Professional Documents
Culture Documents
اجهود ابن حزم في جدال اليهود
اجهود ابن حزم في جدال اليهود
اجهود ابن حزم في جدال اليهود
1428
-1-
}
*
{
(163-162
,
,
.
.
/
/
.
.
.
U
.
.
(1)
.(
) :-
.(
)
-
.
.
.
69-
-1-
(1 )
:
.
(
-1
)
-2
.
-3
.
-4
.
-5
.
-6
-7
.
:
.
:
.
-1
.
-2
-3
-2-
:
:
. 1414
-1
.
":
"
:
.
1400
) -
. :
.
:
./
. 1984
./
-2
-
2001
.
-3-
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
-4-
:
:
:
.
.
.
:
.
-5-
.(1) 456
384
.(2)
: ( 138- 92)
92
1
.
http://www.arabandalucia.com/index.php/1699,
(1 )
(2 )
. :
21 19
5 - 3 /1
. 2006/6 /23
-6-
"
.
(1)
(2 )
"
(3 )
: ( 238 - 138)
U
:
170
( 180- 173)
(4 )
(5 )
:
. 120-47
(1 )
1987
:
(2 )
.92 1978
.http://www.arabandalucia.com/index.php/1699
(3 )
.
:
.
-7-
(4 )
(5 )
: ( 300- 238)
( 273 -238)
( 300275)
( 275273)
:
.
.
:
(1)
.(2)
: ( 386- 300)
:
.
(3)
( 339
305
(1 )
.
163
.
:
http://www.arabandalucia.com/index.php/1699
. 298
-8-
(2 )
(3 )
(1)
316
(2)
325
:
:
(3)
: ( 399 - 366)
(
-U
.285-284/1
1998
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
. 304-303
1
:
.
.
.36
-9-
1979
.
.
(1)
(2 )
. 381
(3)
12
(4 )
(5 )
http://www.arabandalucia.com/index.php/1699
. 19
(1 )
(2 )
:
-
(3 )
1
. 132-131 /1 1984
. 132/1
http://www.arabandalucia.com/index.php/1699
- 10 -
(4 )
:
(5 )
:( 422- 399)
)
(
-
":
.(
(1)
(2)
".
418
412
(3 )
422
(1 )
:
1
267/1 1995
.154
(2 )
.237/12 1980
- 11 -
(3 )
(1)
: ( 483- 422)
:
.
:
-1
.
-2
U
-3
(2)
-4
. 324-323
.
.416-324
- 12 -
(1 )
(2 )
":
.(2) "(1)
(3 )
500-410)
479
12
(1 )
465
.409-403
112/7
500
:
1
222/8 1980
(2 )
http://www.arabandalucia.com/index.php/1699
.104
- 13 -
(3 )
(1 )
:
"
(2 )
".
:
.
(4 )
(3 )
":
...
(5 )
"
:
(6)
.
.
( 897-92 )
.212
(1 )
-
2000
. 4 - 3 /4
:
.112/2
.282/10
(2 )
(4 )
. 8 /2
.182/1
- 14 -
(3 )
(5 )
:
(6 )
(1 )
:
":
.
....
. (2)"
.
":
":
(3 )
"
(4 )
" :
"
.213
. (5)"
:
.183 /1
.
- 15 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
.181 /1
(4 )
.8 /2
(5)
:
:
(1 )
(2 )
.
.
(3 )
(4 )
.108
.228
.
.46
.45
- 16 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
) (
(1 )
403
.
(2 )
(3)
(4)
"
.112
.411 1982
. 249 /12
- 17 -
.101
:
:
:
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
"
(1 )
":
...
.(2)"
.
.253/12
416 /30
1
(1 )
1
(2 )
.257 1986
- 18 -
. (1)
(2 )
.(2)
(1 )
(6 )
(5 )
(4 )
(3 )
291-289
- 395 /2 1994
236-235/12
167/1979 1
7
,229 /4 1987
1
299 /3
1992
. 1978 303
. 239 /2
. 691/5
:
.218 /1
:
2
(1 )
1146/3
325/3
403/30
76/5
.99/1988 4
.472/4
1
289 /2
395/2
:
1
.
:
- 19 -
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
(6 )
(6)
":
(5 )
"
(8 )
-1
(3 )
-2
(4)
(7 )
.
(9)
(10)
. 332/4
236-235/12
184/18
. 39-32
. 555
229/4
1977
. 17/1
.
325/3
. 65/1
. 43 1984
.209/1
291-290
21-14
. 136/1
.
:
4
-
- 20 -
(2 )
(3 )
:
:
(4 )
(5 )
(6 )
(7 )
(8 )
. 170 /1
.
:
(1 )
(9 )
(10)
:
79-78
(1 )
.
.
(2)
:
-
:
(4)
:
":
(3)
."
":
. 27
25-23
-
1406
170/1
1
. 25
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
462
:
1999
22
239/2
291/2
396/2
. 21
- 21 -
(4 )
"(1)
":
t
(2 )
"
"
U
(3 )
."
(4 )
":
-
. 80
. 328 /3
- 22 -
(1 )
.180
(2 )
.87-86
(3 )
:
(4 )
(1)
".
