Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISSOME2011 Proceedings
ISSOME2011 Proceedings
HKF:MBHG L<B>G<>
:G= LH<B:E F>=B:
Ikh\^^]bg`lh_ma^
Bgm^kgZmbhgZe<hg_^k^g\^
Bg_hkfZmbhgL\b^g\^
Zg]Lh\bZeF^]bZ
BLLHF> +)**% :n`nlm+-&+/% [h(Mnkdn%
?bgeZg]
>]bm^][r
,672 +89,/$
.,0 +2/0%(5*
0$5,$ .52149,67%(5*
Bg_hkfZmbhglmn]b^lu[h:dZ]^fbNgbo^klbmr
[h% ?bgeZg]
LL
,6620(
LLL
Organising committee
.`X :mMBHH qB/2M- #Q F/2KB lMBp2`bBiv- 6BMHM/
.`X EBK >QHK#2`;- #Q F/2KB lMBp2`bBiv- 6BMHM/
.`X AbiQ >mpBH- lTTbH lMBp2`bBiv- ar2/2M #Q F/2KB
lMBp2`bBiv- 6BMHM/
J`B E`QM[pBbi@"2`;- #Q F/2KB lMBp2`bBiv- 6BMHM/
PmiB LBpFQbFB- #Q F/2KB lMBp2`bBiv- 6BMHM/
Programme committee
.`X JBF2 h?2HrHH- lMBp2`bBiv Q7 qQHp2`?KTiQM- lMBi2/
EBM;/QK
.`X >M qQQ S`F- u2mM;LK lMBp2`bBiv- aQmi? EQ`2
.`X _Q#BM h2B;HM/- aiQ+F?QHK a+?QQH Q7 1+QMQKB+b- ar2/2M
.`X 1p >2KKmM;b@qB`iM- lTTbH lMBp2`bBiv- ar2/2M
.`X CM LQHBM- lMBp2`bBiv Q7 "Q`b- ar2/2M
.`X PHQ7 amM/BM- GmM/ lMBp2`bBiv- ar2/2M
.`X .pB/ aim`i- lMBp2`bBiv Q7 qQHp2`?KTiQM- lMBi2/ EBM;@
/QK
.`X >2H2M 6`M+F2- lMBp2`bBiv Q7 "Q`b- ar2/2M
.`X Cmii >B/2`- GmM/ lMBp2`bBiv- ar2/2M
.`X C2`2Kv >mMbBM;2`- oB`;BMB h2+?- la
.`X 6`M+F hi`/- #Q F/2KB lMBp2`bBiv- 6BMHM/
.`X G2MM`i "D`M2#Q`M- _QvH a+?QQH Q7 GB#``v M/ AM7Q`K@
iBQM a+B2M+2- .2MK`F
.`X GmMM2 6`2mM/- lMBp2`bBiv Q7 "`BiBb? *QHmK#B- *M/
.`X 6`2/`BF bi`K- GmM/ lMBp2`bBiv GB#``B2b- ar2/2M
LY
,6620(
Contents
)RUHZRUG
3DUW ,
L[
&RQIHUHQFH3DSHUVDQG([WHQGHG$EVWUDFWV
7RZDUGV7UDLQLQJ/LEUDULDQ
/X;LDR
7R,QIRUPRUWR,QWHUDFW WKDWLVWKHTXHVWLRQ
0DWKLDV.ODQJDQG-DQ1ROLQ
$XWKRUGLVDPELJXDWLRQIRU
HQKDQFHGVFLHQFHVHUYLFHV
-HIIUH\'HPDLQH
7KHXVHRIVRFLDOPHGLD
WHFKQRORJLHVLQWKHZRUNSUDFWLFHV
RILQIRUPDWLRQSURIHVVLRQDOV
6DOO\%XUIRUG
'HVLJQLQJ*DPHVIRU7HVWLQJ
,QIRUPDWLRQ%HKDYLRU7KHRULHV
-7XRPDV+DUYLDLQHQ
2QVRFLDOPHGLDDQGGRFXPHQWWKHRU\
2OOH6N|OG
+RZWRVWXG\VRFLDOPHGLD
SUDFWLVHVLQFRQYHUJLQJOLEUDU\VSDFHV
+DQQD&DUOVVRQ
*HRHQFRGLQJRIORFDOVHUYLFHVDQGLQIRUPDWLRQ
6DPSSD5RKNLPDLQHQ
YL
,6620(
&ULWLFDODERXWFOXVWHULQJRIWDJV
,VWR+XYLODDQG.ULVWLQ-RKDQQHVVRQ
7KH8VHRI%ORJVLQ/,6 2QOLQH&RXUVHV
'LDQH1HDODQG/X;LDR
$ &RPSDULVRQRI'LIIHUHQW8VHU6LPLODULW\0HDVXUHVDV%DVLVIRU5HVHDUFK
DQG6FLHQWLF
&RRSHUDWLRQ
7DPDUD+HFN
([DPLQLQJWKHXVHVRILQWHUQHWDQGVRFLDOPHGLDDPRQJPHQDWPLOLWDU\FRQ
VFULSWLRQDJH
+HLGL(QZDOG1RRUD+LUYRQHQ7LP/XRWR
:LNL/HDNV&RPPHQWV
1RD$KDURQ\
/RRNLQJIRU/RYHLQ$OOWKH5LJKW3ODFHV
&KULVWRSKHU0DVFDUR 5DFKHO0DJHHDQG6HDQ*RJJLQV
%HKDYLRXUDO7UDFHVDQG,QGLUHFW8VHUWR8VHU0HGLDWLRQLQWKH3DUWLFLSDWRU\
/LEUDU\
/HQQDUW%M|UQHERUQ
7KHFUHDWLRQRIDSHUVRQDOVSDFHRQWKH,QWHUQHW
-HQQ\%URQVWHLQ
/LQJXLVWLFDQG&XOWXUDO
'LIIHUHQFHVLQ&RQWHQW
0DQDJHPHQW
6XVDQQD1\N\UL
7HDFKLQJVRFLDOPHGLDLQ/,6
0RQLFD/DVVLDQG+DQQD0DXULQ6|GHUKROP
3DUW ,,
'RFWRUDO)RUXP
,QIRUPDWLRQUHODWHGDFWLYLWLHVLQDVRFLDOPHGLDDQGSXEOLFOLEUDU\FRQWH[W
0DULD.URQTYLVW%HUJ
8VHUV
FXOWXUDOLGHQWLWLHV UROHVDQGRSHQDFFHVVLQ6HFRQG/LIH
$QQD.DLVD6M|OXQG
YLL
&RQWHQWV
7KH'DQLVKGLJLWDOL]HGFXOWXUDOKHULWDJHDQGLWVXVHUV
-RQDV)UDQVVRQ
6RFLDO0HGLD5HVHDUFKDW6ZHGLVK6FKRRORI/LEUDU\DQG,QIRUPDWLRQ6FL
HQFH
0DULD/LQGK (PPD)RUVJUHQDQG'DYLG*XQQDUVVRQ
'HYHORSLQJSXEOLFOLEUDU\VHUYLFHVE\PHDQVRISURMHFWV
1LQD+\QQl
3DUW ,,,
$GGHQGXP
:ULWLQJIRU:LNLSHGLDDVDOHDUQLQJWDVNLQWKHVFKRROVLQIRUPDWLRQOLWHUDF\
LQVWUXFWLRQ
(HUR6RUPXQHQDQG/HHQL/HKWL|-DQQLFD+HLQVWU|P
,PSOLFDWLRQVRIWKH:HE
7HFKQRORJLHVIRU3XEOLF/LEUDULHVLQWHQGLQJWR)DFLOLWDWH$OWHUQDWLYH3XE
OLF'LVFRXUVH
/HLI.DMEHUJ
7KHXVHRIVRFLDOPHGLDLQWKHZRUNSUDFWLFHVRILQIRUPDWLRQSURIHVVLRQDOV
6DOO\%XUIRUG
Foreword
,6620(
:mMBHH qB/M
CONFERENCE PAPERS
AND EXTENDED ABSTRACTS
Introduction
GB#``v kXy KQ/2H ?b ii`+i2/ HQi Q7 `2b2`+? M/ T`+iB+2
ii2MiBQM BM GB#``v M/ AM7Q`KiBQM a+B2M+2 UGAaV /Bb+BTHBM2X GB#@
``v kXy 2KT?bBx2b i?2 BKTQ`iM+2 Q7 mb2` T`iB+BTiBQM BM +`2i@
BM; M/ 2pHmiBM; b2`pB+2b i?i HB#``B2b T`QpB/2 #Qi? T?vbB+HHv
M/ pB`imHHv U*b2v M/ apbiBMmF- kyyeVX JQpBM; iQr`/b GB#@
``v kXy KQ/2H- GAa T`Q72bbBQMHb `2 +?HH2M;2/ iQ bi`i #2+QKBM;
GB#``BM kXy i2`K }`bi T`QTQb2/ #v ai2T?2M #`K- pB+2
T`2bB/2Mi Q7 AMMQpiBQM i aB`bB.vMBt U#`K- kyyeVX aBM+2 i?2Mi?2`2 ?p2 #22M MmK2`Qmb /Bb+mbbBQMb #Qmi r?i i?2 bFBHHb M/
FMQrH2/;2 i?i GAa T`Q72bbBQMHb b?QmH/ ?p2 BM Q`/2` iQ T`QpB/2
GB#``v kXy b2`pB+2X AM bTBi2 Q7 i?2 p`BQmb HBbib Q7 HB#``BM kXy bFBHHb
M/ FMQrH2/;2- HH ;`22 i?i GB#``v kXy Bb #Qmi mb2`@+2Mi2`2/
TT`Q+? iQ T`QpB/2 M/ BKT`Qp2 HB#``v b2`pB+2b- M/ HB#``BM
kXy M22/b iQ #2 #H2 iQ iF2 i?i TT`Q+? BM ?Bbf?2` /BHv T`+iB+2X
6Q` 2tKTH2- ai2T?2Mb HBbi2/ bBt F2v i`Bib i?i ?2 #2HB2p2/ r2`2
M2+2bb`v 7Q` GB#``BM kXy rBi? i?2 }`bi F2v i`Bi b HB#``BMb kXy
THMb 7Q` i?2B` mb2`b Uai2T?2Mb- kyyeVX *Q?2M Tm#HBb?2/ ?2` Km+?
+Bi2/ rQ`F h?2 GB#``BMb kXy JMB72biQ UkyyeV r?2`2 MBM2 Qmi Q7
i?2 b2p2Mi22M T`BM+BTH2b r2`2 #Qmi mb2`b- i?2 M22/ Q7 mbBM; mb2`b
M22/b- M/ BMpQHpBM; mb2`b BM HB#``v T`+iB+2X
h?2`2 ?p2 #22M T`+iB+2b #Qmi mbBM; +QKKmMBiv@#b2/ T`QD2+ib
BM i2+?BM; GAa +Qm`b2bX AM i?2b2 T`+iB+2b- i?2 2KT?bBb ?b #22M
,6620(
7RZDUGV7UDLQLQJ/LEUDULDQ
,6620(
Findings
h?2 BMi2`pB2r /i bm;;2bi i?i i?2 bim/2Mib MQi QMHv H2`M2/
#Qmi /i#b2 +QM+2Tib M/ /i#b2 i2+?MQHQ;v #mi HbQ TT`2@
+Bi2/ i?2 QTTQ`imMBiv Q7 rQ`FBM; rBi? `2H mb2`b M/ ;BM2/ 2tT2`@
B2M+2b Q7 ?Qr iQ iF2 i?2B` T2`bT2+iBp2b BMiQ ++QmMi M/ BMi2;`i2
i?2K BMiQ i?2 /i#b2 /2bB;MX PM2 ;`QmT rb bbB;M2/ iQ +`2i2
i?2 +QHH2+iBQM /i#b2X h?2 +QHH2+iBQM BM+Hm/2/ Tm#HBb?2/ `iB+H2b#QQFb- 2i+X i i?2 #2;BMMBM; Q7 i?2 T`QD2+i- i?2 bim/2Mib i?Qm;?i
i?2v rQmH/ /2p2HQT HB#``v +iHQ;m2 7Q` i?2 +QHH2+iBQM rBi? #B#@
HBQ;`T?B+ /i HBF2 mi?Q`b- Tm#HB+iBQM v2`- Tm#HBb?2`- 2i+X M
BMi2`pB2r rBi? i?2 `2T`2b2MiiBp2 iQiHHv +?M;2/ i?2 ;`QmTb pB2rX
PM2 K2K#2` `2~2+i2/ QM i?Bb M/ bB/- qQ`FBM; rBi? +HB2Mi Bb
`2HHv BMi2`2biBM;- M/ i?2 T`QD2+i i?i r2 ;Qi- i?2 +iHQ;mBM; Q7
`2bQm`+2bXXXr2 ?p2 iQ #2 HBiiH2 #Bi +`2iBp2 BM ?Qr r2 TT`Q+?
i?2 T`QD2+i #2+mb2XXX?2 rMib Bi iQ #2 TH+2 r?2`2 T2QTH2 +M +QK2
M/ [mB+FHv }M/ `2bQm`+2b rBi?Qmi ?pBM; iQ ivT2 BM b2`+? rQ`/bX
h?2 +QKKmMBiv T`iM2`b HbQ TT`2+Bi2/ i?2 +iBp2 T`iB+BT@
iBQM T`Q+2bbX h?2v r2`2 TH2b2/ i?i i?2 bim/2Mib iQQF i?2 Q`;M@
BxiBQMb T2`bT2+iBp2 b2`BQmbHv BM i?2 /2bB;M T`Q+2bbX PM2 `2T`2b2Mi@
iBp2 bB/, h?2v /Q MQi +QK2 BM rBi? T`2+QM+2Bp2/ B/2b Q7 r?i
b?QmH/ #2 /QM2- r?i M22/b iQ #2 /QM2X h?2v HBbi2M iQ r?i A ?p2
iQ bvXXX M/ A i?BMF i?ib i?2 `B;?i rv iQ /Q Bi- Bib MQi #2BM;
`2+iBp2XXXAp2 b22M bQK2 T`Q72bbBQMH +QMbmHiMib i?i `2Mi b r2HH
T`2T`2/ M/ b i?Q`Qm;? b i?Bb ;`QmT Bb- bQ i?2vp2 #22M p2`v
;QQ/X >2 7m`i?2` +QKK2Mi2/ i?i- XXX h?2v /Q +`2 #Qmi M
Q`;MBxiBQM i?2vp2 ?/ MQ +QMM2+iBQM iQX h?ibXXXbQK2i?BM; i?i
/QMi Hrvb ;2i rBi? i?2 +QMbmHiMi i?i HQQFb i Bi vQm FMQr- i?Bb
Bb #mbBM2bb T`QD2+i QM2 Qz i?2M AHH KQp2 QM iQ bQK2i?BM; 2Hb2XXX
PM2 `2T`2b2MiiBp2 rb ?TTBHv bm`T`Bb2/ r?2M ?2 7QmM/ ?2 rb
2KTQr2`2/ iQ Qz2` 722/#+F /m`BM; i?2 /2bB;M T`Q+2bbX _2~2+iBM;
mTQM ?Bb H2`MBM; 2tT2`B2M+2- ?2 bB/- A ?/Mi `2HBx2/XXXi?i vQm
/QMi Dmbi im`M bQK2i?BM; Qp2` iQ T2QTH2 M/ bv /Q BiX h?2v`2
7RZDUGV7UDLQLQJ/LEUDULDQ
Bibliography
(R) #`K- aX q2# kXy- GB#``v kXy- M/ GB#``BM kXy, S`2T`@
BM; 7Q` i?2 kXy qQ`H/X aB`bB.vMBt PM2 aQm`+2X UkV R- kyye
(k) *b2v- JX 1X apbiBMmF GX *X UkyyeVX GB#``v kXy, a2`pB+2
7Q` i?2 L2ti@:2M2`iBQM GB#``vX GB#``v CQm`MH- RjR- R99y@9k
(j) *Q?2M- GX Ukyye- LQp2K#2` 3VX HB#``BMb kXy KMB72biQX
J2bb;2 TQbi2/ iQ
(9) ?iiT,ffHB#HQ;bXH#MvX2/mfHB#``vkyfkyyefRRf HB#``BMb ky KMB72biQX?iKH
(8) .2r2v- CX URNReV .2KQ+`+v M/ 2/m+iBQMX M BMi`Q/m+iBQM
iQ i?2 T?BHQbQT?v Q7 2/m+iBQM URNee 2/XV- L2r uQ`F, 6`22
S`2bbX
(e) ai2T?2Mb- JX UkyyeVX AMiQ M2r rQ`H/ Q7 HB#``BMb?BTX L2ti
aT+2- h?2 P*G* L2rbH2ii2`X _2i`B2p2/ m;mbi kj- kyRy7`QK ?iiT,ffrrrXQ+H+XQ`;fM2tibT+2fyykfjX?iK
Introduction
h?2 +QM+2Ti Q7 6`22/QK Q7 AM7Q`KiBQM U"HFBM kyy9- GK#H2
kyyk- aQHQp2 kyykV ?b #22M `Bb2/ iQ 7mM/K2MiH ;QQ/ i?i
T2`K2i2b HH bT2+ib Q7 KQ/2`M /2KQ+`iB+ bQ+B2iB2bX h?2 ;QH Q7
i?Bb TT2` Bb iQ 2tTHQ`2 i?2 `QH2 Q7 i?Bb T`BM+BTH2 BM `2HiBQM iQ HQ+H
mi?Q`BiB2b ii2KTib iQ BM+`2b2 +BiBx2M T`iB+BTiBQM pB BM+`2b2/
H2p2Hb Q7 bQ+BH K2/B mb;2X q2 `;m2 i?i bQ+BH K2/B TQHB+v
rQ`F `Bb2b +QM~B+i pBb@@pBb i?2 2bi#HBb?2/ MQ`Kb Q7 6`22/QK
Q7 AM7Q`KiBQM M/ i?2 B/2QHQ;B+H mM/2`TBMMBM;b Q7 i?2 i2+?MQHQ;v
BM mb2X Pm` MHvbBb #mBH/b QM ar2/Bb? +b2 bim/v M/ BHHmbi`i2b
i?2 +QM~B+i #2ir22M +BiBx2M@;Qp2`MK2Mi BMi2`+iBQM pB bQ+BH K2/B
i2+?MQHQ;B2b M/ i?2 2bi#HBb?2/ MQ`Kb Q7 6`22/QK Q7 AM7Q`KiBQMX
Freedom of Information
q?2M *?v/2MBmb UGK#H2 kyykV BM i?2 R3i? +2Mim`v T`QTQb2/ ?Bb
`/B+H pBbBQM Q7 6`22/QK Q7 AM7Q`KiBQM UQz2MiHB;?2ibT`BM+BT2M Q`
6QAV ?2 rb `;mBM; 7Q` M mM?2`/ Q7 H2p2H Q7 QT2MM2bb M/ i`Mb@
T`2M+v BM ;Qp2`MK2MiX >2 `;m2/ i?i 6QA rQmH/ T`Q/m+2 bi#BHBiv
M/ T`2/B+i#BHBiv BM ;Qp2`MK2Mi b i?2 +ib Q7 TQHBiB+BMb M/ Tm#@
HB+ b2`pMib +QmH/ #2 Q#b2`p2/ M/ i`+2/X AM+`2b2/ ++QmMi#BHBiv
H2/b iQ BM+`2b2/ +QMi`QHX >Bb `;mK2Mib +M #2 b22M iQ #2 6Qm@
,6620(
7R,QIRUPRUWR,QWHUDFW WKDWLVWKHTXHVWLRQ
E-government or E-democracy
:Qp2`MK2Mi M/ /2KQ+`+v `2 i iBK2b BMi2`+?M;2#H2 i2`Kb
#mi i?2v b?QmH/ MQi #2 +QM7mb2/X 6Q` i?2 Tm`TQb2 Q7 i?Bb rQ`F
2H2+i`QMB+ ;Qp2`MK2Mi U2@;Qp2`MK2MiV `272`b iQ i?2 bii2b ;QH iQ
KF2 Bib T`Q+2bb2b KQ`2 2{+B2MiX AM +QMi`bi- 2H2+i`QMB+ /2KQ+`+v
,6620(
7R,QIRUPRUWR,QWHUDFW WKDWLVWKHTXHVWLRQ
Empirical Study
ar2/2M Bb /BpB/2/ BMiQ kNy KmMB+BTHBiB2b rBi? TQTmHiBQMb `M@
;BM; #2ir22M k-9ey39d-ydjXR 1+? KmMB+BTHBiv Bb `2bTQMbB#H2 7Q`
bQ+BH b2`pB+2b- +`2 Q7 2H/2`Hv M/ ?M/B+TT2/- +?BH/+`2 M/ b+?QQHbTHMMBM; M/ xQMBM;- 2MpB`QMK2Mi M/ ?2Hi? T`Qi2+iBQM- Tm#HB+
+H2MBM; M/ ;`#;2 KM;2K2Mi- }`2 #`B;/2- ri2` M/ rbi2Q`/2` M/ b2+m`BivX AM //BiBQM iQ i?2b2 `2b i?2 KmMB+BTHBiv Kv
HbQ THv M +iBp2 T`i BM `2+`2iBQMH +iBpBiB2b- +mHim`2- ?QmbBM;2M2`;v- #mbBM2bb M/ `2+2TiBQM Q7 `27m;22bX
hQ #2ii2` mM/2`biM/ i?2 KmMB+BTHBiB2b ii2KTib iQ mb2 bQ+BH
K2/B b THi7Q`K 7Q` BM+`2b2/ QT2MM2bb M/ +BiBx2M BMi2`+iBQM
i?Bb TT2` MHvx2b bQ+BH K2/B TQHB+B2b Tm#HBb?2/ #v ar2/Bb? Km@
MB+BTHBiB2b T`BQ` iQ .2+2K#2` kyRyX
h?2 +?QB+2 Q7 HBKBiBM; i?2 bim/v iQ TQHB+B2b T`BQ` iQ .2+2K#2`
kyRy rb MQi `#Bi``v #mi +QBM+B/2/ rBi? i?2 Tm#HB+iBQM Q7 i?2 `2@
TQ`i 7`QK 1@/2H2;iBQM2M Uh?2 2:Qp2`MK2Mi .2H2;iBQMV r?Q r2`2
;Bp2M M //BiBQMH KM/i2 QM Tm#HB+ BM7Q`KiBQM M/ bQ+BH K2@
/B iQ /2p2HQT /`7i ;mB/2HBM2b 7Q` ;Qp2`MK2Mi ;2M+B2b mb2 Q7 bQ@
+BH K2/BX h?2 Tm#HB+iBQM Q7 i?2b2 ;mB/2HBM2b U1@.2H2;iBQM2M
kyRyV +`2i2/ M BM7Q`KH T`2+2/2Mi i?i ?b #22M 7QHHQr2/ #v KMv
ar2/Bb? KmMB+BTHBiB2bX S`BQ` iQ i?2B` Tm#HB+iBQM i?2 KBM bQm`+2
Q7 b2KB@Q{+BH bmTTQ`i rb SJ Tm#HBb?2/ #v ap2`B;2b EQKKm@
M2` Q+? GM/biBM; Uar2/Bb? bbQ+BiBQM Q7 GQ+H mi?Q`BiB2b M/
_2;BQMbV BM T`BH kyRy UaEG kyRyV M/ /Q+mK2Mi QM Q`;MBx@
iBQMH `2bTQMbB#BHBiv 7Q` /i BM bQ+BH K2/B #v .iBMbT2FiBQM2M
R aiiBbiB+b
kyRRX
,6620(
Results
h?2 2KTB`B+H Ki2`BH `2pB2r2/ 7Q` i?Bb `iB+H2 im`M2/ Qmi iQ
#2 2t+2TiBQMHHv `B+?X Ai ?b MQi #22M TQbbB#H2 iQ 7mHHv 2tTHQ`2 i?2
KMv /Bz2`2Mi /BK2MbBQMb i?i Qm` MHvbBb ?b #`Qm;?i 7Q`r`/X
q2 ?QT2 iQ 2tTHQ`2 b2p2`H i?2K2b BM ;`2i2` /2iBH BM b2T`i2
rQ`FbX q2 ?p2 H`2/v Tm`bm2/ 72r Qi?2` T2`bT2+iBp2b BM
b2T`i2 `iB+H2 UEHM; LQHBM kyRRVX Ai Bb HbQ `B+? }2H/ 7Q` Qi?2`
`2b2`+?2`bX AM i?2 7QHHQrBM;- r2 rBHH i?2`27Q`2- `Qm;?Hv QmiHBM2
MmK#2` Q7 i?2K2b M/ T`Q#H2Kb i?i b22K m`;2Mi 7Q` #Qi? TQHB+v
KF2`b M/ `2b2`+?2`bX
h?2 ke TQHB+B2b BM+Hm/2/ BM i?Bb bim/v p`v rB/2Hv BM i?2B` H2M;i?c
Q`;MBxiBQM- 7Q+mb M/ +QMi2Mi #mi i?2`2 `2 bQK2 +H2` `2b Q7
+QKKQM ;`QmM/ i?i `2 BMi2`2biBM; iQ TQBMi QmiX
G2;HBiv, RN TQHB+B2b BM+Hm/2/ bii2K2Mib `2KBM/BM; i?i +`BK@
BMH +ib rQmH/ MQi #2 iQH2`i2/X h?Bb Bb M BMi2`2biBM; TQBMi b
i?2`2 Bb MQr?2`2 M bbmKTiBQM i?i bQ+BH K2/B mb2 Bb 7`22 7`QK
`2;mHiBQM #v +`BKBMH HrX h?2`27Q`2 i?2 ?B;? MmK#2`b Q7 TQHB+B2b
i?i `2BM7Q`+2 i?2 bii2K2Mi i?i +`BKBMH +ib `2 MQi HHQr2/ BM
bQ+BH K2/B `2 bB;MH Q7 i?2 +QM+2`Mb Q7 i?2 KmMB+BTHBivX /@
/BiBQMHHv R3 TQHB+B2b `272``2/ iQ /KBMBbi`iBp2 HrX h?Bb `2~2+ib
+QM+2`M BM `2HiBQM iQ i?2 pHm2 Q7 +ib +``B2/ Qmi BM bQ+BH K2/B
U7Q` 2tKTH2, q?i Bb i?2 /Bz2`2M+2 BM /KBMBbi`iBp2 Hr #2ir22M
K2bb;2- b2Mi Q` `2+2Bp2/- pB H2ii2`- 2KBH Q` bQ+BH K2/B\VX
MHQ;m2 #Bb, HH TQHB+B2b /2KQMbi`i2/ M MHQ;m2 #BbX h?Bb
Bb MQi mM2tT2+i2/ b i?2 Q`;MBxiBQMb ?p2 r2HH@2bi#HBb?2/ `QmiBM2b7Q`;2/ i?`Qm;? Hr- i`/BiBQM M/ +mHim`2X >Qr2p2`- i?2 MHQ;m2
#Bb Bb Q7i2M b22M +iBM; ;BMbi i?2 HQ;B+ Q7 bQ+BH K2/BX AM T`i
i?Bb Bb b?QrM i?`Qm;? i?2 rvb BM r?B+? H2;H `2[mB`2K2Mib Q7 /@
KBMBbi`iBp2 Hr- bm+? b /miv Q7 b2`pB+2 M/ `+?BpBM;- `2 BMi2`@
T`2i2/ #v i?2 TQHB+B2bX
7R,QIRUPRUWR,QWHUDFW WKDWLVWKHTXHVWLRQ
,6620(
Analysis
Is Social Media a public or private space?
h?2 TQHB+B2b i2M/ MQi iQ /2}M2 bQ+BH K2/BX MmK#2` Q7 TQHB+B2b
HBbi 2tKTH2b Q7 bQ+BH K2/B THi7Q`Kb- ?Qr2p2` i?Bb HBbiBM; T@
T`Q+? iQ i?2 T`Q#H2K Q7 /2}MBiBQM /Q2b MQi //`2bb ?Qr iQ i`2i
MQM@HBbi2/ THi7Q`KbX 6m`i?2`KQ`2- i?Bb TT`Q+? `2bmHib BM M mM@
biBb7+iQ`v MQM@/2}MBiBQM /2}MBiBQMX ii2KTiBM; iQ /2}M2 bQ+BH
K2/B b T?2MQK2MQM #v HBbiBM; Q`;MBxiBQMb i?i T`QpB/2 bQ@
+BH K2/B b2`pB+2b /Q2b HBiiH2 iQ 7m`i?2` Qm` mM/2`biM/BM; Q7 i?2
T?2MQK2MQMX M Q`;MBxiBQM- M/ b2`pB+2- bm+? b- 7Q` 2tKTH26+2#QQF K2Mb /Bz2`2Mi i?BM;b iQ p`BQmb T2QTH2X 6+2#QQF +M
#2 b22M b M2irQ`F- T`Bp+v i?`2i- bBi2 7Q` b2H7@Tm#HB+iBQM T?QiQ@b?`BM; bBi2- +?i bBi2 2i+X //BiBQMHHv- /2}MBiBQM #v
HBbiBM; +Q`TQ`iBQMb /2KM/b i?i i?2b2 +Q`TQ`iBQMb ?p2 iiBM2/
`2HiBp2Hv ;`22/ mTQM M/ biiB+ K2MBM;X >Qr2p2`- 6+2#QQF
Bb MQi i?2 bK2 i?BM; iQ/v b r?2M Bi rb HmM+?2/- rBi? Km+?
KQ`2 TTHB+iBQMb- b2iiBM;b M/ +QKTH2tBivX
h?2 TQHB+B2b HbQ QMHv ``2Hv /Bb+mbb i?2 /Bz2`2M+2 #2ir22M bQ+BH
K2/B mb2/ T`Bpi2Hv #v B/2MiB}2/ KmMB+BTHBiv 2KTHQv22b 7`QK bQ@
+BH K2/B mb2/ #v 2KTHQv22b BM mi?Q`Bx2/ KmMB+BTHBiv #mbBM2bbX
h?Bb H+F Q7 +H`Biv `Bb2b Bbbm2b Q7 ++2Ti#H2 QMHBM2 #2?pBQ`X
AM i?Bb Hii2` [m2biBQM i?2 TQHB+B2b /2KQMbi`i2 +QM~B+i #2ir22M
2M+Qm`;BM; 2KTHQv22b iQ #2 2Mi?mbBbiB+ #Qmi i?2B` rQ`F M/ mb@
BM; bQ+BH K2/BX h?Bb +QM~B+i Bb 2bT2+BHHv pBbB#H2 BM T`Bpi2 b2i@
iBM;b- r?2`2 2KTHQv22b Kv /Bb+mbb Bbbm2b Q7 BMi2`2bi iQ i?2K #mi
Kv M22/ iQ /`r HBM2 #2ir22M 2Mi?mbBbK M/ T`2b2MiBM; +Q`@
`2+i pB2r Q7 KmMB+BTHBiv rQ`F M/ iiBim/2bX SQHB+B2b `2;mH`Hv `2Bi@
2`i2 i?i 2KTHQv22b 7mM/K2MiH 7`22 bT22+? `B;?ib TTHv iQ bQ+BH
K2/B- +QmTH2/ rBi? `2KBM/2`b i?i 2p2M BM i?2B` T`Bpi2 HBp2b 2K@
THQv22b Kv #2 B/2MiB}#H2 rBi? i?2 KmMB+BTHBiv M/ Qr2 HQvHiv
iQ i?2B` 2KTHQv2`X
AM //BiBQM iQ i?2 7`22 bT22+? T`Q#H2K #Qp2 i?2 TQHB+B2b HbQ i@
i2KTi iQ `2;mHi2 7Q`Kb Q7 //`2bbX LBM2 TQHB+B2b bT2+B}+HHv #`BM;
mT i?2 [m2biBQM Q7 7Q`KH Q` BM7Q`KH //`2bb M/ i?2b2 KBMiBM
i?i //`2bb BM bQ+BH K2/B b?QmH/ #2 BM7Q`KHX h?Qb2 mbBM; i?2
KmMB+BTHBiB2b mi?Q`Bx2/ bQ+BH K2/B b?QmH/ Q` Kmbi `2bTQM/ mb@
7R,QIRUPRUWR,QWHUDFW WKDWLVWKHTXHVWLRQ
UkV
UjV
,6620(
7R,QIRUPRUWR,QWHUDFW WKDWLVWKHTXHVWLRQ
Conclusion
6`QK i?2 rQ`/BM; M/ BMi2MiBQMb Q7 i?2 TQHB+B2b BM+Hm/2/ BM i?Bb
bim/v Bi Bb +H2` i?i i?2 KmMB+BTHBiB2b `2 bmz2`BM; 7`QK H+F Q7
+H2` /2}MBiBQM Q7 bQ+BH K2/BX h?2 H+F Q7 /2}MBiBQM Bb MQi T`Q#@
H2K T`iB+mH` iQ KmMB+BTHBiB2b #mi Bi #2+QK2b KQ`2 +mi2 r?2M
?B;?Hv@`mH2 #b2/ Q`;MBxiBQMb- bm+? b KmMB+BTHBiB2b- ii2KTi iQ
`2;mHi2 Bib mb2X qBi?Qmi +H2` /2}MBiBQM Q7 bQ+BH K2/B i?2 B/2
Q7 +`2iBM; TQHB+v BM r?B+? i?2 mb2 Q7 bm+? i2+?MQHQ;v +M #2
`2;mHi2/ #2+QK2b BM+`2bBM;Hv +QKTH2tX h?2 /B{+mHiB2b BM `2;mH@
iBQM i?`Qm;? #2+QK2 KQ`2 +QKTH2t r?2M iFBM; BMiQ ++QmMi i?2
rB/2 `M;2 Q7 b2`pB+2b- 7Q`Kb Q7 +QKKmMB+iBQM M/ BMi2`+iBQM i?2
ar2/Bb? KmMB+BTHBiv Bb +?`;2/ rBi?X
h?2 TQHB+B2b BM+Hm/2/ BM i?Bb bim/v ?p2 7Q+mb2/ QM /Bz2`2Mi mb2b
Q7 i?2 i2+?MQHQ;v M/ p`vBM; H2p2Hb Q7 i?`2ib bQ+BH K2/B KBbmb2
Kv +mb2 i?2 Q`;MBxiBQMX
PM2 bm;;2biBQM b iQ r?v i?2 TQHB+B2b `2KBM p;m2 BM `2HiBQM
iQ KMv Q7 i?2b2 `2b /Bb+mbb2/ #Qp2 Kv #2 7QmM/ BM i?2 bQ+BH
+QMi2ti rBi?BM r?B+? i?2 KmMB+BTHBiB2b QT2`i2X G2;H M/ bQ+BH
mM/2`biM/BM; Q7 2KTHQv22 `B;?ib- 7`22/QK Q7 2tT`2bbBQM- M/ Tm#HB+
,6620(
7R,QIRUPRUWR,QWHUDFW WKDWLVWKHTXHVWLRQ
zB`b iQ H2i i?2 Tm#HB+ FMQr i?2 7+ib M2+2bb`v iQ 7Q`K Dm/;K2Mib
BM TQHBiB+H Kii2`bc M/ bKHH `2 Q7 b2+`2+v 7Q` ;Qp2`MK2Mi iQ
T`2b2`p2 i?2 BMi2;`Biv Q7 +2`iBM b2+`2i BM7Q`KiBQM M/ i?2 T`Bp+v
Q7 BMi2`MH TQHB+v@KFBM; T`Q+2bb2bX "v BMi`Q/m+BM; bQ+BH K2/B
b M BM7Q`KiBQM BM7`bi`m+im`2 BM BMi2`+iBQMb #2ir22M KmMB+BT@
HBiB2b M/ +BiBx2Mb i?Bb T`Bpi2 bT+2 rBHH #2 +?HH2M;2/X Ai rBHH #2
BMi2`2biBM; iQ b22 ?Qr i?Bb TQBMi /2p2HQTb Qp2` iBK2X
AM +HQbBM; Bi Bb rQ`i? TQBMiBM; QM+2 ;BM iQ i?2 ?B;? H2p2H Q7 M@
HQ;m2 #Bb i?i T2`K2i2b i?2 TQHB+B2bX h?2 KmMB+BTHBiB2b pB2r- M/
Q7i2M `272` iQ- bQ+BH K2/B M //BiBQM +QKKmMB+iBQMb +?MM2HX
h?Bb pB2r +H2`Hv b?Qrb H2p2H Q7 mMT`2T`2/M2bb 7Q` Mv `2H BM@
i2`+iBQM i?i Bb i?2 `2H TQi2MiBH Qz2`2/ #v bQ+BH K2/B mb2X h?2
KmMB+BTHBiB2b `2 p2`v Km+? KB`2/ BM KBM/@b2i Q7 2@;Qp2`MK2Mi
M/ ?p2 v2i iQ KQp2 QMr`/b iQ 2@/2KQ+`+v r?2`2 +QHH#Q`iBQMT`iB+BTiBQM M/ /BHQ;m2 `2 F2v BM;`2/B2MibX
qBi? i?Bb H+F Q7 BMi2`+iBQM M/ T`iB+BTiBQM i?2 TQi2MiBH Q7
bQ+BH K2/B ?b v2i iQ `2+? Mv `2H TQi2MiBH M/ +MMQi MQr
#2 b22M b i?2 7mH}HHK2Mi Q7 *?v/2MBmb /`2KX h?2 TQHB+B2b b?Qr
+H2` 7Q+mb QM /TiBM; bQ+BH K2/B b +?MM2Hb Q7 +QKKmMB+@
iBQM iQ 7m`i?2` i?2 BMi2`2bib Q7 2@;Qp2`MK2Mi r?BH2 pQB/BM; bQ+BH
K2/Bb TQi2MiBH b iQQH 7Q` BM+`2bBM; T`iB+BTiQ`v /2KQ+`+v
M/ 7m`i?2`BM; i?2 ;QHb Q7 2@/2KQ+`+vX q2 }M/ i?Bb bii2 Q7 7@
7B`b T`Q#H2KiB+ M/ BM M22/ Q7 #Qi? 7m`i?2` `2b2`+? M/ /BHQ;m2
#2ir22M `2b2`+?2`b M/ TQHB+v KF2`bX
Bibliography
,6620(
%,%/,2*5$3+<
#bi`+i
Introduction
h?2 /BbK#B;miBQM Q7 mi?Q`b rBi? B/2MiB+H U?QKQMvKQmbV MK2b
?b #22M ;`QrBM; +QM+2`M BM #B#HBQK2i`B+b 7Q` b2p2`H v2`bX h?2
B/2MiB}+iBQM Q7 mi?Q`b Bb M2+2bb`v T`2+QM/BiBQM 7Q` ++m`i2
#B#HBQK2i`B+ +H+mHiBQMbX `2pB2r Q7 i?2 +m``2Mi HBi2`im`2 QM m@
,6620(
$XWKRUGLVDPELJXDWLRQIRUHQKDQFHGVFLHQFHVHUYLFHV
,6620(
i?i i?2 +Q``2+i `iB+H2b +M #2 ii`B#mi2/ iQ i?2 T2QTH2 M/ BMbiB@
imiBQMb #2BM; bim/B2/X >Qr2p2`- HH Q7 i?2 K2i/i 7Q` mi?Q`b Bb
MQi Hrvb pBH#H2 U/2T2M/BM; QM i?2 Tm#HBb?2` 7`QK r?B+? i?2
/i rb +QHH2+i2/VX q?BH2 bQK2 `2+Q`/b +QMiBM +QKTH2i2 BM7Q`K@
iBQM BM+Hm/BM; i?2 mi?Q`b }`bi MK2 M/ BMbiBimiBQMH {HBiBQM
Qi?2` `2+Q`/b /Q MQiX h?mb 7Q` i?2 TTHB+iBQM /2b+`B#2/ ?2`2BM
iQ rQ`F rBi? HH `2+Q`/b- Bi Kmbi `2Hv QMHv QM i?2 HQr2bi +QKKQM
/2MQKBMiQ` pBH#H2, +Q@mi?Q`b M/ `272`2M+2bX
h?mb i?2 bT2+B}+ +?HH2M;2 //`2bb2/ ?2`2 Bb iQ ;`QmT mi?Q`@
MK2 BMbiM+2b BM `2HB#H2 M/ miQKi2/ KMM2` ;Bp2M HBK@
Bi2/ KQmMi Q7 K2i/i bm+? i?i Bi #2+QK2b T`+iB+H iQ mM@
/2`iF2 H`;2@b+H2 bim/B2b BMpQHpBM; KMv mi?Q`b 7`QK Mv }2H/
Q7 `2b2`+?X AM i?Bb `2H@rQ`H/ b+2M`BQ- miBHBiv Bb b BKTQ`iMi b
++m`+vX
Method
>QKQMvKQmb MK2 BMbiM+2b U`2i`B2p2/ 7`QK i?2 B6Zb /i@
#b2bV i?i b?`2 +Q@mi?Q`b M/fQ` `272`2M+2b `2 ;`QmT2/ iQ;2i?2`
b QM2 BM/BpB/mH ++Q`/BM; iQ i?2 7QHHQrBM; H;Q`Bi?KX h?Bb Bb BK@
TH2K2Mi2/ BM Cp M/ mb2b HQ+H ++?BM; Q7 MK2b M/ A. MmK#2`b
iQ `2/m+2 i?2 M22/ iQ `2@[m2`v i?2 /i#b2 7Q` i?2 bK2 BM7Q`K@
iBQMX
RX
kX
jX
):)+$',(,3*(:/"&;'(:*$*/),*1(6%(,3*()<:"/+,3#>(?3*(/*'&<,'(=*/*()$)<%Q*1(&'+$:()(-"$2&'+"$(
,)6<*();;/")-3>((?3*(:/"&;(=+,3(,3*(<)/:*',($*/("2(#),-3+$:(;&6<+-),+"$'(=)'(-"$'+1*/*1(
(=*/*(
,3*/*2"/*(-"$'+1*/*1(,"(/*;/*'*$,(",3*/(+$1+0+1&)<'(
;/*1+-,+"$7>(/
E
$XWKRUGLVDPELJXDWLRQIRUHQKDQFHGVFLHQFHVHUYLFHV
=)'("$<%(;"''+6<*(,"(1*,*/#+$*(,3*(R/*-+'+"$("2(,3*(#),-3*'J()'(,3*(,",)<($*/("2(
+$1+0+1&)<'(=+,3(,3),($)#*(.)$1(,3*+/(;&6<+-),+"$'7(+'($",(O$"=$>(
(
(
F"$1+,+"$(./*)<+,%7(
F"$1+,+"$(./*)<+,%7(
(
?STU(
4IMVU(
?*',(.;/*1+-,+"$7(
!"#$%&%'()
/0-%!1(,2&23%!
