Public Inquiry - Proof of Evidence List

TESCO / EVERTON INQUIRY LIBRARY
PROOFS OF EVIDENCE
Guide to referencing:
P – Proof W – Written representations
A – Appendices AD – Additional Information
S - Summary CL – Points of Clarification
R – Rebuttal SOCG – Statements of Common Ground
SUPL – Supplementary INSP – Inspector’s questions or notes
ST – Statements INQ – Extra documents submitted to the Inquiry
Latest additions will be highlighted in yellow for a short period
INSPECTOR
Reference Details of document Party Date submitted if after
17th November
INSP/INQ/1 Questions on Air Quality Mr Pykett 22 November
INSP/INQ/2 Questions on Noise Mr Pykett 4 December
INSP/INQ/3 Draft questions on Traffic Issues Mr Pykett 15 December
INSP/INQ/4 Questions for Mr Halman Mr Jackson 9 January
INSP/INQ/5 Note from Inspectors – Mr Ellis additional 30 January

agreed condition – TEV/INQ/29
Documents list dated 6 February 2009 Page 1

17th November
TEV/OPENING Opening Statement by Patrick Clarkson QC Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton 18 November
Football Club Limited (TEV)
TEV/P/1 Proof of Evidence by John Francis on Planning Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
Issues Football Club Limited (TEV)
Appendices by John Francis:- Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton

TEV/A/1 (1) Letter from CDS - Oct 08 Football Club Limited (TEV)
TEV/A/1 (2) Schedule of Stadia Decisions – DPP -Oct 08
TEV/A/1 (3) Alternative Sites Location Plan-DPP -Oct 08
TEV/A/1 (4) Summary of findings on Alternative Sites –
DPP – Oct 08
TEV/A/1 (5) Outline Application Land Parcel Layout -
Broadway Malyan- Apr 08
TEV/A/1 (6) Proposed Masterplan – Broadway Malyan –
May 08
TEV/A/1 (7) Detailed Description of Proposed
Developments – DPP – Oct 08
Overview of Planning Policy- DPP – Oct 08
TEV/A/1 (8)
Mitigation Strategy Site Plan –DPP- Oct 08
TEV/A/1 (9a)
Sports Facilities Plan –DPP- Oct 08
TEV/A/1 (9b)
Schedule of conditions – DPP- Oct 08
TEV/A/1 (10)
Effects Development Proposals upon
TEV/A/1 (11)
Residential Amenity – DPP- Oct 08
Briefing Note to Residents on Impact on

TEV/A/1 (11a) Residential Amenity
TEV/S/1 Summary by John Francis Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton

TEV/S/1 (1) Proposed Masterplan – Broadway Malyan – Football Club Limited (TEV)
May 08
TEV/S/1 (2) Outline Application Land Parcel Layout -
Broadway Malyan- Apr 08

17th November
TEV/P/2 Proof of Evidence by Jeremy Williams on Retail Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
Planning Issues Football Club Limited (TEV)
Appendices by Jeremy Williams Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
TEV/A/2 (1) Table 1C Population Projections – DPP Nov 08 Football Club Limited (TEV)
TEV/A/2 (2) Retail Capacity Impact Assessment
Methodology – DPP - Oct 08
TEV/A/2 (3) PPS6 Town Centre Health Checks DPP Oct 08
TEV/A/2 (4) Kirkby Land Use Plan – GOAD DPP- Oct 08
TEV/A/2 (5.1) Study area Survey Zones Plan –DPP- Sept 08
TEV/A/2 (5.2) Shopping Provision Survey Zones Plan - DPP
-Oct 08
TEV/A/2 (5.3) Commitments Plan – DPP- Oct 08
TEV/A/2 (6) Third Party Representations – DPP- Oct 08
TEV/A/2 (7) Kirkby Merseyside Household Survey- Allegra
Strategies – Nov 06
TEV/A/2 (8) Analysis Comparison Shopping Habits in PCA-
DPP - Oct 08
TEV/A/2 –Addition Addition to Jeremy Williams Proof – Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton 15 January
Appendix 7 –Household Survey Football Club Limited (TEV)
Questions 45-54
TEV/S/2 Summary by Jeremy Williams Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton

TEV/SUPP/2 Additional Tables by Jeremy Williams Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton 8 December
TEV/CL/2 Note to Inspector – Retail Matters Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton 15 January

17th November
TEV/P/3 Proof of Evidence by Melvin Davis on Master Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
planning and design issues Football Club Limited (TEV)
TEV/S/3 Summary by Melvin Davis Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
TEV/P/4 Proof of Evidence by Joe Ellis on Transportation Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
TEV/A/4 Appendices by Joe Ellis Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
TEV/S/4 Summary by Joe Ellis Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
TEV/P/5 Proof of Evidence by Graeme Tulley on Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
Regeneration Issues Football Club Limited (TEV)
TEV/P/5 Errata Errata to TEV/P/5 Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton 27 November
Appendices by Graeme Tulley Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
TEV/A/5 (i) Economic Impact Assessment – DTZ-Oct 08 Football Club Limited (TEV)
TEV/A/5 (ii) Regeneration & Sports Objectives –DTZ-Oct 08
Replacement Appendices by Graeme Tulley Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton 26 November
TEV/A/5/1 Economic Impact Assessment – DTZ-Nov 08 Football Club Limited (TEV)
TEV/S/5 Summary by Graeme Tulley Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton

TEV/P/6 Proof of Evidence by Alan Black on Commercial Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
TEVP/P/6 (1) Letters from Tushingham Moore , Brantano,
Boots and Arcadia Group Ltd
TEV/S/6 Summary by Alan Black Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
TEV/P/7 Proof of Evidence by Philip Coles on Corporate Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
Issues – Tesco Football Club Limited (TEV)

17th November
TEV/P/8 Proof of Evidence by Robert Elstone on the need Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
for a Stadium – Everton Football Club Football Club Limited (TEV)
TEV/A/8 Appendices by Robert Elstone Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton

Obstructed View Drawings – John Holt Football Club Limited (TEV)
Architects Ltd :
TEV/A/8 (1) Level 2- Obstructed View

TEV/A/8 (2) Level 3 - Obstructed View
TEV/A/8 (5) Goodison Road Stand, Upper North End -

Obstructed View
Goodison Road Stand, Upper South End -
TEV/A/8 (6)
Obstructed View
Goodison Road Stand, Top Balcony - Obstructed
TEV/A/8 (7)
View
Gwladys Street Stand Lower Left Quadrant /
TEV/A/8 (8) Centre- Obstructed View
Gwladys Street Stand Lower Right Quadrant /
TEV/A/8 (9) Centre- Obstructed View
Gwladys Street Stand Upper Tier - Obstructed
TEV/A/8 (10) View
Bullens Road Stand Rear Lower Central -
TEV/A/8 (11) Obstructed View
Bullens Road Stand Rear Lower Quadrant -
TEV/A/8 (12) Obstructed View
Bullens Road Stand Upper Tier – Obstructed
TEV/A/8 (13) View
TEV/S/8 Summary by Robert Elstone Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton


