Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Blood Pressure Variability
Blood Pressure Variability
INTRODUCTION
The World Health Organization (WHO) has reported that an estimated 17 million
people die from cardiovascular diseases (CVD) each year (WHO Fact Sheet, 2001).
Coronary artery disease (CAD) continues to be one of the most common chronic
illnesses in most of the developed world (DAgostino et al., 2000). In Malaysia, heart
diseases were reported to be the number one cause of death from 1988 till 1997
(Southeast Asian Medical Information Centre/International Medical Foundation of
Japan [SEAMIC/IMFJ] Health Statistic, 1999) . In 1998, ischemic heart disease was
accounted for causing the highest mortality rate in Malaysia (8.89/100,000 population)
and was followed closely by cerebro-vascular disease (8.06/100,000 population). It
has been estimated that by the year 2020, there will be a tremendous change in the
disease patterns and demography and that CVD will be the main cause of death in the
developing countries and will remain so in the developed countries (Murray and
Lopez, 1997).
and transient myocardial ischaemia (Parker et al., 1994) tend to occur during the
morning waking hours as compared with the other times of the day. In the case of
acute myocardial infarction, earlier studies have described a circadian periodicity on
the onset of chest pain, based on the subjective reports by the patients (Pell and
DAlonzo, 1963; Thompson et al., 1985).
This observation is
supported by other reports (Willich et al., 1988). The incidence of acute myocardial
infarction documented from the onset of pain between 6 AM and noon was 1.28 times
greater than the other three six-hour intervals period while the incidence of acute
myocardial infarction confirmed enzymatically was 1.43 times greater between 6 AM
and noon than the other period of the day. The circadian periodicity of the incidence
of stroke has also been reported (Marler et al., 1989).
The reasons for the surge of these events in the early morning hours have not
been confirmed but it is generally known that humans possess an internal time clock
that regulates multiple physiologic factors (chronobiology).
It had been
acknowledged in late 1970 that the blood pressure (BP) together with the heart rate
surge soon after a patient awakens and commences activity, with a clearly
demonstrated trough at night (Craig et al., 1978).
wakefulness rather than to the time of day. This was illustrated by one study where
the BP rhythm followed the inverted cycle of activity in night-shift workers (Sundberg
et al., 1988). BP varies by about 50-60 mmHg over a 24-hour period (Mancia et al.,
1983). The mean BP falls by about 10%-20% from waking to sleeping (Staessen et
al., 1991).
Blood pressure fluctuations or variability (BPV) is closely related to the
average level of BP, being greatest when pressure is high (Mancia et al., 1983) . In
patients with essential hypertension, the diurnal rhythm and the nocturnal fall in BP
are preserved (Mancia et al., 1983; Staessen et al., 1991) , the pattern being similar to
that of normotensive except that it is shifted upwards (Pickering, 1990a).
The nocturnal fall in BP (which is arbitrarily defined as BP reduction equal or
greater than 10% of average daytime values) has been reported to be impaired in a
number of other conditions such as ageing, snoring, obstructive apnea syndrome and
secondary hypertension namely renovascular hypertension, phaeochromocytoma and
Cushings syndrome (Coca, 1994).
1.2.1
The factors affecting BP variability are age, sex, physical activity, mental activity,
behavioural and environmental (Coca, 1994).
1.2.1.1
Age
BPV is reported to correlate with age. Elderly subjects tend to have higher BPV as
compared to the younger ones (Sander et al., 2000). This may be partly explained by
the diminished baroreflex sensitivity associated with increased arterial stiffness due to
aging (Tank et al., 2000). Analysis of subjects by age groups also revealed that the BP
level and age independently affected BPV (Sander et al., 2000).
1.2.1.2
Sex
There have been contradictory reports regarding the BPV among sex distribution. In
analyzing ambulatory BP recordings from 354 adolescents (age ranging from 7.2 30.9 years old) with type I Diabetes Mellitus, the BPV was found to be higher in male
compared to the female (Reinhard et al., 1999). In contrast, a community based study
in Japan where the age ranges from 20 to 70 years old, the result was otherwise (Imai
et al., 1997). Another study on atherosclerosis which involved the elderly (subjects of
55 years and above), found no differences among gender (Sander et al., 2000).
