Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ปาฐกถาเรื่อง สุญญตา - อาจารย์เสถียร โพธินันทะ
ปาฐกถาเรื่อง สุญญตา - อาจารย์เสถียร โพธินันทะ
ปาฐกถาเรื่อง สุญญตา - อาจารย์เสถียร โพธินันทะ
Ul'lOnl150V "ClIlJIlJCI1" *
lWBuun:
ru unlBlq:'lnmclu JaUf11Blq
90 nSnl]ltlU W.fI. b(;:olX
.n Vl7El3JVI1m'U
"ElUWlWl1 1$1 Vl7ElLl1TI1'Yl"lJEl-lL"rl nil
WI-!ffl.1':h
,
Lfl'U en flEl ElrulIil1il1La.Jn-! iltJtJrni11il1La.Jm
1 LL'il 1 Lfl'UwkJ1"111'J
"ffnInIWl1'
, ,
I
b7El-l "ElUIil1il1' bU"I-l.YlLfl'l!t
h'l1 f1yh nu UIilt11il1
ilfl113JVl3J1mL'1ln'ill\lnU UIilf'iWl1
1D
1UJll'1!t1Ulil
fh'U 'ffnInIWl1'
(lJ'lJt: ,.Vb'S!&:: ,..." '"
1 L"lJl1;$11 "UWlt11il1"
'Il 'Il
"'lqJtlJWll" 511
h Lfl'U
5l
1.1 .. , ", q
11). ihrw:/.Iumv fJJJwmnmrn flr.11milaml'i:/.l lI)u .
Il. 1'WlllYlr1mmf)\il Ulfj6i\ill 'fl".l..111ufi111 Atheism h...r'l
UlJfie:Wf1rfU1iJuliI
,.
\
,
V 1.1 .., 'I G .d Ad.., IV 1.4 A X AX ....
aJ"1IULLG'n
j.I I I
"U<1lfi<1l1' ,.. m:h'lL"SnC;
IiJ IlJCI..f
<1l1a.!lwlTrtlL'Y1m"Sl ''JUU<1ll'
lUfll1aJVlaJ1U"1Ifl'lfi1
.alU 1
"
'fl<1l<1l1'
\I 'U q
o/lU' fiT)l
., '" Qid 'I 'l
lu lmtliJmflaJ Gll@) LtlUl'Odfl11a.!
11 {(u LU11 "1
III \11*1 j IlJ ....
flo/lo/l1 b Uel<1lo/l1'
fll'Od bbU" flfln fltl1"
fto/l1 m1aJEj(9)tif) Liju IJ
fltl1\l ltl1\lVl'd\l "fll1aJLtlu
,
EinmJ1\lVlU\l
'II "
"l1f1f1itiff'llt'llf;ll"
't IlJOfd q
Uflflft b"Sl 6"111 "1Ieltln
q Cj>tot1"t1
,
til1fltl1-:Jm1ffi"1lfl'lU1\l1;"Sl1in1trn timhd';h
.. e! _ *" oJ.J
'1 "1Ifl\l";ifl \JJl'
.. I 0 Idol J' i1 0.1 IV I.r A I A X
fll11 '''Sfl' 'Od\lu"Slnn"1lU bb(1l IilUu";ia.!l1lflbbftJ 3.Jbb(1l'Y1n"1lL'Y11UULnlil"1lU
, ..., .
'Y1n-nbvi1.awii\lmi LU Ldbn!?] fh11
q *U q: tt
'Y1n-nlu.rn1ffi"1lf)\lU 'Wl"1fVl3.J1 tlt1\lq;)113.JLff-n Ul'Od 'WL"livIm
,. ,.
