Impact Investing in Public Markets: Methodology, Analysis and Thought Leadership
2013 ANNUAL IMPACT REPORT Impact Investing in Public Markets: Methodology, Analysis and Thought Leadership San Francisco New York www.sonencapital.com San Francisco New York www.sonencapital.com Lessons from the Field Lessons from the Field May 2014 May 2014 PUBLICATION DETAILS
PUBLISHER Sonen Capital 50 Osgood Place, Suite 320 San Francisco, CA 94133 info@sonencapital.com www.sonencapital.com
PLEASE SEE IMPORTANT DISCLAIMERS IN APPENDIX AT THE END OF THIS DOCUMENT.
This report was published in May 2014.
AUTHORS Will Morgan Ral Pomares Martn Whitaker Ph.D THE RESULTS PUBLISHED IN THIS REPORT ARE THE CULMINATION OF THE DISCIPLINED INVESTMENT APPROACH OF OUR PUBLIC MARKETS INVESTMENT TEAM: Nick Koukopoulos Eyal Bilgrai, CFA, CAIA Joshua Newman
PROJECT MANAGER Amando Balbuena
DATA SOURCE MSCI ESG Research Leadership Perspectives Executive Summary Introduction to Impact Investing at Sonen Capital Sustainable Investing: Creating Impact Through ESG Integration Thematic Investing: Investing to Meet Social & Environmental Needs Shareholder Engagement & Advocacy Looking Ahead Appendices 3 7 14 18 34 48 52 54 2013 ANNUAL IMPACT REPORT Impact Investing in Public Markets: Methodology, Analysis and Thought Leadership 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 4 MESSAGE FROM RAL POMARES SONEN CAPITAL SR. MANAGING DIRECTOR We are pleased to share with you Sonens frst annual impact report. This report provides quanttatve and qualitatve impact performance data on Sonens public markets investment strategies. We believe that the results and methodology presented in this report provide clarifcaton and transparency for investors building and managing impact portolios, and galvanizes those considering transitoning assets towards impact. Our aim in publishing this report is to demonstrate that impact investng can provide compettve returns with meaningful and measurable economic, social and environmental benefts. At Sonen, we believe that the prudent, proactve integraton of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) issues into the investment process is an integral part of managing sustainability risks and opportunites. Aggregated analysis of underlying securites presented in this report also reveals industry leadership in sustainability, evaluated through ESG dimensions. Sonens mission is to deliver compettve investment solutons with meaningful impact. For the period covered in this report, the frm was able to do just that. In 2013, Sonens investment strategies were compettve with target benchmarks while identfying investments that directly address global social and environmental challenges including climate change, resource scarcity, clean energy sources and poverty reducton among disadvantaged communites around the world. Sonens integrated focus on impact and fnancial performance afords our clients the opportunity to align their investment actvity with personal values. It is this unique combinaton that motvates our team, clients and investors onwards and upwards, providing our inspiraton to build capital markets in which investment resources help address large-scale global challenges. RAUL POMARES Sonen Capital Sr. Managing Director May 2014 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 5 PREFACE FROM WILL MORGAN, SONEN CAPITAL DIRECTOR OF IMPACT This report is the frst in a series of regular impact reports provided to Sonen clients and impact investors. Its purpose is to illustrate, clearly and specifcally, the impact that Sonens investment strategies create across asset classes and investment themes. Through this and other reports, we will show that impact investors can direct resources to create measurable, lastng and large-scale positve impact through a wide variety of investment approaches.
In Sonens view, a partcular social or environmental impact is not limited to or defned by asset class. Rather, these impacts exist both within and across asset classes, and combining varying investment approaches and manager strategies across asset classes results in impact diversifcaton for investors. The optmizaton of such Impact Implementaton at the portolio level is integral to our approach, and is achieved by selectng those managers capable of delivering genuine breadth and depth of impact within asset classes. Finally, shareholder engagement and advocacy further strengthen portolio atributes by exertng asset owners infuence on the companies they own. Across our public markets investng strategies, shareholders actng in concert are advocatng for greater social and environmental sustainability, increased transparency into corporate practces and greater responsibility for the earths precious resources and the communites in which we live and these corporatons operate. Highlights from Sonens investment strategies reveal companies that are actvely reducing greenhouse gas emissions, environmental polluton and resource use directly and through the products or services they provide. Sonens portolio refects greater responsibility and accountability at all levels of corporate structure, from workers throughout complex supply chains to more diverse corporate governance. Sonens Thematc solutons exhibit an orientaton to addressing climate change and resource scarcity, alongside investments that provide social and economic opportunites for disadvantaged populatons in the US and abroad. We antcipate signifcant growth in the impact investng industry in the coming years and, with it, an increasing alignment between the planets urgent social and environmental challenges and the opportunites that asset owners have to solve these problems. WILL MORGAN Sonen Capital Director of Impact May 2014 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 6 Business Ethics 90% Exceed average performance ratings for Business Ethics among respective market indices 4X Fewer Carbon Emissions 1000 metric tons less carbon emitted per million dollars of sales compared to traditional equities benchmarks CO 2 35 Shareholder Actions Direct engagement and shareholder advocacy across 6 impact themes, including political spending, climate change and greater transparency Toxic Emissions Significantly less sulfuric oxides (SOx), nitrogen oxides (NOx) and volatile organic compounds (VOC) compared to traditional equities benchmarks 26X Less Water Used 82,000 cubic meters less water used on average per million dollars of sales compared to traditional equities benchmarks 15X Fewer X Health & Safety 8 Women Representation on Corporate Boards 20+% Companies have an average of 20% more Women on Corporate Boards than market indices 71% Exceed benchmark average for Health & Safety performance ratings for the workforce Public Markets Impact Investing at Sonen Capital C l i m a t e
C h a n g e C o m m u n i t y
D e v e l o p m e n t E n e r g y
E f f i c i e n c y P o v e r t y
A l l e v i a t i o n R e n e w a b l e
E n e r g y R e s o u r c e
E f f i c i e n c y W a s t e W a t e r Impact Themes ESG Investment Highlights Source: MSCI ESG Research. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 7 Within our proprietary impact framework, we pursue our Impact Implementaton through a combinaton of three distnct approaches: I. Responsible: Investments that avoid investng in specifc securites with excessive ESG risks or objectonable practces. These are represented to a lesser extent within Sonens investment approaches. II. Sustainable: Strategies that invest in securites that exhibit high performance along multple ESG dimensions. III. Thematc: Investments that focus on specifc issues of global social and environmental signifcance, such as adaptng to climate change, resource efciency, water, sustainable food producton or poverty alleviaton. Sonens Impact Implementaton blends investment approaches that themselves provide diversifed and Sonens investment platorm delivers impact across asset classes, provided through mult-strategy, mult- themed investment strategies. The public markets strategies described in this report provide clients with the ability to direct investment dollars to companies that are exhibitng industry and market leadership along environmental, social and governance (ESG) dimensions; that have direct exposure to impact-oriented themes; and that are driving positve environmental and social beneft through their actons, products and services. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY IMPACT INVESTING IN PUBLIC MARKETS 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 8 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY complementary impacts within and across asset classes. Impact Implementaton also includes impact actvites beyond security selecton, such as proxy votng and shareholder advocacy actvites that can amplify the Sustainable and Thematc outcomes from various investment strategies. The net efect of our overall framework is the ability to deliver multple, diferent and mutually reinforcing impact themes and sustainability approaches, all of which can be qualifed, monitored and reported at the strategy level. Sonens Impact Dashboard Across public and private markets strategies, we currently evaluate and report impact using a dashboard approach that illustrates product-level social and environmental impact relatve to that of a selected fnancial benchmark. Specifc examples that typify both Sustainable and Thematc approaches are also provided in order to illustrate specifc ways in which underlying securites exhibit ESG leadership or are addressing Thematc social and environmental issues. Sonens Key Performance Indicators At the highest level, we track impact in public markets strategies through the following metrics: 1. A breakdown by Responsible, Sustainable and Thematc investment approaches; 2. A further breakdown by Thematc social and environmental issues represented; 3. Perhaps most importantly, we utlize a set of ESG-based Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that illustrate the actual performance of each strategy, relatve to its benchmark, along certain critcal environmental and social issue vectors; Environment: Carbon Emissions, Toxic Emissions, Water Use Social: Supply Chain Labor Standards, Controversial Sourcing, Health and Safety Governance: Gender Diversity on Corporate Boards, Business Ethics Rankings 4. A summary of proxy votng actvity and other shareolder actons by underlying issue. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 9 Delivering Results The charts below illustrate the impact breakdown of Sonen public markets strategies, as of December 31, 2013. The equites and fxed income strategies all feature a core allocaton to Sustainable investment approaches, with an allocaton to Thematc approaches; Chart 1: Impact Breakdown by Asset Class Thematic 42.7% 57.3% Sustainable Thematic 22.6% 77.4% Sustainable Thematic 26.7% 40.9% Sustainable Responsible 32.4% Thematic 20.1% 79.9% Sustainable
Global Equity US Public Equity Global Fixed Income US Core Fixed Income Sonen Strategies Key Blue bars on the charts refect Sonen investment strategies in US Equites. Green bars on the charts refect Sonen investment strategies in Global Equites. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 10 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY For the equites strategies, energy- and water-related impacts are the most represented Thematc issues, followed by infrastructure, waste and polluton and agriculture; Chart 2: Equities Thematic Investments For the fxed income strategies, social impacts are the most represented impact theme (grouped under the community development heading) followed by clean energy; Chart 3: Fixed Income Thematic Investments 6.9% Infrastructure Other 16.3% Water 39.3% 3.4% Health 22.3% Energy 5.1% Agriculture 1.0% Community Development 5.7% Waste & Pollution 8.7% Other 1.8% Water 8.3% Infrastructure 35.1% Energy 1.4% Agriculture Community Development 42.3% 2.3% Waste & Pollution 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 11
51 companies held in Sonens various strategies were subject to 65 shareholder actons in 2013. Sonen managers directly partcipated in 35 of those actons, with prominent issue areas including politcal spending and environmental sustainability; In terms of the specifc Environmental, Social and Governance KPIs we use to track impact performance: Relatve to the benchmark, Sonens strategies exhibit signifcantly lower carbon intensity, toxic emissions and water usage; Chart 5: Carbon Emissions: Metric Tons of Carbon Emissions per $mm/sales 1 0 5 10 15 20 Other Human Rights Climate & Energy Board Diversity/EEO* Environment Sustainable Governance Political Spending 18 16 11 7 6 4 3 1. Source Data: MSCI ESG Research. Global Equity and MSCI ACWI data incomplete for 2012. Chart 4: 2013 Breakdown of Shareholder Actions *EEO: Equal Opportunity Employment 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 128.81 368.54 Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index 2011 Global Equity Carbon Intensity 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 524.88 177.35 US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index 2012 US Public Equity Carbon Intensity
2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 12
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Our equites strategies are over 4.5x less carbon intensive and 2.7x less carbon intensive than their respectve benchmarks. Similarly, water use is more than 48x and 13x lower than corresponding market benchmarks. We atribute these diferences to the underlying strategies of our managers and their ability to select stocks that create more positve impact relatve to respectve benchmarks; Chart 6: Water Use: Cubic Meters of Water Use per $mm/sales 2 Sonens strategies exceed benchmark performance on sourcing of controversial materials and the health and safety performance for the workforce. We believe this is explained by data availability, and the biases contained in our benchmarking process; Chart 7: Percentage of Companies that Outperform Market Benchmarks (MSCI ACWI and Russell 3000 ) 3 US Public Equity Global Equity 2012 Supply Chain Labor Management 40% 42% 44% 46% 48% 50% 47.8% 50.0% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 56.0% 25.0% Controversial Sourcing US Public Equity Global Equity 2012 80% 84% 88% 92% 96% 100% 92.0% 86.3% Health & Safety US Public Equity Global Equity 2012 0 5000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 2,144.11 27,377.61 Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index 2012 Global Equity Water Use Intensity 0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 1,204.23 58,397.97 US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index 2012 US Public Equity Water Use Intensity 2,3. Source Data: MSCI ESG Research.
