Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CIBC - Case Study
CIBC - Case Study
Paper 131-2009
Case Study
Rick Miller
Risk Management:
Using the SAS Platform at CIBC
Financial Services
Disclaimer
subsidiaries or affiliates.
Financial Services
Todays Discussion
Financial Services
About CIBC
All amounts in C$
Financial Services
Financial Services
Pillar I
Pillar II
Disclosure
and
Market
Discipline
Pillar III
Calculation of
Minimum
Capital
Requirements
SelfAssessment
and
Supervisory
Review
Credit Risk
Operational Risk
Market Risk
Financial Services
Best
Bank A
Bank B
Default Rating
Worst
Corporate
Loan Portfolio
ILLUSTRATIVE
Exposure ($)
Financial Services
Exposures
Total
CAR 1
Capital
Corporate
Loan Portfolio
Bank B
Bank A
ILLUSTRATIVE
($)
Financial Services
Total
CAR 1
Capital
Basel II
Capital
Corporate
Loan Portfolio
Exposures
Bank B
Bank A
ILLUSTRATIVE
AIRB Approach
($)
Financial Services
10
Financial Services
Unexpected
loss
11
Probability of Default
Expected loss
Financial Services
12
STANDARDIZED APPROACH
Standardized
Approach
Financial Services
13
Foundation
Internal Ratings
Based Approach
Standardized
Approach
Financial Services
14
Advanced
Internal Ratings
Based Approach
(AIRB)
Foundation
Internal Ratings
Based Approach
Standardized
Approach
Financial Services
15
Advanced
Internal Ratings
Based Approach
(AIRB)
Foundation
Internal Ratings
Based Approach
Standardised
Approach
Financial Services
CORPORATE
SOVEREIGN
BANK
RETAIL
Residential Secured
Qualifying Revolving Retail
All Other Retail
EQUITIES (non-traded)
16
Financial Services
Other Retail
Residential secured
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
Drawn
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
Undrawn
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
Repo style
transactions
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
OTC
derivatives
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
Other
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
TOTAL
ILLUSTRATIVE
Corporate
xxx
xxx
xxx
Credit Exposures
by type for the period ending...
Sovereign
xxx
xxx
(Canadian $ millions)
Bank
xxx
xxx
17
Financial Services
18
Financial Services
19
Financial Services
Getting Started
20
Financial Services
21
Financial Services
determine where the data exists and identify any data gaps
22
Financial Services
BORROWER
VOLUME
EXPOSURE
DIMENSIONS
ASSIGNMENT OF
RISK PARAMETERS
VIEW OF
CREDIT RISK
Hundreds of thousands
Large authorization /
outstanding balances per
borrower - multiple facilities
Borrower-centric
(across all org units and all
products)
CORPORATE, SOVEREIGN,
BANK, EXPOSURE CLASSES
Many millions
Small authorization /
outstanding balances
Product-centric
(homogeneous pools)
RETAIL EXPOSURE
CLASSES
RATING SYSTEMS
Requires less
complex credit
scoring
23
More straightforward
RECONCILIATION:
EXPOSURES TO G/L
Financial Services
24
Financial Services
25
ILLUSTRATIVE
Borrower / Guarantor
Effective
Borrower
Characteristics
Maturity
Default
Expected
Ratings
Loss
Facility Info
Economic
Loss History
External
Parameter
Collateral
Credit
Estimates
Characteristics
Basel II Capital
Assessments
(PD, LGD, EAD)
Calculations
Credit Risk
Exposures
Basel II
Mitigation
Exposure
Risk
Classes
Weighted Assets Borrower / Guarantor
Identity
(RWA)
Risk Rating /
Scoring Models
Financial Services
(3) booking,
managing
exposures,
and collateral
value
Credit
Adjudication
(2) approve
terms and
conditions
(e.g., limits,
default ratings)
Credit
Application
Fulfillment
and
Operations
Analyze the
Credit Risk Data Lifecycle
(1) initial
data capture,
verification,
validation
Monitoring
and
Reporting
ILLUSTRATIVE
26
Financial Services
Risk
Weighted Assets
(RWA)
Risk
Calculations
(PD, LGD, EAD)
27
ILLUSTRATIVE
Basel II
Regulatory
Capital
Financial Services
Risk
Weighted Assets
(RWA)
Risk
Calculations
