Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Impact of Body Site, Topical Melatonin and Brushing On Hair Regrowth After Clipping Normal Siberian Husky Dogs (Pages 45-50)
The Impact of Body Site, Topical Melatonin and Brushing On Hair Regrowth After Clipping Normal Siberian Husky Dogs (Pages 45-50)
The Impact of Body Site, Topical Melatonin and Brushing On Hair Regrowth After Clipping Normal Siberian Husky Dogs (Pages 45-50)
Abstract The aims of this study were to determine the impact of body site, vigorous brushing and topical melatonin treatment on hair regrowth after clipping normal dogs. Siberian Husky dogs were randomly assigned to
three groups of eight dogs each. All dogs had the lumbosacral region and both lateral thighs clipped. The left
thigh and lumbosacral area received no treatment and were compared in all 24 dogs. Eight dogs had the right
thigh treated with 0.1% melatonin twice daily for 2 months, and hair regrowth was compared with the left thigh.
Eight dogs had the right thigh brushed twice daily for 2 months, and hair regrowth was compared with the left
thigh. Eight dogs had neither thigh treated. Hairs were plucked before and 2 months postclipping, and the proportion of hair growth from the original length was calculated and compared as described above. Biopsy samples
were collected before and after treatment to determine if brushing induced dermal inflammation and melatonin
increased the proportion of anagen follicles. Proportionally, left thigh hairs were significantly longer compared
to lumbosacral hairs 2 months postclipping. No significant differences in hair regrowth were noted between the
nontreated thigh and the thigh treated with melatonin or brushed. No significant difference in dermal inflammation was noted before and after brushing. No significant differences were observed in the proportion of anagen
follicles before and after topical melatonin treatment. Our results showed that the hairs in the lumbosacral region
were proportionally shorter than lateral thigh hairs 2 months postclipping. Moreover, topical melatonin and
brushing had no impact on hair regrowth after clipping normal dogs.
IN TRO D U CT I ON
The delay in hair regrowth after clipping is a wellrecognized but a poorly understood condition that worries
many pet owners who take pride in their pets coat. Concerned owners frequently ask veterinarians how they can
help accelerate hair regrowth. Few studies have evaluated
factors that influence canine hair growth and those that
exist are uncontrolled and include few dogs.14
Hair growth is controlled by complex interactions
between endogenous and exogenous influences.57 It
has often been observed that hairs on the lumbosacral
region grow more slowly than hairs on the lateral thigh
when both areas are clipped for hip surgery. Troncy
et al. noticed while investigating two epidural anaesthesia protocols that 11% of the dogs included in the
study experienced a delay in hair regrowth on the lumbosacral region after clipping.8 Preliminary data from
a study conducted in Greece indicated that neither
epidural anaesthesia nor scrubbing or clipping seems
to affect hair regrowth in this area.9 These results seem
to confirm the frequent anecdotal finding that body
region has an impact on hair regrowth postclipping.
Correspondence: Dr Sheila M. F. Torres, Department of Small
Animal Clinical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine, University
or Minnesota, C339 Veterinary Hospitals, 1352 Boyd Avenue, Saint
Paul, MN 55108, USA. E-mail: torre009@umn.edu
2006 The Authors. Journal compilation 2006 European Society of Veterinary Dermatology
45
46
SF Diaz et al.
success.20 Therefore, the aim of this study was to determine the impact of body site, vigorous brushing and
topical melatonin treatment on hair regrowth after
clipping the hair coat of healthy Siberian Husky dogs.
Biopsy collection
Histopathology
To assess the degree of dermal inflammation in group
2, all inflammatory cells present within the dermis of
the whole tissue section were counted at 40 magnification. In fields containing glands and hair follicles, only
intervening dermal regions were counted. Intravascular
2006 The Authors. Journal compilation 2006 European Society of Veterinary Dermatology
Statistical analysis
Paired Students t-test was used to compare the proportion of hair regrowth postclipping between the lumbosacral area and the left lateral thigh on all 24 dogs.
Paired Students t-tests was also used to compare the
proportion of hair regrowth between the brushed thigh
(right) and the control thigh (left) in group 2, and
between the melatonin-treated thigh (right) and the
control thigh (left) in group 3. Wilcoxon signed ranks
test was used to compare the score given to dermal
inflammation before and after brushing the right leg of
the eight dogs in group 2 and to compare the proportion
of anagen follicles before and after melatonin treatment
of the eight dogs in group 3. A value of P < 0.05 was
considered significant. All analyses were preformed
using (SAS Institute,
Cary, NC, USA).
RESU LTS
The average length of primary hairs before and 2 months
after clipping the lumbosacral area was 5.70 and
2.95 cm, and the left lateral thigh was 3.30 and 2.10 cm,
respectively. The average length of secondary hairs
before and 2 months after clipping the lumbosacral
area was 4.40 and 2.79 cm, and the left lateral thigh was
2.80 and 2.03 cm, respectively. Proportionally, primary
(P = 0.002) and secondary (P = 0.026) hairs were significantly longer on the left lateral thigh compared to
the lumbosacral region 2 months postclipping (Fig. 1).