2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 13
The net effect of our overall framework is the ability to deliver multiple, different and mutually reinforcing impact themes and sustainability approaches, all of which can be qualied, monitored and reported at the strategy level.
Sonens portolios also exhibit higher representaton of women on corporate boards relatve to the benchmark. Chart 8: Percentage of Companies that Outperform Market Benchmarks (MSCI ACWI and Russell 3000 ) 4 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 80.7% 57.0% Women Representation on Corporate Boards US Public Equity Global Equity 2012 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 94.4% 85.4% Business Ethics & Fraud US Public Equity Global Equity 2012 4. Source Data: MSCI ESG Research. CO 2
2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 14
Sonen is commited to understanding and reportng impact as an essental part of the portolio management process; this report provides qualitatve and quanttatve impact data on Sonens underlying investments in the public markets, encompassing all investments across fxed income and public equity securites. At present, we invest in multple managers within our public equity and fxed income strategies. Managers are selected for their ability to artculate a defned impact strategy and demonstrate that underlying securites are consistent with that strategy and that indeed provide the intended impact. Managers are also selected according to their ft with and contributon to Sonens growing collecton of impact investment managers. See Sonens Manager Selecton Process on p. 17 for more informaton on manager selecton. Sonen Capital LLC is commited to providing our clients with impact investment solutons across asset classes and impact themes, with the mission of delivering compettve fnancial returns alongside meaningful positve social and environmental beneft. For asset owners who believe, like we do, that investment capital can help meet large-scale global challenges while generatng strong fnancial returns, our solutons provide a direct link between investment strategy and positve global social and environmental change. INTRODUCTION TO IMPACT INVESTING AT SONEN CAPITAL IMPACT INVESTING IN PUBLIC MARKETS 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 15 Impact Investing Spectrum Chart 9 on the following page illustrates the Sonen Impact Investng Spectrum, including the Sustainable and Thematc investment approaches described above. In general, moving from lef to right relays an increasing focus on impact derived from underlying securites. Sonen Capital strives to ensure that clients beneft from the broadest possible coverage of Responsible, Sustainable, Thematc and Impact First (where desired) investment opportunites across asset classes, impact themes and investment strategies. Our focus is on Sustainable and Thematc investng, where we believe the greatest opportunites to optmize impact and fnancial return exists.
Responsible Investng, in which companies are eliminated from investment due to their involvement in specifc actvites (such as weapons manufacturing, tobacco producton or nuclear energy) is represented to a a lesser extent in Sonens strategies. Nevertheless, Responsible investng consttutes a major element of modern impact investng and indeed is the foundaton on which many new manifestatons of impact investng originate. We separate this from Sustainable and Thematc approaches on the grounds that such negatve screening is technically an avoidance of negatve impact, as opposed to the pursuit of positve impact. However, for some clients, Responsible investment strategies can play a legitmate role in an overall impact strategy. Sustainable Investng focuses on the integraton of ESG factors as a fundamental part of the investment decision-making process. Such ESG data is most ofen used to evaluate related risks and opportunites to specifc companies and industries, although the data itself provides a strong basis from which to evaluate investors impact and the markets infuence on corporate ESG practces. Thematc Investng targets issue areas where social or environmental markets ofer specifc commercial growth opportunites, such as growing worldwide demand for water, or providing goods and services to low- income communites.
SONEN IS COMMITTED TO UNDERSTANDING AND REPORTING IMPACT AS AN ESSENTIAL PART OF THE PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT PROCESS. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 16 INTRODUCTION TO IMPACT INVESTING AT SONEN CAPITAL Creating Impact Through Public Markets Investing In our view, a partcular social or environmental impact is neither limited to nor defned by asset class. Rather, diversifed impact results from combining varying investment approaches and manager strategies across asset classes. We deliver specifc, measurable impact to clients across asset classes in three distnct ways: 1. First, by at a minimum making Responsible investments, which avoid specifc industries or business lines with excessive ESG risks, or objectonable business actvites. Responsible investments represent a small proporton of Sonens investment approaches. 2. Second, by focusing on Sustainable investment approaches, in order to invest in securites across asset classes that exemplify high performance along Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) standards and criteria; and 3. Third, by focusing on Thematc investment approaches, in which asset owners direct their resources to specifc social and environmental impact themes and related needs refectng issues of global urgency. The result is Sonens Impact Implementaton - combining investment approaches that themselves provide diversifed and complementary impact within and across asset classes. Impact implementaton also includes impact actvites beyond security selecton, such as proxy votng and shareholder advocacy actvites that can amplify the Sustainable and Thematc outcomes from various investment strategies. Chart 9: Impact Investing Spectrum 5 5. The Impact Investng Spectrum has been adapted from the Spectrum of Capital, produced by Clara Barby of Bridges Ventures. Classic Investing Responsible Sustainable Thematic Impact First Philanthropy Competitive Returns ESG* Risk Management ESG Opportunities Maximum-Impact Solutions Emphasis on profit maximization without regard for ESG factors Consideration of ESG risk and/or personal values across a range of factors to screen out investments Targeting investments best positioned to benefit from the integration of ESG factors and broad-based macro trends Focus on issue areas where social or environmental needs offer commercial growth opportunities for market rate return Emphasis on the optimization of social or environmental needs (e.g., PRI*), which may result in financial trade off Where social and/or environmental needs outweigh any consideration for financial return *PRI: Program-related investments available to US investors defned by the tax Reform Act of 1969. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 17
Sonens Manager Selection Process To create its mult-manager, mult-themed investment portolios, Sonens team assesses managers and evaluates the ESG/impact merits of their respectve strategies alongside quanttatve, fundamental evalu- aton. Sonen employs a rigorous four-stage due diligence process that fully integrates the analysis of social and environmental impact factors, the skill and experience of the management team in a specifc invest- ment strategy and the funds potental for fnancial return, all overlaid with a disciplined risk management process. Managers and strategies are evaluated along several quanttatve and qualitatve levels. We deploy a full due diligence process to assess manager expertse, commitment and capacity to deliver on both fnancial and social/environmental impact. Detailed due diligence therefore combines a fundamental quanttatve analysis of manager fnancial performance, risk and strategy, with a thorough impact-based due diligence process based upon Sonens Impact Scorecard, a proprietary evaluaton mechanism. Through Sonens integrated im- pact and fnancial due diligence process, we seek to understand the strategy; the strength of the business; the ethics and integrity of the people; the culture of the organizaton; the ownership structure, incentves, staf retenton and turnover; Assets Under Management (AUM) stability in the strategy/fund and at the frm level; and operatonal details including ofering documents and audited fnancials. Sonen intentonally combines managers with varying and complementary investment approaches in order to create a diversifed impact strategy for each asset class. In this manner, a single asset class can deliver multple diferent impact themes and sustainability approaches, all of which can be qualifed, monitored and reported. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 18 As ESG data has become more widely available and reliable, asset managers and investors have begun to utlize it in increasingly creatve ways: As a performance indicator, serving as a proxy for how well a company is managed; As a screening tool, to select securites with specifc positve ESG atributes, or to help investors avoid certain industries altogether due to specifc ESG risks (e.g., excessive liabilites and risks from labor abuses); As a tool to compare relatve ESG performance with industry peers in order to select companies that demonstrate best practces on specifc issues; and To augment methodologies for comparing statc and longitudinal data of a companys ESG performance over tme in comparison to industry peers or to conventonal market-based benchmarks. Sonen uses ESG data to help discern the positve social or environmental impacts of an investment portolio by comparing the same performance of Sustainable investment strategies vary considerably in approach and executon. Ultmately, however, they share a common objectve: to widen the scope of securites evaluaton to consider how ESG issues may afect risk, compettve positoning, shareholder value and market performance over the long term. IMPACT INVESTING IN PUBLIC MARKETS SUSTAINABLE INVESTING: CREATING IMPACT THROUGH ESG INTEGRATION 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 19
market benchmarks. We also monitor the trends in such ESG data in order to understand how companies are evolving in response to the market and investor demand. While data does suggest that ESG and fnancial performance are linked, we know this is a complicated relatonship and do not assume there is a direct correlaton between alpha generaton and specifc ESG leadership. However, for impact investors, ESG performance serves as an excellent proxy for impact, by helping asset owners understand not what companies do, but how they do it. Table 1: Sample E, S and G Characteristics or KPIs Environmental Social Governance Sample KPIs Energy efciency Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions Toxic emissions Waste (generated for producton and for product) Community engagement Human rights Labor standards Disclosure and transparency Board diversity Politcal contributons ESG Risks Cost escalatons Supply chain disruptons Evolving regulatory requirements Reputatonal damage Loss of license to operate Brand loyalty Reputatonal damage Fines and litgaton ESG Opportunites Adaptaton through innovaton New market growth Consumer and investor appeal Consumer and investor appeal Standard setng Reduced labor costs Leadership Stakeholder partcipaton and support Improved fnancial performance ESG Impact GHG emissions reductons Waste reductons Water use reductons Higher worker satsfacton and retenton Improved labor standards Stakeholder alignment Opportunity to set standards and lead industries Lower cost of capital Improved share price Stakeholder alignment 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 20 Sustainable Managers in Public Equities A critcal component of Sonens Impact Implementaton is manager selecton, which is intentonally varied in order to render a diverse array of Sustainable investment approaches. This results in meaningful impact diversifcaton alongside fnancial diversifcaton. SUSTAINABLE INVESTING: CREATING IMPACT THROUGH ESG INTEGRATION Table 2: Sustainable Public Equities Managers Impact Strategies Sustainable Manager Sustainable Impact Thesis Manager Impact Strategy Manager A ESG performance can increase compettveness, reduce risk profles and enhance fnancial performance. Identfy industry-specifc ESG factors that may afect company valuaton and performance Invest in best-in-class companies along ESG performance criteria Actve corporate engagement and proxy votng Manager B Incorporatng ESG performance can reduce investment risk, partcularly for certain industries. Positve ESG screens such as carbon footprint, workforce diversity, employee benefts and governance structures Proxy votng Manager C Companies with higher ESG performance provide higher overall quality and carry less risk. Specifc and defned positve and negatve ESG screens inform investment selecton Actve corporate engagement and shareholder advocacy Manager D Sustainability performance afects long-term business proftability, and companies best positoned to beneft from long-term sustainability trends will be more successful. Industry-specifc sustainability drivers are used to evaluate companies for investment Proxy votng 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 21
