//.

//.
.1o
4
/.
From: Steve lA/allace
[Steve.Wbllacc@gov.ab.cal
Sent: Decernber 17. 2007 4:51 PM
To: Alec BlYth
SuE'ect RE: repott comments
Hl Alec, some rpre @mments on the EmEt report that br sorrn reason I falled to ,ncludo bel'o'*:
Ernst Report
(con't1
Pg 19
-
not surE Wkipedia is a valid rEron souroe, trough l've been out of th academb sceno br arrfille
Pg 19'No CDlrl/G llmib have been elceeded'-can you finbh he sentence off so ib c{ear il apdles b all dl$ued organl(
Pg 23
-
stab rEtson why Ersil udl b not on &ffie
dot
Fig f 0.
Pg 27 t28
-
Menlirn that propan@ftane
8C
h any of the uabr uEIq htt popanqmnane caffir hobpes
imply impact
Itanlq
s*erc
wer measured on 2 wabrwdtsdbse ffifipn!-q_uam.
Pg 2s--2F bst eenbrp.
graffincs[nafura
simihrbrCBM ald wabrrruelb does notnecessarily
Flom: SEve Wallaa
Senh Frlday, [Eaernber t4,20[J7 10:43 AM
To:'Atsc Blyth'
$E* report@mmentr
HiAlec
Sorry br he delay in nry comments, its been pretty cEtzy around bere the last week
Etnrt ReFtrt
/
;
Pg 3t9 - use early 2006 insted of Jan or Feb. I wifl ry b nail down a rpnfi wth he complhnce guys
4/.
Pg5-bstparainsec2.'Largedowrnuardvertcalgradbnts.........areeleected'.Canyoutackon'(seepg. 12or4.4.21'al
,.
the end so that it Is cbar'expected'b veffied later in report
'/
o Pg.6
-
CBM well 100/07-13-27-UIW4M on Table 2 is 00/07-1Y027-22V!4. Preftx 00 or 100 needs to be conecteil
{./-. Pg 8-dadry unibas mbgl (could becorfirad hrrd)
{ .
fFgq-4.z
corretudhn strou[*Oe
qrfir6d
y'o
bgC-#
-
1epa, whd b edandyses ? 2d pra,'debciod h freu,efl in tre pasf -when?
/a
Fig 2
-
red dots look like welts. Can arorE be lnserbdfionr label b black dots?
/g Pg. 12, ld para- insertreftrence b Bacfru&Mk*rael2t02atthe end.
'Please
leave the Kenny well out br now, as you'll address it lnfie other reports. Perhaps send me an updabd draft bebre we
finalize
approprbb (eg. has ornpled insEed of nfiomde)
Pg 6 sec 2.3
-
b 3 l[GV $re[s corecf?
,
A
Pg 8 sec2.4.2
-AQrcE
Pg 11 sec 3.1.1
-'These
rve[..-.'. SarrE bffin of pg h Scc 3.2
Pg 12 sec 3.3.2
-
ld para, 'analy* dgas *6 lap by AE?{\f
Pg 14 sec 5.1.1
-'This
basin
o
bnned-...'Also. cofiuna atend'....craton'- should be pefud
Pg 18 sec 5.3
-'A
cetrer* log sltffIcd
good a cerpnt bontr
Pg 28, 2d para -
n-...in
h D35 waterwell......-
Zlhnmennen ReDort
-/. tnt o
@nse
sounds a litle odd b me (not to mention Mr. Zlmmerman), what do you thlnlo Perhaps
pest bnse is mor
./.
r.
,r
I
. ,/ Pg 30, znd paa
-
"
Of these eight well, the average. ...."
. Pg 32,znd bullet
-
"The AENV (staff member?) involved in the case was not a Hydrogeologist, but they....."
For this report,
just
send me an electronic final version.
Thanks
steve
Steve Vl/allace, fuI.Sc., P.Geol.
Hydrogeologist
Alberta Environment, Groundwater Policy Unit
l0thfl Oxbridge Place,9820 - 106 Street
Edmonton, Alberta T5K 2J6
Phone: (780) 427-9759 Fax: (780) 422-4192
This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to
whom they are addressed. If you have received this email in error please notifu the system manager. This message
contains confidential information and is intended only for the individual named. If you are not the named addressee you
should not disseminate, distribute or copy this e-mail.
