Professional Documents
Culture Documents
How To Really Measure Cost-Effectiveness
How To Really Measure Cost-Effectiveness
How To Really Measure Cost-Effectiveness
1
Treat Vs. Test and Treat STEPS IN THE DEVELOPING A
DECISION TREE
Disease Test + $26,000
+ 0.9 5 QALYS
0.8
Treatment
Test - $1,000 – Intervention Study and Observational Study
0.85 15 QALYS
Decision Disease * Natural history: observational study
+ $25,000 * Intermediate effect of intervention: intervention study
Treat 0.2 5 QALYS
* Final effect of intervention: observational or intervention study
Empirically
Disease
-
• Consensus of expert opinion
$15,000
0.8 14 QALYS • Personal opinion
2
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS POTENTIAL LIMITATIONS
• When events can repeat themselves
• Confidence intervals (e.g., when one can develop cancer this
– “Second-order” Monte-Carlo simulation year, next year, etc.), decision trees
may become too “bushy”
• Robustness of results • Trees generally don’t directly account
for timing of events (e.g., that one can
• Threshold analysis develop cancer this year, next year,
etc.)
• Markov or state transition models may
help overcome these problems
3
STEPS IN CONDUCTING ECONOMIC FOUR ISSUES
EVALUATION IN RANDOMIZED TRIAL
• Step 1: Quantify the costs of care • What health care resource use should be
measured (data collection)?
• Step 2: Quantify outcomes
• How should the resources be valued?
• Step 3: Assess whether and by how much average costs
and outcomes differ among the treatment groups • How many subjects should be included in the
study (sample size)?
• Step 4: Compare magnitude of differences in costs and
outcomes and evaluate "value for the cost"
(e.g., by reporting a cost effectiveness ratio or the • For time-limited trials of therapies with longer-
probability that the ratio is acceptable) term effects: How should long-term results be
projected?
• Step 5: Conduct sensitivity analysis
– Services that make up a large portion of the total – Resource-based relative value units
(Physician services/procedures)
* Reduces likelihood that differences among unmeasured
services will lead to bias – Trial-specific costing exercise (e.g., time and
* Provides measure of variability of costs motion studies
4
15000
$6,277 HOW SHOULD LONG-TERM
$22,971 RESULTS BE PROJECTED?
12000
• For time-limited trials of therapies with potentially
Incremental Costs
9000 $4,407 long term effects, one should evaluate the costs
and outcomes that were observed during the trial
6000
– Maintain the same time horizons for costs and
$1,140
3000 outcomes observed in the trial