Presented Presented by by Richard Richard Leech Leech || Executive Executive Director Director || CBRE CBRE Richard Richard Leech Leech || Executive Executive Director Director || CBRE CBRE Vu Vu Nguyen Nguyen || Vice Vice Director Director || NVB NVB Holiday Holiday Club Club Giang Giang Ngo Ngo || Research Research Manager Manager || CBRE CBRE Nam Nam Tran Tran || Head Head of of Investment Investment | | Archi Archi Group Group 12 12 May 2011 May 2011 nn INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION You Are About To You Are About To t i o n t i o n Understand products offered You Are About To You Are About To d u c t d u c tUnderstand products offered Second home (vacation property ownership) Timeshare (vacation ownership) n t r o d n t r o d ( p) Identify good products among those being offered Make decision I n I n DECISION DECISION DECISION DECISION CB Richard Ellis|Page2 nn Introduction Introduction Types of Resorts Types of Resorts t i o n t i o n Proximity to Primary Market Types of Resorts Types of Resorts d u c t d u c tProximity to Primary Market Destination resorts Located several hundred kilometres from primary market n t r o d n t r o d Visitors tend to fly there & visit once a year for 1-2 weeks Non-destination resorts Within a 2-3 hour drive of the primary market I n I n Within a 2-3 hour drive of the primary market Guests arrive by car, visit more frequently, and stay 3-4 days each time CB Richard Ellis|Page3 Six Senses Ninh Van Bay (Nha Trang) Ngoc Vien Islands (Hanoi) nn Introduction Introduction Types of Resorts Types of Resorts t i o n t i o n Location & Primary Amenities Types of Resorts Types of Resorts d u c t d u c tLocation & Primary Amenities Ocean resorts Lake/river resorts n t r o d n t r o d I n I n The Nam Hai (Da Nang) Hyatt Regency (Da Nang) Ngoc Vien Islands Six Senses Sai Gon River Mountain/ ski resorts Golf course resorts CB Richard Ellis|Page4 Hoang Dong (Lang Son) Flamingo Dai Lai (Vinh Phuc) Tan Vien Villas & Resorts (Hanoi) ee Spectrum of Vacation Ownership Spectrum of Vacation Ownership h a r e h a r e m e s h m e s h T i m T i m CB Richard Ellis|Page5 ee TIMESHARE TIMESHARE Agenda Agenda h a r e h a r eAgenda Agenda m e s h m e s h T i m T i m Overview Buying Ti h Exchanging P Case St di Timeshare Process Studies CB Richard Ellis|Page6 ee OVERVIEW OVERVIEW Timeshare (Vacation Ownership) Timeshare (Vacation Ownership) h a r e h a r e Concept Timeshare (Vacation Ownership) Timeshare (Vacation Ownership) m e s h m e s h Concept The right to accommodations at a vacation development for a specified period each year, for a specified number of years or for t it T i m T i m perpetuity Source: The United States Timeshare Industry The ownership of a particular piece of real estate for a particular time The ownership of a particular piece of real estate for a particular time interval Instead of buying the whole condo, you buy that condo for a specific week of the year This makes ownership much more affordable and available to a wider group year. This makes ownership much more affordable and available to a wider group of people. Source: The Real Estate Investment Handbook A form of ownership or right to the use of a property or to describe A form of ownership or right to the use of a property, or to describe such properties. Multiple parties hold rights to use the property, and each sharer is allotted a period f ti i hi h th th t of time in which they may use the property. The share holder has no claim of ownership of the property. CB Richard Ellis|Page7 ee Overview Overview Nature of Product Nature of Product h a r e h a r e Timeshare is not about making money, but about: Nature of Product Nature of Product m e s h m e s h Timeshare is not about making money, but about: Pride of ownership Getting away from it all to a place of beauty, relaxation, and pleasure T i m T i m A sense of predictability & permanence in an uncertain world CB Richard Ellis|Page8 ee Overview Overview Nature of Product Nature of Product h a r e h a r eNature of Product Nature of Product m e s h m e s h Timeshare Purchase weekly increments T i m T i m y Villas can be deeded, right-to-use or a points-based program Many affiliated with resort/hotel companies Most associated with exchange company Nightly rentals typically available Annual fees Pricing varies by program G ll d l d b ld Generally treated as real property and can be resold CB Richard Ellis|Page9 ee Overview Overview Timeshare Development Timeshare Development h a r e h a r e Timeshares began in France in the late 1960s and were first seen in Timeshare Development Timeshare Development m e s h m e s h g the US in the 1970s. The primary idea was to trade the vacation on one property for a vacation on another property in a different location The motivation was to be able to T i m T i m on another property in a different location. The motivation was to be able to vacation in different parts of the world. Nearly 4,500 timeshare resorts owned by almost 10 million households are located in 81 countries North America: over 2 000 resorts ( 50% of the total) North America: over 2,000 resorts ( 50% of the total) Europe: over 1,000 resorts ( 20% of the total) Entry into the field Prominent resort developers & hoteliers: Starwood, Marriott, Hyatt, Hilton, Thomas Cook, Wyndham, Accor and Disney Thomas Cook, Wyndham, Accor and Disney 40% of potential buyers prefer a branded product while 21% rate it as very/extremely unimportant in their decision making CB Richard Ellis|Page10 ee Overview Overview The Shared Ownership Triangle The Shared Ownership Triangle h a r e h a r e The Shared Ownership Triangle The Shared Ownership Triangle The Shared Ownership Triangle m e s h m e s h The Shared Ownership Triangle T i m T i m CB Richard Ellis|Page11 ee TIMESHARE