The Intersection Of Church And State - In One Chart And 44 Bubbles

By Tyler Durden
Created 08/31/2014 - 18:03
Curious what the political positions are of the various, and all too numerous some would
say, religions and churches in America? This new graph, courtesy of Tobin Grant [2],
maps the ideologies of 44 different religious groups using data comes from Pews
Religious Landscape survey. This survey included 32,000 respondents. It asked very
specific questions on religion that allow us to find out the precise denomination, church,
or religion of each person.
Here are the key observations:
Churches that are similar religiously are also similar ideologically.
Evangelicals are classic conservatives (small role in economy, protect morality).
Pentecostals want a larger role for government on economic issues.
Presbyterian Church in America, Lutheran Church Missouri Synod, and smaller
Methodist churches have historical ties to both evangelicalism and mainline
denominations. On the question of government and morality, they are between
other evangelical churches and mainline denominations.
Mainline churches hold similar economic views as evangelicals but want less
government involvement protecting traditional morality.
Christians in traditionally black denominations and evangelicals are similar in
their views toward morality policy, but there is a large divide on economics.
Catholics are large and represent the center on both dimensions.
Jews are centrist on the economy. There is a major divide between both
Conservative and Orthodox Jews and other streams of Judaism. This divide
falls along the morality dimension.
The nones are united on their ideology toward morality (keep government out!)
but there are interesting divides on government services. Atheists want more
government services; agnostics favor less governmental involvement in
the economy. If you consider Unitarians part of this group, then theyre
the most supportive of government services.
[3]
Some guidelines on how to read the graph:
Each circle represents a denomination, church, or religion. There are several
circles for types of Americans with no religion: self-identified atheist, self-
identified agnostic, and those who say that have no religion in particular.
The size of the circle represents the relative size of the religion in the United
States. For very small groups, I put them in groups with other similar churches.
In these cases, the circle represents collections of similar churches, e.g.,
nondenominational evangelicals, all Baptists who arent in one of the larger
denominations, or all Hindus. The decision for how specific to make the circle
was based on the size of the group in the survey.
The color of the circle indicates the religious tradition of the group: evangelical
Protestant (historically white), Mainline Protestant (historically white),
historically black Protestant, Catholic, a catch-all category for other Christian
groups, all other religions, and those with no religion. (yes, there are some
disagreements about whether some groups should be coded as evangelical
(e.g., Seventh Day Adventist) or even Christian or not (e.g., Jehovahs
Witness). We can debate these decisions in a future post.
The location of the circle represents where a groups members stand on the two
major ideological divides in American politics. The numbers represent the
percentile location of each group (details below). The political ideologies of
religious groups are placed along two dimensions.
o Government involvement in the economy (x-axis). This is the major
ideological divide in the country. At one end are the small government
folks who want a less regulation, fewer services, and more market-
oriented policies. At the other are those who want a stronger safety net,
tougher consumer protections, and greater checks on the economy. In
the Pew survey, this is measured by a question asking whether they
wanted: a smaller government providing fewer services or a bigger
government providing more services?
o Government involvement in morality (y-axis). How much should
government be involved in regulating morality? Some people believe
that the government should protect morality and should uphold
traditional values and religion. Others think government should stay out
of bedrooms and keep up a high wall between church and state. This
can be measured using a question that asked people to pick which
statement comes closest to their beliefs: The government should do
more to protect morality in society or I worry the government is too
involved in this issue?
Some additional notes on the author's website [4].