1.2.1.3
Physical Activity
The mean level of both ambulatory BP and BPV decrease during rest (Pickering,
1990b). Physical activity has been shown to affect BP such as changing of posture
from lying to the sitting or standing causes a change in both systolic and diastolic BP
(Ghione et al., 1993). Dynamic and static exercises are also known causes. Specific
form of exercise such as sexual intercourse can produce a dramatic transient rise in
both systolic and diastolic BP, but these changes are reversed within a few minutes.
1.2.1.4
Mental Activity
1.2.1.5
Behavioral factor such as smoking has been shown to affect BP. In epidemiological
study, the mean BP of smokers when measured casually in the clinic is the same or
lower than the non-smokers (Green et al., 1986).
Ambulatory BP measurement
however showed otherwise. Cellina et al., (1975) reported that smoking increases
about 11 mmHg systolic and 5 mmHg diastolic within a few minutes and lasting for
about 15 minutes in both normotensives and hypertensives. Mann et al., (1991)
showed that in hypertensive patients, smoker with the same clinic BP as the nonsmoker has a significantly higher mean BP than the non-smoker when measured by
using ambulatory BP measurement.
Alcohol intake also increases the BP in both normotensive (Malhotra et al.,
1985) and hypertensive (Potter et al., 1986). The pressor effect of alcohol account for
an average increase of 5 mmHg in both systolic and diastolic 24 hour BP values
(Aguilera et al., 1994). Conflicting results have been reported by the few studies on
dietary sodium intake, with some authors reporting BP variations with a high salt
intake (Richard et al., 1984), but not others (Pickering, 1990b).
1.2.2
However, it is still not clear whether the BPV is the cause or the result of the CVD
process. Hence it is important to understand BPV and the factors regulating it.
1.3.1
1.3.1.1
The cardiovascular center or the vasomotor center is responsible for transmitting both
parasympathetic and sympathetic impulses.
transmitted from the center mainly to the heart through vagal nerves whereas the
sympathetic impulses travel through the cord to almost all the blood vessels in the
human body. This neurogenic control of both the heart and the vessels is important in
maintaining normal BP.
The cardiovascular center is located at the reticular substance of medulla
oblongata. This center regulates the heart rate and contractility of the heart, the
diameter of the blood vessels and integrates impulses received from higher center
(hypothalamic and limbic system). It consists of three centres; the cardio acceleratory
centre (CAC), the cardio inhibitory centre (CIC) and sensory centre. The neurons of
the CAC secrete norepinephrine where they excite the vasoconstrictor neurons of the
sympathetic nervous system. The cardio inhibitory neurons on the other hand have
fibers that project to the CAC. The CIC on receiving impulses will inhibit CAC thus
blocking the vasoconstriction effect resulting in vasodilatation.
transmits inhibitory impulses to the heart via parasympathetic nerve. The third centre,
which is the sensory centre, is located at the nucleus tractus solitarius, which receives
signals from the vagal and glossopharyngeal nerves and gives output to control the
activities of both the CAC and CIC. In low BP condition, the CAC is stimulated with
reciprocal inhibition of the parasympathetic vagal signals to the heart. As a result,
arteries constrict and lead to increase total peripheral resistance. The large veins
constriction will displace the peripheral blood volume towards the heart increasing
venous return, hence the cardiac output, and the increase in both heart rate and
contractile force of the heart muscles. These changes will lead to increase in BP
(Guyton and Hall, 1996).
1.3.1.2
Exaggerated sympathetic activities had been associated with CVD namely the diabetes
(Liao et al., 1995), hypertension (Pikkujamsa et al., 1998; Mancia et al., 1999) and
congestive heart failure (Grassi et al., 1995).
hypertrophy has also been shown to depend not only on BP but also on the reduction
of cardiac sympathetic drive (Morgan and Baker, 1991). Microneurographic approach
has allowed sympathetic nerve traffic to be recorded which showed an increase in
sympathetic burst over time in subjects with family history of hypertension (Yamada
et al., 1988), in hypertensives (Mark, 1996; Floras et al., 1993; Anderson et al., 1988),
in isolated systolic hypertension (Grassi et al., 1999) as well as in pregnancy induced
hypertension (Greenwood et al., 1988).
