Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Editor's Note: What's Inside This Month
Editor's Note: What's Inside This Month
Departments...
Editor’s Note.....1 Reader’s Trivia..... 15 Contact Us ..... 18
Marketing, Privacy, Postal Globalization - good or bad? E-mails and phone contact
Issues. What‘s Inside This Does the recession make you information
Issue want to close the borders?
2
Volume One Issue Eleven / December 2009
The following article is taken from a case study on mobile marketing in Japan from a presentation prepared
by Atsuko Morimoto of AM Associates, Japan. The presentation is downloadable from The Prescott Report
document library "Morimoto mobile study". See below for contact details for Ms. Morimoto.
A Bit of Background they will find you. Mobile spend was up 59% year on
year in 2008.
Mobile services in Japan are controlled by three
Mobiles are part of everyday life. Consumers use
major telecommunications carriers: Docomo, Au, and
their mobile phones in ways that have not yet become
Softbank. Content and applications require the ap-
entirely common in other countries and in this respect
proval of each carrier. The
Japan has been quite a pioneer. The phones have, of
markets for mobile handsets
course, the usual standard features, including
and for mobile services are
the ability to make calls and send text mes-
quite substantial. There are
sages. Of course, you can
slightly over 108 million sub-
send e-mail. Somewhat
scribers in this land of 127
more unusually, they have
million people. It is esti-
better cameras
mated that the online mo-
than one ex-
bile shopping market
pects, generally
(being mobile contents
between 3.2 and
and mobile commerce
10 megapixels,
combined) in
with a 12-
2009 will reach
megapixel cam-
$13.5 billion
era having just
and all this is
been intro-
occurring in a
duced. You can
country the size of
also watch tele-
California with a
vision, use your
population of 127
GPS navigation,
million people. Group
which is becom-
M reported last year that
ing more com-
about 10% of ad spend in
mon elsewhere,
Japan is mobile market-
use your electronic debit card,
ing, or more than is spent on
make railroad pass payments,
direct mail. Japanese consumers
transfer data with infrared, and download pic-
have been accessing the Internet
tograms and ring tones from hit songs. [I was
via mobile for years. 76% of Japanese
surprised last week in Budapest when my dinner host
use the Internet.
paid for his parking spot by sending an SMS of his
If you want to reach busy adults in Japan, mobile is
license plate number to a mobile number on a placard
an effective tool, although it is opt-in. Still, you build
near where he parked. When we left he texted again
your mobile-friendly website and engage in effective
and “the clock stopped”. Editor]
SEM practice, think a little bit about WOMMA, and
5
Volume One Issue Eleven / December 2009
CROSS-BORDER MARKETING:
The Changing Dynamics by Richard N. Miller
Richard N. Miller is Managing Partner of Market Response For instance, where McGraw-Hill once pro-
International (www.rmillerinternational.com) in Chatham, duced over 40 international titles, they now publish
MA. He is Executive-Director Emeritus of the International closer to 20. I see no solution to replacing this loss,
Mailers’ Advisory Group, and the author other than opting for more email lists. Though email
of Multinational Direct Marketing: the campaigns can be produced with considerably less
Methods & The Markets (McGraw-Hill). expense than traditional direct mail campaigns, they
He can be reached at
generally require a larger target universe to attain ac-
rmiller@capecod.net.
ceptable results.
F
Nevertheless, the judicious use of interna-
ew industries have changed as much as a
tional email lists is an important part of any mar-
result of the electronic revolution as interna-
keter‘s arsenal. In the developing regions of the
tional direct marketing . We create campaigns, pre-
world, email currently extends much further than
pare production materials, order lists, monitor the
does any other Internet-based technology. Conse-
letter-shop, take orders, confirm and track shipments,
quently, email lists have evolved as a powerful tool
receive payment, settle claims, handle customer ser-
for collaboration in Africa, Asia, and Latin America,
vice, upsell and upgrade - all without leaving our
especially in the areas of social services and fund
computer screen! When I first came into this busi-
raising.
ness in 1979, every one of those operations was han-
dled by a separate channel, often at disparate geo- Is e-mail Worth It?
graphical locations, and much of the operation was However, the email list industry has not really
manual. And, it took forever. But how things have matured, and costs are all over the lot. Many email
changed! lists are more expensive than traditional mail lists,
Let‘s look at three of the most important ele- particularly in B2B. If a typical international publi-
ments in cross-border direct market- cation‘s direct mail list costs
ing: List, Addressing and Delivery you $250 per thousand, an
and see where things stand today. email list could run almost
twice that, especially if it is
The List Industry: Tra- certified as ―permission‖-
ditional vs. ―e‖ sources based. There is really no jus-
As usual, the health tification for that, especially
of the list industry needs to as response rates for email
lead off any discussion of lists are generally much
direct marketing, interna- lower than traditional lists.