The average length of primary hairs before and 2
months after clipping and brushing the right thigh was
3.50 and 2.35 cm, and after only clipping, the left thigh
was 3.50 and 2.38 cm, respectively. The average length
of secondary hairs before and 2 months after clipping
47
and brushing the right thigh was 3.20 and 2.46 cm,
and after only clipping, the left thigh was 3.10 and
2.21 cm, respectively. No significant difference was
found in the proportion of primary (P = 0.84) or
secondary (P = 0.40) hair regrowth when the brushed
thigh (right thigh) was compared with the control thigh
(Fig. 2).
The average length of primary hairs before and
2 months after clipping and treating the right thigh
with melatonin was 3.80 and 2.15 cm, and after only
clipping, the left thigh was 3.8 and 2.09 cm, respectively. The average length of secondary hairs before and
2 months after clipping and treating the right thigh
with melatonin was 3.00 and 2.36 cm, and after only
clipping, the left thigh was 3.10 and 2.26 cm, respectively. No significant difference in the proportion of
primary (P = 0.52) or secondary (P = 0.15) hair regrowth
was seen when comparing the melatonin-treated thigh
(right thigh) with the control thigh (Fig. 3).
Before brushing in group 2, the degree of dermal
inflammation was low in one dog and medium in seven
dogs. Two months after twice-daily brushing, the degree
of dermal inflammation was low in one dog and medium
in six dogs. These differences were not significant (P =
1.00). Dermal inflammation could not be assessed in
one dog postbrushing because of poor tissue processing. In group 3, no significant differences were observed
2006 The Authors. Journal compilation 2006 European Society of Veterinary Dermatology
48
SF Diaz et al.
DISCU SSIO N
In this study, the hairs on the lumbosacral region were
proportionally shorter than on the lateral thigh at
2 months after clipping normal Siberian Husky dogs.
Moreover, brushing and topical melatonin had no
impact on hair regrowth postclipping.
Hair growth is a very complex phenomenon influenced by many endogenous and exogenous factors.
Endogenous factors include cytokines and growth
regulators. Important exogenous factors include photoperiod and temperature.57 These environmentally
related factors influence the secretion of melatonin
and prolactin, which in turn control the annual cyclical
activity seen in hair follicles.14 Although hair growth
and replacement have been studied in detail in humans,
sheep and laboratory rodents, very few studies have
been published for dogs and cats.14
Linear measurements of the hair shaft have been
performed to assess hair growth.15,24 Using this method,
we found that the hair length on the lumbosacral area
at 2 months postclipping was proportionally shorter
than that on the lateral thigh. In 1983, Gunaratnam
and Wilkinson performed a study in cross-bred male
dogs and showed that different body sites have different rates of hair growth.3 When comparing three body
sites (forehead, shoulder and flank), they found that
those hairs in which the final length was greater grew
faster.3 This would indicate that the speed of hair
growth was related to the final length in each particular
site. In this study, the rate of hair growth was not investigated, making a direct comparison with Gunaratnam
and Wilkinsons findings difficult. The average hair
length of primary hairs before clipping the dogs was
5.7 cm on the lumbosacral area and 3.3 cm on the
lateral thigh. Therefore, if the hair growth rate is truly
faster in body sites with longer hair shafts, it is reasonable to expect that the hair length on the lumbosacral
2006 The Authors. Journal compilation 2006 European Society of Veterinary Dermatology
REFEREN CE S
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
49
2006 The Authors. Journal compilation 2006 European Society of Veterinary Dermatology
50
SF Diaz et al.
Rsum Les buts de cette tude taient de dterminer linfluence de la zone cutane, dun borssage vigoureux
et de lapplication topique de mlatonine sur la repousse pilaire chez les chiens normaux aprs tonte. Des Siberian
husky ont t regroups au hasard en trois groupes de huit chiens. Tous les chiens ont t tondus sur la zone dorsolombaire et sur la face postrieure des cuisses. La cuisse gauche et la zone dorsolombaire nont pas reu de
traitement, et ont t compares chez les 24 chiens. Huit chiens ont eu la cuisse droite traite par lapplication
biquotidienne de 0.1% melatonine pendant deux mois et la repousse a t compare avec lautre cuisse. Huit chiens
nont pas eu de traitement sur les cuisses. Huit chiens ont eu la cuisse droite brosse deux fois par jour pendant
deux mois.
Les poils taient pils avant et deux mois aprs la tonte et la proportion de pousse pilaire a t calcule. Des
biopsies cutanes ont t ralises avant et aprs le traitement pour dterminer si le brossage provoquait une
inflammation et si la mlatonine provoquait une augmentation des poils en anagne. Proportionnellement, les
poils de la cuisse gauche taient significativement plus longs compars aux poils de la zone dorso-lombaire deux
mois aprs la tonte. Aucune diffrence significative na t observe entre les cuisses non traites et les cuisses
brosses ou traites par la mlatonine. Aucune diffrence significative na t observe pour le nombre de poils
en phase anagne. Nos rsultats montrent que les poils de la zone lombo-sacre sont proportionnellement plus
petits que ceux des cuisses deux mois aprs tonte. En outre, la mlatonine ou le brossage ninfluencent pas la
repousse pilaire chez les chiens normaux.