":
.(2)"
:
"
.(3)"
:
456
.(4)
. 154
. 71 1979
(1 )
:
(2 )
.72-71
. 104
. 291-290
.
396/2
- 23 -
(3 )
:
(4 )
.(1)
-1
330
.
.
-2
429
-3
346
.
-4
440
.
:
.(2)
(1 )
.605
1988
:
. 1982 77/55
- 24 -
(2 )
(1 )
"
"
:
(2)
:
-1
"
(4 )
(3 )
"...
-2
399
. (5)
,
-3
. (6)
.(7)
-4
.173
-
(1 )
:
119
. 24
.173
. 165/3
(3 )
626/2
. 313
. 71
265
. 198
- 25 -
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
(6 )
(7 )
:
"
."
(2)
-1
(1 )
-2
-3
(3 )
.(6)
(5 )
-1
(4 )
-2
-3
-4
(7)
. 120
583/2
328
(1 )
(2)
(3)
(4)
. 79
. 36
285/2
. 164/1
66
. 153/1
(5)
103
303/1
. 255 884-
.143
23/1
290/1
- 26 -
(6)
(7)
(1 )
-1
.(2)
-2
402
.
18
(3)
":
-1
.
.
.(5)
(4)
"
"
-2
-3
. (6)
(7 )
. ( 488)
.24
-1
145
. 84
. 143
172/1
. 68
:
.
.
155/5
282/4
- 27 -
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
.69
.280/33
(1 )
(6 )
(7)
(1)
( 479)
-2
.(2)( 493)
.(3)( 539 )
(4)
-3
493 )
.(5)( 520 )
.(6)( 503
-4
-5
-6
-7
(7 )
.
:
.
:
-1
.
"
"
.(
.277/32
329/3
(1)
.401/2
122/4
229 /1
. 142/20
404/30
155/34
(2 )
(3 )
267/5
297/4
(4 )
. 130 /19
145-139
.249-245/2
(5 )
.651/2
(6 )
(7 )
268-267
- 28 -
:
.(
:
-2
:
-3
.
:
-4
":
.(1)"
399
...
(2 )
":
(3)
. 206
. 98-82
(1)
:
.36
- 29 -
."
(2 )
(3 )
":
(1 )
"
.
(2 )
(3)
(4 )
:
(5 )
(6 )
.
. 118
(1 )
.30
. 104-103
30
117-107
.
.
.44
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
.45
- 30 -
(6 )
(1)
":
"
.(2)"
.(3)
:
-
:
":
.30
(1 )
.74
.31
- 31 -
(2 )
:
(3 )
(1 )
"
(2 )
":
:
440
. 440
.
:
:
.
440
.
":
.
.(4)
.(3)"
:
.(5)
" "
"
"
":
.231 /2
(1 )
.45
(2 )
.49-46
(3 )
.17
.33
- 32 -
(4 )
(5 )
(1)
"
456
(2 )
":
-1
.(3)"
-
":
(4 )
"
-2
":
(5)
-3
"
":
.(6)
.283-282
395/2
.187/18
. 51
238-237 / 12
. 326 /3
1147/3
. 291/2
.167 /1
249-247/12
- 33 -
(1 )
(2 )
(4 )
(5 )
:
(3 )
239/2
(6 )
":
.
.
(2)
"
":"
"
-4
(1 )
"
"
-5
"
":
(4 )
"
-6
(3 )
"
":
-7
":
.
(5)
-8
"
":
.
-9
(6 )
"
":
-10
. (7)"
":
-11
.140 /1
(1 )
.(8)"
. 201/4
. 199 /4
321/3
(3 )
.240 /2
(4 )
.299/3
. 435
1393
. 325/ 3
- 34 -
(5 )
(6 )
. 1151/3
(2 )
(7 )
239 /2
(8 )
:
":
-1
.
":
.
(1 )
"
-2
(2 )
"
:
.
(3 )
-1
"
":
(4)
. "-
":
-2
-3
(5)
"
.(6)
(1 )
. 396 /4 1997
. 198/4
. 328-327 /3
:
.239 /2
- 35 -
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
. 189/18
(5 )
.190-189/18
(6 )
)
-
)
-
(1 )
(3 )
(2 )
(4)
-1
.
-2
-3
-4
.
-5
.
-6
.
-7
.
-8
.239/2
.197-93/18
. 92-71
. 1399
(2 )
.
(3 )
:
26
- 36 -
(1 )
(4 )
-9
-10
.
-11
-12
-13
.
-14
-15
-16
.
-17
-18
-19
.
-20
.
-21
-22
-23
.
-24
.
-25
-26
-27
-28
-29
.
-30
.
.
.
-32
-33
.
-34
.
- 37 -
-31
-35
-36
-37
-38
-39
-40
.
.
-42
-41
-43
-44
.
-45
-46
-47
-48
.
-49
-50
-51
.
-52
.
-53
-54
-55
-56
.
-57
-58
.
-59
-60
-61
-62
.
- 38 -
-63
-64
-65
.
-66
-67
-68
-69
.
-70
-71
-72
.
-73
.
-74
:
.
.
.
-1
-2
-3
-4
.
.
-5
-6
-7
-8
-9
.
.
.
-10
-11
-12
.
.
- 39 -
-13
-14
-15
-16
-17
-18
.
-19
.