10
day such as lying down, standing, excitement, eating and noises cause extreme
variability in BP (Cowley et al., 1974). Furthermore, the ability to maintain BP in
response to a challenge such as hemorrhage is markedly reduced following sino-aortic
denervation (Trasher and Keil, 1998).
11
in lethal condition. Its function is minimal in our normal day to day BP regulation
(Guyton and Hall, 1996).
1.3.2
1.3.2.1
12
13
Table 1.1
Differential Effects Mediated by AT1 and AT2 Receptors
AT1 Receptor
AT2 receptor
Vasoconstriction
Vasodilation
(Neuronal) regeneration
Cell differentiation
Cardiac hypertrophy
Apoptosis
Cardiac contractility
Augmentation of peripheral
noradrenergic activity
Central osmocontrol
1.3.2.2
(Muirhead, 1993).
1.3.3
14
The endothelial cells lining the vasculature, apart from serving as a diffusion barrier
for solute and fluid exchange, are involved in regulation of vascular function through
the production of various substances. Cell membrane receptors and membrane bound
ectoenzymes respond to circulating ligands such as substance P, leukotriene, insulin,
thrombin and physical signals such as shear stress, which lead to the activation of
vasodilator and vasoconstrictor substances. Examples of vasodilators are nitric oxide
(NO) and prostacyclin (PGI2), and examples of vasoconstrictors are endothelin (ET)
and thromboxane (Zimmerman, 1997).
NO is a highly reactive free radical that play a major role in the cardiovascular,
pulmonary, gastrointestinal, immune, and central nervous systems (Kuo and
Schroeder, 1995). In addition, deranged NO synthesis is the basis for a number of
pathophysiologic states, such as atherosclerosis, pulmonary hypertension and
hypertension associated with renal failure. It is currently accepted that NO is the
major physiological regulator of basal blood vessel tone. NO is released continuously
by the arterial circulation. Vasodilatory agents such as acetylcholine and bradykinin
act on endothelial cell-surface receptors to trigger NO release and stimulate soluble
guanylyl cyclase, resulting in protein kinase-dependent relaxation of vascular smooth
muscle. In the absence of endothelium, these stimuli lose their vasodilatory properties
(Marletta et al., 1988).
In renal arteriolar regulation, it is suggested that NO plays a role in renin
release and sodium and water homeostasis, thus NO plays the key role in intravascular
volume and vascular tone (Marsden and Brenner, 1991). NO also modulates platelet
adhesion and aggregation, leukocyte adhesion, endothelin generation, plasminogen
activator enzymatic function, and vascular smooth muscle proliferation (Nathan,
1992).
15
development of atherosclerosis.
Vasodilatation is also
ET
infusions reduce renal blood flow and glomerular filtration rate by constricting both
preglomerular and efferent arterioles and eliciting a decrease in the glomerular
filtration rate (Navar et al., 1996).
16
Figure 1.1. Acute regulatory mechanisms act primarily by altering the total peripheral
resistance and cardiovascular haemodynamics and are mostly concerned with the
nervous system.
In contrast, mechanisms over the long term are linked to regulation of sodium
balance and ECF volume, which are involved with the role of kidneys. While the role
of nervous system and kidney are quite well established in regulation of BP and the
pathophysiology of hypertension, evidences suggesting that humoral mechanisms are
responsible for maintaining the high BP are still a matter of debate.
LDL Cholesterol
Ang II
Norepinephrine
Hyperinsulinemia
Diabetes Mellitus
NO
Smoking
Endothelial dysfunction
Fibrinonectin and
collagen
deposition
Smooth Muscle
Cell Migration
and Proliferation
Clotting
Platelet and
lymphocytes
adhesion
Lipid deposition
in media
potentiates
Hypertension/Shear stress
17
Atherosclerosis
18
1.3.3.3 Eicosanoids
Eicosanoids are biologically active products of arachidonic acid that are synthesized
in a variety of tissues and released to act locally on the vasculature. The products of
this cascade exert both vasoconstrictor and vasodilator effects (Chatziantoniou and
Arendshorst, 1993). Prostaglandins which are formed via cyclooxygenase pathway
act as vasodilators via stimulation of adenylate cyclase and cyclic adenosine
monophosphate (cAMP).
19
At
20
ANG II. (Margolius, 1996). Increased activity of the kallikrein-kinin system occurs in
conditions of sodium depletion, indicating that it serves as a mechanism to reduce the
effects of enhanced angiotensin II levels (Mombouli and Vanhoutte, 1995).