4)<'*(;"'+,+0*(
?STU(
?R(W(.?R(X(4R7(
?*',(.;/*1+-,+"$7(
4)<'*($*:),+0*(
/0-%!4%56&23%!
(
4IMVU(
(
*#$+,,)
(
(
?R(W(.?R(X(4Y7(
/67.%!8#!9!:(4;-,2(4!&67.%!;(0!%36.-6&245!&'%!6::-06:<!(;!=6&:'%,#(
jXkX
9X
Results
h#H2 k b?Qrb i?2 MK2b i2bi2/- i?2 v2` 7`QK r?B+? i?Qb2
MK2b r2`2 +QMbB/2`2/X 6Q` " "Q`bQv i?2 H;Q`Bi?K +`2i2/
irQ ;`QmTbX h?2 }`bi ;`QmT ?2H/ Rd Q7 i?2 `iB+H2b FMQrM iQ ?p2
#22M r`Bii2M #v i?Bb T`iB+mH` " "Q`bQv- M/ i?2 b2+QM/ ;`QmT
+QMiBM2/ i2M KQ`2 `iB+H2b FMQrM iQ ?p2 #22M r`Bii2M #v i?Bb
p2`v bK2 T2`bQMX A/2HHv HH kd `iB+H2b rQmH/ ?p2 #22M BM i?2
}`bi ;`QmT- `2bmHiBM; BM S`2+BbBQM Q7 QMHv ejWX
h?2 p2`;2 S`2+BbBQM 7Q` i?2b2 MHvb2b rb dNWX >Qr2p2`i?2 p`B#BHBiv Bb [mBi2 ?B;?X PM2 7B`Hv +QKKQM 2``Q` b22M BM i?2
`2bmHib Q++m`b r?2M i?2 bK2 BM/BpB/mH Tm#HBb?2b `iB+H2b rBi? /B7@
!"#$%&'&()*+(&,)%&-".%(&,%(,%/0&,)%&1%"2&32*.&+)45)&,)*(%&-".%(&+%2%&5*-(4/%2%/&
d
,6620(
"2,45$%(&6-*+-&,*&)"7%&#%%-&+24,,%-&,)4(&7%21&(".%&8%2(*-9&:/%"$$1&"$$&';&"2,45$%(&+*<$/&
)"7%&#%%-&4-&,)%&342(,&=2*<80&2%(<$,4-=&4-&"&>2%54(4*-&*3&*-$1&?@A9&&
&
)&"*&+,-% /$01*('%
3*145'%
.$"*% *$&*+$2$(% +($,&+6+$(%
B&B*2"(*1&
CDD?&
;'&
'&
F&G<#%2&
'EE'&
;DH&
?I&
K&B$"<6",&
CDD?&
JI&
;&
L&B%)2%&
CDDJ&
CHE&
J&
M&K$#2%5),&
CDDD&
DCI&
;C&
N&K56%2."--&
CDDD&
CCC&
C@&
F&O7%2"%2(&
CDDI&
?D&
I&
>&P%<."--&
CDD;&
IJI&
;?&
Q&P4%#<)2&
CDD?&
CH&
;&
R&S5)(%-3%$/&
CDD?&
?J&
I&
TU&>"-&
'EEE&
'J;&
CC&
!&>4%,(5)."--&
'EE'&
DD&
'&
B&F%=%-#%2=&
'EE'&
'J&
C&
Q&U4%="-/&
CDDD&
I?&
C'&
!"#$%&$'&$(%
7*4$%
81'+&+2$%
C;&
IJ&
@D&
@E&
J'&
@'&
C?&
JE&
I&
'E&
I;&
'H&
'E&
CE&
9":'$%
!$-"&+2$%
CE&
'&
'D&
C@&
C&
CE&
J&
E&
I&
;&
D&
'&
E&
J&
8*$0+'+1,%
?@9EA&
DJ9;A&
J;9IA&
?D9HA&
DH9CA&
;?9'A&
;?9'A&
CEE9EA&
JE9EA&
;I9CA&
H@9DA&
D@9@A&
CEE9EA&
??9;A&
7";:$%<=%>004*"0?%16%(+'"#;+-4"&+1,%12$*%@A%,"#$'%01**$'51,(+,-%&1%"%B,1C,%+,(+2+(4":%16%&D"&%,"#$=%
&
!)%&"7%2"=%&>2%54(4*-&3*2&,)%(%&"-"$1(%(&+"(&;DA9&G*+%7%20&,)%&7"24"#4$4,1&4(&V<4,%&)4=)9&S-%&
3"42$1&5*..*-&%22*2&(%%-&4-&,)%&2%(<$,(&*55<2(&+)%-&,)%&(".%&4-/474/<"$&8<#$4()%(&"2,45$%(&
+4,)&/433%2%-,&(%,(&*3&5*W"<,)*2(&*-&,*845(&,)",&"2%&/4(8"2",%&%-*<=)&,*&-*,&()"2%&"-1&
/&XN%10&'EEDY&,)%&"$=*24,).&/%(524#%/&"#*7%&+4$$&
$%"7%&,+*&4-(,"-5%(&*3&,)%&(".%&8%2(*-&<-.",5)%/9&!)4(&4(&"&!"#$%&'%(")*+%&4-&,)",&,)%&-".%W
72`2Mi
b2ib Q7 +Q@mi?Q`b QM iQTB+b i?i `2 /BbT`i2 2MQm;? iQ
4-(,"-5%&4(&"((4=-%/&,*&"-*,)%2&=2*<8&+)%-&4,&4(&5$%"2$1&,)%&(".%&8%2(*-&"(&"&82%74*<($1W
MQi
b?`2 Mv `272`2M+2bX AM bm+? +b2b Q7 bTHBi T2`bQMHBiv (G2v52%",%/&=2*<8&,*&+)45)&4,&()*<$/&)"7%&#%%-&"//%/9&S-%&."1&/%54/%&,*&Z*4-&,)%(%&4-(,"-5%(&
kyyN)
i?2 H;Q`Bi?K /2b+`B#2/ #Qp2 rBHH H2p2 irQ BMbiM+2b Q7 i?2
#"(%/&*-&(*.%&*,)%2&,18%&*3&.%,"/","0&#<,&+4,)*<,&3<2,)%2&(<88*2,4-=&%74/%-5%0&,+*&
bK2
T2`bQM mMKi+?2/X h?Bb Bb 7Hb2 M2;iBp2 BM i?i i?2 MK2@
)*.*-1.*<(&-".%(&2%."4-&/433%2%-,&4-/474/<"$(9&
&
BMbiM+2
Bb bbB;M2/ iQ MQi?2` ;`QmT r?2M Bi Bb +H2`Hv i?2 bK2
K&.*2%&4-3*2.",47%&"-"$1(4(&*3&,)%&2%(<$,(&4(&8*((4#$%&+)%-&,)%&%["5,&-<.#%2&*3&4-/474/<"$(&4(&
T2`bQM
b T`2pBQmbHv@ +`2i2/ ;`QmT iQ r?B+? Bi b?QmH/ ?p2 #22M
6-*+-9&\*2&%[".8$%0&,$)%#&-"./%##"01&"-/&,$)%+%&-"./%##"01&"2%&#*,)&"5,47%&2%(%"25)%2(&
//2/X
PM2 Kv /2+B/2 iQ DQBM i?2b2 BMbiM+2b #b2/ QM bQK2 Qi?2`
$474-=&4-&B"25%$*-"9&O(,%$&+*26(&.*(,$1&4-&2%.*,%&(%-(4-=&+)4$%&O(,%7%&5*-5%-,2",%(&*-&
ivT2
Q7 K2i/i- #mi rBi?Qmi 7m`i?2` bmTTQ`iBM; 2pB/2M+2- irQ
L%*$*=19&d
]4-5$<(47%^&"-/&/4(".#4=<",%/&,)%.&4-,*&3*<2&=2*<8(9&:3&+%&,"6%&,)%&$"2=%(,&=2*<8&.",5)4-=&
?QKQMvKQmb
MK2b `2KBM /Bz2`2Mi BM/BpB/mHbX
O(,%7%&,*&#%&,)%&8*(4,47%&82%/45,4*-&]=2*<8&_C^&"-/&,)%&$"2=%(,&=2*<8&.",5)4-=&O(,%$&4(&,)%&
KQ`2
BM7Q`KiBp2
MHvbBb Q7 i?2 `2bmHib Bb TQbbB#H2 r?2M i?2
-%=",47%&82%/45,4*-&]=2*<8&_'^0&,)%-&"&5*-3<(4*-&,"#$%&5"-&#%&5*-(,2<5,%/&"-/&,)%&>2%54(4*-&
C
2t+i
MmK#2`
Q7
BM/BpB/mHb
Bb FMQrMX
6Q` 2tKTH2- 1bi2H *`@
"-/&F%5"$$&*3&,)%&/4(".#4=<",4*-&5"-&#%&5"$5<$",%/
9&
/2HH+?
M/ 1bi2p2 *`/2HH+? `2 #Qi? +iBp2 `2b2`+?2`b HBpBM; BM
&
"`+2HQMX 1bi2H rQ`Fb KQbiHv BM `2KQi2 b2MbBM; r?BH2 1bi2p2 +QM@
&
+2Mi`i2b
QM :2QHQ;vX h?2 TTHB+iBQM B/2MiB}2/ 9R `iB+H2b Tm#@
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
C
&!)4(&,18%&*3&,"#$%&4(&*3,%-&<(%/&4-&5$4-45"$&(,</4%(&,*&%7"$<",%&,)%&%33%5,47%-%((&*3&(*.%&-%+&/2<=&]3*2&
HBb?2/
#v *`/2HH+? 1 bBM+2 kyyk UBM+HmbBp2V M/ /BbK#B;mi2/
dd&
i?2K
BMiQ 7Qm` ;`QmTbX A7 r2 iF2 i?2 H`;2bi ;`QmT Ki+?BM; 1b@
i2p2 iQ #2 i?2 TQbBiBp2 T`2/B+iBQM U;`QmT ORV M/ i?2 H`;2bi ;`QmT
Ki+?BM; 1bi2H Bb i?2 M2;iBp2 T`2/B+iBQM U;`QmT OkV- i?2M +QM@
$XWKRUGLVDPELJXDWLRQIRUHQKDQFHGVFLHQFHVHUYLFHV
!
!"#$%&'(
)*"+%,&%-.(
"#$%&%!
"#$%'!
"#$%&%!
()!
*!
"#$%'!
5!
*(!
!
6%-7''!1!824!
!
!
!
+,%-.#./0!1!234!
!
!
/#0$"(12(3-.456%-.(�$"((
!%&7':7$./0!/;!$<%#%!,%#:'$#!.#!=.&%0!>?!$<%!!"##$%&'()*++%,"#-*.()*%//-)-%.#!/;!@AB2!
7$$<%E#!F*2B)GHA!I0$%,%#$.0='?J!$<%!#.0='%!%,,/,!.0!K,%L.-$./0!F7!/",'%(0*'-#-1%G!/--:,,%L!
7mbBQM i#H2 +M #2 +QMbi`m+i2/ M/ i?2 S`2+BbBQM M/ _2+HH Q7 i?2
/BbK#B;miBQM +M #2 +H+mHi2/R X
%0!"#$%'!K:>'.#<%L!70!7,$.-'%!/0!M%/'/=?J!K,%#:N7>'?!-.$.0=!/,!-/O7:$</,.0=!E.$<!/0%!/;!
M 2pHmiBQM Q7 i?2b2 `2bmHib Bb ;Bp2M #v i?2 Jii?2rb +Q``2H@
P<%!$<,%%!/",'%(.%2"#-1%'!E%,%!-/0$7.0%L!.0!7!$<.,L!=,/:K!/;!
iBQM
+Q2{+B2Mi Q7 yXdN (Jii?2rb URNd8V)X AMi2`2biBM;Hv- i?2 bBM;H2
t
2``Q` BM T`2/B+iBQM U 7Hb2 TQbBiBp2V Q++m``2/ r?2M 1bi2H Tm#HBb?2/
%!/$<%,!()!7,$.-'%#!>?!"#$%&%J!$<%!;7-$!$<7$!$<%?!#<7,%!0/!-/O7:$</,#!/,!,%;%,%0-%#!,%&%7'#!7!
M `iB+H2 QM :2QHQ;v- T`2bmK#Hv +BiBM; Q` +Q@mi?Q`BM; rBi? QM2
$.0-$!,%#%7,-<!$/K.-A!9'$</:=<!0/$!$<%!=/7'!/;!7:$</,!L.#7N>.=:7$./0J!$<%#%!;7'#%!0%=7$.&%#!
Q7 1bi2p2b mbmH +QHH#Q`iQ`bX h?2 i?`22 7Hb2 M2;iBp2b r2`2 +QM@
0!>%!/;!.0$%,%#$!.0!-<7,7-$%,.#.0=!$<%!L.;;%,%0$!7#K%-$#!!+%,<7K#!
iBM2/ BM i?B`/ ;`QmT Q7 2t+HmbBp2Hv 1bi2p2b `iB+H2bX q?BH2 i?2b2
%!.0L.&.L:7'!.#!7-$.&%!.0!$E/!L.#$.0-$!;.%'L#J!/,!$<%!#%K7,7$%!=,/:K.0=#!N.=<$!.0L.-7$%!
b?QmH/ ?p2 #22M +QHH2+i2/ BMiQ i?2 }`bi ;`QmT rBi? i?2 Qi?2` k8
;%,%0$!K<7#%#!/;!$<%.,!-7,%%,A!
`iB+H2b #v 1bi2p2- i?2 7+i i?i i?2v b?`2 MQ +Q@mi?Q`b Q` `27@
,Q!E.$<A!V%-/0L'?J!$<%!7KK'.-7$./0!,:0#!.0!7!N700%,J!,%W:.,.0=!/0'?!$E/!K.%-%#!
.0;/,N7$./0!F7!07N%!70L!$<%!?%7,!;,/N!E<.-<!$/!>%=.0!-/''%-$.0=!,%-/,L#G!70L!7!;%E!
R h?Bb ivT2 Q7 i#H2 Bb Q7i2M mb2/ BM +HBMB+H bim/B2b iQ 2pHmi2 i?2 2z2+iBp2M2bb Q7 bQK2
0:$%#!$/!/,=70.X%!$<%!,%-/,L#!.0$/!=,/:K#A!P<.#!N%70#!$<7$!$<%!7KK'.-7$./0!-70!>%!:#%L!>?!
M2r /`m; U7Q` 2tKTH2VX h?2 MQ`KH i2`KBMQHQ;v Bb i?2M *QM/BiBQM 7Q` i?2 +QHmKMb
/#%!E</!<7&%!0/!>7-Q=,/:0L!.0!>.>'./N%$,.-#!/,!K,/=,7NN.0=A!S0!$<%!/$<%,!<70LJ!$<%!
M/ h`2iK2Mi 7Q` i?2 `QrbX
.$7$./0#!/;!$<.#!7KK,/7-<!.0-':L%!$<%!=,%7$!L%7'!/;!&7,.7>.'.$?!.0!$<%!K,%-.#./0!/;!$<%!,%#:'$#!
L!$<%!.0;'%Y.>.'.$?!/;!$<%!7'=/,.$<N!$/!7--/:0$!;/,!K:>'.-7$./0!K7$$%,0#!$<7$!L/!0/$!;.$!$<%!
/L%'A!!
0%E!&%,#./0#!/;!$<%!L7$7>7#%!>%-/N%!7&7.'7>'%J!7LL.$./07'!$?K%#!/;!N%$7L7$7!-70!>%!
':L%L!.0$/!$<%!7'=/,.$<N!$/!.0-,%7#%!.$#!7--:,7-?A!Z?!%Y$%0L.0=!$<%!N%$7L7$7!:#%L!;/,!
NK7,.#/0!$/!.0-':L%!.0#$.$:$./07'!7;;.'.7$./0!.$!.#!'.Q%'?!$<7$!$<%!,%L:-$./0!.0!#:K%,;':/:#!
N%#!-70!>%!;:,$<%,!.NK,/&%LA!Z%-7:#%!$<%!#K%''.0=!/;!$<%!07N%!$/!>%!L.#7N>.=:7$%L!.#!0/$!
,6620(
QMHv 9dW U1bi2H M/ 1bi2p2 2+? ;2i QM2 ;`QmT- K2MBM; i?i i?2
jy Qi?2` ;`QmTb `2 mMM2+2bb`vVX
Pp2`HH- i?2 /pMi;2b Q7 i?2 TT`Q+? T`2b2Mi2/ ?2`2 `2 irQ@
7QH/, 6B`bi- i?2 TTHB+iBQM +?B2p2b 7B`Hv ;QQ/ `2bmHib- 2bT2+BHHv
+QMbB/2`BM; i?i Bi QMHv ?b irQ ivT2b Q7 K2i/i iQ rQ`F rBi?X
a2+QM/Hv- i?2 TTHB+iBQM `mMb BM ?M/b Qz KMM2`- `2[mB`BM;
QMHv irQ TB2+2b Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM U MK2 M/ i?2 v2` 7`QK r?B+? iQ
#2;BM +QHH2+iBM; `2+Q`/bV M/ 72r KBMmi2b iQ Q`;MBx2 i?2 `2+Q`/b
BMiQ ;`QmTbX h?Bb K2Mb i?i i?2 TTHB+iBQM +M #2 mb2/ #v i?Qb2
r?Q ?p2 MQ #+F;`QmM/ BM #B#HBQK2i`B+b Q` T`Q;`KKBM;X PM i?2
Qi?2` ?M/- i?2 HBKBiiBQMb Q7 i?Bb TT`Q+? BM+Hm/2 i?2 ;`2i /2H
Q7 p`B#BHBiv BM i?2 T`2+BbBQM Q7 i?2 `2bmHib M/ i?2 BM~2tB#BHBiv Q7
i?2 H;Q`Bi?K iQ ++QmMi 7Q` Tm#HB+iBQM Tii2`Mb i?i /Q MQi }i
i?2 KQ/2HX
b M2r p2`bBQMb Q7 i?2 /i#b2 #2+QK2 pBH#H2- //BiBQMH
ivT2b Q7 K2i/i +M #2 BM+Hm/2/ BMiQ i?2 H;Q`Bi?K iQ BM+`2b2
Bib ++m`+vX "v 2ti2M/BM; i?2 K2i/i mb2/ 7Q` +QKT`BbQM iQ
BM+Hm/2 BMbiBimiBQMH {HBiBQM Bi Bb HBF2Hv i?i i?2 `2/m+iBQM BM bm@
T2`~mQmb MK2b +M #2 7m`i?2` BKT`Qp2/X "2+mb2 i?2 bT2HHBM; Q7
i?2 MK2 iQ #2 /BbK#B;mi2/ Bb MQi iF2M BMiQ +QMbB/2`iBQM #v
i?2 H;Q`Bi?K- i?2 `2bmHib `2 i?2Q`2iB+HHv b ;QQ/ 7Q` p2`v
+QKKQM MK2b b 7Q` ``2` QM2bX
Discussion
h?2 KBMBKHBbiB+ TT`Q+? iQ mi?Q` /BbK#B;miBQM T`2b2Mi2/
?2`2 /2KQMbi`i2b ?Qr 7B`Hv ++m`i2 `2bmHib +M #2 Q#iBM2/ mb@
BM; QMHv HBKBi2/ KQmMi Q7 K2i/iX h?2 i2+?MB[m2 7Q` /QBM;
i?Bb b?QmH/ #2 Q7 BMi2`2bi 7Q` i?2 a+B2M+2 kXy ivT2 Q7 bQ+BH K2/B
b2`pB+2b bm+? b *Bi2lGBF2 Q` J2M/2H2v i?i `2 7Q`mKb 7Q` b?`BM;
`272`2M+2b M/ 7Q` #mBH/BM; +QMM2+iBQMb rBi?BM i?2 `2b2`+? +QK@
KmMBivX h?2b2 /Q MQi ?p2 HH Q7 i?2 #B#HBQ;`T?B+ /i i?i
/i#b2 Q7 Tm#HB+iBQMb ?b Ubm+? b i?2 q2# Q7 a+B2M+2V- v2i i?2v
biBHH b22F iQ T`QpB/2 bT+2 r?2`2 Tm#HBb?2/ `2b2`+? Bb Q`;MBx2/X
*m``2MiHv- *Bi2lGBF2 KF2b MQ ii2KTi iQ /BbK#B;mi2 mi?Q`
MK2bX PM2 +M #`Qrb2 *Bi2lGBF2 #v mi?Q` MK2- 7QHHQrBM; i?2
HBMF 7`QK i?2 mi?Q` Q7 QM2 `iB+H2 iQ b22 HBbi Q7 HH `iB+H2b #v
$XWKRUGLVDPELJXDWLRQIRUHQKDQFHGVFLHQFHVHUYLFHV
,6620(
Conclusion
h?2 mi?Q`Biv +QMi`QH Q7 BMbiM+2b Q7 mi?Q` MK2b Bb M QM;Q@
BM; +QM+2`M 7Q` i?2 ++m`i2 K2bm`2K2Mi Q7 b+B2MiB}+ Tm#HB+iBQM
Tii2`MbX _2b2`+? BMiQ mi?Q`@MK2 /BbK#B;miBQM Bb Tm`bmBM;
`M;2 Q7 TT`Q+?2b `M;BM; 7`QK Ki+?BM; QM i?2 bvMit Q7 i?2
MK2b iQ KQ`2 i2+?MB[m2b i?i 2KTHQv /pM+2/ biiBbiB+H MHvbBbX
u2i i?2 Hii2` Bb Q7 MQ mb2 BM B/2MiB7vBM; BM/BpB/mHb r?Q b?`2 i?2
bK2 MK2- M/ i?2 Hii2` ?b QMHv #22M TTHB2/ iQ bKHH- +m`i2/
/ib2ib UBX2X +QMiBMBM; QMHv `2+Q`/b rBi? i?2 7mHH +QKTH2K2Mi Q7
K2i/iVX h?2 KBMBKHBbi TT`Q+? T`2b2Mi2/ ?2`2 Qz2`b #H@
M+2 #2ir22M ++m`+v M/ T`+iB+HBivX Ai Bb 7bi M/ b+H#H2X AM
//BiBQM- #2+mb2 Bi `2HB2b QM QMHv irQ ivT2b Q7 K2i/i- Bi +M #2
/Ti2/ 7Q` mb2 BM a+B2M+2 kXy r2# b2`pB+2b bm+? b *Bi2lGBF2 r?2`2
mb2`b b?`2 mM+m`i2/ BM7Q`KiBQMX h?2 TTHB+iBQM /2b+`B#2/ ?2`2
bm;;2bib i?i Bi /Q2b MQi Hrvb ?p2 iQ #2 i?2 mb2`b i?i /Q i?2
HBMFBM;X aQK2 miQKiBQM UQ` ?v#`B/ TT`Q+?V rQmH/ H2p2`;2
i?2 BMTmi Q7 i?2 +QKKmMBivX
Bibliography
,6620(
,6620(
THi7Q`Kb #v Q`;MBbiBQMb BM Tm`bmBi Q7 i?2B` ;QHb UJ+722 kyyNTX djVX h?Bb `2b2`+? BMp2biB;i2b i?2 /2iBH Q7 1Mi2`T`Bb2 kXyc i?2
mb2 Q7 bQ+BH K2/B rBi?BM p`B2iv Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM T`+iB+2b BM Q`@
;MBbiBQMH +QMi2tibX Ai 2tKBM2b ?Qr BM7Q`KiBQM T`Q72bbBQMHb
2K#2/ i?2 iQQHb Q7 bQ+BH K2/B BM i?2B` T`+iB+2 M/ B/2MiB}2b i?2
/pMi;2b- `BbFb M/ i`Mb7Q`KiBQMb i?i Kv `2bmHiX
AM7Q`KiBQM ;2M+B2b bB;MH i?2B` rBHHBM;M2bb iQ BM+Q`TQ`i2 bQ@
+BH K2/B BM i?2B` T`+iB+2b rBi? H#2Hb bm+? b GB#``v kXy i?i
ii2KTi iQ bbQ+Bi2 HB#``B2b KQ`2 /B`2+iHv rBi? i?2 +?`+i2`BbiB+
M/ i2+?MQHQ;B2b Q7 r2# kXy U"H+F kyydVX "BH2vb Ukyy3V _2+Q`/b
JM;2K2Mi kXy +?HH2M;2b i?2 b+QT2 M/ i?2Q`v Q7 i?2 `2+Q`/b
KM;2K2Mi i`/BiBQM BM i?2 HB;?i Q7 bQ+BH K2/BX h?2 BM7Q`K@
iBQM b2+iQ` i H`;2 HQQFb iQ i?2 M2r i2+?MQHQ;B2b Q7 bQ+BH K2/B
FMQrBM; i?i Bi Kmbi 2M;;2X "Qi? SHmi+?F UkyyeV M/ *`r7Q`/
UkyyeV +?HH2M;2 i?2 mb2 Q7 bm+? H#2Hb- bm;;2biBM; i?i i?2 `/B+H
+?M;2 i?i Bb BKTHB2/ Bb ?vT2 M/ i?i BMMQpiBQM M/ /QTiBQM Q7
bQ+BH K2/B rBHH Hrvb #2 +QMiBMmQmb M/ 2pQHmiBQM`v HBF2 HH
i2+?MQHQ;B2b #27Q`2 i?2KX
h?Bb `2b2`+? Bb bBimi2/ rBi?BM +m``2Mi mbi`HBM M/ BMi2`M@
iBQMH ii2KTib iQ T`QpB/2 2tTHB+Bi bi`i2;B+ M/ TQHB+v TQbBiBQMb
#Qmi i?2 mb2 M/ #2M2}ib Q7 r2# kXy i2+?MQHQ;v rBi?BM ;Qp2`M@
K2MiX ibF7Q`+2- 2bi#HBb?2/ #v i?2 mbi`HBM 62/2`H :Qp2`M@
K2Mi- `2TQ`i2/ BM kyyN- i?2 KMv #2M2}ib M/ QTTQ`imMBiB2b 7@
7Q`/2/ #v i?2 /QTiBQM Q7 bQ+BH K2/B BM i?2 rQ`F Q7 ;Qp2`MK2MiX
h?2 TTHB+iBQM Q7 r2# kXy +QHH#Q`iBp2 iQQHb M/ BMi2`+iBpBiB2b iQ
i?2 T`Q+2bb2b Q7 ;Qp2`MK2Mi Bb QM2 Q7 i?2 i?`22 TBHH`b Q7 :Qp2`M@
K2Mi kXy ++Q`/BM; iQ i?2 mbi`HBM _2TQ`i Q7 i?2 :Qp2`MK2Mi kXy
hbF7Q`+2- 1M;;2, :2iiBM; QM rBi? :Qp2`MK2Mi kXyX h?2 `2TQ`i
+HBKb UTX jV i?i b i?2v ?p2 QmibB/2 Q7 ;Qp2`MK2Mi- i?2b2 iQQHb
M/ T`+iB+2b +M BM+`2b2 T`Q/m+iBpBiv M/ 2{+B2M+v rBi?BM i?2
;Qp2`MK2Mi b2+iQ`X
u2i- LB+QHb :`m2M UkyRyV- i?2 +?B` Q7 i?2 :Qp2`MK2Mi kXy
ibF7Q`+2 bm#b2[m2MiHv bii2b i?i :Qp2`MK2Mi kXy Bb mHiBKi2Hv
#Qmi r?i BM/BpB/mH ;2M+B2b- M/ v2b- BM/BpB/mH Tm#HB+ b2`pMib
/Q iQ KF2 Bi ?TT2MX AM ++Q`/ rBi? :`m2Mb /pB+2- i?Bb `2b2`+?
KQp2b rv 7`QK iQT@/QrM bi`i2;v- TQHB+v M/ KM;2K2Mi i?i
`2+QKK2M/b M/ /B`2+ib i?2 /QTiBQM Q7 bQ+BH K2/B M/ b22Fb
7KHXVHRIVRFLDOPHGLDWHFKQRORJLHVLQWKHZRUNSUDFWLFHV
,6620(
7KHXVHRIVRFLDOPHGLDWHFKQRORJLHVLQWKHZRUNSUDFWLFHV
Bibliography
,6620(
#bi`+i
:K2b ?p2 HQM; #22M mb2/ 7Q` Tm`TQb2b `M;BM; 7`QK 2Mi2`iBM@
K2Mi iQ KBHBi`v i`BMBM;X h?Bb TT2` T`2b2Mib i?2 mb2 Q7 ;K2bT`iB+mH`Hv T?vbB+H 7Q`Kb Q7 `QH2@THvBM;- 7Q` i?2 Tm`TQb2 Q7 i2bi@
BM; BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQ` i?2Q`B2bX AM Bi- +b2 2tKTH2 ;K2b `2
2tKBM2/- rBi? T`iB+mH` 2KT?bBb QM i?2 rv i?2v ?p2 #22M
mb2/ iQ bim/v ?Qr +Q;MBiBp2 mi?Q`Biv 7Q` b2+QM/@?M/ BM7Q`K@
iBQM Bb 7Q`K2/X
Introduction
h?Bb `iB+H2 /2b+`B#2b i?2 /2bB;M Q7 +2`iBM FBM/b Q7 bKHH T?vbB+H
T`2i2M+2 ;K2b- /QM2 7Q` i?2 Tm`TQb2 Q7 mbBM; i?Qb2 ;K2b b BM@
7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQ` H#Q`iQ`B2bX :K2b ?p2 HQM; ?BbiQ`v Q7 mb2
b i2+?BM; iQQHb- ;QBM; #+F i H2bi jyyy v2`b UGBM2K- kyyjVX
PM2 Q7 i?2 KQbi +2Mi`H rb E`B2;bTB2H- Tm#HBb?2/ BM R3k9 #v >2``
pQM _2BbbrBix M/ ?Bb bQM- M/ mb2/ iQ i`BM S`mbbBM Q{+2`b iQ
bm+? M 2{+B2M+v i?i i?2 T`+iB+2 [mB+FHv bT`2/ iQ Qi?2` MiBQMbX
q?2M Q{+2`b `2iB`2/ M/ #2+K2 #mbBM2bbK2M- i?2v iQQF i?2 B/2
Q7 bBKmHiBQM@#b2/ i`BMBM; rBi? i?2K- ;BpBM; #B`i? iQ i?2 T`+iB+2
Q7 #mbBM2bb bBKmHiBQMf;K2b- biBHH mb2/ BM 2+QMQKB+b 2/m+iBQM BM@
biBimiBQMb `QmM/ i?2 rQ`H/ U>2M`BFb2M- kyyNVX
AM //BiBQM iQ bim/2Mi i`BMBM;- bm+? ;K2b ;2i HbQ /2THQv2/ BM
rQ`FTH+2b- 7Q` i?2 Tm`TQb2 Q7 BKT`QpBM; +Q`TQ`i2 T2`7Q`KM+2- BM@
?Qmb2 +QKKmMB+iBQM- M/ bQ QMX h?2v p2`v 2z2+iBp2Hv M2;i2 2t@
BbiBM;- T`Q#H2KiB+ K2MiH KQ/2Hb Uhbm+?Bv hbm+?Bv- RNNNV M/
,6620(
i2+? bvbi2KB+ i?BMFBM; Ub T2` a2M;2- kyyeV- b i?2v i?2Kb2Hp2b `2
?B;?Hv +QMi`QHH2/ BM7Q`KiBQM bvbi2Kb +T#H2 Q7 b?QrBM; 2ti2M/2/
+mb2@M/@2z2+i T?2MQK2M U>`pBBM2M GB2#2`Qi?- BM T`2bbVX
h?2 ;K2b /Bb+mbb2/ BM i?Bb `iB+H2 ?p2 #22M /2p2HQT2/ #v +QK#BM@
BM; i`Bib 7`QK bm+? Q`;MBxiBQMH H2`MBM; bBKmHiBQMf;K2b M/
7`QK HBp2@+iBQM `QH2@THvBM; UH`TV- ;K2b r?2`2 T`iB+BTMib T?vb@
B+HHv THv }+iBQMH +?`+i2`b BM }+iBp2 Q` Hi2`2/ b2iiBM;b U"`2MM2kyy8c JQMiQH- ai2M`Qb q2`M- kyyNVX hQQHb 7`QK Tbv+?Q/`K
Ub T2` JQ`2MQ- RN8jV ?p2 HbQ #22M //2/- bQ b iQ 7+BHBii2 i?2
+QKKmMBiv@7Q`KBM; bT2+i Q7 bm+? ;K2b Ub T2` "QrKM- kyRyVX
h?2v r2`2 /2bB;M2/ iQ #2 bm{+B2MiHv `2HBbiB+ UbBKmHiBQM@HBF2V bQ
b iQ T`QpB/2 `2HB#H2 `2bmHib- v2i MQi bQ `2HBbiB+ i?i T`iB+BTMib
rQmH/ bi`i HQQFBM; 7Q` /2T`im`2b 7`QK `2HBiv BMbi2/ Q7 HBF2M2bb2b
rBi? Bi Ub T2` GB2#2`Qi? >`pBBM2M- BM T`2bbVX
'HVLJQLQJ*DPHVIRU7HVWLQJ,QIRUPDWLRQ%HKDYLRU7KHRULHV
,6620(
'HVLJQLQJ*DPHVIRU7HVWLQJ,QIRUPDWLRQ%HKDYLRU7KHRULHV
,6620(
'HVLJQLQJ*DPHVIRU7HVWLQJ,QIRUPDWLRQ%HKDYLRU7KHRULHV
,6620(
R
a2`T2Mi Q7 b? /2Hb rBi? i?2 bm`pBpQ`b Q7 `2HB;BQmb +mHi r?Qb2 H2/2` ?b /B2/r?B+? K2Mb bmBi#H2 bi`i2;B+ BM7Q`KiBQM- BM //BiBQMH iQ i?i Q7 ;2M2`H BMi2`2bi- Bb
pBH#H2 BM #mM/M+2 /m`BM; THvX
k h?2 ;K2 Kbi2` Q` /2bB;M2` Bb #v /27mHi +QMbB/2`2/ M 2tT2`i M/ +Q;MBiBp2
mi?Q`Biv `2;`/BM; i?2 ;K2- #mi Bb ;K2@2ti2`MH QM2X A7 i?2 ;K2 Kbi2` THvb
'HVLJQLQJ*DPHVIRU7HVWLQJ,QIRUPDWLRQ%HKDYLRU7KHRULHV
+?`+i2`- i?i +?`+i2` b +Q;MBiBp2 mi?Q`Biv Bb pHm2@Dm/;2/ Dmbi b HH i?2 Qi?2`bX
aQK2 THv2`b Kv- ?Qr2p2`- mb2 Qmi@Q7@;K2 FMQrH2/;2 iQ Dm/;2 ;K2 Kbi2` @THv2/
+?`+i2` b TQi2MiBHHv bmT2`BQ` BM7Q`KiBQM bQm`+2 U>`pBBM2M- kyyeVX
,6620(
bBKBH` KMM2`- M TT`2Mi H+F Q7 2tT2`iBb2 BM MQi?2` `2H2pMi }2H/ Kv `2bmHi
BM /BbKBbbH Q7 +imH 2tT2`iBb2 BM i?2 T`BK`v `2X 6Q` 2tKTH2- H2/2`b?BT bFBHHb i2M/
iQ ;2i /Bb`2;`/2/ BM bBKmHiBQMb- B7 i?2 TQi2MiBH H2/2` ?b i`Qm#H2 rBi? i?2 i2+?MB+H
BMi2`7+2 UGBbF- ETHM+HB _B;;BQ- BM T`2bbVX
9 h?2 bK2 `2+iBQMb r2`2 /2i2+i2/ `2;`/H2bb Q7 THvBM; ;`QmT, *`BiB+- 7Q` BMbiM+2rb Q`B;BMHHv `mM i M BMi2`+iBp2 `ib 72biBpH- #mi ?b bBM+2 #22M mb2/ HbQ BM b+?QQHbQi?2` `i 72biBpHb M/ `2iB`2K2Mi +QKKmMBivX
'HVLJQLQJ*DPHVIRU7HVWLQJ,QIRUPDWLRQ%HKDYLRU7KHRULHV
8 h?i
i?2 +?`+i2`b `2 ;Bp2M i?2 MK2b M/ bi2`2QivTB+H i`Bib Q7 MBKHb bbBbib BM
i?Bb b72 /BbiM+BM;X
e S2`bQMH p`B#H2b Kv HbQ z2+i BM@;K2 BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQ`X 6Q` 2tKTH2- bQK2@
i?BM; /B2;2iB+ i?i +mib iQQ +HQb2 iQ THv2`b T2`bQMH i`mKb Kv +mb2 bB;MB}+Mi
#`2F Ua+?B+F- kyy3VX
,6620(
'HVLJQLQJ*DPHVIRU7HVWLQJ,QIRUPDWLRQ%HKDYLRU7KHRULHV
,6620(
'HVLJQLQJ*DPHVIRU7HVWLQJ,QIRUPDWLRQ%HKDYLRU7KHRULHV
Conclusions
aQ- r?i /Q r2 2bb2MiBHHv ?p2 ?2`2\ 1bBHv /2bB;M2/- ?B;?Hv
+QMi`QHH2/ bQ+BH BM7Q`KiBQM 2MpB`QMK2Mib- BMiQ r?B+? i?2 Q`;M@
Bx2` +M BMTmi /i r?BH2 FMQrBM; i?2 F2v p`B#H2bX h?2v `2
Q#b2`p#H2 /m`BM; i?2B` `mM@iBK2- M/ +M B7 M2+2bb`v #2 `2+Q`/2/b +M i?2B` /2#`B2}M;bX "v +?M;BM; BM+2MiBp2b- M/ BM+2MiBp2 BM@
i2MbBiv H2p2Hb- i?2 /2bB;M2` +M HbQ Q#b2`p2 +?M;2b BM BM7Q`KiBQM
#2?pBQ` Tii2`MbX 6m`i?2`KQ`2- B7 i?2 ;K2 Bb ;QQ/- i?2 THv2`b
rBHH rMi iQ bT2F #Qmi Bi iQ ;`2i 2ti2Mi 7i2`r`/b- b r2HH b
bT`2/ i?2 ;K2 iQ M2r m/B2M+2bX q?BH2 MQi `2HB#H2 b 2tT2`@
BK2Mib iQ ;`2i 2ti2Mi- i?2 M2r `mMb iQQ T`QpB/2 /i QM ?Qr
i?i T`iB+mH` bvbi2K b22Kb iQ rQ`F- M/ ?Qr `2HB#H2 i?2 BMBiBH
}M/BM;b `2X
h?Bb Bb #mi T`2HBKBM`v bi;2X 1tT2`BK2Mib rBi? bm+? ;K2b
b22K iQ TQBMi iQr`/b i?2`2 #2BM; /2}MBi2 i2KTHi2b- Q` Tii2`MbQ7 BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQ`- ;Qp2`M2/ #v bQ+BH +QMi`+ib M/ 2tT2+i@
iBQMbX h?`Qm;? `iB}+BH `2bi`B+iBQMb- r2 #`BM; #Qi? i?2 Tii2`Mb
M/ i?2 `mH2b ;Qp2`MBM; i?2K iQ i?2 7Q`2X h?2v +M i?2M #2 +QK@
T`2/ iQ KQ`2 +HBMB+H /i- b r2HH b 2`HB2` 2tT2`BK2Mib rBi?