tional or domestic. Publish- Thom Hansen, VP
ing is the oldest and one of International at Direct Me-
the richest sources of lists in dia, Inc. calls it ―greed‖.
the international direct marketing (www.directmedia.com. They can
field. However, with dramatic changes in charge more, so they do. So-called ―opt-
reading habits, the number of periodical titles in‖ names are compiled from lists where
has declined significantly, impacting the total uni- names have been generated with only im-
verse of subscriber names available. plied or passive permission. With a true per-
8
Volume One Issue Eleven / December 2009
Privacy Update
Behavioral Targeting. alleges that this is done without the appropriate level
This subject is beginning to reoccupy of knowledge and consent by BT‘s customers. Deep
the privacy debate on both sides of the packet inspection is used by broadband and mobile
Atlantic. In the US, it will be one of operators to provide various levels of service to cus-
the items on the agenda in a series of tomers. This, also raises the issue of net neutrality, as
roundtables on privacy being con- the practice enables the carrier to discriminate among
ducted by The US Federal Trade Commission, which messages or downloads, perhaps enabling it to ration
began on December 7 in Washington, DC. http:// bandwidth to someone down loading videos fre-
www.ftc.gov/bcp/workshops/privacyroundtables/ quently.
PrivacyRoundtable_DraftAgenda.pdf. Very Important Survey Results on Behav-
As early as March 31 of this year, the Euro- ioral Targeting.
pean Commissioner for Consumer Affairs Meglena A recently released survey of American atti-
Kuneva expressed in a public policy address her tudes toward the practice has significantly elevated the
concerns regarding online behavioral advertising, subject. Americans Reject Targeted Advertising and
urging business to protect consumers and give them the three activities that enable it; Turow, Hoofnagle,
more power. In October, Commissioner Viviane King, Bleakely, and Hennessy. The work interprets
Reding (Information, Society, and Media) raised the the result of a nationwide telephone survey of Ameri-
temperature by referring to an action by the Com- can attitudes to targeted advertising and the data col-
mission against the UK for not being aggressive lection practices that support it.
enough in enforcing the Data Protection Directive in Americans overwhelmingly reject the practice
regards to the practice. She indicated that the Com- Here is a handful of the findings of the survey, which
mission was receiving many expressions of concern was conducted with substantial scientific rigor:
about the practice and was ―closely monitoring‖ the • 66% do not want ads tailored to their interests. The
situation. figure goes to a range between 73% and 86% when
Meanwhile, the UK‘s Office of Fair Trading people are told the three ways data are gathered:
has announced an investigation/consultation into the tracking, tailoring of ads, and targeting of ads.
practice, a sometimes lengthy proedure that normally • Younger people are only slightly less concerned than
kick-starts self-regulation exercises in the business older people, with 55% of 18-24 year olds rejecting
world and frequently can lead to rule-making or, less tailored advertising. This flies in the face of ―common
frequently, legislation. The OFT‘s investigation, knowledge‖ that the young are not privacy sensitive.
however, appears to center around whether online • 92% agree there should be a law requiring websites
retailers use their tracking of a visitor‘s browsing to delete records of an individual‘s browsing.
pattern in order to raise the price of an item unfairly. • Young and old both reject tailored ads, tailored dis-
They are less concerned about privacy than fair com- counts, and tailored news.
petition, not surprising, given their title. Americans are also less knowledgeable about
In the meantime, the European Commission the protections currently afforded them by the law
has commenced an action against the UK for failing with respect to data collection and the use companies
to take stronger action against BT and Phorm, a tar- can make of their browsing habits. Surprisingly, re-
geted marketing firm, with respect to its use of ―deep spondents felt they had more legal protection than
packet inspection‖ of BT customers‘ traffic. The EC they do, and replied incorrectly in well over a major-
12
Volume One Issue Eleven / December 2009
14
Volume One Issue Eleven / December 2009
Order the following countries from shortest to longest in terms of turning possessions in to ti-
Q: tled property (and by extension, richest to poorest): Indonesia, Australia, Congo. Bonus ques-
tion : does it matter, for heaven’s sake? All bureaucracies make us wait, so what?
The influential economist and advisor Hernando de Soto, author of The Mystery of Capital: Why
A: Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else, first articulated what should have been
obvious: the formalities required to turn assets into capital directly impacts the turning of assets into
capital. That is to say, if it takes a lot of bureaucracy and agony and time and money to get a trans-
ferable title to property, so it can be exchanged or mortgaged, or to incorporate a business to make it
transferable, this will directly impact, in a negative way, capital formation and wealth creation.
