Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Synthesis of Proposals and Recommendations From The Regional Forums (Basic Working Document For The Consultation)
Synthesis of Proposals and Recommendations From The Regional Forums (Basic Working Document For The Consultation)
Regional Forums
[Basic working document for the Consultation]
1. Introduction
Article 1 of the Constitution of the Republic of Uganda declares, All power belongs to
the people who shall exercise their sovereignty in accordance with this constitution. In
this regard, a credible electoral system is an essential foundation for citizens to exercise
their power and the means through which they determine who among them is qualified to
hold political office at all levels of governance. An electoral system is credible if it enjoys
the confidence of all citizens and creates a level playing field for all political actors who
seek to participate in elective politics. Most important, an electoral system is credible if it
creates conditions for free and fair elections.
Over the last 50 years of independence, Uganda has held at least 6 major elections (1962,
1980, 1996, 2001, 2006 and 2011) involving the election of president and members of the
parliament. In the recent past, elections have been held on a regular basis as commanded
by the constitution. However, in all these cases, both winners and losers contest election
outcomes. In many ways, elections are have increasingly become flashpoints for potential
conflicts and human rights abuses. The increasing monetization of elections also creates
more distortions in the elections process and have become a huge burden on taxpaying
citizens.
There is now general consensus that reforms of our electoral system are a fundamental
pre-requisite to a free and fair elections and the future stability of our country. However,
there has been clear absence of political will or lack of leadership to ensure that such
reforms are undertaken in a timely manner to improve our electoral system and help on
the management of future elections. The National Consultation was conceived as a
process to mobilize citizens so that We the People are in charge of driving both the
content and process of electoral reform.
2. Methodology of the Regional Forums
The National Consultation process builds on previous efforts towards the reform of our
electoral system. These include efforts by the Citizens Manifesto process, the Citizens
Coalition on Electoral Democracy in Uganda (CCEDU), the Electoral Commission, the
Interparty Political Organizations Dialogue (IPOD), the free and Fair Elections
Campaign, the National Consultative Forum (NCF) and Cabinet. The proposals from
these efforts were analyzed in their entirety and a guidance document containing 21
issues was produced to guide the regional forums. In addition, a set of questions was then
developed to guide the upcoming National Consultation (Annex 2).
In preparation for the National Consultation on Free and Fair Elections, 14 regional
forums were organized during the months of September and October 2014. The regions
were based on those that existed at the time of independence. These regions are: Toro,
Bukedi, Teso, Kigezi, Sebei, Busoga, Bunyoro, Ankole, Bugisu, Buganda West, Buganda
East, Lango, Achoil, Karamoja, West Nile. Over 3000 leaders including elected local
officials, Members of Parliament, business leaders, religious leaders, representatives of
civil society, women, youth and cultural institutions participated in the Regional Forums.
This synthesis report is an abridged summary of the proposals and recommendations
from all the 14 regional forums. Regional specific proposals can be found on the matrix
to this report or the separate reports for each of the regions.
The report is based on the proposals from these regional forums as presented in the
outcome documents. The purpose of the report is to guide deliberations at the National
Consultation. This purpose is served in two ways: first, the report outlines areas where
there is broad consensus on the 21 issues that guided the discussions at the regional
forums. Secondly, the report also highlights areas where there is no consensus from
across the regions. The objective is that the National Consultation can ratify the issues
where there is clear consensus. By implication, most of the time can directed towards
those issues where there is no consensus.
3. Proposals and recommendations from the Regional Forums
Issue # 1: Internal democracy of political parties
Article 71. Multiparty political system
A political party in the multiparty political system shall conform to the following
principles
(a) Every political party shall have a national character;
(b) Membership of a political party shall not be based on sex, ethnicity, religion or other
sectional division;
(c) The internal organisation of a political party shall conform to the democratic
principles enshrined in this Constitution;
(d) Members of the national organs of a political party shall be regularly elected from
citizens of Uganda in conformity with the provisions of paragraphs (a) and (b) of this
article and with due consideration for gender;
(e) Political parties shall be required by law to account for the sources and use of their
funds and assets;
All political parties should hold regular elections for all party
positions at the national and branch level.
A constitution of a political party should impose term limits on
its top leadership positions especially party chairpersons and
party presidents.
Disciplinary committees of political parties should be
established at all levels and should operate in a bottom-up
mode than a top-down mode.
Funding for political parties should be predicated upon the
party adhering to these fundamental principles on internal
democracy.
iv)
iii)
iv)
v)
ii)
iii)
v)
vi)
in the public service of Uganda other than those referred to in paragraph (a) of this clause
and in article 200 of this Constitution, including the confirmation of their appointments
and the exercise of disciplinary control over such persons and their removal from office.
(2) Except with the consent of the President, no person shall be appointed under this
article to act in any office on the personal staff of the President.