bBKBH` ;K2bX GBF2 Qi?2` H#Q`iQ`v 2tT2`BK2Mib- i?2b2 ;K2@i2bib
d JMv
+m``2Mi@/v H`Tb H`2/v 2z2+iBp2Hv Ki+? EH##2`b +`Bi2`B- #mi i?2 H#Q`i@
Q`v TT`Q+? K2i?Q/QHQ;v /Q2b MQi v2i HHQr 7Q` i?i H2p2H Q7 +`2iBp2 7`22/QK r?2M
Bi Bb BM mb2X
,6620(
`2 MQi iQiHHv `2HB#H2- #mi i?i Bb i?2 Mim`2 Q7 Mv 2tT2`BK2Mi
rBi? ?mKM 7+iQ`X
h?2b2 2tT2`BK2Mib ?p2 QM2 7m`i?2` /pMi;2 rQ`i? K2MiBQM@
BM;, .QM2 r2HH- i?2v `2 ;`2i 2tT2`B2M+2b 7Q` HH BMpQHp2/X S2QTH2
HQp2 ;K2b- M/ Bi b?QrbX q?2M rb i?2 Hbi iBK2 vQm /B/ H#Q`@
iQ`v 2tT2`BK2Mi QM BM7Q`KiBQM +iBpBiv- M/ ;Qi i?2 T`iB+BTMib
iQ b?Qmi h?Bb rb ;`2i5 A rMi iQ iF2 i?Bb ?QK2 rBi? K2 M/
`mM Bi 7Q` Kv 7`B2M/b5 r?2M Bi 2M/2/\ A ;2i i?i HH i?2 iBK2- THmb
i?2 +imH /i `2bmHibX
Funding
h?Bb TT2` rb r`Bii2M rBi? i?2 ?2HT Q7 ;`Mi 7`QK i?2 lMB@
p2`bBiv Q7 hKT2`2X
Bibliography
,6620(
%,%/,2*5$3+<
,6620(
%,%/,2*5$3+<
,6620(
%,%/,2*5$3+<
(8d) amBib- "X URNd3VX h?2 ;`bb?QTT2`, :K2b- HB72 M/ miQTBX
hQ`QMiQ, lMBp2`bBiv Q7 hQ`QMiQ S`2bbX
(83) hQ//- _X CX URNNNVX liBHBxiBQM Q7 ?2`QBM BM7Q`KiBQM #v /@
QH2b+2Mi ;B`Hb BM mbi`HB, +Q;MBiBp2 MHvbBbX CQm`MH Q7
i?2 K2`B+M aQ+B2iv 7Q` AM7Q`KiBQM a+B2M+2- 8yURV- Ry@kjX
(8N) h_A"lLG- h>1 UkyRyVX (.2p2HQT2/ #v CX hX >`pBBM2M)X
iQiH Q7 e `mMb BM "2H`mb- 6BMHM/ M/ LQ`rvX
(ey) hbm+?Bv- hX hbm+?Bv- aX URNNNVX h?2 mMB[m2 +QMi`B#m@
iBQM Q7 ;KBM;fbBKmHiBQM, hQr`/b 2bi#HBb?K2Mi Q7 i?2
/Bb+BTHBM2X AM .X amM/2`b CX a2p2`M- U1/bXV h?2 BMi2`M@
iBQMH bBKmHiBQM ;KBM; `2b2`+? v2`#QQF, aBKmHiBQMb
;K2b 7Q` bi`i2;v M/ TQHB+v THMMBM;X UTTX 9e@8dVX EQ;M
S;2, GQM/QMX
(eR) o`iBBM2M- GX Uky RyVX u?i2BbHHBM2M FbBiv, o2`FQbiQD iBiQD D v?i2BbB 2HKvFbB (>M/B+`7ib M/ b2Mb2 Q7 +QK@
KmMBiv, L2irQ`Fb- bFBHHb M/ b?`2/ 2tT2`B2M+2b)X .Q+iQ`H
/Bbb2`iiBQMX CQ2Mbmm, lMBp2`bBiv Q7 1bi2`M 6BMHM/X
(ek) qHiQM- EX GX URNNyVX JBK2bBb b KF2@#2HB2p2, PM i?2 7QmM/@
iBQMb Q7 i?2 `2T`2b2MiiBQMH `ibX *K#`B/;2, >`p`/ lMB@
p2`bBiv S`2bbX
(ej) qBHbQM- SX URNdjVX aBimiBQMH `2H2pM+2X AM7Q`KiBQM aiQ`;2
_2i`B2pH- NU3V- 98d@9dRX
(e9) qBHbQM- SX URNddVX Sm#HB+ FMQrH2/;2- T`Bpi2 B;MQ`M+2, hQ@
r`/ HB#``v M/ BM7Q`KiBQM TQHB+vX q2biTQ`i, :`22MrQQ/X
(e8) qBHbQM- SX URN3jVX a2+QM/@?M/ FMQrH2/;2, M BM[mB`v BMiQ
+Q;MBiBp2 mi?Q`BivX q2biTQ`i, :`22MrQQ/X
(ee) qBHbQM- hX qHb?- *X URNNeVX AM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQm`, M
BMi2`/Bb+BTHBM`v T2`bT2+iBp2 (1H2+i`QMB+ p2`bBQM)X h?2 "`BiBb?
GB#``v "Q`/X
,6620(
Author description
CX hmQKb >`pBBM2M UJXh?V Bb +?B27 HB#``BM r?Q 7i2` Kb@
i2`b /2;`22 BM i?2QHQ;v #2+K2 M BM7Q`KiBQM bim/B2b M/ ;K2
b+?QH`X >2 Bb +m``2MiHv r`BiBM; ?Bb /Q+iQ`H /Bbb2`iiBQM i i?2
lMBp2`bBiv Q7 hKT2`2- 6BMHM/- QM `BimHBbiB+ ;K2b b BM7Q`K@
iBQM bvbi2KbX >`pBBM2M HbQ T`Q72bbBQMHHv /2bB;Mb ;K2b 7Q`
2Mi2`iBMK2Mi- `i 2p2Mib- M/ b 2/m+iBQMH M/ Q`;MBxiBQMH
H2`MBM; iQQHbX
,6620(
2QVRFLDOPHGLDDQGGRFXPHQWWKHRU\
`2HiBQM #2ir22M i?2 pB`imH rQ`H/ M/ #HQ;b #Qmi Bi- M/ ?Qr QM2
`2T`2b2Mib- `2K2/Bi2b- M/ `27Q`Kb- i?2 Qi?2` U"QHi2` :`mbBMRNNNVX
h?2 ii2KTi iQ mM/2`biM/ M/ 2tTHQ`2 i?2 bQ+BH Mim`2 Q7 /Q+@
mK2Mib +2Mi`H i2M2i Q7 /Q+mK2Mi i?2Q`v `2bQMi2 rBi? i?2
MQiBQM Q7 `2+Q`/- 7mM/K2MiH +QM+2Ti BM `+?BpH b+B2M+2 b r2HH
b QM2 Q7 i?2 KQbi #bB+ mMBib Q7 i?2 `+?Bp2X AM i`/BiBQMH `+?BpH
i?Qm;?i- i?2 `2+Q`/ Bb M2mi`H Q#D2+i i?i T`QpB/2b mi?2MiB+ BM@
7Q`KiBQM #Qmi i?2 +QMi2ti Q7 Bib +`2iBQM Uh?QKbb2M- kyyRVX
>Qr2p2`- TQbiKQ/2`M `+?BpH b+B2M+2 bb2`ib i?i i?2 `2+Q`/ Bb
bQ+BHHv +QMbi`m+i2/ M/- 7m`i?2`KQ`2- ++2Mimi2b i?2 M22/ iQ /2@
p2HQT M2r `+?BpH 7`K2rQ`Fb M/ T`+iB+2b QM i?2 #bBb Q7 i?Bb
pB2rTQBMi U*QQF- kyyRc h`+2- kyykVX
,6620(
i?Bb rvX HH Q7 i?2 #HQ;b r2`2 r`Bii2M BM 1M;HBb? M/ +iBp2 i
i?2 iBK2 Q7 /i +QHH2+iBQMX _2H2pMi #HQ; TQbib r2`2 B/2MiB}2/
mbBM; i?2 #HQ;b #mBHi@BM b2`+? iQQHb M/ 7QHFbQMQKB+ i;b- M/ b2@
H2+i2/ 7Q` MHvbBb mbBM; Tm`TQbBp2 bKTHBM; UqBH/2Kmi?- kyyNVX
h?2 /i rb MHvx2/ mbBM; +Q@rQ`/ MHvbBb- +QMi2Mi MHvbBb@
K2i?Q/ /2bB;M2/ iQ K2bm`2 i?2 7`2[m2M+v M/ +Q@Q++m``2M+2 Q7
HBM;mBbiB+ mMBib UrQ`/b- TB`b Q7 rQ`/b- T?`b2bV BM #Q/v Q7 i2ti
U*Qm`iBH- RNN9c *HHQM- 2i HX- RN3jc >2- RNNNVX JmHiB/BK2MbBQMH
b+HBM; UJ.aV rb mb2/ iQ pBbmHBx2 i?2 BMi2``2HiBQMb #2ir22M i?2
BM/2t2/ i2`Kb BM irQ@/BK2MbBQMH M2irQ`F KTb bmBi#H2 7Q` [mH@
BiiBp2 BMi2`T`2iiBQM U>QHK#2`;- 2i HX- kyyNVX h?2 MHvbBb rb
T2`7Q`K2/ mbBM; "B#1t+2H- M BM7QK2i`B+ +QKTmi2` bQ7ir`2 iQQH
r`Bii2M 2bT2+BHHv 7Q` i?Bb Tm`TQb2 US2`bbQM- kyyeVX *Q@rQ`/ M@
HvbBb rb +?Qb2M b i?2 K2i?Q/ Q7 /i MHvbBb #2+mb2 Bi HHQrb
7Q` 2{+B2Mi B/2MiB}+iBQM- [mMiB}+iBQM- M/ BMi2`HBMF;2 Q7 i?2
/QKBMMi KQ/2b Q7 HBM;mBbiB+ 2tT`2bbBQMb `2T`2b2MiiBQMb BM
H`;2 b2i Q7 i2tib- b r2HH b M 2bBHv ++2bbB#H2 rv iQ bvMi?2bBx2
M/ T`2b2Mi i?2b2 `2bmHib BM ;`T?B+H `2T`2b2MiiBQM r2HH@bmBi2/
7Q` [mHBiiBp2 MHvbBbX
2QVRFLDOPHGLDDQGGRFXPHQWWKHRU\
Bibliography
,6620(
%,%/,2*5$3+<
,6620(
Introduction
1i?MQ;`T?B+HHv BMbTB`2/ K2i?Q/b ?p2 BM `2+2Mi v2`b #22M bm+@
+2bb7mHHv TTHB2/ BM AM7Q`KiBQM a+B2M+2 UAaV `2b2`+? QM /Bz2`2Mi
7Q`Kb Q7 bQ+BH K2/B `2Hi2/ T`+iB+2b U+X7X amM/BM 6`M+F2
kyyNc kyyN#- ED2HH#2`; kyRyVX h?Bb TT2` BKb iQ +QMi`B#mi2 iQ
M 2K2`;BM; /Bb+mbbBQM QM i?2 mb2 Q7 i?Bb K2i?Q/QHQ;B+H TT`Q+?
7Q` MHvbBM; M/ +QKT`2?2M/BM; +QMb2[m2M+2b Q7 i?2 kXy@im`M BM
Tm#HB+ HB#``B2bX .`rBM; QM i?2 2tT2`B2M+2b Q7 QM2@v2` HQM; 2i?@
MQ;`T?B+ bim/v Q7 2p2`v/v rQ`F@`2Hi2/ bQ+BH K2/B T`+iB+2b BM
ar2/Bb? Tm#HB+ HB#``v- A bm;;2bi i?i i?2`2 `2 bB;MB}+Mi 2TB@
bi2KB+ #2M2}ib Q7 mbBM; i?2 2i?MQ;`T?B+ TT`Q+? BM i?Bb }2H/X "v
b?B7iBM; 7Q+mb iQ 2p2`v/v T`+iB+2b M/ `QmiBM2b BM HQ+H b2iiBM;bM2r 72im`2b Q7 i?2 kXy@T?2MQK2M `2 ++2Mimi2/- +QMi`B#miBM; iQ
/Bz2`2Mi mM/2`biM/BM;b Q7 i?2 `QH2 Q7 bQ+BH K2/B BM Tm#HB+ HB#``v
/2p2HQTK2MiX
>Qr2p2`- /QBM; 2i?MQ;`T?v BM i?Bb b2iiBM; HbQ +QMbiBimi2b M
2TBbi2KB+ +?HH2M;2X h?2 kXy@im`M ?b +QMi`B#mi2/ iQ i`Mb7Q`KBM;
Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b BMiQ bb2K#H;2b Q7 K2/Bi2/ M/ MQM@K2/Bi2/ b2i@
iBM;b r?2`2 +QMi2Mi Bb +QMiBMmQmbHv ~QrBM; #2ir22M /BbT`i2- #mi
+QMp2`;BM; bT+2bX am+? `2b2`+?@}2H/ +QMi2bib i`/BiBQMH mM/2`@
,6620(
+RZWRVWXG\VRFLDOPHGLDSUDFWLVHVLQFRQYHUJLQJOLEUDU\VSDFHV
i2`- irQ #HQ;b `mM #v i?2 HB#``v- M/ HbQ i?2 HB#``vb uQmim#2
+?MM2HX AM P+iQ#2` kyRy A //BiBQMHHv bi`i2/ bT2M/BM; +QmTH2
Q7 /vb r22F i i?2 HB#``v- Q#b2`pBM; M/ T`iB+BTiBM; BM i?2
/v@iQ@/v +iBpBiB2b i i?2 /2T`iK2MiX .m`BM; i?Bb T2`BQ/- i?2
rQ`F2`b r2`2 bF2/ iQ r`Bi2 HQ;#QQFb /2b+`B#BM; i?2B` rQ`F +iBp@
BiB2bX //BiBQMHHv- BMi2`pB2rb rBi? HB#``v KM;2`b QM /Bz2`2Mi
H2p2Hb BM i?2 Q`;MBxiBQM r2`2 +QM/m+i2/X
"v HQ+HBxBM; i?2 kXy@T?2MQK2MQM BM T`iB+mH` b2iiBM; Bi Bb TQb@
bB#H2 iQ mM/2`biM/ Bib T`Q/m+iBQM b 2K#2//2/ BM HQ+H BMbiBimiBQMH
`QmiBM2b- r?B+?- A `;m2- /Bp2`bB}2b M/ /22T2Mb Qm` mM/2`biM/BM;
Q7 Bib +QMb2[m2M+2bX >2M+2- i?2 2KT?bBb QM 2p2`v/v- bBimi2/ +@
iBQMb- r?B+? i?2 2i?MQ;`T?B+ TT`Q+? bm;;2bib- T`QpB/2b Aa rBi?
i?2 QTTQ`imMBiv 7Q` MQp2H BMbB;?ib BMiQ i?2 kXy@im`M BM HB#``v /2p2H@
QTK2MiX "2`BM; i?2b2 #2M2}ib BM KBM/- M Mbr2` iQ i?2 +?HH2M;2b
i?2 kXy@2MpB`QK2Mib T`QpB/2 7Q` Aa@`2b2`+?2`b Bb +HH2/ 7Q` b iQ #2
#H2 iQ +QMiBMm2 /2p2HQTBM; i?Bb K2i?Q/QHQ;B+H TT`Q+? 7Q` i?Bb
Q#D2+i Q7 `2b2`+?X
,6620(
+RZWRVWXG\VRFLDOPHGLDSUDFWLVHVLQFRQYHUJLQJOLEUDU\VSDFHV
,6620(
iBM;b p2`v b2`BQmbHv UBMbQ7` b i?2v `2 K2Mb Q` `2bQm`+2 7Q` #2BM;
+Q@T`2b2MiV- #mi Bi HbQ /Q2b MQi 2t+Hm/2 7+2@iQ 7+2 bBimiBQMbX *Q@
T`2b2M+2 b bi`iBM; TQBMi 2M#H2b KQ`2 bvKK2i`B+H i`2iK2Mi
Q7 7Q`Kb Q7 BMi2`+iBQMX
.2THQvBM; i?2 2TBbi2KB+ bi`i2;v Q7 +Q@T`2b2M+2 M/ 7Q+mb QM
bi`2Kb Q7 T`+iB+2b `i?2` i?M bBM;H2 T?vbB+H TH+2- HHQr2/
K2 iQ +HQb2Hv 7QHHQr i?2 +iBQMb Q7 BM7Q`KMib i?`Qm;? /Bz2`2Mi
b2iiBM;b M/ TH+2bX JQ`2Qp2`- i?Bb 2M?M+2/ i?2 TQbbB#BHBiv Q7 mM@
/2`biM/BM; i?2 +QMM2+iBQM #2ir22M i?2 HB#``v 2MpB`QMK2Mi M/
Qi?2` b2iiBM;b- i?mb 2bi#HBb?BM; i?2 HBMFb iQ KQ`2 rB/2Hv /BbT2`b2/
K2/B T`+iBb2b b A bm;;2bi2/ #Qp2X AM i?Bb rv +Q@T`2b2M+2 /`rb
i?2 ii2MiBQM iQ r?i +M #2 b22M b BMi2`b2+iBM; rQ`H/b T`2b2Mi BM
HB#``B2b +QMbiBimi2/ #v +QMp2`;BM; bT+2bX
Concluding remarks
MHvbBM; M/ +QKT`2?2M/BM; +QMb2[m2M+2b Q7 i?2 kXy@im`M BM
Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b mbBM; 2i?MQ;`T?v T`QpB/2b Aa rBi? MQp2H TQbbB#BH@
BiB2b Q7 ;BMBM; Q`B;BMH BMbB;?ib BMiQ i?Bb b?B7i BM HB#``v /2p2HQT@
K2MiX TTHvBM; `2+2Mi bi`i2;B2b- bm+? b i?2 MQiBQM Q7 +Q@T`2b2M+2?p2 i?2 TQbbB#BHBiv Q7 7m`i?2` 2M`B+?BM; i?2b2 BMbB;?ibX 6Q+mbBM; QM
bi`2Kb Q7 T`+iB+2b- b r2HH b 7QHHQrBM; i?2 rQ`F Q7 BM7Q`K@
Mib i?`Qm;? /Bz2`2Mi bT+2b- T`QpB/2b i?2 7QmM/iBQM 7Q` #2ii2`
mM/2`biM/BM; Q7 i?2 M2r bFBHHb `2[mB`2/ #v HB#``BMb r?2M i?2B`
rQ`FTH+2 Bb MQi `2bi`B+i2/ iQ T?vbB+H TH+2 #mi /BbT2`b2/ BM KMv
+QMp2`;BM; bT+2bX
Bibliography
,6620(
#bi`+i
Framework
h?2 TT2` BKb iQ +QMi`B#mi2 i?2 2KTB`B+H HBi2`im`2 QM GB#@
``v kXy /2p2HQTK2Mi U*b2v apbiBMmF kyye- >QHK#2`; 2i HX
kyyN- kyyN#V #v MHvxBM; i?2 7mM+iBQMHBiB2b M/ mb2b Q7 M2r
/B;BiH Tm#HB+ HB#``v b2`pB+2X :2Q@2M+Q/BM; Q7 HB#``v b2`pB+2b ?b
#22M T`2pBQmbHv bim/B2/ 2X;X #v *2`pQM2 Ukyy3V M/ SQr2HH 2i HX
UkyRyVX h?2 7`K2rQ`F TTHB2/ QM i?2 2K2`;BM; Tii2`M Q7 BM7Q`K@
,6620(
Results
Technologies applied in the service
:2Q;`T?B+H 2M+Q/BM; Q7 /B;BiH +QMi2Mi Bb M AMi2`M2i i2+?MQ@
HQ;v ;BMBM; TQTmH`Biv HbQ KQM; Tm#HB+ HB#``B2bX USQr2HH 2i HX
kyRyVX oB`imHBTQHFmX} Bb M AMi2`M2i Kb?@mT b2`pB+2 miBHBxBM;
:QQ;H2 JTb THi7Q`K- i?2 `2Hi2/ SAk M/ EJG +Q/2j BMiQ M2r
Q` 2tBbiBM; /B;BiH +QMi2MibX h?2 ;2Q@2M+Q/BM; iQQHb HHQr mb2`b iQ
HBMF ;2Q;`T?B+H HQ+iBQMb M/ `Qmi2 /2b+`BTiBQMb BMiQ M AMi2`M2i
b2`pB+2- `2bmHiBM; HQ+iBQM@r`2 /B;BiH +QHH2+iBQMb KBMiBM2/ #v
i?2 HB#``v bizX h?2 b2`pB+2 Bb #mBHi QM M QT2M bQm`+2 +QMi2Mi
KM;2K2Mi bvbi2K U*JaV CQQKH BMbiHHiBQM- HHQrBM; i?2 ;2M@
2`iBQM Q7 /vMKB+ r2# T;2b M/ p`BQmb bQ+BH K2/B 7mM+iBQMHBi@
B2bX L2r +QMi2Mi +M #2 BM+Hm/2/ BMiQ b2`pB+2 rBi?Qmi T`Q;`KKBM;
R ?iiT,ffrrrXb2Q@7Q`2MbB+bX+QKf+;B@#BMf#HXTH
k TTHB2/
j EJG
S`Q;`KKBM; AMi2`7+2
Bb sJG b+?2K TTHB2/ BM :QQ;H2 JTb b2`pB+2 M/ SAX a22 q2`M2+F2 Ukyy3V
*HRHQFRGLQJRIORFDOVHUYLFHVDQGLQIRUPDWLRQ
9 ZmB+F
cultural events and significant historical locations around the town, the
map themes are not limited to include cultural events and sites only.
Instead, after the launch of the service, other activities have emerged to
be included to the service.
,6620(
The service provides currently7 74 entitled maps and/or routes
featuring information about various sites, services and activities in
Hmeenlinna town and the surrounding region. Information provided in
the service ranges over the following themes: history (11), adventure (2),
nature and environment (15), art (10), literature (7), events (1), public
services (21) sports and recreational activities (7). The amount of maps
has increases 246 % from 30 to 74 maps in eight months, app. one new
map being published every week.
3.3. T he#v
uses
and the
users of the *m``2MiHvservice 9yWe Q7 i?2K `2
;2M2`i2/
2ti2`MH
+QMi`B#miQ`bX
d
BM/BpB/mHb b i?2 KDQ`Biv eyW Q7 `2T`2b2Mib Q`;MBxiBQMb bm+? b
KmMB+BTH
mi?Q`BiB2bbQ+B2iH
bbQ+BiBQMb
Q` }`KX
KDQ`Biv
The local
audiences
have adopted
the service.
Forh?2
instance,
a
Q7 map
i?2 +QMi2Mi
+`2i2/
#v i?2 HB#``v
biz
Bb #b2/
QM QMHBM2
`iB+H2b
about local
cross-country
skiing
routes
has been
viewed
for
3 THi7Q`KH`2/v
QM >K2@qBFB
r?2`2b
i?2 +QMi2Mi
;2M2`i2/
over 100000
times by March
7th, 2011.
Discussions
related
to the
#vmost
i?2 2ti2`MH
mi?Q`b
2Bi?2` Q7 i?2B` QrM BM/BpB/mH +`2iBQMpopular maps
haveBbemerged.
The proportion
of user-generated
is growing. While a
Q` T`QpB/2/
#v i?2 Q`;MBxiBQMb
i?2vcontent
`2T`2b2MiX
half of the included maps (25) were authored or ordered by the
project staff during 2010, the other half a (25) of maps are now
Conclusions
generated by external contributors. Currently, 40%8 of them are
h?2 +QK#BMiBQM
Q7 AMi2`M2i
BM pB`imHB@
individuals
as the majority
60%9i2+?MQHQ;B2b
of representsTTHB2/
organizations
such
TQHFmX}
Kv #2 authorities,
+QM+2Bp2/ bsocietal
M BMMQpiBp2
bQHmiBQM
i?2 +QMi2ti
as municipal
associations
or aBM firm.
The
of the content
created T`QpB/2b
by the library
staff isM/
based
on
Q7 majority
Tm#HB+ HB#``B2bX
h?2 THi7Q`K
#Qi? mb27mH
pHm#H2
online
articles
already
on BM?#BiMib
a
H
me-Wiki
BM7Q`KiBQM
M/
7mM+iBQMHBiB2b
7Q` i?2 HQ+H
M/
pBbBiQ`b
10
platform, whereas
the`2;BQMX
contentlb2`
generated
by the
external
authorsi?2
Q7 >K22MHBMM
+Biv M/
722/#+F
?2HTb
BM+`2bBM;
is
either
of
their
own
individual
creation,
or
provided
the
[mHBiv Q7 i?2 Tm#HB+ b2`pB+2X .BzmbBQM Q7 pB`imHBTQHFmX}bbyi2+?MQ@
organizations
they
represent.
HQ;v +QK#BMiBQM M/ +`Qbb@ b2+iQ`BH b2`pB+2 KQ/2H iQ Qi?2` KmMB@
+BTHBiB2b M/ Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b rBi?BM 7Q`2b22#H2 7mim`2 Bb HBF2Hv iQ
4.
C O N C L USI O NS
combination
of T`QD2+i
Internet
technologies
applied in
Q7 RyThe
BM/BpB/mH
mi?Q`b 2t+Hm/BM;
M/ HB#``v
bizX
Q7
Ry BM/BpB/mH mi?Q`b
2t+Hm/BM;
T`QD2+i M/as
HB#``v
bizX
virtuaalipolku.fi
may
be conceived
an innovative
solution in
3 >K2qBFB Bb KQ/B}2/ rBFB THi7Q`K 7Q` mb2`@;2M2`i2/ `iB+H2b #Qmi i?2 +mHim`2
the context of public libraries. The platform provides both useful
M/ ?BbiQ`v Q7 >K2 _2;BQMX
e9
de
*HRHQFRGLQJRIORFDOVHUYLFHVDQGLQIRUPDWLRQ
Bibliography
,6620(
Introduction
6QHFbQMQKB2b M/ bQ+BH i;;BM; bvbi2Kb ?p2 #22M T`QTQb2/ b
TQbbB#H2 bQHmiBQM iQ +QmMi2` i?2 K`;BMHBbBM; i2M/2M+B2b Q7 H`;2
mMBp2`bH +HbbB}+iBQM bvbi2Kb (Ry)X h?2 BK Q7 Qm` T`2b2MiiBQM
Bb iQ /Bb+mbb i?2 BKTHB+iBQMb Q7 +`BiB+H i?2Q`v M/ i?2 +QM+2Ti Q7
BMi2`b2+iBQMHBiv iQ i?2 BMi2`T`2iiBQM M/ mb2 Q7 i; +Hmbi2`b b
`2T`2b2MiiBQMb Q7 pB2rTQBMibX AM bTBi2 Q7 i?2 r2Hi? Q7 2KTB`B+H
`2b2`+? QM 7QHFbQMQKB2b M/ +Hmbi2`BM; Q7 i;b iQ;2i?2` rBi? 2t@
KTH2b Q7 +`BiB+H T2`bT2+iBp2b 7Q+mbbBM; QM K`;BMHBbiBQM BM i?2
+QMi2ti Q7 7QHFbQMQKB2b U2X;X (R)V- MQ +QKT`2?2MbBp2 +`BiB+H T@
T`Q+? iQ i; +Hmbi2`b ?b #22M T`2b2Mi2/X
Method
Pm` `;mK2Mi Q7 i?2 T`+iB+#BHBiv Q7 BMi2`b2+iBQMHBiv b 7`K2@
rQ`F Q7 mM/2`biM/BM; i?2 Mim`2 Q7 i; +Hmbi2`b Bb #b2/ QM i?2
`2pB2r Q7 2`HB2` HBi2`im`2 iQ;2i?2` rBi? ;`QmM/2/ i?2Q`v #b2/
2KTB`B+H MHvbBb Q7 b2i Q7 6HB+F` i;b bBKBH` iQ i?Qb2 mb2/ #v
>mpBH (e)X MHvb2/ i;b r2`2 #b2/ QM HBbi Q7 +QKKQM 2bi?2iB+
/D2+iBp2b +QHH2+i2/ BM M 2`HB2` 2KTB`B+H bim/v Q7 C+Q#b2M 2i HX
(d)X h?2 i;b M/ i; +Hmbi2`b r2`2 `2i`B2p2/ 7`QK 6HB+F` mbBM; i?2
#bB+ b2`+? 7mM+iBQM M/ #mBHi@BM +Hmbi2`BM; 7mM+iBQMHBivX iQiH
RRk +Hmbi2`b r2`2 MHvb2/ mbBM; +HQb2 `2/BM; M/ pBbmH +QMi2Mi
MHvbBbX h?2 pHB/Biv Q7 i?2 +QM+HmbBQMb r2`2 i2bi2/ mbBM; b2`B2b
Q7 / ?Q+ i2bib #b2/ QM i?2 MHvbBb Q7 i?2 +Hmbi2`BM; Q7 MiBQMH
,6620(
`2T`2b2MiiBQMb mbBM; i?2 MK2b Q7 }p2 LQ`/B+ +QmMi`B2b Uar2/2M6BMHM/- .2MK`F- LQ`rv M/ A+2HM/V- K2`B+ M/ :2`KMv
b +Hmbi2`BM; i;bX h?2 T`Q+2/m`2 Q7 `2i`B2pH M/ MHvbBb Q7 i?2
i;b M/ +Hmbi2`b rb i?2 bK2 b rBi? 2bi?2iB+ /D2+iBp2bX
Intersectional perspective
h?2Q`B2b QM BMi2`b2+iBQMHBiv ?p2 BM i?2 Hbi /2+/2b #2+QK2
BM+`2bBM;Hv T`QKBM2Mi BM MHvb2b Q7 bBimiBQMb M/ T`Q+2bb2b `2@
HiBM; iQ B/2MiBiv +i2;Q`B2b bm+? b i?2 QM2b aimMb `272`b iQ b
i?2 +HbbB+H #+F;`QmM/ +i2;Q`B2b Q7 ;2M/2`- 2i?MB+Biv- `+2- ;2b2tmHBiv M/ +Hbb(RR)X JQ`2 `2+2Mi bim/B2b Q7i2M BM+Hm/2 7Q` 2t@
KTH2 `2HB;BQM M/ 7mM+iBQMHBiv BM i?2b2 BMi2`b2+iBQMH +i2;Q`B2b#mi r?B+? +HbbB}+iBQMb `2 `2H2pMi iQ bim/v BM bT2+B}+ +b2 `2
MQi b22M b ;Bp2M #27Q`2?M/X PM2 Q7 i?2 +2Mi`H bT2+ib Q7 BMi2`b2+@
iBQMHBiv BM `2HiBQM iQ KmHiBTH2 pB2rTQBMib BM i;;BM; Bb i?2 [m2b@
iBQMBM; Q7 B/2b #Qmi 2t+HmbBp2 +i2;Q`B2bX *i2;Q`B2b `2 BMbi2/
b22M b BMi2`b2+iBM;- ~mB/ M/ bQ+BHHv +QMbi`m+i2/X AMi2`b2+iBQMH
i?2Q`B2b HbQ #`BM; 7Q`i? i?2 BKTQ`iM+2 Q7 i?i T2QTH2 7`QK /Bz2`@
2Mi BMi2`b2+iBQMH +i2;Q`B2b b?QmH/ #2 #H2 iQ 2tT`2bb i?2Kb2Hp2bX
a2H7@2tT`2bbBQM Bb b22M b BKTQ`iMi #Qi? BM i2`Kb Q7 i?2B` B/2MiBi@
B2b M/ QTBMBQMb BM ;2M2`H- M/ BM `2HiBQM iQ B/2MiBiv +i2;Q`B2bX
6Q` 2tKTH2- QM2 rQKM +MMQi bT2F 7Q` HH rQK2M- #2+mb2 Q7
i?2 2tBbi2M+2 Q7 Qi?2` B/2MiBiv +i2;Q`B2b i?i Kv#2 `2 iF2M 7Q`
;`Mi2/ U2bT2+BHHv B7 i?2v `2T`2b2Mi KDQ`BiB2bV M/ ?B//2MX
.2Q/iQ (9) bm;;2bib i?i i;;BM; T`QpB/2b M QTTQ`imMBiv 7Q`
HB#``BMb iQ `2H2b2 bQK2 Q7 i?2 i`/BiBQMH +QMi`QH M/ 2KTQr2`
mb2`b- K`;BMHBb2/ Q` MQi- iQ +`2i2 i?2B` QrM bi`m+im`2b Q7 Q`;M@
BbBM; FMQrH2/;2X PHbQM M/ 6Qt (Ry) bbQ+Bi2 b2H7@`2T`2b2MiiBQM
rBi? bm+? mb2`@+2Mi`2/ i2+?MQHQ;B2b b bQ+BH i;;BM; (i?i) Kv
2tBbi b K2Mb 7Q` bBM;mH` mb2`b iQ B/2MiB7v rBi? KmHiBTH2 `2HKb+`2iBM; /vMKB+ M/ mb2`@Q`;MBx2/ bQ+BH +HbbB}+iBQM bvbi2KX
AM bTBi2 Q7 i?2 QT2M T`iB+BTiBQM M/ mb2 Q7 / ?Q+ F2vrQ`/bb r?QH2- 7QHFbQMQKB2b i2M/ iQ `2T`2b2Mi KDQ`Biv pB2rb b Mv
Qi?2` EP bvbi2Kb U2X;X (j)VX >mpBH (e) T`QTQb2b b +QM+HmbBQM
Q7 bim/v Q7 2bi?2iB+ `2T`2b2MiiBQM BM 6HB+F` 7QHFbQMQKv i?i i;
+Hmbi2`b +M #2 mb2/ b +M/B/i2 `2T`2b2MiiBQMb Q7 T`2/QKBMMi
&ULWLFDODERXWFOXVWHULQJRIWDJV
Discussion
PM i?2 #bBb Q7 i?2 2`HB2` HBi2`im`2 Bi Bb +H2` i?i i?2 THm`HBbiB+
TQi2MiBH Q7 7QHFbQMQKB2b ?b KDQ` HBKBiiBQMbX b r?QH2- 7QHF@
bQMQKB2b ?p2 i2M/2M+v iQ 2KT?bBb2 KDQ`Biv pB2rTQBMib 2p2M
B7 i?2v HHQr THm`HBbK QM i?2 H2p2H Q7 BM/BpB/mHb M/ ;`QmTbX q2
bm;;2bi- ?Qr2p2`- i?i +`BiB+H `2/BM; Q7 i; +Hmbi2`b Kv T`QpB/2
T`+iB+#H2 7`K2rQ`F 7Q` HH2pBiBM; bQK2 Q7 i?2 i?2Q`2iB+H M/
T`+iB+H b?Q`i+QKBM;bX q2 ;`22 rBi? i?2 +QM+HmbBQMb Q7 >mpBH
(e) i?i i; +Hmbi2`b `2 `2Hi2/ iQ pB2rTQBMib #mi 2KT?bBb2 i i?2
bK2 iBK2 i?i i?2 `2HiBQM Q7 i?2b2 irQ MQiBQMb `2[mB`2b 7m`i?2`
2H#Q`iBQMX
6B`biHv- r2 bm;;2bi i?i i?2`2 `2 MHviB+HHv mb#H2 T`HH2Hb
#2ir22M i; +Hmbi2`b M/ BMi2`b2+iBQMH +i2;Q`B2b BM i?2 b2Mb2 bm;@
;2bi2/ #v M BMi2`b2+iBQMH T2`bT2+iBp2X 6`QK M BMi2`b2+iBQMH
TQBMi Q7 pB2r- +Hmbi2`b +QK#BM2 +i2;Q`B2b- TQBMi iQ /Bz2`2Mi /B`@
2+iBQMb rBi?BM i?2 i;;BM; bvbi2K M/ KBt /Bz2`2Mi H2p2Hb Q7 `2T@
`2b2MiiBQM BM+Hm/BM; T2`bT2+iBp2b UM/ QTBMBQMbV- 7Q`K M/ +QM@
i2MiX h?2 T`+iB+H #2M2}i Q7 M miQKiB+ B/2MiB}+iBQM Q7 i;
+Hmbi2`b Bb i?i Bi Bb TQbbB#H2 iQ 2tTQb2 M2r K`;BMHBb2/ +i2;Q`B2b
rBi?Qmi T`BQ` FMQrH2/;2 Q7 i?2B` 2tBbi2M+2X h?2 2KTB`B+H MHvbBb
Q7 i?2 i; +Hmbi2`b BM 6HB+F` /i ;Bp2b 2pB/2M+2 Q7 i?2 THmbB#BH@
Biv Q7 i?2 T`QTQbHX h?2 +Hmbi2`BM; Q7 i;b `2Hi2/ iQ /D2+iBp2b HBF2
;`+27mH 2tTQb2b i?`22 KDQ` +i2;Q`B2b Q7 ;`+27mHM2bb U#B`/b- /M+2
M/ rQK2MVX M2+/QiH 2tT2`BK2Mib rBi? Qi?2` ivT2b Q7 i;b bm+?
