Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Accidental Project Managers Not A Myth in The Public Sector PDF
Accidental Project Managers Not A Myth in The Public Sector PDF
Manyindividualsfindthemselvesundertakingprojectmanagementresponsibilitieswithlittleorno
preparation.Referredtoasaccidentalprojectmanagers,theyhavenotrainingorexperienceandmust
oftenmanageprojectsfromthesideoftheirdesks.
ResearchersVanessaDarrell,ofWesternAustraliasdepartmentoftreasuryandfinance,andDavid
BaccariniandPeterE.D.LoveofCurtinUniversityofTechnologyinPerth,Australiawerecurioustoknow
moreaboutaccidentalprojectmanagers,particularlyinthepublicsector.
Theresearchersnoticedasurginginterestinprojectmanagementinthepublicsector,notingthatthere
isagrowingneedforgovernmentdepartmentstobecomemoreresponsivetochange,andthattheyare
increasinglyrecognizingthattheprojectisanadaptableformofworkorganization.
Butunliketraditionalprojectbasedindustries,suchasaerospaceandconstruction,whichuse
professionalprojectmanagers,thepublicsectorisappointinguntrainedstafferstomanageprojects
wheneverthereisanunexpectedneedforprojectmanagement.
Theresearcherscoinedthetermaccidentalprojectmanagertoillustratethetrialbyfirenatureof
theirintroductiontoprojectmanagement.
Sinceprojectmanagersneedtohaveacomprehensiveunderstandingofpeople,thetaskandtools,and
theorganizationalenvironmentwithinwhichtheyareworking,theresearcherssetouttoexaminethe
experiencesofaccidentalprojectmanagersinWesternAustraliaspublicsector.Theywantedtoidentify
keyskillsandknowledgegapsthatwouldhelpthepublicsectortounderstandtheneedtotrainits
peopleinordertoachievesuccessfulprojectoutcomes.
Theresearchersdevelopedanddistributedaquestionnairethatwascompletedby46publicsectorstaff
whohadassumedtheroleofprojectmanagerwithlimitedornopreparationforthejob.The
questionnaireexaminedwhypeoplewereselected;theirskills,knowledgeandexperience;
organizationalsupportandtheorganizationalenvironment.
Thequestionnairerevealedahighincidenceofparttimeprojectmanagers70percentof
respondentsreportedthattheyhadotheroperationalresponsibilities.Aswell,respondentsidentifieda
rangeofprojecttypesthattheyhadbeeninvolvedwith,suchasorganizationalchange,administrative,
informationtechnology,policydevelopment,construction,andcommunityinitiatives.
Theresearchersfoundthatmostoftheprojectsinthepublicsector,withtheexceptionofIT,
constructionandinstallationbasedprojects,areofanontechnicalnature.Yet,respondentsranked
technicalknowledgeandgeneralmanagementskillsasthefundamentalreasonsfortheirselectionas
projectmanager.
Availabilitywasalsorankedhighly,whichsupportsthenotionthataccidentalprojectmanagersare
chosenbecausetheyareintherightplaceattherighttime.
2012PMPerspectivesResearchGroup
Page1of3
Lowrankingfactorsintheaccidentalprojectmanagersselectionwere:projectmanagementskills,
customer/clientrelationship,organizationalknowledge,andseniority.
Thequestionnairealsorevealedthatrespondentsperceivedtheirskillstobeeffectiveorhighlyeffective
inthefollowingareas:
interpersonal(60%),
management(46%),
technical(41%)
andprojectmanagement(36%).
Interestingly,respondentsindicatedthataprojectmanagershouldpossessstrongskillsinthefollowing
importantareas:
interpersonal(57%),
projectmanagement(42%),
technical(39%),
andgeneralmanagement(35%).
Theaccidentalprojectmanagersfoundthefollowingorganizationalsupportstobeeffectiveorhighly
effective:
opportunitiestogainexperience(72%),
assessmentandfeedback(57%),
educationandtraining(54%),onthejobtraining(48%),
recognitionoftheroleorwork(46%),
coachingandmentoring(31%),
andadditionalremuneration(17%).
However,74%ofrespondentsindicatedthattheirorganizationdidnotprovideenoughdevelopment
opportunities.
Respondentsalsoindicatedahighlevelofmanagementsupport,butmostindicatedanabsenceof
projectmanagementtoolsand83%acknowledgedthattherewasnoprojectmanagementmethodology
inplace.Only41percentofrespondentsindicatedthattheirdepartmentseesprojectmanagementasa
corecompetency.
Theresearcherssaythisisareflectionofanorganizationthatisnotfullyrecognizingthecriticalnature
oftheprojectmanagementfunction.Therelativelyhighlevelofmanagementsupportindicatesa
willingnessorenthusiasmforprojectmanagementbutthelackofmethodologiesandtoolsimpliesa
lackofpreparednessandalackofsoundprojectmanagementfoundationfromwhichtoachieve
successfulprojectoutcomes.
Overall,saytheresearchers,thepublicsectorsseniormanagementneedstoreevaluatethewayit
selectsprojectmanagerssothatindividualswiththeappropriateskillsarechosentoundertakethis
importantrole.Theresearchersrecommendthatseniormanagementbemoreproactiveinoffering
2012PMPerspectivesResearchGroup
Page2of3
developmentalopportunitiestobothexistingandpotentialprojectmanagers.Andtheysuggestthat
organizationscouldbemoreinnovativebyengagingseveralpeopleacrosstheorganizationascoaches
andmentors,andfordeliveringassessmentandfeedback.Aswell,theysaythelackofproject
managementtools,techniquesandmethodologiesshouldbeofconcerntoorganizationsandsenior
managers.
Withouttheseprojectmanagementtools,theysay,anorganizationdoesnothaveastrongfoundation
fromwhichtobuildskilledprojectmanagers,anorganizationalcultureofprojectmanagement,and
ultimately,betterbusinessoutcomes.
Giventhatthereisagrowingawarenessoftheimportanceofprojectmanagersforimplementing
businessstrategiesandachievingorganizationalgoals,theresearchersweresurprisedbytheirfindings.
Whiletheyexpectedthattheaccidentalprojectmanagerwouldbeclosetoextinction,thesurveyresults
suggesttheoppositetheaccidentalprojectmanagerisaliveandkickinginthepublicsector.
Source:Darrell,V.,Baccarini,D.andLove,P.E.D.Demystifyingthefolkloreoftheaccidentalproject
managerinthepublicsector,ProjectManagementJournal,41:5,December2010,pp.5663.
PMPerspectives.orgisawebsitewhichconnectsprojectmanagersandsponsorswithproject
managementresearchers.Ourmissionistounderstandandimproveprojectmanagementpractices.The
researchteamcomprisesDr.BlaizeHornerReichandDr.AndrewGeminofromSimonFraserUniversity,
CanadaandDr.ChrisSauerfromOxfordUniversity,UK.
Reich,Gemino,Sauer(2012)
ThisPDFversionwasreproducedin2013withminortypographiccorrections.
2012PMPerspectivesResearchGroup
Page3of3