'Y1l\lh LLGiVlmut)\l 'W
'II
LJI
, , ,
, .
tI flULIilLtJu'Yln,j
,
flU
BUL(9) bW"Sl:::fi111 'flU'Od%.:J'
,
VlaJ1 tlt1..'J.rm fl til f111aJ UULU fllUih:h ''Y1n-n' VlaJl
'II. ,
'Y1lU bbU'NULU
,
\!J it Ll'V'l'Od,lI.LP)uB\lnu
VlaJ1 t)lW(9)11 bUU U
'II ,
\
! . L I ; U : . . l t
, " ,
L
L @ l i l U i . } 1 \ h , t : ! . 1 l 1 i l l ! > 1
, "
' t 1 . t L s
1 L ! . ' L t f L @ i L ! . '
t e l 1 1 . ) : \ L I M ' L ! . '
" , ,
' " , \ f > l t e l t : ' U 1 . 1 ' L ! . ' o o w
U ' t 1 . . : : : L A . L I : . . L U ' t 1 . . @ J l ' . L ' ' t 1 . I ; \ I i l L U ' t 1 . t f ' t 1 . J l ' . 1 I : ' L I i l @ C , f l l U I i l ' t 1 . 1 l . ' t 1 . U I : ' m ,
, . . . . f J i ' " = ' F f ' w f : 1 I " " . r , . . .W ' f : 1 I 1 ' 1
L ' ( $ i : ' ' t 1 . 1 .
" ,
r t U
I ' I 0 I l ' ' ' ' ' t t 1 I n J = l ' J : I ' . . . . P ' " t
. ' " ,
' t 1 . U I : ' @ ' t 1 . ,
, . . f "
w L ! } i
. ' "
! . r m : : : L ! . M '
' " 1 \ 1 \
r t L f l l L C " ' t 1 . I J ' ! . L U L ' l I . 1 @ 1 i l J i i l ! . L U L ' l I . 1 @
" . . .
I i > 1 \
1 1 ! .
' "
( $ ! i >
N ! L W f 1 L f 1 1 1 . 1 > 1 I l 1 1 1 A f 1 L L ! L 1 1 .
t = t ' I I ! ) ' I I ' ! t ; : f r ' " ,
f 1 L I 1 1 1 . 1 1 1 : ' 1 1 M . ,
" " 1 \
1 1 U J ' t } I : ' G 1 1 . : : : l A . L t . 1 1 1 . ' l 1 . 1 J 1 p 1 i L f i { j
' l 1 . l l ' s 1 I 1 L U , ! : I > G I 1 . ' l 1 . 1 J 1 ' ! J . I : ' L f i G
" , . . . .
G ! } L l t ' L . t . ' : : : L . t . M . 1 f 1 L U , ! :
u u ( 3 ! l -
' l 1 . j ; : L : : : t \ ! : : : L . t . M . 1
. . . .
1 \ t \
I t 1 . 1 1 . ' l 1 . f J '
. . . . . .
1 \ b a . b
: : : 1 I l l f l 1 . ! J ' ! l 1 1 A . M . ' l 1 . f J 1
k . L ' p l l l .
. . . . . .
L 1 I : ' I J 1 1 l A . L l ! , t l 1 1 1 L U ' ! : I > I t l t L l I l t L ,
. . .