The BP regulation involves many interactions among the various neural,
hormonal, and paracrine mechanisms regulating cardiovascular and renal function.
This understandably gives rise to problems in managing hypertension. In particular,
short-term changes in BP are caused by a numerous mechanisms that affect cardiac
output, total peripheral resistance, and cardiovascular capacitance. This is mainly by
the nervous system mechanism.
In the long term, however, most of these actions can be buffered or
compensated by appropriate renal adjustments of sodium balance, extracellular (EC)
fluid volume (through dietary intake, insensible loss and urinary excretion) and blood
volume. These renal adjustments are influenced by the RAAS and other kidney
mediated neurohormones. The interaction of these various mechanisms in blood
pressure regulation is shown in Figure 1.2.
1.4.1
21
Dietary intake
Insensible loss
Urinary excretion
Neurohumoral systems
ECF
Blood pressure
Mean arterial
pressure
Venous
return
Cardiac output
Total peripheral
resistance
Vascular capacitance
22
1.4.1.1.1
To perform the conduit function effectively, large arteries need to deliver the amount
of blood from the heart to the peripheral tissues, as determined by the metabolic
activities in the tissues. A continuous, steady and effectively constant flow of blood is
required in the arteriolar systems to ensure efficient metabolic exchange. To maintain
such a steady flow, a constant pressure head (represented by mean arterial pressure)
must be applied to overcome resistance to flow caused by blood viscosity and friction.
For a given cardiac output, mean arterial pressure is determined by the cross-sectional
area and the number of arterioles and arteries. This represents peripheral vascular
resistance.
resistance resulting from a reduction in the caliber of arterioles and small arteries.
From a hemodynamic point of view, therefore, the conduit function of large arteries is
23
dependent on mean arterial pressure, blood flow and the relation between them
(London and Guerin, 1999).
1.4.1.1.2
The principal role of arteries as cushions is to dampen the pressure oscillations that are
caused by the intermittent nature of ventricular ejection (Nichols and ORourke,
1991). The efficiency of this cushioning function is determined by the viscoelastic
properties of the arterial walls described in terms of compliance, distensibility or
stiffness. In performing the cushioning function, the arterial system is able to directly
accommodate the entire volume of blood ejected from the heart during systole.
Arteries store part of the stroke volume during systolic ejection and drain it during
diastole. This so called Windkessel function thus transforms the pulsatile flow of
central arteries into the steady flow required in the peripheral tissues.
1.4.2
Arterial compliance is defined as the change of volume for a given change in pressure.
It is one of the properties that characterize the pulsatile behaviour of the vasculature,
besides the pulse pressure. It is also the reverse of arterial stiffness.
Arterial compliance is vital for an artery to perform the cushioning effect.
This effect simply means that the arteries dampen the pressure oscillations that are
caused by the intermittent nature of the ventricular contraction.
By acting as a
cushion, the arterial system is able to accommodate the entire blood volume ejected
from the heart during systole. The arteries store part of the stroke volume during
systolic ejection and drain it during diastole. To understand the mechanism of arterial
compliance measurement, the Windkessel theory assumes the circulation in two ways.
24
The large arteries which have the property of elasticity are the central reservoirs, into
which the heart pumps and from which blood travels. The elasticity of the proximal
large arteries is the result of the high elastin to collagen ratio in their walls, which
progressively declines towards the peripheries. From these elastic reservoirs, the
blood travels through the peripheral arteries which act as the non-elastic conduits to
tissues. Some researchers (Cohn et al., 1995; Izzo et al., 2001), refer to the aorta and
its major branches as large arteries. This is to differentiate from the more muscular
conduit arteries, such as the radial and brachial, and the smaller predominantly
muscular peripheral arteries. The elasticity of a given arterial segment depends on its
distending pressure. As the distending pressure increases, there is a reduction of
elasticity as there is greater involvement of the relatively inelastic collagen fibers.
This distending pressure in circulation is determined by the mean arterial pressure.
Mean arterial pressure is taken into account in arterial stiffness measurement to
differentiate the anticipated effects of distending pressure from the real differences in
the arterial wall elasticity.
