Professional Documents
Culture Documents
15.energy Audits of Fishing Vessels Lessons Learned and The Way Forward
15.energy Audits of Fishing Vessels Lessons Learned and The Way Forward
15.energy Audits of Fishing Vessels Lessons Learned and The Way Forward
AbstractCommercial fishing activities are strongly fueldependent. Consequently, the dramatic increase in the price of
diesel fuel has impacted negatively on the economic incomes of
fishing. Moreover, the overexploitation of north-Atlantic
fisheries, over many decades, has caused international regulatory
bodies to establish more restrictive catch quotas, on certain
commercial fisheries. Both the fuel dependency and the
restrictive catch limitation have brought the Basque commercial
fishing industry to its survival limit. To examine the situation,
an energy audit methodology for fishing vessels has been
developed, with two objectives: a) to make shipowners aware of
the way fuel is consumed in their activities; b) help shipowners to
reduce their fuel bill. This contribution provides an overview of
the methodology, together with the steps undertaken for energy
audits. Three fishing vessels (a stern trawler, a live bait purse
seiner, and a troller have been studied, for developing this
methodology. The methodology uses a combination of
commercial tools, such as GESTOIL (an onboard fuel
consumption management system) to collect and assess data. The
energy audit has served to highlight the areas of major
consumption and potential savings; it provides also a list of
recommendations to shipowners, for changes in the operational
patterns of a ship. Likewise, structural changes to increase the
fuel efficiency of a vessel. In order to improve the efficiency of
future energy audits, the experience gained and the difficulties
undergone are presented.
Keywords: Energy audits, fishing vessels, energy consumption,
best practice, experience learned.
I.
INTRODUCTION
Three
Basque
fishing
vessels
were
audited,
comprehensively, during a year. The main details of the vessels
analysed are listed in Table 1. The fishing gears analysed are
representative of the main fishing gears used in the Basque
fishing fleet: a stern trawler, a troller, and a purse seiner
(operating with two fishing modalities: the purse seine and the
life bait purse seine).
TABLE 1. DETAILS OF THE VESSELS
Vessel 1
Fishing gear
Length
overall (m)
Length at
waterline
Displacement
(dwt)
Displacement
(GT)
Construction
year
Hull material
Trawling nets
Vessel 2
Purse seine and life
bait purse seine
Vessel 3
Trolling line*
39
37
25.9
33.4
30
20
239.1
149
66.4
432
231
84.2
2008
2004
1995
Steel
Steel
Steel
Base port
Ondarroa
Orio
Bermeo
Main engine
1030kW 8cyl.
800rpm
1060kW 16cyl.
1600rpm
3 of 1500 rpm:
3 of 1500rpm:
493 kW 12cyl.
1800rpm
2 of 1500rpm:
Auxiliary
engines
2 of 515kW,
1 of 59 kW,
a shaft generator
420kW,
170kW,
112kW
Crew size
11
Target
species
Mixed fisheries
15
Anchovy, mackerel,
horse-mackerel,
sardine (purse
seiner); Tuna (Life
bait p.s.)
Fishery
The Atlantic, A1
and A2 zones
The Atlantic,
VII-VIII zones
Fishing
period
Mid-Sept. until
mid-July
Summer and
autumn
Downtime
period
Beginning of
July until midSeptember
Mid-December until
mid-February
Mid-March
until beginning
of June
32kW,
20kW,
a shaft
generator
5
Tuna
*Vessel 3 combines three fishing modalities during a year: trolling line, gillnet
and vertical lines. In this contribution, only the results of the trolling line are
presented.
RESULTS
A. Performance indicators
Performance indicators are listed in Table 2. The detailed
report and results are available in [11]. An interesting indicator
in energy efficiency is the fuel use coefficient which provides
results in terms of litres of fuel consumed, per tonne of fish
landed [10, 12]. Vessel 3 is the smallest in dimension, capacity
and crew size amongst the three vessels. Purse seine is the most
efficient of all the fishing gear studied, since it presents the best
indicator in relation to the litres of fuel consumed, for the fish
landed, i.e. 98 L/t. Considering tuna as a target species, the
results indicate that trolling line and the life bait purse seine
present a similar energy performance indicator (1080L/t and
1136 L/t, respectively). Further whilst, purse seining for
pelagic species is the least energy-intensive of the three, the
trawling is the most energy-intensive. The most realistic
comparison would arise, however, when two vessels operating
in the same fisheries and using the same fishing gear are
compared. The results obtained are similar with the ones
presented in [10] for the same target species and gear used.
Regarding the fuel costs compared with the total costs of
the vessel, trolling is the one presenting the lowest ratio (15.3%
in comparison to the 30-40% for the other gears).