1
,
u riV1llfflf1'u1
,
fll'it\.J$j lViunL1mmcl
'W$jLf1t1 "1
'1
,
ut6'6 LVi
OJ OJ
nLf1f1'L "1 nLf1flmJl\1nf11\1 m.il\l'Vi tn'lJLUULL"IJnLLtlf1n'VIUl 'V'j'tYiV1fiEl\lfi"
, ,
nLf11f1' 'Vnnd'L'i:!u
OJ
-;ijltJ1WJttJEa-lW'VIiEl iiL'V'jil:;'WiLvhYfu:;j.,l tJ8:WWL"IJ1L-lJ1:Wl'l'liL'VIa-l 'lViL"IJ1mElu.51L'li
L'VI:W L'l
'l-6f1f)Ufi (logic)
,
La.J tJ Ela-l LLnL"IJ f1 b,) m Lfl tJ L VI CiJdL'l 1.m\lLVi
ft1um,:wtc;i1\1 '1
UtlCl.JLtlCilla-lL'lfl1 LbtJn
lh mtJuUmtJc;i1\l '1 eJeJn'ttl lq;)uL"IJln
'YhUnt;JUmHvhu e-J3Jnt;lUmtJ
u<iiL11ni11 8E 11V1tUmtJd L'ln
LVlUn!iJl3J '1
tn3J : 'lUL'YltJ)
CJ\tl1l : '1
tn3J : (WilLamlUL'YltJ)
!;liJ1J :!le:J
GO -..J:dl
finu
'1/
'1/ 1
fl1U
mh\JL'l
Ql3J : 'lUL'YltJ)
"B1I :
m3-l : ('WiMtml.UL'YltJ)
!iJe:JU : B'Yl'If1 GO m"lf"lfl
1qJqJlru. n'YlUl t11rnVll
,
e:JUlfllll U-..J-..JUu
,
L1'YlU1Ln{ilt11rnVll l.ul;hu
, ,
LtJ'lUe:JUlfllll III'W5je:J1"lf"lfl
'1/
LYI'n:::t;,\tiiUqJl-3Lmn
f)::; f):::L'UtJUlUlflIllB'Yl1S1 III
s- .1 o"l __ ,.i
,
IV A'!"I ....'1 ..,
GO Vl1-l m m mfl
" ,
Q13J : (bJ!lLam'luL'YltJ)
"B1I : m"lf"lfl l.u 'W'l"lim"lf"lfl
III
'1/ '1/
LtJ;a h LtJe.hn 'lVi
,
'<iill.bf)1"lf"lfl '1
'1/ '1/
La fll
1l13J : lu,L'YltJ)
"illl : l!l LL1JlJ
VI!iemnlJI.
d "I " ... 'U
h"ll8\1L':f1nbVl!iuu,nU
.J $ v.. .... , a 4..1 r. A
LbGlmm':f
\
{)nLv.JLf,Jl '1 1'\
a.Jl
Il1IJ :
"811 ; mh\lL'"lmb71trnn if1tJ..J\I 5:llJl\1L'"ll1l1eJa\lLff ffft'lJ
nu, L':f1
. .
l-o.J"lla\lL':f1
"',. q, " 'U
,,'U
fl11a.1ff"llmi1\1
,
tl1lndJu,mh\lh
,
itY1'Wlu,nu,
Il1IJ ; ('W5:lbamLU,L'YltJ)
,,811 ; hVJn '1
L d a1"lf"1fl
'l'OJ
1; 'II 1;
1l13J :
,,811 : 'G,)tdl'lflda.Jlrlem on
I
'lfld'OJ:;11'lfldl.n!?'lrlau, t.ll'lfldbnlilrlau,LUu,
I.d t.ll
'1 n\l5:ifimffL,hii
u, a\l
tl13,1 : LU,b'YItJ)
"8il : e:J1"J.l"1fl
\f 'iJ \! 'U ttJ
<i)'l
\I
\I
,,.
bbmle:J1"1f"1fl LlIU,1JlGl
1.1
h
\J .. \J 1.1
'l L'n
U1tJ n. B1U'VIit'lflEl'WEl1n
'IJ 'II
t.11J1 : ('W!1L5tJ-lLUL'VlU)
"'Sil :ciULUUfl113-1L{;U'lJ1-lflru
q
rt1J1 ; LUL'VlU)
flail :
UnltJLrIj11'Vl
. .
..Ji ... ({ "I "I_!
"" ... I ... ...:r *'
"1'Vl'fiYl"lWlJU Lj1J..I'Vl'nU
U1jru
3-I1n "1'V1'fimMlildu'nnDlumnuu11il
.. '"
rt1J1 : tJ11Vi11 DUitL'n"lf11Yl'V1151.m
'Yi1UL.;J1 I.'VI'I4n'l4uu
1'14
flSiI ; 3-Il'QnnmtJUEln
nLflfl'LUU
'lJ1-l<il13-lU1UL.n1-l ciudju'lJ1-lmllLU
rt1IJ : I.U bdfl1Uj:::fl'UnUmj3-lruL.;J1nL'VIflL-H13-11L"lh-t.,xu'VIiEl
<il1U : 'n
LYl'n:::%V...,lU ci'
'1'IJn<ill3-1
<1113-1 mflU<ilnnLflf{
1\\f' " .. , "
11nlfl'LLlf3-lYl'ntlL'n
.
