This document summarizes the Parivartan Project in Bihar, India which aims to improve routine immunization rates through community mobilization. It discusses how the project works with over 18,000 self-help groups, reaching 275,000 women, to educate them about the benefits of routine immunization. Through village volunteers called Sahelis, information is shared and discussions are held to increase awareness and motivate collective action in support of immunization. While immunization rates remain low in Bihar, initial outcomes of the program show increased community support and participation in immunization as a result of these group discussions.
This document summarizes the Parivartan Project in Bihar, India which aims to improve routine immunization rates through community mobilization. It discusses how the project works with over 18,000 self-help groups, reaching 275,000 women, to educate them about the benefits of routine immunization. Through village volunteers called Sahelis, information is shared and discussions are held to increase awareness and motivate collective action in support of immunization. While immunization rates remain low in Bihar, initial outcomes of the program show increased community support and participation in immunization as a result of these group discussions.
This document summarizes the Parivartan Project in Bihar, India which aims to improve routine immunization rates through community mobilization. It discusses how the project works with over 18,000 self-help groups, reaching 275,000 women, to educate them about the benefits of routine immunization. Through village volunteers called Sahelis, information is shared and discussions are held to increase awareness and motivate collective action in support of immunization. While immunization rates remain low in Bihar, initial outcomes of the program show increased community support and participation in immunization as a result of these group discussions.
Community Mobilisation: Parivartan Project in Bihar
Background: Bihar is one of Indias largest and poorest states with over 100 million people. Poor nutrition and poor health, particularly for women and children, lead to early deaths and generational cycles of lost potential. The state has one of the countrys highest rates of maternal, neonatal and infant mortality. Underlying factors that contribute to these negative health outcomes primarily include extreme poverty, gender and social inequality among many others. Recent trends in routine immunization outcomes in a high-burden state like Bihar is critical to India achieving its goals and contributing to Millennium Development Goals (MDG) 4 and 5.
Despite recent gains and commitments from the Government of Bihar (GOB) and active leadership of key stakeholders to improve routine immunization outcomes, deep-rooted problems limit the governments ability to affect lasting change. Persistent barriers include poor quality and availability of frontline staffs, limited access to services by neglected and marginalized populations, lack of accurate data, lack of effective program management, weak training systems, of supervision in health facilities. To this end, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF) is currently funding the Ananya Initiative, in partnership with the Government of Bihar (GOB), to accelerate improvements in a broad range of priority health outcomes: reproductive, maternal, neonatal and child health, nutrition, key infectious diseases, and sanitation and hygiene. Within Ananya, Project Concern International (PCI), in partnership with PATH and the Foundation for Research in Health Systems (FRHS), is implementing a community mobilization and social accountability grant, referred to as Parivartan, which provides a platform to empower communities to engage in processes that catalyze support networks and enable shifts in behavior and social norms, contributing to improved and sustainable health and sanitation outcomes in Bihar. Parivartans overall objective is to increase the adoption of key maternal, new-born, child health, and sanitation (MNCHS) behaviour among women of reproductive age in the Most Marginalized communities of scheduled castes, scheduled tribes, and backward Muslims. Parivartans theory of change proposes to overcome the barriers to driving health and sanitation outcomes among most marginalized communities in Bihar by organizing women into Self Help Groups (SHGs), sensitizing them to be influencers on health & sanitation and empowering them to lead their communities to improved family health behaviour, as well as greater accountability and equity of services.
Parivartan Reach Out: Parivartan works in 55 blocks in 8 districts 1 of Bihar (see map) to address equity issues related to caste, gender and other social variables which influence health and sanitation outcomes. At the grassroots, the project reaches approximately 275,000 women in the reproductive age group in the most marginalized communities through 18,000+ SHGs created by Parivartan, with each group typically having 12-15
1 Patna, Begusarai, Samastipur, East Champaran, West Champaran, Gopalganj, Khagaria, and Saharsa
Page | 2 women. In addition, Parivartan reaches out to approximately 150,000+ women belonging to 10,000+ Jeevika SHGs in two districts of Khagaria and Saharsa. Through these SHGs, Parivartan mobilizes communities with a focus on: a) strengthening their ability to shape social norms and promote behavior change and drive demand for services critical to MNCHS; and b) strengthening accountability and monitoring mechanisms through community structures for MNCHS services and related schemes to advance equity and service access. Each community group is supported by a Saheli, a village volunteer, who initiates and facilitates the discussions on MNCHS, leading to behavior change.
Parivartans Focus on Routine Immunization (RI): The vaccination of children against six serious but preventable diseases (tuberculosis, diphtheria, pertussis, tetanus, poliomyelitis, and measles) has been a cornerstone of the child health care system in India. The proportion of children fully immunized has remained at 67.5% in Bihar (AHS, 2011). According to Parivartan Baseline Report (2014), 47% of children in the targeted districts are fully immunized.
This is important to address, given Bihars low routine immunization rates, as evidenced by the fact that nearly half of the children belonging to Parivartan groups are not fully immunized. For addressing this issues Parivartan is making efforts to increase awareness among marginalized on the benefits of RI. This is being done through an integrated approach, with messages on RI, specifically those on immunization integrated with other MNCHS messages. The Parivartan compendium consists of 13 modules, one of which focuses entirely on the issues related to RI (See snapshot of the module on the right).