17th November
TEV/P/9 Proof of Evidence by Chris Potts on Stadium Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
Location Issues Football Club Limited (TEV)
TEV/A/9 Appendices by Chris Potts Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
(available in hard Football Club Limited (TEV)
copy only)
TEV/S/9 Summary by Chris Potts Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
TEV/P/10 Proof of Evidence by David Keirle on Stadium Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
Design Issues Football Club Limited (TEV)
Appendices by David Keirle-Stadium Plans by Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
Barr : Football Club Limited (TEV)
TEV/A/10 (1) Stadium Site Plan & Roof Plan
TEV/A/10 (2) Stadium – Ground Floor Plan
TEV/A/10 (3) Stadium- 1st Floor Plan
TEV/A/10 (4) Stadium- 2nd Floor Plan
TEV/A/10 (5) Stadium- 3rd Floor Plan
TEV/A/10 (6) Typical Section North Stand (Bment Omitted)
TEV/A/10 (7) Elevation 1 of 2
TEV/A/10 (8) Elevation 2 of 2
TEV/A/10 (9) Stadium- Upper Level Plan
TEV/A/10 (10) Stadium – Upper Deck Plan
TEV/A/10 (11) Typical Section South Stand (Bment Omitted)
TEV/A/10 (12) Stadium Site Plan & Ground Floor Plan
TEV/S/10 Summary by David Keirle Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton
TEV/P/11 Proof of evidence - Noise and Vibration Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton 18 December
TEV/P/11 (Appen a) Note on Acoustic & Vibration Effects of Proposals Football Club Limited (TEV)
on Residential Amenity
TEV/P/11 (Appen b) Note on Design, Construction& Maintenance of
Acoustic Bund
TEV/P/11 (Appen c) Response to Living Conditions- Noise &
Disturbance
TEV /CLOSING Closing Statement by Patrick Clarkson QC Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton 6 February

Miscellaneous Documents Submitted to the Inquiry by Tesco/Everton (TEV)
Reference Details of document Date submitted if after

17th November
TEV/INQ/1 Cherry Field Drive Kirkby – Council Agreement 20 November
TEV/INQ/2 Plan - Landfill Location- Buro Happold 19 November
TEV/INQ/3 Letter from NWRA dated 11/2/2008 to Kirkby Planning Team 19 November
TEV/INQ/4 Letter from NWRA dated 5/6/2008 19 November
Landscape Plans – Broadway Malyan : 20 November

TEV/INQ/5 Public Realm Proposals General Arrangement (colour)
TEV/INQ/5 (1) Public Realm Proposals General Arrangement (black & white)
TEV/INQ/5 (2) Detail Area 1 - Gateway & Boulevard
TEV/INQ/5 (3) Detail Area 2 - Everton Walk & Ramp
TEV/INQ/5 (4) Detail Area 3 - Kirkby Leisure Centre
TEV/INQ/5 (5) Detail Area 4 - Sheet 1 of 2 Kirkby Leisure Centre
TEV/INQ/5 (5.1) Detail Area 4 - Sheet 2 of 2 Kirkby Leisure Centre
TEV/INQ/6 See Section 106 19 November
TEV/INQ/7 (1) Bundle of plans of bund – Superseded 25 November

TEV/INQ/7 (2)
TEV/INQ/7 (3)
TEV/INQ/7 (4)
TEV/INQ/8 Landscape plan- crossroads 25 November
TEV/INQ/9 Response to Inspector’s questions on Air Quality (INSP/INQ/1) 2 December
TEV/INQ/10 Tesco Branch size 2 December
TEV/INQ/11 Review of Visual Impacts 2 December
TEV/INQ/12 Note on Design, Construction & Maintenance of Acoustic Bund 2 December


17th November
TEV/INQ/13 Note on Acoustic & Vibration effects of Proposals on Residential Amenity. 2 December
TEV/INQ/14 Salford Reds Stadium Decision - Letter to Eversheds 3 December
TEV/INQ 14 a Salford Reds Stadium – Conditions 30 January
TEV/INQ/15 Email regarding exclusivity agreement 3 December

TEV/INQ/16 – Text Response to question re initial design 3 December
TEV/INQ/16 Vision for Kirkby – Saunders Architects
TEV/INQ/17 Growth rates & periods from MapInfo Brief 07/02 3 December
TEV/INQ/18 Correspondence between Warren Bradley & Peter Kilfoyle 3 December
TEV/INQ/19 Acoustic Fence Drawing at Narrowest Point- Superseded 3 December

TEV/INQ/20 Acoustic Fence Drawing -Superseded 3 December
TEV/INQ/21 Brief for Council facilities 4 December
TEV/INQ-22 Note on hospitality awards won by Everton FC 10 December
TEV/INQ/23 Notes on termination rights under Tesco/Everton agreement 11 December
TEV/INQ/24 Bund adjacent to Whinberry Drive- update 11 December 2008 11 December
TEV/INQ/25 Schedule of known leases within Kirkby Town Centre (relates to item 7 of 16 December
outstanding matters 16/12/08)
TEV/INQ/26 Decision letter for Dalton Park (relates to item 5 of outstanding matters) 16 December
TEV/INQ/27 Note on Ground Contamination issues 16 December


17th November
TEV/INQ/28 Photographs of sample completed bund/acoustic barrier combination with 8 January
planting
TEV/INQ/29 Joe Ellis’s response to the Inspector’s questions on Transport/Highways 7 January
TEV/INQ/30 Stadium Transport Measures 8 January
TEV/INQ/31 Response to query from Andrew Pykett about the feasibility of a stadium roof 8 January
TEV/INQ/32 Missing sheet from TEV/P/2 –Appendix 7 (submitted by Liverpool CC) 8 January
TEV/INQ/33 Everton Football Club Home Matches 13 January
TEV/INQ/34 Response to Inspector’s questions – G Tulley proof- Indices of Deprivation 13 January
TEV/INQ/35 Appendix Statement on expenditure Growth for Inspector 15 January
TEV/INQ/36 Consultation with Voluntary Organisations by Everton in the Community (EITC) 15 January
TEV/INQ/ 37 Response to questions by Grange Residents Assoc (GRANGE/INQ/5) 20 January
TEV/INQ/38 Letter from Drivers Jonas dated 7th May 2008 21 January
TEV/INQ /39 (i) Response to questions raised by parties with respect to Transport Assessment – 21 January
Various Transport Additional Questions.
TEV/INQ/39(ii) Everton FC Season Ticket Holders 2006/7
TEV/INQ/39(iii) Everton FC Season ticket holders by post code

17th November

TEV/INQ/40 KEIOC Officers and Aims of Group 26 January
TEV/INQ/41 Briefing note on vacation of units in Town Centre 27 January
TEV/INQ/42 Update on ES Addendum Consultation 28 January
TEV/INQ/43 Response to KRAG / INQ/8 28 January
TEV/INQ/44 Retail Travel Distance savings – Joe Ellis 28 January
TEV/INQ/45 Letter from Tesco to Grange Residents – Jan 2008 29 January
TEV/INQ/46 Agreed changes to Section 106 Agreement since Friday 30 January 2009 4 February
Comparison Agreement
Comparison Phasing
TEV/INQ/47- Text Revised Plan 2 for Section 106 Agreement 5 February
Plan

17th November
SUP/KMBC/Opening Opening by Martin Kingston QC Knowsley MBC (KMBC) 18 November
SUP/KMBC/P/1 Proof of Evidence by Sheena Ramsey on Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

Regneration
Appendices by Sheena Ramsey: Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

SUP/KMBC/A/1 (i) Maps of Kirkby
SUP/KMBC/A/1 (ii) Local Areas Agreement Targets
SUP/KMBC/A/1 (iii) Knowsley Employment & Skills Partnership &

Pledge
SUP/KMBC/A/1 (iv) Kirkby Baseline Data
Additional Appendix by Sheena Ramsey in Knowsley MBC (KMBC) 27 November

SUP/KMBC/A/1/1 relation to Kirkby TC Development Proposals
1997 – 2008
Annex 1 Outline Planning Permission Land County Road/
Hall Lane Oct 1997
Annex 2 a Letter CDP to KMBC 5 Nov 98

Annex 2 b Letter CDP to KMBC 19 Nov 98
Annex 3 a Letter KMBC to Tesco Apr 99
Annex 3 b Letter KMBC to Tesco May 99
Annex 4 Letter CDP to KMBC Jun 99
Annex 5 Letter KMBC to Morrisons Aug 99
Annex 6 Letter Morrisons to KMBC Oct 99
Annex 7 Letter Asda to KMBC Jan 02
Annex 8 Letter Mark Hus to KMBC Aug 04
Annex 9 & 10 St Modwen Proposals Oct 04