'II
'" '"
Uj:::L1l'V1'V1mU'VI13-111il1n-H1.:JU1n lui! LU'W5l
L"ldbL'VI'r1:::bUUril1n1jl'Vl
n
t.11L'n tllj3-lrn
'II
-H1-lU1n3-l1nj:::'V1U 'kJWbflEJ 'kJL<Ji' \ibml::: W
'II
b-H13-111 bfi8 bYl'n:::%:::,xuncif1.:J 1 1'VIfi)
rt1J1 : L5H.:!
jf{ cl
q
v Ji v
(1
\
'
<:0,'" 1.. A. :1 ., .'1
L"ll L'Vl3-J
.. " , ..
fliil : 4ll\lmh\l-afl-n., l:JJ41l\l:ru
L LilU1aJLJl tl -n1\l1 'Vl3-J1 tlfl113-J11:ru3-Jl
..dtl
'll .. 'U'
tib7au
tl1l1 : li'lL<iuiiun"151U
LTInijn
...
flilil :
ffn LLI1111 bUUm1"3-JruL'Yh,iULa\l fl 1 I.aJLUU
1'V1'l.:!' nl3-Jflrn r:l l.aJij
" q q q
Q U UJbuuiltlLU1'Yhu tln"llULftY'ailih u nLUuiltl
"lJ 'I , \J
Lbf1'Yhu
1"ft bft'WeJW 1"ft LLi\1Ln<;)nLflft
'II "
'Vl1"an
a1"15''lfl'luh 'Vl3-Jltlml3-J11mh-l.a
fl111 :
l"1fL'Vl3-J
''; , q
"11 ....
fliltJ : L"15am-lU\jn
"
11111 : Ul\l'YhUb-1l1
fliltJ :'W'l"1f
..,,, .... .. I A.A "l'" .., ..,
1"lfl:;"lla\l1,!flflfl';jLft'Wtl
I.'YhYi'u
01S1 : ilLLIJi'lui{uVI1Ul'ifL'Vl3-J
flillJ : ff\lY1flEltl1lUa
51'Vl'iU tll'Vl1n11
'1
tl13J :
. ,
. t . l l ' L I l ' I 1 . p . 1
. . . , . A . h
t - U : . . I f I l ! . U : . . U ! b n . U L I f I I f I ' I 1 . @ @ ! . I t 1 . ' I 1 . ' I 1 . L I f I I U \ . . I t 1 . L B : f ' C L I J
I ' " J : I ' , , , = , , , . , . . n v " , . I = "
, . . . '
l l t t :
. . . .
r t l t 1 . 1 ! - 1 l 1 l f ' C L I J
. . . . . .
I 1 l r t L I J
, . . .
. . . . . . . . .
f t l r t L I J
' "
n " l I
I 1 l 1 3 ! h ' t 1 . l t 1 . h I 1 l : f ' C L I J
I 1 L U
U t . I t 1 . , t f ' l r t l 7 . e . .
k .
i
- " . " . f ' ' I t : : ; / 1 " . . .
! 1 I L U ' t ! r t l
. . .
1 t 1 t 1 . 1 J l o 1
h . . .
t s f t l I 1 l C i \ r t L I J
J 1 0 r
r t 1 t 1 . 1 , 1 1 . ' @ U ! 1 I l ! . l ! .
r 1
' t 1 .
n
1 ; r t L I J
r , : 1 1 s , f " C ' . . . . 1 , .
n e l o f )
1 t 1 t 1 . 1 J l o 1 1 [ 1 t : f ' C L I J
h
@ t ! ' ' t 1 . ! ! ' : : : . t . U t - g ' t 1 . I l ' L I f U I 3 ' t 1 .
" ,
L , t ' L ! h ' l 1 . t
h '
l '
. . . . . .
.
' "
\ . . .
B ! : . . n . 1 A . : : : W L I f
. . . , .
l : ! ! . B ! . j 1 . t .
