bank
Contact: Tony Johnson of Canada (RBC) and Dexia. We rank among the world's top 10 global custodians,
Head, Sales & Relationship with approximately USD 2.0 trillion in client assets under custody, including in-
Management house assets of RBC and Dexia. Our innovative products and services help clients
E: antony.johnson@rbcdexia-is.com maximise operational efficiency, minimise risk and enhance portfolio returns. And
Address: 71 Queen Victoria Street,
our 3,800 professionals in 15 markets offer proven expertise to enhance clients’
London, EC4V 4DE, UK
business performance.
Santander is Spain’s leading financial institution and the largest bank in the euro zone
by market capitalization. Our commitment and contribution to the securities industry is
T: Europe: (34) 91 2893932 / 28
well established after more than a century of providing services in this field.
T: USA: (1212) 350 39 02
W: santanderglobal.com Santander’s cutting edge technology enables it to offer a comprehensive array of inno-
E: globalsecurities@ vative services in a broad range of markets. Santander currently has full local capabili-
gruposantander.com ties in Iberian and Latin American markets along with a franchised presence in many
others. Santander`s experience and product range ensures that every aspect of the
securities business is fully contemplated.
SEB is the leading provider of securities services in the Nordic and Baltic area. We
are committed to custody and clearing processes for the wholesale market. We hold
securities worth over EUR 460 bn and provide services in more that 70 markets, 9
T: +46 8 763 5770 of them under the SEB name (Sweden, Norway, Finland, Denmark, Luxembourg,
F: +46 8 763 6930 Germany, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania).
We offer a full range of securities services including corporate action and
Contact: Goran Fors
information services, securities lending and services to remote members of the
E: goran.fors@seb.se Nordic and Baltic stock exchanges. We continuously develop new products in
W: www.seb.se connection with clients and partners to ensure we deliver the high-quality
products our clients demand. We always strive to make the processes more
efficient. With a history of 150 years in the securities industry; we know the market
and our clients well.
Standard Chartered leading the way in Asia, Africa and the Middle East.
Standard Chartered has a history of over 150 years in banking and is in many of the
world's fastest-growing markets with an extensive global network of over 1,200
branches (including subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures) in over 50 countries C: Neil Daswani,
in the Asia Pacific Region, South Asia, the Middle East, Africa, the United Kingdom Global Head, Securities Services
and the Americas.
T: +65 6517 0022
As one of Asia's leading custodians, Standard Chartered has an impressive track E: Neil.Daswani@sg.standard-
record across the 16 Asian markets in which it provides securities services. It serves chartered.com
global, regional and local custodians and broker-dealers, as well as local and regional W: www.standardchartered.com
fund managers. The Bank plays a key role in promoting the development of these
markets and keeping the international investor community informed of industry
developments across the region.
Unicredit Markets & Investment Banking (MIB) serves as UniCredit Group's global
product and competence center for global financial markets and investment banking
services, including Custody throughout Central and Eastern Europe, including Austria.
T: +43 50505-58510
Brand diversitiy under which the group operates (Bank Austria Creditanstalt, HVB,
Bank BPH, Bank Pekao, Zagrebacka Banka and International Moscow Bank), has its F: +43 50505-58579
roots in local market presence and knowledge, contributing into a single unified prod- C: Andreas Petzl , Head of Sales
uct across the region. In 2006 the group was recognised by no less than 3 independ- and Relationship Management
ent surveys as being the best region custodian
Markets & Investment Banking E: Andreas.petzl@ba-ca.com
The group's ability to deliver service excellence across 13 markets is the cornerstone of W: www.hvb-custody.com/
our success. From participation in local market associations to our inter group training
sessions, to a client consultative approach, the group continues to work towards mak-
ing a single impression - excellence.
Data Services
Capco Reference Data Services (CRDS) provides a suite of reference data
management solutions that help financial services providers to achieve C: Donna Faup Bailey
superior data integrity, solve data integration issues and transform
operational performance while lowering data management costs. These Director Business Strategy &
services include a comprehensive managed services offering - a proven Marketing, Capco
alternative to in-house management of reference data as well as index T: +212 284 8749
and ETF data solutions. CRDS also provides consulting services E: Donna.FaupBailey@Capco.com
including advisory, assessment, migration, implementation, integration,
project management, development and training. For more information, W: www.capco.com/crds
please visit www.capco.com/crds.