Fax Mark Hus re St Modwen proposals Nov 04
17th November
Additional Appendix by Sheena Ramsey Knowsley MBC (KMBC) 27 November
SUP/KMBC/A/1/1 –
Annex 11 Letter Asda to KMBC June 05
SUP/KMBC/A/1/1 – KMBC Approval of Development Partner Jul 05

Annex 12
SUP/KMBC/A/1/1 – Letter KMBC -Development Securities plc Jun 07

Annex 13
SUP/KMBC/A/1/1 – Letter KMBC -Development Securities plc Aug 07

Annex 14 a
SUP/KMBC/A/1/1 – Letter KMBC to Tesco Aug 07

Annex 14 b
SUP/KMBC/A/1/1 Letter KMBC -Development Securities plc Jan 08

Annex 15
SUP/KMBC/A/1/ 2 Further Additional Appendix by Sheena Ramsey Knowsley MBC (KMBC) 28 November
SUP/KMBC/S/1 Summary by Sheena Ramsey Knowsley MBC (KMBC)
SUP/KMBC/P/2 Proof of Evidence by Gary Halman on planning Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

Issues
SUP/KMBC/A/2 Appendix to Gary Halman’s Proof of Evidence Knowsley MBC (KMBC) 20 November
SUP/KMBC/S/2 Summary by Gary Halman Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

17th November
SUP/KMBC/P/3 Proof of Evidence by Michael Hollis on Retail & Knowsley MBC (KMBC)
Regeneration Issues
Appendices by Michael Holliss Knowsley MBC (KMBC)
SUP/KMBC/A/3
SUP/KMBC/A/3 (1.1) Socio Economic Baseline Tables

SUP/KMBC/A/3 (1.2) IMD 2007 Kirkby Wards
SUP/KMBC/A/3 (1.3) IMD 2007 Knowsley Borough
Figures and spreadsheets for Retails Spending
Patterns (Derived from NEMS July 08) :
SUP/KMBC/A/3 (2.1) Figure 1 Catchment Area
SUP/KMBC/A/3 (2.2) Figure 2 Catchment Area with Buffers
SUP/KMBC/A/3 (2.3) Knowsley Comparison Spreadsheets
SUP/KMBC/A/3 (2.4) Knowsley Convenience Spreadsheets
SUP/KMBC/A/3 (3) Experian Press Release Oct 08
SUP/KMBC/S/3 Summary by Michael Holliss Knowsley MBC (KMBC)
SUP/KMBC/SUPL/3 Supplementary Proof by Michael Holliss Knowsley MBC (KMBC)
SUP/KMBC/SUPL2 /3 Second Supplementary Proof by Michael Holliss Knowsley MBC (KMBC) 27 November
SUP/KMBC/SUPL3/3 Response to Inspector on Question on Knowsley MBC (KMBC) 11 December

Expenditure Growth
SUP/KMBC/SUPL4/3 Revised Response to Inspectors Question on Knowsley MBC (KMBC) 14 January
Sheet 1 Expenditure Growth
Sheet 2
SUP/KMBC/P/4 Proof of Evidence by Philip Sapiro on Traffic Knowsley MBC (KMBC)
Issues
SUP/KMBC/S/4 Summary by Philip Sapiro Knowsley MBC (KMBC)
SUP/KMBC/R/4 Rebuttal Proof from Philip Sapiro Knowsley MBC (KMBC) 6 January

17th November
SUP/KMBC/R/Joint Rebuttal Proof from Sheena Ramsey, Mike Knowsley MBC (KMBC) 27 November
Holliss & Gary Halman
SUP/KMBC/R/Joint/ Knowsley MBC (KMBC)
Appendices- cover
sheet

Appendix 1 ( 1 of 2) Emails re M Taylor’s Response Nov 08
Appendix 1 ( 2 of 2) M Taylor Response to KMBC Questions Nov 08
Appendix 2 Letter St Modwen to West Lancs DC Apr 08
Appendix 3 (1 of 2) Letter Cushman Wakefield to St Modwen Oct 08

Appendix 3 (2 of 2) Skelmersdale Retail & Leisure Market
-Cushman Wakefield Apr 06
History Skelmersdale Identification 3rd Tier

Appendix 4
Settlement in RSS
GONW RSS to 2021 Statement of reasons
Appendix 5
Further Change
KMBC Proposed Response to SOS Proposed
Appendix 6
Changes to RSS
Kirkby Skelmersdale Baseline Comparisons
Appendix 7 (1 of 2)
Skelmersdale IMD 2007
Appendix 7 (2 of 2)
Summary of Developer & Council Press
Appendix 8 Releases – Skelmersdale Redevelopment
Skelmersdale Estimated Investment
Appendix 9 Skelmersdale – Summary of St Modwen’s
Appendix 10 Latest Financial Position
SUP/ KMBC/CLOSING Closing statement by John Barrett Knowsley MBC (KMBC) 5 February
Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

17th November
KMBC/MISC/1 KMBC Response to Mrs Pethard 18 November
KMBC/MISC/2 KMBC - Impacts on formal sports provision 28 November
Appendix 1 Map of Kirkby Community Area Playing Fields

Appendix 2 Map of Existing Newly Constructed and Proposed Outdoor Facilities

Appendix 3 Inspectors Response KRUDP Inquiry
Appendix 4 Letter Sport England supporting Scheme Oct 08
KMBC/INQ/1 Election Press Coverage 3 December
KMBC/INQ/2 Letter from NWRDA dated 19 November 3 December
Building Schools for the Future Programme 3 December
KMBC/INQ/3 (i) Letter BSF to J Fleming Dec 07

KMBC/INQ/3 (ii) Letter KMBC to J Gittens Jul 07
KMBC/INQ/3 (iii) KMBC Cabinet Report BSF – Revisions to Programme Sept 06
KMBC/INQ/4 KMBC Cabinet Report - UDP Policies to be Saved 3 December
KMBC/INQ/5 St Helens MBC Committee Report re Rugby Stadium 3 December

KMBC/INQ/6 Liverpool City Council Committee Rport re LFC Stadium 3 December
KMBC/INQ/7 KMBC/ TESCO/EFC – Exclusivity Agreement Dates 3 December
KMBC/INQ/8- Text Attractions & Linkages 4 December
KMBC/INQ/8(a)-
Drawing
KMBC/INQ/9 Indices of Deprivation 2007 4 December

17th November
KMBC/INQ/10 Genesis of Proposed Draft Changes to PPS 6 4 December
KMBC/INQ/11 English Partnership Additionality Guide Oct 2008- Economic Multiplier 4 December
KMBC/INQ/12 IMD Mapping- Knowsley & Objecting Authorities 5 December

KMBC/INQ/13 Management Horizons Retail Ranking 2008 5 December
KMBC/INQ/14 (a) Proposals for Redevelopment of Kirkby 9 December

KMBC/INQ/14 (b) Consultation draft –Kirkby Markets Improvements 9 December
KMBC/INQ/14 (c) Kirkby Market Square Concepts-Consultation 9 December
KMBC/INQ/15 Liverpool CC Planning Committee report and minutes 4/6/08 9 December
KMBC/INQ/16 Cabinet Office –Multiple Deprivation in England 10 December
KMBC/INQ/17 Press cuttings –Daily Post 10/12/08 –Alistair Darling 10 December
KMBC/INQ/18 Kirkby Civic Centre - Usage 10 December
KMBC/INQ/19 Extract from Inspector’s Report- Knowsley UDP 10 December
KMBC/INQ/20 Building School for Future locations & approximate distances 11 December
KMBC/INQ/20a More detailed version of KMBC/INQ/20 (related to item 15 of outstanding matters) 16 December
KMBC/INQ/21 KMBC Committee Report - Probity in Planning Jun 07 11 December
KMBC/INQ/22 Liverpool City Council Press Release – 18 May 2006 18 December