b 6BMMBb? UirQ +Hmbi2`b `2Hi2/ iQ /2bB;Mf`+?Bi2+im`2 M/ KmbB+V
M/ ar2/Bb? U7Qm` +i2;Q`B2b, ~;f7QQ/fBF2f#Hm2fv2HHQr- KmbB+rQK2M M/ +`bV `2p2H bBKBH`Hv BMi2HHB;B#H2 +Hmbi2`bX ++Q`/BM; iQ
i?2 MHvb2/ Ki2`BH- i?2 TQbbB#BHBiB2b iQ /Dmbi +i2;Q`B2b +QmH/
T`Q##Hv // iQ i?2 BMi2`b2+iBQMH TQbbB#BHBiB2b Q7 7QHFbQMQKB2bX
h?2 MHvbBb Q7 i; +Hmbi2`b KB;?i #2 `2}M2/ #v i`MbT`2M+v Q7
,6620(
&ULWLFDODERXWFOXVWHULQJRIWDJV
Conclusions
b +QM+HmbBQM r2 bm;;2bi i?i i?2`2 Bb ;2M2`H M22/ 7Q`
+`BiB+H T2`bT2+iBp2 iQ +i2;Q`BbiBQMb bm+? b i; +Hmbi2`b M/ i?2
+QMb2[m2M+2b Q7 i?2 +ib Q7 +i2;Q`BbiBQM BM i?2 +QMi2ti Q7 7QHF@
bQMQKB2bX AM +QMi`bi iQ i?2 bbmKTiBQMb i?i 7QHFbQMQKB2b 2K@
TQr2` K`;BMHBb2/ pB2rTQBMib- i?2B` +`2iQ`b M/ mb2`b b?QmH/ #2
BM+`2bBM;Hv r`2 Q7 i?2B` TQi2MiBH iQ 2M7Q`+2 ?2;2KQMB+ +i2;Q`@
B2bX a2+QM/Hv- r2 bm;;2bi i?i 2tTHB+Bi K2bm`2b UbBKBH` iQ PHbQMb
+QMb+BQmbM2bb`BbBM;V `2 M22/2/ BM /2bB;MBM; M/ mbBM; i;;BM; bvb@
i2Kb iQ +QmMi2` i?2B` K`;BMHBbBM; i2M/2M+B2bX
h?2 T`2b2Mi bim/v +M #2 BKTHB+iBQMb #Qi? 7Q` i;;BM; bvbi2K
+QMbi`m+iQ`b- mb2`b M/ BM `2b2`+?X A7 mb2`b `2 ;Bp2M KQ`2 TQr2`
iQ 2tT`2bb QTBMBQMb M/ +i2;Q`Bb2- QM2 [m2biBQM i?i `Bb2b 7`QK
+`BiB+H TQBMi Q7 pB2r Bb r?2i?2` i?Bb HbQ #`BM;b H`;2` `2bTQMb@
B#BHBiv 7Q` ?Qr +i2;Q`BbiBQM Bb /QM2 U7Q` 7m`i?2` /Bb+mbbBQMb QM `2@
bTQMbB#BHBiv- i`MbT`2M+v M/ i`mbi- b22 7Q` 2tKTH2 62BM#2`; (8)VX
*`2iQ`b Q7 i;;BM; bvbi2K KB;?i #2M2}i Q7 +QMbB/2`BM; i?2 +QM@
b2[m2M+2b Q7 i?2 /Bz2`2Mi 7mM+iBQMb Q7 i?2 bvbi2Kb- ?Qr iQ ;mB/2
mb2`b iQ mb2 Q` T`272` T`iB+mH` 7mM+iBQM- ?Qr iQ T`2b2Mi b2`+?
`2bmHib U2X;X ?Qr iQ T`QpB/2 iQQHb 7Q` b2H2+iBM; T`iB+mH` +`Bi2`B
Q7 `2H2pM+2V b r2HH b ?Qr iQ +QMbi`m+i BMi2`b2+iBQMHHv `2T`2b2Mi@
iBp2 H;Q`Bi?Kb 7Q` +Hmbi2`BM; i;bX hQ 2KT?bBb2 TQTmH`Biv M/
KDQ`Biv Bb QMHv QM2 Hi2`MiBp2 iQ T`2b2Mi b2H2+iBQM Q7 /Q+mK2MibM/ 2p2M B7 Bi rQmH/ #2 T2`+2Bp2/ i?2 KQbi `2H2pMi QM2- i?2`2 `2
TQbbB#BHBiB2b iQ 2tTQb2 H2bb TQTmH` K`;BMH +i2;Q`B2b i?i KB;?i
#2 `2H2pMi 7Q` bT2+B}+ ;`QmTb Q7 mb2`bX
Bibliography
,6620(
Introduction
"HQ;b `2 KDQ` THv2` Q7 i?2 q2# kXy rp2X h?2v `2 2bv@iQ@
mT/i2 r2# bBi2 +?`+i2`Bx2/ #v /i2/ 2Mi`B2b /BbTHv2/ BM `2p2`b2
+?`QMQHQ;B+H Q`/2` Uai27M+- kyye- TX kjyV- 2M#HBM; T2QTH2 iQ
[mB+FHv b?`2 rBi? i?2B` 7KBHB2b- 7`B2M/b- Q` 2p2M i?2 2MiB`2 r2#
TQTmHiBQM i?2B` i?Qm;?ib- `2~2+iBQMb- M/ 2KQiBQMb QMHBM2X h?2b2
+?`+i2`BbiB+b ?p2 ;BM2/ #HQ;b TQTmH`Biv BM 2/m+iBQMH b2iiBM;b
U.BpBiBMB- >m;HQFF2M- JQ`F2M- kyy8c :HQ;Qz- kyydc >m+F- kyydc
GBM 2i HX- kyyeVX S`2pBQmb bim/B2b ?p2 +FMQrH2/;2/ i?i #HQ;b
7mM+iBQM b `2~2+iBp2 /2pB+2b M/ BMi2`+iBp2 /2pB+2b rBi? `2bT2+i
iQ i?2B` T2/;Q;B+H #2M2}ib U.2M; um2M- kyyNVX 6Q` 2tKTH2"`2b+B M/ JBHH2` UkyyeV b 62`/B; M/ h`KK2HH Ukyy9V ?p2 7QmM/
i?i 2/m+iBQMH #HQ;;BM; T`QpB/2b bim/2Mib QTTQ`imMBiB2b iQ 2M;;2
BM `2~2+iBp2 i?BMFBM; T`Q+2bb M/ 2tT`2bb i?2Kb2Hp2b- r?B+? +QmH/
?2HT `2HB2p2 2KQiBQMH bi`2bbX aiBH2` M/ S?BHH2Q UkyyjV 7QmM/ i?i
r`BiBM; 2/m+iBQMH #HQ;b 2M+Qm`;2/ i?2 bim/2Mib iQ i?BMF /22T2`
M/ `2~2+i QM KQ`2 Bbbm2bX _2+Q;MBxBM; #HQ;b b BMi2`+iBp2 /2pB+2b62`/B; UkyydV 7QmM/ #HQ;b iQ #2 b?`2/ bT+2 7Q` +QHH#Q`iBp2 M/
+QQT2`iBp2 H2`MBM;X _2b2`+?2`b 7QmM/ i?i #HQ;b zQ`/2/ bQ+BH
`2~2+iBQM M/ ?2HT2/ +QMM2+i QMHBM2 H2`M2`b #v 2M#HBM; i?2K iQ
2tT`2bb i?2B` 722HBM;b- bQ+BHBx2- M/ bmTTQ`i 2+? Qi?2` BM H2`MBM;
+iBpBiB2b U.B+F2v- kyy9c 6`K2`- kyy9VX
,6620(
7KH8VHRI%ORJVLQ/,6
2QOLQH&RXUVHV
Figure 1. A Screenshot of the Social Software and Libraries Class Edmodo Site
There were 39 students enrolled. The students learning progress and learning outcomes were
evaluated through three aspects: class participation, individual assignments, and group
BMassignments.
i?2 +HbbX
R b?Qrb
M MQMvKBx2/
b+`22Mb?Qi
i?2 +Hbb
As a6B;m`2
form of class
participation,
the students were required
to post a Q7
minimum
of
1/KQ/Q
bBi2Xentries throughout the term using WordPress. Although not required, the
10 personal blog
h?2`2
r2`2
jN bim/2Mib
2M`QHH2/X
h?2Students
bim/2Mib
H2`MBM;
T`Q;`2bb
students
were
encouraged
to post microblogs
to Edmodo.
completed
two individual
M/
H2`MBM;
Qmi+QK2b
r2`2
2pHmi2/
i?`Qm;?
i?`22
bT2+ib,
assignments as well as one group assignment: the final project. Each group consisted of four+Hbb
or
T`iB+BTiBQMBM/BpB/mH
bbB;MK2MibM/ ;`QmT bbB;MK2MibX b
five students, and there
were eight groups
in total.
7Q`K Q7 +Hbb T`iB+BTiBQM- i?2 bim/2Mib r2`2 `2[mB`2/ iQ TQbi
KBMBKmK Q7 Ry T2`bQMH #HQ; 2Mi`B2b i?`Qm;?Qmi i?2 i2`K mbBM;
qQ`/S`2bbX Hi?Qm;? MQi `2[mB`2/- i?2 bim/2Mib r2`2 2M+Qm`;2/
iQ TQbi KB+`Q#HQ;b iQ 1/KQ/QX aim/2Mib +QKTH2i2/ irQ BM/BpB/mH
bbB;MK2Mib
b r2HH b QM2 ;`QmT bbB;MK2Mi, i?2 }MH T`QD2+iX
1+? ;`QmT +QMbBbi2/ Q7 7Qm` Q` }p2 bim/2Mib- M/ i?2`2 r2`2 2B;?i
;`QmTb BM iQiHX
,6620(
7KH8VHRI%ORJVLQ/,6 2QOLQH&RXUVHV
Conclusion
q2 ?p2 #22M BMp2biB;iBM; ?Qr bim/2Mib mb2 #HQ;;BM; BM +``v@
BM; Qmi H2`MBM; +iBpBiB2b Q7 M QMHBM2 GAa +Qm`b2, aQ+BH aQ7ir`2
M/ GB#``B2bX Ai b22Kb i?i #HQ;;BM; Bb pHm#H2 iQQH 7Q` bim@
/2Mib iQ `2~2+i QM i?2B` 2tT2`B2M+2b M/ 7Q` BMbi`m+iQ`b iQ i`+F
bim/2Mib /2p2HQTK2Mi i?`Qm;?Qmi i?2 i2`KX h?2 }M/BM;b Q7 i?Bb
bim/v +QMi`B#mi2 iQ i?2 `2b2`+? 2zQ`i Q7 2tTHQ`BM; #2bi i2+?BM;
T`+iB+2b #Qmi BMi2;`iBM; q2# kXy i2+?MQHQ;B2b BM QMHBM2 +Hbb2bX
6mim`2 `2b2`+? rBHH BM+Q`TQ`i2 //BiBQMH [mHBiiBp2 MHvbBb Q7
i?2b2 bim/2Mib #HQ;b M/ KB+`Q#HQ;bX aBM+2 i?2 BMbi`m+iQ` rBHH #2
i2+?BM; i?Bb +Qm`b2 ;BM BM 7HH kyRR M/ rBMi2` kyRk mbBM; bBKBH`
QMHBM2 KQ/HBiB2b- //BiBQMH /i +QHH2+iBQM rBHH HbQ #2 TQbbB#H2X
Bibliography
,6620(
%,%/,2*5$3+<
Introduction
L2r r2#@i2+?MQHQ;B2b +M 7+BHBii2 b+B2MiB}+ M/ #mbBM2bb rQ`F
M/ `2b2`+? BM KMv rvbX h?2 +`BiB+H bT2+i Bb r?B+? bi`m+im`2b
M/ K2i?Q/b `2 iQ #2 mb2/ iQ 2HB+Bi i?2 #2bi Qmi Q7 i?2 2tBbi@
2Mi `2bQm`+2b\ h?2 BM7Q`KiBQM@Qp2`HQ/ Bb T`2b2Mi BM HH@/v HB72
M/ b+B2M+2bX _2+QKK2M/2` bvbi2Kb i`v iQ bQHp2 i?Bb T`Q#H2K M/
?p2 MQi QMHv 2bi#HBb?2/ BM 2@+QKK2`+2- #mi HbQ BM i?2 +QHH#Q`@
iBp2 r2#- bm+? b QM aQ+BH@"QQFK`FBM; THi7Q`Kb (>2+FfS2i2`b
Ry)X AM i?Bb TT2`- r2 MHvx2 /i#b2 Q7 `2+Q`/b 7QmM/ QM "B#@
bQMQKv- *Bi2lGBF2 M/ *QMMQi2 i?`22 aQ+BH@"QQFK`FBM; avb@
i2Kb 7Q` b+B2MiB}+ `272`2M+2b M/ 2tTHQ`2/ i?2 i`BT`iBi2 +QMM2+@
iBQM Q7 mb2`b- /Q+mK2Mib M/ i;b #v i?`22 K2bm`2K2Mi K2i?Q/bX
q2 +QM+2Mi`i2/ QM irQ `2b2`+? [m2biBQMb +QM+2`MBM; i?2 `2+QK@
K2M/iBQM Q7 bBKBH` mb2`b, RV `2 i?2`2 /Bz2`2M+2b r?2M r2 TTHv
/Bz2`2Mi +Q2{+B2Mib U.B+2- *QbBMmb- C++`/@aM2i?V\- M/ kV `2
i?2`2 /Bz2`2M+2b r?2M r2 TTHv b?`2/ /Q+mK2Mib Q` b?`2/ i;b\
Related work
.Bz2`2Mi H;Q`Bi?Kb ?p2 #22M /2p2HQT2/ M/ MHvx2/ iQ ;2i
i?2 #2bi T2`7Q`KM+2 7Q` `2+QKK2M/iBQMX q2 +M /2+B/2 #2ir22M
i?`22 K2i?Q/b, +QMi2Mi@#b2/ M/ +QHH#Q`iBp2 }Hi2`BM; `2+QK@
,6620(
K2M/2` bvbi2Kb M/ ?v#`B/ 7Q`Kb Q7 i?2b2 irQ (S2i2`b yN- axQKbxQ`
yd)X aQ+BH@"QQFK`FBM; avbi2Kb Ua"aV KBMHv +QM+2Mi`i2 QM i?2
mb2`b +iBpBiB2b M/ i?2`27Q`2 QM +QHH#Q`iBp2 }Hi2`BM; U*6V- KQ`2
T`2+Bb2Hv 7QHFbQMQKv@#b2/ *6, AM a"a- r?2`2 mb2` #QQFK`F
`2bQm`+2b M/ i; i?2K #v F2vrQ`/b- i?2 i`BT`iBi2 mb2`@`2bQm`+2@
i; +QMM2+iBQM +M #2 mb2/ iQ `2+QKK2M/ bBKBH` `2bQm`+2b M/
HbQ bBKBH` mb2`bX aQ 7` KMv H;Q`Bi?Kb +QM+2Mi`i2 QM +Q+Bi@
iBQM MHvbBb (oM 1+FfqHiKM y3) M/ `2bQm`+2 `2+QKK2M/iBQM
(2X;X GBM; y3- wM`/Bf*T` y3- w?2MfGBfu2mM; yN)- 72r QM mb2`
`2+QKK2M/iBQMb (GmQ 2i HX y3)X *QKT`BbQMb Q7 /Bz2`2Mi bBKBH`@
Biv K2bm`2b M/ H;Q`Bi?Kb +M #2 7QmM/ BM (*+?2/ 2i HX RR)(1;;?2 yN) M/ (>K2`b 2i HX 3N)X (_Q`pB; NN) +QM+2Mi`i2b QM
i?2 pBbmH 2tTHQ`iBQM Q7 K2bm`2b #b2/ QM /Bz2`2Mi b+HBM; K2i?@
Q/bX AM i?Bb TT2` r2 HbQ +QKT`2 /Bz2`2Mi +Q2{+B2Mib- #mi BM i?2
b2+QM/ bi2T +QKT`2 i?2 /Bz2`2M+2b #2ir22M mb2` `2+QKK2M/iBQM
#b2/ QM `2bQm`+2b QM i?2 QM2 ?M/ M/ #b2/ QM i;b QM i?2 Qi?2`X
Methods
AM i?Bb TT2` r2 mb2 i?2 .B+2- *QbBMmb M/ C++`/@aM2i? +Q27@
}+B2Mi iQ K2bm`2 i?2 bBKBH`Biv #2ir22M mb2`b Q7 i?2 a"a "B#@
bQMQKv- *Bi2lGBF2 M/ *QMMQi2 M/ MHvx2 i?2 /Bz2`2Mi `MFBM;
`2bmHib +QM+2`MBM; i?2 mb2`b BM7Q`KiBQM M22/bX ++Q`/BM; iQ (oM
1+FfqHiKM y3) bBKBH`Biv K2bm`2 Ui?2v mb2/ Bi 7Q` +Q+BiiBQMbV
b?QmH/ 7mH}HH irQ +QM/BiBQMb,
R h?2 bBKBH`Biv #2ir22M irQ mb2`b b?QmH/ #2 KtBKH B7 i?2
T`Q}H2b /Bz2` #v i KQbi KmHiBTHB+iBp2 +QMbiMi UTXRe89VX
k h?2`2 b?QmH/ #2 MQ bBKBH`Biv B7 i?2 mi?Q`b ?p2 MQi?BM; BM
+QKKQM- BX2X Mv +Q+BiiBQMb M/ BM Qm` +b2 Mv #QQFK`Fb
Q` i;bX
HH i?`22 +Q2{+B2Mib biBb7v i?2b2 +QM/BiBQMbX AMbi2/ S2`bQMb +Q`@
`2HiBQM +Q2{+B2Mi /Q2bMi biBb7v i?2 +QM/BiBQMb M/ b?Qrb bQK2
r2FM2bb2b Ub22 2X;X oM 1+FfqHiKM y3V- r?B+? rb HbQ /Bb@
+mbb2/ #27Q`2 #v (?H;`2MfC`p2MBM;f_Qmbb2m yj)X AM i?2B` TT2`
i?2v b?Qr2/- KQM; Qi?2` i?BM;b- i?i i?2 S2`bQM +Q``2HiBQM mb2/
7Q` +Q@+BiiBQM MHvbBb ?b b?Q`i+QKBM;b r?2M 2tTM/BM; i?2 /i
$ &RPSDULVRQRI'LIIHUHQW8VHU6LPLODULW\0HDVXUHV
!" #$%&%'($)*+,'-%'.)'(/0/+1&/23'/4'2$%'1*2$)&('$15%'.)2$/.6'/.'7)00).8'/"%"'1.3'7)7/212/).('
1.,'/.')*&'71(%'1.3'-))901&9(')&'216("'
'
''
''!"#$% %
%
%
%%%
%&'(")*(%%
%%
%
%+,##,-./0)$,12'
3"4*-$%56%0"7"8,-"19%#'$::"#"$)1(%*($.;%<2$-$%,%"(%12$%)*7=$-%':%(")48$%=''>7,->(%'-%1,4(%':%?($-%@;%=%12$%)*7=$-%
':%(")48$%=''>7,->(%'-%1,4(%':%?($-%A%,).%4%12$%)*7=$-%':%#'77')%=''>7,->(%'-%1,4(B%%%%
:++'2$&%%'7)%44/7/%.2('(12/(43'2$%(%'7).,/2/).("';.(2%1,'<%1&().=('7)&&%+12/).'7)%44/7/%.2',)%(.=2'(12/(43'
2$%'7).,/2/).('1.,'($)>('()0%'>%19.%((%('?(%%'%"6"'@1.'A79BC1+201.'DEF8'>$/7$'>1('1+()',/(7*((%,'
-%4)&%' -3' G:$+6&%.BH1&5%./.6BI)*((%1*' DJK"' ;.' 2$%/&' L1L%&' 2$%3' ($)>%,8' 10).6' )2$%&' 2$/.6(8' 2$12'
bKTH22p2M B7 QMHv x2`Q@p2+iQ` pHm2b `2 //2/ U7m`i?2` /Bb+mb@
2$%' <%1&().' 7)&&%+12/).' *(%,' 4)&' 7)M7/212/).' 1.1+3(/(' $1(' ($)&27)0/.6(' >$%.' %NL1.,/.6' 2$%' ,121'
bBQM
QM
i?2
iQTB+ Bb HbQ /QM2 #v 2X;X (G2v/2b/Q`z y8)- (G2v/2b@
(10L+%8'%5%.'/4').+3'O%&)M5%72)&'51+*%('1&%'1,,%,'?4*&2$%&',/(7*((/).').'2$%'2)L/7'/('1+()',).%'-3'%"6"'
/Q`zfom;?M
ye)- (a+?M2B/2`f"Q`HmM/ yd) M/ (a+?M2B/2`f"Q`HmM/
GP%3,%(,)&44'DQK8'GP%3,%(,)&44B@1*6$1.'DRK8'GS7$.%/,%&BT)&+*.,'DU1K'1.,'GS7$.%/,%&BT)&+*.,'DU-KF"''
yd#)VX
V*&' ,121-1(%' 7).21/.(' WJ8UR!' -))901&9(' 4&)0' X/2%YP/9%8' X)..)2%1' 1.,' T/-().)038' /.' )*&' 71(%'
Pm` /i#b2 +QMiBMb Rj-dek #QQFK`Fb 7`QK *Bi2lGBF2- *QM@
(7/%.2/4/7'1&2/7+%('7$)(%.'4&)0'ZQ'L$3(/71+'[)*&.1+("'WD8Z\E')4'2$%0'1&%',/5%&(%'1&2/7+%(8'0127$%,'5/1'
MQi2
M/
"B#bQMQKvBM Qm`>%&%'
+b2
b+B2MiB}+
`iB+H2b
7`QK
]V;8' 2/2+%'
1.,' Y#M7),%"'
#$%(%' -))901&9('
2166%,'
>/2$' JR8ZJJ'
216("' C%'+?Qb2M
,%+%2%,' 2$%'
216('
7).21/./.6'^/0L)&2^'-%71*(%'2$%(%'216('
98
T?vbB+H DQm`MHbX Ry-9N3 Q7 i?2K `2 /Bp2`b2 `iB+H2b- Ki+?2/
M >%&%' L&)L)(%,'
pB
.PA- iBiH2 M/ lh@+Q/2X h?2b2 #QQFK`Fb r2`2 i;;2/ rBi?
1*2)012/71++3'-3'X/2%YP/9%'/4'1'*(%&'/0L)&2('$/('4/+%("':42%&'2$/('7+%1&/.6'>%'$1,'JQ8EEW'216(8'>$/7$'>%'
je-9jj
i;bX q2 /2H2i2/ i?2 i;b +QMiBMBM; WBKTQ`iW- WD#@
&%5/(%,'4*&2$%&_'+/.%('1.,'*.,%&+/.%('>%&%',%+%2%,8'2$%'L+*&1+'4)&0('&%L+17%,'-3'(/.6*+1&'4)&0('1.,'
`27W
M/
WmTHQ/W #2+mb2 i?2b2 i;b /QMi b2KMiB+HHv /2@
A.6+/($'>)&,('(L%++/.6'>/2$''"'#$/('615%'*('E8!JJ'*./`*%'216("'
C%'7)*.2'!8ZUJ'*./`*%'*(%&('>$)'-))901&9%,'2$%'1&2/7+%(8'W8\UZ')4'2$%0'2166%,'2$%/&'-))901&9("'
b+`B#2
i?2 +QMi2Mi Q7 i?2 #QQFK`F i?2v `2 ;2M2`i2/ iQ M/ i?2
}H2@BKTQ`i
i;b r2`2 T`QTQb2/ miQKiB+HHv #v *Bi2lGBF2 B7
C%'+%42')*2'*(%&('>$)'$15%').+3').%'-))901&9'-%71*(%'2$%3'>)*+,'$/6$+3'/.4+*%.7%'2$%'&%(*+2(8'/"%"'
mb2`
BKTQ`ib ?Bb }H2bX 7i2` i?Bb +H2`BM; r2 ?/ j8-33R i;b- r?B+?
*(%&ML1/&('>$)'$15%').%'-))901&9'/.'7)00).'1.,'-)2$').+3').%'-))901&9'12'1++8'71*(%'1'(/0/+1&/23'
)4'W"';2'>)*+,'-%'/0L)&21.2'4)&'1'*(%&M&%7)00%.,%&'(3(2%0'2)'(%2'1'2$&%($)+,_'%/2$%&'1'*(%&'($)*+,'
r2
`2pBb2/ 7m`i?2`, HBM2b M/ mM/2`HBM2b r2`2 /2H2i2/- i?2 THm`H
$15%' 1' 0/./0*0'
).' -))901&9('
1.,B)&'7Q`Kb
$%' ($)*+,'
$15%'1M;HBb?
1' 0/./0*0'rQ`/b
).' (/0/+1&'
-))901&9('rBi?
>/2$'
7Q`Kb
`2TH+2/
#v bBM;mH`
M/
bT2HHBM;
1.)2$%&'*(%&8'-%4)&%'2$/('*(%&'/('&%7)00%.,%,'2)'$/0"'#$%'+1(2'1(L%72'71.'1+()'-%'&%6*+12%,'-3'2$%'
b
`2TH+2/ #v K2`B+M bT2HHBM; rBi? xX h?Bb ;p2 mb 3-kjj mMB[m2
*(%&'$/0(%+4'>/2$'2$%'$%+L')4'1'(+/,%&8'()'2$%'*(%&'71.',%2%&0/.%'2$%'10)*.2')4'(/0/+1&'*(%&('>$)'1&%'
i;bX
q2 +QmMi k-9dj mMB[m2 mb2`b r?Q #QQFK`F2/ i?2 `iB+H2b&%7)00%.,%,'2)'$/0'G(%%'a.1*2O'WD'4)&'&%()*&7%M&%7)00%.,12/).K"'X/2%YP/9%'$1('1'0/./0*0')4'!D'
&%()*&7%('1'*(%&'0*(2'$15%'/.'+/-&1&3'-%4)&%'$%'6%2('&%()*&7%'&%7)00%.,12/)."'P%15/.6')*2'1++'*(%&('
R-Nd9
Q7 i?2K i;;2/ i?2B` #QQFK`FbX
>/2$'+%(('2$%.'2>)'-))901&9(8'>%'$15%'R8ZJD'*(%&ML1/&('>$)'($1&%'12'+%1(2').%'-))901&9"'
q2 H27i Qmi mb2`b r?Q ?p2 QMHv QM2 #QQFK`F #2+mb2 i?2v
rQmH/
?B;?Hv BM~m2M+2 i?2 `2bmHib- BX2X mb2`@TB`b r?Q ?p2 QM2
!" #$%&'(%)
#QQFK`F BM +QKKQM M/ #Qi? QMHv QM2 #QQFK`F i HH- +mb2
)!"*)+,--$.$/0$%)1$(2$$/)34$--,0,$/(%)
:.1+3O/.6'
bBKBH`Biv
Q7 RX Ai rQmH/ #2 BKTQ`iMi 7Q` mb2`@`2+QKK2M/2`
)*&' 2$&%%' 7)%44/7/%.2(' >%' 4)*.,' 7)&&%+12/).' -%2>%%.' *(%&' (/0/+1&/23' -1(%,' ).' &%()*&7%('
bvbi2K
iQ
b2i
i?`2b?QH/, 2Bi?2` mb2` b?QmH/ ?p2 KBMBKmK QM
1.,'*(%&'(/0/+1&/23'-1(%,').'216(_';.'-)2$'(7%.1&/)(']/7%'1.,'H1771&,MS.%12$'615%'(/0/+1&'&%(*+2(''2$%'
#QQFK`Fb
M/fQ`
?2 b?QmH/
?p2
KBMBKmK
QM(/0/+1&'
bBKBH`
+122%&' ($)>/.6' 0/.)&'
(/0/+1&/23'
51+*%' ' 71*(%'
2$%'0%1(*&%'
1&%' `*/2%'
?(%%'#QQFK`Fb
GA66$%' WDKF"' ;.'
7).2&1(2'X)(/.*('615%',/44%&%.2'&1.9/.6'&%(*+2(_';2'71.'-%'(1/,8'2$12'X)(/.*(',/(2/.6*/($%('-%2>%%.'2$%'
rBi?
MQi?2` mb2`- #27Q`2 i?Bb mb2` Bb `2+QKK2M/2/ iQ ?BKX h?2 Hbi
1++)712/).' )4' 2$%' &%()*&7%(' 1.,' 216(' -%2>%%.' 1' *(%&ML1/&' Gb10%&(' %2' 1+"' E\K"' #$%' `*%(2/).' /(' .)>'
bT2+i
+M HbQ #2 `2;mHi2/ #v i?2 mb2` ?BKb2H7 rBi? i?2 ?2HT Q7
>$/7$'&1.9/.6')4'(/0/+1&'*(%&('(%&5%('-%(2'4)&'2$%'2%(2M/M*(%&'/('(%1&7$/.6'4)&'
bHB/2`bQ
i?2 mb2` +M /2i2`KBM2 i?2 KQmMi Q7 bBKBH` mb2`b r?Q `2
.%>'&%()*&7%(8'$%'0/6$2'+/9%'1'(/0/+1&'*(%&'>$)'$1('-))901&9%,'01.3'&%()*&7%("''
`2+QKK2M/2/ iQ ?BK (b22 EMmix Ry 7Q` `2bQm`+2@`2+QKK2M/iBQM)X
/
*Bi2lGBF2
?b KBMBKmK Q7 ky `2bQm`+2b mb2` Kmbi ?p2 BM HB#@
h
``v #27Q`2 ?2 ;2ib `2bQm`+2 `2+QKK2M/iBQMX G2pBM; Qmi HH mb2`b
,6620(
rBi? H2bb i?2M irQ #QQFK`Fb- r2 ?p2 e-9jy mb2`@TB`b r?Q b?`2
i H2bi QM2 #QQFK`FX
Results
Differences between Coefficients
MHvxBM; Qm` i?`22 +Q2{+B2Mib r2 7QmM/ +Q``2HiBQM #2ir22M
mb2` bBKBH`Biv #b2/ QM `2bQm`+2b M/ mb2` bBKBH`Biv #b2/ QM i;b,
AM #Qi? b+2M`BQb .B+2 M/ C++`/@aM2i? ;p2 bBKBH` `2bmHib
i?2 Hii2` b?QrBM; KBMQ` bBKBH`Biv pHm2 +mb2 i?2 K2bm`2 `2
[mBi2 bBKBH` Ub22 (1;;?2 Ry)VX AM +QMi`bi *QbBMmb ;p2 /Bz2`2Mi
`MFBM; `2bmHib, Ai +M #2 bB/- i?i *QbBMmb /BbiBM;mBb?2b #2ir22M
i?2 HHQ+iBQM Q7 i?2 `2bQm`+2b M/ i;b #2ir22M mb2`@TB` (>K2`b
2i HX 3N)X h?2 [m2biBQM Bb MQr r?B+? `MFBM; Q7 bBKBH` mb2`b b2`p2b
#2bi 7Q` i?2 i2bi@mb2`b M22/b\ A7 i?2 i2bi@mb2` Bb b2`+?BM; 7Q` M2r
`2bQm`+2b- ?2 KB;?i HBF2 bBKBH` mb2` r?Q ?b #QQFK`F2/ KMv
`2bQm`+2bX
AM i#H2 R mb2` /+?2M- r?Q ?b kR9 #QQFK`Fb- rQmH/ #2 `2+QK@
K2M/2/ mb2` +Q`iBx QM `MF Ry rBi? .B+2 bBKBH`Biv Q7 yXyR38X
lbBM; *QbBMmb i?2 bBKBH`Biv Bb yXyNed- rBi? r?B+? +Q`iBx rQmH/
#2 QM `MF i?`22 U.B+2V Q` `MF 7Qm` U*QbBMmbVX "mi 7Q` /+?2M
i?2 irQ #QQFK`Fb Q7 +Q`iBx TQbbB#Hv rQmH/Mi Km+? ?2HT ?BK
7Q` 7m`i?2` `2b2`+?- +QMi``v i?2 kR9 `iB+H2b Q7 /+?2M KB;?i #2
;QQ/ HB#``v 7Q` +Q`iBxX A7 /+?2M rQmH/ ?p2 H2bb i?M kR9
#QQFK`Fb- ?2 rQmH/ #2 KQ`2 bBKBH` iQ +Q`iBxX *QM+2`MBM; i?2
`2b2`+? bT2+i 7Q` +Q`iBx i?Bb rQmH/ #2 b?Q`i+QKBM; 7Q` ?BKX
$ &RPSDULVRQRI'LIIHUHQW8VHU6LPLODULW\0HDVXUHV
!"#$
/
%&'($)*+",$!-$.$(&*/%0*1'23$4*/$&'15$$
$
!"#$
/
%&'($)*+",$!-$.$(&*/%0*1'23$4*/$&'15$$
$
!"#$%&'()'*+,$&'-.'/-&.."/"&012'34'0$53&%'-.'$2&%67+"%2)'$2&%62"5",+%"14'3+2&8'-0'3--95+%92:'2-$%/&)';"32-0-54:'
<"1&=>"9&:'<-00-1&+?'
+4664*$ -6$
-6$
5,()9
5,()#
%&+($ :4,&*5,$
-6$
3+8(*
5,()#
-6
-6
AB
CAD
EB ,0&-2 )--<(
F5AGCD F5AHAH
AI
CAD
EB ,0&-2 3&+2%-/
F5ACE F5AECH
AA
CAD
EC ,0&-2 <,-(1*2,
F5FBCI F5AFDG
B
CAD
HH ,0&-2 <<'1(
F5FEIA F5FHIG
$
H
CAD
CH ,0&-2 <-,1*2,
F5FE
F5FBFD
!"#$%&'()'*+,$&'-.'/-&.."/"&012'34'0$53&%'-.'$2&%67+"%2)'$2&%62"5",+%"14'3+2&8'-0'3--95+%92:'2-$%/&)';"32-0-54:'
E
CAD
CE ,0&-2 <.%'-&+19&/#
F5FDAB F5FHBD
<"1&=>"9&:'<-00-1&+?'
D
CAD
AE ,0&-2 %.%&.!&.%%
F5FGDJ F5FIFH
E
CAD
AFE ,0&-2 /*,2-#
F5FGAG F5FGGD
+4664*$
5,()9 ).'%*2&'""
5,()#
%&+($ :4,&*5,$
G -6$CAD -6$ J ,0&-2
F5FCHJ
F5FHBD
-6$ C 3+8(*
-6 F5FJHI
-6
CAD 5,()# C ,0&-2 0.*/%'7
F5FABE
AB
CAD
EB ,0&-2 )--<(
F5AGCD F5AHAH '
AI
CAD
EB ,0&-2 3&+2%-/
F5ACE F5AECH 3--95+%92'C35D:'-%8&%&8'34'
@+3,&'A)'B"^^
AA
CAD
EC ,0&-2 <,-(1*2,
F5FBCI F5AFDG
E"/&:'2-$%/&)';"32-0-54:'<"1&=>"9&:'<-00-1&+?'
B
CAD
HH ,0&-2 <<'1(
F5FEIA F5FHIG
!"#$%&''()(*+(,$-(./((*$.012$0*3$)(,45)+(2-0,(3$,&6&70)&.&(,$$
H
CAD
CH ,0&-2 <-,1*2,
F5FE
F5FBFD
E
CAD
CE ,0&-2 <.%'-&+19&/#
F5FDAB F5FHBD
62."#7'23$ %&-$ +(-/$ ('1'"./'%#$ !.(-,$*2$ %.3(8$%&-$ 0*-44'0'-2%($ 9/*:',-$ ('1'"./$ /-(+"%(5$ ;&-$ '2%-/-(%'23$
D
CAD
AE ,0&-2 %.%&.!&.%%
F5FGDJ F5FIFH
.(9-0%$'($%&-$,'44-/-2%$/.2<'23$!-%)--2$('1'"./$+(-/($!.(-,$*2$%.3($*2$%&-$*2-$&.2,$.2,$*2$/-(*+/0-($
E
CAD
AFE ,0&-2 /*,2-#
F5FGAG F5FGGD
*2$%&-$*%&-/$&.2,5$$
G
CAD
J ,0&-2 ).'%*2&'""
F5FCHJ F5FHBD
C
CAD $
C ,0&-2 )&*$
0.*/%'7
F5FABE F5FJHI
!*%&$ &.:-$ %&-$ 3/-.%-(%$
('1'"./'%#$
' :."+-$ -'%&-/$ !.(-,$ *2$
@+3,&'A)'B"^^ 3--95+%92'C35D:'-%8&%&8'34'
/-(*+/0-($)-/-$%.<-2$'2%*$.00*+2%5$=(-/$('1'"./'%#$!.(-,$*2$%.3($1.#$&.:-$.,:.2%.3-($*:-/$%&-$*2-$
E"/&:'2-$%/&)';"32-0-54:'<"1&=>"9&:'<-00-1&+?'