Through its subsidiaries, DTCC provides clearance, settlement and information serv-
ices for equities, corporate and municipal bonds, government and mortgage-backed London: Richard Bustard
securities and over-the-counter derivatives. DTCC's depository also provides custody T: +44 (0)20 7444-0403
and asset servicing for more than 2.5 million securities issues from the United E: rbustard@dtcc.com
States and more than 100 other countries and territories. In addition, DTCC is a
leading processor of mutual funds and insurance transactions, linking funds and car- New York: Susan Spivey
riers with their distribution networks. DTCC has operating facilities in multiple loca-
tions in the United States and overseas. For more information on DTCC, visit T: + 1 212 855-4144
www.dtcc.com. E: sspivey@dtcc.com
DTCC’s GCA Validation Service gathers and distributes validated global corporate General information
actions announcement information on more than 1.4 million securities from more T: +1 212 855-1000
than 150 countries in more than 16 languages, more than any other provider.
SunGard's solutions for data management provide technology for the management
W: www.sungard.com/dataman-
and delivery of market, historical and reference data to financial services
agementsolutions
institutions, energy and public sector organizations. SunGard also offers outsourced
T: 1-888-441-9935
data management services, as well as real-time, interactive and flat-file data feeds
F: 212-977-7144
for application integration. Aggregating market data and financial content from more
C: Marketing Department
than 100 third-party sources, SunGard's solutions for data management add value
E: moreinfo@sungard.com
through a range of services including cleansing, enrichment and analytics. To find
A: SunGard
out how SunGard's solutions for data management can help improve productivity,
888 Seventh Avenue
portfolio optimization and investment opportunity with predictive analytics and
New York, NY 10106
packaged data please visit www.sungard.com/datamanagementsolutions.
Fund Administration
Andrew Collins Managing Director Butterfield Fund Services (BFS) provides valuation, accounting, corporate secretarial,
T: 441-299-3954 compliance, directorial and shareholder services to hedge funds, fund-of-funds, and
E: andrewcollins@bntb.bm mutual funds. BFS also services international pension & insurance trusts. Clients
Tania Kowalski Marketing such as financial institutions, insurance companies, and institutional investors use
Manager T: 441-278-6300 Butterfield Fund Services to set up and launch investment funds. BFS operates in
E: taniakowalski@bntb.bm Bermuda, Bahamas, the Cayman Islands and Guernsey.
A: Rosebank Centre 11 Whether a fund is just starting out or is well established, Butterfield Fund Services
Bermudiana Road, Pembroke, can provide complete solutions to help clients better service their investors. With
Bermuda HM 08 / P.O. Box HM over $50 billion in assets under administration, many alternative funds have turned
195 Hamilton, Bermuda HM AX to Butterfield Fund Services for timely and accurate administration services.
The CACEIS Group is a partnership between the Investor Services business lines of
T: +33 1 57 78 10 78 Crédit Agricole S.A. and Groupe Caisse d'Epargne. With a total of 823 billion in
C: Patrick Lemuet (France) assets under administration (30/6/2006), we are Europe’s premier third party fund
E: france@caceis.com administrator. CACEIS provides a full range of services in France, Luxembourg,
Ireland, Belgium and The Netherlands. These services include portfolio valuation
T: +352 4767 2567 with multiple and automated pricing sources, NAV calculation, product structuring,
C: José-Benamin Longrée tax relevant data calculation, fees and commissions calculation, on-line client report-
(International) ing, legal and statutory investment guideline monitoring, performance measurement
and globalisation techniques such as Cloning. Our transfer agency services include
E: international@caceis.com retail and institutional account management, Europe-wide transaction processing,
W: www.caceis.com distribution network management, third party distribution and shareholder services.
The Fastnet Network, operated by CACEIS, undertakes some of the above services
and is a partnership venture with the Fortis Group.