1a /r o t-r\A-,
lsgu^e--
Alec Bhrth
,^\
(tqJ
fe /o
'/'
./.
.lf r''
J.
From: Sleve l/lfallace
[Steve.V\Ialhce@gov.ab.cal
t$enft December2A,20/}T 8:19AM
To: Alec Bly0r
Su$ect tanlidsen repqt
Athclrrrents: RE l-aurfulsen s,B[ comphint drdi
HiAlec,
4B*e
find oornrnents bdotir,
l4q
ta
il) t1
./
"/
,
Pg 5, 3tu
Fre-
ppase r*rrc f,or h lhe deper]fCF o tre norffreq/Bacrru and Mf*rad?)
/:
Pg 6, 2d para
-
175.9
-
tf{.qirlC, does not rnabtr up wttr TaUe l,f,rough it nraffires Frg 3.
/o
Pg 7, bp
-
Encana CBM ur*t0OOS,{ 1&7,A,VY4ll. SeposeO b be m? As pg I a br ttunes
y't
Pg E, 2d para
-
a st dy of the pobrdd frr mdrane ni.faton.....b orrersf unda irwesEdim by AEI{V.
rc pgn to npntiu tds sfudy when we dl out the ornplaint review ftdingo, so perhaps we stpuld leave it
outdftbrptt
/,.
Trcof pageg?
o
,,/
.
Pg 11, bp
-
pertry tse 'HtiaH the in@ative prooess'as a fumal 'investigation' (as per legbffion)
was nddoneas fus I anrawe
Tabfe 1
-
mis*ng silrdlot perts on fll/[I7-11 {Pt7-ZBtU4
-T.lfr
aat
ta#
Pg12-ot125 typo
ro
il-l$Uf +(tr?.{trl-zUtftlt
L
W17
4.5.2-tUhqfiPad->
"p8
" -vL'w\P^^'^''
4ot4
Pg 31
-
H para
-
"Itrls ffiliufly vdHaEs.....are the sarne as the e[hane.....'. Pertaps ]rrcntion ftis does
nd necessarly fnply leact
.
AnyoffproommenEfiom Emsfi reporthatrny appfi
Alsd I atEctr a comment by Leslie Millr, whidr you may rrant to consider hcorporbting.
Stev6
Steye Wallace, DISa, P.G@L
Ilydrogeologist
Albefio hvirowstt, M*aq PolW Unit
|0thfl Ox.bridge Place, 9820 - lM Svect
Mnonton Alfurta T5KU6
Phone: (780) 427-9759 Far,: (7E0) 1224192
This email and any files tansmited wi& it are confidential and intnded solely for fte use of the
individual m eutity to ufton
@
ae adfresed. Ifyouhave rEceiwd this mail in error please notify
the system
matrager. T[is message coffiins confidential infomatiq d is irEnded *{y fot th
individual named. Ifyou are notthe nmed adftssee you should not disseminate, distributc or copy ftis
e-mail.
Alec Blytt
fiom: S'Eve l/Uallace
[Steve.\Illallace@gov.ab.caJ
Sent December27,2007 11:27 A?fr
To: Alec Bly0t
Subfect Emst report
Hi Aie
Just a couple of more comments on the Ertrst report, ptrease make the changesthen send final hanlcopies
and CD.
4.
Pg 5
-
last para of Sec 2
-
perhqps
*@lculated"
is more accurate than 'measured'
/ o Pg 19 (4.5.3) - BETX should beaTE(
,/
.
Pg 19 (4.5.4) - last tno sentences
-
should there only be one?
/,
.
Fg 2Q
-senEncaattop
needs conected (The analytical techniques....)
,1/
.
Pg.30, 4rt butlet
-
need to cfrange gradient value (t see ib been revised)
C----'+
*
fu
/>
This cmail and any fiIes trmgnitEd wih it are corfidedial md intooded soldy for fte use of the
individual. or em0iry to urhom trsy
qrc
addressed" If you have receirrcd tris email in emor pleas notifr
the sysm
menager.
This mcssage contains confidmtial infomation and is intenild only for the
individul named" If you are mt tb nmd addrcssee you should not disseminah, distuihtu or copy
tfiis
e-mail.