!.(-,$*2$/-(*+/0-(>$;&-/-$1'3&%$!-$1*/-$.2,$,'44-/-2%$('1'"./$+(-/($
!"#$%&''()(*+(,$-(./((*$.012$0*3$)(,45)+(2-0,(3$,&6&70)&.&(,$$
%&-$/-(*+/0-(8$.2,$%.3($1.#$'24*/1$%&-$+(-/8$'2$)&'0&$0*2%-?%$%&-$*%&-/$+(-/($/-.,$%&-$/-(*+/0-5$@4$
62."#7'23$ %&-$ +(-/$ ('1'"./'%#$ !.(-,$*2$ %.3(8$%&-$ 0*-44'0'-2%($ 9/*:',-$ ('1'"./$ /-(+"%(5$ ;&-$ '2%-/-(%'23$
$
.(9-0%$'($%&-$,'44-/-2%$/.2<'23$!-%)--2$('1'"./$+(-/($!.(-,$*2$%.3($*2$%&-$*2-$&.2,$.2,$*2$/-(*+/0-($
*2$%&-$*%&-/$&.2,5$$
$ )&*$ !*%&$ &.:-$ %&-$ 3/-.%-(%$ ('1'"./'%#$ :."+-$ -'%&-/$ !.(-,$ *2$
/-(*+/0-($)-/-$%.<-2$'2%*$.00*+2%5$=(-/$('1'"./'%#$!.(-,$*2$%.3($1.#$&.:-$.,:.2%.3-($*:-/$%&-$*2-$
!.(-,$*2$/-(*+/0-(>$;&-/-$1'3&%$!-$1*/-$.2,$,'44-/-2%$('1'"./$+(-/($
%&-$/-(*+/0-(8$.2,$%.3($1.#$'24*/1$%&-$+(-/8$'2$)&'0&$0*2%-?%$%&-$*%&-/$+(-/($/-.,$%&-$/-(*+/0-5$@4$
$
,6620(
'%11%&! 234*!
234*
5'6.&
O^
X[
XN
\^
X[
^]
[\
XN
^\
XO
^S[
^S[
^S[
^S[
^S[
^S[
^S[
^S[
^S[
^S[
234*!
)*.07
)*.08
]\ &0"#(
]d &0"#(
Xc &0"#(
X[c &0"#(
^NX &0"#(
O[ &0"#(
[]\ &0"#(
^NS &0"#(
O] &0"#(
^S] &0"#(
)*.07
9+'.! $%*+&)*!
234*
234*
4##8.
N>X[c\
*"-()#/
N>XN[d
8#&1+(&
N>^c]^
/+&(#2
N>^ddc
%(&/#%9
N>^dN[
8831.
N>^[X\
130"%#59-..1%(( N>^\]^
:%-5.0"5#.3(*#/ N>^\^d
T##'%(T2+)3
N>^OXS
9/+(08+9-.)#/
N>^O^^
N>XcXc
N>XXcX
N>XdNS
N>^cX]
N>^dS^
N>XN\\
N>^S^c
N>^\]X
N>^S]\
N>^O^^ !
"#$%&!'(!)*+*%#,*-.!^^ -#/01!2,3&,&3!$.!4*5&1!026,5&(!
7*$0282+.1!9*-&:;*<&1!92882-&#=!!
"# $%&'()*+%&!!
!"#$%&'%()%*#$+,$%$-.#/$/#0+11#(&#/$.2.)#1$3.$)"%)$4#$0+-5&$+,,#/$)"/##$/#0+11#(&%)3+(.6$.3135%/$
T`i 7`QK ;?mMi2` M/ r22Fb- r?Q #Qi? ?p2 i?2 ;`2i2bi
bBKBH`Biv
pHm2
2Bi?2`
#b2/
QM
ii?#?ii
yXyj9N
yXydye
kR9 N
,3#5&$ 7"#/#$ )"#$ -.#/$ "31.#5,$ 0%($ ,35)#/$ )"#$ /#.-5).$ 5++83(*$ +(52$ %)$ /#.+-/0#.$ 9++81%/8#&$ 92$ .:#03,30$
/+?2M
rBiQM?BHH
yXykeN
yXye39
`2bQm`+2b
r2`2
iF2M
BMiQ
++QmMiX
#;:#/)$ -.#/.<=$ %(&$)%*.$4"30"$%/#$%..3*(#&$92$.:#03,30$ #;:#/)$ -.#/.$%(&$5#%&$)+$/#5#'%()$ /#.+-/0#.>$
lb2`
bBKBH`Biv #b2/
QM +,,#/.$
i;b%$ ,-/)"#/$
Kv %.:#0)$
?p2 4"30"$
/pMi;2b
Qp2` 43)"$
i?2&3/#0)$
QM2
!"#$ -.#/?/#0+11#(&%)3+($
)"#/#,+/#$
0%((+)$ 9#$ ,-5,355#&$
kR9
k /+?2M +Q`iBx yXyR38 yXyNed #b2/ QM `2bQm`+2b, h?2`2 KB;?i
/#.+-/0#$+/$)%*$/#0+11#(&%)3+(>$@#$%5.+$,+-(&$+-)$)"%)$)"#/#$3.$%$*/#%)$&3,,#/#(0#$9#)4##($-.#/$
#2
KQ`2 M/ /Bz2`2Mi bBKBH` mb2`b r?B+? rQmH/Mi #2 7QmM/ Qp2`
(##&.6$ A.$ "#$ .#%/0"3(*$ ,+/$ 0++:#/%)3+($ :%/)(#/.$ +/$ ,+/$ /#5#'%()$ /#.+-/0#.B$ !"3.$ 3.$ 31:+/)%()$ ,+/$
i?2
`2bQm`+2b- M/ i;b Kv BM7Q`K i?2 mb2`- BM r?B+? +QMi2ti i?2
.3135%/3)2$1#%.-/#1#()$%(&$)"#$/%(83(*$+,$)"#$/#.-5).$,+/$%$.3(*5#$-.#/>$C-/)"#/$/#.#%/0"$"%.$)+$9#$
Qi?2`
`2/
i?2
`2bQm`+2X
A7%/#$
/+?2M
Bb b2`+?BM;
7Q` T`QD2+i
&+(#$ +($mb2`b
)"3.$ ,3#5&>$
D$ (#4$
E-#.)3+($
3.$ 3,$ )"#/#$
,#%)-/#.$ 4"30"$
0+-5&$ 9#$ 3()#*/%)#&$
3($ -.#/$
T`iM2`bi?2,+/$
i;b
+M3(,+/1%)3+($
;Bp2 ?BK%9+-)$
M BKT`2bbBQM
Q7 i?2 `iB+H2b
/#0+11#(&%)3+(=$
#;%1:5#$
4"30"$ +,$ )"#$ 9++81%/8#&$
:%:#/.$ )"#$+QMi2Mi
-.#/$ "%.$
%5/#%&2$/#%&$+/$4"30"$"#$&3.538#.>$F($G3)#HI38#$%$-.#/$0%($(+4$.)%)#$+,$"#$"%.$/#%&$%($%/)305#$+/$4355$
i?2
Qi?2` mb2`b `2 BMi2`2bi2/ BM M/ i?2`27Q`2 Q7 i?2 mb2`b `2b2`+?
>!"#.#$,#%)-/#.$13*")$*3'#$,-/)"#/$3(,+/1%)3+($%9+-)$%$-.#/=$
}2H/X
4"30"$ 4355$ 9#$ "#5:,-5$ )+$ ,3(&$ 0++:#/%)3+($ :%/)(#/.$ %(&$ (%//+4$ )"#$ "-*"$ %1+-()$ +,$ /#5#'%()$
/#.+-/0#.>$ F-/$ ,-/)"#/$ /#.#%/0"$ )/3#.$ )+$ 31:5#1#()$ )"#.#$ %.:#0).$ %.$ 4#55$ %.$ )+$ 0+193(#$
/#0+11#(&%)3+($9%.#&$+($)%*.$%(&$+($/#.+-/0#.>$D(+)"#/$3('#.)3*%)3+($."+-5&$%5.+$9#$)"#$)#.)3(*$+,$
&3,,#/#()$ :/+;313)2$ %(&$ .3135%/3)2$ 1#%.-/#.>$ D.$ .#'#/%5$ %-)"+/.$ +(.)/%)#&$ 7#>*>$
JD"5*/#(KL%/'#(3(*KM+-..#%-$NOP=$JQ0"(#3&#/KR+/5-(&$NS9P<$)"#$0"+30#$+,$%$.:#03,30$1#%.-/#$3.$+,)#($
.-9T#0)3'#>$U3,,#/#()$1#%.-/#.$%.8$,+/$&3,,#/#()$0/3)#/3%$%(&$5#%&$)+$&3,,#/#()$/#.-5).=$4"30"$/#E-3/#$%$
h?2 /pMi;2 Q7 mb2` `2+QKK2M/2` bvbi2K Bb i?i r2 +QmH/
&#)%35#&$0+1:%/3.+(>$
Conclusion
$ &RPSDULVRQRI'LIIHUHQW8VHU6LPLODULW\0HDVXUHV
Bibliography
(R) (?H;`2MfC`p2MBM;f_Qmbb2m yj) ?H;`2M- S2`c C`p2MBM;"Qc _Qmbb2m- _QMH/ UkyyjVX _2[mB`2K2Mib 7Q` *Q+BiiBQM
aBKBH`Biv J2bm`2- rBi? aT2+BH _272`2M+2 iQ S2`bQMb *Q@
`2HiBQM *Q2{+B2MiX AM, CQm`MH Q7 i?2 K2`B+M aQ+B2iv 7Q`
AM7Q`KiBQM a+B2M+2 M/ h2+?MQHQ;v- 89- e- 88y@8eyX
(k) (*+?2/ 2i HX RR) *+?2/- 6B/2Hc *`M2B`Q- o+iQ`c 62`MM@
/2x- .B2;Qc 6Q`KQbQ- o`2BtQ UkyRRV, *QKT`BbQM Q7 +QHH#Q`@
iBp2 }Hi2`BM; H;Q`Bi?Kb, GBKBiiBQMb Q7 +m``2Mi i2+?MB[m2b
M/ T`QTQbHb 7Q` b+H#H2- ?B;?@ T2`7Q`KM+2 `2+QKK2M/2`
bvbi2KbX AM, *J h`Mb+iBQMb QM i?2 q2#- 8fR- `iB+H2 kX
(j) (1;;?2 Ry) 1;;?2- G2Q UkyRyV, :QQ/ S`QT2`iB2b Q7 aBKBH`@
Biv J2bm`2b M/ h?2B` *QKTH2K2Mi`BivX AM, CQm`MH Q7 i?2
K2`B+M aQ+B2iv 7Q` AM7Q`KiBQM a+B2M+2 M/ h2+?MQHQ;veRfRy- kR8RkReyX
(9) (>K2`b 2i HX 3N) >K2`b- GB2p2c >2K2`v+F- up2bc >2`r2v2`b:mB/Qc CMbb2M- J`+ URN3NV, aBKBH`Biv J2bm`2b BM a+B2MiQ@
K2i`B+ _2b2`+?, h?2 C++`/ AM/2t o2`bmb aHiQMb *QbBM2
6Q`KmHX AM, AM7Q`KiBQM S`Q+2bbBM; JM;2K2Mi- k8fjjR8jR3X
(8) (>2+FfS2i2`b Ry)X >2+F- hK`c S2i2`b- Ab#2HH UkyRyVX 1t@
T2`i _2+QKK2M/2` avbi2Kb, 1bi#HBb?BM; *QKKmMBiB2b Q7
S`+iB+2 "b2/ QM aQ+BH "QQFK`FBM; avbi2KbX AM, S`Q+22/@
BM;b Q7 A@EMQr kyRyX Ryi? AMi2`MiBQMH *QM72`2M+2 QM EMQr@
H2/;2 JM;2K2Mi M/ EMQrH2/;2 h2+?MQHQ;B2b- 983@9e9X
,6620(
(e) (EMmix Ry) EMmix- Ei?`BMc aQm#mbi- aBKQM2c aiQ+FqQH7;M; :X UkyRyV, h; +Hmbi2`b b BM7Q`KiBQM `2i`B2pH BM@
i2`7+2bX AM, S`Q+22/BM;b Q7 i?2 9ji? MMmH >rBB AMi2`M@
iBQMH *QM72`2M+2 QM avbi2K a+B2M+2b U>A*aa@9jV- Ry T;2bX
(d) (G2v/2b/Q`z y8) G2v/2b/Q`z- GQ2i Ukyy8VX aBKBH`Biv J2b@
m`2- mi?Q` *Q+BiiBQM MHvbBb- M/ AM7Q`KiBQM h?2Q`vX
AM, CQm`MH Q7 i?2 K2`B+M aQ+B2iv 7Q` AM7Q`KiBQM a+B2M+2
M/ h2+?MQHQ;v- 8e- d- deN@ddkX
(3) (G2v/2b/Q`zfom;?M ye) G2v/2b/Q`z- GQ2ic om;?M- GBr2M
UkyyeVX *Q@Q++m``2M+2 Ki`B+2b M/ i?2B` TTHB+iBQMb BM BM@
7Q`KiBQM b+B2M+2, 1ti2M/BM; * iQ i?2 q2# 2MpB`QMK2MiX
AM, CQm`MH Q7 i?2 K2`B+M aQ+B2iv 7Q` AM7Q`KiBQM a+B2M+2
M/ h2+?MQHQ;v- 8d- Rk- ReReRek3X
(N) (GBM; 2i HX y3) GBM;- >mBx?Bc sm- um2c GB- um272M;c LvF_B+?B Ukyy3V, *QHH#Q`iBp2 6BHi2`BM; _2+QKK2M/2` avbi2Kb
lbBM; h; AM7Q`KiBQMX AM, *J AMi2`MiBQMH *QM72`2M+2
QM q2# AMi2HHB;2M+2 M/ AMi2HHB;2Mi ;2Mi h2+?MQHQ;vX kyy3
A111fqA*- 8NekX
(Ry) (GmQ 2i HX y3) GmQ- >2M;c LBm- *?M;vQM;c a?2M- _mBKBMc
lHH`B+?- *`bi2M Ukyy3V, +QHH#Q`iBp2 }Hi2`BM; 7`K2rQ`F
#b2/ QM #Qi? HQ+H mb2` bBKBH`Biv M/ ;HQ#H mb2` bBKBH`BivX
AM, J+?BM2 G2`MBM;- dkfj- kjRk98X
(RR) (S2i2`b yN) S2i2`b- Ab#2HH UkyyNV, 6QHFbQMQKB2bX AM/2tBM;
M/ _2i`B2pH BM q2# kXy UEMQrH2/;2 M/ AM7Q`KiBQMVX .2
:`mvi2`- am`, "2`HBMX
(Rk) (_Q`pB; NN) _Q`pB;- J`F URNNNV, AK;2b Q7 bBKBH`Biv,
oBbmH 1tTHQ`iBQM Q7 PTiBKH aBKBH`Biv J2i`B+b M/ a+HBM;
S`QT2`iB2b Q7 h_1* hQTB+@.Q+mK2Mi a2ibX AM, CQm`MH Q7 i?2
K2`B+M aQ+B2iv 7Q` AM7Q`KiBQM a+B2M+2- 8yf3- ejNe8RX
(Rj) (a+?M2B/2`f"Q`HmM/ yd) a+?M2B/2`- C2bT2` qXc "Q`HmM/- SB
UkyydV, Ji`Bt +QKT`BbQM- S`i R, JQiBpiBQM M/ BKTQ`i@
Mi Bbbm2b 7Q` K2bm`BM; i?2 `2b2K#HM+2 #2ir22M T`QtBK@
Biv K2bm`2b Q` Q`/BMiBQM `2bmHibX AM, CQm`MH Q7 i?2 K2`@
%,%/,2*5$3+<
1RRUD+LUYRQHQ
,QIRUPDWLRQ6WXGLHV )DFXOW\RI+XPDQLWLHV 8QLYHUVLW\RI2XOXDQG'HSDUWPHQWRI6SRUWV
DQG([HUFLVH0HGLFLQH 2XOX'HDFRQHVV,QVWLWXWH
7LP/XRWR
&XOWXUDO$QWKURSRORJ\ 8QLYHUVLW\RI2XOX )LQODQG
Extended abstract
h?2 F2v 2H2K2Mib Q7 bQ+BH K2/B- +QKKmMBiv M/ BMi2`+iBQMKv BM+`2b2 BM/BpB/mHb +iBp2 T`iB+BTiBQM BM p`BQmb bT2+ib Q7
bQ+BH HB72 pB i?2 AMi2`M2i- M/ Qz2` QTTQ`imMBiB2b 7Q` #mBH/BM; +QK@
KmMBiB2b `QmM/ bT2+B}+ ?2Hi? Bbbm2bX aQ+BH K2/B TTHB+iBQMb
+M T`QpB/2 M QT2M THi7Q`K 7Q` b?`BM; B/2b- 2tT2`B2M+2b- QTBM@
BQMb M/ +QM+2`Mb QM ?2Hi? Bbbm2b UJm``v 2i HX- kyy3VX HbQ i?2v
+M Qz2` p`B2iv Q7 i2+?MB+H 72im`2b U2X;X- biimb mT/i2b- K2/B
b?`BM;- TTHB+iBQM ?QbiBM;- bvM+?`QMQmb HBMFBM;- ;`QmT 7Q`KBM;V
i?i `2 r2HH@bmBi2/ 7Q` bmTTQ`iBM; /Bz2`2Mi BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQm`b
UqQ?M 2i HX- kyRRVX _2b2`+? QM bQ+BH K2/B BM AM7Q`KiBQM a+B@
2M+2 ?p2 7Q+mb2/- 7Q` 2tKTH2- QM BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQm` QM /Bz2`@
2Mi bQ+BH M2irQ`FBM; bBi2b UCMb2M 2i HX- kyRRV M/ bQ+BH BM7Q`K@
iBQM mb2b Q7 6+2#QQF UqQ?M 2i HX- kyRRVX
,6620(
([DPLQLQJWKHXVHVRILQWHUQHWDQGVRFLDOPHGLDDPRQJPHQDWPLOLWDU\FRQVFULSWLRQDJH
bQ i?i TiB2Mib UM/ Qi?2` T2QTH2 BMi2`2bi2/ BM ?2Hi?V +M ;i?2`H2`M 7`QK- M/ bmTTQ`i 2+? Qi?2`- iQ BKT`Qp2 ?2Hi? Qmi+QK2bX
h?Bb TT2` `2Hi2b iQ KmHiB/Bb+BTHBM`v `2b2`+? T`QD2+i UJPSPV
r?2`2 i?2 2tT2`iBb2 Q7 b2p2`H /Bb+BTHBM2b- BM+Hm/BM; aTQ`ib J2/B@
+BM2- AM7Q`KiBQM aim/B2b- *mHim`H Mi?`QTQHQ;v- J2/B+H h2+?@
MQHQ;v- M/ 1H2+i`B+H 1M;BM22`BM;- `2 #`Qm;?i iQ;2i?2`X h?2
T`QD2+i Tm`bm2b iQ /2+`2b2 i?2 TQi2MiBH bQ+BH K`;BMHBxiBQM Q7
+QMb+`BTiBQM@;2/ 6BMMBb? K2M #v 2M;;BM; i?2K iQr`/b M +iBp2
HB72bivH2 #v b2iiBM; mT M BMi2`p2MiBQM r?B+? miBHBx2b HbQ bQ+BH K2@
/BX h?2 BK Q7 i?Bb TT2` Bb iQ BMp2biB;i2 i?2 +QMb+`BTiBQM@;2/
K2Mb mb2 Q7 i?2 AMi2`M2i M/ bQ+BH K2/B b2`pB+2b iQ }M/ i?2 #2bi
+?MM2Hb 7Q` `2+?BM; i?2KX h?2 `2bmHib Q7 i?2 bim/v `2TQ`i2/ ?2`2
Kv #2 miBHBx2/ BM b2H2+iBM; M/ TQbbB#Hv /Bz2`2MiBiBM; +?MM2Hb
7Q` ?2Hi? +QKKmMB+iBQM r?2M b2iiBM; mT i?2 BMi2`p2MiBQMX
h?2 bim/v TQTmHiBQM +QMbBbib Q7 HH K2M i KBHBi`v +QMb+`BTiBQM
;2 BM i?2 PmHm `2 BM LQ`i?2`M 6BMHM/ BM kyRy UMRyyyfv2`VX AM
6BMHM/ KBHBi`v b2`pB+2 Bb KM/iQ`v- rBi? QTiBQM Q7 MQM@KBHBi`v
b2`pB+2 Q` iQiH Q#D2+iBQM- M/ MMmHHv HH R3@v2`@QH/ K2M `2
+HH2/ 7Q` KBHBi`v b2`pB+2X h?2`27Q`2- +QMb+`BTiBQM@;2/ K2M T`QpB/2
H`;2- TQTmHiBQM #b2/ `2T`2b2MiiBp2 bKTH2 Q7 6BMMBb? vQmM;
K2MX AM kyRy +QHH2+iBQM Q7 +`Qbb@b2+iBQMH /i rb ;i?2`2/ i i?2
PmHm `2;BQM +HH@mTb r?2`2 TT`QtX Ryyy K2M r2`2 T`2b2Mi M/ Q7
r?QK ey T2`+2Mi }HH2/ BM [m2biBQMMB`2X h?2 [m2biBQMMB`2 +QM@
iBM2/ b2p2`H ?2Hi?@`2Hi2/ i?2K2b BM+Hm/BM; p`BQmb Bi2Kb #Qmi
T?vbB+H +iBpBiv #2?pBQm` +?M;2- BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQm`- M/ i?2
mb2 Q7 AMi2`M2i M/ bQ+BH K2/BX h?2 +QHH2+i2/ /i r2`2 MHvb2/
biiBbiB+HHv mbBM; aiiBbiB+H S+F;2 7Q` i?2 aQ+BH a+B2M+2b UaSaaV
p2`bBQM RNXyX
h?2 `2bTQM/2Mib r2`2 7`QK Rd iQ kk v2` QH/ K2M UK2M ;2
RdXNVX h?2B` ++2bb iQ i?2 AMi2`M2i 7`QK ?QK2 M/ 7`2[m2M+v Q7 Bib
mb2 r2`2 bm`p2v2/ BM+Hm/BM; i?2 /2pB+2b mb2/ 7Q` ++2bbBM; Bi M/
i?2 T2`+2Bp2/ BKTQ`iM+2 Q7 i?2 AMi2`M2iX h?2 Tm`TQb2b 7Q` i?2
AMi2`M2i mb2 KQM; vQmM; K2M r2`2 bF2/- b r2HH b i?2 mb2 Q7
/Bz2`2Mi bQ+BH K2/B b2`pB+2b BM+Hm/BM; i?2 iBK2 BM ?Qm`b T2` /vM/ i?2 `2bQMb 7Q` i?2 mb2X uQmM; K2M r2`2 HbQ bF2/ r?2i?2`
i?2v T`QpB/2 +QMi2Mi iQ i?2 AMi2`M2i- r?i FBM/ Q7 +QMi2Mi- r?2i?2`
i?2v ?p2 i?2B` QrM ?QK2T;2b Q` #HQ;- Q` /Q i?2v 7QHHQr /Bb+mbbBQM
,6620(
Bibliography
(R) "QmHQb- JXLXEX- M/ q?22H2`- aX- kyyd- h?2 2K2`;BM; q2#
kXy bQ+BH bQ7ir`2, M 2M#HBM; bmBi2 Q7 bQ+B#H2 i2+?MQHQ;B2b
BM ?2Hi? M/ ?2Hi? +`2 2/m+iBQM- >2Hi? AM7 GB#` CX k9,k@
kjX
(k) "`2MMM- _X- .?H- aX- M/ 1;H2- GX- kyRy- S2`bm/BM; vQmM;
+QMbmK2`b iQ KF2 ?2Hi?v Mmi`BiBQMH /2+BbBQMb- C J`FX
keUdV,ej8@e88X
(j) *?Qm- qXaX- >mMi- uXJX- "2+FDQ`/- 1X"X- JQb2`- _XSX- M/
>2bb2- "XqX- kyyN- aQ+BH K2/B mb2 BM i?2 lMBi2/ aii2b,
BKTHB+iBQMb 7Q` ?2Hi? +QKKmMB+iBQMX C J2/ AMi2`M2i _2bX
RRU9V,293X
(9) 62`MM/2x@Gm[m2- GX- E`Hb2M- _X- E`Q;bi`/- hX- "m`FQrhXJX M/ oQ;MBH/- GXEX- kyRy- S2`bQMHBx2/ ?2Hi? TTHB+@
iBQMb BM i?2 q2# kXy, i?2 2K2`;2M+v Q7 M2r TT`Q+?- AM,
jkM/ MMmH AMi2`MiBQMH *QM72`2M+2 Q7 i?2 A111 1J"a"m2MQb B`2b- `;2MiBM- m;mbi jR@a2Ti2K#2` 9- kyRyX
(8) CMb2M- "XCX- aQ#2H- EX- M/ *QQF- :X- kyRR- "2BM; M2irQ`F2/
M/ #2BM; 2M;;2/, i?2 BKT+i Q7 bQ+BH M2irQ`FBM; QM 2+Q@
KK2`+2 BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQ`- AM, S`Q+22/BM;b Q7 i?2 kyRR
B*QM72`2M+2- a2iiH2- la 3X@RRX 62#`m`v kyRRX
(e) Jm``v- SXCX- *#`2`- JX- >Mb2M- JX- SiQM- *X- 1HFBM- SXGXM/ 1`/H2v- qXaX- kyy3- hQr`/b //`2bbBM; i?2 QTTQ`imM@
BiB2b M/ +?HH2M;2b Q7 q2# kXy 7Q` ?2Hi? M/ BM7Q`KiB+b-
,6620(
WIKILEAKS COMMENTS
$ 4XDOLWDWLYH,QYHVWLJDWLRQ
1RD$KDURQ\
%DU,ODQ8QLYHUVLW\ ,VUDHO
AMi2`M2i +QKK2Mib `2 T`i Q7 lb2` :2M2`i2/ *QMi2Mi Ul:*Vr?2`2 mb2`b 2tTM/ QM- +`BiB[m2- M/ 2tT`2bb i?2B` B/2b #Qmi p`B@
Qmb iQTB+b BM M2rb M/ MQM@M2rb +QMi2tibX
h?2 +m``2Mi bim/v 7Q+mb2b QM qBFBG2Fb MQM@T`Q}i K2/B Q`@
;MBxiBQM i?i b22Fb iQ /2HBp2` BKTQ`iMi M2rb M/ BM7Q`KiBQM
iQ i?2 Tm#HB+M/ BKb iQ 2tTHQ`2 qBFBG2Fb rQ`H/rB/2 BKT+i
KQM;bi `2/2`b Q7 i?`22 QMHBM2 M2rbTT2`b- b 2tT`2bb2/ i?`Qm;?
`2/2` +QKK2MibX 1+? Q7 i?2 M2rbTT2`bh?2 L2r uQ`F hBK2b
BM i?2 lMBi2/ aii2b- h?2 :m`/BM BM i?2 lMBi2/ EBM;/QK M/
uM2i BM Ab`2HBb KDQ`- TQTmH` +?MM2H Q7 +QKKmMB+iBQM BM
Bib +QmMi`vX h?Bb bim/v BKb iQ +?`+i2`Bx2 M/ MHvx2 i?2 KBM
i?2K2b b 2tT`2bb2/ i?`Qm;? `2/2` +QKK2MibX h?2 irQ T`BK`v
`2b2`+? [m2biBQMb `2, RX q?i `2 i?2 KBM i?2K2b i?i `2
2tT`2bb2/ BM i?2 +QKK2Mib\ kX Ab i?2`2 /Bz2`2M+2 KQM; i?2
i?`22 QMHBM2 M2rbTT2`b +QM+2`MBM; i?2 i?2K2b 2tT`2bb2/ i?`Qm;?
i?2 +QKK2Mib\
h?2 `2b2`+? }M/BM;b Kv 7+BHBii2 BKT`Qp2/ mM/2`biM/BM;- 7Q`
#Qi? i?2 HvKM M/ 7Q` K2/B Q` BM7Q`KiBQM `2b2`+?2`b- Q7 i?2
TQr2` M/ BKT+i Q7 i?2 K2/B M/ BM7Q`KiBQM QM Qm` /BHv HBp2bX
h?Bb TT2` T`2b2Mib M MHvbBb Q7 +QKK2Mib r?B+? r2`2 +QHH2+@
i2/ QM .2+2K#2` Rbi kyRy- i?`22 /vb 7i2` i?2 qBFBG2Fb 2/BiQ`b
#2;M `2H2bBM; ?m;2 KQmMib Q7 H2Fb 7`QK HH Qp2` i?2 rQ`H/X h?2
`2b2`+?2` +QM/m+i2/ +QMi2Mi MHvbBb QM bKTH2 Q7 i?2 +QK@
K2MibX h?2 mi?Q` 2Mi2`2/ i?2 rQ`/ qBFBG2Fb BM i?2 b2`+?
2M;BM2 Q7 2+? M2rbTT2` QM R .2+2K#2`- kyRyX o`BQmb Mbr2`b
,6620(
r2`2 `2i`B2p2/- #mi i?2 mi?Q` /2+B/2/ iQ 7Q+mb QM `iB+H2b i?i /B/
MQi +QM+2Mi`i2 QM bT2+B}+ 2p2Mi- #mi `i?2` QM i?Qb2 `2HiBM;
iQ i?2 qBFBG2Fb T?2MQK2MQM 7`QK rB/2- ;2M2`H T2`bT2+iBp2b 2tT`2bb2/ BM bQK2 +b2b BM i?2 2/BiQ`BH +QHmKMb Q` i?2 QTBMBQM
T;2bX h?2 `2b2`+?2` +?Qb2 QM2 `iB+H2 7`QK uM2i rBi? RNd +QK@
K2Mib- QM2 `iB+H2 7`QK h?2 L2r uQ`F hBK2b rBi? jde +QKK2MibM/ QM2 `iB+H2 7`QK h?2 :m`/BM rBi? j83 +QKK2MibX bKTH2
Q7 8Nd +QKK2Mib rb b2H2+i2/, kyy 7`QK h?2 L2r uQ`F hBK2b- kyy
7`QK h?2 :m`/BM- M/ RNd 7`QK uM2iX h?2 +QKK2Mib 7`QK h?2
L2r uQ`F hBK2b M/ 7`QK h?2 :m`/BM r2`2 `M/QKHv b2H2+i2/
#v /`rBM; 2p2`v i?B`/ +QKK2Mi 7`QK 2+? M2rbTT2`X HH uM2i
+QKK2Mib r2`2 b2H2+i2/X h?2 /2b+`BTiBp2 biiBbiB+H MHvbBb M/
i?2 +QMi2Mi MHvbBb r2`2 +QM/m+i2/ QM i?2b2 8Nd +QKK2MibX h?2
b2+QM/ T?b2 Q7 i?2 `2b2`+? BMpQHp2/ biiBbiB+H /2b+`BTiBp2 M@
HvbBb M/ i?2 i?B`/ T?b2 BMpQHp2/ +QMi2Mi MHvbBbX AM Q`/2` iQ
+HbbB7v i?2 +QKK2Mib- i?2 mi?Q` /BpB/2/ 2+? +QKK2Mi BMiQ mMBib
Q7 K2MBM;- r?B+? +QKT`Bb2 i?2 mMBib Q7 MHvbBbX mMBi Q7 K2M@
BM; +M #2 T?`b2- b2Mi2M+2- Q` b2p2`H b2Mi2M+2b i?i +QMp2v
QM2 K2bb;2X h?2 i2`K rb +QBM2/ #v >2M`B URNNkV- r?Q `;m2/
i?i +QKTmi2`@K2/Bi2/ +QKKmMB+iBQM K2bb;2b ?/ KQ`2 i?M
QM2 mMBi Q7 K2MBM;- M/ i?i QM2 b?QmH/ /2}M2 Bib QrM `2H2pMi
mMBi Q7 K2MBM;X h?2 8Nd +QKK2Mib +QMbBbi2/ Q7 Rkyy mMBib Q7 M@
HvbBbX 1+? +HbbB}+iBQM rb bb2bb2/ #v bBM;H2 +HbbB}2` M/ i?2M
+`Qbb@+?2+F2/ #v b2+QM/ +HbbB}2`Xh?2 }MH T2`+2Mi;2 Q7 ;`22@
K2Mi 7Q` HH +Q/BM; /2+BbBQMb rb NkW- bm;;2biBM; i?i i?2 +Q/BM;
+HbbB}+iBQM mb2/ rb `2HB#H2X
h?2 M2ti b2+iBQMb T`2b2Mi i?2 KBM }M/BM;bX h?2 +QMi2Mi MHvbBb
`2p2Hb /Bz2`2M+2b #2ir22M h?2 L2r uQ`F hBK2b- h?2 :m`/BM QM
QM2 ?M/ M/ uM2i QM i?2 Qi?2`X AM #Qi? h?2 L2r uQ`F hBK2b M/
h?2 :m`/BM i?2 qBFBH2Fb Bbbm2 Bb Q7 KDQ` BMi2`2bi- ii`+iBM;
Km+? +QKK2Mi2` ii2MiBQMX AM h?2 L2r uQ`F hBK2b i?2 qBFBH2Fb
iQTB+ +QKT`Bb2b #Qmi kdXdyW Q7 iQiH mMBib Q7 MHvbBb M/ BM+Hm/2b
p`BQmb bT2+ib bm+? b, 7Q` M/ ;BMbi qBFBH2Fb- 7Q` M/ ;BMbi
bbM;2- qBFBH2Fb pHm2- BKT+i M/ TQHB+vX AM h?2 :m`/@
BM i?2 qBFBH2Fb Bbbm2 Bb H`;2` M/ ++QmMib 7Q` 9kXdkW Q7 iQiH
mMBib Q7 MHvbBb M/ BM+Hm/2b i?2 bK2 bT2+ibX h?Bb #`Q/ +i@
2;Q`v, qBFBH2Fb i?i rb 7QmM/ BM #Qi? h?2 L2r uQ`F hBK2b M/
:LNL/HDNV&RPPHQWV
,6620(
:LNL/HDNV&RPPHQWV
Bibliography
,6620(
Introduction
.iBM; r2#bBi2b `2 7`2[m2MiHv bim/B2/ 7Q`K Q7 bQ+BH K2/B
r?2`2 T2QTH2 K2bm`2 i?2 Qmi+QK2, .B/ A }M/ T`iM2`\ q?BH2
mb2`b Q7 i?2b2 bBi2b ?p2 i?Bb +H2` K2bm`2- `2b2`+?2`b ?p2 MQi
2tKBM2/ i?2 2tTHB+Bi Qmi+QK2b Q7 bm+? +iBpBivX AMbi2/- Tbi
bim/B2b ?p2 7Q+mb2/ QM i?2 +?`+i2`BbiB+b Q7 BM/BpB/mHb r?Q mb2
QMHBM2 /iBM; bBi2b Uai2T?m`2 2i HX- kyyNc amii2` 2i HX- kyRyV?Qr BM/BpB/mHb `2T`2b2Mi i?2Kb2Hp2b QM /Bz2`2Mi QMHBM2 /iBM; r2#@
bBi2b U>M+Q+F hQK kyyNc 1HHBbQM 2i HX- kyyNV- M/ i?2 b2`+?
bi`i2;B2b BM/BpB/mHb miBHBx2 iQ }M/ T`iM2` U6BQ`2 2i HX- kyRyc
>Bib+? 2i HX- kyyeVX Pm` bim/v }HHb ;T BM bQ+BH K2/B `2b2`+?