The module on RI specifically focused and informed the community members on:
About importance of routine immunization Inform community about the vaccination date and vaccination site (VHSND, PHC, Sub-Center and Community Health Centre) and importance of the different doses Sensitization and Awareness creation of group members on collective actions and also Support ASHA and ANM in immunization process 65.6 65.4 67.5 Total Rural Urban Children Fully Immunized (%) - AHS 2011 48 39 43 53 47 41 54 0 47 0 20 40 60 Patna E Champaran W Champaran Saharsha Samastipur Begusarai Gopalganj Khagaria Overall Immunization Baseline
Page | 3
At the grassroots, Sahelis conduct group meetings, during which modules are rolled out. In these meeting, Sahelis engage in discussions using informational materials such as flash cards, games, and stories from the modules. These discussions lead to increased levels of participation which, over time, evolves from the low end of passive listening to the high end of collective action that ultimately results in adoption of MNCHS behaviors at the individual level. Sahelis help SHG women to understand that RI is not only a personal issues, its more a community development issue. They encourage debate and foster acceptance on RI, which are described in detail in the module. Further, emphasis is also placed on diffusion, through the group members, to other eligible women within their household, and in their neighboring areas. In addition, Parivartan focuses on creating linkages with the front line workers (FLWs) such as ASHAs and Anganwadi Workers (AWWs) through their participation in group meetings. Parivartan initiated roll out of the RI module in the month of December-January 2014, and all 18,000 SHGs already covered. Till date 2265 Sahelis had been trained for rolling out the module on RI. These trained Sahelis have trained all the community groups across Parivartan Districts.
Different Doses - OPV, Vitamin A BCG, DPT and Others Importance of RI Vaccination Sites and Dates VHSND, PHC, Inform Community About RI Sensitization Awareness Collective Actions
Page | 4 For addressing the issues related with routine immunization, the Sahelis undertake a variety of strategically related social mobilization activities in their assigned areas and also participate in training sessions to improve their skills:
- The Sahelis meet with womens groups to share information on routine immunization and enlist their support in spreading the word. The Sahelis organize daytime gatherings of mothers to encourage them to immunize their children. Even the Sahelis also visit homes to educate caregivers of unimmunized children about OPV and engage them to fully immunize their children. Sahelis first target families furthest from routine immunization points and where a newborn resides and then secondarily any home behind schedule on routine immunization, and finally households fully up-to-date on vaccination.
Through this process, the Sahelis basically help the community members to take collective actions. Though, it will take some time to capture outcome and impact level indicators on RI issues from these groups, but the outcome level indicators showed a huge change in the group level due to the roll out of the RI module:
Sahelis Family Level Group Level Influencing the Community Groups Influencing Individuals Learning Objectives To inform community about benefits of routine immunization and Motivate the group members To facilitate experiential sharing within and outside groups on RI Session Overview Importance of RI - Discussion on Issues realted to RI Discussing the different types of Vaccination Stakeholders Engaged Women in the SHGs (Parivartan and Jeevika SHGs) directly Front line workers (linking to the SHGs) Materials Cards (various colors), flip chart, chart papers, board marker, bold marker, cello tape, white board stand, clips Presentation slides/flip chart
Page | 5
Success Stories: We Musahars could never have got immunization services had we not got together Saheli, Dhanauji village, Block Pakridayal, East Champaran
Way forward: Parivartan has a plan of collecting RI outcome indicators such as number of fully immunized children in Ananya districts. These indicators are captured through project MIS on monthly basis, sample surveys on quarterly basis, and the evaluation studies (Midline and End line). Further, for sustainability and scalability of processes, PCI has signed a Memorandum of Cooperation (MOC) with Bihar Rural Livelihoods Promotion Society (BRLPS), for health and sanitation integration with BRLPS project Jeevika (Bihar Rural Livelihoods Project). Parivartan is focusing on the process wherein all the Parivartan-promoted community groups will become incorporated into the Jeevika framework with the retention of the ongoing Health and Sanitation Agenda. The transition process, initiated in the month of August 2013, would aim to cover all 18,000 community groups by September 2014. Further, Parivartan has established a Health Technical Group (HTG) within Jeevika to provide technical assistance to Jeevika to advance the health, nutrition, water and sanitation agenda within Jeevikas community-based institutions across the state of Bihar.
This village lacks access to good health facilities. There is no Anganwadi center in the village. The ANM used to conduct routine immunization in the house of a higher caste Rajput family on a monthly basis and Musahars women were not encouraged to come forth to access her services. As a result, Musahars children and pregnant women were not vaccinated nor were they receiving any other services from the ANM. When Parivartan started work in the village, care was taken to appoint staff and Saheli that belonged to the Musahars community so that they could identify with them and be viewed as one of them. One day, while discussing Routine Immunization it was decided that some action must be taken to ensure regular immunization services. The Parivartan staff met with block officials and due to this, ANM was directed by the Medical Officer to change the venue for conducting immunization sessions in the village. After eight months hence, all pregnant women are receiving TT doses and IFA tablets at their doorstep and all Musahar children are being vaccinated by the ANM regularly. 39 43 53 47 41 54 0 47 47 50 57 51 58 55 63 53 E Champaran W Champaran Saharsha Samastipur Begusarai Gopalganj Khagaria Overall Changes in RI Outcome Indicator Baseline