"
"
-20
-21
-22
.
-23
-24
.
.
.
-26
-27
-28
-29
.
.
-30
-31
-32
.
.
.
-33
-34
-35
-36
-37
-38
-39
.
.
.
.
.
.
-40
-41
-42
-43
-44
.
.
- 40 -
-25
-45
-46
-47
-48
-49
.
-50
-51
-52
.
-53
-54
.
-55
-56
-57
.
-58
-59
-60
.
-61
-62
:
.
.(
.(
-64
:
-1
.(
-63
-2
-3
-4
-5
.
r
.(1)
.
122
- 41 -
(1 )
":
r
(1 )
"
.
:
(2 )
":
"
(3 )
.(4)
. 116/2
(1 )
. 206-205/18
.
(2 )
:
(3 )
:
211 /4 1983
:
. 40
169 /1 2003
- 42 -
(4 )
(1)
. (2)
-
:(3)
(4)
.281-277 /2
124
. 176-175
- 43 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
108-105 /1
.473
)-
:
:
-
":(1)(
:
-
:
-
:
":
(2)
r
"
(3 )
(4 )
) :-
.(5)"
-
.5-
(1 )
(2 )
8
.69/4
.22-
(3 )
. 11-
(4 )
. 291-288/2
- 44 -
(5 )
(1)
.(2)
":(3)(
U
.
-
r
-
):-
U
(4 )
):
(6)(5 )"
(
-
):
:
.
:
":
. 101
1978
. 336
.
.17-
. 292-291/2
- 45 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
.7 -
(4 )
. 41-
(5 )
(6 )
(1 )
:
.
(2 )
": -
) :-
-1
(3 )
(
.
-2
.
-3
.
.
-4
.(4)
-5
U
-
. 81/4
(1 )
. 473
(2 )
. 6.254-252
- 46 -
(3 )
:
(4 )
:
-
(1)
.(2)
-
:U
(3 )
:
):
(4)
"
"
-
:r
(7)
.(5)-
(6 )
)
. 18-17 /3
. 256
(1 )
(2 )
. 23-22
(3 )
. 209/1 547
(4 )
.10 /3
.8 / 3
.15 -
- 47 -
(5 )
(6 )
(7 )
(1 )
(2 )
:
":
)U
(4)(3 )
. (5)
:
: -
(1
r
-
.(6)
):-
. 384
.
.413
(1 )
(2 )
. 10830/1 2003
-
(3 )
(4 )
3
:
(5 )
. 420 1984
.283/2
- 48 -
(6 )
(1)
(
(2 )
):-
(2
): -
(3 )
(4 )
.
"
": "
"
-
(5)
":
"
r
..
"
.23-
(1 )
.180.213-128
(2 )
:
.23.357 /2
- 49 -
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
(1)
"
.
.
.
U
.
:
:
):U
(1
(2 )
(
-
(3 )
.395 /2
(1 )
1
.27 -
(2 )
.
/
85 /2
(3 )
. 135
-
121 1998
- 50 -
. 235
226
) :
(1 )
):
(
-
(3)
(2)
:(
(2
(4 )
":
(5 )
":
:-
.-
"
.(6)
.9 -
(1 )
.115-
(2 )
.348-347/2
(3 )
(4 )
270
257-255 /2
186-185 /2
. 201
305-1978 303
.77
-
(5 )
1
76/21 1978
.107
- 51 -
(6 )
(1 )
(2 )
:-
) :r
) :-
(3 )
(4 )
).U
(
-
(5 )
.
":
(6)
.
:
"
.
-
.
.
(7 )
):"
":
(
. 265 /1
:
/
54
34
1397
:
-
(1 )
(2 )
. 22-21
.52-
(3 )
.88-
(4 )
.27 -
(5 )
.11-10
. 55
- 52 -
(6 )
:
(7 )
":
"
"
"
:
."
" :-
:-
"
]:
(5 )
(4)
I
":
.(6)"
29
(3 )
...
. 711
(1 )
) :U
"
. 351/2
.115-
179
:
.257/6 372
55
}
- 53 -
. 353/2
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
.161/1
:
(5 )
(6 )
):-
"
"
(1)
.(2)
:
:(
(1
":
(3 )
"
r
r
u
-
(4)
(
). -
):-
.26. 294
.521/1
(1 )
:
(2 )
(3 )
.76-
- 54 -
(4 )
):
(1 )
(2 )
(
-
(3 )
"
"
":
(2
:
.
" :r
"
-
:(
.)
(4)
:
.
.22-
(1 )
.210-
(2 )
.358-357/2
. 360- 358
- 55 -
(3 )
:
(4 )
"
:(1)
":
-
0-
r
-
.
": -
:
.
.
(2 )
"
. 368-363
(1 )
:
.82 98
- 56 -
(2 )
:
-
:
-
(1 )
:
.-
:
.
):
*
.
(2 )
(
u
u
u
-
. 241/2
:
.78- 76
- 57 -
(1 )
(2 )
(1)
):
(2 )
:
.-
:
-
- -
.
(3)
} :r
(6 )
(5)
) :-
(4)
(
":
. 17/4
(1 )
.83-
. 488
(3 )
:
804
/5
(2 )
(4 )
553:1
. 55
- 58 -
(5 )
:
(6 )
.