Sustainable Managers in Fixed Income Table 3: Sustainable Fixed Income Managers Impact Strategies Sustainable Manager Sustainable Impact Thesis Manager Impact Strategy Manager A Extra-fnancial factors can impact fnancial risk and return of investments. Higher corporate ESG standards are positvely correlated to higher credit ratngs and lower volatlity. Focus on municipal issuers that provide essental services such as infrastructure, educaton and sanitaton Identfy corporate bonds with high ESG performance Manager B Corporate ESG liabilites may afect company valuaton and ability to return capital to investors. Sovereign ESG performance can afect governments willingness and ability to repay debts. Examine corporate ESG performance for excessive related risks and liabilites Examine sovereign governments level of corrupton, environmental stewardship, politcal stability and human development indices Manager C Countries with high commitments to environmental, social and governance sustainability policies are inherently more likely to deliver a beter return to investors a sustainability dividend. Proprietary tool to evaluate country-level ESG risks and opportunites along 16 specifc dimensions not typically covered by sovereign bond ratngs agencies Table 4: Variations in Integrating ESG Data in the Investment Process ESG Risk Public Equity ESG Opportunity Public Equity ESG Risk Fixed Income ESG Opportunity Fixed Income Use of ESG Data Reveal risks in supply chains Select companies that are the best performers along specifc ESG dimensions Examine non-fnancial risks that may afect a countrys willingness and ability to repay debts Evaluate municipal and sovereign ESG performance Example Heavy reliance on fossil fuels can result in supply disruptons or price escalatons. Investng in energy efciency or renewable sources can reduce such carbon risk and carbon emissions Companies with higher rates of employee satsfacton and compliance with labor standards enjoy greater stability and fewer supply disruptons Low educaton rates, gender inequality and limited civil libertes reduce overall long-term stability and solvency Reduced resource depleton and environmental sustainability can improve long-term credit quality 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 22 SUSTAINABLE INVESTING: CREATING IMPACT THROUGH ESG INTEGRATION
Growth in Sustainable Investing Strategic impact investng in public markets can indeed create impact and at a large scale. As more investors enter the market with expectatons of social and environmental sustainability on the part of the companies they own, these investors demand greater transparency through corporate disclosure on related maters, and exercise their ownership rights to induce favorable corporate policy changes. The growth in investng that explicitly integrates ESG data illustrates that asset owners wish to express their values by investng in strategies that incorporate such consideratons. Asset owners may also believe that their investments may be at risk if environmental, social and governance issues are not considered as part of a prudent investment process. Chart 10 below shows the growth of Responsible and Sustainable investng from 1995-2012. Chart 10: Growth of Responsible and Sustainable Investing 6
Chart 11: US Social and Environmental Shareholder Proposals Filed, 2004-2014 7 Simultaneously, these actve investors are also taking advantage of their positon as owners to induce companies to conform to industry best practces, which includes sustainability disclosure but increasingly takes into account specifc issues relatng to climate change, social inclusion and transparent governance. A steadily growing proporton of shareholder proposals now include requests that companies consider social or environmental issues, and/or that companies disclose related data and informaton.
$3.7 trillion represents 11.3% of the total $33 tril- lion AUM in the US Market 486% increase from 1995 to 2012 In 2012, 60% of Request For Proposals (RFP) included ESG criteria 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 200 49 87 183 60 113 198 56 103 195 64 111 201 62 140 180 48 145 182 65 148 185 68 153 180 61 148 192 49 153 417 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Votes Omitted Withdrawn #
P r o p o s a l s $- $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 $3,000 $3,500 $4,000 $4,500 US $ Billions 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2010 2012 $639 $1,185 $2,159 $2,323 $2,164 $2,290 $2,711 $3,069 $3,744 6. US SIF, The Forum for Sustainable and Responsible Investment. 2012 Report on Sustainable and Responsible Investng Trends in the United States. Bank of America Merrill Lynch, February 11, 2011 report on SRI - becoming mainstream. 7. Proxy Preview 2014. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 23
Growth in Sustainable Investing (continued)
Last, we are witnessing signifcant growth in the number and variety of companies that are disclosing sustainability data. We suspect that this is in response to a greater appette among investors as we note above, but also due to companies recogniton that ESG performance is no longer the domain of a small cadre of investors, but is rather becoming a commonplace expectaton. Chart 12 below displays the upward trend in the number of companies partcipatng in the Global Reportng Initatve (GRI), an organizaton whose mission is to make sustainability reportng standard practce for all companies and organizatons. In culminaton of this growing popularity of Sustainable investng, alongside investor demand for disclosure and transparency, pro-forma trend data from Sonens various strategies illustrates a defnitve response from companies over the last four years: reduced carbon and toxic emissions, and a reducton in the amount of water use for normal operatons (refer to charts 14 and 15). Sonens investors thus become actve partcipants in guiding corporate behavior, and the wider capital markets, toward greater social and environmental sustainability.
Chart 12: Growth in Companies Reporting Sustainability Data GRI Reporting Trend: 1999 - 2012 8
8. 2013 Global Conference on Sustainability and Reportng; GRI. 0 500 1000 1,500 2,000 2,500 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 24 SUSTAINABLE INVESTING: CREATING IMPACT THROUGH ESG INTEGRATION Sonen ESG Key Performance Indicators Another key component of Sonens impact reportng methodology is the collecton, analysis and aggregaton of ESG data for the underlying investments in our investment strategies and related performance relatve to relevant benchmark for specifc asset classes. Our impact dashboard gives asset owners an immediate reference point for each portolios impact relatve to its benchmarks, and trend analyses help reveal how portolio companies contnue to improve their ESG and impact performance. A. ESG Analysis: Environment For Sonens public markets strategies, we have chosen to measure environmental performance in three critcal areas: 1. Climate change, specifcally the carbon emissions of underlying portolio holdings normalized by sales;
2. Environmental polluton, as measured by toxic emissions normalized by sales; and 3. Rates of water use, also normalized by sales. Sonens strategies exhibit signifcantly stronger environmental performance relatve to their respectve market benchmark across all KPIs. 9 Specifcally: With respect to carbon intensity (tons of carbon emited per $million of sales), Sonens equites strategies produce 3x fewer carbon emissions than their respectve benchmarks. Rates of water withdrawal (measured by m 3
withdrawn per $million of sales) are 48x less and 13x less for Sonens collecton of US Public Equity and Global Equity strategies relatve to respectve market benchmarks. Environmental polluton, measured by various toxic emissions, is 2x lower than the benchmark for US Public Equity, and more than 66x lower than the benchmark for Global Equity. Trend data shows that Sonens portolio companies are actvely reducing carbon and toxic emissions, as well as reducing the amount of water use over tme. In additon to assessing relatve performance, these KPIs may be used as a signal by investors who antcipate increased regulatory and reputatonal risks for companies with excessive carbon emissions, toxic emissions or rates of water withdrawal. As the threat of climate change and water scarcity grows, impact investors can invest in companies that are proactvely addressing the issue and simultaneously insulatng themselves from the increasing likelihood of regulatory risk related to emissions and water scarcity. 9. Performance data for Sonens strategies and for market benchmarks does not cover all securites due to lack of availability of data or due to companies that do not report related informaton. Sonen Strategies Key Blue bars on the charts refect Sonen investment strategies in US Equites. Green bars on the charts refect Sonen investment strategies in Global Equites. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 25
Chart 13: Carbon, Water Use and Toxic Emissions Environmental Performance (Measured in Intensity metrics tons (carbon, toxic emissions) or m 3 (water) per $mm/sales) 10 10. Source Data: MSCI ESG Research. Measuring and comparing intensity (unit/$mm in revenues) allows for a comparison between companies with signifcantly diferent scales of operatons and/or market capitalizatons. Note that amounts are absolute and not weighted by security for either Sonen strategies or respectve market benchmarks. Global Equity and MSCI ACWI data incomplete for 2012. 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 128.81 368.54 Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index 2011 Global Equity Carbon Intensity 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 524.88 177.35 US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index 2012 US Public Equity Carbon Intensity 0 5000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 2,144.11 27,377.61 Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index 2012 Global Equity Water Use Intensity 0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 1,204.23 58,397.97 US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index 2012 US Public Equity Water Use Intensity Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index 2012 0.668 Global Equity Total Toxic Emissions Intensity 0.00 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.010 0.035 0.072 US Public Equity Total Toxic Emissions Intensity 0.00 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index 2012
2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 26
SUSTAINABLE INVESTING: CREATING IMPACT THROUGH ESG INTEGRATION Chart 14: Carbon Intensity Trends from 2009 - 2012 (metric tons per $mm/sales) 11 The charts above illustrate the trends in carbon intensity averages (metric tons of CO 2 emissions per million dollars of sales). It is important to note that the compositon of Sonen strategies, as well as their respectve market benchmarks, does not remain constant for the period. It does illustrate, however, that this collecton of securites has actvely reduced average carbon emissions over this tme frame. 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 2010 2011 2012 359.69 723.45 298.78 647.78 185.27 479.13 177.35 524.88 Carbon Intensity Trends from 2009 - 2012 (metric tons per $mm/sales) 2009 US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index 11. Source Data: MSCI ESG Research. Data for Global Equity and MSCI ACWI is partally complete for 2012 and will change as more data becomes available. 0 100 200 300 400 500 2010 2011 2009 Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index Carbon Intensity Trends from 2009 - 2012 (metric tons per $mm/sales) 156 422 124 386 129 347
2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 27
Chart 15: Toxic Emissions Trends from 2009 - 2012 (metric tons per $mm/sales) 12 The charts above illustrate the trends in toxic emissions intensity averages (metric tons of nitrogen oxide (NOx), sulfur oxide (SOx), and volatle organic compound (VOC) emissions per million dollars of sales). It is important to note that the compositon of Sonen strategies, as well as their respectve market benchmarks, does not remain constant for the period. It does illustrate, however, that this collecton of securites has actvely reduced toxic emissions from 2009 to 2012. For many clients, qualitatve informaton about underlying securites provides additonal narratve and anecdotal informaton that brings to life the quanttatve performance data in Sonens impact dashboard. Table 5 further explains this environmental performance data across Sonens investment strategies. 0 6 12 18 5.76 16.92 10.14 16.15 6.40 12.10 3.48 7.17 Toxic Emissions Trends from 2009 - 2012 (metric tons per $mm/sales) 2009 US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index 2010 US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index 2011 US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index 2012 US Public Equity Russell 3000 Index 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 1.46 78.45 1.42 74.03 1.32 75.43 0.97 66.82 2009 Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index 2010 Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index 2011 Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index 2012 Global Equity MSCI ACWI Index 12. Source Data: MSCI ESG Research.
