Table S1: Critical appraisal form

Adapted from:
Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP), Public Health Resource Unit, nstitute of
Health Science, !"ford#
!"man A$, Cook $%, &u'att &H (())*)# Users+ guides to the medical literature# ,#
Ho- to use an o.er.ie-# %A/A 010: (2314(21(#
R5,56 7!CUS Clearl'
(80)
Some-ha
t (8()
9o or
can+t tell
(:)
9otes
(# $id the re.ie- address a clearl'
focussed issue;
Consider -hether the authors reported
inclusion criteria according to PC! or
-hether there -as substantial .ariation
in the studies included -ith regards to:
Participants (end4users and
patients)
Settings
$omain (condition, acti.it',
impact and outcomes
considered)
Comparisons made

Pada abstrak
dengan tulisan
ber-arna biru
halaman 3*3
menun<un<ukan
kriteria no (
dengan * poin
'aitu participants,
setting, domain
dan comparison
made terpenuhi
dengan baik#
0# $id the re.ie- assess a clearl'
focussed technolog';
Consider -hether the authors reported
e"plicit inclusion criteria regarding the
technical specification of the
inter.ention and its use or -hether
there -as substantial .ariation in the
studies regarding the inter.ention and
its use#
f more than one technolog' -as
assessed, -ere the technologies and
their relationship to the other
technologies clearl' delineated;

Pada method
halaman 3*3
hingga 3*1
penulis
men<elaskan
spesifikasi teknis
penelitian#
=ermasuk <uga
cara
mendapatkan
data lalu lintas
'ang dibutuhkan
untuk menun<ang
penelitian
2# $id the authors look for the
appropriate sort of papers;
Consider -hether the authors reported
Pada method
halaman 3*1 dan
3*> penulis
melaporkan
-hat stud' designs -ere eligible and
the reasons for doing so# Additionall',
consider -hether the studies had:
!utcomes rele.ant to re.ie-
ob<ecti.e
A design and methods
appropriate for addressing the
re.ie- ob<ecti.e

metode
penelitian 'ang
dilakukan 'aitu
case control dan
merupakan
metode 'ang
rele.an untuk
menun<ang ob<ek
penelitian serta
menggunakan
pembatasan
analisis 'aitu
han'a untuk
anak 'ang
ber<arak :,*?m
dari rumah untuk
mendukung
penelitian#
,A@$=A !7 R5,56 R5SU@=S Clearl'
(80)
Some-hat
(8()
9o or
can+t tell
(:)
9otes
*# $o 'ou think the important, rele.ant
studies -ere included;
@ook for the usual on the databases
used, -hether unpublished research
searched, if rele.ant references
re.ie-ed, plus searching:
Health nformatics resources
Personal contact -ith e"perts
nternet
Additionall', does the search string
demonstrate a-areness of inde"ing
issues in H; Has the re.ie- been
update if much time has passed since
the searches and publication;

Pada method
halaman 3*1
di<elaskan bah-a
ada sumber info
kesehatan,
kontak dengan
ahli dan <uga
internet untuk
mendukung
penelitian# Salah
satu contohn'a
adalah
menggunakan
stata sof-are,
data dari
departemen
teknis lalu lintas
dan lain4lain
untuk
melengkapi
kebututuhan data
penelitian#
B# $id the re.ie-+s authors do enough
to assess the Cualit' of the included
studies;
Consider -hether the' performed
assessment -ith tool , characterised
Cualit' b' assigning le.el of e.idence

Pada method
halaman 3*1
men<elaskan alat
atau cara teknis
'ang digunakan
dalam
mendukung
b' stud' t'pe onl', or limited inclusion
to rigorous designs etc (unit of anal'sis
especiall' important, contamination,
confound)#
penelitian
sehingga dapat
membuktikan
kebenaran data
penelitian
tersebut#
3# 6ere the studies accuratel'
described;
@ook for the usual on design, methods
and results and Cualit' plus s'stem
functionalit', integration, deplo'ment
strateg', user4s'stem interaction,
organisational conte"t, timing of stud',
and an' negati.e findings#
1# Are the results reported in a clear
and meaningful -a';
Ho- are the results structured and
ho- are the' presented
(summarisation, reproduction or
interpretation, neither)

