Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cinematic Analysis Assignment 2014 - 2015
Cinematic Analysis Assignment 2014 - 2015
As a final act of defiance, the newsies join together to print newspapers promoting their cause.
The next day, most of the working kids in New York showed up outside Pulitzers office for a
massive demonstration, which resulted in a newsies victory and the arrest of the warren. The
newsies banding together to use the power of the press resulted in awareness to child labor.
Part B: Describe the historical setting of the film and the significant aspects of American
society portrayed. This requires some research and the use of at least two citations. Explore the
films historic accuracy, its significance at the time it was produced or the historiography (biases)
presented in the film. Remember to include MLA based in-text citations, from at least two
outside sources, and to include a Works Cited Page.
Newsies is an over dramatization of the newsboys strike of 1899, with strong bonds between
characters and the exaggeration of the cruelty of the newspaper owners. Many shots of the film
show an industrialized New York, with many more skyscrapers than there were in 1899 (New
York Historical Society). Some small details are historically accurate, such as both Jack and a
striker from 1899 being arrested for tearing up newspapers of the strikebreakers (New York
Times archive). Although the movie incorporated a few quotes from the strike, the language that
the strikers used in the movie is more sophisticated and modern than the language the newsies
from 1899 used (New York Daily Tribune). Many of the newsboys were poor and homeless.
They did not jump on wagons or swing on signs as the movie depicted. The movie romanticizes
the joy of a newsboy and the freedom that they felt selling newspapers.
Pulitzer was depicted as greedy and cruel in the movie, but in reality he had very little to do with
the strike. The price of the newspaper was raised because of the war, not because Pulitzer wanted
more money than Hearst, as shown in the movie. Pulitzer and Hearst were not strong
competitors, as Pulitzer was more prominent in the media world by a large margin (PostGazette). Pulitzer was rarely in his office at the time of the strike, and didnt even come into
contact with strikers.
The movie portrays many aspects of New York society that had little relation to the newsboys
strike. The movie depicted a club that resembles a place many upper-class New Yorkers would
have gone to in the evening. Jack claimed his parents went out west to search for new land, a
realistic situation in that time. Yet one scene describes a cowboy stereotype, as Jack dreams of
men on horses whipping their lassos around. One aspect the movie emphasized was that
newspapers refused to print stories about the strike. In actuality, most competing newspapers
were extremely active in the coverage of the strike (post-gazette). The part of the movie where
the newsies banding together to use Pulitzers printing press to create their own newspapers was
entirely fictitious. Although the newsboys had organized leaders in their strike, they did not print
their own newspaper. Printing presses all around the east coast were giving them plenty of
popularity. Finally, the victory the newsies won in the end of the movie was expanded. The
real newsboys struck a deal to have the newspaper companies buy back papers that they did not
sell but the price was kept at 60 cents.
Part C: Complete ONE of the following options (Be sure to include the writing prompt you
respond to in the paper:
1. Discuss how various cinematographic techniques are used to increase the viewers
awareness of the setting, characters or plot development.
2. Mostly strait on perspective-sympathise with newsies cause
3. Shows pans of industrius news cit full of biuldings
4. Very intricate backgrounds
5. Most shots newsies coming sowards camera to inspire viewers
6. Analyze the use of metaphor and imagery in the film, citing several examples.
a. Children sleeping on a gravestone
b. Nuns represent maternal figure (giving food, telling them they will be saved)
c. Dummy in audience next to kid, womens dress is purple, contrasts with
newsies black, grey, tattered clothing
d. Tiny up next to brooklyhn bridge
e. Children beat drums during strike like soldiers
Grading Rubric
Excelle
nt ( 5)
Good
(4
-4.5 )
Weak
(3-3.5)
Poor
(1-2)
Grade Conversions
Total Score______/20
18-20- A
16-17- B
14-15 -C
12-13- D
0-11- E
MLA Format
You must include in-text citations and a works cited page with your analysis. The
Modern Language Association is responsible for developing the rules that govern
how to appropriate cite outside works. Go to http://cap.mbhs.edu/resources.html
or http://imc.mbhs.edu/resources/bib/mla.pdf for a basic overview of MLA
formatting. Parenthetical citations are used in the text of your paper to credit the
origins of the idea or thought used. If the author, page number or website is not
mentioned in the text of the paper it must be parenthetically cited as follows:
Ragtime, the 1981 film about life at the turn of the 20 th century director Milos
Forman creates characters with great clarity in the few narratives he explores
amidst the jumble of tales originally explored in E.L. Doctrows bestselling novel
(Ebert, rogerebert.com).
Plagiarism
In order to avoid all instances of plagiarism all cinematic analyses must be
submitted to Turnitin.com by noon on the Due Date.