Purse seine
Trolling line
224
89
91
100
Mon-Sat (6 d/voyage)
0.8 day/voyage
15 days/voyage
20 day/voyage
841896
L/yr
Fuel
consumption
L/h
Vessel 3
Vessel 2
Main
66600
Aux.
Sail.
Fish.
Elec.
22.4 %
65.5%
178.4
162.2
L fuel/tn fish
landed
Main
135150
Aux.
Main
49751
Aux.
Main
Aux.
Sail.
Fish.
Elec.
Sail.
Fish.
Elec.
Sail.
Fish.
Elec.
9.3 %
68.9%
15.1%
16.0%
81.8%
5.3%
12.9%
58.4%
30.6%
11 %
87.46*
6.3*
102.5
5.5
35.89
21.70
1646 L/t
146 L/t
1080 L/t
1136 L/t
Average RPM
789
686
1083*
600*
1150
600
1000
1200
10.4
4.01
9.5*
0.9*
> 6.5
26.1
93.3
12.0*
1.7*
190
45
117
258
Income (/yr)
Fish landed (tonnes)
1550717
320830
429333
198268
511.5
455.8
125. 2
43.8
15.3%
fish in life bait purse seiners, and water pumps for the
condenser of refrigerators.
GROUP 3. Equipment/machinery for fishing. Equipment
onboard used for and during fishing and the management of the
catch, such as suction pumps, and the net winch.
GROUP 4.
Trawler
(%)
Purse
seiner
(%)
Life
bait
Purse
seiner
(%)
Trolling
line (%)
Navigation equipment/machinery
20,2
3,4
2,2
41,9
20,0
5,2
6,6
28,3
36,9
4,6
38,6
0,6
Accommodation
6,58
7,2
4,7
2,3
Lighting
5,07
16.3
16.9
3,9
Additional equipment/machinery
11,3
63.2
30.9
22,9
Vessel 1
L/yr
Return
saved
(yr)
Vessel 2
L/yr
Return
saved
(yr)
Vessel 3^
L/yr
Return
saved
(yr)
45.322
13954
337
3812
1.2
1647
1.9
3861
3.3
841
4,2
400
5.3
3242
1.5
792
3.1
16291
5660
1296
162653*
54974*
951*
360287*
115034*
3198*
c)
Improving
machinery
IV.
the
energy
consumption
of
auxiliary
Changing some of the lights to LED (Vessel 1 only all the 18W fluorescent lamps located in the
engine room; Vessel 2 and 3 - all interior 18W
fluorescent lamps): 55% saving.
RECOMMENDATION TO EFFICIENTLY AUDIT
FISHING VESSELS
A. Auditing process
The comprehensive analysis of the vessels, together with
the interactions with shipowners, skippers, chief engineers and
the particulars of the fishing seasons, have led to the
development of an energy audit methodology. This
methodology presents the steps of an energy audit in, a
structured manner. Likewise, it may assist auditors in reducing
the time to collect quality data and decrease the disturbance to
the crew and shipowner, during the audit.
The methodology is based upon the Spanish norm for
energy audits [16]; on published literature [4]; and on the
experience gained doing comprehensive energy audits. The
methodology is:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
7.
8.
9.
10. ENERGY EFFICIENT MEASURES. Several energyefficient measures will be formulated, to help to reduce
the energy demand of the vessel. The physical and
economic feasibility of each measure will be assessed
also from the data assessed.
11. FINAL REPORT. The Final Report will detail the energy
diagnosis of the vessel. The report will include: the goal
and scope of the audit; the methodology followed; and the
proposed energy efficient measures, for that particular
vessel and working conditions.
B. Additional recommendations
Several recommendations are proposed that can help in the
auditing process and the implementation of the energy-efficient
measures.
CONCLUSIONS
[5]
[6]
[7]
[12] P. Tyedmers, "Fisheries and Energy Use", C.J. Cleveland (ED), The
encyclopedia of energy, Academic Press/Elsevier Science, San Diego,
2004, pp. 683-693.
[13] IEA, "World Energy Outlook 2008", World Energy Outlook 20082008,
OECD/IEA: Paris. p. 578.
[14] R. Latorre, "Reducing fishing vessel fuel consumption and NOX
emissions", Ocean Engineering, 2001, 28(6):723-733.
[15] J.M. Torres Palenzuela, L. Gonzales Vilas, E. Spyrakos, L. Rodriguez
Dominguez, "Routing optimization using neural networks and
oceanographic models from remote sensing data", 1st International
Symposium on Fishing Vessel Energy Efficiency, 2010, Vigo, Spain.
[16] UNE, UNE 216501:2009 Auditoras Energticas, 2009, AENOR.
[17] R. Asariotis, "Climate change impatcs on international transportation
and adptation", Oral presentation at RiMER (Research in Marine
Environment and Resources), Donostia-San Sebastin, Spain, 31
January-10 February 2012.