PAKISTAN JOURNAL OF MEDICAL SCIENCES

www.pjms.com.pk
EVALUATION OF MANUSCRIPT FOR PUBLICATION
Guid!i"s #o$ R%iw$s&
The manuscript being sent !r re"ie# is c!ni$entia% $!cument& hence it sh!u%$ n!t be
$iscusse$ #ith the auth!rs' in case (!u #ish t! c!nsu%t s!me c!%%eagues p%ease $iscuss this
#ith the e$it!rs irst
) The ina% $ecisi!n t! accept !r re*ect the manuscript rests #ith E$it!ria% Managing C!mmittee'
) In case a manuscript is re*ecte$+ the re"ie#ers are e,pecte$ t! gi"e $etai%e$ reas!ns' I a
#rite-up can be impr!"e$+ gi"e $etai%e$ rec!mmen$ati!ns #hich #!u%$ he%p the auth!rs'
Manuscript Re' N!' '()*++,EJS)-(*(. Tit%e ! the Manuscript. T/ #i$s0 /1$0 sou"d 1mp!i0ud
usi"2 di2i01! sop/121! s00/oscop s3s0m is p$opo$0io"1! 0o 0/ c/1"2 i" c1$di1c
ou0pu0.
Re"ie#er/s Name. D$. F1$14 S/1#i5
The manuscript can be c%assiie$ as.-
0Tic1 #hich e"er is app%icab%e2
SCORE 3UI4E 0T! be use$ b( the Reeree 5 Re"ie#er2
The Manuscript is. Be%!# Stan$ar$ A%$12
Satisact!r( 3!!$ Ver( 3!!$
Continued on back page
6' Tit%e . Is it Accurate+ C!mprehensi"e
No
7' Abstract is structure$ 0Ob*ecti"e+ Meth!$!%!g(+ Resu%ts+
C!nc%usi!n2 an$ c!n"e(s the message eecti"e%(8
6s
6s
9' :e( ;!r$s are appr!priate
6s
G"$1! Co"sid$10io"s
<' Are the in$ings in the manuscript imp!rtant8
6s
=' 4!es the paper c!ntain Ne# i$eas5in$ings8
>es N!
?' I n!t @ 4!es it present !%$ materia% in a better #a(8 >es N!
A' Reerences are as per uni!rm reBuirement !r Bi!me$ica% C!urna%s
as per ICMCE gui$e%ines8
>es N!
D' Are the ethica% c!nsi$erati!ns a$eBuate%( a$$resse$8
6s
Spci#ic Co"sid$10io"s
E' Is the re"ie# ! %iterature c!mprehensi"e an$ re%e"ant8
No
6F' 4!es it c!ntain reerence t! %!ca% stu$ies $!ne in Pa1istan5
in the regi!n8
>es N!
66' Are the aims an$ !b*ecti"es c%ear%( speciie$
6s
67' Is the samp%e 0i app%icab%e2 a$eBuate%( $escribe$8
an$ Meth!$s c%ariie$8
6s
O$i2i"1! A$0ic!
7
Note: Manuscript with Reviewers Comments.
69' Are the $ata c!%%ecti!n instruments+ inc%u$ing Buesti!nnaires
0i app%icab%e2 c%ear%( $escribe$8
>es N!
6<' Is the research $esign 0i app%icab%e2 a$eBuate t! achie"e the
!b*ecti"e ! the stu$(8
6s
6=' Are the statistica% tests *ustiie$8 >es N!
6?' 4!es it reBuire c!nsu%tati!n b( a statistician8 6s
6A' Are the tab%es 0i app%icab%e2 c%ear an$ tit%e$8 6s
6D' Are the tab%es+ igures+ ph!t!graphs useu%+ re%e"ant 0i app%icab%e2 6s
6E' 4! the resu%ts a$$ress the aims ! the stu$(8 6s
7F' 4!es the $iscussi!n e,p%ain the in$ings in c!mparis!n #ith
!ther $ata a"ai%ab%e8
No
76' C!nc%usi!ns. Are the c!nc%usi!ns appr!priate8 6s
77' Gas the %imitati!ns ! the stu$( been menti!ne$ b( the auth!rs8 6s
79' 4!es the #rite up retain ba%ance an$ gi"e suicient #eightage
t! c!ntrar( "ie#p!ints8
>es N!
7<' ;i%% this manuscript a$$ t! e,isting 1n!#%e$ge in this ie%$8 6s
7=' 4!es it c!n"e( the message c%ear%(8 No
(Comments to be communicated to authors. please use additional sheet if given space is not enough)
G"$1! Comm"0s ,Fo$ Au0/o$s.
P!1s $%iw m3 comm"0s o" 0/ 080
Spci#ic Comm"0s ,Fo$ Au0/o$s.
C!mments !r E$it!r.
;RITTEN EN3LISG H
REPORT 0State c%ear%(2
I appr!"e$+ #hat sh!u%$ be the !"era%% pri!rit( sc!re !r pub%icati!n8
D$. F1$14 S/1#i5
4ate. Mo"d13 7
"d
Dcm9$ 7+'( Re"ie#er/s Signature
P!!r
Appr!"e$ Appr!"e$
Ad%isd R%isio"
Poo$
Immediate
Routine Can wait publication
4ear auth!r e mai% 4ec'9+ 7F69
This reers t! (!ur manuscript N!' ECS-<9D9' ;e ha"e g!t it re"ie#e$' The re"ie#ers c!mments are
mar1e$ !n the manuscript'
Re"ie#e$ b(
4r' FaraI ShaiB
Aga :han Uni"ersit( G!spita%
:arachi' Pa1istan'
6' P%ease pr!"i$e in$i"i$ua% auth!rs c!ntributi!n' See semen as attachment'
7' Pr!"i$e $!i ! th!se reerences #here a"ai%ab%e'
9' Other c!mments an$ suggesti!ns are mar1e$ !n the manuscript'
P%ease re"ise an$ resubmit resp!n$ing t! re"ie#ers c!mments an$ suggesti!ns' Ma1e sure t! ma1e
a%% changes in the i%e being sent as attachment an$ high%ight !r eas( i$entiicati!n #hich #i%%
ensure spee$( pr!cessing'
Shau1at A%i Ca#ai$
Managing E$it!r
Pa1 C Me$ Sci