New York: Christopher Lynch JPMorgan Fund Administration provides a full suite of products for all aspects of
T: +1 718-242-7555 fund administration, enabling asset managers to focus on their core business of
E: chris.e.lynch@jpmorgan.com investment management. Fully integrated with JPMorgan's custody and fund
London: Dick Feehan accounting system, it also accepts automated data feeds from clients' in-house or
T: +44 (20) 7742-0102 third party accounting platforms. By automating these activities, we leverage
E: dick.j.feehan@jpmorgan.com
technology to build flexible business systems that increase efficiencies and deliver
Sydney: Laurence Bailey customer focused solutions.
T: (61-2) 9250-4833
E:laurence.bailey@jpmorgan.com A world-class team of experienced industry professionals provides the expertise you
W: www.jpmorgan.com/wss need in fund administration services.
Our clients have access to a broad range of value added services and tailored solu- T: +44 (0) 1481 744000
tions including global custody and fund administration services for funds domiciled F: +44 (0) 1481 744529
in the Caribbean and Channel Islands. C: Jose Santamaria
E: jose.santamaria@rbc.com
Our services include Trustee, banking and credit facilities, treasury and foreign A: PO Box 48 Canada Court
exchange, trade execution, financial accounting, corporate services, derivative sup- St Peter Port Guernsey
port services and online access, leveraging a custody network that covers 80 plus GY1 3BQ United Kingdom
markets worldwide. Our service combines leading edge technology with professional W: www.rbcprivatebanking.
expertise and a truly integrated service delivering creative, customised solutions. com/ci.html
For over 25 years, Trident Trust has been a leading provider of corporate, trust and
fund services to the financial service sector worldwide.
W: www.tridenttrust.com Fund Services: A full range of back office administration services tailored for
T: +44 (0) 20 7935 1503 hedge, private equity and closed-ended funds. Flexibility in structuring a fund’s
F: +44 (0) 20 7935 7242 administration allows us to work closely with accounting firms and other service
C: Robin Harris providers to offer a cost-effective administrative solution.
E: rharris@tridenttrust.com Services include full fund accounting, NAV calculations, registrar and transfer
A: 7 Welbeck Street agent, corporate secretarial including company formation, due diligence compliance
London W1G 9YE UK and internet reporting. Assets of Funds Serviced: $20 billion No. of Funds: 300
New York: Mario Novello T: 212-840-8280 London: Robin Harris T: 0207-935-1503
BVI: Barry Goodman T: 284-494-2434 Cayman Is: Rick Gorter T: 345-949-0880
Guernsey: Mark Le Tissier T: 01481-727571 Jersey: Mike Spittal T: 01534-733401
Hedge Fund Services, based in the Cayman Islands, Ireland and Canada holds a
leading position in the area of hedge fund administration, offering a complete range
W: www.ubs.com/fundservices of services including accounting, NAV computation, share holder services, banking
C: Mr Gerhard Fusenig and credit facilities. With the dedication and experience of a professional team of
T: +41 44 235 4992 200 and our state-of-the-art web reporting, accounting and shareholder systems, we
E: gerhard.fusenig@ubs.com are well positioned to provide clients with a first class service.
With specialist expertise in both single manager and fund of hedge fund adminis-
A: UBS Global Asset tration, we provide facilities for both onshore and offshore funds.
Management, Fund Services, Capabilities also extend to services for investment funds through our teams in
Stauffacherstrasse 41, PO Box, Luxembourg, Switzerland and the UK.
CH-8098, Zurich, Switzerland Cayman Islands: Darren Stainrod, tel. +1-345-914 1076
Ireland: Don McClean, tel. +353-1-436 3636
Canada: Pearse Griffith, tel. +1-416-971 4702
Prime Brokerage
Fimat’s Alternative Investment Solutions team (AIS) is a dedicated global Prime
C: Philippe Teilhard Brokerage team serving the alternative investment community including hedge
A: Fimat International Banque SA funds and CTAs.