TIMESHARE Agenda Agenda h a r e h a r eAgenda Agenda m e s h m e s h T i m T i m Overview Buying Ti h Exchanging P Case St di Timeshare Process Studies CB Richard Ellis|Page12 ee BUYING TIMESHARE BUYING TIMESHARE Why would you buy? Why would you buy? h a r e h a r e Purchase Motivation Why would you buy? Why would you buy? m e s h m e s h Purchase Motivation 8 out of 10 owners state they are satisfied with their purchase of all owners recommend timeshares to friends T i m T i m Flexibility over when, where, and how they vacation You can visit your home resort or exchange to others through companies In some programs you can even exchange for spas, cruises, hotels, and specialty p g y g p p y tours throughout the world Economics: Owners report they save money over the long term Certainty about the availability and quality of popular resorts Certainty about the availability and quality of popular resorts Safety and secure environments for family vacations Quality Quality The quality of accommodations offered at timeshare resorts is typically of a higher standard than that of normal hotel accommodation. Many of the top hospitality brands have even developed timeshare resorts that are Many of the top hospitality brands have even developed timeshare resorts that are of higher quality than their established hotel brand. Variety for ownership or exchange CB Richard Ellis|Page13 Villas, apartments, lodges, cottages, catamarans, houseboats, canal boats or even cruise ships. ee Buying Timeshare Buying Timeshare Why would you buy? Why would you buy? h a r e h a r e Purchase Motivation Why would you buy? Why would you buy? m e s h m e s h Purchase Motivation Amenities go beyond traditional hospitality accommodation Spacious units T i m T i m Resort amenities Swimming pools, tennis courts, Jacuzzi, spa and fitness facilities. Golf, boating, skiing, water sports, and amusement and theme parks on-site or nearby, planned childrens activities. TOP 5 REASONS TO BUY TIMESHARE 42% 44% Economics (buy future vacation at current rate) Exchange vacation 5% 5% Secured Resort Quality Reasonable Rate vacation at current rate) 4% 5% Favor Resort Secured Resort Quality CB Richard Ellis|Page14 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% Source: RCIs Member Survey (2005) ee Buying Timeshare Buying Timeshare Timeshare Guests/Owner Timeshare Guests/Owner h a r e h a r e Use pattern Timeshare Guests/Owner Timeshare Guests/Owner m e s h m e s h Use pattern Only 2% of timeshare owners normally return to the same location at the same time each year T i m T i m Use Pattern of Timeshare Owners not used at all, 9% give away/rent it out, 7% exchange timeshare, 44% , household use of timeshare, 40% CB Richard Ellis|Page15 Source: The United States Timeshare Industry: Overview and Economic Impact Analysis, 1997 ee Buying Timeshare Buying Timeshare Why would you NOT buy? Why would you NOT buy? h a r e h a r e Hesitation About Buying Why would you NOT buy? Why would you NOT buy? m e s h m e s h Hesitation About Buying High initial purchase & annual maintenance fee Motivation for purchasing was economic. T i m T i m To purchase, the potential owner must feel that the long-term savings will outweigh the initial and continuing costs. Not using the timeshare enough to justify the expense of the purchase g g j y p p The resort experience will not meet the expectations created during the sales presentation. Al t 20% i di t d th t hi h l t h i d th t h it t Almost 20% indicated that high-pressure sales techniques caused them to hesitate before buying. The key to successfully investing in a timeshare Purchase the highest quality unit (in terms of geographic location and time of the year) at the lowest price time of the year) at the lowest price CB Richard Ellis|Page16 ee TIMESHARE TIMESHARE Agenda Agenda h a r e h a r eAgenda Agenda m e s h m e s h T i m T i m Overview Buying Ti h Exchanging P Case St di Timeshare Process Studies CB Richard Ellis|Page17 ee EXCHANGING TIMESHARE EXCHANGING TIMESHARE Exchange Product Evolution Exchange Product Evolution h a r e h a r e Exchange Product Evolution Exchange Product Evolution Exchange Product Evolution m e s h m e s h Exchange Product Evolution T i m T i m CB Richard Ellis|Page18 ee Exchanging Timeshare Exchanging Timeshare Exchanging Methods Exchanging Methods h a r e h a r e (1) Through exchange agencies Exchanging Methods Exchanging Methods m e s h m e s h (1) Through exchange agencies 2 largest & most reputable agencies Resort Condominiums International (RCI) T i m T i m Interval International (II) Most timeshares use one or the other of these firms, while some use both both CB Richard Ellis|Page19 ee Exchanging Timeshare Exchanging Timeshare Exchanging Methods Exchanging Methods h a r e h a r e Exchange Process Exchanging Methods Exchanging Methods m e s h m e s h Exchange Process T i m T i m CB Richard Ellis|Page20 ee Exchanging Timeshare Exchanging Timeshare Exchanging Methods Exchanging Methods h a r e h a r e RCI International Network Exchanging Methods Exchanging Methods m e s h m e s h RCI International Network (6,308 resorts @2011) T i m T i m CB Richard Ellis|Page21 ee Exchanging Timeshare Exchanging Timeshare Exchanging Methods Exchanging Methods h a r e h a r e (2) Through independent exchange companies Exchanging Methods Exchanging Methods m e s h m e s h (2) Through independent exchange companies Owners can exchange without needing the resort to have a formal affiliation agreement with the companies M j t i ( M i tt I t ti l) d l ti h T i m T i m Major resort companies (e.g., Marriott International) develop timeshare resorts & maintain a private internal exchange system (3) Through direct exchange (bulletin boards) This requires locating an owner with the location and weeks are mutually d i d