For example, the faster the incorporation formalities, the better the wealth creation. In order to form a
corporation: Australia -2 days; Indonesia -168 days; Congo -215 days. (By the way, in New York State, it takes
about 45 minutes to form a corporation. Editor).
The poor are poor only in terms of the ―bell-jar‖ that the traditional legal system puts around wealth ti-
tles, such as complex and tedious incorporation and land registration requirements. In fact, home builders in the
The developing countries maintain very high tariff barriers against imports from other devel-
Q: oping countries. If these barriers were reduced to equivalency with developed countries, this
would result in increased exports from developing countries of about (a) US$ 50 billion (b)
US$ 100 billion (c) US$ 350 billion in value.
(C) US$ 350 billion. South vs. South barriers to trade basically continue to prevent trade. Brazil
A: sells and buys more with China than with any country in South America. If these countries in-
creased their export trade by only US$ 350 billion, this would be 7 times as much as they receive in
aid. Countries in Latin America and Africa have very high barriers to trade with each other, and they
are among the most under-developed countries.
True or false – Farmers in Japan, Europe and the US are the biggest obstacles to final trade
Q: liberalization.
True, very true. Subsidies for production, tariff and quota barriers for imports are major barriers.
A: The US, Japan, and Europe continue to use them; all to keep agricultural products out of their mar-
kets, and to spread their products in world markets at a price unsupported farmers can not sustain.
This is painful and hurtful to developing countries such as Morocco, where agriculture may be only
14 percent of GDP but 44 percent of the workforce. Developed countries spend over US$ 318 billion in sup-
ports for a minor percentage of their population (below 1 percent in the US). In Europe, rice costs 5 times the
world price, beef costs 2 times.
True or false - All things being equal, a company will move its work overseas on price alone.
Save enough on production costs and nothing else matters.
Q:
A survey by McKinsey and Company of companies who had moved production overseas concluded
that tax and financial incentives are not all that relevant, something this writer has observed over 30
A: years of international business. In a close case they may be decisive, but they are down the list a
long way.
On a scale of 1 (least important) to 10 (most important), what matters is infrastructure (10),
trained workers (9), a fair and transparent regulatory environment (9) , and ease of access for foreign
management (7). Financial incentives, such as tax breaks, rate (5).
In short, as Friedman noted from his interviews with executives at major companies around the world, if
you don‘t have reliable electrical power, I can‘t make (whatever, such as computer chips), and if you don‘t
have good roads and railroads, I can‘t get my (whatever..chips) to market overseas.
Why this should surprise anyone is beyond me. I learned in 8th grade history that the first thing settlers
True or false. Globalization encourages a “race to the bottom” in social and environmental
Q: standards. Workers make less and are exploited, and foreign companies exploit the environ-
ment for all their worth.
False. Not as easy an answer as you thought it would be, I bet. For the most part, investments by
A: developed country companies and multinationals are done on the basis of world-class standards. The
OECD has found that wage rates in foreign-invested companies are about double that of local-
invested manufacturers.
Wages in India‘s BPO companies are 50 pct to 100 pct above local white-collar sector jobs
requiring similar skills. Thomas Friedman noted the same thing. Moreover, since major companies tend to im-
pose similar standards and requirements on all their facilities, they tend to import and impose the same high-
level environmental standards that they observe in developed countries.
Q:
Surprisingly, that is false. Well, what did you expect? Of course Argentina believes it is above it all,
A: now that it has paid off the World Bank and has a healthy balance of payments situation. But in fact,
the rest of the world believes globalization is improving their lives, even Brazilians, 66 percent of
whom think it‘s good, compared to only 35 percent of Argentines.
In fact, Argentina is the only country that feels it is bad, with 39% of respondents disapproving of glob-
alization. Globalization is viewed positively in the US (62%), China (76%), and Kenya (82%). Even the
gloomiest and most pessimistic country on earth, Russia, was more positive (31% than negative 14%) than Ar-
gentina (35% for, 39% against). Ah, even in France, where they burn down McDonald‘s, 72% of those below
age 30 say globalization is a good thing, more than their elders over age 50, of whom 58% think it‘s good.
17
Volume One Issue Eleven/December 2009
Contact Us:
To Contribute
We welcome contributions, commentary, and suggestions. Please contact us at:
+1.914.533.0208, or e-mail us at: editor@prescottreport.com. For editorial guidelines on contri-
butions, e-mail the same address or visit the this page at www.prescottreport.com for a copy..
To Subscribe/Unsubscribe/Change Address
You may visit www.prescottreport.com or send an e-mail with your name, company name, title,
address, and e-mail address to: subscribe@prescottreport.com
ISSN 1949-3320
© 2009
18