In normal physiological condition, ejection of blood from the left ventricle
during systole initiates an arterial wave that travels toward the periphery. At the site
where impedance mismatches take place, mainly at the high resistance arterioles,
wave reflections occur. Due to the differences in elastic qualities as well as wave
reflection, the shape of the arterial waveform varies throughout the arterial tree. This
shape is formed by the systolic and diastolic pressure waves (refer figure 1.3). In the
large compliance arteries, the initial systolic pressure (P 1) travels from the heart to
periphery forming peak SBP. Reflected pressure waves (P 2) arrive at central aorta in
diastole, augmenting DBP and increasing the coronary artery perfusion. Increased
arterial stiffness causes the pressure waves to travel faster. Also being termed as
25
increasing pulse wave velocity, this causes the pressure waves to arrive at the
peripheral circulation earlier and to be reflected earlier. The reflected waves, instead
of augmenting DBP now augments SBP that result in increasing left ventricular
workload as well as compromising the coronary artery blood flow.
The information held within the waveforms of the proximal aorta is of
interest because the blood pressure at this site, rather than peripherally determines the
left ventricular load and coronary artery blood flow. However, peripheral blood
pressure measurement is more common in the majority of methodologies used.
Recently, techniques based on the determination of a pressure transfer function
between the radial artery and the aorta has been used to provide an estimate of central
pressure wave reflection (Karamanoglu et al., 1995).
Figure 1.3. The shapes of arterial waveforms differ from one artery to another.
Adapted with permission from Cohn, 1999.
26
1.4.3
The composition of blood vessels influences the compliance of the vessel wall (Cox,
1981; Liu et al., 1989). With ageing and hypertension, the arteries stiffen as a result of
degeneration of arterial media with fractures and fragmentation of elastic lamellae,
increased collagen and calcium content, and dilation and hypertrophy of large arteries
and the aorta (ORourke, 1982). This concept takes into account the relation between
structure and mechanics of the vessel wall in terms of the elastic modular of individual
wall components. Apart from the collagen and elastin, arterial wall elasticity is also
influenced by endothelium (Kinlay et al., 2001), arterial wall smooth muscle bulk and
tone (Bank et al., 1996; 1999), endothelin receptor gene (Lajemi et al., 2001a) and AT2
receptor (Lajemi et al., 2001b). The functional and structural modifications to the
arterial wall have important effects on the cardiovascular system by increasing the
incidence of fracture, rupture and aneurysm formation and the development of
atherosclerosis. Following these changes, compliance is reduced, the systolic and
pulse pressure increase. These cause fatigue of arterial walls, accelerating arterial
damage, thus feeding the vicious cycle.
1.4.4
Age dependent decline in large and small arteries compliances, reflecting structural or
functional changes has been demonstrated (McVeigh et al., 1999). In disease states
such as hypertension, diabetes and atherosclerosis, the reduction in the compliance is
prominent at the smaller vessel level in arteries sensitive to NO release (Cohn et al.,
1995). Compliance reduction in disease states is a marker for the early stages of
vascular diseases and may explain the underlying pathology of BPV.
1.5 RISK FACTORS IN CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES
27
Clinicians and health authorities for many years have expressed interest in methods of
identifying individuals who are at increase risk of CAD.
1.5.1
It has been well established that risk factors tend to cluster in individuals. When these
risk factors coexist, the impact on CAD is greater than additive, and is usually
multiplicative. The current trend which is towards a more holistic approach in CAD
risk evaluation and preventive management has led to the development of several new
guidelines.
2000), the New Zealand Guidelines on the management of mild hypertension (New
Zealand Guidelines Group, 1994) and the Oslo Diet Heart Study (Samuelsson et al.,
28
1987) are examples of these guidelines which apply simple methods of evaluating
absolute risk based on consideration of several risk factors.
Risk factors in an
individual are therefore becoming essential to be identified and should be taken into
consideration in patients management.
1.5.2
Essential Hypertension
Though hypertension has been known for over a century, its pathophysiology and
management remain a problem. It remains to be the major reversible risk factor for
CVD and renal failure. An analysis of the Modification of Diet in Renal Disease
study (Lazarus et al., 1997) revealed that for each 1 mmHg increase in mean arterial
pressure, there is an associated 35% increase in CVD. For each 5 mmHg increase,
there is an associated increase of 3% in left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH). There is
substantial evidence documenting the linear relationship between the degree of
hypertension and the risk for cardiovascular and renal diseases in all populations
(Wilson and Culleton, 1998). The prevalence of hypertension end organ damage
differs in different areas.
hypertension, mortality rates of ischaemic heart disease are high (Jones, 1995)
whereas in East Asean countries, stroke is the leading cause of death among
hypertensive communities.