desired. This form of exchange saves money on exchange fees and is often sought after. CB Richard Ellis|Page22 ee Exchanging Timeshare Exchanging Timeshare Exchanging Methods Exchanging Methods h a r e h a r e Redweek.com Exchanging Methods Exchanging Methods m e s h m e s h Redweek.com T i m T i m CB Richard Ellis|Page23 ee Exchanging Timeshare Exchanging Timeshare Exchange Tips for Buyers Exchange Tips for Buyers h a r e h a r e Key Things for a Successful Exchange Exchange Tips for Buyers Exchange Tips for Buyers m e s h m e s h Key Things for a Successful Exchange Think what before where Think about activities & experiences you would enjoy during your vacation T i m T i m Advance planning pays off Place your request as far as possible in advance of the dates you want to travel to maximize your chances of securing the vacation of your dreams y g y Be flexible when requesting travel dates and resort locations Listing several options enhances your chance for a timely confirmation Willi t t it dl f th i ill h h Willingness to accept a unit regardless of the size will enhance your exchange opportunities Consider a trip in the off-season or visit a lesser known destination that offers a similar vacation experience Source: ARDA 2011 Source: ARDA, 2011 CB Richard Ellis|Page24 ee TIMESHARE TIMESHARE Agenda Agenda h a r e h a r eAgenda Agenda m e s h m e s h T i m T i m Overview Buying Ti h Exchanging P Case St di Timeshare Process Studies CB Richard Ellis|Page25 ee CASE STUDIES CASE STUDIES China China h a r e h a r eChina China m e s h m e s h T i m T i m 4,000 hotels and resorts CB Richard Ellis|Page26 ee Case Studies Case Studies Malaysia Malaysia h a r e h a r eMalaysia Malaysia m e s h m e s h RCI T i m T i m Home & Affiliated (domestic Internal Resorts (domestic & overseas) Limited Exchange CB Richard Ellis|Page27 Exchange ee Case Studies Case Studies Vietnam Vietnam h a r e h a r e Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club (NVBHC) Vietnam Vietnam m e s h m e s h Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club (NVBHC) Opened in 2010 Is an affiliate of the Resort Condominium International (RCI) T i m T i m ( ) Members can enjoy vacations at 4 - 5 star resorts in NVBHCs system. Cl b R t Club Resorts Club connections (domestic) Club connections (overseas) ( ) Club privileges Club cruises and more than 4000 resorts in RCI's system CB Richard Ellis|Page28 ee Case Studies Case Studies Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club h a r e h a r e Member benefits Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club m e s h m e s h Member benefits 7 nights/year at the resorts within Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club or exchanged with 4,000 RCI-affiliated resorts in over 100 countries. T i m T i m Split, accrue, and advance their vacations using a flexible days/units system. Complimentary use of swimming pool fitness and additional discounts Complimentary use of swimming pool, fitness and additional discounts on other services at the resorts. Additional privileges at luxurious merchandises p g Dedicated Member Service team to consult all travel needs Private butlers at our member resorts CB Richard Ellis|Page29 ee Case Studies Case Studies Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club h a r e h a r e Resort Selection Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club m e s h m e s h Resort Selection Club Resorts Ana Mandara Villas Dalat Resort & Spa, Ana Mandara Hue, Ana Mandara T i m T i m Ninh Binh (opening in May 2011), Ana Mandara Hoi An (expected to open in 2013), Ana Mandara Binh Thuan (expected to open in 2013) Club connections (domestic) ( ) Allezboo Resort, Seahorse Resort, Sunrise Nha Trang Hotel, Diamond Bay Resort, Hoi An Boutique Resort, and more to come. Cl b ti ( ) Club connections (overseas) Absolute Vacation Club, Palace Vacation Club, Legend Holidays Club, Ramada Yantai Club, etc. Club privileges Evason Ana Mandara Nha Trang, Six Senses Ninh Van Bay, Princess D'Anam Movenpick Saigon Intercontinental Westlake Hanoi Six Senses DAnam, Movenpick Saigon, Intercontinental Westlake Hanoi, Six Senses Saigon River (2012), Six Senses Phu Quoc (2014), etc. Club cruises CB Richard Ellis|Page30 Bhaya Cruises, Paradise Cruises, etc. ee Case Studies Case Studies Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club h a r e h a r e Package Options Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club m e s h m e s h Package Options T i m T i m 5 years 17 years 27 years 17 years Corporate Individual Individual VIP 1 room 1 room 1 room 1 pool villa N E h RCI E h RCI E h TRC E h (*) No Exchange RCI Exchange RCI Exchange TRC Exchange (*) CB Richard Ellis|Page31 (*) Note: TRC (The Registry Collection), a brand of Wyndham Worldwide, is an exclusive Club of 5-star and luxury hotels & resorts ee Broad Spectrum of Vacation Ownership Broad Spectrum of Vacation Ownership o m e o m e d
h o d
h o c o n d c o n d S e c S e c CB Richard Ellis|Page32 ee SECOND HOME SECOND HOME Agenda Agenda o m e o m eAgenda Agenda d
h o d
h o c o n d c o n d S e c S e c CB Richard Ellis|Page33 ee VIETNAM SECOND HOME MARKET VIETNAM SECOND HOME MARKET Key Concepts Key Concepts o m e o m e Secondhome Key Concepts Key Concepts d
h o d
h o Secondhome A residence that is not one's Principal Residence Source: Barron's Real Estate Dictionary c o n d c o n d A home that is not the primary residence of the owner but is not a rental property Source: Financial Publishing S e c S e c Source: Financial Publishing Terms varied: UK: holiday home US: second home/vacation property Australia: a holiday house/home, or weekender CB Richard Ellis|Page34 ee Vietnam Second Home Market Vietnam Second Home Market o m e o m e d
h o d
