Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Paddy Ashdown Slams 'Kneejerk' Tory Response To Jihadi Terror Threat
Paddy Ashdown Slams 'Kneejerk' Tory Response To Jihadi Terror Threat
terror threat.
Intervention comes as Cameron prepares anti-terror message, with prime minister
criticised over 'damaging' rhetoric
The Observer, Saturday 30 August 0!"
#addy Ashdown has accused Tory ministers o$ sto%ing $ear in the minds o$ the &ritish peop'e(
Tensions between Conservatives and )ibera' *emocrats over how to counter the terrorism threat
$rom e+tremists have been e+posed as #addy Ashdown accuses Tory ministers o$ ,%nee-er%,
responses and o$ sto%ing $ear in the minds o$ the &ritish peop'e(
The $ormer )ibera' *emocrat 'eader and $ormer high representative $or &osnia and .er/egovina,
writing in the Observer, a'so criticises *avid Cameron $or i''--udged rhetoric that he says cou'd
a'ienate ordinary 0us'ims and hamper the batt'e to de$eat -ihadis(
Ashdown's intervention comes as Cameron and the deputy prime minister, 1ic% C'egg, try this
wee%end to hammer out a pac%age o$ anti-terrorism measures in time to announce them to the
.ouse o$ Commons when 0#s return $rom their summer brea% on 0onday(
On 2riday the 'eve' o$ threat o$ a terrorist attac% in the 34 was raised to ,severe, by the 5oint
Terrorism Ana'ysis Centre 65TAC7 due to $ears about &ritish -ihadis returning $rom Ira8 and Syria(
This prompted Cameron to warn that the danger posed by Is'amic State 6Isis7 e+tremists presented
the biggest security threat o$ modern times, surpassing that o$ a'-9aida(
:hi'e not attempting to deny or p'ay down the threat $rom -ihadis returning to the 34, Ashdown
says that the threat 'eve' in 1orthern Ire'and has a'so been ,severe, $or the past $our years, as it was
in a'' o$ &ritain $or much o$ the !;<0s and !;;0s when the I=A posed the greatest danger(
.e argues that the current threat is ,one we have $aced be$ore and one we %now how to dea' with >
e$$ective'y, without panic and without a who'e new range o$ e+ecutive powers which cou'd
endanger our 'iberties(
,Indeed, when it comes to $acing threats, it was sure'y $ar more di$$icu't to cope with I=A terrorists
s'ipping across the Irish Sea than it is to stop -ihadis returning $rom Ira8(,
In terms that are bound to anger many Tories, he says that a$ter the threat 'eve' was increased,
senior Conservatives ,$rom the prime minister downwards ? too% to every avai'ab'e airwave to te''
us how $rightened we shou'd be and why this re8uired a range o$ new powers $or them to e+ercise,(
:hi'e he argues that Cameron appeared, initia''y, to be aware o$ the need to avoid over-hasty
responses, Tory ministers had recent'y ,indu'ged in a spasm o$ %nee-er%ing which wou'd have made
even St @itus $ee' concerned( And )abour, $rightened as a'ways when it comes to 'iberty and
security, capitu'ates to the demand(,
On his )&C radio phone-in show 'ast wee%, C'egg, whose party prides itse'$ on standing up $or civi'
'iberties, denied that the current regime o$ so-ca''ed Tpims >Terrorist #revention and Investigation
0easures > which are the successors to contro' orders, were a so$t option and de$ended their use(
.owever, the deputy prime minister appeared to concede that $urther measures to strengthen Tpims
cou'd be necessary(
,I care as much as anyone e'se about the sa$ety o$ the &ritish pub'ic, that sometimes you need to
ta%e these unorthodo+ measures, which is what both contro' orders and terrorism prevention
investigation measures are,, he said, adding ,then there's the debate about e+act'y how you design
them,(
Ashdown ta%es aims at Cameron's c'aims that the batt'e with Isis is about de$ending &ritish or
,western va'ues,(
,.ere it is not 0r Cameron's proposa's that I $ear, it is his rhetoric( .e recent'y to'd us that this $ight
was about de$ending 'western va'ues'( I cannot thin% o$ any phrase, short o$ those used by Aeorge
&ush during the Ira8 war, which more damages our abi'ity to win this batt'e( 2or it at once con$irms
the -ihadis' 0anichean view that this is indeed a strugg'e between the west and them, whi'e at the
same time a'ienating those very Is'amic moderates, whose he'p we need most in de$eating Isis and
its cohorts(
,The truth is that this increasing'y bruta' and dangerous batt'e wi'' not be won $or our 'western
va'ues' but $or the universa' va'ues which underpin and unite a'' the wor'd's great re'igions and
phi'osophies > inc'uding, perhaps especia''y at this moment > Is'am(
,The point here, which the government is studious'y missing is that the best de$ence $or &ritain 'ies,
not in action on the domestic $ront, but on the internationa' one(
,The biggest danger we $ace, is not returning -ihadis, but a widening re'igious war which threatens,
not -ust to engu'$ the 0idd'e Bast and change its borders, but to spread across the entire g'oba'
Is'amic community with potentia' conse8uences $or peace on a much wider sca'e(,
At an B3 summit in &russe's on Saturday night Cameron was e+pected to 'aunch a $resh push $or
measures which wou'd ma%e it easier to trac% the movement o$ potentia' -ihadis( This inc'uded an
attempt to restart sta''ed p'ans which wou'd a''ow po'ice and security services across the B3 to
share air'ine passenger detai's( The p'ans have been b'oc%ed in the Buropean par'iament amid
concerns over civi' 'iberties(
The change in threat 'eve's to ,severe, means a terrorist attac% is considered ,high'y 'i%e'y,,
a'though the home secretary, Theresa 0ay, stressed there was no speci$ic inte''igence( ,The increase
in the threat 'eve' is re'ated to deve'opments in Syria and Ira8 where terrorist groups are p'anning
attac%s against the west,, 0ay said(
,Some o$ those p'ots are 'i%e'y to invo've $oreign $ighters who have trave''ed there $rom the 34
and Burope to ta%e part in those con$'icts(,