:
(3
. (1)"
":
:
r
}":U
.
. 357/2
121 /2 175
(1 )
:
(2 )
758
. 521/1
- 59 -
"
"
"
"
"
(1 )
.
r
(2 )
...
:
.
.
:
U
-
. 66
:
.11-
- 60 -
(1 )
(2 )
(1 )
.I
(2)
):
(
.
. 382- 381
.
. 56 -
- 61 -
(1 )
(2 )
(1 )
:
-
(2)
":
:
(3)
:-
(4 )
":
.(5)"
. 474
.
.18- 17
(2 )
- 62 -
(3 )
.
. 1979 /
. 64
(1 )
:
:
(4 )
. 92/12
(5 )
:
:
:
:
:
- 63 -
:
-
.....
-
:
:
-
":
.
(1)
"
-
-1
-2
. 613
- 64 -
-3
(2 )
. 285/1
-4
-5
(1 )
(2 )
":
u
(1 )
"
"
u
:
:
:
114
!!
" :-
(2 ) "
(3 )
:
.
(4 )
"
"
.
. 287/1
(1 )
.290 /1
.297-291/1
. 77
- 65 -
(2 )
:
(3 )
(4 )
.(1)
110
(2 )
"
(3 )
":
.
-
."
(4 )
"
:(5)
-1
(6 )
. 298 /1
(1 )
(2 )
. 29-28
. 615
(3 )
. 301/1
616-615
.
. 99
- 66 -
(4 )
:
(5 )
(6 )
-2
.
.(1)
( 2)
.
"
(3 )
"
-3
-4
(4)
":
"
-5
-
":
"
":
" :
(5 )
"
.
(6 )
"
:
:
(7)
"
. 298 /1
""
:
.301 /1 :
. 77
2007 /3/15
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
. 294/1
(4 )
.290 /1
(5 )
.301 /1
(6 )
http://www.pnic.gov.ps/arabic/palestine/israel_dectionary.html
- 67 -
"
(7 )
1970
430
:
-
(1 )
":
(2 )
"
.202 /1
.202 /1
- 68 -
(1 )
(2 )
":
.(1)"
u
-
(2)
-1
.(
.(
-2
-3
).
.(
. 297/1
. 618
- 69 -
(1 )
:
(2 )
:
:
:
.
":
(1 )
"
":
.
:
u
4
.
.
. (3)"
" :.
(2)
".
)
. 252/1
. 5-3/49 :
. 245/1
- 70 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
. (1)
(2)
.
":
12
120
":
.....(3)
13
15
14
16
(4)
.
.
".
17
438=35+403
465
.
465
600
":
120
464
(5 )
"
12
":
u
13
(6 )
."
(7)
":
!!
23
. 75
:
3 /6
(2 )
209/1
(3 )
17-12/11
(4 )
. 210-209/1
(5 )
13-12 /7
8
(6 )
:
- 71 -
(1 )
(7 )
.(1)"
:
24
4
"
:
5
(2 )"
(
.
(5)
"
.(3)!!
(4)
19
:
"
":
"
20
.(6)
:
31
7
":
(7 )
":
".
.
8
.
24-23 /7
(1 )
5 - 4 /8
8
(2 )
:
2 /4
(4 )
20-19 /4
. 208 /1
- 72 -
(5 )
:
31 /16
(3 )
(6 )
(7 )
:":
".
(2 )
"
":
:
(1)
"
(3)
"
":
(4)
":
"
"
(5)
:
11
12
.
(6)
".
.(7)"
" :"
:
5
":
:
(8)
"
8-7/11
. 255-254/1
255/1
(2 )
(3 )
14/14
256/1
- 73 -
(4 )
(5 )
12-10/4
.256/1
(1 )
5 / 20
(6 )
(7 )
(8 )
9
(1)
":
":
"
.(2)
20
":
.
(3 )
29
.
30
".
":
(4 )
.
:
".
":
21
(5 )
(6)
".
".
:
:
(8)
6
1
(7 )
":
":
".
}I
9 /5
.8
20/18
30/31
21/46
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
6 /7
(6 )
2 - 1 /8
(7 )
82-
- 74 -
(1 )
(8 )
(1)
:
(
(2)
:
24
(4)
":
(3)
".
"
"
":
":
."
(5 )
."
(1 )
:
:
:
:
.7
.
. 25-24 /2
(2 )
(3 )
24 /3
(4 )
.
. 208-207/1
- 75 -
(5 )
1656
. (1)"
-
"
1307
(2324)
.
.
2262
(2023)
(2 )
!!
(2200)
:
(5 )
(4)
(3)
u
942
1972
292
.(6)
.
.
.
":
.
171
.7
.7
. 172
.
.
- 76 -
(1 )
(2 )
4/27 :
(3 )
4/27
(4 )
:
(5 )
(6 )
(1 )
"
...
.
-
u
:
u
"
(2)
.
.
" :u
):
(3 )
U
*
*
*
*
u
(4 )
u
.
. 8-1/18
219/1
.220/ 1
(2 )
.221/ 1
(3 )
. 73-69
- 77 -
(1 )
(4 )
- "
"
(1)
(2 )
"
( 440 )
":
(3 )
."
:
.
Y
.