KMBC/INQ/22a St Helens Development Review 2007 19 December

17th November
KMBC/INQ/23 Letter from Merseytravel to Inspector dated 13th November 2008 6 January
KMBC/INQ/24 NWRA – North West Economic Baseline – extract from report – July 2005 6 January
KMBC/INQ/25 Philip Sapiro’s response to the Inspector’s questions on Transport/Highways 6 January
KMBC/INQ/26 List of information requested by the Inspector on Monday 15 December 2008 20 January

KMBC/INQ/27 Response to questions raised during Cross Examination of Gary Halman 20 January
KMBC/INQ/28 Response to questions submitted by KRAG to Chief Executive of KMBC 21 January
KMBC/INQ/29 Response to questions submitted from Inspector Mr Jackson (INSP/INQ/4) 21 January
KMBC/INQ/30 Email from Cllr Dave Smithson (14 May 2007) to Liberal Democrat Councillors 22 January
regarding Lib Dem position on Kirkby Plans
KMBC/INQ/31 Archdiocese Land Deal Dec 08 4 February
KMBC/INQ/32 Response to Inspectors request for clarification on Section 106 Agreement items. 5 February
KMBC/INQ/33 Response to KRAG/INQ/13 5 February
KMBC/INQ/34 Controlled Parking Zone Agreement between KMBC and Sefton MBC 6 February

17th November
LCC/OPENING Opening by Stephen Sauvain QC LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC) 18 November
LCC/P/1 Proof of Evidence by Michael Burchnall LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

(was referenced
LCC/P/MJB)
Appendices by Michael Burchnall : LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)
LCC/A/1 (1)
(was referenced LCC UDP Extracts
LCC/A/MJB)

LCC/A/1 (2) Letter LCC to Secretary of State Jul 08
LCC/A/1 (3) Letter King Sturge to KMBC May 08
LCC/A/1 (4) Screening Opinion re Goodison Park Nov 07
LCC/A/1/ (5) Extract Planning Statement Accompanying
Bellefield Planning Application
LCC/A/1 (6) Supplementary Statement – Regeneration
Benefits Linked with Sale of Bellefield.
LCC/A/1 (7) Letter Savills to LCC May 08
LCC/A/1 (8) Demographic Map of Kirkby
LCC/S/1 Summary by Michael Burchnall LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)
LCC/P/2 Proof of Evidence by Andrew Pepler on Retail LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)
Issues
(was referenced
LIV/P/ADP)
LCC/S/2 Summary by Andrew Pepler on Retail Issues LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC) 18 November
LCC/R/2 Rebuttal by Andrew Pepler on Retail Issues LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC) 18 November

17th November
LCC/P/3 Proof of Evidence by Mark McVicar on LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)
(was not Commercial matters and appendices
referenced)
LCC/A/3 (1) Selection of Current UK Retail Involvements
LCC/A/3 (2) Kirkby Retails Plan -GOAD
LCC/A/3 (3) Photographs Kirkby TC
LCC/A/3 (4) Kirkby Lease Expiry Details – GOAD
LCC/A/3 (5) Proposed Masterplan- Colour
LCC/A/3 (6) Location Map of Kirkby and Surrounding Areas
LCC/A/3 (7) 2008 Kirkby Population Projection - CACI
LCC/A/3 (8) Liverpool Echo – Marks & Spencer

Refurbishment
LCC/A/3 (9) Plans Bournemouth – Castlepoint, Cheshunt -
Brookfield Centre
LCC/A/3 (10) Plan Kirkby – Existing & Potential Changes
LCC/A/3 (11) Different Perspective Annual Report 2007 –
Development Securities PLC
LCC/A/3 (12) Marketbeat UK June 07- Cushman Wakefield
LCC/A/3 (13) Proposed Masterplan – Black White
LCC/A/3 (14) Telegraph – Everton Chairman Sell Club-Aug 08
LCC/A/3 (15) EFC Annual Report 2007
LCC/A/3 (16) Kirkby Existing Area Plan
LCC/A/3 (17) Peter Kilfoyle Statement
LCC/A/3 (18) Letter King Sturge to KMBC May 08
LCC/3/P/Addendum Addendum LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC) 9 January
LCC/P/3 - Updated Updated Proof of Evidence by Mark McVicar on LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC) 13 January
Commercial matters and appendices
LCC/S/3 Summary by Mark McVicar on Commercial LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC) 18 November
matters
LCC/CLOSING Closing statement LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC) 5 February
Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Liverpool CC (LCC)

17th November
LCC/INQ/1 Extract from the Inspector’s report (see CD 3.1 (c )) 18 November
LCC/INQ/2 Erratum to LCC/P/1 – this is also attached to LCC/P/1 for completeness 26 November
LCC/INQ/3 Closing submissions from former Bellfield Training Ground -28 November 2008 3 December
LCC/INQ/4 Addendum to LCC/P/2 –Andrew Pepler Proof of Evidence 21 January

LCC/INQ/5 Appeal decision (Appeal Ref :APP/Z4310/A/08/2079502) – Bellefield Training 21 January
Ground . land off Sandforth Road Liverpool 12 and numbers 88,90, 92 & 94
Sandforth Road Liverpool L12 1LW
LCC/INQ/6 Article from Liverpool Daily Post , dated Wednesday 21 January 2009 21 January
Property group feels the pinch as tenants hit trouble.
LCC/INQ/7 Comments from LCC on TEV/INQ/44 30 January
Appendix

17th November
CAO/OPENING Opening by Mr Roger Lancaster COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS 18 November
(CAO)
CAO/P/1 Proof of Evidence by Keith Nutter on Retail COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS

Issues (CAO)
CAO/A/1 Appendices by Keith Nutter COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS

(CAO)
CAO/S/1 Summary by Keith Nutter COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS

(CAO)

CAO/P/2 Proof of Evidence (and appendices) by Phil COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
Megson on Strategic Planning overview (CAO)
CAO /P/ 2-
Appendices Various Correspondence
CAO/S/2 Summary by Phil Megson COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS

(CAO)
CAO/P/3 Proof of Evidence by Ian Gill COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS

(CAO)
CAO/A/3 Appendices by Ian Gill COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
(CAO)
CAO/A/3/1 Letter from English Partnerships dated 12 COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS 18 November
November 2008 (CAO)
CAO/S/3 Summary by Ian Gill COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS

(CAO)
CAO/R/3 Rebuttal Proof by Ian Gill COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS

(CAO)

17th November
CAO/P/4 Proof of Evidence by Michelle Taylor on the COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
impact on the redevelopment of Skelmersdale (CAO)
Appendices by Michelle Taylor : COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
CAO/A/4 (1) Details on Edmonton Green, Trentham Gardens (CAO)
& Longbridge
CAO/A/4 (2) St Modwen Objections to Planning Application
CAO/A/4 (3) Design Standards
CAO/A/4 (a) Email KMBC to St Modwen Dec 01
CAO/A/4 (b) St Modwen News Statements Nov 02 Apr 03 &
June 03
CAO/A/4 (c) Kirkby Retail and Kiosk Details June 03