2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 28 SUSTAINABLE INVESTING: CREATING IMPACT THROUGH ESG INTEGRATION Table 5: Sample Environmental Performance Highlights from Sonen Equities and Fixed Income Strategies Security (Sector) Asset Class Environmental Performance Highlights Waste Management (Industrials) Public Equity (US) Strong policies to mitgate GHG emissions, with 15% reductons in emissions between 2010 and 2012. Various waste-to-energy initatves (methane capture), with use of renewable energy sources (wind, solar and waste heat) for its own power needs. Operates ten bioreactor landflls in the US and Canada that reduce overall toxicity, leachate (runof) and overall landfll volume. Landfll gases are also collected and used onsite or sold. Agilent Technologies (Healthcare) Public Equity (Global) Among lowest energy consumpton in industry peer set, due to energy efciency improvements at producton facilites and solar power systems in Western US and Germany, producing 51,120 MWh of electricity annually. Actvely minimizing environmental impacts of products and packaging, through product take-back programs and internal Design for Environment Guidelines. Santa Rosa, CA facility recycles 38% of all water and treats wastewater on site. Ecolab (Industrials) Fixed Income (US) Reduced carbon emissions intensity by 25% since 2006, with an additonal 5% reducton target over next fve years. Solid waste and wastewater reducton targets of 10% (each) from 2012 through 2017. 70 million gallons of water saved across the companys facilites in 2012 through internal efciency programs. Starbucks (Restaurants) Fixed Income (Global) Target to reduce total energy consumpton by 25% through 2015 (2008 baseline). Renewable energy credit purchases equivalent to 100% of electricity used in all company stores by 2015. All new stores must align with sustainable building standards. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 29
B. ESG Analysis: Social In order to report social performance and impact, we have selected three KPIs that we believe represent some of the most important and challenging social performance criteria for companies today: 1. A Supply Chain Labor Management KPI, which evaluates the extent to which companies adhere to internatonal norms on labor, including the eliminaton of child labor, provision of safe work environments and provision of compensaton in accordance with local law; 2. A Controversial Sourcing KPI, which evaluates the extent to which companies rely on materials that originate in regions associated with human rights or labor abuses. While the issue afects many industries, controversial sourcing is of partcular importance for the technology industry, where electronic components for mobile phones, tablets, computers and electronic circuits ofen require minerals such as tn, tungsten and copper; and 3. A Health and Safety KPI, which monitors the degree to which underlying securites maintain related policies and procedures in the workplace in order to ensure worker safety. This is of partcular concern overseas, where such management may be less stringent or labor standards may be more permissive. Social performance along such dimensions is of partcular concern to impact investors who, at a minimum, want to be assured that their investments are not proftng from substandard treatment of laborers, indirectly supportng corrupt governments or procurement of materials in unscrupulous ways. Chart 16 on the following page illustrates the percentage of portolio companies in Sonens Equity strategies that exceed average performance ratngs for social KPIs relatve to their benchmarks. Benchmarks for US Public Equity and Global Equity are the Russell 3000 and the MSCI ACWI, respectvely. Key observatons include: Supply Chain Labor Management: higher performing companies for this KPI secure third party monitoring of supply chains and maintain actve strategies and incentves that help suppliers comply with internatonal norms. a. Highest performers include companies such as Motorola, whose Supplier Code of Conduct is enforced through third-party audits, with detailed public reportng on fndings that surpass any other company in its industry. b. Our Global Equity strategy does not meet the average benchmark (MSCI ACWI) performance for supply chain labor management as fewer than 6% of companies in the strategy (by weight) are reportng related data. Going forward, Sonen expects to collect more data to help ensure that portolio companies are exceeding performance standards in supply chain labor management. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 30 SUSTAINABLE INVESTING: CREATING IMPACT THROUGH ESG INTEGRATION Controversial Sourcing of Materials: Higher performing companies for this KPI are able to trace the origins of raw materials, as well as obtain third-party certfcaton that such materials were procured in a manner that minimizes or eliminates any associaton with or funding to groups or governments engaged in human rights violatons. Positve scores are also atributed to companies that provide greater degrees of transparency into supplier networks. a. More than 56% of Sonens US Public Equity strategy exceed the average benchmark performance (Russell 3000) for the controversial sourcing KPI. Intel is a star performer, declaring at 2014s Consumer Electronics Show that all of its microprocessors will be free of confict minerals. b. Our Global Equity strategy does not perform to the average benchmark score (MSCI ACWI) again because of the small number of companies reportng in this category (<7% by strategy weight). As this data becomes more available, Sonen expects that this portolio will exceed the benchmarks performance on controversial sourcing due to Global Equity managers scrutny of such issues. Sonens underlying securites average performance in Health and Safety (H&S) exceeds that of respectve benchmarks for all public markets strategies, exemplifed by Praxair in US Public Equity. Chart 16: Percent of Equities that Exceed Average US Public Equity Global Equity 2012 Supply Chain Labor Management 40% 42% 44% 46% 48% 50% 47.8% 50.0% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 56.0% 25.0% Controversial Sourcing US Public Equity Global Equity 2012 80% 84% 88% 92% 96% 100% 92.0% 86.3% Health & Safety US Public Equity Global Equity 2012 13. Source Data: MSCI ESG Research. Benchmark Performance on Key Performance Indicators 13 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 31
Consumer and Regulatory Expectations for Responsible Procurement United States consumer data suggests that 88% of consumers would avoid purchasing products from com- panies they knew to be undertaking irresponsible business practces. 14
And, in the recent Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform Act, companies are now required to report from where minerals used in their products originate. This added scrutny from regulators, as well as growing expecta- tons from consumers and greater performance among afected companies, will ultmately result in a reduc- ton in the amount and frequency of unintended contributon to labor and human rights abuses abroad.
Table 6: Sample Social Performance Highlights from Sonen Equities and Fixed Income Strategies Security (Sector) Asset Class Social Performance Highlights Supply Chain, Controversial Sourcing, Health and Safety Praxair (Industrial Gases) Public Equity (US) Lowest employee accident rate in its industry Comprehensive H&S internal audits every three years Quarterly H&S reports to board, an industry best practce Qualcomm (Informaton Technology) Public Equity (Global) Since 2011, formal policy in place to ensure supply chain is free of confict minerals Member of Electronic Industry Citzenship Coaliton (EICC) to ensure worker safety and fairness, as well as environmental responsibility Consistently ranks among top workplaces in employee surveys, including working mothers Intel Corp (Semi-conductors) Fixed Income (US) Member of EICC, with recent pressure on lower-ter suppliers to adhere to similar principles Regular audits at all top 75 suppliers; public identfcaton of all suppliers Provides educatonal resources and training to suppliers and regular feedback on performance Announced in Jan 2014 at Consumer Electronics Show that all microprocessors released in 2014 will be free of confict minerals Bombardier (Aerospace, Trans- portaton) Fixed Income (Global) Reduced accident frequency and severity rates by 10% in 2012, and by 50% since 2008 Comprehensive Health, Safety and Environment Preventve Culture program including training and management engagement Target of zero occupatonal illness and injury rate Compliance program for Supplier Code of Conduct 14. Cone Communicatons, and Echo. 2013 Cone Communicatons/Echo Global CSR Study. 2013 Global CSR Study. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 32 SUSTAINABLE INVESTING: CREATING IMPACT THROUGH ESG INTEGRATION C. ESG Analysis: Governance Sonen monitors corporate governance through two straightorward KPIs: 1. The compositon and diversity of the board, specifcally the percentage of women serving on corporate boards; and 2. Relatve performance with respect to incidents of corporate malfeasance, including insider trading, controversies related to governance and fnes/ litgaton. As impact investors may wish to express personal or insttutonal values and priorites through investment strategies, companies performance with respect to the embrace of diversity, business integrity, transparency and ethics can be of great importance and can refect on asset owners themselves. Moreover, a growing body of evidence suggests that companies with greater diversity, and partcularly gender diversity, beneft from improved fnancial performance and reduced risk or insolvency in day-to-day management practces. 15 Chart 17 on the following page illustrates the percentage of portolio companies in Sonens Public Equity strategies that exceed benchmark average performance ratngs for social KPIs. Benchmarks for US Public Equity and Global Equity are the Russell 3000 and the MSCI ACWI, respectvely. Highlights include: 81% of Sonens US Public Equity strategy have more Women Representaton than the average representaton among Russell 3000 companies. The fgure is 57% for Global Equity compared to the MSCI ACWI. The percentage of women serving on corporate boards within Sonens US Public Equity and Global Equity strategies are 15.1% and 16.0%, respectvely. These fgures compare favorably to 11.8% and 13.8% for Russell 3000 and MSCI ACWI companies. 15 companies report at least a third of total board representaton is comprised of women. 85% and 94% (US and Global Equity strategies, respectvely) exceed average benchmark performance for Business Ethics and Fraud.