(3) Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the President may delegate any of his or
her powers under this article by directions in writing, to any service commission or to any
other authority or public officer as may be prescribed by Parliament and may, in like
manner, revoke the delegation.
iv)
ii)
iii)
A president should serve his or her term to the end and hand
over to a transitional arrangement led by Chief Justice or
ii)
iii)
The following issues emerge as the consensus from across the country:
i)
Local governments should receive their funding directly from the consolidated
fund as a percentage of the national budget. This will enhance their autonomy
and authority to deal with issues of service delivery.
ii)
iii)
Issue # 14: Requirement for public servants and serving officers of the security
services to retire before being nominated for office.
One of the major sources of post-election litigation is the question of resignation of
public servants or serving military officers. In some cases, concerns are often about
serving military officers who are denied the right to retire in order to contest for elections.
The following represents the measure of consensus from all the fourteen regional forums:
i)
Public servants and serving officers of the security services should resign their
positions before they are nominated to contest for electoral positions.
ii)
iii)
others.
(2) No person shall be compulsorily deprived of property or any interest in or right over
property of any description except where the following conditions are satisfied
(a) the taking of possession or acquisition is necessary for public use or in the interest of
defence, public safety, public order, public morality or public health; and
(b) the compulsory taking of possession or acquisition of property is made under a law
which makes provision for
(i) prompt payment of fair and adequate compensation, prior to the taking of possession
or acquisition of the property; and
(ii) a right of access to a court of law by any person who has an interest or right over the
property.
Since 2001, Government has proposed to amend reasons for compulsory acquisition to
include investment. Government also seeks to discriminate against land that does not
have permanent structures. In such cases, such land can be compulsorily acquired and
compensation can be made within one year after a citizen has been deprived of such land.
Government justification for this amendment is that it needs to be able to promote
economic development and create jobs.
The following points emerge as consensus from the regional reports.
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
v)
There is clear consensus on this issue that the age qualification for a
president should remain not less than 35 years and not more than 75
years.
Issue # 18: Tenure of Office of President
Article 105: Tenure of office of a President
(1) A person elected President under this Constitution shall, subject to clause (3) of this
article, hold office for a term of five years.
There is ongoing debate on the tenure of office of a president. Two issues are apparent in
this debate:
First the proposal to increase the term of office of the president from 5 years to 7
years.
A proposal to reintroduce a two-term limit on the number of terms a person can
be elected president.
i)
ii)
Presidential form of Government A presidential system is a republican system of government where a head of
government is also head of state and leads an executive branch that is separate from the legislative branch. The head of
state often is also the head of government, and most importantly: the executive branch does not derive its democratic
legitimacy from the legislature.
Parliamentary form of Government A parliamentary system is a system of democratic governance of a state in
which the executive branch derives its democratic legitimacy from, and is held accountable to,
the legislature (parliament); In a parliamentary system, the head of state is normally a different person from the head of
government. In a parliamentary system, by contrast, the legislature holds supreme power. The prime minister is chosen
by members of the legislature (Parliament) from among their own number and in practice is the leader of the majority
party in the legislature. The cabinet members must also belong to the legislature, where they are subject to the same
kind of questioning that the prime minister experiences. If the prime minister loses the support of the majority in the
legislature on a significant vote, he or she must resign, and elections are called immediately.
The main difference between a parliamentary and presidential system of government is that in a presidential system, the
president is separate from the legislative body, but in a parliamentary system, the chief executive, such as a prime
minister, is part of the legislative body, or parliament. A presidential system separates the executive and legislative
functions of the government and provides what are commonly called checks and balances to limit the power of both the
chief executive and the legislature. In a parliamentary system, the legislature holds the power, and the chief executive
must answer to the legislature. Another main difference is that in a presidential system, the chief executive and
members of the legislature are elected separately by the people, but in a parliamentary system, the legislature is elected
by the people and then must appoint or recommend for appointment one of its members to be the chief executive.
(1) The Electoral Commission shall ensure that elections are held at times fixed and
notified in advance to the public.
(2) No candidate in an election shall be denied reasonable access and use of State-owned
communication media.
(3) All presidential candidates shall be given equal time and space on the State-owned
media to present their programmes to the people.
(4) Parliament shall make laws regulating the use of public resources and institutions
during election campaigns.
Group 1: PURPLE
Issue # 1: Internal democracy of political parties
Issue # 2: Independent candidates/Independent MPs
Issue # 3: Relationship between Citizens and their MPs and
political parties
Issue # 4: Representation of special interest groups
Issue # 5: Demarcation of constituencies and the number of
Members of Parliament
How do we guarantee this citizens compact
Group 2: BROWN
Issue # 6: The need for a new and independent electoral
commission
Issue # 7: Getting our votes counted- The Voters Register
Issue # 8: Powers of appointment to Constitutional Commission
Issue # 9: Votes required for a winner of a presidential election to be declared
president.
Issue # 10: Role of security forces and militia groups in the
electoral process
How do we guarantee this citizens compact
Group 3: PINK
Issue # 11: Nomination fees and facilitation of presidential
candidates