h o c o n d c o n d S e c S e c CB Richard Ellis|Page35 ee Vietnam Second Home Market Vietnam Second Home Market o m e o m e Unit Price (US$) PROJECTS' PRICE BY LAUNCHING YEAR d
h o d
h o Tuan Chau Ha Long The Nam Hai Hyatt Regency Vinpearl Danang $1,800,000 $2,000,000 c o n d c o n d Tuan Chau Ha Long Montgomerie Links The Nam Hai Six Senses Saigon River Six Senses Con Dao $1,400,000 $1,600,000 S e c S e c Ocean Villas Sanctuary Ho Tram Saint Simeon $1,000,000 $1,200,000 Flamingo Dai Lai Ngoc Vien Islands Flamboyant Grand Arena Hill S Li k Son Tra Spa & Resort Furama Villas Blue Sapphire $600,000 $800,000 Hoang Dong Melody Villas Tan Vien Villas Lam Son Resort Mui Ne Domain Dune Residences Sea Links Oceanami $200,000 $400,000 Swan Lake Villas Green Villas Country House Giang Huong Sunny Villas $0 $200,000 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 CB Richard Ellis|Page36 Northern Projects Central Projects Southern Projects ee Vietnam Second Home Market Vietnam Second Home Market Hoa Binh / Ba Vi / Vinh Phuc Hoa Binh / Ba Vi / Vinh Phuc o m e o m e Province Profile Monsoon climate with cold winters Hoa Binh / Ba Vi / Vinh Phuc Hoa Binh / Ba Vi / Vinh Phuc d
h o d
h o Family vacation Things to do: day trips, golf, natural landscaping St G t l t ( M t Pl ) c o n d c o n d Strong Governmental support (new Master Plan) Infrastructure Developing infrastructure 1-2 hours from Noi Bai International Airport S e c S e c 1 2 hours from Noi Bai International Airport Active Developers Archi Group, INT, Beverly Investment Buyer Options Large variety of choice y p Lake/river, golf course, mountain villas, townhouses Varying price ranges Projects Unit Price Price psm Land Hoa Binh Lam Son Resort Sunset Villas US$200-350,000 or US$50-170,000 (land only) US$220-500 psm Ba Vi Zen resort US$100,000 (land only) US$190psm(land only) Ngoc Vienisland US$640-870,000 US$700-800 psm The GrandArena US$400 800 000 US$850 1300 psm CB Richard Ellis|Page37 The Grand Arena US$400-800,000 US$850-1300 psm VinhPhuc Flamingo Dai Lai US$720,000 US$1,200 psm ee Vietnam Second Home Market Vietnam Second Home Market Hai Phong / Quang Ninh Hai Phong / Quang Ninh o m e o m e City/Province Adult / young family vacation Hai Phong / Quang Ninh Hai Phong / Quang Ninh d
h o d
h o y Profile y g y Things to do: 2-3 day trips, natural wonders, water sports Infrastructure Developing infrastructure c o n d c o n d 2-3 hour from international airport Active Developers Vinaconex ITC, Amco-Mibaek Vina, Daso B O ti Limited choices S e c S e c Buyer Options Limited choices Beach or city villas, townhouses CB Richard Ellis|Page38 ee Vietnam Second Home Market Vietnam Second Home Market Da Nang City Da Nang City o m e o m e City Profile Established tourism destination in Vietnam Da Nang City Da Nang City d
h o d
h o y Adult / older family vacation Things to do: day trips, golf, natural wonders, water sports St G t l t c o n d c o n d Strong Governmental support Temperate climate all year round Infrastructure Excellent infrastructure S e c S e c Infrastructure Excellent infrastructure International airport Active Developers VinaCapital/ VinaLiving, Indochina Land, Blooming Buyer Options Wide variety of choice Beach, golf course, mountain and city villas, condos Q lit & i Quality & price CB Richard Ellis|Page39 ee Vietnam Second Home Market Vietnam Second Home Market Nha Trang City Nha Trang City o m e o m e City Profile Family friendly destination Nha Trang City Nha Trang City d
h o d
h o y y y Primarily HCMC short-stay visitors Limited things to do - water activities c o n d c o n d Infrastructure Improved infrastructure International airport Active Developers Vin Group Ninh Van Bay Havana TD Corporation Hoan S e c S e c Active Developers Vin Group, Ninh Van Bay, Havana, TD Corporation, Hoan Cau, VinaCapital/ VinaLiving, An Vien Group Buyer Options Limited choice Beach and city condos available Land lots CB Richard Ellis|Page40 ee Vietnam Second Home Market Vietnam Second Home Market Phan Thiet / Mui Ne Phan Thiet / Mui Ne o m e o m e City Profile Family friendly destination Phan Thiet / Mui Ne Phan Thiet / Mui Ne d
h o d
h o y y y Primarily HCMC weekend getaway Things to do: mainly water sports, some natural wonders c o n d c o n d Infrastructure No airport, roadways can be congested Active Developers A&B, Rang Dong, Sai Gon Invest B O i Li it d h i S e c S e c Buyer Options Limited choice Seaside resort investments Land lots Condos are coming CB Richard Ellis|Page41 ee Vietnam Second Home Market Vietnam Second Home Market Long Hai / Vung Tau Long Hai / Vung Tau o m e o m e City Profile Inexpensive weekend holiday Long Hai / Vung Tau Long Hai / Vung Tau d
h o d
h o y p y HCMC quick getaway Things to do: water activities, local dining options c o n d c o n d Infrastructure Infrastructure improvement underway Active Developers Lac Viet Corporation, DIC, Refico, Cotecland, Rung Duong, PVC-IC S e c S e c PVC IC Buyer Options Limited choice Seaside resort investments Land lots Condos are coming CB Richard Ellis|Page42 ee Vietnam Second Home Market Vietnam Second Home Market Phu Quoc Island Phu Quoc Island o m e o m e City Profile Island visited by HCMC crowd as family weekend getaway Phu Quoc Island Phu Quoc Island d
h o d
h o y y y g y Things to do water activities, eco-tourism Infrastructure Limited infrastructure with plans for improvement including an international airport c o n d c o n d an international airport Active Developers Tropicana, Chen La, Berjaya Buyer Options Limited choice S e c S e c Buyer Options Limited choice Seaside resort investments Land lots CB Richard Ellis|Page43 ee SECOND HOME SECOND HOME Agenda Agenda o m e o m eAgenda Agenda d
h o d
h o c o n d c o n d S e c S e c CB Richard Ellis|Page44 ee A Buyers Guide A Buyers Guide Why buy a second home? Why buy a second home? o m e o m e As an Investment, buyers should consider Why buy a second home? Why buy a second home? d