-1
u
(969)
(187)
(182)
(369)
. 628
.
. 85
.
. 202-201/1
- 78 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
.(1)
":
-2
. (2)"
-3
25=3+4 +5+3+6+4
" :
32=
-
(3)
"
"
u
. 211-210/1
- 79 -
(1 )
.212/1 ,
(2 )
. 242 /1
(3 )
-4
)
(
21300=6200+8600+6500:
:
"
.(1) "
-5
.(2)
- 80 -
.276-275/1
(1 )
. 241 /1
(2 )
,1
217
-6
51
603550
":
u
.
(2) "
:
"
(3)
":
-1
15
.(4)
:
:
:
14
16
13
.
15
. (5)(
46-45 /1
.216/1
(1 )
(2 )
15 /4 :
. 208/1
. 16-13/15 :
- 81 -
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
.
40
":
(1 )
-2
41
(2 )
".
(3 )
".
u(
13
":
400)
.
)
u
.(4)
u
(217)
. 213 /1
:
.42-40 /12 :
(2 )
13/15 :
(3 )
253-252/1
- 82 -
(1 )
(4 )
u
(123)
(1 )
":
U
"
":
(2 )
"
(414)
"
)
. (3)
:
10 "
(1 )
(4 )
:
:
11
. 87
(1 )
. 216 /1
.215/1
.(11 :2
:
.
- 83 -
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
(4)
13 (3)
(2)
12
(6)
14 (5)
".
":
.
.
(1 )
.
(2 )
(3 )
.
.(
.
:
(4 )
(1):
(5 )
(6 )
(2 )
.
.
.
.
150
.
120
1146
.
- 84 -
(1 )
."
".
":
(2)
.
.
(3)
":
."
,
.
":
203 /1
196/2
(1 )
:
(2 )
(3 )
160-159 /3
- 85 -
.(1)"
-1
(2 )
.
:
r
(3 )
"
":
"
.
" (4)
335 /5
(1 )
. 205/1
.230/4 17
(2 )
(3 )
218-217/8 167
(4 )
- 86 -
.
:
.(1)
.
-
-2
.(2)
:
" :-
:
-1
":
(3 )
".
19 "
):
. 206-205 /1
- 87 -
(1 )
.218 /1
(2 )
.250 /1
(3 )
20
.
.
21
.
.
24
22
23
.
(1 )
:-
(2 )
-2
(3 )
-3
U
-
.(4)
.24 -14/7
(1 )
.250/1
207-/22
- 88 -
(2 )
. 271/1
(3 )
264/1
(4 )
(1 )
-4
19
!!
":
.
(2 )
-5
(3 )
.
-6
u
.
":
19/21
.275/1
.323 /1
- 89 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(1 )
"
-7
(
" :
.(2)"
.
37
38
-8
":
" :
(3)
".
.(4)"
.324-323/1
. 324 /1
.38-37 /12
. 274/1
- 90 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
":
-9
.(1)"
.(2)
(
(
-10
-11
)
.
":
.
7
8
(3)
".
-
.(4)
.274/1
(1 )
. 322 /1
(2 )
.8-5 /34
. 285-284 /1
- 91 -
(3 )
:
(4 )
:
:
:
:
:
:
- 92 -
:
":
(2 ){ 28
:
.
26}
:
(1)
"
27
":
(3)
"
:
.
22
"
:
.
(4 )
".
23
.
":
. 202/1
28-26 /1
207/1 :
.23-22 /3
- 93 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
}:
(1)
{..........
r
(
(2 )
"
U
":
(3 )
"
.16/1 183
(4 )
"
229/65 6
.182
- 94 -
"
(1 )
(2 )
. 203-202/1
(3 )
.207 /1
(4 )
:
"
":
......
:
.
(1 )
: -1
":
...
.
"
:-
14"
(2)
."
.
."
":
u
-
":
(4)
."
(3)
-2
-
"
":
-3
.
(
!!
(5)"
-4
:
(6)
-5
.255/1
(1 )
.14/14
(2 )
. 59
(3 )
.1 / 82
.309/1
.324 /1
- 95 -
(4 )
(5 )
(6 )
:"
U
":
"
.(1)
)
.
-7
(2 )
"
:
.
-6
:-
(3)
":
":
:
:
(4)
:
11
"
10
:
:
:
-
.311 /1
(1 )
.325 /1
(2 )
(3 )
119-118
12
:
1
. 57
.
:
26 /1
- 96 -
62/1 1405
181/1
(4 )
13
.
:
14
.(1)
.
(2)
(3 )
":u
:u
.
:
u
:
.181 /1
. 328 1995
- 97 -
14-9 /32 :
:
:
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
:u
(1)
."
" ::
U
-
(2)
:2
3
(3)
:
.
.
.
}:
(4 )
I
(5)
:
.17-1 /33
.59-58
(2 )
3-1 /2
. 54
(3 )
(4 )
. 38-
- 98 -
(1 )
(5 )
"
"
U
:t:
:
U
-
":
:
:
r
.
(1 )
.
24
):
:
:
28
29
25
26
.
:
. 233-232 /1
- 99 -
27
(1 )
30
(1)
31
:
.
: -
":
.(3)"
(2 )
":
5)
(4)
.