(PD, LGD, EAD)
Risk Rating /
Scoring Models
Parameter
Estimates
28
ILLUSTRATIVE
Basel II
Regulatory
Capital
Financial Services
Risk
Calculations
(PD, LGD, EAD)
Risk Rating /
Scoring Models
Economic
Loss History
External
Credit
Assessments
29
ILLUSTRATIVE
Basel II
Regulatory
Capital
Parameter
Estimates
Credit Risk
Mitigation
Risk
Weighted Assets
(RWA)
Instrument
Balances
Financial Services
30
Financial Services
Risk Rating /
Scoring Models
Risk
Calculations
(PD, LGD, EAD)
Economic
Loss History
31
External
Credit
Assessments
Basel II
Regulatory
Capital
Parameter
Estimates
Credit Risk
Mitigation
Risk
Weighted Assets
(RWA)
Instrument
Balances
Financial Services
32
Financial Services
required history (at least one full economic cycle) not readily
available for some required attributes
33
Financial Services
Transaction Metrics
Pool Pool Pool Pool Pool Pool
1
2
3
4
5
n
Borrower Metrics
Transaction Metrics
Pool Pool Pool Pool Pool Pool
1
2
3
4
5
n
PD
34
Analytic Engine:
determines pools
forecasts PD for each pool
revises pools to ensure
appropriate Capital
stress testing
Historic Portfolio
Performance Data
Borrower Metrics
Financial Services
35
Financial Services
Internal
source data
Current
ILLUSTRATIVE
Owner-occupied /
mixed
Rental property
Pool F
36
Pool E
Pool D
1-29 days
delinquent
Pool C
Pool B
30-59 days
delinquent
60-89 days
delinquent
Pool A
Financial Services
37
Financial Services
ILLUSTRATIVE
38
Financial Services
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
Max
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
Adjusted
PD
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
PD
Estimate
00.0
00.0
00.0
00.0
00.0
00.0
Average
Balance
ILLUSTRATIVE
A
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
PD (bps)
B
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
Min
C
0000.00
0000.00
0000.00
Std
0000.00
0000.00
Mean PD
0000.00
0000.00
Pool ID
39
Financial Services
40
Financial Services
Risk Rating /
Scoring Models
Risk
Calculations
(PD, LGD, EAD)
Economic
Loss History
41
External
Credit
Assessments
Basel II
Regulatory
Capital
Parameter
Estimates
Credit Risk
Mitigation
Risk
Weighted Assets
(RWA)
Instrument
Balances
Financial Services
42
Financial Services
staging areas
Economic
Capital
calculation
engines
Business
Rules
Risk
Analytics
Models
RETAIL &
WHOLESALE
CREDIT
RISK DATA
WAREHOUSES
RWA
calculation
engines
Direct
Feed to
Regulators
Other
Applications
& Models
Reports
Views
ILLUSTRATIVE
Credit
Application &
Adjudication
Account
Management
& Monitoring
Transaction
Systems
External
Ratings
43
Financial Services
final reconciliation of
all risk assets
ILLUSTRATIVE
General Ledger
reconcile balances of
retail assets to
General Ledger
reference data
staging area
data validation
Parameter tables
(PD, LGD, EAD)
44
Financial Services
Org
Org
BOA
Account
BOA
Account
SubAcct
CustGrp
CustGrp
Balance
Balance
Finance systems
Other Financial Attributes
SubAcct
45
Financial Services
Org
Org
BOA
Account
BOA
Account
SubAcct
CustGrp
CustGrp
Balance
Balance
Finance systems
Other Financial Attributes
Challenges:
source systems are not unique by Basel II Exposure Class
ensuring accurate booking of transactions across multiple source
systems
SubAcct
46
Financial Services
47
Financial Services
SAS
Enterprise
Miner
Risk
Analytics
Models
RETAIL
CREDIT
RISK DATA
WAREHOUSE
SAS
Enterprise
Guide
SAS
DI Studio
Business
Rules
SAS
Enterprise
Guide
SAS
Risk Dimensions
RWA
calculation
engines
Reports
Other
Applications
& Models
Direct
Feed to
Regulators
SAS
OLAP
Studio
48
staging areas
Economic
Capital
calculation
engines
Party
Reference
Data
G/L
Balances &
Hierarchies
Credit
Application &
Adjudication
Account
Management
& Monitoring
Transaction
Systems
External
Ratings
Financial Services
Summary
49
Financial Services
50
Financial Services
Thank You
contact: rick.miller@cibc.ca
51