CAO/A/4 (d) Photos of Kirkby & Email KMBC to St Modwen
re Morrisons Aug 03
CAO/A/4 (e) Plan Kirkby Mar 02
CAO/A/4 (f) Email KMBC to St Modwen Oct 03
CAO/A/4 (g1) Email St Modwen to KMBC Dec 03
CAO/A/4 (g2) New Vision Document
CAO/A/4 (g3) St Modwen News Statement Jan 04
CAO/S/4 - Front Summary of Michelle Taylor COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS 7 January
CAO/S/4 – Summary (CAO)
CAO/R/4 – Front Rebuttal Proof by Michelle Taylor COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
CA0/R/4 -Rebuttal (CAO)
Supplementary Proof by Michelle Taylor COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS 18 November
CAO/SUPL/4 (a) M Taylor Response to KMBC - Proof Of (CAO)
Evidence Questions Nov 08
CAO/SUPL/4 (b) Skelmersdale Draft SPD Apr 08
CAO/SUPL/4 (c) Various Emails St Modwen & KMBC Feb 02 to
Apr 04
CAO/SUPL/4 (d) Email St Modwen to Morrisons Sept 04
CAO/SUPL/4 (e) Letter Cushman & Wakefield to St Modwen re
Skelmersdale Jul 07
CAO/SUPL/4 (f) Retail Occupiers of Skelmersdale, Southport
Wigan

17th November
CAO/SUPL/4 (Plan 1)
CAO/SUPL/4 (Plan 2) Various Plans Southport, Skelmersdale &
CAO/SUPL/4 (Plan 3) Wigan - Cushman & Wakefield
CAO/SUPL/4 (Plan 4)
CAO/SUPL/4 (Plan 5)
Addition to Supplementary Proof by Michelle COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS 24 November
Taylor : (CAO)
CAO/SUPL/4/1 Response to Email 18 Nov 08
CAO/SUPL/4/1-App 1 Retail & Leisure Market Apr 06- Cushman &
Wakefield
CAO/SUPL/4/1-App 2 Skelmersdale Town Centre Estimated
Investment

CAO/P/5 Proof of Evidence by Tom Ferguson on the COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
impact on St Helen’s (CAO)
CAO/A/5 Appendices by Tom Ferguson COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
CAO/S/5 Summary by Tom Ferguson COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
(CAO)
CAO/P/6 Proof of Evidence by Andy Wallis on the impact COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
on Sefton (CAO)
CAO/A/6 Appendices by Andy Wallis COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
CAO/S/6 Summary by Andy Wallis on the impact on COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
Sefton (CAO)
CAO/R/6 Rebuttal Proof by Andy Wallis on the impact on COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
Sefton (CAO)
CAO/P/7 Proof of Evidence by Mr C Hubbard on COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
Commercial Issues (CAO)
CAO/P/7 - Errata Errata to Mr C Hubbard proof & summary COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS 26 January
(CAO/P/7 & CAO S/7) (CAO)
CAO/A/7 Appendices by Mr Hubbard COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
(CAO)
CAO/S/7 Summary by Mr Hubbard COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS
(CAO)
CAO/CLOSING Closing statement COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS 5 February
(CAO)
Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Combined Authority Objectors (CAO)
Reference Details of Document Date submitted if after

17th November
CAO/INQ/1 Press cuttings 27 November
CAO/INQ/2 Match attendance 2 December
CAO/INQ/3 League tables 3 December
CAO/INQ/4 Planning Committee Minutes – Sefton MBC – dated 4 June 2008 7 January

CAO/INQ/5 ‘Agenda Item 11’ – Sefton MBC – 7 May 2008 7 January
CAO/INQ/6 Retail Floorspace in the Skelmersdale TC SPC Masterplan 8 January
CAO/INQ/7 Table 4.1 (amended to reflect potential uplift in Skelmersdale floor space) 13 January
CAO/INQ/7 - Table 4.1 (amended to reflect figures used in RSOCG – Column A of Table 8) 22 January
Updated
CAO/INQ/8 ING Retail Property Fund buys £75 m St Helens shopping centre - extract 13 January
CAO/INQ/9 Amended Impact tables for Mr Nutter 14 January
CAO/INQ/9 – Amended Impact tables for Mr Nutter – for clarity purposes 22 January
Updated
CAO/INQ/10 St Modwen Company Ltd – End of year trading update 20th November 2008 19 January

17th November
GRO/P/1 Proof of Evidence by Grosvenor Limited Grosvenor Limited (GRO)
GRO/A/1 Appendices by Grosvenor Limited Grosvenor Limited (GRO)
GRO/P/2 No document - Reference number not required

GRO/P/3 Further submission by Grosvenor Ltd Grosvenor Limited (GRO) 9 January
Appendix 1 – page 1 Kirkby Town Centre Existing Sources Trade
2008
Appendix 1 – page 2 Total Available Comparison Goods Expenditure

GRO/SUMMARY Summary of proof by Grosvenor Ltd Grosvenor Limited (GRO) 26 January

17th November
KRAG/OPENING Opening by Tony Barton Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 November
(KRAG)
KRAG/P/1 Proof of Evidence by Mr J Gittins Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
(KRAG)
Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
KRAG/A/1 – Front cover Mr J Gittins (KRAG)
Appendix 1
Appendix 1a E-Mails (Arriva & Stagecoach)
Appendix 1b
Kirkby Railway Station evening
Appendix 2 arrivals & departures
Appendix 3 Kirkby Railway Station Saturday

arrivals
Appendix 4 Valley Road Traffic Survey (evening)

Appendix 5 London TravelWatch Board Meeting
Appendix 6 London Assembly Transport
Committee Sports Stadium review
Appendix 7 Emirates Stadium Problems (U Tube
on-line video)
KRAG/S/1- Front sheet Summary of Proof of Evidence by Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
KRAG/S/1 Mr J Gittins (KRAG)
KRAG/P/2 Proof of Evidence by Women’s Health Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
Group (KRAG)
KRAG/A/2 Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December

Women’s Health Group (KRAG)
KRAG/A/2/FANS ‘FANS’ DVD – part of appendices of Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
proof of evidence by Women’s Health (KRAG)
Group

17th November
KRAG/S/2 Summary of Proof of Evidence by Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
Women’s Health Group (KRAG)
KRAG/S/2 –Updated Revised summary by Women’s Health Kirkby Residents Action Group 22 January
Group (KRAG)
KRAG/P/3 Proof of Evidence by Mr P Ross Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
KRAG/A/3- Cover Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mr Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
P Ross (KRAG)
Appendix 1
Appendix 1a
Appendix 1b
Appendix 2
Appendix 3
Appendix 3a

KRAG/S/3 Summary of Proof of Evidence by Mr Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
P Ross (KRAG)
KRAG/P/4 Proof of Evidence by Mr B Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December

Fearnehough (KRAG)
KRAG/A/4 – Front sheet Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mr Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
Appendix 1 B Fearnehough (KRAG)
Appendix 2
Appendix 3
Appendix 4
KRAG/S/4 Summary of Proof of Evidence by Mr Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December

B Fearnehough (KRAG)

17th November
KRAG/P/5 Proof of Evidence by Mrs D Reid Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
(KRAG)
KRAG/A/5- Front sheet Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
Appendix 1 Mrs D Reid (KRAG)
Appendix 2
Appendix 3
Appendix 4
Appendix 5
Appendix 6
Appendix 7
KRAG/P/6 & KRAG/A/6 Proof of Evidence by Mrs P Pendleton Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
Appendices of Proof of Evidence by (KRAG)
Mrs P Pendleton *photographs
included within the Appendices have
been submitted on a separate disk

KRAG/P/7 Proof of Evidence by The Revd Dr Tim Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
Stratford (KRAG)
KRAG/A/7 Appendices of Evidence by The Revd Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
Dr Tim Stratford (KRAG)
KRAG/S/7 Summary of Proof of Evidence by The Kirkby Residents Action Group 18 December
Revd Dr Tim Stratford (KRAG)
KRAG/CLOSING Closing statement on behalf of KRAG Kirkby Residents Action Group 4 February
coalition. (KRAG)
Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