Gender Diversity on Corporate Boards In two studies of Fortune 500 companies between 2001 and 2008, returns on sales and invested capital were all signifcantly higher for those companies with larger representaton of women on the Board of Directors. And for those companies with more than three women on the board, those fndings were amplifed and also included higher rates of return on equity. 16
15. Gender Diversity and Corporate Performance. Credit Suisse Research Insttute (2012). 16. Joy, Carter, Wagner and Narayanan. The Botom Line: Corporate Performance and Womens Representaton on Boards. Catalyst Insttute (2007 and 2011). 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 33
Gender Diversity on Corporate Boards (continued) Similarly, in a study of share prices for more than 2,360 global companies over the period 2005-2011, Credit Suisse Research Insttute found that companies with one or more women board members outperformed those companies with no women board members considerably. For large-cap companies (> $10 billion) share prices outperformed by 26%, while for small- and mid-cap companies, share prices outperformed by 17%. 17 The study further concludes that companies with women on the board exhibited higher returns on equity, lower debt to equity ratos and beter average growth over the same period. 18
Chart 17: Percent of Equities that Exceed Average Benchmark Performance on Key Performance Indicators 19 17. Gender Diversity and Corporate Performance. Credit Suisse Research Insttute (2012). 18. IBID p.14. 19. Source Data: MSCI ESG Research. 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 80.7% 57.0% Women Representation on Corporate Boards US Public Equity Global Equity 2012 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 94.4% 85.4% Business Ethics & Fraud US Public Equity Global Equity 2012 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 34 Thematc managers select securites that deliver products or services within defned sectors that are directly related to the partcular theme in queston. Some Thematc managers also integrate ESG data in the investment process for even beter impact performance. Table 7 illustrates the seven priority sustainability topics identfed for immediate proactve management in the 2012 United Natons Conference on Sustainable Development. Sonens Public Equity and Fixed Income investment strategies actvely address all of these issues, with the excepton of Oceans. Perhaps more than ever, these challenges present opportunites for Thematc investors to direct capital towards solutons that align closely with global sustainable development priorites and create new sources of alpha for their portolios. Whereas Sustainable impact investors pursue impact by directng capital to companies that are actvely managing ESG risks and opportunites throughout their organizatons, Thematc investors focus on areas where social and/or environmental needs create specifc commercial growth opportunites within broad environmental and/or social themes, such as energy, waste management or community development. IMPACT INVESTING IN PUBLIC MARKETS THEMATIC INVESTING: INVESTING TO MEET SOCIAL & ENVIRONMENTAL NEEDS 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 35
Table 7: UN Sustainable Development Priorities 20 UN Sustainability Theme Sustainability Context Employment More than 2.3 million green jobs have been created in renewable energy sector in recent years Agriculture is the largest employer in the world Clean Energy Energy is the largest contributor to climate change, accountng for 60% of global GHG emissions Reducing carbon intensity of energy is a key objectve in long-term climate goals Sustainable Cites Cites use 2% of total land area but account for up to 80% of energy consumpton and 75% of carbon emissions Rapid urbanizaton is stressing water supplies, sewage infrastructure and public health Food Security and Sustainable Agri- culture Projected increases in fertlizer use for food producton through 2050 could result in up to 20% more river nitrogen in coastal ecosystems 500 million small farms worldwide provide up to 80% of food consumed in least developed countries Agriculture contributes about 50% of total organic water pollutants globally Water Every day, 2 million tons of human waste are disposed of in water courses 70% of all available freshwater is used for irrigaton Humanity will feel the impact of climate change most strongly through water Disaster Readiness 102 million people are afected by foods annually Drought and famine have killed nearly 600,000 people and afected 1.6 billion people, since 1980 Oceans Over 3 billion people depend on the oceans and coastal biodiversity for their livelihoods Up to 40% of the worlds oceans are negatvely afected by human actvites 20. United Natons. The Future We Want United Natons (2012) 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 36 Thematic Managers in Public Equity The charts below illustrate the relevant proporton of Thematc investng in Sonens various Public Equity strategies. Chart 18: Impact Breakdown Chart 19: Thematic Breakdown THEMATIC INVESTING: INVESTING TO MEET SOCIAL & ENVIRONMENTAL NEEDS Global Equity US Public Equity Global Equity US Public Equity Thematic 42.7% 57.3% Sustainable Thematic 22.6% 77.4% Sustainable 3.5% Waste & Pollution 6.6% Infrastructure 12.9% Energy 1.6% Other Water 74.9% Agriculture 0.6% 6.4% Health 7.1% Infrastructure 7.2% Water 7.8% Waste & Pollution 1.9% Community Development Energy 30.7% Other 29.8% 9.1% Agriculture 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 37 As we do with Sustainable strategies, Sonen combines carefully selected Thematc Public Equity managers specializing in certain impact strategies in order to provide for diversifed impact across the portolio. Prominent impact themes include: Enhancing resource optmizaton through technologies and services that focus on energy efciency and the availability of water; Reducing waste through processes and technologies for recycling and re-use; Improving agricultural efciency and productvity, specifcally with water and land optmizaton, and supportng the local and organic food movements; and Providing and improving essental infrastructure such as updated pipelines and water distributon.
Table 8: Public Equities Managers Thematic Impact Strategies Thematc Manager Thematc Impact Thesis Manager Impact Strategy Manager A Companies that most efciently use environmental and fnancial resources will produce superior profts over tme. Invest in companies that make use of technologies, materials or services to increase resource productvity and lower costs by reducing raw materials usage and lowering toxicity and amount of waste. Manager B Environmental needs reveal revenue growth and cost improvement opportunites for companies addressing such problems at scale. Invest in companies that capitalize on environmentally-driven growth, borne from regulatons and incentves; advances in technologies; and solutons related to agriculture, health and resource scarcity. Manager C New infrastructure and innovaton is needed to meet rising global needs for water. Investments in infrastructure, technologies and utlites. Manager D Essental resources required for economic growth are fnite and increasingly scarce. Invest in solutons to scarcity rather than increasing supply; focus on efciency related to water, energy and waste. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 38 18.3% Project Loans 19.7% Small Business Dev. Housing 62.0% 3.2% Water 4.0% Waste & Pollution 14.4% Infrastructure Energy 60.8% Agriculture 2.4% 15.2% Other THEMATIC INVESTING: INVESTING TO MEET SOCIAL & ENVIRONMENTAL NEEDS Global Fixed Income US Core Fixed Income Global Fixed Income US Core Fixed Income Thematic 42.7% 57.3% Sustainable Thematic 22.6% 77.4% Sustainable Thematic 26.7% 40.9% Sustainable Responsible 32.4% Thematic 20.1% 79.9% Sustainable Chart 20: Impact Breakdown Chart 21: Thematic Breakdown Thematic Managers in Fixed Income Thematc fxed income investng includes a full range of government bonds (from supranatonal to municipal) whose proceeds target a wide range of social and environmental impacts. Prominent themes within Sonens Thematc Fixed Income strategies include: Community development projects and fnancial services for low-income regions of the United States; Large-scale projects and infrastructure that helps the economy adapt to and mitgate the efects of climate change through mult-sector approaches; and Mult-sector investments that focus on agriculture, water and waste management projects around the world. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 39 resource use efciency and help address the stresses caused by larger and more urbanized global populatons. Our Thematc strategies address climate change through energy efciency and renewable energy. Climate Change: Energy Efciency Companies held within Sonens Thematc manager portolios target energy efciency across multple dimensions: At large scale, through retrofts of coal-burning power generaton plants; At the industrial and commercial levels, with fuel- efcient motors and drive trains for entre truck feets and industrial cook ranges that use 35% less fuel and energy to operate; and At the consumer level, with handheld electronics devices that use signifcantly less energy to power and stay powered. (Consumer electronics and computer equipment now represent 15% of global residental electricity consumpton, with this energy use projected to triple by 2030 in the absence of energy efciency improvements). 22 Thematic Investing: Exploring the Key Underlying Themes Climate Change Climate change is projected to have multple and varied impacts on water resources, natural ecosystems, food security, human health and many other sectors of the global economy, in unpredictable and potentally catastrophic ways. 21 Sonens Thematc investng strategies address the issue of climate change in multple approaches, specifcally: By improving the resilience of regions and populatons most vulnerable to the deleterious efects of climate change, for example the poor, rural communites who depend on the land for their subsistence; By investng in products and services that are helping to reduce global consumpton paterns that contribute to climate change, focusing on energy efciency, renewable energy and waste; and By directng investment resources to the provision of technologies and infrastructure that not only help to reduce GHG emissions, but also promote
21. Yamba, Moomaw, M. Kamimoto, J. Nyboer, K. Urama, and T. Weir. Special Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitgaton. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA. 22. Internatonal Energy Agency. Energy Efciency-FAQs. Table 9: Fixed Income Managers Thematic Impact Strategies Thematc Manager Thematc Impact Thesis Manager Impact Strategy Manager A Investments that support low- and moderate-in- come communites can strengthen communites and satsfy a variety of investment objectves. Invest in securites that facilitate low-income homeownership, rental housing, healthcare and educaton, small business growth and job creaton. Manager B Addressing climate change requires unprecedented global cooperaton through instruments that facilitate public and private sector cooperaton. Manager provides access to innovatve investments dedicated explicitly to addressing the efects of climate change. Proceeds from fxed income investments are used to mitgate climate change (low-carbon infrastructure, clean technology, energy efciency and renewable energy) and adapt to climate change (water and soil erosion, food protecton, food security and sustainable forest management). 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 40 THEMATIC INVESTING: INVESTING TO MEET SOCIAL & ENVIRONMENTAL NEEDS Table 10: Climate Change Thematic Impact: Energy Efciency Security (Sector) Asset Class Energy Efciency Highlights ARM Holdings (Informaton Technology) Public Equity (US) For every wat that is used on a CPU, one more wat is needed to cool it down. Saving one wat on energy demand thus translates to two wats of energy savings. ARM makes the most energy efcient semiconductor chips in mobile devices. ARM-based processors are expected to be found in more than 90% of the worlds cell phones, and 22% of all laptops by 2015. 