In Malaysia, it was reported that the proportion of death due to cardiovascular
disease has multiplied more than three-fold since 1965 (Khor, 1994).
A high
29
found to be hypertensive with 16.8% of them from urban areas compared to 12.3%
from rural areas. Recent report from The Second National Health and Morbidity
Survey estimated that the overall prevalence of hypertension among adults in
Malaysia is 29.9 % in 1996. This figure comprised 14.0 % of the self-reported
hypertension and 15.9 per cent of undiagnosed hypertension.
Meta-analysis of recent studies that have examined the impact of
hypertension showed that there was a success in decreasing the incidence of stroke
(MacMahon et al., 1986).
incidence of CAD (Samuelsson et al., 1987; Grimm et al., 1990). This raised the
questions of whether considering a measurement of 140/90 mmHg to represent
adequately controlled BP is sufficient, for if this criterion is taken, only one quarter of
hypertensive patients are being adequately treated (American Heart Association,
2000). Furthermore, when patients with treated and controlled hypertension were
compared with normotensive subjects with similar levels of BP, there was still an
approximately 30% higher incidence of CAD among hypertensive patients (Havlik, et
al. 1989). It appears that in addition to the inadequate BP control, an important reason
for inadequate impact on the incidence of CAD is that there may be multiple features
of hypertension, of which high BP is only one of them. Could BPV be another
element in hypertension and is it also a feature in hypertensive Malaysian population?
30
1.5.3
It has been recognized for years that diabetic patients have two to three fold increased
risk for CVD as compared with their non-diabetic counterparts (Kannel et al., 1979).
Much of the morbidity and mortality associated with diabetes mellitus (DM) is
attributable to the macrovascular and microvascular complications of the disease.
Diabetics are at increased risk of all cardiovascular events including stoke, recurrent
hospitalization for myocardial infarct or unstable angina and heart failure.
The prevalence of hypertension in diabetics is at least two fold greater when
compared to the non-diabetic population (National Centre of Health Statistic, 1981).
The prevalence of complications is also greater in diabetics with hypertension than
those who are normotensives. The advent of 24 hour ABPM has triggered a lot of
studies trying to identify the BP load in diabetics that can lead to covert nephropathy.
Hansen et al., (1992) used ABPM to study circadian variation of BP in subjects with
type I DM. The authors found a trend to progressive loss of nocturnal BP reduction as
albuminuria increased from normoalbuminuria to microalbuminuria and on to overt
nephropathy when compared with healthy control subjects. However, despite the
trend, the difference between control and normoalbuminuric subjects did not reach
statistically significant level. Lurbe et al., (1993) on the other hand found a significant
nocturnal BP blunting in type 1 adolescent DM patients and his finding was supported
by others (Gilbert et al., 1994).
More recent studies have looked into the 24 hours overall mean BP and BPV.
Mitchell et al., (1997) observed that in microalbuminuric type II DM subjects, the 24
hours and daytime systolic BP were significantly higher than controls and this was
supported by earlier studies (White, 1992). Mc Kinlay et al., (1994) found that there
was increased systolic BPV in the type II DM subjects during the day but the
31
difference for diastolic BPV was not significant. The day and night ratio for systolic
BP, diastolic BP, heart rate and heart rate variability were the same in both patients
and controls. Combe et al., (1993) on the other hand found that the systolic BPV and
diastolic BPV were significantly increased among the type II DM subjects with
cardiac autonomic neuropathy as compared to the controls. However, the studies did
not take into account other risk factors as the diabetic in their subjects were not
controlled for BP or lipid profile. The aim of this study is therefore to see the effect of
hyperglycemia on BPV with as minimal influence as possible from other
cardiovascular risk factors.