17th November
KRAG/INQ/1 Location of Kirkby Catholic Learning Centre -Options Appraisal 5 December
KRAG/INQ/2 Local Election Press Note 10 December
KRAG/INQ/3 Results of development Securities Public Consultation 10 December
KRAG/INQ/4 Your Kirkby – Your Future – Shaping the future of your town centre 11 December
KRAG/INQ/5 Outstanding questions for Sheena Ramsey 6 January
KRAG/INQ/6 Outstanding questions for Robert Elstone 6 January
KRAG/INQ/7 Question regarding TEV/INQ/16 16 January
KRAG/INQ/8 Question regarding TEV/P/11 20 January
KRAG/INQ/9 Written response to Mr Brennan’ evidence regarding Area Partnership Board 22 January

KRAG/INQ/10 Map of Kirkby area to easily identify areas mentioned in KRAG/P/2 22 January
KRAG/INQ/11 Application of SOCECON / JOINT/1 to KRAG/P/7 23 January
KRAG/INQ/12 Written Response regarding part of Mr Dodd’s evidence 23 January

Appendix
KRAG/INQ/13 Response by KRAG to KMBC/INQ/31 5 February

17th November
KEIOC/P/1 Proof of Evidence by Trevor Skempton Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
(KEIOC)
KEIOC/A/1- front Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Trevor Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
cover Skempton (KEIOC)
Appendix 1 Rebuilding Goodison

Appendix 2 Case Against Everton’s ‘Destination Kirkby’
Appendix 3 Policy DQ1 – Knowsley UDP
Appendix 4 Guidance on Tall Buildings – English Heritage &
CABE
KEIOC/S/1 Summary of Proof of Evidence by Trevor Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
Skempton (KEIOC)
KEIOC/P/2 Proof of Evidence by Dave Thompson Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
(KEIOC)
KEIOC/A/2 – front Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Dave Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
cover Thompson (KEIOC)
Appendix 1 Merseyrail Train Map
Appendix 2 London Assembly (Transport Committee) – A
question of sports travel
Appendix 3 DfT - National Travel Survey 2006

KEIOC/A/A/2 Replacement Appendices of Proof of Evidence Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
by Dave Thompson (KEIOC)
KEIOC/S/2 Summary of Proof of Evidence by Dave Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
Thompson (KEIOC)
KEIOC/P/3 Proof of Evidence by Mark Grayson Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
(KEIOC)
KEIOC/A/3 Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mark Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
Grayson (KEIOC)

17th November
KEIOC/P/4 Proof of Evidence by Colin Fitzpatrick Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
(KEIOC)
KEIOC/A/4-front Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Colin Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
cover Fitzpatrick (KEIOC)
Appendix 1 Redevelopment of Goodison Park – Ward
McHugh Associates
Appendix 2 Liverpool Daily Post Article – 21/7/07
Appendix 3 Sir Terry Leahy Open letter – Liverpool Echo
11/8/07
Appendix 4 Liverpool Daily Post Article – 29/11/08
Appendix 5 Deloitte Letter – 2/4/08
Appendix 6 Simon Inglis Comments
Appendix 7 Distance from Major Centre
Appendix 8 Unsold Seats at Match’s during Season
Appendix 9 Stadium Capital Financing Group Opens London
Office
Appendix 10 AGM Report – 10/12/07
Appendix 11 EGM Transcript – 3/9/08
Appendix 12 Keith Wyness Q & A
Appendix 13 KEIOC Galaxy Survey Results
Appendix 14 Kirkby Business Case spreadsheet
KEIOC/S/4 Summary of Proof of Evidence by Colin Keep Everton In Our City 18 December
Fitzpatrick (KEIOC)

KEIOC/CLOSING Closing statement on behalf KEIOC campaign Keep Everton In Our City 4 February
(KEIOC)
Statements submitted by Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC)

17th November
ST/KEIOC/1 Statement outlining their case Keep Everton In Our City
(KEIOC)
Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC)

17th November
KEIOC/INQ/1 HOC Report 4 December
KEIOC/INQ/2 Daily Mail cuttings- November 2008 4 December
KEIOC/INQ/3 Minutes of KMBC Planning Meeting – 10/12/04 9 December

KEIOC/INQ/4 Knowsley News – June 2007 – Special Kirkby edition 9 December
KEIOC/INQ/5 Everton – EGM Newsletter 9 December
KEIOC/INQ/6 KEIOC Newsletter Issue 1 9 December
KEIOC/INQ/7 Destination Kirkby presentation to George Howarth MP 9 December
KEIOC/INQ/8 Our Kirkby, Our Future pamphlet 9 December
KEIOC/INQ/9 New Stadium – The Observer 9 December
KEIOC/INQ/10 Notes for Meeting 16/01/06 10 December
KEIOC/INQ/11 Newspaper article- Battle Raging for Soul of “The People’s Club” 16 December
(www.irishtimes.com -24/11/08)
KEIOC/INQ/12 Interview between KEIOC and Peter Mc Kenna (www.keioc.net- 16 December
17/11/08)
KEIOC/INQ/13 Letter from Merseyrail to KEIOC dated 10 December 2008 7 January
KEIOC/INQ/14 Destination Kirkby – similar case studies 7 January
KEIOC/INQ/15 Map of the area surrounding Goodison Park 7 January
KEIOC/INQ/16 Letter to Stagecoach Merseyside dated 24 November 2008 7 January

KEIOC/INQ/17 Letter to Arriva dated 24 November 2008 7 January
KEIOC/INQ/18 Map of Goodison area 7 January
KEIOC/INQ/19 Stadium sizes for Everton FC and Liverpool FC 29 January
KEIOC/INQ/19a Updated document on Stadium sizes for Everton FC and Liverpool FC 2 February
WR/KEIOC/INQ/20 Details of timings of FA Cup match- Everton V Liverpool – Wed 4 Feb 09 5 February
Reference Details of document Party Date submitted if after 17th

November
P/KCLD/1 Proof of Evidence by Councillor F Knowsley Constituency Liberal 18 December
Fricker Democrats (KCLD)
P/KCLD/2 Proof of Evidence by Councillor Knowsley Constituency Liberal 18 December

P/KCLD/2 (a) Ian Smith Democrats (KCLD)
KCLD/CLOSING Closing statement by KCLD Knowsley Constituency Liberal 4 February

Democrats (KCLD)
Statements submitted by Mr Fisher - Knowsley Constituency Liberal Democrats (KCLD)
Reference Details of document Party Date submitted if after 17th

November
ST/FISHER/1 Statement outlining his XX Mr Fisher
ST/FISHER/2 Copy of email dated 3 November Mr Fisher 19 November

between Mr Fisher & Mark
Butterworth
Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Knowsley Constituency Liberal Democrats (KCLD)
Reference Details of document Date submitted if after 17th November

KCLD/INQ/1 Developments of Kirkby Town Centre 4 December
KCLD/INQ/2 Boundary commission for England 5 December
KCLD/INQ/3 Email from Alisha Lee, Merseytravel to Councillor Fricker 7 January

17th November
GRANGE/P/1 Proof of Evidence by The Grange Residents The Grange Residents Association 18 December
Association
GRANGE/P/1/A Appendices to Proof of Evidence by The Grange The Grange Residents Association 18 December
Residents Association
GRANGE/P/2 Proof of evidence by The Grange Residents The Grange Residents Association 23 January
Association
GRANGE/A/2 Appendices to Proof of Evidence by The Grange The Grange Residents Association 27 January
GRANGE/P/3 Proof of evidence by The Grange Residents The Grange Residents Association 28 January
Association
Statements submitted by the Grange Residents

17th November
ST/GRANGE/1 Statement by the Grange Residents Committee Grange Residents Committee
on the Impact on Residents
ST/GRANGE/2 Statement by the Grange Residents Committee Grange Residents Committee
ST /GRANGE/3 Questions to Melvin Davies Grange Residents Committee 26 November

WR/GRANGE/1 Outstanding issues- regeneration of Croxteth – Grange Residents Committee 5 February
Fazakerley bund and increased traffic volumes
Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by The Grange Residents Association (GRA)
Reference Document Date submitted if after

17th November
GRANGE/INQ/1 Reply to document TEV/INQ/12
GRANGE/INQ/2 Reply to document TEV/INQ/13 10 December
GRANGE/INQ/3 Statistics on Football related arrests and & banning orders 6 January
GRANGE/INQ/4 Questions from Mrs Pethard on behalf of GRA regarding noise 6 January
GRANGE/INQ/5 Questions from Mrs pethard on behalf of GRA in relation to sunlight and daylight & 12 January
CD 10.1.6 & TEV/INQ/11.