:
:-
":
":
"
(5 )
"
":
(6)"
: :
U
:
.
-
.31-24/32
. 115 (
.7-5 /6
.3 - 1 /6
- 100 -
(2 )
(3 )
.116
. 209/1
(1 )
(4 )
(5 )
(6 )
.
.
(1)
:
":
u
- (3)"
(4 )
(5 )
"
"
.(6)
(2 )
":
":
"
":
"
"
:
-
.
-
t
:
(7 )
-1
. 65
. 24
(2 )
. 22
(3 )
.28 /32
:
.1 /1
- 101 -
(1 )
(4 )
(5 )
. 234 /1
(6 )
. 326/1
(7 )
-2
-3
-4
-5
.
.
-6
-7
:
U
(
(1)
:
23 :
(
.
:
-
(2)
(3)
. 328-327/1
(1 )
.23/25
. 230 /1
- 102 -
(2 )
:
(3 )
18
(1)
):
(.
U-
u
u
(2)
(3 )
:
:
":
.
u
.
.
.
(4 )
"
.18/15
. 218-217 /1
. 22
.
. 59-58
- 103 -
(1 )
:
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
:-
:
":
:
:
(1 )
"
(2)
22
":
.
(3)
23
".
" :-
U
"!
(4)
23
".
.
.65
(1 )
:
.
. 438
.23-22 /33
65
- 104 -
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
:(1)
:
:
)
:
(
-1
-2
.
(
-3
.
-4
.
:
.
:(2)
.
332
2000 2
(1 )
(2 )
27
. 336
- 105 -
:
:
(1)
:
-1
u
.
.
:u
-2
-3
-4
:
:u
.
-
(2 )
t
:
. 284 /1
. 223 /1
- 106 -
(1 )
(2 )
(1 )
u
.
u
-
U
:
:
r
.
-
u
:
:
-
(2 )
.
:u
( 3)
:u
.(5)
":
)
":
(4 )
":
"
u
(6)
u
. 70
.
. 224-223 /1
. 231/1
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
.4-3 /49
(4 )
. 31-1/ 34
.322-321 /1
- 107 -
(5 )
:
(6 )
": -
.(1)"
:u
u
. (2)
"
"
.
(3 )
:(4)
:
.
.
.
:
(6)
.(5)
(
:u
.
(7 )
.234/1
. 239/1
.
.22/1
(1 )
:
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
.284 /1
.
. 241/1
- 108 -
(5 )
:
(6 )
(7 )
(1)
": -
":
.
-
(2 )
"
(3)
.
(
)
-
":
(4)
u
":-
"
.
-
"
.325/1
(1 )
. 82
(2 )
.284 /1
.212-211 /1
- 109 -
(3 )
(4 )
. (1)
":
(2)
"
- 110 -
. 246/1
(1 )
.312-311 /1
(2 )
.(1)
:(2)
:
-1
-2
.
:
-3
-4
1999
(1 )
291/2
:
2004
./
./
(
/
/
- 111 -
(2 )
-5
.
-
.
.
(1 )
:(
.
.
(
292 /2
- 112 -
(1 )
:
-
":
.(1) "
":
u
r
":
"
(2)
(3 )
"
(5 )"
":
(4)
:
":
-
u
":
219/1
220/1
.222/1 ,
.221/,1
.222/,1
- 113 -
(1 )
:
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
."
(1)
"
.(2)"
":
..(3)"
:
":
"
-
"
-
(5 )
"
.(4)"
":
" :-
(6 )
"
(7)
291/2
- 114 -
.209 /1
:
. 27-24
. 70-69
. 233 /1
:
24/32 :
. 65
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
(6 )
(7 )
.(1)
.
.
(2)
.
""
.
2848-2842 1995 6
283 /2
- 115 -
(1 )
(2 )
22
.(1)"
-
.(2)
:
:
":
":
(3 )
" :-
"
(4 )
"
u
":
:
u
.(5)"
":
.
.2
./
. 56
- 116 -
1/12
38 1996
.309/1
.309/1,
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
:
:
:
:
- 117 -
,
) :-
(1)
):U
*
*
*
(2)
U
-
(3)
):-
(
):-
*
*
.82 .81-78,
.123 -
- 118 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(1)
(
"
"
(2 )
(3)
):-
"
.
(4 )
"
"
"
. 69-67
. 15
(1 )
:
.9. 49
- 119 -
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
: ( 1055-993)
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
:
.
.
.
.
- 120 -
.(1)
":
(2 )
"
(3)
{
(4 )
:
:
.
.
.52 /2
( 897-92 )
(1 )
(2 )
165-149 2000
.233 /1
.187-
.125-
- 121 -
(3 )
(4 )
(1)
)
):
.(2)
(
.
:
:-
:
:
.
:u
.
. 78 . 79 -
- 122 -
(1 )
(2 )
:r
!
!
r
(1)
):
. (2)(
):
":
(
.(3)"
"
":
:
"
"
):
:
(...
"
"
"
:t
" :-
):
(
r
.
.
(5 )
) :-
. 49
:
.131 -
. 111 /4
1988
(4 )
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
. 184-183/5
. 69-
- 123 -
(5 )
(1)
):
(
.(
)
r
r
):
.
