Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
com/ifrs
Contents
At a glance
Process overview
Step 1
Step 2
Step 3
Step 4
Tax in the financial statements comprises current and deferred tax. Current tax is
based largely on the amounts included in the tax return. These might bear little
resemblance to the amounts in the financial statements. Tax laws and accounting
standards often require that income, expenditure, assets and liabilities are recognised
and measured differently. For example, expenditure accrued in the financial
statements might only be tax deductible when paid in the future. Deferred tax
accounting addresses these differences.
Step 5
10
Outside basis
difference
13
Deferred tax accounting compares the amount recorded in the financial statements
(the book base) with the amount attributable to that asset or liability for tax purposes
(the tax base). The tax base is established by individual territory tax rules. However,
the principles and the process used to recognise and measure deferred tax assets and
deferred tax liabilities in acquisition accounting are the same, no matter where the
acquisition occurs. This guide goes through the process, step by step, of determining
deferred tax in a business combination.
Business combinations could involve the acquisition of different types of enterprise.
Some enterprises (such as limited liability partnerships) do not pay tax directly, and
the profits are taxable in the hands of the investor. These are known as tax
transparent entities. This guide focuses on the acquisitions of corporations that are
taxable entities.
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
pwc.com/ifrs
Process overview
The process to be followed in acquisition accounting is:
Step 1
Transaction
Taxable
Non-taxable
Step 2
Temporary
Differences
Step 3
Tax Benefits
Step 4
Measure &
Recognise
Deferred
Tax
Step 5
Election
Calculate
Goodwill
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
pwc.com/ifrs
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
pwc.com/ifrs
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
pwc.com/ifrs
Question: How would the deferred taxes related to that asset be recorded in a taxable
and non-taxable business combination?
Answer:
The asset would be recorded at its fair value of CU150 on the acquisition date (book
base). The old tax base is likely to carry over (CU80) in a non-taxable transaction. The
tax base is likely to be the fair value (CU150) in a taxable transaction.
This is illustrated in the table:
Non-Taxable Transaction
Book Base
Tax Base
Temporary Difference
150
80
70
150
Taxable Transaction
150
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
pwc.com/ifrs
Example 2
A customer relationship is identified on the acquisition date and recognised at fair
value of CU1,300. The tax basis of the intangible asset is zero, because no deduction is
allowed in the tax jurisdiction. The tax rate is 40%.
Question: What is the deferred tax effect of recognising the intangible asset?
Answer:
The customer relationship creates an additional temporary difference equal to the fair
value of the intangible at the acquisition date. The following entry is recorded at the
acquisition date:
Dr
Intangible asset
CU1,300
Cr
CU250
Cr
Goodwill
CU780
CU400
Dr
Goodwill
CU600
Cr
Contingent liability
CU1,000
The temporary difference deferred tax asset should be adjusted in subsequent periods
as the amount of the contingent liability changes.
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
pwc.com/ifrs
The tax basis of the goodwill is adjusted by the amount recorded for the
contingency where settlement of the contingent liability would result in taxdeductible goodwill.
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
pwc.com/ifrs
the acquirer has sufficient taxable temporary differences that will generate
taxable income;
the acquiree has sufficient taxable temporary differences arising from the
recognition of assets at fair value that will generate taxable income;
the acquirer anticipates that there might be sufficient other income (this could
include profits elsewhere in the group, if these can be offset by the acquirees
losses under the relevant tax laws); or
tax planning opportunities might reduce future expenses or create additional
taxable income.
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
pwc.com/ifrs
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
pwc.com/ifrs
Book Base
(FV)
Tax
Base
Temporary
Difference
700
500
200
270
200
70
80
100
(20)
Accounts receivable
150
150
Cash
130
130
Total Assets
1,330
1,080
250
Accounts payable
(160)
(160)
(100)
1,070
Inventory
100
920
150
1,500
(1,010)
490
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
10
pwc.com/ifrs
Initial recognition
The initial recognition of a temporary difference depends on whether component 2
goodwill arises from the book value or the tax value.
A temporary taxable difference arises if the book value is higher than the tax base. IAS
12 does not allow a deferred tax liability to be recognised on the initial recognition of
goodwill. This is because a deferred tax liability would reduce the fair value of
identifiable assets and increase book goodwill. The overall impact is to gross up
goodwill, which does not provide useful information.
A deductible temporary difference arises if the tax base is higher than the book base. A
deferred tax asset is recognised if the recognition criteria are met (that is, realisation
will depend on available future taxable profit).
A deferred tax asset complicates the calculation of goodwill. The additional asset
increases the net assets acquired, which reduces the book base of goodwill in the
financial statements, leading to a larger temporary difference. To solve this issue, an
iterative formula is used to determine goodwill and the deferred tax asset:
(tax rate/(1 tax rate)) preliminary temporary difference (PTD) = deferred tax asset
This formula sometimes needs to be adjusted, and it cannot always be used in more
complex business combinations (for example, where there is not a single tax rate or
there is a gain in bargain purchase). Where this is the case, we would advise
consultation.