1.5.4
Hyperlipidaemia
Hyperlipidaemia also increases the risk of CAD and atherosclerotic disease in other
vessels. The role of elevated concentrations of serum cholesterol in the pathogenesis
of atherosclerosis is well established based on human studies (Verschuren et al., 1995;
Kannel et al., 1979), animal experiment (Schwartz, 1991) and clinical pathological
observation (Newman et al., 1986). In the Framingham Study, the total cholesterol
level was found to be independent and statistically significant in relation to the rate of
CHD in young men, young and older women (Castelli, 1988).
Since lipoproteins are the principal carriers of cholesterol in the blood,
intensive investigation was initiated on lipoprotein metabolism. LDL levels were
found to be the lipoprotein most highly correlated with CAD. The Lipid Research
Clinics Prevalence Study (Pekkanen et al., 1990) demonstrated in a 10-year follow up
that LDL cholesterol was strongly associated with CAD in men with or without CAD
at the time of entry into the study. On the other hand the results of 5 randomized
clinical trials involving hydroxymethylglutaryl coenzyme A (HMG-CoA) reductase
32
inhibitors (statin) therapy, had provided evidence that treatment with simvastatin,
pravastatin or lovastatin resulted in reduction of total cholesterol by 20-25% and LDL
by 25-35% and further decreasing event of CAD (Downs et al., 1998; LIPID Study
Group, 1998; Sacks et al., 1996; Scandinavian Simvastatin Survival Study Group,
1994; Shepherd et al., 1995).
It is however debatable as to whether the assessment of LDL or total
cholesterol alone is sufficient and accurate to identify an individual at risk for
myocardial infarction. HDL is the lipoprotein that has an anti atherogenic effect since
it lacks apo-B. HDL confers protection against atherosclerotic CVD and an inverse
relationship between HDL cholesterol and CAD has been established in several
studies (Castelli et al., 1986; Stampfer et al., 1991).
The growing importance of HDL as a predictor of CAD was supported by the
findings in the 26 year follow up Framingham study where 20% of patients with
myocardial infarctions had their cholesterol levels lower than 5.17 mmol/L (200
mg/dl), levels considered safe according to most guidelines. Most of the patients who
had myocardial infarctions at low total cholesterol levels had HDL lower than 0.91
mmol/L (35 mg/dl) emphasizing the importance of the total-to-HDL cholesterol ratio
in determining the atherogenic potential of blood lipids.
increases with the total-to-HDL cholesterol ratio (Castelli, 1988). In the Prospective
Cardiovascular Mnster (PROCAM) study population, patients who had total-to-HDL
cholesterol ratio of less than 5.0 had an incidence of myocardial infarction of 17.3%
over 10 years.
This incidence was greater than that seen in patients with high
triglyceride or LDL cholesterol (Assmann, 2001). This ratio was also found to be a
better predictor of CAD than total cholesterol, LDL, HDL and triglyceride in
Physicians Health Study (Stampfer et al., 1991) and other studies (Grover et al.,
33
1995; Kinosian et al., 1994). Because of the important influence of HDL cholesterol
at even moderate levels of serum total or LDL cholesterol, the total-to-HDL
cholesterol ratio is probably the best guide for therapy with treatment best instituted at
ratios more than 5.0, irrespective of the serum total or LDL cholesterol level (Kannel,
1995). Asmar et al., (1992) had found that patients with and without plasma lipid
abnormality displayed similar 24-hour mean ambulatory BP. However there is no
reported study to evaluate if there is a difference in BPV in hyperlipidemic group (as
defined by total-to-HDL cholesterol less than 5.0) compare to those with normal
serum lipid.
1.5.5
34
et al., 1992; Safar et al., 1987) and increased neuroendocrine hormone such as plasma
insulin, norepinehrine and plasma renin activity (Neutel et al., 1992).
Is BPV then part of the complex inherited syndrome? Ravogli et al., (1990)
has revealed that normotensive subjects with parental hypertension manifested a
significantly higher 24-hour mean ambulatory BP as compared to those without family
history. The subjects with family history were further dichotomized into those having
both parents with hypertension and those with only single parent with hypertension.
The systolic clinic BP, the mean 24-hour systolic BP, the mean of 24-hour mean
arterial pressure and the left ventricular mass index were always and significantly
higher in those with both parents hypertensive as compared to the normal controls. In
those with one parent hypertensive, only the clinic diastolic and mean arterial pressure
showed significantly higher value than the normal controls.
No difference was
observed with regards to 24 hour mean ambulatory BP in the group where both
parents were hypertensives and those with only a single parent with hypertension.