(3 )(2)
u
":
":U
":
. 719/5 1981
"
10
. 78 -
.(172-171/1
1980
- 124 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
..(1) "
."
(2)
".
":
I
.
.(3)
20
:
.
):
(
u
.(4)
.
):
..(5)(
:
)
. 51
. 51
- 125 -
5 /20
(2 )
20/18
(3 )
:
32 27
(1 )
(4 )
(5 )
(1)
. .
:
:
.
:
:
.
(2)
:"
":U
-
"
:t
"
"
":
(
(3)
( )
:
:
.(4)
.29 . 51
.112-111 /26
. 3817-3816 /30
- 126 -
(1 )
:
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
"
.
"
(1)
):
.(2)(
)
.
(3 )
:
:
:
-
23
.
:
24
(6)
(.
. 48/31
22
(4 )
(5)
(1 )
2
. 29-
.39/1
. 52
.
- 127 -
:
24-22 /3
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
(6 )
.-
)U
)
(2)
):
(
(3)
):
:
.
. (
):
:
:-
(1)
.(4)(
.(5)r
. 10-
(1 )
. 11-
(2 )
. 12-
(3 )
. 38. 53
- 128 -
(4 )
(5 )
:-
):
.
) :-
(2 )
(3)
(12-10)
:
-
:
)
*
) (
(
)
.
(4 )
.112-111/26
:
.38-
. 225-224 /15
.182-181/2
- 129 -
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
:
(
:
-
2
3
":
"
.
.(1)"
:.
(2)
!
-
):"
.(4)((3)
): -
:
-
(6 )
:
(5)
"
:
:
3-1 /2
. 54
.330
:
.38.35.111-
- 130 -
(1 )
:
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
(6 )
) :U
(1)
(2)
(
-
(3 )
"
"r
-
.(4)
"
"
"
"
):
(5)
"
"
"
(6 )
.36 -29
(1 )
. 65 -
(2 )
1997/4 2581
(3 )
. 56
:
. 107
. 11
- 131 -
(4 )
(5 )
(6 )
"
":
:
"
"
:
:
.
(2 )
(1 )
"
":
"
":
.
(3 )
):
(4 )
(5)
(1 )
:
1
. 1875 /1993 4
1
. 961 2000
(4 )
:
- 132 -
(3 )
. 4-
. 95 /2
(2 )
(5 )
:
(
(1 )
u
-
(3)
) :-
" :-
:
(2)
:-
):
(
*
(4)
. 56
- 133 -
):
(1 )
.39-
(2 )
.6 -
(3 )
.45 40
(4 )
):
(1)
(
.(2)r
:-
39
)-
t
:
.(3)
:
:
"
"
.
:
"
":
:
(
(4 )
)U
(5)
) :-
t
)
(6)
. 57
(1 )
.83 /27
. 57
(3 )
. 89/8
:
.. 78. 92-
- 134 -
(2 )
(4 )
(5 )
(6 )
(1)
)
)
:
(
(2 )
-)
.(3)
) :-
.
:
.
(4)
(5 )
" :-
(7 )
u
:
(6 )
" :-
".
.
U
. 114-113/17
(1 )
.24-
(2 )
. 119 /29
. 95 /2
.1793 /1
1306
(3 )
(4 )
:
15-11/32
. 58
- 135 -
(5)
(6 )
(7 )
U
.
) :r
:
" :-
(1 )
:
:( )
..
(2)
:
.
( )
):
):
):
(3)
):
(5)
.
:
(4)
:
:
.(
. 94188-
- 136 -
(1 )
(2 )
11 -
(3 )
16 -
(4 )
17 -
(5 )
(1 )
((2)
.
):
:(3)
:-
(
-1
"
"
":
:
"
(
(
":
-2
t
":
r
):
):
) :U
r
-
u
-
(4)
.
:
-3
r
46 -
(1 )
81 . 115/11
:
. 116 -
- 137 -
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
) :-
(1 )
(2)
"
:-
)U
:
-1
".
"
"
(
r
.
.
r
:
-2
:
.
:
-3
-4
:
.
"
":
r
-
):
(3 )
(4)
):
(
.1.244/8
(1 )
:
. 157-
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
. 432 /2 1980
- 138 -
"93"
r
r
r
.(1)
:
":
":
u
. (2)"
. 271/1
(1 )
. 62
- 139 -
(2 )
:
):
:-
(1)
:
:-
:-
)
!
:"
(2 )
"-
(3 )
(4 )
:
.
. 69-
(1)
. 62
.128/9 1978
. 2968
1991
- 140 -
(2 )
:
(3 )
(4)
"
"-
"
"(1)
. (2)
"
"
"
"
.
:
:
r
:
.
:
":
(3 )
:
:
:r
:
.9 -
(1 )
35.120/10
- 141 -
(2 )
:
(3 )
.(1)"
:r
(2 )
"
.
":
(3)
:
:
.(4)
"
"
.
(5)
. 224/7
. 62/3
.408 /1
. 251/3
2
. /
(1 )
(2 )
(3 )
(4 )
(5 )
.171 1993
- 142 -
:
:
"
":
(1)
..
."
.(2)"
)
(3)
" :-
.8 /3
(2 )
62
.9 -
- 143 -
(1 )
(3 )
!
!
:
-
:
(
!
