The Youth MP's in NSW voted to restore the right to silence for those accused of crimes. They passed the Restoration of the Right to Silence Bill to repeal a section of the Evidence Act that allowed courts to make negative inferences from those who remained silent. A Youth Member said this protects vulnerable people, especially non-English speakers. The Bill follows a committee investigation that found the Evidence Act infringed on legal and human rights principles by putting pressure on those being questioned. Another Youth Member said stress or fear during police interviews could lead people to self-incrimination as they cannot reliably recall events. The NSW Government and Opposition will now consider the views of young people on this issue based on the committee's recommendations.
The Youth MP's in NSW voted to restore the right to silence for those accused of crimes. They passed the Restoration of the Right to Silence Bill to repeal a section of the Evidence Act that allowed courts to make negative inferences from those who remained silent. A Youth Member said this protects vulnerable people, especially non-English speakers. The Bill follows a committee investigation that found the Evidence Act infringed on legal and human rights principles by putting pressure on those being questioned. Another Youth Member said stress or fear during police interviews could lead people to self-incrimination as they cannot reliably recall events. The NSW Government and Opposition will now consider the views of young people on this issue based on the committee's recommendations.
The Youth MP's in NSW voted to restore the right to silence for those accused of crimes. They passed the Restoration of the Right to Silence Bill to repeal a section of the Evidence Act that allowed courts to make negative inferences from those who remained silent. A Youth Member said this protects vulnerable people, especially non-English speakers. The Bill follows a committee investigation that found the Evidence Act infringed on legal and human rights principles by putting pressure on those being questioned. Another Youth Member said stress or fear during police interviews could lead people to self-incrimination as they cannot reliably recall events. The NSW Government and Opposition will now consider the views of young people on this issue based on the committee's recommendations.
8 July 2014: Following the NSW Government amending of the Evidence Act in August last year, the YMCA NSW Youth Parliament overwhelmingly voted to restore the right to silence for both summary and indictable offences. The Restoration of the Right to Silence Bill, presented to the Youth Parliament aims repeal section 89a of the Evidence Act which allowed the courts to take an unfavourable and unacceptable inference from a person who remained silent. By restoring the right to silence in the criminal justice system, we are protecting societys most vulnerable, especially from those who come from a non-English speaking background, said Youth Member for Newcastle Cameron Allen. The proposed Bill follows the results of an investigation by the Justice and Law Reform Committee that the Evidence Act infringed on key legal and human rights principles and placed enormous pressure on the person being questioned. During police interviews, situations of stress, fatigue or fear can propel individuals to an unacceptable risk of self incrimination as one cannot recall with complete reliance reaffirmed Youth Member for East Hills Montana Sedman. The Justice and Law Reform Bill is one of 20 different pieces of legislation going before the Youth Parliament. These pieces of legislation have been developed following six months of hard work and consultation by Members of the Youth Parliament from around New South Wales. Following this emphatic result, the NSW Government and Opposition will receive a copy of the Committees recommendations and be able to consider the thoughts of young people from around NSW on the matter. Over the past thirteen years more than half a dozen pieces of Youth Legislation passed by the young people of NSW have been passed into NSW law. The YMCA NSW Youth Parliament continues to sit for the remainder of the week. -ENDS-
Media Release For Immediate Release Media contact: Robert Barrie Media and Public Relations Manager YMCA NSW Youth Parliament P: 0439605736 E: yp.media@ymca.org.au
About the YMCA: The YMCA is a vibrant, self-funding, not-for-profit charity delivering contemporary programs focused on family, healthy living, developing young people and those less fortunate. The Y's ability to positively impact people's lives, strengthen communities and respond proactively to many of today's biggest social challenges is significant, with its diverse programs and services delivered to over 40 communities across NSW in more than 110 locations, generating in excess of four million visits per year.
About the YMCA NSW Youth Parliament: The YMCA NSW Youth Parliament gives young people a voice in the running of NSW. The apolitical program, as all programs within the broader YMCA Youth and Government division, aims to promote youth-led advocacy, active community leadership and legal and parliamentary education.