23 Borg Warner (Consumer Cycli- cal) Public Equity (Global) Products to manage combuston engines for fuel efciency and reduced emissions. Major supplier to the rapidly growing clean diesel and hybrid vehicle market worldwide. NY State Energy Research and Development Authority (Municipal Bond) Fixed Income (US) NY State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) provides funding to support sustainable community development, create opportunites for green jobs and establish a revolving loan fund. The fund fnances energy audits and energy efciency retrofts or improvements for the owners or occupants of residental, mult-family, small business and not- for-proft buildings. The statewide program promotes energy efciency and the installaton of clean technologies to reduce energy costs and reduce GHG emissions. Access to energy assessments, installaton services, low-cost fnancing and training for various green-collar careers. Private Sector Energy Efciency (Supranatonal) Fixed Income (Global) Energy conservaton in Chinas industrial sector. Strengthening government capacity for implementng industrial energy efciency programs. Estmated 4 million tons of avoided CO 2 equivalent emissions annually. Climate Change: Renewable Energy According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, energy-related GHG emissions, largely from fossil fuel combuston for heat and electricity generaton and transportaton, account for around 70% of total global CO 2 and methane emissions. 24 Clearly, renewable energy sources can supply energy on a much more sustainable basis than conventonal fossil fuels, and will play - indeed are already playing - a key role in long-term climate change mitgaton. As a target for investment, however, the renewable energy sector presents multple challenges, and we must be circumspect about how best to direct capital into the space. 23. Farivar, Cyrus. Smart Phone Chips Calling for Data Centers. MIT Technology Review (2011). 24. R.E.H. Sims, R.N. Schock, A. Adegbululgbe, J. Fenhann, I. Konstantnaviciute, W. Moomaw, H.B. Nimir, B. Schlamadinger, J. Torres-Martnez, C. Turner, Y. Uchi- yama, S.J.V. Vuori, N. Wamukonya, X. Zhang, 2007: Energy supply. In Climate Change 2007: Mitgaton. Contributon of Working Group III to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. [B. Metz, O.R. Davidson, P.R. Bosch, R. Dave, L.A. Meyer (eds)], Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 41 Sonens Thematc investments target renewable energy by investng in: Companies that own and operate large-scale renewable energy infrastructure; Companies that provide essental technology or services to the renewable energy industry; Companies that make productve use of waste for re-purposing or providing energy; and Companies that support the growth of the sector by owning or purchasing large quanttes of renewable energy. Table 11: Climate Change Thematic Impact: Renewable Energy Security (Sector) Asset Class Renewable Energy Highlights ABB (Industrials) Public Equity (US) Largest provider of generators to the wind industry and the largest supplier of power grids worldwide. 55% of revenues are related to products and services that reduce GHG emissions. Corporate growth policy through 2015 identfes mitgatng climate change through renewable energy investments as key drivers of business growth. Technologies for smart grid distributon networks include meters, building automaton systems and high-efciency distributon transformers. Emerson (Industrials) Public Equity (Global) Power equipment manufacturer and technology provider, with a growing portolio of full-service solutons for design, build and management of solar, geothermal, wind, hydroelectric and biomass power generaton facilites worldwide. Design and technology for wind turbines, solar farms and machine technology for hydro plants. Commonwealth Financing Authority (Municipal Bond) Fixed Income (US) Bond proceeds to fnance grants for public and private enttes to generate industrial improvements, specifcally for alternatve energy projects including supportng early stage alternatve energy projects and polluton control projects. The program provides funds for eforts that include investments in early- stage actvites to develop and implement alternatve energy and energy efciency technologies; grants to certain coal electric generatng or co- generaton units for polluton control projects; and grants, loans or rebates to individual residents or small businesses for solar energy projects. Geothermal Power Generaton (Supranatonal) Fixed Income (Global) Green Bond fnancing for a 150MW geothermal power plant in Indonesia to reduce dependence on coal-fred power generaton. Reducing estmated annual of 1.1 million tons of CO 2 equivalents annually. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 42 THEMATIC INVESTING: INVESTING TO MEET SOCIAL & ENVIRONMENTAL NEEDS Resource Efciency and Waste According to the US government, global society has consumed more natural resources in the last 50 years than all previous history. 25 And of all the raw materials consumed in the US over the last 100 years, more than half were consumed in the last 25 years. 26 With the size of the global economy expected to double and the world populaton to increase by one-third by 2030, the pressure on natural resources, the environment and the worlds carrying capacity will only intensify. 27
To promote a more sustainable use of materials, the UN has adopted the concept of Sustainable Materials Management (SMM) - a systematc approach to using and reusing materials more productvely over their entre lifecycles. SMM seeks to: Use materials in the most productve way with an emphasis on using less; Reduce toxic chemicals and environmental impacts throughout the material life cycle; and Assure we have sufcient resources to meet todays needs and those of the future. 28
Sonens Thematc investments pursue the principles of SMM in a variety of ways, including: Investng in companies whose main business is promotng the re-use of materials; Investng in companies that provide responsible and appropriate disposal of hazardous industrial materials; and Investng in waste disposal infrastructure that minimizes environmental impact. 25. Sustainable Materials Management. SMM Basic Informaton. Environmental Protecton Agency. May 23, 2013. 26. IBID. 27. Sustainable Materials Management. Green Growth Policy Brief. Organizaton for Economic Co-operaton and Development (2012). 28. Sustainable Materials Management. SMM Basic Informaton. Environmental Protecton Agency. May 23, 2013. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 43 Table 12: Thematic Impact: Resource Efciency and Waste Security (Sector) Asset Class Resource Efciency and Waste Highlights LKQ (Consumer Cycli- cal) Public Equity (US) Natonwide provider of recycled auto engines. Over 500 facilites collect, dismantle and re-sell replacement parts from salvaged vehicles and trucks. 82% of each salvaged vehicle is recycled. Recycling and refurbishing eforts resulted in GHG reductons of 1 million metric tons (2011). 18 million pounds of automotve bateries recycled and reused (2011). 2.2 million tres reused, recycled or recovered for energy (2011). Pilot program to recycle foam from seats, which is currently difcult to recycle. Pennon Group (Utlites) Public Equity (Global) Actvely maximizes the value of residual waste through recycling and transforming to energy where possible. Pennon subsidiary Viridor operates in the UK and focuses on transforming waste into a resource. Viridor recycled 37% of all materials in 2013 (up from 35% in 2012), totaling 2.6 million tons of recovered material and 240,463 tons of organic waste composted. Renewable energy from waste sources (landfll gas and biogas) totaled 820 GWh in 2013, up from 760 GWh in 2012. New Jersey Environmental Infrastructure Trust (Municipal Bond) Fixed Income (US) 2012 Series bonds provide low-cost fnancing for the constructon of environmental infrastructure projects, including wastewater, nonpoint source polluton controls and safe drinking water. To safeguard water quality, landflls are eligible for fnancing, including constructon, closure and restoraton to prevent, reduce control or treat leachate. Municipal Solid Waste Infra- structure (Supranatonal) Fixed Income (Global) Green Bond fnancing to increase solid waste management from 0% to 80% in Amman. Reduces CO 2 emissions by 212 metric tons and produces 6 MWhs of electricity annually.
2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 44 THEMATIC INVESTING: INVESTING TO MEET SOCIAL & ENVIRONMENTAL NEEDS Water According to the United Natons, the success of the worlds economy depends on the sustainable management of water resources and on providing adequate water supply and sanitaton services to the worlds growing populaton. 29 Water not only provides the most basic sustenance for human survival, but it also directly afects energy, food security and human health. Some forecasts predict that under current economic growth rates, and without efciency gains, by 2030 global water demand will exceed available water resources by 40%. And in developing countries, this defcit could reach 50%. 30 By 2015, an average annual investment of $772 billion will be required for water and wastewater services around the world just to keep pace with populaton growth, urbanizaton and industrial water needs. 31 In the US alone, much of the water delivery system was frst installed afer World War II and is nearing the end of its useful life. An estmated 7 billion gallons of water are lost daily due to leaky pipes in the US; with 240,000 water mains rupturing every day. 32 Restoring existng water systems and expanding new systems to serve a growing populaton will cost at least $1 trillion over the next 25 years in the US alone. 33
According to the World Economic Forums Water Initatve, improving water infrastructure for cites, energy and industry will become urgent across all economies, especially in Asia. Poor quality and inefcient water supply services will be seen as a brake on economic growth. Private fnance will be required, as public funds will not be able to fll the water investment gap. 34 Sonens Thematc investments in water address global water issues by: Investng in infrastructure that ensures the efcient delivery and availability of water in our aging and growing cites, partcularly in regions with high rates of populaton growth; Supportng emerging innovatons that promote a more efcient use of this limited resource; and Investng in projects that build water resilience within disadvantaged populatons, reducing the risk of fooding as well as mitgatng erosion and denudaton from severe climate events. 29. United Natons Water, and Rio+20 Summit. Water in a Green Economy. Rio+20 Summit Conference Book (2012). 30. Chartng Our Water Future. 2030 Water Resources Group (2009). 31. Samans, Richard and Dominic Waughray. The Bubble is Close to Burstng. World Economic Forum (2009). 32. 2013 Report Card for Americas Infrastructure. Americas Society of Civil Engineers (2013). 33. Buried No Longer: Confrontng Americas Water Infrastructure Challenge. American Water Works Associaton (2012). 34. Samans, Richard and Dominic Waughray. The Bubble is Close to Burstng. World Economic Forum (2009). 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 45