The study also demonstrated no difference in BP reaction to mental stress tests.
As far as BPV is concern, there have been contradictory results by previous
studies. Manuck et al., (1996) found that there was no difference with regards to BP
reactivity due to mental stress test in subjects with FHT and the matched control.
However, Lemne, (1998) found otherwise. The study showed that even a rather mild
level of heredity for hypertension leads to increase BPV, in particular 24-hour and
daytime systolic BPV apart from increased in BP reactivity to mental stress tests.
35
1.5.6
Hyperuricaemia
In recent years, several new clinical and epidemiological studies have examined the
importance of uric acid as a possible independent cardiovascular risk factor. Several
prospective studies have shown an association between hyperuricaemia and incidence
of coronary heart disease, CVD and death (Brand et al., 1985; Freedman et al., 1995;
Levine et al., 1989; Yano et al., 1984; Lehto et al., 1998; Wannamethee et al., 1997).
Despite the strength of these associations, uric acid has not been established as
a causal risk factor for CVD. Instead, uric acid seems to be linked to hypertension,
dyslipidaemia and disordered glucose metabolism. Several recent reports however
have attempted to dispel this notion. In the Framingham Study, the uric acid values
measured at the fourth biennial examination had predicted the subsequent
development of coronary heart disease in general, and myocardial infarction in
particular (Brand et al., 1985).
equally strong in both sexes even after correcting for antihypertensive treatment. The
association however was not significant when diastolic BP and blood cholesterol were
adjusted for. Freedman and colleagues (Freedman et al., 1995) on the other hand
demonstrated that each 60 mol/L increment in uric acid level was associated with a
48% increase in the risk for ischemic heart disease among women. Furthermore, a
growing body of laboratory and clinical evidence suggest that uric acid plays a role in
platelet adhesiveness (Emmerson, 1979; Ginsberg et al., 1977), formation of free
radicals (Vasquez-Vivar et al., 1996) and oxidative stress (Anker et al., 1997; Leyva et
al., 1998).
The potential mechanisms whereby uric acid could contribute to the
pathogenesis of hypertension and cardiovascular end organ damage are also
investigated, though the data are still lacking. A large body of evidence links uric acid
36
Clinically,
hyperuricaemia occurs during interruption of limb arterial flow (Friedl et al., 1990),
after coronary angioplasty (Huizer et al., 1989), during coronary artery bypass surgery
(Lazzarino et al., 1994) and in other hypoxic states (Sahebjani, 1998; Hayabuchi et al.,
1993).
The relationships between hyperuricaemia and BPV as well as arterial
compliance have not so far been reported.
1.5.7
Cigarette Smoking
The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that 25% of deaths from CVD at
age 35 to 69 years are attributable to tobacco (World Health Organization, 1999).
Throughout the world, it is estimated that one third of the worlds adult population are
smokers. Death from all tobacco related diseases worldwide are estimated to be 4
million annually and rising (World Health Organization, 1996).
Although the
prevalence of smoking has declined in western countries in recent decades, there has
been a marked increase in tobacco use in less developed countries, with the prevalence
of smoking rising 3.4 % per year (World Health Organization, 1999). In Malaysia,
cigarette smoking accounts for 25% of all death. In 1996, it was reported that the
smoking prevalence was 24.8% among Malaysians over the age of 18 years. There
37
was an increase of 3.3% compared to the previous survey in 1986 (Ministry of Health,
National Health and Morbidity Survey, 1996).
Cigarette smoking is a major risk factor in the development of atherosclerosis
and coronary events. Previous studies have shown that smoking induces immediate
constriction of epicardial coronary arteries and an increase in coronary resistance tone
(Moliternao et al., 1994; Maouad et al., 1986). Kiowski, et al., (1994) showed that
long term smoking is associated with impairment of endothelium dependent
vasodilator response while the short term smoking enhances endothelin-1-induced
vasoconstriction.
38
however, Mann et al., (1991) reported that the awake ambulatory systolic BP of
smokers was significantly higher than that of non smokers. The awake diastolic BP,
the sleep systolic and diastolic ambulatory BP were not affected by smoking status.
These findings were supported by others (Poulsen et al., 1998; Benowitz et al., 1984).
There has been however very limited data on the effect of smoking on BPV.
39