(UK Branch) - part of the Societe The AIS team offers a global range of brokerage activities on a wide range of asset
Generale Group classes including equities, bonds, currencies, commodities, and their related listed &
SG House, 41 Tower Hill OTC derivative products. The team also provides a dedicated account management
London EC3N 4SG, UK team, cross-margining tools between securities & derivative instruments, hedge fund
T: + 44 207 676 85 36 start-up services, hedge fund industry quantitative information and capital
F + 44 207 628 44 47 introductions services.
E: philippe.teilhard@fimat.co.uk The AIS team is part of Fimat, which employs over 1,600 people in 26 markets,
and is a member of 46 derivatives exchanges, and 17 stock exchanges worldwide.
A: Europe/Asia/Africa
Fundtech's payments solutions automate all aspects of the funds transfer and cus- 42 New Broad Street
tomer notification process, enabling straight-through-processing (STP) of payments. London EC2M 1SB
Fundtech also offers payments solutions for continuous linked settlement (CLS), nos- United Kingdom
tro account management and enterprise-wide payments management.
T: +44-207-588-1100
Global PAYplus - The enterprise-wide payments management solution for global
F: +44-207-588-1155
financial institutions.
PAYplus RTGS - A fully integrated, multi-currency payment system for banks resid- A: Americas
ing in countries outside the U.S. that have established Real Time Gross Settlement 30 Montgomery Street Suite 501
(RTGS) standards. Jersey City, NJ 07302
PAYplus USA - The leading payments solution for financial institutions in the US. T: +1-201-946-1100
F: +1-201-946-1313
Securities Lending .
Data Explorers Limited, a specialist and independent company, offers impartial
W: www.dataexplorers.com
quantitative measurement of securities lending performance services to the global T: +44 (20) 7392 4000
securities financing industry. We help our clients monitor and understand the F: +44 (20) 7392 4004
relative performance of their lending activity and risk, and turn raw lending, borrow- A: 155 Commercial Street,
ing and collateral data into useful, actionable information. We also provide proxies London E1 6BJ United Kingdom
for short selling information. London: Julian Pittam
Working with the industry we ensure information flows are appropriate and peer T: +44 (20) 7392 5018
groups relevant. We are not involved in transactions. E: jp@dataexplorers.com
All of our services: Performance Explorer, Transaction Explorer, Risk Explorer, Boston: Tim Smith
Index Explorer and Report Explorer are web based and available to clients T: + 1 (617) 973 5099
E: tim.smith@dataexplorers.com
over the internet.
Santander is the only Spanish financial institution with a team exclusively dedicated
to securities finance & with the purchase of Abbey in 2004 has expanded its
W: www.gruposantander.com capacity on a Global basis with trading teams in London (UK) & Connecticut (USA).
T: (3491) 289 39 42/54
Santander's leading local capabilities in Spain, Portugal, UK, USA & Latin America,
E: securitieslending@
along with its solid balance sheet & combined with the state-of-the-art technology,
gruposantander.com provides its clients with the broadest range of solutions in securities lending &
financing, including availability across all assets classes, as well as access to
uncommon emerging markets.
Technology
ADP Brokerage Services Group is an industry leading outsourcing vendor for global
T: +44 (0) 207 551 3000 transaction processing systems, desktop productivity applications and investor
communication services to banks and brokerages worldwide.
E: bsginfo@adp.com -Proxy Edge – comprehensive solution for institutional global proxy voting management.
-Gloss – leading international STP system which automates the trade processing
Address: The ISIS Building, lifecycle from trade capture through confirmation, clearing agency
193 Marsh Wall, London, reporting and settlement.
E14 9SG, UK -Tarot - a UK retail and private client stockbroking, custody and fund management solution.
-Securities Data Management – outsourced data services for securities operations.
Advent Software EMEA, established in 1998, provides trusted solutions for the front
through to back office operations, based on a true real-time fund/portfolio
T: +44 (0)20 7631 9240 accounting platform, to the investment management community throughout Europe,
F: +44 (0)20 7631 9256 Middle East and Africa. Advent has an established network of offices across the
region serving a growing client base of asset managers, hedge fund managers, prime
E: emea@advent.com
brokers, fund administrators, wealth managers, private banks and family offices who
A: One Bedford Avenue, continue to improve their businesses using Advent’s suite of integrated investment
London WC1B 3AU, UK management solutions. Advent Software EMEA is part of Advent Software Inc.