#v 2tKBMBM; Tm#HB+HHv pBH#H2 bm++2bb biQ`B2b +QHH2+i2/ i?`Qm;?
bvbi2KiB+ `M/QK bKTH2 7`QK bm++2bb bBi2b {HBi2/ rBi? i?`22
Q7 i?2 KQbi TQTmH` QMHBM2 /iBM; r2#bBi2b BM i?2 lMBi2/ aii2bJi+?X+QK UM4899V- 2>`KQMv UM4kRjV M/ PF*mTB/ UM4eRVX
,6620(
/RRNLQJIRU/RYHLQ$OOWKH5LJKW3ODFHV
Bb i?2 7Qm`i? ?B;?2bi MmK#2` Q7 bm++2bb biQ`B2b 7Q` Mv +Biv- BM i?2
laX h?2 iQT i?`22 +BiB2b rBi? i?2 ?B;?2bi MmK#2` Q7 bm++2bb biQ`B2b
BM Qm` bKTH2 `2 >QmbiQM UM4RRV- *?B+;Q UM4NV- M/ L2r uQ`F
*Biv UM43VX h?Bb MQKHv M/ T`2HBKBM`v MHvbBb Q7 i?2 biQ`B2b
bbQ+Bi2/ rBi? i?2b2 T`Q}H2b bm;;2bib i?i bQ+BH M2irQ`Fb BM i?2
`2H rQ`H/ /Q BM~m2M+2 QMHBM2 bQ+BH M2irQ`F /QTiBQM BM i?2 +b2 Q7
QMHBM2 /iBM; bBi2bX h?Bb Bb M BMi2`2biBM; `2 7Q` 7mim`2 `2b2`+?X
Pm` b2+QM/ }M/BM; Bb i?i i?2 K2bm`2b Q7 /iBM; bm++2bb `2
/Bz2`2Mi 7Q` 2+? Q7 i?2 i?`22 r2# bBi2bX h?Bb }M/BM; Bb BHHmbi`i2/
BM h#H2 RX 2>`KQMvb bm++2bb biQ`B2b `2 KQbiHv +QKT`Bb2/ Q7
K``B2/ +QmTH2b U39WV- r?2`2b i?2 MmK#2` Q7 K``B2/ +QmTH2b QM
Ji+?X+QK U9eXdWV M/ PF*mTB/ UkjWV Bb bB;MB}+MiHv HQr2`X /@
/BiBQMHHv- i?2 MmK#2` Q7 2>`KQMv M/ Ji+?X+QK bm++2bb T`Q}H2b
BM+`2b2b 7`QK .iBM; i?`Qm;? 1M;;2/ iQ J``B2/- r?2`2b PF@
*mTB/b 7`2[m2M+v /2+`2b2b 7`QK .iBM; i?`Qm;? J``B2/X am++2bb
QM 2>`KQMv Bb /2}M2/ b K``B;2- r?2`2b bm++2bb QM Ji+?X+QK
Bb KQ`2 2p2MHv bTHBiX PF*mTB/ mb2`b KQbi +QKKQMHv /2}M2 bm++2bb
b /iBM;X h?Bb ?b BKTQ`iMi BKTHB+iBQMb 7Q` i?2 K2bm`2K2Mi
Q7 bm++2bb Q7 `2HiBQMb?BTb BM bQ+BH K2/BX am++2bb Bb +QMi2timH
M/ T`iB+BTMi /2}M2/X qBi? 7mim`2 bim/B2b r2 rBHH 2tTHQ`2 ?Qr
/Bz2`2Mi K2bm`2b Q7 bm++2bb #2+QK2 b2H7@T2`T2imiBM; QM /iBM;
bBi2b- Q` +?M;2 Qp2` iBK2 b +HB2Mib 2pQHp2X PM2 HbQ KB;?i 2tT2+i
i?2 +HB2Mi2H2 QM QMHBM2 /iBM; bBi2b iQ im`M Qp2` KQ`2 `2;mH`Hv i?M
Qi?2` 7Q`Kb Q7 bQ+BH K2/BX lM/2`biM/BM; i?2b2 `i2b Q7 +?M;2
Kv T`QpB/2 M //BiBQMH- BKTHB+Bi K2bm`2 Q7 bm++2bbX
h?2 i?B`/ }M/BM; /2KQMbi`i2b /Bz2`2M+2 BM i?2 +QMi2Mi Q7 i?2
rQ`/b miBHBx2/ BM i?2 bm++2bb biQ`B2bX h?2 KQbi mb2/ rQ`/ rBi?BM
2+? b2i Q7 biQ`B2b rb i?2 MK2 Q7 i?2 /iBM; r2#bBi2 r?2`2 BM@
/BpB/mHb K2iX h?Bb BHHmbi`i2b i?i r?2M /2b+`B#BM; bm++2bb7mH
`2HiBQMb?BT BM/BpB/mHb `272` iQ i?2 K2+?MBbK BM r?B+? i?2v K2i
i p2`v ?B;? `i2X PM2 Q7 i?2 KQbi 7`2[m2MiHv mb2/ T?`b2b i?i W
qBi?BM aBi2 Q7 1+? aiimb TT2`2/ BM HKQbi ?H7 Q7 i?2 T`Q}H2b
rb /2`BpiBp2 Q7 h?MF vQm UPMHBM2 .iBM; aBi2VX h?Bb BM/B+@
i2b i?i i?2 i2+?MQHQ;v miBHBx2/ 7Q` }M/BM; T`iM2` rb bHB2Mi
bT2+i Q7 i?2 bm++2bb biQ`B2b M/ i?i i?2 +QmTH2b Kv ii`B#mi2
bQK2 H2p2H Q7 i?2B` bm++2bb iQ i?2 i2+?MQHQ;vX
C&:'&.!&!)1'"8)S.$-(7)$%'"#7%)N.''-&C5))+#::&!!)"()&<.'8"(;)-!)C&1-(&C).!)8.''-.7&3),%&'&.!)
!#::&!!)"()N.$:%5:"8)-!)8"'&)&V&(0;)!/0-$5)HFA#/-C)#!&'!)8"!$):"88"(0;)C&1-(&)!#::&!!).!))
IC.$-(75J))6%-!)%.!)-8/"'$.($)-8/0-:.$-"(!)1"')$%&)8&.!#'&8&($)"1)!#::&!!)"1)'&0.$-"(!%-/!)-()!":-.0)
8&C-.5))+#::&!!)-!):"($&W$#.0).(C)/.'$-:-/.($)C&1-(&C5))X-$%)1#$#'&)!$#C-&!),&),-00)&W/0"'&)%",)
C-11&'&($)8&.!#'&!)"1)!#::&!!)9&:"8&)!&01Y/&'/&$#.$-(7)"()C.$-(7)!-$&!3)"'):%.(7&)"V&')$-8&).!)
:0-&($!)&V"0V&5))H(&).0!")8-7%$)&W/&:$)$%&):0-&($&0&)"()"(0-(&)C.$-(7)!-$&!)$")$#'()"V&')8"'&)'&7#0.'0;)
$%.()"$%&')1"'8!)"1)!":-.0)8&C-.5))*(C&'!$.(C-(7)$%&!&)'.$&!)"1):%.(7&)8.;)/'"V-C&).().CC-$-"(.03)
,6620(
-8/0-:-$)8&.!#'&)"1)!#::&!!5)
GL)
!"#$%&$'"($%)"*+",-.&"(%-%/0"
B4)
G4)
P4)
O4)
LO5P)
\4)
24)
?\5\)
Q4)
S.$-(7)
QP5B)
2Q5\)
L4)
?4)
LB5Q)
Q2)
Q45G)
T(7.7&C))
N.''-&C)
45\)
4)
&<.'8"(;)
N.$:%)
H]A#/-C)
1'2$')"3-%$'4"#)50$%)"
6.90&)?Z)X%.$)I+#::&!!J)0""F!)0-F&)1"')C-11&'&($)H(0-(&)S.$-(7)X&9!-$&!)
6%&)$%-'C)1-(C-(7)C&8"(!$'.$&!).)C-11&'&(:&)-()$%&):"($&($)"1)$%&),"'C!)#$-0-[&C)-()$%&)!#::&!!)
!$"'-&!5))6%&)8"!$)#!&C),"'C),-$%-()&.:%)!&$)"1)!$"'-&!),.!)$%&)(.8&)"1)$%&)C.$-(7),&9!-$&),%&'&)
-(C-V-C#.0!)8&$5))6%-!)-00#!$'.$&!)$%.$),%&()C&!:'-9-(7).)!#::&!!1#0)'&0.$-"(!%-/)-(C-V-C#.0!)'&1&')$")
$%&)8&:%.(-!8)-(),%-:%)$%&;)8&$).$).)V&';)%-7%)'.$&5))H(&)"1)$%&)8"!$)1'&U#&($0;)#!&C)/%'.!&!)$%.$)
/RRNLQJIRU/RYHLQ$OOWKH5LJKW3ODFHV
Bibliography
,6620(
#bi`+i
,6620(
Introduction
>QKQ Gm/2Mb BKTBM;2b QM ?Bb 2MpB`QMK2Mi, >2 BMi2``mTib+?M;2b- BMi2MbB}2bc ?2 7QHHQrb Ti?b M/ BM TbbBM;- H2p2b i`+2b
Q7 ?Bb T`2b2M+2 2p2`vr?2`2X R
q?2M BMi2`+iBM; rBi? BM7Q`KiBQM bT+2b HBF2 i?2 q2# Q` HB#@
``B2b- mb2`b Kv H2p2 K`Fb Q` i`+2b Q7 i?2B` +iBpBiB2b i?i Kv
;mB/2 Qi?2` mb2`b iQ }M/ M/ mb2 BM7Q`KiBQM `2bQm`+2bX 1tKTH2b
Q7 bm+? #2?pBQm`H i`+2b `2 rQ`M +Qp2`b- /Q;@2`2/ T;2b M/
?M/r`Bii2M MQi2b BM #QQFbc H27i@#2?BM/ #QQFb QM i#H2c mb2`@
;2M2`i2/ iQTB+H i;b M/ `iBM;b BM QMHBM2 +iHQ;m2bc 2/Bib BM
rBFBbc r2# bBi2 HQ; }H2b Q7 mb2` pBbBibc M/ Km+? KQ`2 (2X;X d- Rek3)X b rBHH #2 2H#Q`i2/ 7m`i?2` #2HQr- #2?pBQm`H i`+2b +M
#2 T?vbB+H Q` /B;BiH- BMi2M/2/ Q` mMBMi2M/2/ #v i?2 i`+2 H2p2`
#2BM; BM /B`2+i Q` BM/B`2+i +QMi+i rBi? i?2 i`+2 }M/2`X
L2r zQ`/M+2b- BX2X +iBQM#H2 T`QT2`iB2b (kj)- 7Q` mb2`b #Qi? iQ
H2p2 #2?pBQm`H i`+2b M/ iQ }M/ M/ 7QHHQr #2?pBQm`H i`+2b
7`QK Qi?2` mb2`b- ?p2 #22M F2v /`Bp2`b BM i?2 /2p2HQTK2Mi Q7 M2r
T`iB+BTiQ`v BM7Q`KiBQM bT+2b BM+Hm/BM; bQ+BH K2/B THi7Q`KbX
h;;BM;- `iBM;- 2/BiBM;- M/ `2@KBtBM; `2 2tKTH2b Q7 T`iB+BTi@
Q`v +iBpBiB2b M/ mb2`@iQ@ mb2` K2/BiBQM (R) H2pBM; #2?pBQm`H
i`+2b i?i +M #2 7QmM/ M/ 7QHHQr2/ #v Qi?2` mb2`bX h?Bb FBM/ Q7
bQ+BH MpB;iBQM (e- d) /2Hb rBi? mb2`b #2?pBQm` i?i Bb ;mB/2/
#v i?2 #2?pBQm` Q7 Qi?2` mb2`bc KQpBM; i?`Qm;? M BM7Q`KiBQM
bT+2 M/ 2tTHQBiBM; i?2 +iBpBiB2b M/ Q`B2MiiBQMb Q7 Qi?2`b BM i?i
bT+2 (d- TX kdd)X
h?Bb TT2` #`B2~v QmiHBM2b 7`K2rQ`F 7Q` /Bb+mbbBM; zQ`/M+2b
7Q` #2?pBQm`H i`+2b- mb2`@iQ@mb2` K2/BiBQM M/ bQ+BH MpB;iBQM
BM T`iB+BTiQ`v HB#``v b2iiBM; UGB#``v kXyVX aT2+BH 7Q+mb Bb QM
bm+? zQ`/M+2b 7Q` BM/B`2+i- bvM+?`QMQmb- mb2`@iQ@mb2` K2/BiBQM
M/ bQ+BH MpB;iBQM 7+BHBii2/ #v #2?pBQm`H i`+2b H27i #2?BM/
#v mb2`b BM i?2 T?vbB+H GB#``v kXyX
JMv GB#``v kXy TT`Q+?2b M/ /Bb+mbbBQMb ?p2 7Q+mb2/ QM
r2#@ #b2/ bQHmiBQMb HBF2 #HQ;b- rBFBb- i;;BM;- bQ+BH M2irQ`F bBi2b2i+X- 7Q` mb2` T`iB+BTiBQM (2X;X N- kk)X h?Bb TT2` T`2b2Mib ?QH@
R *QMbiMi
%HKDYLRXUDO7UDFHVDQG,QGLUHFW8VHUWR8VHU0HGLDWLRQ
,6620(
F igure 1. ,QWHJUDWLYH PXOWLPRGDO LQWHUIDFH PRGHO > @ 8VHU LQ FHQWHU ZLWKLQ VRFLRcognitive-HPERGLHG FRQWH[W EURNHQ OLQH FLUFOH LQWHUDFWV GRXEOH DUURZV ZLWK KXPDQ
(hum.), physical (phys.) and digital (dig.) information resources. Between resources are
mediation flows (single arrows). See more details and explanations in [1].
3.
A F F O R D A N C ES F O R USE R-T O-USE R
M E D I AT I O N+QMi2MiI N T H E M/
WHO
L E 2bv
I N F OBbR Bi
M A7Q`
TIO
N iQ }M/
b?`BM; BM7Q`KiBQMH
?Qr
mb2`b
E H AV
I O U+QMi2Mi
R L I F E BM
C YHHC LT`ib
E
M/ H2`M B7`QK
bm+?
Q7 i?2 HB#``vb BMi2;`iBp2
BMi2`7+2 b KQ/2HH2/ BM 6B;X R\
In the participatory library outlined above, different affordances for user-toAM GB#``v M/ AM7Q`KiBQM a+B2M+2 UGAaV- ?mKM BM7Q`KiBQM
user mediation are essential: How well do library interfaces allow users to
#2?pBQm`
?b #22M
b i?2
iQiHBiv
Q7 ?mKM
#2?pBQ` BM
leave behavioural
traces/2}M2/
by creating,
storing
and sharing
informational
`2HiBQM
+?MM2Hb
Q7 BM7Q`KiBQMBM+Hm/BM;
content, iQ
andbQm`+2b
how easy M/
is it for
users to find
and learn from such
content in#Qi?
all +i@
parts
RIWKHOLEUDU\VLQWHJUDWLYHLQWHUIDFHDVPRGHOOHGLQ)LJ"
Bp2 M/ TbbBp2 BM7Q`KiBQM b22FBM;- M/ BM7Q`KiBQM mb2 (jy)X h?2
7`K2rQ`F QmiHBM2/ BM i?Bb TT2` mM7QH/b i?2 pB2r QM ?mKM BM7Q`K@
iBQM #2?pBQm` #v /BpB/BM; Bi BMiQ }p2 KBM 7+2ib F2v 7+2ib BM
GAa `2b2`+? /2HBM; rBi? ?Qr ?mKMb +`2i2- biQ`2- b?`2- }M/
M/ H2`M r?2M ?M/HBM; /Bz2`2Mi FBM/b Q7 BM7Q`KiBQMH +QMi2Mi+7X 6B;X kX
h?2 MQiBQM Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM mb2 BM qBHbQMb /2}MBiBQM #Qp2 Bb
i?mb 2tTM/2/ BMiQ KQ`2 7+2ib BM Q`/2` iQ +QKT`Bb2 m;K2Mi2/ 7@
7Q`/M+2b 7Q` mb2`b BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQm` BM T`iB+BTiQ`v HB#``v
b2iiBM;X
h?2 `2bmHiBM; biB+F KM BM 6B;X k `2T`2b2Mib i?2 mb2` BM 6B;X
Rc mb2` r?Q +M ?M/H2 BM7Q`KiBQM BM /Bz2`2Mi rvb BM /Bz2`2Mi
bBimiBQMbX h?2 Q`/2` Q7 i?2 }p2 7+2ib b?QmH/ MQi #2 mM/2`biQQ/
bi`B+iHv HBM2`Hv- b /Bz2`2Mi ivT2b Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQm` +M
Q++m` BM /Bz2`2Mi Q`/2` BM /Bz2`2Mi BM7Q`KiBQMH T`Q+2bb2bX
LENNART BJRNEBORN
4.
%HKDYLRXUDO7UDFHVDQG,QGLUHFW8VHUWR8VHU0HGLDWLRQ
KBM #2?pBQm`H 7+2ib BM i?2 KQ/2HX h?i Bb- #2bB/2b i?2 i`/B@
iBQMH 7+2ib }M/ M/ H2`M- mb2`b b?QmH/ HbQ #2 #H2 iQ +`2i2- biQ`2
M/ b?`2 BM7Q`KiBQMH +QMi2Mi b T`i Q7 i?2 BMi2;`iBp2 HB#``v
BMi2`7+2- 2X;X BM QMHBM2 +iHQ;m2b- rBFBb- #HQ;b- Q` BM i?2 HB#``vb
T?vbB+H b2iiBM;bX
AM Qi?2` rQ`/b- T`iB+BTiQ`v TT`Q+?2b HBF2 GB#``v kXy T`QpB/2
KQ`2 zQ`/M+2b 7Q` mb2`@iQ@mb2` K2/BiBQM #Qi? rBi? `2;`/ iQ
H2pBM; #2?pBQm`H i`+2b U+`2i2- biQ`2- b?`2V M/ iQ 7QHHQrBM;
bm+? i`+2b U}M/- H2`MVX
URV
WUDFHOHDYHU
For example, a user may discover behavioural traces in the shape of books
left behind after use on a table by other users in a physical library (cf. Fig.
4a). This indirect user-to-XVHU PHGLDWLRQ PD\ QRWEH LQWHQGHGE\WKHWUDFH
OHDYHUV EXW LV SHUFHLYHG E\ WKH WUDFH ILQGHU LQ KLV RU KHU LQGLUHFW VRFLDO
,6620(
navigation.
T able 1. Typology for direct and indirect user-to-user mediation and social navigation.
UkV
user-recommended books (Fig. 4c). The same library also provided tabs with
smileys and ratings (*LJJOH, 6RE, 6KRFN, <DZQ, etc.) for users to
attach to books they liked or disliked (Fig. 4d). This is an example of an
affordance for indirect and intended user-to-user mediation and social
navigation in the physical library with obvious parallels to tagging and rating
in library online catalogues [e.g. 3, 9, 18] or on social web sites like
%HKDYLRXUDO7UDFHVDQG,QGLUHFW8VHUWR8VHU0HGLDWLRQ
LibraryThing.com.
Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM `2bQm`+2b MQi FMQrM Q` MQi THMM2/ BM /pM+2 (Rk)X PM2 Q7 i?2 HB#``B2b BM i?2 bim/v ?/ b?2Hp2b rBi? mb2`@iQ@ mb2`@
`2+QKK2M/2/ #QQFb U6B;X 9+VX h?2 bK2 HB#``v HbQ T`QpB/2/ i#b
rBi? bKBH2vb M/ `iBM;b U:B;;H2- aQ#- a?Q+F- urM- 2i+XV 7Q`
mb2`b iQ ii+? iQ #QQFb i?2v HBF2/ Q` /BbHBF2/ U6B;X 9/VX h?Bb Bb
M 2tKTH2 Q7 M zQ`/M+2 7Q` BM/B`2+i M/ BMi2M/2/ mb2`@iQ@mb2`
K2/BiBQM M/ bQ+BH MpB;iBQM BM i?2 T?vbB+H HB#``v rBi? Q#pBQmb
T`HH2Hb iQ i;;BM; M/ `iBM; BM HB#``v QMHBM2 +iHQ;m2b (2X;X jN- R3) Q` QM bQ+BH r2# bBi2b HBF2 GB#``vh?BM;X+QKX
,6620(
5.
A U GbQ+BH
M E NMpB;iBQM
T E D A F F#v
O RH2pBM;
D A N CM/
ES }M/BM;
F O R USE
R-T#2@
OK2/BiBQM
M/
/B;BiH
USE
R
M
E
D
I
AT
I
O
N
I
N
T
H
E
PA
R
T
I
C
IPAT
O
R
Y
?pBQm`H i`+2b BM T?vbB+H bT+2bX
LIBRAR
Y 7Q+mb2/ QM i`Mb72``BM; r2# b2`pB+2b HBF2
aQ 7`- HB#``B2b
?p2
b2`+?BM;- `2b2`piBQM- `272`2M+2 b2`pB+2- 2i+X- iQ KQ#BH2 THi7Q`Kb
Mobile,
ambient, and
location-based
connect
(2X;X
8- 3)Xpervasive,
h?2b2 TT`Q+?2b
?p2
i?mb KBMHvtechnologies
#22M +QM+2`M2/
physical
and
digital
information
spaces.
For
example,
by
mobile
phones
rBi? i?2 irQ 7+2ib }M/ M/ H2`M BM i?2 BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQm` HB72able
of displaying
physical
objectskXy
enriched
RFID #2
chips,
+v+H2
KQ/2H BM information
6B;X kX AM from
T?vbB+H
GB#``v
b2iiBM;with
Bi rQmH/
2D
barcodes,
etc.
[e.g.
4,
15,
25,
29].
These
technologies
provide
BMi2`2biBM; b r2HH iQ H2i mb2`b +`2i2- biQ`2- M/ b?`2 BM7Q`KiBQMnew
affordances
for indirect
user-to-user#vmediation
and social
rBi?
KQ#BH2 T?QM2b7Q` 2tKTH2mbBM; KQ#BH2
T?QM2bnavigation
iQ i`+F by
leaving
finding
digital`2pB2rbbehavioural
physical spaces.
M/
b?Qrand
i;b`iBM;bM/traces
Qi?2`in#2?pBQm`H
i`+2b- /B@
So far, libraries have focused on transferring web services like searching,
;BiHHv ii+?2/ #v Qi?2` mb2`b iQ T?vbB+H BM7Q`KiBQM `2bQm`+2b BM
reservation, reference service, etc., to mobile platforms [e.g. 5, 8]. These
i?2 T?vbB+H HB#``vX aBKBH` zQ`/M+2b 7Q` m;K2MiBM; T?vbB+H
approaches have thus mainly been concerned with the two facets find and
bT+2b
/B;BiH- BM7Q`KiBQMH Hv2`b `2 H`2/v T`QpB/2/ b
learn rBi?
in the information behaviour life cycle model in Fig. 2. In a physical
TTHB+iBQMb
bK`iT?QM2b
+QKTMB2b
HBF2toGv`X+QKX
Library 2.0 7Q`
setting
it would be #v
interesting
as well
let users create, store,
m;K2MiBM;
T?vbB+H
2MpB`QMK2Mib
rBi?
+QKKmMB+iBp2
/2pB+2b
and share information with mobile phones, for example, by using
mobile
+M
HbQ
#2
BM
i?2
b?T2
Q7
bQ@+HH2/
K#B2Mi
BMi2`7+2b
(2X;X
RR- R9phones to track and show tags, ratings, reviews, and other behavioural
traces,
k8-digitally
kN)X lbBM;
pBbmH
Qi?2` information
b2MbQ`v KQ/2b
7Q` `2T@
attached
by +m2bother bQmM/users toM/
physical
resources
in the
`2b2MiBM;
#2?pBQm`H
Tii2`Mb
#v mb2`b iQ
Qi?2` spaces
mb2`b BMwith
physical ;;`2;i2/
library. Similar
affordances
for augmenting
physical
HB#``v
#2 K2Mb
iQ biBKmHi2
mb2`@iQ@mb2`
K2/BiBQM
M/ IRU
digLWDO +QmH/
LQIRUPDWLRQDO
OD\HUV
DUH DOUHDG\
SURYLGHG DV
DSSOLFDWLRQV
smartphones by companies like Layar.com.
%HKDYLRXUDO7UDFHVDQG,QGLUHFW8VHUWR8VHU0HGLDWLRQ
Concluding remarks
h?Bb TT2` ?b T`2b2Mi2/ 7`K2rQ`F 7Q` /Bb+mbbBM; zQ`/M+2b
7Q` mb2`@iQ@ mb2` K2/BiBQM M/ bQ+BH MpB;iBQM- 7Q` H2pBM; M/
7QHHQrBM; #2?pBQm`H i`+2b Q7 mb2` +iBpBiB2b BM T`iB+BTiQ`v HB#@
``v b2iiBM;X aT2+BH 7Q+mb ?b #22M QM zQ`/M+2b 7Q` BM/B`2+i mb2`@
iQ@mb2` K2/BiBQM M/ bQ+BH MpB;iBQM BM i?2 T?vbB+H GB#``v kXy
r?2`2 mb2`b +iBpBiB2b Kv #2 ;mB/2/ #v i`+2b H27i Q7 Qi?2` mb2`b
+iBpBiB2bX AM i?Bb +QMi2ti- i?2 TT2` ?b TQBMi2/ iQ HQr@ i2+? b
r2HH b ?B@i2+? 2tKTH2b +`Qbb ?mKM- T?vbB+H- M/ /B;BiH KQ/@
HBiB2b rBi? `B+? TQi2MiBHb 7Q` 7m`i?2` /2p2HQTK2Mi M/ BMi2;`iBQM
i?i Kv 7+BHBii2 #Qi? i`+2 H2p2`b M/ i`+2 }M/2`bX
AM +QMiBMmiBQM Q7 i?2 BMi`Q/m+iQ`v [mQi2- i?2 QmiHBM2/ BMi2;@
`iBp2 HB#``v BMi2`7+2 BM 6B;X R Kv #2 b22M b T`iB+BTiQ`v
K2/BmK M/ M 2M#HBM; M/ 2M;;BM; KmHiB@Tm`TQb2 bT+2 M
QT2M@KBM/2/ bT+2 (kd) 7Q` >QKQ Gm/2Mb- i?2 SHvBM; JM (RN)X
,6620(
Bibliography
,6620(
G#X
%,%/,2*5$3+<
,6620(
Theoretical background
*QKTmi2`@K2/Bi2/ 2MpB`QMK2Mib U*J1V BM ;2M2`H M/ i?2 AM@
i2`M2i BM T`iB+mH` HHQr mb2`b iQ +`2i2 M/ /2p2HQT pB`imH B/2M@
iBiB2b M/ bT+2b i?i Q++mTv M2Bi?2` bT+2 MQ` iBK2 UST+?`BbbBkyykVX J+E2MM M/ "`;? UkyyyV T`QTQb2/ 7Qm` /QKBMb BM r?B+?
bQ+BH BMi2`+iBQM pB *J1 /Bz2`b 7`QK Qi?2` +QMp2MiBQMH K2/B,
`2HiBp2 MQMvKBiv- ii2MmiBQM Q7 T?vbB+H /BbiM+2- `2/m+2/ BK@
TQ`iM+2 Q7 T?vbB+H TT2`M+2 M/ ;`2i2` +QMi`QH Qp2` i?2 iBK2
M/ T+2 Q7 BMi2`+iBQMbX P7 T`iB+mH` `2H2pM+2 iQ i?2 T`2b2Mi
bim/v `2 i?2 MQiBQM Q7 MQMvKBiv M/ i?2 +QMi`QH i?i *J1b bm+?
b #HQ;b HHQr BM/BpB/mHb Qp2` i?2B` BMi2`+iBQMb rBi? Qi?2`bX +@
+Q`/BM; iQ amH2` Ukyy9V- MQMvKBiv Bb i?2 +QM+2HK2Mi Q7 B/2MiBiv
i?i #2+QK2b TQbbB#H2 r?2M T2QTH2 ?p2 i?2 QTTQ`imMBiv iQ b2T@
`i2 i?2B` +iBQMb QMHBM2 7`QK i?2B` BM@T2`bQM HB72 bivH2 M/ B/2M@
iBivc i?2v 722H H2bb pmHM2`#H2 #Qmi b2H7@/Bb+HQbBM; #2+mb2 r?i2p2`
i?2v bv Q` /Q +MMQi #2 /B`2+iHv HBMF2/ iQ i?2 `2bi Q7 i?2B` HBp2bX
a2H7 /Bb+HQbm`2 Bb i?2 +i Q7 `2p2HBM; T2`bQMH BM7Q`KiBQM iQ Qi?@
2`b U`+?2`- RN3y- TXR3jVX h?Bb T`QT2MbBiv M BM/BpB/mH ?b 7Q`
`2p2HBM; T2`bQMH BM7Q`KiBQM `2Hi2b iQ i?2 +QMi2Mi Q7 i?2 b2H7@
T`2b2MiiBQM i?2v +?QQb2 iQ /BbTHv UC2Mb2M *?m :BHHv- kyyjVX
h?Bb bim/v BMp2biB;i2b b2H7@T`2b2MiiBQM M/ b2H7@/Bb+HQbm`2 BM T2`@
bQMH #HQ;b 7mM+iBQMBM; b pB`imH T2`bQMH bT+2bX
,6620(
Methods
h?Bb bim/v 2tKBM2b i?2 7QHHQrBM; [m2biBQMb `2;`/BM; i?2 +`2@
iBQM Q7 pB`imH T`2b2M+2 BM #HQ;b,
R >Qr /Q #HQ;;2`b b2H7@T`2b2Mi BM i?2B` #HQ;b M/ r?i `QH2 /Q2b
i?Bb T2`bQMH bT+2 ?p2 BM i?2 #HQ;;2`b HB72\
k hQ r?i 2ti2Mi i?2 T2`+2TiBQM Q7 #HQ; b T2`bQMH bT+2
HHQrb #HQ;;2`b iQ /Bb+HQb2 T2`bQMH BM7Q`KiBQM\
j q?i FBM/ Q7 T2`bQMH BM7Q`KiBQM Bb BM+Hm/2/ BM i?2 #HQ;;2`b
b2H7@/Bb+HQbm`2\
9 hQ r?i 2ti2Mi #HQ;;2`b FMQr i?2B` `2/2`b M/ ?Qr i?2 `2/@
2`b +QKK2Mib BM~m2M+2 i?2 #HQ;;2`b b2H7@T`2b2MiiBQM M/
b2H7@/Bb+HQbm`2\
h?2 bim/v rb +QM/m+i2/ 7Q` QM2 KQMi? U.2+2K#2` R8 iQ CMm@
`v R8- kyRRV mbBM; M QMHBM2 bm`p2vX h?2 #HQ;b BM i?2 bKTH2 r2`2
b2H2+i2/ 7`QK i?2 T2`bQMH #HQ;b +i2;Q`v BM irQ Ab`2HB #HQ; /B`2+i@
Q`B2b M/ Bi +QMbBbi2/ Q7 `2;mH`Hv KBMiBM2/ T2`bQMH #HQ;b r`Bii2M
BM >2#`2rX h?2 +QMi2Mi Q7 2+? #HQ; rb 2tKBM2/ iQ p2`B7v i?i Bi
7KHFUHDWLRQRIDSHUVRQDOVSDFHRQWKH,QWHUQHW
Findings
h?2 rv #HQ;;2`b T`2b2Mi i?2Kb2Hp2b BM i?2B` #HQ;b M/ i?2 Mim`2
Q7 i?2 BM7Q`KiBQM i?2v +?QQb2 iQ /Bb+HQb2 `2 +2Mi`H Bbbm2b BM mM/2`@
biM/BM; i?2 +`2iBQM Q7 pB`imH T`2b2M+2 QM +v#2`bT+2X 6BM/BM;b
b?Qr i?i i?2 KDQ`Biv Q7 #HQ;;2`b i?i T`iB+BTi2/ BM i?Bb bim/v
+`2i2/ M MQMvKQmb pB`imH T`2b2M+2c i?2v KBMiBM2/ bQK2 FBM/
Q7 MQMvKBiv #v B/2MiB7vBM; i?2Kb2Hp2b mbBM; p`BMi Q7 i?2B` `2H
MK2 UR3XjW M 4R8V Q` Tb2m/QMvK UeRW M 4 8yVc QMHv kyXdW
Q7 i?2 #HQ;;2`b /BbTHv2/ T2`bQMH T?QiQX h?Bb i2M/2M+v 7Q` b2H7@
T`2b2MiiBQM /Q2b MQi +QM+m`b rBi? }M/BM;b 7`QK Qi?2` bim/B2b BM
r?B+? i?2 KDQ`Biv Q7 #HQ;;2`b B/2MiB}2/ i?2Kb2Hp2b #v i?2B` `2H
,6620(
7KHFUHDWLRQRIDSHUVRQDOVSDFHRQWKH,QWHUQHW
Bibliography
,6620(
%,%/,2*5$3+<
Introduction
h?2 }MH TT2` `2TQ`ib T`i Q7 i?2 `2bmHib Q7 M QM@;QBM; bim/vr?B+? iQTB+ Bb HBM;mBbiB+ M/ +mHim`H /Bz2`2M+2b BM KmHiBHBM;mH M/
KmHiB+mHim`H #HQ;QbT?2`2X h?2 T`2HBKBM`v `2bmHib rBi? i?2 6BMMBb?
HM;m;2 Ki2`BH +H2`Hv b?Qr ?Qr i?2 B/2 Q7 BM/2tBM; /Bp2`;2b
T`iHv 7mM/K2MiHHv #2ir22M BM7Q`KiBQM T`Q72bbBQMHb M/ #HQ;@
r`Bi2`bX
AM i?2 #bi`+i i?2 i?2Q`2iB+H #+F;`QmM/ b r2HH b KQiBpiBQMb
7Q` i?2 bim/v M/ bQK2 ;2M2`H pB2rTQBMib `2 /Bb+mbb2/X
,6620(
/LQJXLVWLFDQG&XOWXUDO'LIIHUHQFHVLQ&RQWHQW0DQDJHPHQW
written in Russia and Finland even samples written in mother tongue and English are selected.
The
total sample is in all fifty blogs, from which ten most recent updates are
collected.
The
,6620(
analyzed material covers thus 500 text samples.
Country
1. language
2. language
Finland
Russia
United states
Finnish 10 samples
Russian 10 samples
English 10 samples
English 10 samples
English 10 samples
in all
(50)
20
20
10
The material collection bases on theoretical sampling (see Seale 1998, 329; Strauss and
Corbin 1990, 176-179) and its criteria are diary-like content, provision of indexing terms1 for
b #2BM;
+QM+2`M2/
rBi?ofr?i
T2QTH2
/Qand
rBi?
HM;m;2 ofM/
r?i
the readers,
similar
search features
the used
platform,
the background
the author,
and HM;m;2
the publication
country
and language.
/Q2b
iQ T2QTH2X
This study focuses on examination of the linguistic methods, which are used to describe
;m;2bofM/
i?2 and
i?BMFBM;
i?2v of
`2~2+i
KBMHv
7`QK
the content
the blogs,
the functions
the indexing.
Thebi2K
method
used+mHim`H
is discourse
M22/b
7Q` 2tT`2bbBQM
amQDM2M
aHi2`
GM;m;2
analysis.
Indexing
is reflected toUb22
the functions
and RNNjc
text-types
found RNN3VX
in the actual
blog texts.
When
cultural
the comparison
are Finland,
Russia
and United
Bb analyzing
MQi biiB+
Ub22differences
2X;X o`MiQH
RNNycpairs
Bi+?BbQM
RNNRc
qB2`x#B+F
States,
and
in
their
linguistic
aspects
Finnish,
Russian
and
English
(as
American
RNNdc G2?iQM2M kyyyc EiM kyy9V M/ i?2`27Q`2 HbQ i?2B`English
/Q+m@and
lingua franca) are explored.
Aims,
What kinds
of functions and
the indexing
and titles of blog texts reflect? What kinds of
material
methods
motives are found in the documentation of subjective blog writings?
bim/v
MHvb2b
rvb
?Qr
#HQ;;2`b
T`QpB/2 i2t@
h?Bb
Are there
differences
in style/Bz2`2Mi
and function
of blog
indexing
and titling?
imH
AreiQQHb
there 7Q`
clearBM7Q`KiBQM
documentation`2i`B2pH
discourses M/
between
specific
countries
versus languages
2M#H2b }M/BM; BM7Q`KiBQM
versus
certain
background
of
the
authors?
What
kind
of
customs
exists
in the `2
Finnish
7`QK i?2B` #HQ;bX h?2 7Qm` HM;m;2 M/ +mHim`2 TB`b MHvx2/
versus American versus Russian versus international material?
/LQJXLVWLFDQG&XOWXUDO'LIIHUHQFHVLQ&RQWHQW0DQDJHPHQW
h?Bb bim/v 7Q+mb2b QM 2tKBMiBQM Q7 i?2 HBM;mBbiB+ K2i?Q/br?B+? `2 mb2/ iQ /2b+`B#2 i?2 +QMi2Mi Q7 i?2 #HQ;b- M/ i?2 7mM+@
iBQMb Q7 i?2 BM/2tBM;X h?2 K2i?Q/ mb2/ Bb /Bb+Qm`b2 MHvbBbX AM/2t@
BM; Bb `2~2+i2/ iQ i?2 7mM+iBQMb M/ i2ti@ivT2b 7QmM/ BM i?2 +imH
#HQ; i2tibX q?2M MHvxBM; +mHim`H /Bz2`2M+2b i?2 +QKT`BbQM
TB`b `2 6BMHM/- _mbbB M/ lMBi2/ aii2b- M/ BM i?2B` HBM;mBbiB+
bT2+ib 6BMMBb?- _mbbBM M/ 1M;HBb? Ub K2`B+M 1M;HBb? M/
HBM;m 7`M+V `2 2tTHQ`2/X
h?2 `2b2`+? [m2biBQMb `2,
q?i FBM/b Q7 7mM+iBQMb i?2 BM/2tBM; M/ iBiH2b Q7 #HQ; i2tib
`2~2+i\ q?i FBM/b Q7 KQiBp2b `2 7QmM/ BM i?2 /Q+mK2Mi@
iBQM Q7 bm#D2+iBp2 #HQ; r`BiBM;b\
`2 i?2`2 /Bz2`2M+2b BM bivH2 M/ 7mM+iBQM Q7 #HQ; BM/2tBM;
M/ iBiHBM;\
`2 i?2`2 +H2` /Q+mK2MiiBQM /Bb+Qm`b2b #2ir22M bT2+B}+
+QmMi`B2b p2`bmb HM;m;2b p2`bmb +2`iBM #+F;`QmM/ Q7 i?2
mi?Q`b\ q?i FBM/ Q7 +mbiQKb 2tBbib BM i?2 6BMMBb? p2`bmb
K2`B+M p2`bmb _mbbBM p2`bmb BMi2`MiBQMH Ki2`BH\
AM/2tBM; Bb `2~2+i2/ iQ i?2 +QMi2Mi Q7 i?2 #HQ; i2tib- iBiH2b M/
b2`+? TQbbB#BHBiB2bX h?2 7Q+mb Bb QM 7mM+iBQMb M/ bivH2bX 6Q` 2t@
KTH2 i?2 ;2Q;`T?B+H TH+2 Q7 r`BiBM; Q` `272`2M+2 Bb BMi2`2biBM;
HbQ 7`QK i?2 T2`bT2+iBp2 Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM b22FBM;- M/ Bi +M #2 2t@
T`2bb2/ BM KMv /Bz2`2Mi rvb U+7X GBM/;`2M kyy8VX
Results
.2bTBi2 Q7 i?2B` mMBp2`bHBiv M/ ;`QrBM; TQTmH`Biv #HQ;b b
7Q`K Q7 bQ+BH K2/B `2 biBHH HBiiH2 bim/B2/ Ub22 ED2HH#2`; kyRyVX h?2
HBM;mBbiB+ M/ +mHim`H bT2+i Q7 bQ+BH K2/B BM7Q`KiBQM b22FBM;/2b+`B#2/ BM i?2 `2b2`+? THM- `2T`2b2Mib mMB[m2 TT`Q+?X h?2
iQTB+ Q7 i?2 `2b2`+? +QM+2`Mb /B`2+iHv i?2 KQbi +?HH2M;BM; ibFb
rBi?BM BM7Q`KiBQM b+B2M+2 iQ/v- r?B+? Bb iQ +?B2p2 #2ii2` mM@
/2`biM/BM; Q7 i?2 7mM/K2MiHb Q7 ?mKM BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQm`M/ i?2 rvb BM r?B+? Bi +?M;2b Qp2` iBK2 Ub22 "r/2M _Q#BMbQM
kyy3- NVX
,6620(
Bibliography
,6620(
%,%/,2*5$3+<
,6620(
%,%/,2*5$3+<
Introduction
S2QTH2 mb2 bQ+BH K2/B BM KMv bBimiBQMb M/ +QMi2tib Q7 i?2B`
2p2`v/v HB72X h?2b2 BMi2`+iBQMb M/ `2Mb 2MiBH 2MQ`KQmb KQmMib
Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM M/ ?p2 HbQ +?M;2/ i?2 rvb KMv T2QTH2 BMi2`+i
M/ +QKKmMB+i2X a+BH/QM2- _QiQHQ M/ aMv/2` UkyRRV B/2MiB}2/
i?2K2b 7Q` r?B+? bQ+BH K2/B ?b ?/ H`;2 BKT+i M/ ?Qr i?2b2
`2 `2H2pMi 7Q` +m``B+mHb M/ ;QHb Q7 Ba+?QQHb M/ BM7Q`KiBQM b+B@
2M+2 /2T`iK2Mib, bQ+BH K2/B +QKKmMBiB2b- QrM2`b?BT- T`Bp+v
M/ ;Qp2`MM+2 Q7 mb2`@;2M2`i2/ +QMi2Mi QM bQ+BH M2irQ`Fb- M/
?Qr bQ+BH K2/B Kv BKT+i 2/m+iBQM M/ H2`MBM; i HH ;2b
Ua+BH/QM2- _QiQHQ aMv/2`- kyRR- TX 8R9VX
h?2 +QM+2Ti bQ+BH K2/B Bb 2HmbBp2- M/ /2}MBiBQMb /2T2M/ QM i?2
+QMi2ti r?2`2 Bi Bb TTHB2/- +QKKQMHv rBi? 7Q+mb QM i2+?MQHQ;v
Q` K`F2iBM;X aQ+BH K2/B +Qm`b2b `2 Q7i2M Qz2`2/ #v +QKK2`+BH
2/m+iBQM +QKTMB2bX h?2 KDQ`Biv Q7 i?2b2 `2 T`+iB+HHv Q`B2Mi2/
M/ 7Q+mb QM i?2 mb2 Q7 bQ+BH K2/B 7`QK +QKK2`+BH T2`bT2+iBp2b BM #mbBM2bb /pMi;2b- M/ K`F2iBM;- Q` QM bT2+B}+ i2+?MQHQ@
;B+H iQQHb M/ `2MbX *Qm`b2b im;?i BM +/2KB+ /Bb+BTHBM2b ?p2
T`2pBQmbHv ?/ bBKBH` M``Qr 7Q+BX ar2/Bb? mMBp2`bBiB2b +m``2MiHv
Qz2` bQ+BH K2/B +Qm`b2b BM /Bb+BTHBM2b bm+? b K2/B bim/B2bc 2/m@
+iBQMc M/ BM7Q`KiB+bX
b /2KQMbi`i2/ #v a+BH/QM2- _QiQHQ M/ aMv/2` UkyRRV- KMv
bT2+ib Q7 bQ+BH K2/B `2 +HQb2Hv +QMM2+i2/ iQ `2b H`2/v bim/@
B2/ rBi?BM KMv GAa +m``B+mHbX 6m`i?2`KQ`2- GAa Bb r2HH 2[mBTT2/
,6620(
7HDFKLQJVRFLDOPHGLDLQ/,6
,6620(
itQMQKv Q7 7+iQ`b i?i Kv z2+i i?2 /2bB;M- /QTiBQM M/ mb2
Q7 q2# #b2/ bvbi2K 7Q` BM7Q`KiBQM b?`BM; M/ +QHH#Q`iBQMX
Principal contributions
qBi? Qm` 2tKTH2 r2 ?p2 /2KQMbi`i2/ M TT`Q+? iQ i2+?@
BM; bQ+BH K2/B BM GAa i?i #`B/;2b i?2 ;Tb #2ir22M i?2Q`v M/
T`+iB+2- M/- 7m`i?2`KQ`2 BMi`Q/m+2b T2`bT2+iBp2 +QM+2`MBM; bQ@
+BH BMi2`+iBQM iQ i?2 +m``2Mi i2+?MQHQ;v M/ K`F2iBM; 7Q+mb2/
i2+?BM; TT`Q+?2bX q2 ?p2 HbQ B/2MiB}2/ #Q/v Q7 `2b2`+?