Resumen El propsito de este estudio fue determinar el impacto de la localizacin corporal, el cepillado
vigoroso y la aplicacin de melatonina tpica en el crecimiento del pelo tras rasurado en perros normales. Perros
Huskies Siberianos se asignaron de forma aleatoria en tres grupos de ocho perros cada uno. Todos los perros
fueron rasurados en la regin lumbosacra y el lateral de los muslos. El muslo izquierdo y la zona lumbosacra no
recibieron tratamiento y se compararon en los 24 perros. Ocho perros recibieron tratamiento con 0.1% de
melatonina dos veces al da durante dos meses en el muslo derecho, y el crecimiento del pelo se compar con el
del muslo izquierdo. Ocho perros fueron cepillados dos veces al da durante dos meses en el muslo derecho, y el
crecimiento del pelo se comparo con el lado izquierdo. Ocho perros no recibieron ningn tratamiento. Algunos
pelos fueron arrancados antes del rasurado y dos meses despus del mismo, y la proporcin de crecimiento del
pelo respecto la longitud original se calcul y compar tal y como se ha descrito. Se tomaron biopsias antes y
tras el tratamiento para determinar si el cepillado produca inflamacin drmica y si la melatonina incrementaba
la proporcin de pelos en fase anagnica. Proporcionalmente, los pelos del lado izquierdo fueron significativamente ms largos que los de la regin lumbosacra dos meses tras el rasurado. No hubo diferencia significativa
entre los laterales de las extremidades tratados con melatonina o cepillado y los no tratados. No se observ una
diferencia significativa en la proporcin de pelos en fase anagnica antes y tras el tratamiento con melatonina
tpica. Nuestros resultados demuestran que los pelos de la regin lumbosacra son proporcionalmente mas cortos
que los de los muslos dos meses tras el rasurado. Y lo que es mas, el tratamiento con melatonina topica y el cepillado no influyeron en el crecimiento del pelo tras el rasurado en perros normales.
Zusammenfassung Die Ziele dieser Studie waren es, die Auswirkung der Krperregion, sowie von krftigem
Brsten und topischer Behandlung mit Melatonin auf das Nachwachsen der Haare nach dem Scheren von normalen Hunden zu eruieren. Sibirische Huskies wurden zufllig in drei Gruppen von je acht Hunden eingeteilt.
Bei allen Hunden wurde die Lumbosakralregion und die beiden lateralen Oberschenkel geschoren. Der linke
Oberschenkel- und die Lumbosakralregion wurden nicht behandelt und bei allen 24 Hunden verglichen. Bei acht
Hunden wurde der rechte Oberschenkel mit 0.1% Melatonin zwei Monate lang zweimal tglich behandelt und
das Nachwachsen der Haare verglichen mit dem des linken Oberschenkels. Bei acht Hunden wurde der rechte
Oberschenkel zwei Monate lang zweimal tglich gebrstet und das Nachwachsen der Haare verglichen mit dem
des linken Oberschenkels. Bei acht Hunden wurde weder der eine noch der andere Oberschenkel behandelt.
Vor und zwei Monate nach dem Scheren wurden Haare ausgezupft, die Proportion des Haarwuchses von der
Originallnge kalkuliert und verglichen wie oben beschrieben. Biopsieproben wurden vor und nach der Behandlung entnommen, um festzustellen, ob das Brsten eine dermale Entzndung verursachte und ob Melatonin
den Anteil an anagenen Haarfollikeln steigerte. Zwei Monate nach dem Scheren waren die Haare des linken
Oberschenkels im Verhltnis signifikant lnger im Vergleich zu den lumbosakralen Haaren. Kein signifikanter
Unterschied beim Nachwachsen der Haare wurde zwischen den nicht behandelten und den mit Melatonin behandelten oder gebrsteten Oberschenkeln gefunden. Es bestand kein signifikanter Unterschied bei der dermalen
Entzndung vor und nach dem Brsten. Keine signifikanten Unterschiede wurden beim Anteil an anagenen
Haarfollikeln vor und nach der topischen Behandlung mit Melatonin beobachtet. Unsere Ergebnisse zeigten,
dass die Haare in der Lumbosakralregion zwei Monate nach dem Scheren verhltnismssig krzer waren als die
Haare der lateralen Oberschenkel. Auerdem hatte weder die topische Melatoninbehandlung noch das Brsten
einen Einfluss auf das Nachwachsen der Haare nach dem Scheren normaler Hunde.
2006 The Authors. Journal compilation 2006 European Society of Veterinary Dermatology