Table 13: Thematic Impact: Water Infrastructure and Utilities Security (Sector) Asset Class Water Infrastructure and Utlites Danaher (Industrials) Public Equity (US) Danahers water quality and treatment business provides instrumentaton and disinfecton systems to help analyze and manage the quality of ultra- pure, potable water and wastewater in residental, commercial and industrial applicatons. UV disinfecton systems cost 80% - 90% less than other treatments, does not require chlorine and can meet the US EPAs increasingly stringent quality standards for micro-organisms. UV facility in New York is the largest in the world, capable of treatng 2.2 billion gallons/day. Copasa (Utlites) Public Equity (Global) Copasa supplies 14.1 million people in Minas Gerais, Brazil, with water, an increase of 3.1% since 2011. Copasas sewage infrastructure serves 8.8 million customers, 6.2% higher than in 2011. Copasa is investng nearly $4 billion to expand water and sewage services to 100% of the populaton in the service area. In partnership with the local government, Copasa is expanding basic water and sewage services in parts of the state with lower human development indices. Riverside Sewer Fund (Municipal Bond) Fixed Income (US) Build America Bonds fnance capital projects to upgrade local water infrastructure that support local populaton growth. Riversides Green Acton Plan calls for increasing the use of recycled water by 30% by 2020, through water re-use from the treatment plant and by shifing a large water customer to recycled water. Flood Man- agement and Mitgaton (Suprana- tonal) Fixed Income (Global) Green Bond fnancing for food management infrastructure improvements to improve Chinas Huai River Basins resilience to the impacts of climate change. Berms, channels and irrigaton infrastructure protect 9,500 square km and 6.6 million people from fooding and disasters that occur every three to fve years. Wastewater collecton, treatment and watershed management in Xining Municipality. Reduces the annual food vulnerability of 400,000 people. Eliminates 2 million tons of untreated wastewater fow into rivers and 900,000 tons of soil erosion. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 46 THEMATIC INVESTING: INVESTING TO MEET SOCIAL & ENVIRONMENTAL NEEDS In support of increasing the availability and quality of one of the worlds most limited and stressed resources, Sonens Thematc investments target companies that develop and distribute technologies that improve water efciency and re- use, including purifcaton and treatment. Table 14: Thematic Impact: Water Efciency and Technologies Security (Sector) Asset Class Water Efciency and Technologies Highlights Pall (Industrials) Public Equity (US) Multple technologies to conserve and re-use water, and restore wastewater to environmentally safe levels before discharge. Mobile water treatment systems can produce drinking water from virtually any raw water source and are ofen deployed afer natural disasters or unantcipated disruptons to municipal supplies. Kurita (Industrials) Public Equity (Global) Ultrapure water producton systems. Wastewater treatment for industrial and commercial uses. Water reclamaton and re-use from industrial uses. Soil and groundwater remediaton. Hilton Head Public Service Dis- trict (Municipal Bond) Fixed Income (US) Bond proceeds used to refund outstanding debt and fnance improvements to the local water treatment system. Infrastructure includes a reverse osmosis treatment facility and aquifer storage and recovery well. 100% of residental and commercial wastewater is distributed to wetlands and used for irrigaton (1 billion gallons/year). Water Re- source Man- agement (Suprana- tonal) Fixed Income (Global) Water management system and infrastructure investments in Tunisia, a region with severe water scarcity, have allowed the country to capture over 80% of useable water. Irrigaton infrastructure for over 25,000 hectares. 10,000 households provided with drinking water. Community Development and Poverty Alleviaton Beyond investng for environmental impacts on climate change and resource efciency, Sonens strategies also provide investors with direct exposure, across asset classes, to various social impact investments. Sonens Public Equity strategies provide a range of consumers with goods and services that can enhance their lives, such as access to basic fnancial services and infrastructure. Fixed Income strategies ofer direct exposure to investments that target disadvantaged populatons in the US, specifcally providing access to afordable homeownership, small business development loans and pooled investments into community facilites that provide care for low-income seniors. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 47
Global Fixed Income investments provide access to World Bank and European Central Bank Green Bonds, whose proceeds are explicitly used for adaptng to and mitgatng the efects of climate change. These bonds ofen maintain a focus on poor, rural populatons who are most vulnerable to the impacts of climate change such as fooding and disruptons in subsistence farming. Table 15: Thematic Impact: Community Development and Poverty Alleviation Security (Sector) Asset Class Community Development and Poverty Alleviaton Highlights Visa (Financials) Public Equity (US) Visas fnancial inclusion program includes greater access to basic fnancial services through a broad electronic payments network and fnancial educaton programs. Partnerships with mobile payments providers expand Visas reach. In Zambia alone, 10% of the natonal GDP is business-to-business mobile payments. Actve services throughout Latn America, Africa, India and Southeast Asia. 27 million people in 30 countries use Visas fnancial literacy tools. Sabesp (Utlites) Public Equity (Global) Water and sewage services to residental and commercial use throughout So Paulo State, Brazil. Sabesp provides water to 27 million people and sanitaton to 20 million people in the So Paulo metropolitan area. By 2020, Sabesp plans to make 1.6 million new water connectons and 1.65 million sewage connectons toward its long-term goal of universal sanitaton services in its market. Target to reduce infrastructure water losses by 45% through 2019 (from 2013 levels). 35 Capital Green Apartments (Project Loan) Fixed Income (US) Financing for low-income mult-family housing. All vacant units must be leased to households earning no more than 50% of adjusted median income for the area. Urban In- frastructure and Financial Services (Suprana- tonal) Fixed Income (Global) Improve availability and fuel efciency of public transportaton feet in metropolitan Colombia, where 75% of the populaton relies on such service. Improve air quality and reduce CO 2 emissions by 250,000 metric tons/year. Catastrophe risk insurance in Macedonia and Serbia increases farmers, home- owners and governmental agencies access to fnancial protecton from regional climate change hazards, facilitatng the growth of catastrophic risk insurance in vulnerable communites. 35. Sabesp Financial Statements, 31 December, 2013. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 48 1. Politcal Spending greater transparency in how corporatons spend resources on lobbying eforts; 2. Sustainable Governance establishing board-level sustainability commitees, greater disclosure and reportng on sustainability risks and opportunites; 3. Environment reducing electronic waste, increasing takeback and recycling programs, reducing packaging and sustainable palm oil policies; 4. Board Diversity/Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) greater diversity in corporate boards or in the workplace; 5. Climate and Energy greater disclosure on company risks related to climate change and disclosure on energy and water use; 6. Human Rights/Decent Work increasing scrutny and reportng on human rights conditons throughout supply chain; and 7. Other internet privacy, data security. Shareholder engagement and advocacy are important elements of impact investors eforts to infuence corporate policy towards greater social, economic and environmental sustainability. In 2013, 51 companies in Sonens equity strategies were subject to 65 various shareholder advocacy actons, including shareholder resolutons and direct corporate engagement intended to induce specifc changes in management practces. Sonens managers voted on or partcipated directly in 35 of these actons. Actons were withdrawn for approximately 28 of these eforts due to agreement from management to address the issue in queston. The most common issues in 2013s shareholder resolutons include: IMPACT INVESTING IN PUBLIC MARKETS SHAREHOLDER ENGAGEMENT & ADVOCACY 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 49
0 5 10 15 20 Other Human Rights Climate & Energy Board Diversity/EEO Environment Sustainable Governance Political Spending 18 2 16 10 11 7 7 4 6 3 4 0 3 2 Total Shareholder Actions Number Withdrawn Chart 22: Subjects of Sonen Public Markets Shareholder Engagement (2013) Elicitng corporate policy change through such eforts is ofen a long-term propositon. It is also an incremental one that typically begins with eforts to induce corporate management to provide basic disclosures on its actual practces followed by codifying desired policies in corporate bylaws and governing documents. While some shareholder victories may seem small, they can actually be quite signifcant, partcularly when large industry leaders (such as Nike, see example in Table 16 on the following page) implement policies that set standards that industry peers feel compelled to follow. Alongside other insttutonal shareholders and advocacy groups, a number of notable policy successes were achieved in 2013 for a variety of holdings in Sonens Public Equity strategies (see Table 16 on the following page). In 2014, Sonen expects additonal shareholder resolutons and engagements on similar topics, leading with proposals on politcal spending, followed by a push for greater responsiveness to climate change and energy use and board-level sustainability reportng to shareholders. Sonen monitors ongoing shareholder and proxy votng actvity in order to solidify its understanding of the holistc impact created through Sustainable and Thematc investng, and how ESG issues and impact themes are further reinforced through shareholder actons. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 50 SHAREHOLDER ENGAGEMENT AND ADVOCACY Table 16: Examples of Corporate Policy Shifts Resulting from Shareholder Engagement Company Issue and Request Result 3M Politcal Spending - Proposals requestng beter lobbying policies, disclosure and oversight, including indirect initatves through trade associatons and think tanks. Agreed to add specifc language to policy that requires clarity on what groups may be sponsoring contentous legislaton. Withdrew from membership in American Legislatve Exchange Council (ALEC). Lincoln Elec- tric Sustainable Governance - Sustainability Reportng - Proposal that Lincoln adopt quanttatve company-wide goals for reducing GHG emissions from operatons and report on its plans to achieve these goals by fall 2014. Dialogue resulted in agreement to set GHG reduc- ton targets and increase sustainability reportng signifcantly in 2014. United Natural Foods Other Environment - Resoluton for company to issue a report assessing water risk in their supply chain and actons to mitgate the impact of water scarcity on long-term shareholder value. In 2013, United Natural Foods delivered on its commitment to conduct and report on a water risk assessment in its Alberts Organics division. The companys management reported that water analysis tools could help the company evaluate existng and prospectve supplier relatonships. Starbucks Other Environment - Request that Starbucks set a target date for sourcing 100% Certfed Sustainable Palm Oil or for purchasing GreenPalm certfcates covering 100% of sourced palm oil, with plans to verify suppliers compliance with the policy. Agreed to source 100% from sustainable sources by 2015. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 51
Company Issue and Request Result Nike Sustainable Governance Sustainability Reportng - Shareholders request that the Board of Directors take the steps necessary to require the companys signifcant suppliers to each publish an annual, independently verifable sustainability report that the company makes available to its shareholders. Withdrew a co-fled resoluton that pushed ESG transparency through supply chain. Nike agreed to a phased-in approach that will encourage major suppliers to publish their own sustainability reports. Target Other Environment - Request to implement electronics recycling policies, take back programs and preventon of e-waste exportng. Proposal withdrawn due to companys agreement to address the issues. Mondelez Interna- tonal Human Rights - Decent Work 1. Extended producer responsibility increase rates of packaging recycling to reduce related carbon emissions. 2. Request that company produce annual sustainability report, focusing specifcally on gender equality throughout the supply chain. 1. Company now determines the percentage of post-consumer recycled material package design, including energy and carbon dioxide emissions required to create packaging. 2. Company agreed to conduct and publish third-party impact assessments on women in supply chains and sign on to UN Womens Empowerment Principles.