h o d
h o As an Investment, buyers should consider Location/resort types Ownership: Leasehold vs. Freehold c o n d c o n d p Cost of Purchase (payment terms, construction progress) Costs of Ownership / Rental pool program S e c S e c Appreciation potential As a Vacation Property, buyers should consider Location/resort types & Purpose P i & i f Price & service fees Facilities / Amenities of the Development & around the property Swimming pool golf gardens shuttle service shopping Swimming pool, golf, gardens, shuttle service, shopping Food & beverage outlets, retail centres Leisure activities golf, yachting, biking CB Richard Ellis|Page45 ee A Buyers Guide A Buyers Guide Buyer's Check List Buyer's Check List o m e o m e Top Things for Buyers to Review Buyer s Check List Buyer s Check List d
h o d
h o Top Things for Buyers to Review Location, location, location Brand c o n d c o n d Quality Business Operation Model S e c S e c CB Richard Ellis|Page46 ee A Buyers Guide A Buyers Guide Buyer's Check List Buyer's Check List -- Location Location o m e o m e Location - City Buyer s Check List Buyer s Check List -- Location Location d
h o d
h o Location City Access/Infrastructure Tourism c o n d c o n d Other activities that support holiday lifestyle Government support through funding, initiatives, investments, S e c S e c infrastructure projects CB Richard Ellis|Page47 ee A Buyers Guide A Buyers Guide Buyer's Check List Buyer's Check List -- Location Location o m e o m e Good Governance Infrastructure Investment Linked Buyer s Check List Buyer s Check List -- Location Location d
h o d
h o Good Governance Infrastructure Investment Linked Infrastructure Advantage Less Valued Economic Governance Infrastructure Advantages Highly Valued Economic Governance 0 c o n d c o n d Less Valued Economic Governance Highly Valued Economic Governance Da Nang 8 0 Hanoi Hai Phong S e c S e c r u c t u r e Khanh Hoa Quang Nam BR-VT Vi nh Phuc Quang Ni nh I n f r a s t r Ki Gi 6 0 Ki en Gi ang Hoa Bi nh Low Infrastructure Less Valued Economic Governance Low Infrastructure Highly valued economic governance 70 50 60 4 0 CB Richard Ellis|Page48 Weighted Provincial Competitive Index2010 Source: USAID/VNCI Policy Paper #15 2010, p. 27 70 50 60 ee A Buyers Guide A Buyers Guide Buyer's Check List Buyer's Check List -- Location Location o m e o m e Tourism Local & International Buyer s Check List Buyer s Check List -- Location Location d
h o d
h o Tourism Local & International Level of tourism top 10 domestic destinations & numbers of arrivals to each (annually) c o n d c o n d 7 000 8,000 s a n d ) TOP 10 DESTINATIONS IN VIETNAM (2010) S e c S e c 5,000 6,000 7,000 v a l s
( t h o u s 2 000 3,000 4,000 b e r
o f
a r r i v - 1,000 2,000 N u m HCMC Da Nang Hanoi Quang Ninh Hue Khanh Hoa Binh Thuan Can Tho Da Lat Phu Quoc International Arrivals Local Arrivals CB Richard Ellis|Page49 International Arrivals Local Arrivals Source: Vietnamese Statistics Office ee A Buyers Guide A Buyers Guide Buyer's Check List Buyer's Check List -- Location Location o m e o m e Location - Address Buyer s Check List Buyer s Check List -- Location Location d
h o d
h o Location Address On the beach, near the sea, in the city, in the mountains Location can determine long term capital value c o n d c o n d g p Limited locations choice vs. availability Early buyers will get the best locations S e c S e c Good developments are often unique CB Richard Ellis|Page50 ee A Buyers Guide A Buyers Guide Buyer's Check List Buyer's Check List -- Branding Branding o m e o m e Brands a way to categorize Buyer s Check List Buyer s Check List -- Branding Branding d
h o d
h o Brands a way to categorize Can apply to property developers, managers, and operators Helps to quickly and easily identify a property/service c o n d c o n d Sets levels for quality & standards International/national visibility & product knowledge Enhances value S e c S e c Enhances value CB Richard Ellis|Page51 ee A Buyers Guide A Buyers Guide Buyer's Check List Buyer's Check List -- Quality Options Quality Options o m e o m e Market skips straight to quality Buyer s Check List Buyer s Check List -- Quality Options Quality Options d
h o d
h o Market skips straight to quality Traditional build-up period skipped in Vietnam E.g. beach side bungalows/huts c o n d c o n d Quality developers are active in several second home markets offering peace of mind for absentee owners Q lit f d l t l i iti fi t /fitti S e c S e c Quality of developments planning, amenities, fixtures/fittings on par with city homes (or beyond due to number of quality options!) Quality assurance further supported with branded Q y pp owners/operators/managers who up-hold set international standards CB Richard Ellis|Page52 ee A Buyers Guide A Buyers Guide Buyer's Check List Buyer's Check List -- Business Operation Business Operation o m e o m eBuyer s Check List Buyer s Check List -- Business Operation Business Operation Model Model d
h o d
h o What happens when you arent there? Who manages the property? c o n d c o n d g p p y Is there a rental pool program? What is expected ROI? S e c S e c CB Richard Ellis|Page53 ee SECONDHOME SECONDHOME Agenda Agenda o m e o m eAgenda Agenda d
h o d
h o c o n d c o n d S e c S e c CB Richard Ellis|Page54 ee RENTAL POOL PROGRAM RENTAL POOL PROGRAM A Business Operation Model A Business Operation Model o m e o m e Vacation Rental Pool A Business Operation Model A Business Operation Model d
h o d
h o Vacation Rental Pool Renting vacation property (on a nightly or weekly basis) could provide additional income. c o n d c o n d For renters, the savings can be significant compared to hotels or vacation packages. For owners, it can be as rewarding as paying the mortgage S e c S e c , g p y g g g CB Richard Ellis|Page55 The Nam Hai Six Senses Sai Gon ee Rental Pool Program Rental Pool Program Key Concepts Key Concepts o m e o m e Key Concepts Key Concepts Key Concepts d