W: www.advent.com (Nasdaq: ADVS), a global organisation that has been providing solutions to the
world's leading financial professionals since 1983. Firms in more than 50 countries
using Advent technology manage investments totaling more than US $8 trillion.
A: EMEA - Progress Apama Progress Apama provides the next-generation Algorithmic Trading
68 Lombard Street Platform for both the buy and sell-side financial institutions - giving
London EC3v 9LJ traders full control over composing, deploying and managing algorithmic
T: +44 (0) 870 3517212
trading strategies, such as VWAP, spread trading and index arbitrage.
E: fraser.herrick@progress.com
A: USA - Progress Apama Apama has customers using the Algorithmic Trading Platform in equities,
10th Floor, 230 Park Avenue futures & options, foreign exchange and bonds and often trading multiple
New York NY assets classes within the same strategy.
T: +1 203 606 5006
E: jim.feingold@progress.com
Apama's platform plugs straight into any market data feeds, order
W: www.progress.com/apama management systems and databases.
Burns Statistics provides software and consulting services. We are focusing on ran-
W: www.burns-stat.com
dom portfolios, a technique that provides significantly improved performance meas-
T: +44 (0)20 7525 0696
urement. A particularly powerful feature is that the initial holdings of the portfolio C: Patrick Burns
can be used in the performance analysis in order to gain even more precision. E: patrick@burns-stat.com
Performance measurement is after the fact, but random portfolios also allow fund 4-b Jodrell Road
managers to test trading strategies before implementing them. There are many addi- London
E3 2LA UK
tional uses of random portfolios as well, one is to objectively evaluate the effect of
constraints on a portfolio.
DST International is the world’s premier vendor of technology solutions to the global
T: UK +44 (0)20 8390 5000
investment management community with over 700 clients in 55 countries, and
Boston +1 617 482 8800
1500 employees in 19 of the world’s leading financial centres. Our wide range of
Hong Kong +85 225 812 880
asset management solutions meet the needs of fund managers, dealers, settlement
F: +44 (0)20 8390 7000
staff, custodians and record keepers operating as international asset managers; from
E: info@dstintl.com
front office simulation, opinion management and modelling functions, through data
A: DST House, St Mark’s Hill,
management, dealing and settlement to custody and corporate actions. The suite of
Surbiton, Surrey, KT6 4QD
products can be used either as stand-alone applications or brought together in flexi-
W: www.dstinternational.com
ble combinations according to specific needs.
peterevans is a leading independent provider of front to back office solutions for the
financial services sector. Clearly focused on the securities and investment market,
peterevans and built upon more than 21 years of experience, peterevans presents a
New Broad Street House sophisticated boutique approach in a homogenized market place.
35 New Broad Street xanite, peterevans suite of products, offers a configurable, fully integrated,
London EC2M 1NH browser based, comprehensive solution that can be deployed as a single application
T: +44 (0) 29 20 402200 or integrated as components into your existing platform. The xanite modules can de
E: info@peterevans.com delivered via an ASP or self-hosted. Covering wealth management, custody,
W: www.peterevans.com corporate actions, clearing and settlement, private client and on-line stock broking
with full operational and administrative support for the front, middle and back office.
xanite gives full but controlled access to clients, portfolio, fund and relationship
managers, brokers, middle and back office staff – on line anywhere in the world.
Over 100 Capital Markets firms worldwide rely on Singularity to achieve step-change
improvements in efficiency and cost-effectiveness. Across front, middle and back office
T: +44 (0)20 7826 4470 operations, Singularity's clients are improving performance by automating process and
F: +44 (0)20 7826 4480 leveraging their human capital most effectively. Our process automation solutions com-
C: Nick Stevens bine deep knowledge and long-standing capital markets experience with award-winning
E: sales@singularity.co.uk technology. Clients include JPMorgan, Bank of Tokyo Mitsubishi UFJ, Raymond James,
A: Cable House, 4th Floor Prudential, Invesco, BNPParibas, Morgan Stanley, American Express and M&G.