Table 16: Examples of Corporate Policy Shifts Resulting from Shareholder Engagement (continued) 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 52 Environmental, Social and Governance performance data show that Sonens collecton of public markets securites have materially outperformed relevant market benchmarks on Key Performance Indicators such as carbon emissions, environmental polluton and water use. Sonens public markets securites also illustrate outperformance in social and governance KPIs such as worker health and safety, raw material sourcing free of confict, corrupton and board diversity. Thematc investments in all asset classes focus on climate change, specifcally through products and technologies that increase energy efciency and promote renewable energy use. Other Thematc focus areas include resource efciency, waste and polluton and social and community development for disadvantaged populatons. The various impacts across Sustainable and Thematc investments are synergistc and mutually reinforcing, and are further amplifed by the actons taken on the part of asset owners who advocate for greater In this inaugural impact report, we have atempted to illustrate how impact is being created across our public markets strategies. Through a careful and deliberate process of Impact Implementaton, comprising rigorous manager selecton, an integraton of Responsible, Sustainable and Thematc impact investment approaches, and the development and evaluaton of actual aggregated performance data, we believe we have demonstrated an ability to deliver genuine breadth and depth of impact across our frms public markets investment platorm. IMPACT INVESTING IN PUBLIC MARKETS LOOKING AHEAD 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 53
sustainability, transparency and responsibility to all stakeholders from companies in their portolios. Impact Looking Forward Over the long term, Sonen will seek to explore the relatonship between the ESG KPIs that we examine and the related fnancial returns of underlying securites. We will build on the work of others in the industry who are exploring sustainability reportng standards, and build on the premise of the positve relatonship between impact returns and fnancial returns. This report consttutes only the frst iteraton of Sonens impact reportng framework. As we contnue to innovate on impact reportng and evaluaton for clients, we antcipate more client-focused impact dashboards that refect specifc and customized interest areas. We are implementng plans to ensure a more thorough data collecton process across strategies to inform clients of the impact they are creatng, and provide further knowledge for Sonens ongoing impact evaluaton. In 2014, Sonen will expand impact reportng to include high-impact private strategies. We believe that the private markets provide compelling opportunites to target specifc social and environmental impact themes and objectves while striving to meet long-term investment objectves. As such, our private markets investments are optmized to deliver both atractve fnancial returns and explicit, meaningful impact. Private markets investng with Thematc exposure gives investors an opportunity to direct their resources to enterprises that generate explicit social or environmental benefts. These benefts are typically delivered through goods, services or technologies provided to the marketplace, and can typically be expressed by specifc outputs that map to broader social or environmental objectves. The ability to express such outputs clearly provides an excellent opportunity for impact investors to connect their investng with specifc social or environmental actvites and outcomes. Such impacts can be further enhanced by: A. Selectng managers and funds that are highly aligned with specifc or intended social or environmental objectves; and B. Working with managers to strengthen their own data collecton and reportng capabilites. We seek to create portolios that meet specifc target allocaton and diversifcaton needs across geography, sectors, investment stage and fund management teams while providing comprehensive coverage of critcal social and environmental impact themes. The focus sectors of Sonens private markets strategies e.g., sustainable tmberland and agriculture, clean power, environmental infrastructure, healthcare and access to fnancial services refect the areas in which we believe impact and investment objectves are not only compatble but also mutually reinforcing. 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 54 Appendix I: Acronyms and Abbreviations ALEC: American Legislatve Exchange Council EICC: Electronic Industry Citzenship Coaliton EEO: Equal Opportunity Employment EPA: Environmental Protecton Agency ESG: Environmental, Social and Governance GHG: Greenhouse Gas GRI: Global Reportng Initatve GWh: Gigawat Hour H&S: Health and Safety KPI: Key Performance Indicator MWh: Megawat Hour NOx: Nitrogen Oxide PRI: Program Related Investments RFP: Request for Proposal SMM: Sustainable Materials Management SOx: Sulfur Oxide WBGB: World Bank Green Bond VOC: Volatle Organic Compound Appendix II: Glossary of Terms Controversial Sourcing KPI: This Key Performance Indicator evaluates the extent to which companies rely on materials that originate in regions associated with human rights or labor abuses. While the issue afects many industries, controversial sourcing is of partcular importance for the technology industry, where electronic components for mobile phones, tablets, computers and electronic circuits ofen require minerals such as tn, tungsten and copper. GHG: Greenhouse Gases are gases in an atmosphere IMPACT INVESTING IN PUBLIC MARKETS APPENDICES 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 55
that absorb and emit radiaton within the thermal infrared range. This process is the fundamental cause of the greenhouse efect. Health and Safety KPI: This Key Performance Indicator monitors the degree to which underlying securites maintain related policies and procedures in the workplace in order to ensure worker safety. This is of partcular concern overseas, where such management may be less stringent or labor standards may be more relaxed. Impact Implementaton: The combinaton of investment approaches that themselves provide diversifed and complementary impacts within and across asset classes, and that includes impact actvites beyond security selecton, such as proxy votng and shareholder advocacy actvites that can amplify the Sustainable and Thematc outcomes from various investment strategies. Impact Scorecard: A dashboard used to track the integrated impact due diligence process to evaluate managers and strategies along quanttatve and qualitatve levels. MSCI ACWI: The MSCI ACWI Index is a free foat- adjusted market capitalizaton weighted index that is designed to measure the equity market performance of developed and emerging markets. The MSCI ACWI consists of 45 country indices comprising 24 developed and 21 emerging market country indices. The developed market country indices included are: Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hong Kong, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Japan, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal, Singapore, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United States. The emerging market country indices included are: Brazil, Chile, China, Colombia, Czech Republic, Egypt, Hungary, India, Indonesia, Korea, Malaysia, Mexico, Morocco, Peru, Philippines, Poland, Russia, South Africa, Taiwan, Thailand and Turkey. Private Markets (Not Marked-to-Market): Investments that cannot be exchanged or converted to cash easily without a substantal loss in value. Public Markets (Marketable Securites): Investments that can be converted to cash quickly at a reasonable price. Responsible Investng: Investments which avoid specifc industries or business lines with excessive ESG risks, or include objectonable business actvites. Russell 3000 Index: The Russell 3000 Index measures the performance of the largest 3000 US companies representng approximately 98% of the investable US equity market. The Russell 3000 Index is constructed to provide a comprehensive, unbiased and stable barometer of the broad market and is completely reconsttuted annually to ensure new and growing equites are refected. Supply Chain Labor Management KPI: This Key Performance Indicator evaluates the extent to which companies adhere to internatonal norms on labor, including the eliminaton of child labor, provision of safe work environments and provision of compensaton in accordance with local law. Sustainable Investng: Investng in securites across asset classes that exemplify high performance along 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 56 APPENDICES Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) standards and criteria. Thematc Investng: Investment approach in which asset owners direct their resources to specifc social and environmental impact themes and related needs that refect issues of global urgency. Appendix III: Important Disclaimers Limited Purpose of the Report: This document is provided for informatonal and educatonal purposes only. Any reference to a partcular investment, portolio or security contained in this report does not consttute a recommendaton or an ofer by Sonen Capital to buy, sell or hold such investment or security. This report does not consttute a solicitaton or ofer to provide any advice or services in any jurisdicton, including without limitaton, any jurisdicton in which such a solicitaton or ofer is unlawful or to any person to whom it is unlawful. No Financial, Investment, Tax or Legal Advice: The informaton herein is not intended to provide, and should not be construed as, fnancial, investment, tax or legal advice. The informaton contained herein does not take into account the partcular investment objectves or fnancial circumstances of any partcular recipient, or whether or not any recommendaton, investment, security or strategy described herein is suitable or appropriate for the readers investment objectves and fnancial situaton. Recipients of this report are strongly urged to consult with their own advisers regarding any potental strategy, investment or transacton. Third-Party Sources: Sonen Capital has obtained certain informaton in this report from third-party sources that it believes to be reliable, but such informaton has not been independently verifed and no representaton as to its accuracy or completeness is made. Except as otherwise indicated, the informaton provided herein is based on maters as they exist as of fscal year 2012 and not as of any future date. This presentaton will not be updated or otherwise revised to refect informaton that may become available, or based upon any change in circumstance occurring afer the date that appears on the cover of this presentaton. MSCI Source Data: Neither MSCI nor any other party involved in or related to compiling, computng or creatng the MSCI data makes any express or implied warrantes or representatons with respect to such data (or the results to be obtained by the use thereof), and all such partes hereby expressly disclaim all warrantes of originality, accuracy, completeness, merchantability or ftness for a partcular purpose with respect to any of such data. Without limitng any of the foregoing, in no event shall MSCI, any of its afliates or any third- party involved in or related to compiling, computng or creatng the data have the liability for any direct, indirect, special, punitve, consequental or any other damages (including lost profts) even if notfed of the possibility of such damages. No further distributon or disseminaton of the MSCI data is permited without MSCIs express writen consent. MSCI ESG Research: This document and all of the informaton contained in it, including without limitaton all text, data, graphs, charts (collectvely, the Informaton) is the property of MSCl Inc. or its subsidiaries (collectvely, MSCI), or MSCIs licensors, direct or indirect suppliers or any third party involved in making or compiling any Informaton (collectvely, with MSCI, 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 57 the Informaton Providers) and is provided for informatonal purposes only. The Informaton may not be reproduced or redisseminated in whole or in part without prior writen permission from MSCI.
The Informaton may not be used to create derivatve works or to verify or correct other data or informaton. For example ( but without limitaton), the Informaton many not be used to create indices, databases, risk models, analytcs, sofware, or in connecton with the issuing, ofering, sponsoring, managing or marketng of any securites, portolios, fnancial products or other investment vehicles utlizing or based on, linked to, tracking or otherwise derived from the Informaton or any other MSCI data, informaton, products or services.
The user of the Informaton assumes the entre risk of any use it may make or permit to be made of the Informaton. NONE OF THE INFORMATION PROVIDERS MAKES ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES OR REPRESENTATIONS WITH RESPECT TO THE INFORMATION (OR THE RESULTS TO BE OBTAINED BY THE USE THEREOF), AND TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAW, EACH INFORMATION PROVIDER EXPRESSLY DISCLAIMS ALL IMPLIED WARRANTIES (INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF ORIGINALITY, ACCURACY, TIMELINESS, NON-INFRINGEMENT, COMPLETENESS, MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE) WITH RESPECT TO ANY OF THE INFORMATION. Without limitng any of the foregoing and to the maximum extent permited by applicable law, in no event shall any Informaton Provider have any liability regarding any of the Informaton for any direct, indirect, special, punitve , consequental (including lost profts) or any other damages even if notfed of the possibility of such damages. The forego ing shall not exclude or limit any liability that may not by applicable law be excluded or limited, including without limitaton (a s applicable), any liability for death or personal injury to the extent that such injury results from the negligence or wilful default of itself, its servants, agents or sub- contractors.
Informaton containing any historical informaton, data or analysis should not be taken as an indicaton or guarantee of any future performance, analysis, forecast or predicton. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
None of the Informaton consttutes an ofer to sell (or a solicitaton of an ofer to buy) , any security, fnancial product or other investment vehicle or any trading strategy.
MSCIs indirect wholly-owned subsidiary Insttutonal Shareholder Services, Inc. (ISS) is a Registered Investment Adviser under the Investment Adv isers Act of 1940. Except with respect to any applicable products or services from ISS (including applicable products or services from MSCI ESG Research Informaton , which are provided by ISS), none of MSCIs products or services recommends, endorses, approves or otherwise expresses any opinion regarding any issuer, securites, fnancial products or instruments or trading strategies and none of M SCIs products or services is intended to consttute investment advice or a recommendaton to make (or refrain 2013 Annual Impact Report Sonen Capital 58 APPENDICES from making) any kin d of investment decision and may not be relied on as such.
The MSCI ESG Indices use ratngs and other data, analysis and informaton from MSCI ESG Research. MSCI ESG Research is produced by ISS or its subsidiaries. Issuers mentoned or included in any MSCI ESG Research materials may be a client of MSCI, ISS, or another MSCI subsidiary, or the parent of, or afliated with, a client of MSCI, ISS, or another MSCI subsidiary, including ISS Corporate Services, Inc., which provides tools and services to issuers. MSCI ESG Research materials, including materials utlized in any MSCI ESG Indices or other products, have not been submited to, nor received approval from, the United States Securites and Exchange Commission or any other reg ulatory body. Any use of or access to products, services or informaton of MSCI requires a license from MSCI. MSCI, Barra, RiskMetrics, ISS, CFRA, FEA , and other MSCI brands and product names are the trademarks, service marks, or registered trademarks or service marks of MSCI or its subsidiaries in the United States and other jurisdictons. The Global Industry Classifcaton Standard (GICS) was developed by and is the exclusive property of MSCI and Standard & Poors. Global Industry Classifcaton Standard (GICS) is a service mark of MSCI and Standard & Poors Assumptons: Certain analyses contained in this report are based on a number of assumptons which, if altered, could materially afect the conclusions reached in this report. Sonen Capital reserves the right to change any opinions expressed, or assumptons made, herein without notce. Russell 3000: Russell 3000 is a registered trademark of Russell Investments. They have not reviewed or verifed in any way the informaton presented in this report. Copyright Notfcaton: No part of this report may be reproduced except as authorized by writen permission from Sonen Capital.