Thanks
Steve
rl
w
rage r or r
Alec Blyth
*
I
Fom: Steveta{afiae
[Steve.laIaflre@gov.ab.ca]
Sent December2B, 2W7 9:29AM
To: Alec Blyth
Subject Slgnerand Emst Reports
HiAlec
Gomments on the Signer report Please finallze and send report
PgsS-10/05
Pg 6,
O - dease
tefrue bsfi enEnce Hc befue
Tablel-rill(bhtabb
Pg 10, 4.3
-Agpod
qudlty rccorQ b...'
Tabb 2
-rc
make sure taHe is rpt spfft bdrren two pagps
Pg 14
-
1.1.,1. Oily w#r dop (and pocseb g* otsofr0on) oocurc liorn ZXllmg
fit*s
dnce). So trb
heof evt{encebnotmsfrong. Dortreessadly needbct}arge, hltrcedwe nd b begepered frrhe
quedion. ForlnsEne, dalyprpirlgdropsrry befteotsriffiUfiadorreyou mention. SdnebrLauftben
Wop
19n-m3, rhe dne). lf re-mdedt drange h oorctrslon secfron bo.
Pg 34.-
rc
elpard at fie erd of hst paragr4h 6 you dH in tle condus&rns
Pg 34, Sd hdtet Dos not mabfi ffinent in sec 2.2
Comrrenb ln drer rcuiere tH may appf
//'
"a t-ra
''
/.
,:
Also, I lke hor you phrase things at he end of page 31 abotft pmpane/butane (hst senEnce) and wonder if yor
can use ftis rnoding in the Emst report as wdl lf ils not bo late.
f\On-
fsPonsiuc-
Steve
This email and my files tansmitEd with it ue confidential d iffiiled solely for fte usc of th
individual or entity b ntom ttey are addressed. Ifyou bane received this email in arorplease Doti&
th
EM
'nqtragpr.
This message contains confideutial infmdion md is iffided only fc the
individual named" If you are not the nmed addressee you shuld not disminab, distribtle m copy
rhis
o-mail.
@
Alec Bffi
From: Ledie Miller
lleslie.Mille]@gov.ab-cal
Scnt Decernber 18,2@712:08 PM
To: Steve Wbllace
Subfec{: RE: Lauddsen well complalnt draft
HiSbve,
ln Seefron {2 of Sre repdt, t want b dd that
rrrhen Genitsen Dd[ing co]dtJcH the doum hde camera
inspedion of the rrdl, he also did a "frush
and brush'of the rydl (baslcally deand some of tte encrusfiation fsn
me'friOe tre vrdl caslng r.rdrc high prmsnrcd sbem)
prftr to instdling e IEt v PVC liner in trc uell. The tu$l
ard brush' conducbd bf fte aAnei was fre dosest fting b nrainbnance firat has bst done on the LaurUsen
urells{ne he initid oottffiwifit AEI{V.
Nob: afur the holes urere discorrercd in the eirg, the cadng was not rephced - ttre nen A/G lher was mady
plaed insile the conoded c*$ng.
Use the information as you see ftt.
Thanks,
Leslie
Frcm: Steve Wallace
SenE lvlonday, Deernber t7,?:007 8:38 AM
To: Leslle Miller
SubIecfi FW: Laurldsen
tadl omplaint draft
HiLeslie
Here is the link b he tauridsen draft rWft I dL nd ter fiom Ma0n or Daren on the Emst report, if you trink
Urey rnay urant b look at ftis one please pm it on. I wputs sugges(
you pdnt
q coPy dght alpyt
?s
he leporb
Ooi't smy up on tre ARC FTP siti bo lorg. l'tl be ty[E frnaffze a[ thes reporc by year end, so best b gFue rE
any oomments m
qron
as yil cen
(this uueek petsraHy).
Steve
Frcm: Alec BlyUr
[mailb:AhcBlyth@arc.ab.ca]
Sel& Frlday, December 14,2W71:18 Pt'l
To: Steve Wallace
Subjech Lauridsen well comphint draft
HiSEve,
The drad of ffre taudrlsen repot is comple&e. lt is bo
Bqq
to gend
-so-yoq_can
get it here:
ntteyioGiOe.aruaO.calOounifdnauridsen
rlven gomplaint revlew OratpOt
f
VoUTAe
anytouble orquestion,
give ne a call.
Research Hydrogeologist