Reference Document Party Date submitted if after
17th November
KRISP/P/1 Proof of Evidence by David Dodd on behalf of Kirkby Residents In Support of 18 December
KRISP Progress (KRISP) – Kirkby Small
Firms Forum
KRISP/P/2 Updated Proof of evidence by David Dodd on Kirkby Residents In Support of 20 January
behalf of KRISP (reformatted original proof) Progress (KRISP) – Kirkby Small
Firms Forum
Statements submitted by KRISP

17th November
ST/KRISP/1 Statement outlining their case KRISP

Proofs submitted by Mr S Harrison

17th November
P/HARRISON.S/1 Proof of Evidence by Mr Steve Harrison Mr Stephen Harrison 18 December
A/HARRISON.S/1 Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mr Steven Mr Stephen Harrison 18 December

Harrison
S/HARRISON.S/1 Summary of Proof of Evidence by Mr Steven Mr Stephen Harrison 18 December

Harrison
WR/HARRISON/1 Additional information from Mr Steven Harrison Mr Stephen Harrison 30 January
Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Mr S Harrison
Reference Document Date submitted if after

17th November
HARRISON/INQ/1 Network Rail – Route Utilisation Strategy – Draft for Consultation 6 January 2009
HARRISON/INQ/2 Merseyrail Timetables 6 January 2009
HARRISON/INQ/3 National Fan Survey – extract 6 January 2009
HARRISON/INQ/4 Paper Cutting 10 September 1997 7 January 2009

HARRISON/INQ/5 Article from Merseyrail – 6 January 2009 7 January 2009
Reference Document Party Date submitted if after 17th

November
KTA/P/1 Proof by Mr Thomas Norman on Kirkby Traders Association 18 December
behalf of the Kirkby Traders
Association
KTA/P/2 Proof by Mrs Irene Brand on Kirkby Traders Association 18 December

Association
KTA/P/3 Proof by Mr Jason Keen on behalf Kirkby Traders Association 18 December

of the Kirkby Traders Association
KTA/P/4 Proof by Mr Kevin Routeledge on Kirkby Traders Association 18 December

Association
KTA/P/5 Proof by Mr Rodney Smith on Kirkby Traders Association 18 December

Association
KTA/CLOSING Closing statement by Mr Thomas Kirkby Traders Association 4 February

Norman on behalf of the Kirkby
Traders Association

Proof and Statements submitted by 3RD Parties
Reference Document Party Date submitted if

after 17th November
OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P Proof of Evidence by Mrs Rona Mrs Rona Hazlehurst 18 December
Hazlehurst
OBJ/HAZLEHURST/A Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mrs Mrs Rona Hazlehurst 18 December

Rona Hazlehurst
OBJ/HAZLEHURST/S Summary of Proof of Evidence by Mrs Mrs Rona Hazlehurst 18 December

Rona Hazlehurst
OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/ADDENDUM Addendum to Proof Mrs Rona Hazlehurst 8 January

(a)
OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/ADDENDUM
(b)
(c)
(d)
OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/1 (a) Further Proof of Evidence Mrs Rona Hazlehurst 8 January

OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/1 (b)
OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/1 (c)
OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/1 (d)
OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/1 (e)
OBJ/INEZ/1 Objection Statement by Ms. Phyllis Ms. Phyllis Inez 18 December

Inez
P/McDONALD/1 Proof by Mr Ian Mc Donald on behalf Everton Independent Blues 18 December

of Everton Independent Blues

after 17th November
P/McDONALD -Updated Updated proof by Mr Ian Mc Donald on behalf Everton Independent Blues 26 January
of Everton Independent Blues
App/McDONALD -Updated Appendices Ian Mc Donald on behalf of Everton Independent Blues 26 January
Everton Independent Blues
CL/MCDONALD/1 Clarification by Ian Mc Donald on behalf of Everton Independent Blues 5 February

Everton Independent Blues
CL/MCDONALD/1 (b)
RAMBLERS/P/1 Proof by Mr David Dent on behalf of the Ramblers Association 18 December

Ramblers Association
ST/ABBOTT/1 Statement from Mr John Abbott Mr John Abbott 9 January
ST/BARTON.A/1 Statement from Tony Barton Mr Tony Barton 8 January
ST/BARTON.A/1/Updated Updated statement from Tony Barton Mr Tony Barton 21 January
ST/BARTON.L/1 Statement by Ms. Liza Barton Ms. Liza Barton 18 December
ST/BRENNAN/1 Statement by Mr Tony Brennan Mr Tony Brennan 18 December
ST/CHAPMAN/1 Statement by Mr Reginald Chapman Mr Reginald Chapman 18 December
ST/CORNWALL/1 Statement from Mr David Cornwall Mr David Cornwall 13 January
ST/DE-GIER/1 Statement by Mr Matthew De-Gier Mr Matthew De-Gier 18 December

after 17th November
ST/DE-GIER/1- Updated Updated statement from Mr Matthew De – Mr Matthew De-Gier 26 January
Gier
ST/DRUMMOND/1 Statement by Judi Drummond Judi Drummond 5 February
ST/FLEMING.J/1 Statement by Mr John Fleming Mr John Fleming 18 December
ST/FRAUGHN/1 Statement by Mr Edward Fraughn Mr Edward Fraughn 18 December
ST/GALLAGHER/1 Statement from Mr Michael Gallagher Mr Michael Gallagher 9 January
ST/HARRISON.B/1 Statement by Mr Bernard Harrison Mr Bernard Harrison 18 December
ST/HAMILL/1 Statement by P Hamill Mr P Hamill 12 January
ST/MARTIN.R/1 Statement by Ronald Martin Mr Ronald Martin 4 December
ST/MCCORMICK/1 Statement by Mr McCormick Mr MC Cormick 8 January
ST/MCVEIGH/1 Statement from Mr T McVeigh Newtown Cabs Ltd 20 January
ST/MURPHY/1 Statement by Mrs A Murphy Mrs Ann Murphy 22 January
ST/O’BRIEN/1 Statement by Chris O’Brien Chris O’Brien 18 December
ST/REID/1 Statement by Mrs D Reid Mrs D Reid 18 December
ST/RIMMER/1 Statement by Mr John Rimmer Mr John Rimmer 18 December

after 17th November
ST/RIMMER/- Updated Updated statement by Mr John Rimmer Mr John Rimmer 12 January

ST/RIMMER/Updated Clarification and copies of all correspondence Mr John Rimmer 5 February
Addendum from Mr J Rimmer
ST/SCOTT/1 Statement by Mr Scott – Brookhaven Brookhaven Residents 8 January

ST/TONER/1 Statement by Mrs Catherine Toner Mrs Catherine Toner 18 December
ST/WHITE/1 Statement from Mr John White Mr John White 13 January
ST/WILLIAMS/1 Statement from Mr R Williams The Oakfield Project 20 January
SUP/ST/OKTA/1 Statement by Mr Brian Caulfield on behalf of OKTA 18 December

