Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ALS Moral Dilemma
ALS Moral Dilemma
Oksana Jan Bernal | Angela Carmela Cerdena | John Reymund Bungcayao | 4MA2
What is ALS?
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), often referred to as "Lou Gehrig's Disease," is a progressive
neurodegenerative disease that affects nerve cells in the brain and the spinal cord. Motor
neurons reach from the brain to the spinal cord and from the spinal cord to the muscles
throughout the body.
Universalization
Is it possible not to undergo an embryonic stem cell therapy? There is nothing wrong with trying
to save a life, but choosing one's life over another is inhumane. The zygote that grows in a vitro
or what we call "test tube baby, is in no way different from a zygote growing in a uterus. The
zygote has a life and is in its way to becoming a fully developed human being, therefore it has
the right to live. Just because it is less developed, doesn't mean it is any less of a person. Saying
that we would undergo embryonic stem cell therapy is like saying that it is fine to take another
person's life for our own sake.
Making it a universalized maxim is not possible. Making it a universalized maxim is not possible.
For the reason that if every person is permitted to take one's life for his/her welfare, then it will
make the laws useless and illogical. Even if there is a huge possibility that embryonic stem cell
surgery could be a big help in curing an ALS patient, the fact that every life is equally important
will always hold true. Even if there is a huge possibility that embryonic stem cell surgery could
be a big help in curing an ALS patient, the fact that every life is equally important will always
hold true.
Duty
We haven't shown the impossibility of not undergoing an embryonic stem cell surgery being
universal and necessary, so i cannot conclude that undergoing such surgery is willed universal
and necessary, ergo, we have an imperfect duty.