!
!
.
(1)
. 64
- 144 -
(1 )
:
(
-1
u
.
.
-2
-3
.
(
-4
)
.
-5
.
.
(
.(
-6
-7
-8
.
-9
.
(
-10
-11
- 145 -
-12
.
-1
(
.
.
-
- 146 -
)
-2
69
-1
44
-2
44
22
-3
44
11
-4
45
17
-5
45
-6
45
41
-7
46
-8
47
23-22
-9
47
15
-10
48
108
-11
49
23
-12
49
180
-13
50
27
-14
51
-15
51
115
-16
52
52
-17
52
88
-18
52
27
-19
53
115
-20
54
26
-21
54
76
-22
55
22
-23
55
210
-24
57
78-76
-25
- 147 -
58
83
-26
58
210
-27
60
11
-28
61
56
-29
74
82
-30
77
73-69
-31
98
38
-32
114
70-69
-33
114
27-24
-34
118
82-78
-35
118
123
-36
119
69-67
-37
119
-38
121
187
-39
121
125
-40
122
79-78
-41
123
69
-42
123
131
-43
124
78
-44
125
32-27
-45
126
29
-46
127
29
-47
128
12-10
-48
128
38
-49
129
38
-50
130
35
-51
130
38
-52
130
111
-53
- 148 -
131
36-29
-54
131
65
-55
131
107
-56
131
11
-57
132
-58
133
-59
133
45-39
-60
134
78
-61
134
92
-62
135
24
-63
136
94
-64
136
188
-65
136
11 46
-66
136
16
-67
136
17
-68
137
81
-69
137
116
-70
137
-71
138
157
-72
140
69
-73
141
-74
141
35
-75
143
-76
- 149 -
/
. 1397
.
-1
.
-2
. /
-3
.
. 1991
3
./
. 1996
-4
-5
-6
-7
. 1980
-8
.
-9
. 1993
. 1988
. 2002
-10
-11
1
-
-12
/
.
-14
. 884-
-13
-15
. 1978
- 150 -
/
. 2001
-16
-
. /
-17
. 1987
./
1
.
-18
-
. 1982
-19
-20
. 1995
/
-21
. 1405
-22
. 1993
-23
. 2003
/
. 2004
-24
1
/
-25
. 1980
.
-26
. /
-27
. 1984
-28
. 1980
-29
. 1988
- 151 -
-30
1
. 1984
-31
. 1977
-32
. 1978
.
./
-33
. /
-34
. 1964
. /
-35
. 1979
1
-
-36
. 1986
/
. 1983
-37
. /
-38
-39
. 1979
-40
. 1960 . 1979
-41
/
. 1990
.
-42
-
. 1978
1
/
-44
/
-45
.
- 152 -
-43
-46
.
/
-47
. 1984
-48
1
. 1988
/
.
-49
1
/
-50
-51
. 1393
. 1994
2
/
-52
-53
.
. /
-54
-55
. 2000
-56
. 1998
/
.
-57
.
-58
. 1984
. 1978
- 153 -
-59
. 1981
-
10
-60
. /
-61
. 1995
-62
. 1978
.(
.
-
-63
-64
/
1
. 1987
1
-
-66
. 1997
. 1978
-65
-67
2
-
-68
-69
. 2003
-
-70
.
-71
. 1995
.
.
-72
. 1980
-73
3
/
.
1
-75
/
. 2003
- 154 -
-74
-76
. /
-77
. 1999
-1
-78
. 1992
/
. 1998
-79
-
-80
-81
:
. /
-1
1988
-2
.1982/55
8
-3
26
. 1399
. /
.332
2000 2
)
.2006/6/23
-4
27
-5
:(
-1
http://www.arabandalucia.com/index.php/1699,
2007/3/15
-2
http://www.pnic.gov.ps/arabic/palestine/israel_dectionary.html
- 155 -
. /( 897-92)
. 2000
-1
. /
. 1406
-2
1
. /
. 2003
-3
-4
1999
/
.
-5
2004
- 156 -
Abstract
- 157 -
Chapter four: Represents Ibn Hazm replies on the accusations of Ibn AlNagziah Al-Yahoodee about some verses of Holly Quran. Where, he
showed that these similarities resulted from the lack of knowledge of the
Arabic language. Also this chapter presents the views of many scholars
both modern and old about the questioned verses.
Finally: Conclusion includes the following findings:
Provide evidences of the alterations and the changes in Torah through
the internal and external examination and criticism of Torah.
Provide evidences of the alterations and changes in Torah through the
scientific examination and criticism of Torah.
Provide evidences of the alterations and the changes in Torah through
identification of diversions and misleads in the Jewish faith.
Identify the Jewish accusations and allegations about the Holly Quran
and the best ways to controvert them.
- 158 -
1
2
2
3
4
:
:
:
6
6
13
17
:
:
19
19
21
24
25
29
33
36
:
:
42
43
43
48
:
:
63
- 159 -
64
64
68
:
:
70
70
72
73
75
76
78
:
:
92
:
93
93
96
105
105
106
109
109
111
111
113
115
115
116
:
:
118
120
:
:
120
- 160 -
121
122
122
125
128
130
133
136
140
143
145
145
146
147
150
157
159
Abstract
- 161 -