7HDFKLQJVRFLDOPHGLDLQ/,6
Bibliography
,6620(
II
DOCTORAL FORUM
INFORMATION-RELATED ACTIVITIES
IN A SOCIAL MEDIA AND PUBLIC LIBRARY
CONTEXT
0DULD.URQTYLVW%HUJ
cER$NDGHPL8QLYHUVLW\ )LQODQG
Introduction
h?2 BK Q7 i?Bb TT2` Bb iQ T`2b2Mi M QM;QBM; `2b2`+? T`QD2+i
+QM+2`MBM; bQ+BH K2/B M/ Tm#HB+ HB#``B2bX h?2b2 irQ +QMbiBimi2
M BMi2`2biBM; BM7Q`KiBQM@`B+? +QMi2tiX h?2 `2HiBQMb?BT #2ir22M
bQ+BH K2/B M/ Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b UHbQ +HH2/ GB#``v kXyV +M #2
b22M b +QK#BMiBQM Q7 i?2 7QHHQrBM; #mBH/BM; #HQ+Fb, i2+?MQHQ;v
M/ iQQHb- q2# kXy- bQ+BH bT2+ib- mb2`b- T`iB+BTiBQM- HB#``B2b M/
HB#``v b2`pB+2b- M/ BMi2`+iBpBiv U>QHK#2`; 2i HX- kyyNVX aQ+BH
K2/B Bb Q7i2M +i2;Q`Bx2/ b iQQH 7Q` +QKKmMB+iBQM M/ 2Mi2`@
iBMK2Mi- #mi /Bz2`2Mi BM7Q`KiBQM +iBpBiB2b `2 HbQ M BM?2`2Mi
T`i Q7 bQ+BH K2/BX aQ+BH K2/B iQQHb ?p2 z2+i2/ i?2 2tTMbBQM
Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM- i?2 `i2 Q7 2tTMbBQM M/ i?2 ;i?2`BM; Q7 ?mKM
BM7Q`KiBQM UHH`/- kyyNVX h?2`27Q`2- `2b2`+? BMi2`2bi BMiQ i?2
BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQ` M/ T`+iB+2b Bb 2bb2MiBHX 6Bb?2` CmHB2M
UkyyN- TX j9kV bT2+B}+HHv K2MiBQMb q2# kXy b bQm`+2 Q7 pbi
Ki2`BH 7Q` BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQ` `2b2`+?X apQHBM2M UkyRRV HbQ
BM/B+i2b i?i i?2`2 Bb M22/ 7Q` KQ`2 `2b2`+? BM bQ+BH K2/B M/
Bib BKTHB+iBQMb BM 2p2`v/v HB72 BM7Q`KiBQM b22FBM; M/ b?`BM;X
AM7Q`KiBQM +iBpBiB2b HbQ +QMbiBimi2 M BKTQ`iMi T`i Q7 Tm#HB+
HB#``B2b- M/ QM2 Q7 i?2 KBM Tm`TQb2b Q7 HB#``B2b Bb iQ /Bbb2KBMi2
BM7Q`KiBQM M/ +mHim`2X qBHbQM Ukyy3V /Q2b- ?Qr2p2`- TQBMi Qmi
i?2 H+F Q7 `2b2`+? BMiQ BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQ` BM i?2 Tm#HB+ HB#``v
b2iiBM;X
,6620(
,QIRUPDWLRQUHODWHGDFWLYLWLHVLQDVRFLDOPHGLDDQGSXEOLFOLEUDU\FRQWH[W
rb iQ ;2i #`Q/ Qp2`pB2r Q7 i?2 mb2 Q7 bQ+BH K2/B M/ HB#``B2b
M/ QTBMBQMb #Qmi bQ+BH K2/B b2`pB+2b BM Tm#HB+ HB#``B2bX
h?Bb bim/v +QMbBbib Q7 irQ [m2biBQMMB`2b- QM2 BK2/ iQr`/b
mb2`b M/ i?2 Qi?2` iQr`/b HB#``v T`Q72bbBQMHbX h?2 mb2` [m2b@
iBQMMB`2 rb /Bbi`B#mi2/ i?`Qm;? MQMT`Q##BHBiv [mQi bKTHBM;
i i?2 hm`Fm AMi2`MiBQMH "QQF 6B` M/ i i?2 hm`Fm *Biv JBM
GB#``vX iQiH Q7 d9R `2bTQMb2b r2`2 +QHH2+i2/X h?2 HB#``v T`Q@
72bbBQMHb BM Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b BM i?2 `2 Q7 6BMHM/ S`QT2` `2+2Bp2/
BMpBiiBQMb iQ T`iB+BTi2 BM r2# [m2biBQMMB`2X h?2 Mbr2`BM;
`i2 rb jyX9W r?B+? b?QmH/ #2 +QMbB/2`2/ `2/BM; i?2 `2bmHibX
h?2 b2+QM/ T?b2 Bb +QMi2Mi MHvbBb Q7 6+2#QQF T;2b Q7 Tm#@
HB+ HB#``B2b BM 6BMHM/ S`QT2`X h?2 ;QH Bb iQ bim/v i?2 BM?2`2Mi
BM7Q`KiBQM +iBpBiB2b Q#b2`p#H2 BM i?Bb b2iiBM;X h?Bb bim/v Bb biBHH
BM T`Q;`2bb M/ Bib `2bmHib rBHH MQi #2 /Bb+mbb2/ BM i?Bb TT2`X
Preliminary results
_2bmHib 7`QK i?2 mb2` bm`p2v b?Qr i?i r?2M Bi +QK2b iQ BM7Q`K@
iBQM +iBpBiB2b QM i?2 q2#- mb2`b ;2M2`HHv 2M;;2 BM i?2 7QHHQrBM;,
b22FBM;- `2/BM;fpB2rBM;- +QKKmMB+iBM;- +`2iBM; M/ +QMi`B#mi@
BM;X h?2 KQbi +QKKQM Q7 i?2b2 }p2 +iBpBiB2b `2 i?2 i`/BiBQMH
b22FBM;- `2/BM; M/ +QKKmMB+iBM;X h?2 +`2iBM; M/ +QMi`B#@
miBM; +iBpBiB2b i?i `2 Q7i2M bi`QM;Hv +QMM2+i2/ iQ i?2 MQiBQM Q7
bQ+BH K2/B `2 MQi b rB/2bT`2/ b i?2 i`/BiBQMH +iBpBiB2bX
a22FBM; 2M;;2b mT iQ NjW Q7 i?2 mb2`b QM 7`2[m2Mi #bBb- r?BH2
+`2iBM; 2M;;2b jdW M/ +QMi`B#miBM; jyW Q7 i?2 mb2`bX
Pp2` ?H7 Q7 i?2 mb2`b bmTTQ`i i?2 BKTH2K2MiiBQM Q7 bQ+BH K2/B
b2`pB+2b BM Tm#HB+ HB#``B2bX h?2 `2bmHib /Q- ?Qr2p2`- BM/B+i2 i?i
i?2 mb2`b /Q MQi M2+2bb`BHv b22 bQ+BH K2/B M/ Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b
b T`ib Q7 i?2 bK2 +QMi2tiX lb2`b i2M/ iQ #b2 i?2B` QTBMBQMb QM
i?2B` T`2pBQmb 2tT2`B2M+2b Q7 HB#``B2b M/ MQi M2+2bb`BHv QM i?2B`
2tT2`B2M+2 Q7 bQ+BH K2/BX h?2v /Q- 7Q` 2tKTH2- T`272` +QMi+iBM;
i?2 biz 7+2@iQ@7+2 M/ b?Qr `2HiBp2Hv HQr BMi2`2bi BM pB`imH
`272`2M+2- Hi?Qm;? i?2v ;2M2`HHv 2MDQv i?2 +QKKmMB+iBQM TQbbB#@
BHBiB2b Q7 i?2 q2#X lb2`b HbQ 2tT2+i M/ }M/ i`/BiBQMH 72im`2b Q7
i?2 HB#``v +iHQ; bm+? b T`QKTiM2bb- `2HB#BHBiv M/ mb#BHBiv b
KQ`2 BKTQ`iMi i?M TQbbB#BHBiB2b iQ BM~m2M+2 i?2 +QMi2Mi Q` i?i
,6620(
i?2 +iHQ; ?b KMv mb2`bX h?2 bQ+BH K2/B +iBpBiv i?i BMi2`2bib
i?2 mb2`b i?2 KQbi ?b iQ /Q rBi? `2/BM; `2pB2rb r`Bii2M #v Qi?2`
mb2`b M/ HB#``v biz- r?BH2 i?2 BMi2`2bi 7Q` +QMi`B#miBM; M/ 2bT2@
+BHHv +`2iBM; +iBpBiB2b Bb Km+? HQr2`X qQ`i?v Q7 MQi2 Bb i?i i?2
mb2`b BM i?2 bm`p2v biBHH Tmi i?2 KQbi r2B;?i QM MQMvKBiv M/ `2;@
mHiBQMbX HKQbi dyW Q7 i?2 mb2`b rMi iQ `2KBM MQMvKQmb r?2M
r`BiBM; +QKK2Mib QM i?2 HB#``v r2# bBi2 M/ Qp2` 3yW +QMbB/2` Bi
BKTQ`iMi i?i i?2 HB#``v ?p2 `mH2b 7Q` r?i i?2 mb2`b r`Bi2 QM
i?2 HB#``v r2# bBi2X
h?2 T`BK2 KQiBpiQ` 7Q` mb2`b iQ 2M;;2 BM HB#``v +iBpBiB2b QM
i?2 q2# b22Kb iQ #2 b2Mb2 Q7 +QKKmMBiv rBi? i?2 HB#``vX h?2v
`2 MQi +QM+2`M2/ rBi? ;2iiBM; Mv `2+Q;MBiBQM Q` `2r`/b 7Q` T`@
iB+BTiBM;X h?2 mb2`b i?i b?Qr i?2 KQbi BMi2MiBQMb M/ BMi2`2bi 7Q`
iFBM; T`i BM bQ+BH K2/B +iBpBiB2b BM i?2 Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b `2 Ry@
Re v2` QH/b- 7`2[m2Mi HB#``v mb2`b M/ i?Qb2 r?Q ;2M2`HHv 2MDQv
+`2iBM; +QMi2Mi QM i?2 q2#X
_2bmHib 7`QK i?2 bm`p2v KQM; HB#``v T`Q72bbBQMHb b?Qr i?2v
`2 T`BK`BHv KQiBpi2/ #v i?2 TQbbB#BHBiv Q7 /2p2HQTBM; i?2 HB#``v
M/ Bib b2`pB+2bX h?2 pBH#H2 `2bQm`+2b 7Q` bQ+BH K2/B b2`pB+2b
BM i?2 Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b `2 bm{+B2Mi +QMbB/2`BM; bFBHHb M/ }MM+BH
K2Mb- i?2 #B; 2t+2TiBQM Bb iBK2X Ai Bb 2pB/2Mi i?i i?2 H+F Q7 iBK2
M/ biz `2 i?2 #B;;2bi T`Q#H2Kb +QM+2`MBM; i?2 BKTH2K2MiiBQM Q7
bQ+BH K2/B BM Tm#HB+ HB#``B2bX h?2 HB#``v T`Q72bbBQMHb biBHH b?Qr
BMi2`2bi BM rQ`FBM; rBi? bQ+BH K2/B b2`pB+2bX h?2v- ?Qr2p2`- b?Qr
KQ`2 BMi2`2bi BM r`BiBM; #HQ; TQbib i?M BM +iBpBiB2b i?i `2 KQ`2
2tTHB+Bi #Qmi BMi2`+iBQM rBi? mb2`b- bm+? b H2/BM; #QQF /Bb+mb@
bBQMb- ;BpBM; pB`imH `272`2M+2 Q` Qz2`BM; mb2`b i?2 #BHBiv iQ +QMM2+i
rBi? i?2 HB#``v QM bQ+BH M2irQ`FBM; bBi2b bm+? b 6+2#QQFX
Conclusions
h?2 bm`p2v `2bmHib BM/B+i2 i?i i?2`2 `2 KMv BM?2`2Mi TQb@
bB#BHBiB2b BM BKTH2K2MiBM; bQ+BH K2/B b2`pB+2b BM HB#``B2bX "Qi?
mb2`b M/ HB#``v T`Q72bbBQMHb `2 7KBHB` rBi? bQ+BH K2/B b2`@
pB+2b Qp2`HHX h?2 HB#``v T`Q72bbBQMHb HbQ #2HB2p2 i?i bQ+BH K2/B
b2`pB+2b +QmH/ QT2M i?2 /QQ` 7Q` M2r mb2`b M/ BKT`Qp2 i?2 HB#``v
r2# b2`pB+2bX
,QIRUPDWLRQUHODWHGDFWLYLWLHVLQDVRFLDOPHGLDDQGSXEOLFOLEUDU\FRQWH[W
Bibliography
,6620(
#bi`+i
Background
Jv `2b2`+? 7Q+mb2b QM mb2`b +mHim`H B/2MiBiB2b- `QH2b M/ i?2
BKT+i PT2M ++2bb +iBpBiB2b BM a2+QM/ GB72 UaGVX lb2`b BM i?`22
/Bz2`2Mi i?2K2b `2 bim/B2/, 2/m+iBQM- 2Mi2`T`Bb2b M/ 2Mi2`iBM@
K2Mi Ui?2 i?`22 1bVX h?2b2 i?`22 1b 7Q`K pbi MmK#2`b Q7 /B7@
72`2Mi `2b M/ 2MpB`QMK2Mib BM pB`imH rQ`H/bX
AM Kv `2b2`+?- 1/m+iBQM GB72 i?2 }`bi 1 `2T`2b2MiiBp2b Q`B@
;BMi2 7`QK _Q+F+HBz2 lMBp2`bBivX h?2 mMBp2`bBivb bT2+BH 72im`2
Bb i?i Bi Bb QT2M iQ HH M/ rQ`Fb QM i?2 AMi2`M2iX 6m`i?2`- Bi Bb
MQM@T`Q}i- MQM@++`2/Bi2/- BM7Q`KH bbQ+BiBQM Q7 BMbi`m+iQ`b 7`QK
p`BQmb mMBp2`bBiB2b M/ +QHH2;2b `QmM/ i?2 rQ`H/X
A +?Qb2 _Q+F+HBz2 lMBp2`bBiv b Kv `2b2`+? bm#D2+i bBM+2 Bi Bb
QT2M iQ 2p2`vQM2 M/ ?b M 2t+2HH2Mi `2b2`+? HB#``v i?i QT2`i2b
QM M QT2M ++2bb T`BM+BTH2X h?2 HB#``v Bb i?2 ?2`i Q7 mMBp2`bBiv
r?2`2 QM2 +M }M/ `2b2`+? Ki2`BHb- iQQHb- /pB+2 M/ +QMi+ib iQ
bim/v M/ +``v Qmi `2b2`+? Q` Dmbi Tbb i?2 iBK2X
,6620(
Methods
A 2tKBM2 ?Qr i?2 mb2` +QMbBbib Q7 bBM;H2 +mHim`H B/2MiBiv BM
/Bz2`2Mi +QMi2tibc ?Qr i?2 QT2M ++2bb +iBpBiB2b z2+i i?2 +mHim`H
B/2MiBiv 7Q`KiBQMc M/ ?Qr i?2 QT2M ++2bb +iBpBiv TT2`b BM
/Bz2`2Mi `QH2bX Jv Ki2`BH Bb +QHH2+i2/ 7`QK BMi2`pB2rb- pB/2Qb M/
BK;2b 7`QK Kv `2b2`+? `2b BM a2+QM/ GB72X Hi?Qm;? a2+QM/
GB72 Bb HKQbi +QTv Q7 Qm` `2H rQ`H/- Bi b?QmH/ #2 2tKBM2/ QM
Bib QrM T`2KBb2bX *mHim`2b BM pB`imH rQ`H/b +QKT`Bb2 T2QTH2 @ M/
T2QTH2 `2 `2[mB`2K2Mi 7Q` i?2 +mHim`2 iQ 2tBbiX
q?BH2 A mb2 i2ti +QMi2Mi MHvbBb b bmTTQ`i K2i?Q/ BM Kv
`2b2`+?- A BK iQ mb2 b2KBQiB+ [mHBiiBp2 pBbmH +QMi2Mi MHvbBb
b Kv KBM `2b2`+? K2i?Q/X a2KBQiB+ pBbmH +QMi2Mi MHvbBb Bb
b2H/QK mb2/ BM +mHim`H `2b2`+?- i H2bi BM 6BMHM/ M/ 1m`QT2c
?Qr2p2`- A BK iQ 2tTHQBi i?Bb K2i?Q/ BM Kv `2b2`+? #2+mb2 Q7 i?2
+H2` pBbmH BKTmHb2 BM pB`imH rQ`H/bX
A K 2bT2+BHHv BMi2`2bi2/ BM BK;2b M/ KQpBM; TB+im`2bX AK;2
Ki2`BH M/ KmHiBTH2 B/2MiBiB2b ?p2 #2+QK2 KQ`2 BKTQ`iMi 7Q`
AMi2`M2i `2b2`+?2`b bBM+2 T2QTH2 `2 iFBM; M/ Tm#HBb?BM; TB+im`2b
QM AMi2`M2i KQ`2 i?M 2p2`X oBbmH Ki2`BH QM i?2 AMi2`M2i ?b
#22M T`2pBQmbHv 2tKBM2/ HKQbi 2t+HmbBp2Hv b i2+?MB+H 2tT`2b@
bBQMX
8VHUV
FXOWXUDOLGHQWLWLHV UROHVDQGRSHQDFFHVVLQ6HFRQG/LIH
,6620(
8VHUV
FXOWXUDOLGHQWLWLHV UROHVDQGRSHQDFFHVVLQ6HFRQG/LIH
,6620(
License
h?Bb rQ`F Bb HB+2Mb2/ mM/2` i?2 *`2iBp2 *QKKQMb LBK2@1B
KmmiQFbB jXy JmQFFKiQM GB+2Mb2X hQ pB2r +QTv Q7 i?Bb HB@
+2Mb2- pBbBi ?iiT,ff+`2iBp2+QKKQMbXQ`;fHB+2Mb2bf#v@M/fjXyf Q` b2M/
H2ii2` iQ *`2iBp2 *QKKQMb- 999 *bi`Q ai`22i- amBi2 Nyy- JQmM@
iBM oB2r- *HB7Q`MB- N9y9R- laX
Bibliography
(R) /H2`S2i2`
kyykX
"2vQM/
*mHim`H
A/2M@
iBiv,
_2~2+iBQMb
QM
JmHiB+mHim`HBbK?iiT,ffrrrXK2/Bi2X+QKf`iB+H2bf/H2`jX+7K
(k) "MFb- J`+mb kyydX lbBM; oBbmH .i BM ZmHBiiBp2 _2@
b2`+?X GQM/QMX h?QmbM/ PFb *HB7Q`MBX aBM;TQ`2X AM/BX
Aa"L Nd3@y@deRN@9NdN@9X a:1X
(j) "MFb J`+mb M/ JQ`T?v >Qr`/ RNNdX _2i?BMFBM; oBbmH
Mi?`QTQHQ;vX GQM/QMX L2r >p2MX Aa"L y jyy@yeeNR@yX uH2
mMBp2`bBiv T`2bbX
(9) "2HH- S?BHBT kyyRX *QMi2Mi MHvbBb Q7 oBbmH AK;2bX >M/@
#QQF Q7 oBbmH MHvbBbX _2T`BMi2/ kyyjX Aa"L y deRN e9de
k U?#FVX Aa"L y deRN e9de y UT#FVX a;2X GQM/QM kyyRX
(8) "Q2HHbiQ`z- hQK kyy3X *QKBM; QM ;2 BM a2+QM/ GB72, M
Mi?`QTQHQ;Bbi 2tTHQ`2b i?2 pB`imHHv ?mKMX S`BM+2iQM lMB@
p2`bBiv S`2bbX
(e) C2MFBMb- _B+?`/ kyy3X aQ+BH A/2MiBivX j`/ 2/BiBQMX Aa"L
y@9R8@99393@9 UbB/XV Aa"L y@9R8@ 9939N@k UMB/XV Aa"L Nd3@
y@9R8@99393@k UbB/XV Aa"L Nd3@y@9R8@9939N@N UMB/XV JBHiQM
S`F- #BM;/QM- PtQMX _QmiH2/;2 kyy3X
(d) >HH- aim`i kyyjX h?2Q`BxBM; .BbTQ`, `2/2` kyyjX *mH@
im`H A/2MiBiv M/ .BbTQ`X
,6620(
#bi`+i
Introduction
.2MK`F ?b BM+`2bBM;Hv /B;BiBx2/ Bib +mHim`H ?2`Bi;2 BM H`;2
b+H2 /m`BM; i?2 kyyybX h?2 +QHH2+iBQMb Q7 /B;BiBx2/ Ki2`BHb BM@
+Hm/2 bm#biMiBH KQmMib Q7 i2tib- #QQFb- TB+im`2b M/ KQpB2bX
H`;2 T`i Q7 i?2 +QHH2+iBQMb `2 K/2 pBH#H2 QM i?2 AMi2`M2i- M/
i?2 [m2biBQM `Bb2b Q7 ?Qr M/ iQ r?i 2ti2Mi i?2b2 +QHH2+iBQMb `2
+imHHv mb2/\ h?2 S?X.X T`QD2+i 7Q+mb2b QM i?2 Tm#HB+b mb2 Q7
/B;BiBx2/ +mHim`H ?2`Bi;2 BM 2p2`v/v HB72X h?2 T`QD2+i bim/B2b i?2
/B;BiH +QHH2+iBQMb Q7 i?2 K2KQ`v BMbiBimiBQMb- QT2`iBQMHHv /2}M2/
b i?2 +QHH2+iBQMb i?i ?p2 +QMDQBMiHv #22M bp2/ M/ i?2M /B;Bi@
Bx2/ #v i?2 `+?Bp2b- HB#``v M/ Kmb2mK BMbiBimiBQMb UBM+Hm/BM;
m/BQ@pBbmH `+?Bp2bV BM Q`/2` iQ HBKBi i?2 BMp2biB;iBQMX h?2 T`Q@
D2+i 7Q+mb Bb QM i?2 `2HiBQMb #2ir22M i?2 mb2`b Ub2`+?V #2?pBQ`-
,6620(
b2`+? bi`i2;B2b M/ i?2 }M/#BHBiv Q7 i?2 +mHim`H `2bQm`+2b- 2X;X`2 i?2 +QHH2+iBQMb 2bBHv 7QmM/ #v i?2 mb2`b Q` `2 i?2v BMpBbB#H2 QM
i?2 r2#\- M/ r?Q `2 i?2 mb2`b M/ `2 i?2v b2`+?BM; 7Q` rQ`F Q`
H2Bbm`2 Tm`TQb2b\
Framework
h?2 bi`iBM; TQBMi BM i?2 `2b2`+? T`QD2+i Bb i?2 `2HiBQMb?BT
#2ir22M mb2`- BM7Q`KiBQM M/ BM7Q`KiBQM bvbi2KX AM i?Bb +b2
i?2 BM7Q`KiBQM bvbi2K +QMbBbib Q7 #Qi? i?2 HQ+H BM7Q`KiBQM bvb@
i2Kb U/i#b2 Q` +QMi2Mi KM;2K2Mi bvbi2KV M/ i?2 r2# b
r?QH2 UBM+Hm/BM; r2# b2`+? 2M;BM2bVX
6`QK i?2 mb2`b TQBMi Q7 pB2r i?2 Bbbm2 Bb i?2 BMi2`+iBQM #2ir22M
mb2` +iBQMb- BM7Q`KiBQM #2?pBQ` M/ b2`+? bi`i2;B2b- r?B+? Kv
#2 pBbmHBx2/ b bi`2K Q7 mb2` BMi2`+iBQMbX 6`QK i?2 bvbi2K
TQBMi Q7 pB2r i?2 bvbi2K #Qi? ;2M2`i2b i?2 722/#+F iQ i?2 mb2`b
+iBQMb M/ Bb `2bTQMbB#H2 7Q` i?2 }M/#BHBiv Q7 i?2 BM7Q`KiBQM BM
i?2 bvbi2KX
AM7Q`KiBQM QM i?2 r2# Bb Tm#HBb?2/ BM bQK2 bQ`i Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM
bvbi2K- r?B+? Bb K/2 Tm#HB+ QM i?2 r2# i?`Qm;? r2# b2`p2`X
>Qr }M/#H2 i?2 BM7Q`KiBQM Bb /2T2M/b QM KMv i?BM;b- #mi i?2
7KH'DQLVKGLJLWDOL]HGFXOWXUDOKHULWDJHDQGLWVXVHUV
4.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
Whether, and how, the user finds the cultural heritage information
depends on factors both on the system side (e.g. findability) and the user
herself (e.g. information need, motivation, level of information literacy).
mb2`
?b iQ }M/
?2` rv
QM deals
i?2 r2#
`2bQm`+2
+QMiBMBM;
The Hrvb
project research
questions
(RQ)
withi?2
different
aspects
of the
i?2
BM7Q`KiBQM
Q#D2+ib
Ub
BHHmbi`i2/
BM
6B;m`2
R
#2HQrVX
research problem. RQ 1-4 are mainly descriptive in nature and leads to
h?2 BM7Q`KiBQM
`2bQm`+2b
correlation
questions in
RQ5. ?p2 irQ H2p2Hb, Q#D2+i M/ `2bQm`+2X
P#D2+ib `2 i?2 BM7Q`KiBQM- i?2 bBM;H2 TB+im`2b- pB/2Qb M/ i2tib
+QMiBMBM;
i?2 +mHim`H
?2`Bi;2X
PMdo
i?2
H2p2H i?2`2 `2
4.1
RQ1:
What do
the users
in `2bQm`+2
the cultural
MpB;iBQMH
7mM+iBQMb
HBF2 BMi2`MH b2`+? M/ +i2;Q`B2b iQ;2i?2`
heritage
resource?
rBi? ;2M2`H BM7Q`KiBQMX h?2 `2bQm`+2 H2p2H Bb 7QH/2/ `QmM/ i?2
+QHH2+iBQM
Q7 Q#D2+ibM/itBbis possible
Hv2` i?i
?b iQout
#2specific
T2M2i`i2/
From system
log files
to single
searchiQ
`2+?
i?2
Q#D2+ibX
h?Bb
/BpBbBQM
Bb
BKTQ`iMi
r?2M
HQQFBM;
QM
b2`+?
sessions and to follow a user through a session. It is often not possible
to
bi`i2;B2b
M/
MpB;iBQMH
rvb
QM
i?2
r2#X
AM
6B;m`2
R
i?2
BM@
track a user across different sessions this depends on the availability of
7Q`KiBQM
UQ#D2+iV M/
BM7Q`KiBQM
bvbi2K U`2bQm`+2V
`2 logs.
b?QrM
sufficient IP-number
and session-ID
information
in the specific
Theb
+B`+H2b
rBi?BM
i?2
Qmi2`
r2#
+B`+H2X
log file data will, however, be sufficient to explore the moves and tactics,
the two most basic levels of the four levels of interaction (Bates, 1990;
Jansen, 2009). In addition, it is important to study both the navigation
and the queries of the user (Mat-Hassan & Levene, 2005), as the two
behaviors are two sides of the same coin. Several quantitative usage
measures are relevant and interesting, e.g. bouncing rate, depth and
length of visits and the number of object looked at (Nicholas et al.,
2006).
,6620(
Research questions
q?2i?2`- M/ ?Qr- i?2 mb2` }M/b i?2 +mHim`H ?2`Bi;2 BM7Q`K@
iBQM /2T2M/b QM 7+iQ`b #Qi? QM i?2 bvbi2K bB/2 U2X;X }M/#BHBivV
M/ i?2 mb2` ?2`b2H7 U2X;X BM7Q`KiBQM M22/- KQiBpiBQM- H2p2H Q7
BM7Q`KiBQM HBi2`+vVX h?2 T`QD2+i `2b2`+? [m2biBQMb U_ZV /2Hb
rBi? /Bz2`2Mi bT2+ib Q7 i?2 `2b2`+? T`Q#H2KX _Z R@9 `2 KBMHv
/2b+`BTiBp2 BM Mim`2 M/ H2/b iQ +Q``2HiBQM [m2biBQMb BM _Z8X
7KH'DQLVKGLJLWDOL]HGFXOWXUDOKHULWDJHDQGLWVXVHUV
#X
+X
b JQ`pBHH2b /2}MBiBQM b?Qrb }M/#BHBiv QT2`i2b QM /Bz2`2Mi H2p2Hb#Qi? QM Q#D2+i H2p2H U#V M/ QM bvbi2K H2p2H U+VX >2 HbQ /Bb+mbb2b
i?2 [mHBiv Q7 M/ i?2 /2;`22 Q7 }M/#BHBiv- r?B+? BKTHB2b i?i }M/@
#BHBiv +M #2 [mMiB}2/ i bQK2 b+H2X AM7Q`KiBQM QM i?2 r2#
Bb Tm#HBb?2/ BM bQK2 BM7Q`KiBQM bvbi2K U2X;X +QMi2Mi KM;2@
K2Mi bvbi2K- #HQ; Q` /i#b2V M/ i?2 BM7Q`KiBQM bvbi2K Bb i?2M
pBH#H2 QM i?2 r2#X "2+mb2 Q7 i?2 +QKTH2tBiv Q7 r2# Tm#HB+@
iBQM }M/#BHBiv Bb +QMbiMiHv +?M;BM; M/ ?`/ iQ +H+mHi2- #mi Bi
KB;?i #2 i?2 KQbi BKTQ`iMi bT2+i QM BM7Q`KiBQM QM i?2 r2# BM
i?Bb 2` Q7 b2`+? 2M;BM2 mb2X
h?2 THM Bb iQ mb2 M MHvbBb T`QiQ+QH M/ K2bm`2 ii`B#mi2b i
#Qi? `2bQm`+2 M/ Q#D2+i H2p2HX h?2 bT2+ib M/ ii`B#mi2b K2b@
m`2/ rBHH #2 /2`Bp2/ 7`QK `2b2`+? BM `2H2pMi `2b- 2X;X r2# BM@
7Q`KiBQM `2i`B2pH- b2`+? #2?pBQ` M/ BM7Q`KiBQM `+?Bi2+im`2#mi HbQ 7`QK #2bi T`+iB+2 BM i?2 }2H/b b2`+? 2M;BM2 QTiBKBxiBQM
M/ r2# mb#BHBiv U2X;X 1M;2 kyyNVX ii`B#mi2b M/ 7+iQ`b HBF2 i?2
7QHHQrBM; rBHH #2 bim/B2/,
,6620(
RQ4: Who are the users and what are their thoughts
on the cultural heritage resources?
_2b2`+? [m2biBQM 9 Bb Mbr2`2/ T`BK`v rBi? q2# bm`p2vb- QM2
BM 2+? Q7 i?2 bim/B2/ `2bQm`+2bX h?2 BK Bb iQ ;i?2` /i iQ ;Q ;2i
#2ii2` TB+im`2 Q7 i?2 mb2`bX h?2 HQ; }H2b +QMiBM Dmbi #2?pBQ`H
i`+2b Q7 i?2 mb2`b +iBQMb- MQi Mv /i #Qmi i?2 mb2`b Q` i?2B`
M22/bX
h?2 q2# bm`p2vb +QmH/ #2 +QMM2+i2/ iQ QM2 Q` b2p2`H TT`Q+?2b2X;X AM7Q`KiBQM ?Q`BxQM UaQMM2MrH/- qBH/2Kmi?- "- >`KQM
R ?iiT,ff#B#HBQi2FX/F
7KH'DQLVKGLJLWDOL]HGFXOWXUDOKHULWDJHDQGLWVXVHUV
Research design
h?2 bim/v Bb [mMiBiiBp2 M/ BM i?2 Qp2`HTTBM; `2 #2ir22M
b2p2`H `2b2`+? }2H/b, r2#QK2i`B+b- BM7Q`KiBQM b22FBM; M/ `2@
i`B2pH M/ r2# b2`+?X _2b2`+? [m2biBQM R M/ k rBHH #2 Mbr2`2/
rBi? MHvbBb Q7 HQ; }H2b 7`QK i?2 bim/B2/ ?2`Bi;2 `2bQm`+2bX h?2
HQ; MHvbBb rBHH #2 +QKTH2K2Mi2/ rBi? r2# bm`p2vb ii+?2/ iQ i?2
`2bQm`+2b b rv iQ ;2i #2ii2` TB+im`2 Q7 i?2 mb2`b U_Z9VX hQ
Mbr2` `2b2`+? [m2biBQM j i?2 bim/B2/ `2bQm`+2b `2 2pHmi2/ rBi?
}M/#BHBiv b+?2K2 iQ ``Bp2 i +QKT`#H2 }M/#BHBiv b+Q`2bX
,6620(
https://www.kulturarv.dk/kid/
http://www.dr.dk/Bonanza/index.htm
4
http://www.kb.dk/permalink/2006/poma/info/en/frontpage.htm
3
7KH'DQLVKGLJLWDOL]HGFXOWXUDOKHULWDJHDQGLWVXVHUV
k ?iiTb,ffrrrXFmHim``pX/FfFB/f
j ?iiT,ffrrrX/`X/Ff"QMMxfBM/2tX?iK
9 ?iiT,ffrrrXF#X/FfT2`KHBMFfkyyefTQKfBM7Qf2Mf7`QMiT;2X?iK
Bibliography
(R) "i2b- JX CX URNNyVX q?2`2 a?QmH/ i?2 S2`bQM aiQT M/ i?2
AM7Q`KiBQM a2`+? AMi2`7+2 ai`i\X AM7Q`KiBQM S`Q+2bbBM;
JM;2K2Mi- ke- 8d8@8NRX
(k) "D`M2#Q`M- GX- AM;r2`b2M- SX Ukyy9VX hQr`/ #bB+
7`K2rQ`F 7Q` r2#QK2i`B+bX CQm`MH Q7 i?2 K2`B+M aQ+B2iv
7Q` AM7Q`KiBQM a+B2M+2 M/ h2+?MQHQ;v- 88UR9V- RkRe@RkkdX
(j) "`Q/2`- X UkyykVX itQMQKv Q7 r2# b2`+?X aA:A_ 6Q`mKjeUkV- j@RyX
(9) "vbi`K- EX- C`p2HBM- EX URNN8VX hbF +QKTH2tBiv z2+ib
BM7Q`KiBQM b22FBM; M/ mb2X AM7Q`KiBQM S`Q+2bbBM; JM@
;2K2Mi- jRUkV- RNR@kRjX
(8) *2`i2m- JX /X URN39VX h?2 T`+iB+2 Q7 2p2`v/v HB72X "2`F2H2v*, lMBp2`bBiv Q7 *HB7Q`MB S`2bbX
(e) 1M;2- 1X UkyyNVX h?2 `i Q7 a1PX a2#biQTQH- *, P_2BHHv
J2/BX
(d) CMb2M- "X CX UkyyNVX h?2 K2i?Q/QHQ;v Q7 b2`+? HQ; MHvbBbX
AM "X CX CMb2M- AX hFbB X aTBMF U1/bXV- >M/#QQF Q7
`2b2`+? QM r2# HQ; MHvbBbX >2`b?2v- LuX A:A :HQ#HX
(3) G2p2M2- JX UkyRyVX M BMi`Q/m+iBQM iQ b2`+? 2M;BM2b M/ r2#
MpB;iBQMX >Q#QF2M- LXCX, CQ?M qBH2vX
(N) Ji@>bbM- JX- G2p2M2- JX Ukyy8VX bbQ+BiBM; b2`+?