Pada result
halaman 3*1
di<elaskan secara
<elas
perhitungan
mengenai rasio
kecelakaan
anak4anak
tertinggi ter<adi
pada anak4anak
asia 'aitu B,> kali
lebih tinggi
dibandingkan
dengan anak4
anak berkulit
putih#
># f the results of included ha.e been
combined, -as it reasonable to do so;
Consider if there -as substantial
heterogeneit' amongst studies in terms
of settings andDor conditions, Cualit',
comparisons made, timing of, s'stem4
user interaction, sophistication andDor
and deplo'ment strateg'#
7or meta4anal'sis consider in addition
the choice of effects model and
summar' measures, and the results of
interaction or statistical heterogeneit'#
7inall' -hether the reasons for an'
.ariations in impact are anal'sed
andDor discussed#

Pada method
dan result
halaman 3*1
disebutkan
adan'a
heterogenitas
substansial studi
dalam penelitian
'aitu ras dari
anak4anak ob<ek
penelitian, <arak
rumah dan -aktu
penelitian 'ang
berbeda4beda#
)# $id the re.ie- demonstrate
a-areness of its o-n limitations;
Pada @imitations
halaman 3*)
penulis
Consider -hether the re.ie- noted
@imitations of included studies
@imitations of the re.ie- itself
7indings in light of research

menuliskan
keterbatasan4
keterbatasan
'ang ada dalam
penelitian
tersebut# Salah
satun'a adalah
membatasi
pengukuran
polisi tidur pada
anak4anak
kemudian
mengabaikan
efek
perlindungan
proteksi dari
polisi tidur
disekitar rumah
anak4anak#
R5SU@=S Clearl'
(80)
Some-ha
t (8()
9o or
can+t tell
(:)
9otes
(:# $oes the re.ie- present an o.erall
result;
Consider
f 'ou are clear about the
re.ie-s Ebottom line+ results
6hat these are (numericall' or
narrati.el')
Ho- -ere the results e"pressed
(conclusi.enessDdoubt)

Pada abstrak
halaman 3*3
men<elaskan
cukup baik
mengenai
gambaran
penelitian#
=ermasuk hasil
dari penelitian
'ang dilakukan
'aitu perhitungan
!R pada anak4
anak 'ang
mengalami
kecelakan lalu
lintas di <alan
ra'a#
((# Ho- precise are the results;
Are the results presented -ith
confidence inter.als if e"pressed
numericall'; 9arrati.e structure for
assigning le.els of e.idence;
APP@CAF@=A Clearl'
(80)
Some-hat
(8()
9o or
can+t tell
(:)
9otes
(0# 9e"t steps or implications for
considering implementation of such
technologies; Appropriate based on
findings and other pertinent factors;
7urther research indicated;

Pada bagian
Conclusions
halaman 3*)
men<elaskan
adan'a
pengiimplementasi
an penelitian
dilingkup geografis
lokal dan
mengundang
penelitian
tambahan pada
efektifitas inter.ensi
lalu lintas
(2# Are the results generalisable
be'ond the confines of the setting in
-hich the -ork -as originall'
conducted;
Consider -hether the authors noted
the generalisabilit' of their results
and an' heterogeneit'# Additionall',
consider -hether enough detail -as
presented on s'stem functionalit',
integration, deplo'ment strateg',
user4s'stem interaction,
organisational conte"t, timing of
stud', and an' negati.e findings#
mportantl', the proportion of studies
from benchmark leaders and
academic institutions should also be
considered#

Pada conclusions
halaman 3*)
di<elaskan proses
pengenerealisasian
penelitian dilakukan
ditempat a-al
dilakukan penelitian
dan digunakan
dalam ruang
lingkup lokal dan
tidak melampaui
dari batas4batas
pengaturan
penger<aan
penelitian#
(*# 6ere all rele.ant outcomes
considered;
$epending on the re.ie- ob<ecti.e,
-ere all outcomes rele.ant to
ans-ering that Cuestion considered;

Conclusions
halaman 3*)
secara tidak
langsung
menun<ukan
rele.ansi karena
penelitian
menggunakan
obser.asi langsung
bukti bah-a
kecepatan
berpengaruh
terhadap
penurunan <umlah
cedera pe<alan kaki
anak4anak#
(B# Are 'ou able to assess the
benefit .ersus risk and costs;
5.en if this is not addressed b' the
re.ie-, -hat do 'ou think; 6as
there an' discussion of negati.es
such as costs or risks;

$alam discussion
halaman 3*1, tidak
dibahas mengenai
pembia'aan
pembuatan polisi
tidur disuatu
lingkungan padat
anak4anak untuk
mendukung
keberhasilan
penelitian
penurunan <umlah
pe<alan kaki anak4
anak 'ang cedera
akibat kecelakaan
lalu lintas