‘Official’ Kirkby Traders Association
Written Representations
Reference Document Party Date submitted if after 17th

November
WR/Cooltrader/1 Written Representation from Cooltraders
Cooltrader submitted by Edmund
Kirby

WA/Cooltrader/1 Appendices from Cooltrader
WR/CPRE/1 Written Representation by CPRE Mr Murray 18 December

WR/FLEMING.V/ 1 Written Representation Mrs Veronica Fleming 18 December
WR/Iceland/1 Written Representation from Iceland Foods Limited
Iceland submitted by Edmund
Kirby
WA/Iceland/1 Appendices from Iceland
WR/Iceland/A Extra letter dated 6th November

via Agent
WR/INEZ/1 Written Representation Phyllis Inez 2 February
WR/ING/1 Written Representation from ING Property Fund Britannica (ING)
submitted by Edmund Kirby
WR/ING/1(1) Letter Y Parker 7.11.08
WA/ING/1 Appendices from ING
WR/MPMGT/1 Millbrook Park Millennium Green Mr Gittens on behalf of Trust 10 December
Trust Papers
WR/PENDLETON/1 Written Representation Mr Edward Pendleton 18 December
WR/POVER/1 Written Representation Mr Steven Pover 18 December
WR/RCO/1 Written Representation Rosie Cooper MP for West 18 November
Lancashire
WR/RCO/2 Additional Written Representation Rosie Cooper MP for West 30 January
Lancashire
WR/SLP/1 Written Representation Skelmersdale Limited Partnership 18 November
WR/WOOLFORD/1 Written Representation Mr Woolford 18 December
WR/WOOLFORD/1 – Back page
Statements of Common Ground

after 17th November
SOCG/RETAIL/1 Statement of Common Ground on Retail
Issues
SOCG/RETAIL/2 Statement of Common Ground on Retail 17 November

Issues
SOCG/RETAIL/3 Statement of Common Ground on Retail 13 January
Issues
SOCG/RETAIL/4 Statement of Common Ground on Retail 26 January

Issues
SOCG/GENERAL/1 Statement of Common Ground on

SOCG/GENERAL/1 (1) Planning Issues
SOCG/GENERAL/1 (2)
SOCG/GENERAL/1 (3)
SOCG/GENERAL/1 (3.2)
SOCECON/JOINT/1 Statement of Common Ground- Statistical 13 January

Evidence Base
RETAIL/JOINT/1 Composite Document Dealing with 30 January

Appendix a Reduced Comparison Growth Rates
Appendix b
Appendix c
S106 Agreement

after 17th November
S106 Agreement Tesco & Everton 18 November
S106 Appendix

S106 Plan A Tesco Freehold & Leasehold Tesco & Everton 18 November
S106 Plan B Tesco Controlled Land Tesco & Everton 18 November
Section 106 /2 Updated from 18 November Tesco & Everton 12 December
Section 106 /2 Appendices Updated Tesco & Everton 15 January
Section 106/3 Updated from 12 December Tesco & Everton 6 February
Conditions of Agreement

after 17th November
TEV/KMBC/CONDITIONS/1 Conditions of agreement between Tesco / Tesco Stores Limited/ Everton 19 January
KMBC Fottball Club Limited(TEV) / KMBC
TEV/KMBC/CONDITIONS/2 Updated conditions of agreement Tesco Stores Limited/ Everton 29 January

Appendix between Tesco / KMBC Fottball Club Limited(TEV) / KMBC
TEV/KMBC/CONDITIONS/3 Updated conditions of agreement Tesco Stores Limited/ Everton 5 February

between Tesco / KMBC Fottball Club Limited(TEV) / KMBC

Public Inquiry - Proof of Evidence List

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

You might also like

Public Inquiry - Proof of Evidence List

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Public Inquiry - Proof of Evidence List

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

TESCO / EVERTON INQUIRY LIBRARY

Latest additions will be highlighted in yellow for a short period

INSP/INQ/2 Questions on Noise Mr Pykett 4 December

INSP/INQ/3 Draft questions on Traffic Issues Mr Pykett 15 December

INSP/INQ/4 Questions for Mr Halman Mr Jackson 9 January

INSP/INQ/5 Note from Inspectors – Mr Ellis additional 30 January

Reference Details of document Party Date submitted if after

Documents list dated 6 February 2009 Page 1

Appendices by John Francis:- Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton

Briefing Note to Residents on Impact on

TEV/S/1 Summary by John Francis Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton

Documents list dated 6 February 2009 Page 2

TEV/S/2 Summary by Jeremy Williams Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton

Documents list dated 6 February 2009 Page 3

TEV/A/5 (ii) Regeneration & Sports Objectives –DTZ-Oct 08

TEV/S/5 Summary by Graeme Tulley Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton

Documents list dated 6 February 2009 Page 4

TEV/A/8 Appendices by Robert Elstone Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton

TEV/A/8 (1) Level 2- Obstructed View

TEV/A/8 (5) Goodison Road Stand, Upper North End -

TEV/S/8 Summary by Robert Elstone Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton

Documents list dated 6 February 2009 Page 5

Documents list dated 6 February 2009 Page 6

Reference Details of document Date submitted if after

TEV/INQ/2 Plan - Landfill Location- Buro Happold 19 November

TEV/INQ/4 Letter from NWRA dated 5/6/2008 19 November

Landscape Plans – Broadway Malyan : 20 November

TEV/INQ/7 (1) Bundle of plans of bund – Superseded 25 November

TEV/INQ/8 Landscape plan- crossroads 25 November

TEV/INQ/9 Response to Inspector’s questions on Air Quality (INSP/INQ/1) 2 December

TEV/INQ/10 Tesco Branch size 2 December

TEV/INQ/11 Review of Visual Impacts 2 December

TEV/INQ/12 Note on Design, Construction & Maintenance of Acoustic Bund 2 December

Documents list dated 6 February 2009 Page 7

Reference Details of document Date submitted if after

TEV/INQ/14 Salford Reds Stadium Decision - Letter to Eversheds 3 December

TEV/INQ 14 a Salford Reds Stadium – Conditions 30 January

TEV/INQ/15 Email regarding exclusivity agreement 3 December

TEV/INQ/18 Correspondence between Warren Bradley & Peter Kilfoyle 3 December

TEV/INQ/19 Acoustic Fence Drawing at Narrowest Point- Superseded 3 December

TEV/INQ-22 Note on hospitality awards won by Everton FC 10 December

TEV/INQ/23 Notes on termination rights under Tesco/Everton agreement 11 December

TEV/INQ/24 Bund adjacent to Whinberry Drive- update 11 December 2008 11 December

TEV/INQ/27 Note on Ground Contamination issues 16 December

Documents list dated 6 February 2009 Page 8

Reference Details of document Date submitted if after

TEV/INQ/29 Joe Ellis’s response to the Inspector’s questions on Transport/Highways 7 January

TEV/INQ/30 Stadium Transport Measures 8 January

TEV/INQ/33 Everton Football Club Home Matches 13 January

TEV/INQ/34 Response to Inspector’s questions – G Tulley proof- Indices of Deprivation 13 January

TEV/INQ/35 Appendix Statement on expenditure Growth for Inspector 15 January

TEV/INQ/ 37 Response to questions by Grange Residents Assoc (GRANGE/INQ/5) 20 January

TEV/INQ/39(iii) Everton FC Season ticket holders by post code

Miscellaneous Documents Submitted to the Inquiry by Tesco/Everton (TEV)

Reference Details of document Date submitted if after

Documents list dated 6 February 2009 Page 9

TEV/INQ/41 Briefing note on vacation of units in Town Centre 27 January

TEV/INQ/42 Update on ES Addendum Consultation 28 January