Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 2 - 13112014
Chapter 2 - 13112014
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Concept
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
2.1.4.1 PRTG
VoIP Spear is an online network monitoring tool that can monitor VoIP
application QoS 24 hours a day. It uses the packet loss, latency and
jitter characteristics of the internet connection to calculate an industrystandard mean opinion score (MOS) between 1 (very poor quality) to 5
(very good quality). The user needs to create an account under VoIP
Spear in order to use this tool. This tool is available for free for
personal use and also available for full version commercial version with
fee of $1.00 per month.
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
2.1.3 Codecs
Audio codecs compress and decompress digital audio data based on the
audio file format or streaming media audio format. Audio codecs are
important to deliver high-reliability audio signal with minimum number of bits
while not dropping the quality. In hardware, audio codec is a single device
that encodes analog audio as digital signals and decodes it back into analog
audio. The audio codecs that are covered in this project include G711, G722,
GSM, iLBC and Speex.
2.1.3.1: G.711
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
second rate with the tolerance on that rate 50 parts per million (ppm).
8 bits non-uniform or logarithmic quantization used to represent each
sample that results in a 64 kbit/s bit rate. There are two version of this
codec which are -law that is used primarily in North America and Alaw that is in use in other countries except North America.
2.1.3.2: G.722
2.1.3.3: GSM
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
2.1.3.4: iLBC
2.1.3.5: SPEEX
2.1.3.6: H.263
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
2.1.3.7: H.264
2.1.3.8: Theora
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
2.1.3.9: Cinepak
2.1.3.10: VP8
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
10
2.2.1 Introduction
To carry out this project, related journals and has been researched to act as
references regarding the scope and objectives of the project. The journals and
articles have been researched based on the MANET, video conferencing and
VoIP topics.
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
11
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
12
2.2.4 Study the Best Approach Implementation and Codec Selection for VoIP
over Virtual Private Network
From the journal Study the Best Approach Implementation and Codec
Selection for VoIP over Virtual Private Network by Mohd Nazri Ismail (2013),
IPv4 over IPv6 can improve the internet or intranet with benefits such as it has
expended addressing capabilities, enhanced support for multicast and QoS and
more efficient and robust mobility mechanisms.
The writer focused the analysis performance on codec selection
measurement during conversation between two parties. The VoIP over VPN
technology is analyzed using network management service. Based on system
performance, codec G.711 and G.726 generate the highest percentage memory
usage for hardware VPN implementation. Based on CPU utilization, it can be
conclude that VoIP conversation did not affect the CPU utilization performance
using hardware. Based on delay, overall result shows that codec G.726 achieve
the highest delay, followed by codec G.711, GSM and iLBC. Based on jitter, the
result shows that VoIP over VPN hardware implementation will generate low jitter
compare to VoIP over VPN software implementation. Based on mean opinion
score (MOS), VoIP over VPN software can degrade VoIP performance compare
to VoIP over VPN hardware.
As a conclusion, VoIP over VPN using software base can contribute
higher delay jitter and CPU utilization compared to VPN hardware device. Due to
the result, the writer recommended to implement VoIP over VPN using hardware
base in order to achieve a good quality service conversation.
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
13
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
14
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
15
To do this project, I am required to search for journal or article with related topic with the project title. In this section,
we will discuss an in-depth explanation of the articles.
Author
Title
Purpose
Research Question
Methodology
Abdullah M I,
Rahman M M,
To study the
Ul-Ambia A,
Performance of
performance of
Conferencing
routing protocols
Islamic University,
over MANET
Pabna Science
Routing
and Techology
Protocols
involved in video
Mahmud M Z.
University,
conferencing
Simulation studies
protocol out of
based on
conferencing area
packet loss
Bangladesh (2012)
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
VoIP
Brak S E,
Bouhorma M,
Brak M E,
Boudhir A A
Abdelmalek Essadi
University, Tangier,
Tetouan, Morocco
(2013)
Applications
over MANET:
To study the
Codec
impact of routing
Performance
protocol
Enhancement
parameter setting
by Tuning
on codec
Routing
performance
of a call can be
be achieved by
maximized by codec
tuning routing
parameter?
parameters
Protocol
Parameters
To analyzed the
Study the Best
Approach
Ismail M N
Implementation
and Codec
University of Kuala
Lumpur, Malaysia
(2013)
Selection for
VoIP over
Virtual Private
Network
source
application and
Is hardware device
measurement via
hardware device
hardware device is
able to contribute
the performance of
better performance
quality of VoIP
compare to open
source application.
conversation
between
branches
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
Li Z P,
To propose a
Yin X C,
new kind of
Yao P Y,
protocol that is
Huang J N
used in MANET,
Peer Computing
advantage can be
based Dynamic
integrated
Source Routing
successfully into
MANET routing
been deployed
protocol design in
with passive
Corporate
MANET routing
performance of
Research and
algorithm and
MANET?
Development,
innovative P2P
Lenovo China,
routing
China (2006)
mechanism.
Implementation
Telecommunication
Engineering
Institute, Airforce
Engineering
University, Lenovo
of P2P
Computing in
Design of
MANET Routing
Protocol
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
Abolhasan M,
Hagelstein B,
Wang J C P,
Franklin D R,
Safaie F,
Wysocki T
Telecommunication
and Information
Technology
Research Institute,
University of
To develop a
Is PWAN able to
Development
Portable Wireless
node density in a
and
Ad hoc Node
of service of a
short-range, multi-hop
Performance
(PWAN) device
environment is capable
Evaluation of a
which establishes
condition of high
of providing high
Flexible, Low
multi-hop routes
node density in a
quality connections
Cost MANET
short-range, multi-
routing protocol
hop environment
low.
Wollongong,
Australia,
University of
Nebraska
Lincoln, USA
Table 1: Literature Review Matrix
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)
Module Provided
Literature Literature
Literature Literature
Literature
Review 1
Review 3
Review 5
Review 2
Review 4
MANET performance
tested using network
simulation software
Appropriate MANET routing
protocol to maximized its
performance
Audio and video codec
selection for best
performance
Best approach to enhance
codecs performance
Table 2: Literature Review Comparison
Legend
Literature Review 1
Literature Review 2
Literature Review 3
Literature Review 4
Literature Review 5
MANET
Diagram 1 show the area of testing for the project where three laptops will be
connected in a MANET. Each of the laptops has been installed with Linphone and
Eyebeam softphone software. The software is configured with audio and video
codecs that will be covered in this performance analysis project. Laptop A will be
installed with VoIP Spear and PRTG Monitoring Tool to do the performance analysis
of the audio and video codecs via the MANET connection.
Performance Analysis of Audio Video Codec via Mobile Adhoc Network (MANET)