, . . . ,
. . . .
L l 1 U ' I 1 . ' I 1 . t ' L I i l @ ' I 1 . G ' , 1 1 . 1 : n e l o f )
" l I . . . . K t 1 k ! ' ! " I l ,I
t t l
. . . . .
L ! l - ' l : ! ! : I t ! i - l : ! ! . l i t
. . . . . ..
' I 1 . L t 9 ' 1 1 . ! i - ' I 1 . 1 r t L I J
.
1 J 1 0 1 f t l
. . . . . . ' "
f1all ; 'l.4fLtJulJ'vf'il,.tbLnnu'1.J1 '1 rlU"ilt
bmfl113-JVl3-JlE.ltl EJ
t A. 1:
fla L6lfUVI'j"mn'j"11'Yl
fI13J : q.)a flmYl"lJa-lii;wvnu
f1all :
U'Y'lYll"v\. '11 Luuit'Y'lYllUflUti aii1i":i":i3-J
d "
m1 'Y'l1nYlL7EJUaii1i,,3-J aii1i":i":i3-J'l.uitmEJfl":i11flqjm:mYl
LtJU
tl?lfqJ1Yl'j"lVl3-Jrn it'W't*lff.lJ,dl itmEJrtll'l '1 L"lJll1 t:-J3-J3-JlthEJ'Ylafl
fI13J ;n34V1fmJm"ill,f1 mEJ'l.ULrI":i11'Yl"lJ I-lL"rldbel-lUl-lyhunnme:mJa-l Ul-l
h
f1all : bfl":i1TYI L":i
'1 'lJanl11qJqJlrn;ru.fi
dJumJ'1I:::LUU'1'Yl1l1ll1t: LUUU'V'lVnu
1l13J ;(L3J34LftCl-l'l.UL'Yltl)
f1all : q
"-<1 \i 11 'fJ" '\I ..
vnn I fl41a"mffCl tll
13Jil tlfl"/)'''v\.
\J .. .. "1" 'U"
EJd1u,a6ifl'Ylnoff 'I. LonbJ'11L"rl$jn bb<J111b"rl'rtl l Lrifl
'IJ q \i '" .. 'U \i \i
fl113J
"1 "" I u ifEJnLVlSj lUrlU b"rltln"llU"ilt' IuifClnbJ$j'Yll"'11L"rl$j luifCl
LY'I .... '" .. \i.. 'U..
lhbJ$j'l.fl":i3-JltJan
,.onhi' L
bd I " .. \l "
tl11J : (lJjilLftm'l.uL'Yltl)
'lI
f1all ; illn":i::Ju
'II
"lfJ1 LLrtlgr"LnWl dju
El,"ifCl bJ<1i'eJ-35u bJ
. .
\
q If '" ....q
5"lJ rtLDUbfll:!
, .
L'W'1"l::;L'1"ltJJne:J1mJqJqJlmh:l'Yhu
a1lJ :
Glilll : tlUti utlVlit\lLL1i'1<f1\lf)f)nLiJu"lI'lWi'YIn.nf)f)mnnfl'1"jrl
.
.,
,
lJ
, 'II
"
nV13-l'11:!
Cf II
tllVlln11L'1"l "'limn
q
'-innfl'';i'1"A
a1lJ : lUL'Ylll)
Glilll : l\l LLqi
q
Uf1f1&l bbib lljl'1"flU 1'1"n'YIj\l
'" ,
I.bti<fl-l 1Jl\lLb'lt1"
" .
'Yl':i.:l <0>0<;;0 1Jl\lLbvi\l'Yl1\lbb1i'1<f1\lL1'YlU1 m';) 'lJl-lbbvi\l'Yl'1"-lLb1i'1<f1-lL1'VlUl <o>lD 1Jl\lbb'lt1\l
'Yl':i'lbLfl<fl'l m 'lJl,m'lt1':)'Ylj\lbl.fl<fl\l lD 'lJl\lbL"'\l'Ylj\lI.Lfl<?1\ll1' <0>
'" '"
l<f1if)Vlit-l
\