Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Napa Valley, California - Getting Water Supplies From Thin Air by Using The WaterBoxx
Napa Valley, California - Getting Water Supplies From Thin Air by Using The WaterBoxx
Newsletter of the Mayors Water Council of The United States Conference of Mayors
SUMMER/Fall 2010
Message from
the Co-Chairs
Mayoral interest in public water and wastewater
issues is growing. Eight water-related resolutions were
considered and adopted this June at the 78th Annual
Meeting of The U.S. Conference of Mayors. The single
most pronounced theme common to all of these new
water policies is the desire of Mayors to impose costefficiencies in an area that has burgeoned with public investment over the last five decades. Not surprising
since required spending in this area far exceeds inflation, and expected future cost requirements are daunting at a time when Main Street is still reeling from the
Great Recession. Still, cities are committed to the goals
of the Clean Water Act and the Safe Drinking Water
Act. The newly adopted policies call for smarter service
and infrastructure management at the local level; and
they call for more sophisticated planning and partnering with federal agencies. Congress, however, remains
silent in this debate, apparently comfortable with
expanding clean water goals that will be paid for by
local governments, or happy to authorize new federal
financial assistance that they likely suspect will never be
appropriated.
A critical, and glaringly absent, element necessary
to achieve clean water goals is a national coordinated
strategy on water that involves local, state and federal
government working together, and a dialogue between
local elected officials and Congress. Rather than continuing to struggle with top-down federal mandates that
are increasingly unaffordable, Congressional consultation could provide the needed leadership to prioritize
goals and better match mandates to the reality of local
financing burdens. The end-game goals enjoy a general consensus among federal and local government
- fishable and swimmable waters, safe drinking water,
floodplain management to protect people, property
and natural resources, etc. But the urgency driving the
federal appetite to push through rules and regulations
to cure all water problems in the short-run has painful affordability implications for: local government who
must take on significant long-term debt to finance the
necessary infrastructure; ever-increasing operations
Page 1
Status of Combined
Sewer Overflow
Dialogue with US EPA
THE UNITED STATES
CONFERENCE OF MAYORS
Elizabeth B. Kautz
Mayor of Burnsville
President
Antonio R. Villaraigosa
Mayor of Los Angeles
Vice President
Michael A. Nutter
Mayor of Philadelphia
Second Vice President
Tom Cochran
CEO and Executive Director
Message
from page 1
Overflow
from page 2
by one Mayors expressed their frustration with a consent decree negotiation process where the federal
agencies involved cast the local government as villains, if not engaging in near-criminal behavior. Their
accounts of negotiations across the nation indicated
that the EPA Regions (there are 10 EPA Regional Offices) lacked consistency in their negotiation processes
and attitudes. The consent agreement negotiation
process has become so adversarial that local government perceived EPA and DOJ demands to far exceed
what was necessary to achieve compliance with clean
water goals. In short, the Mayoral consensus was that
the federal government was acting with too heavy a
hand in this process, and that success was being measured by asserting command and control approaches
that had little to do with compliance and more to do
with punitive mandates that no longer balanced environmental benefits with local government expenditures. Throughout this conversation the EPA and DOJ
were attentive and open to criticism without presenting
a defensive posture.
Our second meeting was held in February of 2010.
In that meeting, EPA and DOJ took the initiative and
extended an offer to explore ways in which more flexibility could be incorporated into the consent negotiation process to ensure compliance but provide some
financial and other types of relief to local government.
In recognition of the frustrations expressed by Mayors
in the previous meeting, EPA and DOJ identified four
areas of concern that they are willing to focus the dialogue on for flexibility options: affordability; incorporating green infrastructure; front-end loading benefits
to extend compliance schedules; and, addressing carbon footprint issues. EPA made it clear that the dialogue could not, as a legal matter, touch on any current
enforcement actions, but could suggest policy options
in general. It was during that meeting that we agreed
to a format for discussion a technical advisory group
made up of staff from Conference of Mayors member
cities and the Mayors Water Council staff, and repre-
Page 3
OPINION
Every mayor and local elected official has the ability, and perhaps the obligation, to review the local
procurement practices of their utility staff. This provides an excellent opportunity to ensure that bidding
is aligned with modern asset management standards,
and considers life-cycle costs and performance of
materials in all public projects. Current procurement
methods, however, are costly and prevent informed
decisions from being made because bids are often
closed to qualified products. Opening them, according to experts, will save municipalities between 10 to
20 percent on all goods and services purchased.
The water and wastewater sector is a case in point.
Pipe is the largest component of a water utilitys assets
and seriously impacts operations and maintenance
costs, which are spiralling out of control, increasing by
6 per cent above inflation yearly. So, the performance
of a utilitys pipe materials is critical to holding the line
on costs. The traditional habit of using one or two
pipe materials exclusively, says Mayor Stratton, is
no longer satisfactory. Local officials need to compare
all proven pipe materials.
The solution to these problems begins with sustainability, durability and corrosion resistance, and this
is why municipalities must actively consider including
alternative materials such as PVC in their bidding processes. Increased durability means fewer leaks, better
water conservation and lower costs.
With over two million miles in service, PVC has
been celebrated by Engineering News Record as one
of the top 20 engineering advancements of the last
125 years. A study by the American Water Works
Association Research Foundation recently quantified
Procurement
from page 4
While many localities have yet to take full advanMayors Water Council
Page 5
is required this approach breaks the chain of providing water supply by using carbon producing energy.
(The technology and how it operates can be found on
http://groasis.com).
This new approach to water supply is important for
the Napa Valley. The Robert Mondavi vineyard is dry
farmed, and does not employ an irrigation system.
