Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Harrower 2010
Harrower 2010
a r t i c l e i n f o
a b s t r a c t
Article history:
Received 8 July 2009
Received in revised form
28 December 2009
Accepted 4 January 2010
From small bands of foragers, pastoralists, and village agriculturists, to states and civilizations water
accessibility and management played a crucial role in sustenance and social life throughout the ancient
world. Recent advances in Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and related remote sensing technologies offer powerful means of analyzing water ow that are well-suited to clarify design and operational
requirements of different irrigation and water management systems. Ancient Southwest Arabian irrigation technologies developed over thousands of years culminating in some the ancient worlds most
advanced ashood water systems. This paper describes satellite imagery Digital Elevation Model (DEM)
extraction and GIS hydrological modeling procedures conducted for the Wadi Sana watershed of
Hadramawt Governate, Yemen. Results help illustrate one of the local contexts in which small-scale
irrigation originated in Southwest Arabia and additionally serve as an example for those interested in
applying similar methods in other regions.
2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords:
Geographic Information Systems
Hydrology
Irrigation
Ancient near east
Remote sensing
1. Introduction
Archaeologists have long noted the importance of access to and
management of water among ancient societies (Raikes, 1967;
Steward, 1930; Wittfogel, 1957). Indeed, the spatial distribution of
precipitation and water ow have been identied as factors
important to the movements of foragers (Kelly, 1995), the settlement choices of agriculturists (Byrd, 2005), and the food producing
economies of ancient states (Marcus and Stanish, 2006). While air
photos and topographic maps have traditionally provided qualitative means of evaluating the role of water, recent advances in
remote sensing and Geographic Information System (GIS) technologies allow a far wider breadth analyses poised to generate
signicant new understanding of ancient human use of water
resources. Such analyses not only assist in characterizing physical
environments but additionally help reveal how ancient peoples
conceptualized and manipulated their surroundings.
Irrigation was important from crop agricultures beginnings in
Yemen at least as early as the 4th millennium BC through the rise of
states more than 2000 years later. Early small-scale systems
diverted water from springs, hillslopes, or captured soil and water
in terraces (Harrower, 2008a, b; Wilkinson, 1999). A wide diversity
1448
Fig. 1. MODIS satellite image map of Southwest Arabia showing locations of ancient
states and the Wadi Sana watershed study area.
1449
Fig. 2. Digital Elevation Model (DEM) (15 m resolution) extracted from ASTER satellite imagery with PCI Geomatics software.
threshold) and thus provides a less subjective dataset for quantitative analyses.
1450
Fig. 3. ASTER satellite image map of middle Wadi Sana showing check dams, diversion channels, and a stream network depicting areas where ow from more than 750 15 15 m
grid cells accumulates.
100
A - Watershed
100%
Watershed
Check Dams
Diversion Channels
10
80%
B - Check Dams
Frequency
100
10
1
100
C - Diversion Channels
Cumulative Percent
60%
40%
20%
10
0%
1
.5
10
100
1,000
10,000
10
19
43
131
475 10497
Fig. 5. Flow accumulation maximum values for check dams, diversion channels, and
points randomly distributed throughout the Wadi Sana watershed (this graph presents
the same data as Fig. 4 in slightly different way illustrating differences as evaluated by
the KolmogorovSmirnov test).
1451
Fig. 6. Quickbird image map showing one of the areas along middle Wadi Sana where diversion channels redirect water towards check dams along the margins of the main Wadi
Sana channel.
Table 1
KolmogorovSmirnov statistics comparing ow accumulation values in 50 m radii
around 125 check dams and 49 diversion channels with ow accumulation in 50 m
radii around 1000 points randomly distributed throughout the Wadi Sana watershed (ow accumulation maximum results outside brackets, ow accumulation
mean results inside brackets).
Check dams
Diversion channels
Difference
Z-Value
Sig. (2-tail)
0.318 (0.283)
0.210 (0.230)
3.352 (2.983)
1.434 (1.572)
0.000 (0.000)
0.033 (0.014)
4. Conclusions
In a vast array of hyper-arid to temperate contexts worldwide,
spatial patterning of water ow across landscapes signicantly
inuenced ancient human action and choices. Digital Elevation
Models and GIS hydrological modeling tools hold important
potential to help clarify technical and operational dimensions of
water management systems in a wide range of circumstances.
Advances in DEM availability will undoubtedly continue to expand
the range and improve the resolution of modeling opportunities.
Geographic Information Systems-based approaches are likely to be
increasingly combined with non-spatial quantitative hydrological
modeling (e.g., Crook, 2009; Whitehead et al., 2008). For example,
HEC-GeoRAS software (US Army Corps of Engineers, 2009) interfaces with GIS to facilitate modeling of channel hydraulics and
holds a wealth of opportunities for archaeological analyses of water
ow and irrigation.
In ancient Wadi Sana, local experience with sporadic monsoon
runoff led ancient peoples at the cusp of irrigations origins to
understand landscapes as hydrologically malleable domains of
anthropogenic control. GIS hydrological modeling has enhanced
understanding of their activities and choices in redirecting low-
1452