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
11
pwc.com/ifrs
Example 6
A taxable acquisition results in initial book goodwill of CU450. A separate
determination for taxes results in tax-deductible goodwill of CU600. The difference
between book and tax goodwill is CU150. Assume a tax rate of 40%.
Question: How is the deferred tax asset calculated?
Answer:
Without the iterative formula, the deferred tax asset would be calculated as:
(CU600 CU450) 40% = CU60
The recognition of an additional asset of CU60 would reduce book goodwill to CU390.
There is now a bigger temporary difference of (CU600 CU390) = CU210. This
process continues; so, to simplify the calculation, we use the following formula:
(tax Rate/(1 tax Rate)) x preliminary temporary difference (PTD) = deferred tax asset
(40%/(1 40%)) CU150 = deferred tax asset of CU100
The acquirer records a deferred tax asset for CU100, with a corresponding decrease in
book goodwill. Goodwill for financial reporting purposes is CU350, and a deferred tax
asset of CU100 is recorded. The resulting deferred tax asset reflects the temporary
difference related to goodwill, as illustrated below:
(Tax goodwill book goodwill) 40% = deferred tax asset
(CU600 CU350) 40% = CU100
Subsequent treatment
No deferred tax liability is recorded initially where the carrying amount of goodwill
exceeds the tax base. A deferred tax liability is recognised subsequently if component 1
goodwill changes. No deferred tax liability is recognised for a change in component 2
goodwill (excess).
Example 7
The carrying amount of goodwill is initially CU100 with a tax base of zero. At the end of
year 1, the goodwill is impaired by CU10.
Question: What is the deferred tax effect of the initial and subsequent measurement
of goodwill?
Answer:
The initial taxable temporary difference is CU20, but this cannot be recognised.
The tax base of goodwill has reduced to CU64 (CU80 80%) by the end of year 1, but
the carrying amount remains unchanged. The reduction of CU16 in component 1
goodwill is measured and recognised as a deferred tax liability.
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
12
pwc.com/ifrs
Example 8
The carrying amount of goodwill is initially CU100, with a tax base of CU80. A
deduction is allowed for tax purposes at 20% per year. No impairment has occurred in
year 1.
Question: What is the deferred tax effect of the initial and subsequent measurement of
goodwill?
Answer:
The initial taxable temporary difference is CU20, but this cannot be recognised.
The tax base of goodwill has reduced to CU64 (CU80 80%) by the end of year 1, but
the carrying amount remains unchanged. The reduction of CU16 in component 1
goodwill is measured and recognised as a deferred tax liability.
Calculating goodwill was the last step in the process for acquisition accounting. The
purchase price allocation can now be finalised.
Deferred tax impacts other areas of group accounting. The main impact is
discussed below.
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
13
pwc.com/ifrs
These changes will alter the book basis of the investment, but not the tax basis, and
they could give rise to a temporary difference. IAS 12 provides an exception for
recognising the deferred tax arising on the outside basis difference. The exception is
required if the parent controls the timing of the reversal of the temporary difference,
and it is probable that the temporary difference will not reverse in the
foreseeable future.
This exception applies to all subsidiaries, branches, associates, and interests in joint
ventures under IFRS if the criteria are met.
Subsidiary
The ability to control the reversal is always assumed if the investment is a subsidiary,
because a parentsubsidiary relationship is one of control. Management should then
determine if the subsidiarys profits will be distributed or if the subsidiary will be sold
in the foreseeable future. This will most likely depend on whether there is an intention
either to declare dividends or to sell the subsidiary. Management often concludes that
the subsidiary will continue to re-invest its earnings rather than remit them, but this is
not always the case.
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
14
pwc.com/ifrs
Associate
The acquirer has significant influence, but not control, over an associate, and so the
control over timing of the reversal cannot be assumed. The acquirer recognises a
deferred tax liability on the outside basis difference, unless there is an enforceable
agreement that the associates profits will not be distributed in the foreseeable future.
Joint arrangement
The terms of the contractual arrangement between venturers over the distribution of
profits will determine whether deferred tax should be recognised for the temporary
difference arising in connection with a joint arrangement.
Deferred tax asset
The outside tax basis of an investment might exceed the book basis. IAS 12 prohibits
the recognition of a deferred tax asset for an investment in a subsidiary, branch,
associate or joint venture unless the temporary difference will reverse in the
foreseeable future and taxable profit will be available against which the temporary
difference can be utilised.
Where can I find more information?
For more information about deferred tax in business combinations, please also
refer to:
This publication has been prepared for general guidance on matters of interest only, and does not constitute
professional advice. You should not act upon the information contained in this publication without obtaining
specific professional advice. No representation or warranty (express or implied) is given as to the accuracy
or completeness of the information contained in this publication, and, to the extent permitted by law,
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, its members, employees and agents do not accept or assume any liability,
responsibility or duty of care for any consequences of you or anyone else acting, or refraining to act, in
reliance on the information contained in this publication or for any decision based on it.
2013 PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP. All rights reserved. In this document, "PwC" refers to the UK member
firm, and may sometimes refer to the PwC network. Each member firm is a separate legal entity. Please see
www.pwc.com/structure for further details.
PwC: Practical guide to IFRS, Deferred Tax and Business Combinations: IFRS 3/IAS 12
15