Dry farming works well for the older vines, but new
vine plantings doneed an external water source to
The City of Napa is the major city in Americas premier wine country, about an hour north of San Francisco, on 17.8 square miles of land with a population
of 72,585. Napa has a Mediterranean-like climate,
and like most western US cities has low precipitation
levels and is subject to drought cycles that make it difficult to plan for the provision of water supplies.
Agriculture is the key to the success
of Napa Valley and theCities in Napa
County.We created county wide principles that we could all agree on and foremost is the Preservation of Agriculture.
We understand that water resources are
important to agriculture, so much so that
the cities in the Valley do not use ground
water for municipal water supplies.
I recently participated in a groundbreaking ceremony at the Robert Mondavi Winery where a new water technology was introduced that provides
water out of thin air. This new technology
moves us toward city sustainability in a
new way. Its called the Groasis Waterboxx. Invented by Pieter Hoff of the
Netherlands, it is being used for multiple Left to right, Napa Mayor Jill Techel, Bart van
BoluisConsulate General of the Netherlands and, Margit
purposes all over the globe.
It is a simple, yet elegant, technology Mondavi, Vice President of Cultural Affairs at the Robert
Mondavi Winery. Matt Ashby Director of Vineyard
that is very inexpensive. The Waterboxx
Operations at Robert Mondavi Winery and Pieter Hoff, the
is about the size and shape of a tire. It Inventor of the WaterBoxx, install the Waterboxx around
has a concave cylinder cover that is situ- the vine.
ated over a container, (roughly 20 inches
in diameter and 10 inches in height).
There is a hole in the middle, and the Waterboxx is
start. Using the Waterboxx, Mondavi is planting three
placed over a sapling. The top cover gathers rain and
acres of new vines. Each new vine will be covered by
condensation from the atmosphere and stores it in the
the Waterboxx, and it will get the water it needs from
lower container. The container slowly drips the coneither rain or condensation.After one year the plants
tained water under the sapling to supply moisture for
will be strong enough to grow on their own and the
root development.
Groasis Waterboxx can be easily removed at any
The container holds four gallons of water that
time and reused for the other plantings. . This technolis made up of rain water or condensation collected
ogy can work for cities in areas where new plantings
at night when the cover cools more rapidly than the
are desired but irrigation is not available to get the
container. The concave design of the cover allows the
new plants started.
condensate to run into the container. During the day
This is a shining example of low impact developtime the cover prevents evaporation, and the cover
ment for sustainable cities. Groasis, the manufacturer
and container protect the sapling from intense heat,
of the Waterboxx, is involved with many demonstracreating a conducive growing environment. A trickling
tions and experiments world-wide. The technology has
wick is inserted in the bottom of the container to allow
applications that address reforestation, water conserwater to drip into the soil under the sapling to promote
vation and food production. In the Napa Valley, the
root growth. As a result, other than filling the container
technology promises to provide multiple public benat planting, the Waterboxx is self sufficient and relies
efits to our water supply, local economic activity, and
solely on atmospheric water in the form of condensalow impact development.
tion and rain. And because no external energy supply
Mayors Water Council
Page 6
Page 7
Lake Oswego
from page 5
Oklahoma City
from page 7
Schenectady Mayor Brian Stratton led the discussion on the Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) initiative the USCM is engaged in with the US EPA. Mayor
Stratton described the initiative whereby several meetings with the US EPA and the US DOJ have resulted in
an agreement to review the CSO compliance negotiation process, and consider local government proposals
to achieve compliance and simultaneously reduce the
cost to do so. Stratton said that EPA reports indicate
over 800 cities have CSO events that endanger public health, sensitive habitats and critical ecosystems.
He stated that the nations mayors share EPAs goal
of reducing these threats, but that it can be done in a
more cost-efficient manner.
Indianapolis Mayor Greg Ballard commented that
when he took office in 2008 the city had already
entered into a consent agreement to control CSOs
with a price tag of $3.9 billion. He was concerned
about human exposures to raw sewage and worked
to develop an alternative and sustainable engineering solution to reduce flows to the Combined Sewer
System using green infrastructure methods. In 2009
Page 8
Uniform Utilities
Mobile Workforce
from page 9
Page 10
Potential
from page 10
SMART to Sustainable
Page 11
Mobile Workforce
from page 12
Page 12
Glen Falls
from page 13
PWSBs Water
Conservation and
Greening Efforts
with Acoustic Leak
Detection
achieved compliance with New York States progressive dam safety regulations. These achievements suggest that the approach adopted by Glen Falls serves as
a Best Practice for other communities to address their
dam safety problems.
CHA is a full service engineering firm providing
planning and design services to municipalities in the
fields of civil, environmental, geotechnical, mechanical, electrical, structural, traffic and transportation
engineering as well as planning, survey, landscape
architecture, construction inspection, and technology
services. The firm employs 700 staff in over two-dozen
offices across the United States.
Page 14
Providence
from page 14
How it works:
The program:
sensors will be strategically located, and they are partially funded by an American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (Act) Grant that also aids in meeting the Acts
Green Project Reserve investment requirements. Funds
from the grant provide additional benefits. The utility
trained its meter technicians to perform MLOG installations thereby broadening their skill set while enhancing
PWSBs water management program.
Since mid-May, weve installed 2,500 sensors and
discovered 40 leaks. Finding leaks so quickly helps in
reducing non-revenue water and promotes conservation. The MLOG system also enables us to mitigate
leaks from surfacing into main breaks resulting in possible road damage; and time, employee resources and
money to repair, said Mark Ceseretti, PWSBs MLOG
Program Manager.
Ceseretti remarked, Weve asked our customers to
be good water stewards. With the leak detection system, we are leading by example.
Page 15
Page 16