M/ MpB;iBQM #2?pBQ` i?`Qm;? HQ; MHvbBbX CQm`MH Q7 i?2
,6620(
Introduction
aQ+BH K2/B Bb QM2 Q7 b2p2`H ?B;?Hv T`BQ`BiBb2/ `2b2`+? i?2K2b
i i?2 ar2/Bb? a+?QQH Q7 HB#``v M/ BM7Q`KiBQM b+B2M+2X Ai rb
BMBiBi2/ BM .2+2K#2` kyyN M/ rb v2` Hi2` r`/2/ 8 KBH@
HBQM a1E `2b2`+? ;`Mi 7Q` i?2 T2`BQ/ kyRR@kyRj- 7mM/2/ #v "Q`b
lMBp2`bBivX aQ+BH K2/B Bb #`Q/ M/ +?HH2M;BM; `2b2`+? `2
rBi? +iBpBiB2b QM;QBM; Q` #2BM; BMBiBi2/ BM KQbi /Bb+BTHBM2b rBi?BM
i?2 bQ+BH b+B2M+2b M/ ?mKMBiB2bX h?2 bi`2M;i? Q7 GAa- M/ Qm`
`2b2`+? i?2K2- Bb i?2 i`/BiBQM Q7 mM/2`biM/BM; BM7Q`KiBQM M/
BM7Q`KiBQM i2+?MQHQ;B2b #`Q/Hv M/ 7`QK KmHiBim/2 Q7 T2`bT2+i@
Bp2bX Pm` `2b2`+? BKb i BMp2biB;iBM; i?2 +Q@T`Q/m+iBQM Q7 bQ+BH
K2/B M/ bQ+BH `2HiBQMbX q?2`2 `2 bQ+B2iv- BMbiBimiBQMb- T`Q72b@
bBQMb M/ Q`;MBxiBQMb iFBM; bQ+BH K2/B- M/ r?2`2 /Q2b bQ+BH
K2/B iF2 mb\
AM i?Bb #bi`+i vQm rBHH }M/ b?Q`i T`2b2MiiBQM Q7 i?`22 2K2`@
;BM; /Q+iQ`H T`QD2+ib +QMM2+i2/ iQ i?2 bQ+BH K2/B `2b2`+? i i?2
/2T`iK2MiX
,6620(
6RFLDO0HGLD5HVHDUFKDW6ZHGLVK6FKRRORI/LEUDU\DQG,QIRUPDWLRQ6FLHQFH
i?2 +Hmbi2`b Q7 i?2 p`BQmb 2MiBiB2b BM bQ+BH K2/B `2 MQi biiB+
i?2v +?M;2 Qp2` iBK2X A }M/ Bi BMi2`2biBM; iQ bim/v ?Qr i?2v
+?M;2 r?B+? 7Q` 2tKTH2 +QmH/ ;Bp2 ;`QmM/b 7Q` 7Q`2+biBM; Q` M
BM/B+iBQM Q7 B7 +2`iBM +KTB;M Bb bm++2bb7mH Q` MQiX
h?2 T`QD2+i Bb BM Bib bi`i mT T?b2 M/ i?2 }`bi T`i rBHH #2 iQ
BMp2biB;i2 i?2 #QmM/`B2b 7Q` r2#QK2i`B+b b r2HH b 2pHmiBM; i?2
+m``2Mi KBM K2i?Q/b rBi?BM i?2 }2H/X h?2 T`2HBKBM`v iBiH2 Q7 i?2
T`QD2+i Bb ;;`2;iBM;- MHvxBM; M/ pBbmHBxBM; bQ+BH K2/B /i
i?`Qm;? r2#QK2i`B+bX
Maria Lindh: Cloud computing services in organisations ethical dimensions, implications for information management, information professionals
h?2`2 ?p2 #22M bm;;2biBQMb i?i BKTH2K2MiiBQM Q7 +HQm/ +QK@
TmiBM; BM Q`;MBbiBQMb rBHH 7m`i?2` ;`2i +?M;2- #Qi? 7Q` i?2 i`@
/BiBQMH bQ7ir`2 +QKTMB2b b r2HH b 7Q` i?Qb2 rQ`FBM; i i`/B@
iBQMH Ah /2T`iK2Mib U"`Mii- #`B27 ;mB/2 iQ +HQm/ +QKTmiBM;kyRyVX aQK2 HbQ BM/B+i2 i?i i?2`2 rBHH #2 b?B7i BM i?2 M22/
Q7 Ah +QKT2i2M+2 UC+FbQM- a?B7i iQ +HQm/ `2[mB`2b 7`2b? Ah bFBHHb*QKTmi2`rQ`H/ kyRR@y8@y8V- +?M;BM; 7`QK KQ`2 T`+iB+H Ah bFBHHb
iQ bi`i2;B+ M/ /2p2HQTK2Mi bFBHHb +QM+2`MBM; Qp2`HH BM7Q`KiBQM
KM;2K2Mi bi`i2;B2b BM Q`;MBbiBQMbX
_2+2MiHv QM2 ar2/Bb? KmMB+BTHBiv /2+B/2/ iQ BKTH2K2Mi :QQ;H2
TTb- bBM+2 Bi rb 7`22 Q7 +?`;2 M/ i?2 #2biX h?2v r2`2 T`Qm/
Q7 #2BM; i?2 }`bi KmMB+BTHBiv BM ar2/2M mbBM; i?Bb b2`pB+2 M/ ?/
b2`BQmbHv `2~2+i2/ QM 2p2`v T`Q#H2K BM mbBM; BiX h?Bb +b2 `Bb2/
+QM+2`Mb QM i?2 2i?B+b BM i?2B` 2zQ`ibX aim/B2b b?Qr i?i Tm#HB+
Q`;MBbiBQMb H`2/v mb2 +HQm/ +QKTmiBM; iQ ;`2i 2ti2MiX PM2
v2` ;Q h?2 G2;H- 6BMM+BH M/ /KBMBbi`iBp2 a2`pB+2b ;2M+v
BM ar2/2M K/2 bm`p2v- r?2`2 9yW UQmi Q7 jyy Mbr2`bV Q7 i?2
T`iB+BTiBM; Tm#HB+ Q`;MBbiBQMb bB/ i?2v H`2/v ?/ /QTi2/
+HQm/ +QKTmiBM;X
Jv `2b2`+? BKb `2 iQ 2tKBM2 i?2 +?M;BM; `QH2 Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM
T`Q72bbBQMHb r?2M BM7Q`KiBQM KM;2K2Mi +?M;2 /m2 iQ BKTH2@
,6620(
Introduction
.2p2HQTBM; Tm#HB+ HB#``v b2`pB+2b mbmHHv `2[mB`2 T`QD2+i@Q`;MBx2/
TT`Q+?X GB#``B2b +M #`Q/2M i?2B` 2tT2`iBb2 #v `2+`mBiBM; T`Q@
72bbBQMHb QmibB/2 i?2 HB#``v }2H/ 7Q` i?2 M22/b Q7 i?2 /2p2HQTK2Mi
T`QD2+ibX JmHiB@ T`Q72bbBQMH T`QD2+i ;`QmTb +M #2 `2;`/2/ b
M2r iQQH Q` M2r T`+iB+2 7Q` /2p2HQTBM; HB#``v b2`pB+2bX
Research task
h?2 `2b2`+? [m2biBQM Bb, >Qr `2 i?2 6BMMBb? Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b
/2p2HQTBM; i?2B` b2`pB+2b #v K2Mb Q7 T`QD2+ib\
h?2 Mbr2` Bb bQm;?i #v 2tKBMBM; /2p2HQTK2Mi +iBpBiB2b BM
MiBQMrB/2 T`QD2+i GB#``v aT+2b M/ *QM+2Tib BM i?2 AM7Q`K@
iBQM aQ+B2iv Ukyy3@kyRRV- r?B+? Bb T`i Q7 1m`QT2M aQ+BH 6mM/
T`Q;`KK2X h?2`2 `2 i?`22 `2;BQMH HB#``B2b T`iB+BTiBM; BM i?2
T`QD2+i rBi? i?2B` QrM bm#T`QD2+ibX 1+? bm#T`QD2+i ?b b2p2`H
bBKmHiM2Qmb /2p2HQTK2Mi i`;2ibX h?2 bim/v Bb 7Q+mbBM; QM 2+?
T`QD2+i ;`QmT iQ 7QHHQr mT i?2 7Q`KiBQM Q7 bBM;H2 /2p2HQTK2Mi
i`;2i M/ Bib /2p2HQTK2Mi T`Q+2bb2b b i2KTQ`H M``iBp2X h?2
/2p2HQTK2Mi T`Q+2bb Bb 2tKBM2/ 7`QK i?2 T2`bT2+iBp2 Q7 i?2 T`QD2+i
;`QmTX
h?2 T`2b2Mi bim/v BKb i /2b+`B#BM; i?2 /2p2HQTK2Mi +iBpBi@
B2b- BX2X r?i Bb `2HHv Q++m``BM; QM i?2 T`QD2+ibX h?2 bim/v HbQ
2tKBM2b r?i FBM/ Q7 +QHH#Q`iBQM i?2 T`QD2+i i2Kb `2 /QBM;
,6620(
Theoretical framework
h?2 i?2Q`2iB+H 7`K2rQ`F Bb +QMbi`m+i2/ 7`QK b2T`i2 2H2K2Mib
bBM+2 i?2`2 Bb MQ `2/v@K/2 KQ/2H iQ TTHvX ++Q`/BM; iQ "HQK@
[mBbi 2i HX UkyRyV- BMbm{+B2Mi ii2MiBQM ?b #22M TB/ iQ i?2 +iBp@
BiB2b Q7 i?2 /2p2HQT2`b rQ`FBM; BM T`QD2+ibc i?Bb ;T Bb KQbi 2pB/2Mi
BM i?2 bim/v Q7 KmHiB@ T`Q72bbBQMH T`QD2+i ;`QmTbX JQ`2Qp2`- i?2
+QM+2Ti Q7 /2p2HQTK2Mi rQ`F ?b #22M TQQ`Hv /2}M2/X *QKKQM
iQ bm+? /2}MBiBQMb Bb i?i i?2 /2p2HQTK2Mi rQ`F Bb b22M b M i@
i2KTi iQ +?M;2 i?2 Q`;MBxiBQMb +iBpBiB2b Q` iQ BKT`Qp2 Bib rQ`F
K2i?Q/bX h?2 /2}MBiBQM /B{+mHiB2b Kv #2 /m2 iQ i?2 7+i i?i
i?2 i`;2i- b+QT2- Q`;MBxiBQM 7Q`K M/ i?2 #bBb 7Q` /2p2HQTK2Mi
+iBpBiv Kv p`v bB;MB}+MiHv 7`QK QM2 Q`;MBxiBQM iQ MQi?2`X
UhQBFFQ M/ _MiM2M- kyyNV
.2p2HQTK2Mi rQ`F BM T`Bpi2 #mbBM2bb M/ Tm#HB+ /KBMBbi`@
iBQM Bb Q7i2M Q`;MBx2/ b T`QD2+ibX S`QD2+i Bb HbQ M K#B;mQmb
+QM+2TiX AM i?2 i`/BiBQMH T`QD2+i KM;2K2Mi HBi2`im`2 T`QD2+ib
`2 pB2r2/ b BM/2T2M/2Mi iQQHb 7Q` +?B2pBM; +?M;2- MQi b bT2@
+B}+ Q`;MBxiBQMH 7Q`KX h?2 `2b2`+? Q7 i?2 T`QD2+i KM;2K2Mi
i`/BiBQM ?b #22M /BpB/2/ BMiQ i`/BiBQMH bvbi2K@KQ/2H@#b2/ M/
bQ+BH b+B2M+2@#b2/ T`Q+2bb@Q`B2Mi2/ TT`Q+?X U"HQK[mBbi 2i HX
kyRyV
h?2 T`2b2Mi bim/v #mBH/b mTQM i?2 i?2Q`v Q7 i?2 i2KTQ``v Q`@
;MBxiBQM i?2Q`vX GmM/BM M/ a/2`?QHK URNN8V bm;;2bi 7Qm` +QM@
+2Tib i?i `2 `2Hi2/ iQ /Bz2`2Mi T?b2b Q7 i?2 HB72 +v+H2 Q7 i?2
i2KTQ``v Q`;MBxiBQM, +iBQM@ #b2/ 2Mi`2T`2M2m`BHBbK- 7`;@
K2MiiBQM Q7 +QKKBiK2Mi #mBH/BM;- THMM2/ BbQHiBQM M/ BMbiBim@
iBQMHBx2/ i2`KBMiBQMX h?2 T`QD2+i i2K Bb b22M b i2KTQ``v
Q`;MBxiBQM- r?B+? ?b /Bz2`2Mi 72im`2b 7`QK i?Qb2 Q7 T2`KM@
2Mi Q`;MBxiBQMX +iBQM Bb T`BK`v +QM+2Ti BM i?2 i?2Q`v Q7
i2KTQ``v Q`;MBxiBQMbX h?Bb i?2Q`v /Q2b MQi Tv Mv bT2+BH i@
i2MiBQM iQ BMi2`+iBQM rBi? Qi?2` Q`;MBxiBQMb /m`BM; i?2 T`QD2+ib
HB72 +v+H2c ?2M+2 CQ?MbbQM- G7bi`K M/ P?HbbQMb KQ/2H UkyydV
7Q` MHvbBM; i?2 `2HiBQMb?BT #2ir22M /2p2HQTK2Mi T`QD2+ib M/
'HYHORSLQJSXEOLFOLEUDU\VHUYLFHVE\PHDQVRISURMHFWV
,6620(
Data analysis
h?2 2TBbQ/B+ T`Q;`2bb M``iBp2b `2 bi`m+im`2/ b 7QHHQrb, RV
/i2 kV TH+2 jV r?i- r?Q 9V Bbbm2b- B/2b U2p2Mib M/ +iBQMb[mQi2b 7`QK i?2 /iV 8V ivT2 Q7 /i eV 2TBbQ/2 UT2`+2TiBQMb M/
i?Qm;?ib Q7 `2b2`+?2`b 7`QK 2TBbQ/2V dV i?2K2b M/ ;mB/BM; [m2b@
iBQMb Q7 i?2 bim/vX
A/2MiB}2/ /2p2HQTK2Mi T?b2b M/ ibFb `2 HbQ +QMM2+i2/ iQ
i?2 2TBbQ/B+ T`Q;`2bb M``iBp2bX q`BiBM; i?2 2TBbQ/B+ T`Q;`2bb M`@
`iBp2b +M #2 b22M b i?2 }`bi `QmM/ Q7 /i MHvbBbX
q`BiBM; Q7 +?M;2 M``iBp2b UBM i?Bb bim/v, /2p2HQTK2Mi M``i@
Bp2V Bb BM T`Q;`2bbc M2;QiBiBM; #Qmi i?2 +QMi2Mi Q7 i?2 M``iBp2b
Type of data
Official project meetings - field notes of
researcher
Project planning meetings - part of them
recorded
Follow-up meetings - recorded (a total of 8.5
h)
Blogs of project groups
Other materials project plans, baseline
surveys, memos of official project meetings,
e-mail correspondence with the informants
Nine individual episodic interviews with
informants
(a total of 34 h) - recorded and transcribed.
(summer 2011)
5.
DATA ANALYSIS
rBi? i?2 BMi2`pB2r22b rBHH iF2 TH+2 BM bmKK2` kyRRX .2iBH2/ `2@
b2`+?The
[m2biBQMb
rBHH #2narratives
/2`Bp2/ are
7`QK
b2H2+i2/
i?2K2b 7i2` r`BiBM;
episodic progress
structured
as follows:
i?2 /2p2HQTK2Mi
M``iBp2b
Q7 4)
2+?
T`QD2+i
;`QmTXand actions, quotes
1) date 2) place
3) what, who
issues,
ideas (events
from the data) 5) type of data 6) episode (perceptions and thoughts of
7) themes and guiding questions of the study.
researchers
from episode)
For
discussion
Bibliography
,6620(
III
ADDENDUM
-DQQLFD+HLQVWU|P
cER$NDGHPL8QLYHUVLW\ )LQODQG
Introduction
AM i?Bb T`2b2MiiBQM- r2 `2TQ`i }M/BM;b Q7 TBHQi bim/v r?2`2
bim/2Mib Q7 M mTT2` b2+QM/`v b+?QQH r`Qi2 qBFBT2/B `iB+H2b b
;`QmT bbB;MK2MiX Pm` BK rb iQ BMp2biB;i2 r?2i?2` M/ ?Qr
r`BiBM; `iB+H2b 7Q` qBFBT2/B- #b2/ QM BM/2T2M/2MiHv 7QmM/ BM@
7Q`KiBQM- b2`p2b i?2 ;QHb Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM HBi2`+v BMbi`m+iBQMX q2
HbQ rMi2/ iQ }M/ Qmi ?Qr M mi?2MiB+ H2`MBM; ibF- bm+? b
r`BiBM; `iB+H2b iQ #2 Tm#HBb?2/ QM Tm#HB+ 7Q`mK bm+? b qBFBT2@
/B- BM~m2M+2 bim/2Mib +QM+2TiBQM Q7 i?2B` H2`MBM; ibF- b r2HH b
i?2B` TT`Q+? iQ BiX
qBFBT2/B Bb #b2/ QM i?2 pQHmMi`v T`iB+BTiBQM Q7 H`;2
;HQ#H +QKKmMBiv +QKKBii2/ iQ r`Bi2- `2r`Bi2 M/ mT/i2 Bib +QM@
i2MibX AM b+?QQH bbB;MK2Mib Bi ?b- ?Qr2p2`- #22M `2;`/2/ b M
mM`2HB#H2 BM7Q`KiBQM bQm`+2 U2X;X- +?i2`KM kyy8- JQ``Bbb2ii2
kyy3V r?B+? bim/2Mib `2 /pBb2/ MQi iQ mb2X M Hi2`MiBp2 pB2r@
TQBMi Bb iQ `2;`/ qBFBT2/B b Tm#HB+ rBFB r?2`2 bim/2Mib Kv
T`iB+BTi2 BM +QHH#Q`iBp2 FMQrH2/;2 +QMbi`m+iBQMX AM BM7Q`K@
iBQM HBi2`+v UAGV BMbi`m+iBQM i?Bb K2Mb i?i i?2 7Q+mb Bb im`M2/
7`QK BM7Q`KiBQM b22FBM; M/ +QMbmKTiBQM iQ r`BiBM; M/ `2bTQMb@
B#H2 mb2 Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM QM Tm#HB+ 7Q`mKX qBFBT2/B ?b 2tTHB+Bi
,6620(
Research Questions
R >Qr /Q bim/2Mib TT`Q+? M/ 2tT2`B2M+2 b+?QQH bbB;MK2Mib
rBi? i?2 ;QH Q7 +QHH#Q`iBp2Hv T`Q/m+BM; i2tib iQ #2 Tm#@
HBb?2/ QM qBFBT2/B\
k >Qr /Q2b r`BiBM; i2tib 7Q` qBFBT2/B #b2/ QM BM/2T2M/2MiHv
7QmM/ BM7Q`KiBQM b2`p2 i?2 ;QHb Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM HBi2`+v BM@
bi`m+iBQM\
h?Bb bim/v rb +QM/m+i2/ b TBHQi bim/vX AM //BiBQM iQ i?2 `2@
b2`+? [m2biBQMb- MQi?2` BKTQ`iMi ;QH Q7 i?2 bim/v rb iQ H2`M
#Qmi i?2 T`Q+2bb BM Q`/2` iQ #2 #H2 iQ 7Q`KmHi2 KQ`2 7Q+mb2/
`2b2`+? [m2biBQMb 7Q` i?2 KBM bim/vX 6m`i?2`- r2 rMi2/ iQ i2bi
?Qr bmBi#H2 Qm` /i +QHH2+iBQM K2i?Q/b r2`2 BM +Hbb`QQK 2M@
pB`QMK2MiX
:ULWLQJIRU:LNLSHGLDDVDOHDUQLQJWDVNLQWKHVFKRROVLQIRUPDWLRQOLWHUDF\LQVWUXFWLRQ
Collaboration
h?2 }M/BM;b `2p2H2/ /Bp2`bBiv BM i?2 rv bim/2Mib TT`Q+?2/
M/ BKTH2K2Mi2/ +QHH#Q`iBQM, RV b?`2/ ;QH M/ rQ`FBM; iQ@
;2i?2`- kV b?`2/ ;QH #mi rQ`FBM; b2T`i2Hv- M/ jV MQ b?`2/
;QH M/ MQ +QHH#Q`iBQMX h?2 KQmMi M/ H2p2H Q7 ;`QmT rQ`F
HbQ p`B2/ i /Bz2`2Mi bi;2b Q7 i?2 T`Q+2bbX h?2 ;2M2`H i`2M/ rb
i?i THMMBM; i?2 ibF rb /QM2 +QHH#Q`iBp2Hv- #mi BM7Q`KiBQM
,6620(
Discussion
h?2 }M/BM;b b?Qr i?i r`BiBM; 7Q` Tm#HB+ 7Q`mK bm+? b qBFB@
T2/B `2~2+i2/ b2p2`H +Q`2 2H2K2Mib Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM HBi2`+v BMbi`m+@
iBQMX h?2 bim/2Mib rQ`F2/ +QMb+B2MiBQmbHv QM i?2B` ibF- r2`2 +`2@
7mH iQ K`F +BiiBQMb BM +Q``2+i KMM2`- K/2 M 2zQ`i iQ }M/ `2HB@
#H2 BM7Q`KiBQM- 2pHmi2/ BM7Q`KiBQM bQm`+2b- M/ +`27mHHv +QK@
T`2/ BM7Q`KiBQM iQ Qi?2` bQm`+2b iQ 2Mbm`2 Bib `2HB#BHBivX h?2v
HbQ TB/ ii2MiBQM iQ i?2 r`BiBM; bivH2 Q7 i?2 i2ti iQ KF2 Bi T@
T`QT`Bi2 b qBFBT2/B i2tiX
aim/2Mib 2tT2`B2M+2b b?Qr2/ i?i r`BiBM; QM qBFBT2/B b2`p2/
#Qi? H2`MBM; ;QHb BM bm#D2+i +QMi2Mib M/ AG@`2Hi2/ bFBHHbX .B7@
}+mHiB2b BM }M/BM; #HM+2 #2ir22M i?2b2 irQ ;QHb ?p2 #22M
`2TQ`i2/ BM 2`HB2` bim/B2bX JMv H2`MBM; 2tT2`B2M+2b `2Hi2/ iQ
qBFBT2/B bm;;2bi i?i bim/2Mib KB;?i ?p2 ;Qi /22T2` mM/2`@
biM/BM; Q7 Bi b M BM7Q`KiBQM bQm`+2X h?Bb Bb BKTQ`iMi bBM+2
bim/2Mib b2`+? qBFBT2/B Q7i2MX .Q2b i?2 2tT2`B2M+2 Q7 i?2 T`iB@
:ULWLQJIRU:LNLSHGLDDVDOHDUQLQJWDVNLQWKHVFKRROVLQIRUPDWLRQOLWHUDF\LQVWUXFWLRQ
,6620(
Bibliography
,6620(
(8) (8)
JQ``Bbb2ii2_X
Ukyy3VX
q?i
.Q
i?2v
EMQr\
ai`i2;v 6Q` bb2bbBM; *`BiB+H GBi@
2`+vX
EMQrH2/;2
Zm2bi
j8U8V,
R9@RdX
(l_G,
?iiT,ffbHXK2iT`2bbX+QKf+QMi2Mif[k3e9eRy3H9pTjk9f
*Bi2/ J`+? jy- kyRR)
Abstract
AM i?2b2 iBK2b- Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b BM KMv +QmMi`B2b ?p2 BM+`2b@
BM;Hv +QK2 mM/2` T`2bbm`2 7`QK /2p2HQTK2Mib rBi?BM i?2 BM7Q`K@
iBQM HM/b+T2X aQ+BH M2irQ`FBM; 7Q`mKb bm+? b 6+2#QQF- 6HB+F`JvaT+2- hrBii2`- uQmhm#2 M/ bQ+BH i;;BM; T`QpB/2 M QTTQ`@
imMBiv M/ +?HH2M;2 iQ i?2 FBM/ Q7 b2`pB+2b i?2 Tm#HB+ HB#``v T`Q@
/m+2b M/ iQ i?2 bQ+B2iH `QH2 M/ BMbiBimiBQMH B/2MiBiv Bi bbmK2b
7Q` Bib2H7X h?mb- MQi H2bi #2+mb2 Q7 i?2 KbbBp2 /B;BiBxiBQM Q7 BM@
7Q`KiBQM `2bQm`+2b- i?2 T`QHB72`iBQM M/ TQTmH`Biv Q7 b2`+? 2M@
;BM2b- BM T`iB+mH` :QQ;H2- M/ i?2 #QQKBM; i2+?MQHQ;B2b Q7 q2#
kXy Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b }M/ i?2Kb2Hp2b BM p2`v +QKTH2t bBimiBQMX AM
7+i- i?2 2bv@iQ@mb2 i2+?MQHQ;B2b Q7 q2# kXy +?HH2M;2 i?2 #bB+
T`BM+BTH2b Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM b2`pB+2b T`QpBbBQM mM/2`iF2M #v HB#``B2bX
h?2 M2r /B;BiH BM7Q`KiBQM 2MpB`QMK2Mi M/ bQ+BH bQ7ir`2 iQQHb
bm+? b #HQ;b- rBFB2b M/ bQ+BH M2irQ`FBM; bBi2b ?p2 7m2HH2/ /Bb@
+mbbBQM Q7 i?2 7mim`2 Q7 Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b b BM7Q`KiBQM T`QpB/2`bX
7i2` HH i?2`2 b22Kb iQ #2 M22/ 7Q` Tm#HB+ HB#``B2b iQ `2Q`B2Mi
i?2B` BKb M/ Q#D2+iBp2b M/ iQ `2/2}M2 i?2B` b2`pB+2 B/2MiBivX i
i?2 bK2 iBK2 b2`+? 2M;BM2b- M/ 2bT2+BHHv :QQ;H2- `2 BM+`2b@
BM;Hv #2+QKBM; mM/2` b+`miBMvX h?mb- MHvbBb `2bmHib `272``2/ iQ
b?Qr i?i i?2 +QM+2TiBQM Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM M/ i?2 mM/2`HvBM; Tm`@
TQb2 Q7 :QQ;H2 /Bz2` 7`QK i?Qb2 Q7 Tm#HB+ HB#``B2bX 6m`i?2`- M
BM+`2bBM; KQmMi Q7 +`BiB+BbK Bb #2BM; /B`2+i2/ i +QHH#Q`iBp2
,6620(
,PSOLFDWLRQVRIWKH:HE7HFKQRORJLHVIRU3XEOLF/LEUDULHVLQWHQGLQJWR)DFLOLWDWH$OWHUQDWLYH3XEOLF
,6620(
Bibliography
#bi`+i
Introduction
AM `2+2Mi v2`b- /2p2HQTK2Mib BM i?2 BMi2`M2i i2+?MQHQ;B2b Q7 bQ@
+BH K2/B M/ i?2 BM+`2bBM; mb2 Q7 i?2b2 iQQHb ?p2 b22M i?2 r2#
/pM+2 7`QK THi7Q`K Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM /2HBp2`v iQ QM2 i?i BM+Hm/2b
+QMi`B#miBQM M/ +QHH#Q`iBQMX aQ+BH K2/B Q` r2# kXy i2+?MQHQ@
;B2b bm+? b rBFBb- #HQ;b- KB+`Q@#HQ;b M/ bQ+BH #QQFK`FBM;- `2
BM+`2bBM;Hv mb2/ rBi?BM Q`;MBbiBQMb BM Tm`bmBi Q7 i?2B` BM7Q`K@
iBQMH M/ +QKKmMB+iBp2 ;QHbX J/2 TQTmH` BM BM/BpB/mHBbiB+
M/ QT2M mb2 QM i?2 BMi2`M2i- r2# kXy iQQHb Q` bQ+BH K2/B `2 BM@
+`2bBM;Hv mb2/ b iQQHb 7Q` BM7Q`KiBQM M/ FMQrH2/;2 rQ`F rBi?BM
Q`;MBbiBQMbX J+722 UkyyNV- r?Q +HBKb bB;MB}+Mi QTTQ`imMBi@
,6620(
7KHXVHRIVRFLDOPHGLDLQWKHZRUNSUDFWLFHVRILQIRUPDWLRQSURIHVVLRQDOV
Research design
_2b2`+? mbBM; T`+iB+2@#b2/ TT`Q+? 2t?B#Bib /2bB`2 iQ
b?2/ M2r HB;?i QM Q`;MBbiBQMH T?2MQK2M #v ;2iiBM; +HQb2` iQ
i?2 `2H rQ`F BM Q`;MBbiBQMb M/ KQp2 rv 7`QK bi`m+im`H
MQiBQMb Q7 Q`;MBbiBQMb U:2B;2` kyyN- TX RkNVX 6Q` :?2``/B UkyyNVT`+iB+2 Bb HQ+i2/ BM i?2 bB;MB}+Mi Tii2`M Q7 ?Qr +QM/m+i Q` +iBp@
Biv iF2b TH+2X
h?2Q`B2b Q7 T`+iB+2 bbmK2 M 2+QHQ;B+H KQ/2H BM r?B+? ;2M+v
Bb /Bbi`B#mi2/ #2ir22M ?mKMb M/ MQM@?mKMb M/ BM r?B+? i?2 `2@
HiBQMHBiv #2ir22M i?2 bQ+BH rQ`H/ M/ Ki2`BHBiv +M #2 bm#D2+i2/
iQ BM[mB`v U:?2``/B kyyN- TX RR8VX
h?Bb `2b2`+? BMp2biB;i2b i?2 Ki2`BHBiv Q7 i?2 r2# #b2/ iQQHb
Q7 bQ+BH K2/B M/ i?2 bQ+BH rQ`H/ Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM rQ`F BM r?B+?
i?2v `2 #2+QKBM; 2K#2//2/X "DQ`F2M;- *H2;; M/ SBibBb UkyyN- TX
R98V /2b+`B#2 T`+iB+2 b,
MQp2H Tii2`Mb Q7 BMi2`+iBQM /2p2HQT2/ BMiQ T`2/B+i#H2 ``vb
Q7 +iBpBiB2b- +?M;BM; M/ i`Mb7Q`KBM; r?BH2 i i?2 bK2 iBK2
+QMiBMmBM; iQ #2 `272``2/ iQ b i?2 bK2X
M2;QiBi2/- b?`2/ M/ `2+Q;MBb#H2 rv Q7 rQ`FBM; +QHH2+iBp2Hv
K2Mb i?i T`+iB+2b b?B7i M/ 2pQHp2 7`QK `2HiBp2Hv }`K- #mi MQi
}t2/- 7QmM/iBQMX "DQ`F2M; 2i HX UkyyNV 2ti2M/ T`+iB+2 i?2Q`v M/
Qz2` i?2Q`2iB+H +QMbi`m+ib iQ /2b+`B#2 i?2 #2+QKBM; Q7 T`+iB+2X
>Qr2p2`- i?Bb `2b2`+? }M/b ;`2i2` pHm2 BM i?2 T2`bT2+iBp2 i?i
BM7Q`KiBQM T`+iB+2b- b i?2v /QTi i?2 iQQHb Q7 bQ+BH K2/B- `2
,6620(
7KHXVHRIVRFLDOPHGLDLQWKHZRUNSUDFWLFHVRILQIRUPDWLRQSURIHVVLRQDOV
Emerging findings
h?2 2`Hv }M/BM;b Q7 i?Bb `2b2`+? T`QpB/2 ;`QmM/2/ +QM+2TimH
++QmMi Q7 ?Qr bQ+BH K2/B `2 mb2/ BM BM7Q`KiBQM T`+iB+2b- mM@
+Qp2`BM; i?2 TBi7HHb b r2HH b i?2 QTTQ`imMBiB2bX h?2 +QMbi`m+ib Q7
T`+iB+2 i?i `2 `2TQ`i2/ BM i?Bb b2+iBQM Q7 i?2 TT2` `2, i?2 Mim`2
Q7 +QHH2+i2/ +QKKmMBiv FMQrH2/;2c `2@BK;BM; M/ `2@TQbBiBQMBM; BM@
7Q`KiBQM ;2M+B2bc miQMQKv- ;BHBiv M/ BMMQpiBQMc M/ T`QD2+ib,
,6620(
7KHXVHRIVRFLDOPHGLDLQWKHZRUNSUDFWLFHVRILQIRUPDWLRQSURIHVVLRQDOV
,6620(
7KHXVHRIVRFLDOPHGLDLQWKHZRUNSUDFWLFHVRILQIRUPDWLRQSURIHVVLRQDOV
,6620(
7KHXVHRIVRFLDOPHGLDLQWKHZRUNSUDFWLFHVRILQIRUPDWLRQSURIHVVLRQDOV
hrBii2` r?B+? Bb bm+? b?Q`i M/ b?`T bQ`i Q7 iQQH U6mHFM2` kyRyTX RkVX
u2i- b B7 #v Mim`2- M BM7Q`KiBQM T`Q72bbBQMHb TT`Q+? iQ
mbBM; bQ+BH K2/B Bb QM2 Q7 +miBQM M/ THMMBM;X AM i?2 2ti`2K2Bi BMpQHp2b rQ`FBM; T`iB2b- T`QiQivT2b- i2biBM; M/ #2i p2`bBQMbX
JMv bT2+ib Q7 /2bB;M 7Q` QMHBM2 2MpB`QMK2Mib r2`2 +QMbB/2`2/
#v BM7Q`KiBQM T`+iBiBQM2`b BM i?2B` THMM2/ TT`Q+? iQ i?2 mb2
Q7 bQ+BH K2/BX q2 /2bB;M2/ Bi iQ KF2 i?2 KQbi BKTQ`iMi 72im`2b
pBbB#H2 rBi?BM bBM;H2 b+`22M M/ iQ 2Mbm`2 i?i TQbi `2 +QMbBbi@
2MiHv +`2i2/ rBi? i?2 bK2 #bB+ BM7Q`KiBQM- r2 +`2i2/ i2KTHi2X
am+? +QKK2Mi`v `2p2Hb +QKT`2?2MbBp2 M/ i?Qm;?i7mH T`2T`@
iBQM BM i?2 mb2 Q7 bQ+BH K2/BX
AM7Q`KiBQM T`+iBiBQM2`b- BM i?2 THMMBM; Q7 +iBpBiv mbBM; i?2
iQQHb Q7 bQ+BH K2/B- +QMbB/2` i?2 TQbBiBQM Q7 i?2 T`2Mi #Q/vX PM2
;`QmT- r`2 i?i i?2B` THMM2/ 7Q`v BMiQ 6+2#QQF 7Q` BMi2`+iBM;
rBi? bim/2Mib bi QmibB/2 i?2 MQ`Kb Q7 Q{+BH +QKKmMB+iBQM +?M@
M2Hb- bi`i2;B+HHv T`2T`2/ DmbiB}+iBQM iQ +QmMi2` Mv TQbbB#H2
BMbiBimiBQMH +QM+2`MbX "2M+?K`FBM; M/ +QKT`BbQMb Q7 +QKT2i@
BiQ`b mb2 Q7 6+2#QQF r2`2 +QM/m+i2/ M/ #`Qm;?i iQ i?2 i#H2
r?2M #`Q/2` TT`QpH rb M2+2bb`vX Ai rb HbQ BKTQ`iMi iQ
T`+iBiBQM2`b i?i i?2v MQi TT2` iQ #2 mbBM; 6+2#QQF 7Q` Mv@
i?BM; Qi?2` i?M T`Q72bbBQMH +iBpBivX
lb2 Q7 i?2 iQQHb Q7 bQ+BH K2/B BM BbQHi2/ BM7Q`KiBQM T`+iB+2b
Q7i2M Tp2/ i?2 rv 7Q` 2Mi2`T`Bb2 /QTiBQMX h?2 mb2 M/ pHm2 Q7
bQ+BH K2/B 7Q` /Bb+`2i2 Tm`TQb2 M/ BM bKHH@b+H2 T`QD2+ib TB[m2/
i?2 BMi2`2bi Q7 i?2 Q`;MBbiBQM i H`;2X AM/p2`i2MiHv- BM7Q`KiBQM
T`+iB+2b ?/ T2`7Q`K2/ TBHQib 7Q` H`;2` /QTiBQMb Q7 bQ+BH K2/BX
MHvbBb M/ 2pHmiBQM Q7 mb2 Bb T`2pH2Mi BM BM7Q`KiBQM T`+@
iB+2b i?i BM+Q`TQ`i2 bQ+BH K2/BX h?2 Q#iBMBM; Q7 /i `2p2HBM;
i?2 MmK#2` M/ iBKBM; Q7 bT2+B}+ ivT2b Q7 ++2bb M/ BMi2`+iBQMb
72im`2 BM i?2 M``iBp2b Q7 T`+iB+2X AMi2`T`2iiBQMb Q7 +QHH2+i2/
/i bi22`b i?2 rv 7Q` }M2@imMBM;b Q` 7mim`2 /2p2HQTK2MibX PM+2
bQ+BH K2/B Bb BM mb2- +?M;2 Bb #b2/ QM 2pB/2M+2 M/ 2pHmiBQMX
AM7Q`KiBQM T`+iBiBQM2`b `2 +QM+2`M2/ rBi? i?2 `BbF Q7 mbBM;
bQ+BH K2/B- T`iB+mH`Hv r?2M i?2B` i2+?MQHQ;B2b Q7 mb2 M/ i?2 BM@
7Q`KiBQM M/ +QKKmMB+iBQM i?i 7QHHQr `2 BM i?2 Tm#HB+ /QKBMX
S`+iBiBQM2`b HbQ 2tT`2bb2/ +QM+2`M M/ /2p2HQT2/ bi`i2;v iQ
,6620(
Conclusions
h?Bb `2b2`+? }M/b i?i i?2 T`+iB+2b Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM T`Q72bbBQMHb
`2 `2TH2i2 rBi? i?2 mb2 Q7 bQ+BH K2/B M/ `2 `B+?Hv 2ti2M/2/ M/
i`Mb7Q`K2/ b `2bmHiX .2b+`BTiBQMb Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM T`+iB+2 i?i
2K#`+2 bQ+BH K2/B #QmM/ BM i?2 HBi2`im`2 M/ KMv KQ`2 Q++m`
BM i?2 rQ`FTH+2 rBi?Qmi `2TQ`iX h?2 mb2 Q7 bQ+BH K2/B BM BM7Q`K@
iBQM T`+iB+2b Bb +m``2MiHv b?`Qm/2/ BM T`+iB+2@H2/ BMMQpiBQM M/
7KHXVHRIVRFLDOPHGLDLQWKHZRUNSUDFWLFHVRILQIRUPDWLRQSURIHVVLRQDOV
Bibliography
,6620(
%,%/,2*5$3+<
,6620(