54-62 New Broad Street -By cutting latency in securities processing, our clients are recognising new efficien-
London EC2M 1ST UK cies, reducing costs and increasing throughput
Further Contacts: - By streamlining their customer on-boarding processes, our clients are gaining faster
US T: +1 212 946 2685 access to fees, increasing customer satisfaction & gaining greater cross-sell opportunities.
Singapore T: +65 9616 7732 - By automating their KYC & other compliance processes, our clients & reducing risk.
- By improving collaboration in their client reporting cycle, our clients are providing
more timely and insightful investment performance information.
Stewart Copland ,
Consulting Director at Etheios,
starts the new year by reflecting “Life can only be understood
on some old onees... backwards, but it must be lived forwards.”
SOREN KIERKEGAARD
THGISDNIH FORESIGHT
It is customary at the end of a calendar year to look back, reflect It is customary, at the start of a new calendar year, to look
on the changes that have happened, and try to identify patterns or forward, predict the changes that might happen, and to identify
trends that have emerged. new patterns or trends.
With the benefit of hindsight, we can see that 2006 was a time of With the advantage of foresight, we can see that 2007 is going
consolidation and rebuilding in the asset management industry. to be the year when several significant regulatory milestones are
The year started with the announcement of the merger of invest- reached: the new UK sourcebook COLL becomes mandatory in
ment businesses MLIM and Blackrock and industry consolidation February, MiFID is due to come into force across Europe in
continued at the end of the year with the merger of The Bank of November and there will be further proposals on the
New York and Mellon to create the largest global custodian. A development of UCITS4.
good example of rebuilding is Credit Suisse, which rebranded and Although the changes required will largely have been complet-
restructured its global businesses into three clear lines and is now ed in readiness for these implementations, they are milestones on
better able to focus on its core businesses. the convergence path of different regulatory approaches in
In terms of investment management strategies, the main trend Europe.
over the last few years has been a move to open architecture and Hedge funds, in particular, will benefit from this trend and will
multi-manager strategies. The past year has seen the maturity of move from being alternative to an essential, but still relatively
open architecture and multi-manager strategies. small, part of balanced portfolios. UCITS 4 is expected to include
Fund management groups offering their competitors products hedge funds in its scope for the first time – giving a European
was unheard of a few years ago, and now almost all leading players passport to hedge funds. This is likely to further accelerate their
have an open architecture offering. This has helped to polarize the growth and acceptance as a mainstream and regulated product.
industry even further into specialist managers, distributors and While multi-manager strategies have gone so far, the
asset aggregators. Trading and implementation of strategy has development of wrap services still has some way to go and there
become more highly automated. Adoption of electronic trading should be several new launches in the months and years ahead.
systems increased significantly, particularly in global fixed-income Wrap platforms allow managers and IFAs to consolidate and
markets. The importance of STP links from execution through to report on all aspects of a client’s investment portfolio, including
settlement became more critical to achieving fast transaction retail funds, pensions and life policies.
processing. More organisations created direct access from their
However, as has been seen with the stalled growth of fund
trading platforms to clearing facilities such as DTCC, NSCC,
supermarkets, there is probably only shelf space for a few wrap
Bloomberg and Clearstream. Take-up of value-added services
such as compliance and performance analytics improved as platforms: some will fail in development and others will
managers tried harder to identify the source of their returns. consolidate to lead the market. Overestimates of the popularity
Most of these trends were anticipated by the key players and of wrap products are likely to drive fruitless development plans.
factored into their strategies. In addition, market conditions and The areas of largest returns are likely to continue to be
volatility have been relatively benign. If there are lessons to be emerging markets. The search for alpha in these regions will
learnt from these trends, it is that asset managers need to keep need more detailed and timely analytics. There is risk
ahead of the pace of change and build in structural flexibility to from volatility and change but the biggest risk is to not be
cope with more challenging times ahead. invested at all.