h o d
h o Key Concepts An arrangement in which owners in a large community agree to make their units available for rental by a common leasing agent or property c o n d c o n d manager. All share in the overall Revenues/Expenses according to a predetermined formula. S e c S e c predetermined formula. The Complete Real Estate Encyclopedia , 2007 CB Richard Ellis|Page56 ee Rental Pool Program Rental Pool Program Homeowners Homeowners -- Benefit Benefit o m e o m e Property ownership remains with the owner. Can expect value Homeowners Homeowners -- Benefit Benefit d
h o d
h o Property ownership remains with the owner. Can expect value appreciation over time Particularly suitable with Vietnams context c o n d c o n d Owners can use their properties for free for a predetermined period of time every year (1-3 months) O t h f fit f ti th i ti S e c S e c Owners can get a share of profits from renting their properties when they are not present Property is well maintained all year round Property is well maintained all year round Others Are prioritized in booking holiday Are prioritized in booking holiday Get discount when using services & facilities CB Richard Ellis|Page57 ee Rental Pool Program Rental Pool Program Homeowners Homeowners -- Time of Using Time of Using o m e o m e Free Usage: Owners can use their properties for free for a Homeowners Homeowners -- Time of Using Time of Using d
h o d
h o Free Usage: Owners can use their properties for free for a predetermined period of time every year The Nam Hai: 35 days/year c o n d c o n d Hyatt Regency Da Nang: 90 days/year Vinpearl Da Nang: 90 days/year Unused days S e c S e c Unused days Owners can choose to carry forwards to the next year or put their units into the rental pool for extra income Over usage (market practice) Low season: rate for homeowners can be 15% of current rental rate Hi h t t 50% f t t l t High season: rate can go up to 50% of current rental rate Booking 30 days prior to the day of occupation 30 days prior to the day of occupation In case the units are unavailable, homeowners could be offered another alternate at 30% discount from current rental rate CB Richard Ellis|Page58 ee Rental Pool Program Rental Pool Program Sharing Rental Profits Sharing Rental Profits -- Two Methods Two Methods o m e o m e Actual Profit Sharing Sharing Rental Profits Sharing Rental Profits -- Two Methods Two Methods d
h o d
h o Actual Profit Sharing Operator/Resort owner rents out the units (villas/bungalows/condos) as part of the resort pool c o n d c o n d Homeowners get a predetermined share of profits based actual annual net income Hyatt Regency Da Nang Vinpearl Da Nang: owners get 50% of net income S e c S e c Hyatt Regency Da Nang, Vinpearl Da Nang: owners get 50% of net income Furama Villas: 60% of net income for owners Fixed Income Homeowners get fixed income annually based on propertys price Furama Villas: US$10 000 (in value) = 1 point = US$1 annual income Furama Villas: US$10,000 (in value) = 1 point = US$1 annual income Annual income can be low but stress-free and stable. Homeowners do not have to pay any other expenses Homeowners do not have to pay any other expenses CB Richard Ellis|Page59 ee SECOND HOME SECOND HOME Agenda Agenda o m e o m eAgenda Agenda d
h o d
h o c o n d c o n d S e c S e c CB Richard Ellis|Page60 ee CASE STUDIES CASE STUDIES Thailand Thailand -- Karma Samui Beach Resort Karma Samui Beach Resort o m e o m e 5-star luxury beach resort Thailand Thailand -- Karma Samui Beach Resort Karma Samui Beach Resort d
h o d
h o y 36 residential pool villas 2-6 bedrooms c o n d c o n d 216 sm-385 sm Pricing: US$956,000-US$975,000 Property values S e c S e c US$956,000 US$975,000 Property values in surrounding area of resort expected to grow 10-20% per annum over next 5-10 years. 3x30 year leasehold ROI options (Rental Pool) P t h f t l i Percentage share of quarterly income 28 days complimentary use annually Guaranteed ROI 5% of net capital value per annum CB Richard Ellis|Page61 Source: Karmasamui.com ee Case Studies Case Studies Thailand Thailand -- Azaya Villas Mountain Resort Azaya Villas Mountain Resort o m e o m e 3 hectare 5-star mountain resort Thailand Thailand -- Azaya Villas Mountain Resort Azaya Villas Mountain Resort d
h o d
h o 12 luxury villas 2-5 Bedrooms c o n d c o n d 185 sm-465 sm GFA Land 1,089-1,868 sm Pricing S e c S e c c g US$700,000-$1,250,000 Rental income is expected to yield double digit annual returns on investment as well digit annual returns on investment as well as capital appreciation. 3x30 year leasehold R t l P l Rental Pool Management fee: 30% of rental income CB Richard Ellis|Page62 Source: Azayavillas.com ee Case Studies Case Studies Bali Indonesia Bali Indonesia -- Sea Sentosa Beach Resort Sea Sentosa Beach Resort o m e o m e 5-star luxury beach resort Bali, Indonesia Bali, Indonesia -- Sea Sentosa Beach Resort Sea Sentosa Beach Resort d
h o d
h o y 70 luxury residences 1 bedroom: 94 -117 sm GFA c o n d c o n d 2 bedroom: 201 -217 sm GFA 3 bedroom: 188 - 235 sm GFA Pricing S e c S e c c g 1 bedroom - US$450,000 2 bedroom - US$900,000 3 bedroom US$2 000 000 3 bedroom - US$2,000,000 Surrounding area has experienced a 300% increase in land value over last 5 years. 2 25 l h ld 2x25 year leasehold Rental Pool Management fee of 30% net revenue Management fee of 30% net revenue CB Richard Ellis|Page63 Source: SeaSentosa.com ee Case Studies Case Studies Bali Indonesia Bali Indonesia -- Rich Villas Mountain Resort Rich Villas Mountain Resort o m e o m e 17 luxury villas Bali, Indonesia Bali, Indonesia -- Rich Villas Mountain Resort Rich Villas Mountain Resort d
h o d
h o y 1 bedroom - 150 sm 2 bedroom - 200 sm P i i c o n d c o n d Pricing 1 bedroom - US$389,999 2 bedroom - US$489,999 S e c S e c 25 year leasehold Guaranteed ROI for 20-25 years Projected ROI of up to 11.5% Guaranteed buy-back and capital gains CB Richard Ellis|Page64 Source: BaliPlatinum.com ee Case Studies Case Studies Bali Indonesia Bali Indonesia -- Bali Rich Villas Resort Bali Rich Villas Resort o m e o m e ROI Packages Bali, Indonesia Bali, Indonesia -- Bali Rich Villas Resort Bali Rich Villas Resort (cont.) (cont.) d
h o d
h o g Package 1: Fixed ROI, Fixed buy-back, and fixed capital gain c o n d c o n d ROI: 7% net annually Buy-back by developer/operator on year 11 at 10% capital gain 21 days free accommodation annually S e c S e c y y Package 2: Fixed ROI Investment lock in period: 2 years Investment lock in period: 2 years Year 1-3: 8% net annually Year 4-6: 10% net annually Year 7 onwards: 11.5% net annually 21 days free accommodation annually CB Richard Ellis|Page65 ee Case Studies Case Studies Vietnam Vietnam Archi Archi Group Group o m e o m e About Archi Group Vietnam Vietnam Archi Archi Group Group d
h o d
h o An active villa and resort developer in Hanoi since 2007 Projects located within 1 hour from city centre c o n d c o n d S e c S e c CB Richard Ellis|Page66 ee Case Studies Case Studies Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group Archi Group o m e o m e Project Classification Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group Archi Group d
h o d
h o Project Classification Luxury villas & resort First class/Superior c o n d c o n d p High standard/First home vision S e c S e c Tan Vien Villas & Resort Vi N R t L S R t Tan Vien Villas & Resort Vien Nam Resort Lam Son Resort CB Richard Ellis|Page67 9-ivory Resort & Country Club Green Villas Country House Villas ee Case Studies Case Studies Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Project Types Archi Group / Project Types o m e o m e Type 1 - Luxury Villas & Resort Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Project Types Archi Group / Project Types d
h o d
h o Type 1 Luxury Villas & Resort Unit Price: US$300,000 - US$500,000 Villa Land Lot: 1,000 sm - 5,000 sm c o n d c o n d 5-star luxury services: spa, swimming pool, golf, tennis Ex: Lam Son Resort, Vien Nam Villas & Resort (Hoa Binh), 9-Ivory Eco- resort Tan Vien Villas & Resort S e c S e c resort, Tan Vien Villas & Resort Vien Nam Resort Villas 9 Ivory Eco-resort Services Area CB Richard Ellis|Page68 ee Case Studies Case Studies Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Project Types Archi Group / Project Types o m e o m e Type 2 - First Class Villas & Resort Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Project Types Archi Group / Project Types d
h o d
h o Type 2 First Class Villas & Resort Unit Price: US$150,000 - US$300,000 Villa Land Lot: 1,000 sm c o n d c o n d 4-star services: spa, swimming pool, mini-golf, tennis Ex: Green Villas, Family Villas (Ba Vi, Hanoi) S e c S e c Green Villas CB Richard Ellis|Page69 Villa Interior ee Case Studies Case Studies Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Project Types Archi Group / Project Types o m e o m e Type 3 - High Standard/ First Home Vision Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Project Types Archi Group / Project Types d
h o d
h o Type 3 High Standard/ First Home Vision Unit Price: US$80,000-$120,000 Villa Land Lot: 500 sm c o n d c o n d 3-4-star services: spa, swimming pool, fishing, bus to city centre Ex: Country house 1,2,3 S e c S e c First home vision 10 minutes to Hoa Lac Hi-Tech Park, 30 minutes to the new CBD and NUAs along Thang Long Boulevard NUAs along Thang Long Boulevard Target young people with high income and modern life style CB Richard Ellis|Page70 Country House Villas ee Case Studies Case Studies Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Investment Archi Group / Investment o m e o m e Investment Consideration Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Investment Archi Group / Investment d
h o d
h o Investment Consideration For buyers during initial/internal launch: 20-30% discount from the quoted price. c o n d c o n d 60%-70% price appreciation in the first year of purchase Commitment from Developer: t ll/ ll it ld t t t hi h i S e c S e c to sell/resell units sold to customers at higher price quoted price escalation over time Participate in Archi Group business program Participate in Archi Group business program Archi Group sells villas for the villa owner Archi Groups Rental Pool Program CB Richard Ellis|Page71 ee Case Studies Case Studies Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Rental Pool Archi Group / Rental Pool o m e o m e Rental Pool Program Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Rental Pool Archi Group / Rental Pool d
h o d
h o Rental Pool Program 5 year agreement 60/40 profit sharing between property owners/developers c o n d c o n d No limit for villas holiday of owners (3 months priority booking) Discount for services Archi Group responsible for marketing & propertys maintenance S e c S e c Archi Group responsible for marketing & property s maintenance Villas Owner Benefit 60% profit of rental pool program for villa owners Exchange holidays in all resort projects of Archi Group (Hoa Binh, Ba Vi, Phu Quoc) Phu Quoc) Discount of Archi Group resort service fees: 15% for F&B, 20% for spa Convert to holiday & weekend voucher for friends and family Participate in Archi Group investment program for villa owner CB Richard Ellis|Page72 ee Case Studies Case Studies Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Rental Pool Archi Group / Rental Pool o m e o m e Tan Vien Villas & Resort Sample P/L (*) Vietnam Vietnam Archi Group / Rental Pool Archi Group / Rental Pool d
h o d
h o Tan Vien Villas & Resort Sample P/L ( ) DESCRIPTION AMOUNT p a (US$) UNIT TYPE c o n d c o n d p.a (US$) Gross Revenue 20,000 Credit Card Commissions -800.4% of Gross Revenue Travel Agency Commission -3601.8% of Gross Revenue Total Rental Income 19 560 S e c S e c Total Rental Income 19,560 Expenses Cost of Goods Sold -3,91220% of Rental Income Rental Program Administration Fee -9785% of Rental Income Net Rental Income 14 670 Net Rental Income 14,670 Rental Program Fee -5,86840% of Net Rental Income Purchaser Net Income 8,802 Other Purchaser Expenses Reserve for big maintenance villas 4403% of Net Rental Income Reserve for big maintenance villas -4403% of Net Rental Income Utilities -7345% of Net Rental Income Management & small maintenance Fee -2,250US$0.75/sm/month Maintenance Fee for pubblic area -750US$0.25/sm/month Purchaser's Net Income 4 628 Purchaser's Net Income 4,628 3 Bedroom 250 sm Villas CB Richard Ellis|Page73 (*) Notes: Figures are for illustration only and are not indicative of the return that will be generated by participating in the Rental Program at Tan Vien Villas & Resort ee Case Studies Case Studies Ninh Ninh Van Bay Van Bay Six Senses Private Residences Saigon Six Senses Private Residences Saigon o m e o m e Location Ninh Ninh Van Bay Van Bay Six Senses Private Residences Saigon Six Senses Private Residences Saigon d
h o d
h oLocation In the Dong Nai River Beautiful landscape, eco-friendly environment c o n d c o n d eaut u a dscape, eco e d y e o e t S e c S e c CB Richard Ellis|Page74 ee Case Studies Case Studies Ninh Ninh Van Bay Van Bay Six Senses Private Residences Saigon Six Senses Private Residences Saigon o m e o m e Resort Operator - Six Senses Resort & Spa Group Ninh Ninh Van Bay Van Bay Six Senses Private Residences Saigon Six Senses Private Residences Saigon d
h o d
h o Resort Operator Six Senses Resort & Spa Group A leading resort and spa brand in the world, managing luxury resorts in Maldives, Thailand, Vietnam, Oman, Jordan, and Spain c o n d c o n d E.g: Six Senses Ninh Van Bay in Nha Trang, Vietnam won 15 international & national prizes having the annual revenue more than US$7 million S e c S e c g $ CB Richard Ellis|Page75 ee Case Studies Case Studies Ninh Ninh Van Bay Van Bay Six Senses Private Residences Saigon Six Senses Private Residences Saigon o m e o m e Specific design & High-end quality Ninh Ninh Van Bay Van Bay Six Senses Private Residences Saigon Six Senses Private Residences Saigon d
h o d
h o Specific design & High end quality Villa complex design: incorporates the classic Six Senses focus on all natural and environmentally responsible materials. c o n d c o n d Furnishings are classically simple synonymous with intelligent luxury and some emphasis of regionally inspired features. Furniture & fixtures included S e c S e c Furniture & fixtures included the latest energy-saving and environmentally responsible equipment all creature comforts: latest entertainment & audio systems, iPod universal d ki t ti fl t l t l i i d IDD t l h ith WiFi docking stations, flat-panel television and IDD telephones with WiFi Facilities & Amenities Personal gyms libraries private wine cellars and spa facilities Personal gyms, libraries, private wine cellars and spa facilities CB Richard Ellis|Page76 ee Case Studies Case Studies Ninh Ninh Van Bay Van Bay Six Senses Private Residences Saigon Six Senses Private Residences Saigon o m e o m e Villa Types Ninh Ninh Van Bay Van Bay Six Senses Private Residences Saigon Six Senses Private Residences Saigon d
h o d
h o Villa Types Type Land Area (sm) Price Services c o n d c o n d Latitude Villa Land Area: 406 sm Built Area: 243.1 sm US$500,000 S e c S e c 5-star++ services, swimming golf Pool Villa -1 BR Land Area: 650 sm Built Area: 352.5 sm US$1 million swimming, golf, tennis, worlds most creative experiences for Pool Villa Suite - 2 BR Land Area: 1,400 sm Built Area: 534.8 sm Pool: 248.5 sm US$1.5 million experiences for kids, spa Reserve Villa - 4 BR Land Area: 3,000 sm Built Area: 1,007 sm > US$3 million Pool: 365 sm CB Richard Ellis|Page77 ee Case Studies Case Studies Ninh Ninh Van Bay Van Bay Six Senses Private Residences Saigon Six Senses Private Residences Saigon o m e o m e Business Operating Model Ninh Ninh Van Bay Van Bay Six Senses Private Residences Saigon Six Senses Private Residences Saigon d
h o d
h o Business Operating Model Homeowners can choose 3 options Rental pool for 365 days/year c o n d c o n d Rental pool excluding 30 days per year Projected owners income: 80% of net profit after tax p.a Owners can use their properties for 30 days per year S e c S e c Owners can use their properties for 30 days per year Not join in rental pool CB Richard Ellis|Page78 Thank you for attending Thank you for attending!! Ngo Thi Huong Giang (Ms) Nguyen Thanh Vu (Mr.) Tran Hoang Nam (Mr.) Contact Details Contact Details Ngo Thi Huong Giang (Ms) Reseach Manager CB Richard Ellis (Vietnam) M: 0903 210 679 E: giang.ngo@cbre.com Nguyen Thanh Vu (Mr.) Vice Director (Sale & Marketing) Ninh Van Bay Holiday Club M: 0908 337 137 E: vunt@ninhvanbay.vn Tran Hoang Nam (Mr.) Head of Investment Archi Invest M: 0904 980 989 E: namth@archi.vn CB Richard Ellis|Page79 2011 CB Richard Ellis, We obtained the information above from sources we believe to be reliable. However, we have not verified its accuracy and make no guarantee, warranty or representation about it. It is submitted subject to the possibility of errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. We include projections, opinions, assumptions or estimates for example only, and they may not represent current or future performance of the property. You and your tax and legal advisors should conduct your own investigation of the property and transaction.