Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 51

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Paper 131-2009

Case Study

Rick Miller

SAS Global Forum 2009

Vice-President, Credit Risk Data Solutions


Risk Management, CIBC

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Risk Management:
Using the SAS Platform at CIBC

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Disclaimer

Any views, opinions, advice, statements, or other information or content

expressed or implied in the following presentation are solely those of the

presenter and do not necessarily state or reflect the views, positions, or

SAS Global Forum 2009

opinion of Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC) or any of its

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

subsidiaries or affiliates.

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Key Data Challenges


The Journey Ahead

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

Increased Spotlight on Credit Risk Data

A Brief Overview of the Basel II Framework

Todays Discussion

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

About CIBC

All amounts in C$

Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC) is a leading


North American Financial institution

we offer a full range of products and services to almost


11 million individuals and small businesses, corporate and
institutional clients

SAS Global Forum 2009

At year-end (October 31, 2008):


Market capitalization was $20.8 billion
Tier 1 capital ratio was 10.5%
employed nearly 40,000 employees worldwide
had 1,050 branches in Canada and more than 3,700 ABMs

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

constituent of the Dow Jones Sustainability Index (DJSI)


for seven consecutive years (one of 25 banks worldwide)

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

The Basel II Framework Goals

a global framework issued by Bank of International


Settlements (BIS) and managed by national supervisors
Credit Risk
Operational Risk
Market Risk

developed over the period 1999 2005 with broad


impact studies
consultation globally
with
Pillar III
Pillar I along
Pillar
II quantitative
Calculation of
SelfDisclosure
Minimum
Assessment
and
Capital
and

The Basel IIRequirements


Committee Goals
were: Market
Supervisory
Discipline
Review
to enhance risk sensitivity
of capital
requirements
greater emphasis on banks own assessment of risk
improve transparency for market discipline

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

Basel II was implemented November 1, 2007 by CIBC and


other major banks in Canada

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Pillar I

Pillar II

Disclosure
and
Market
Discipline

Pillar III

SAS Global Forum 2009

Calculation of
Minimum
Capital
Requirements

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SelfAssessment
and
Supervisory
Review

Credit Risk
Operational Risk
Market Risk

The Basel II Framework

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Best

Bank A

Bank B

Default Rating

Worst

Corporate
Loan Portfolio

Distribution of Credit Risk

For what matters.

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

ILLUSTRATIVE

assume credit portfolio size is identical for both banks


but with a different mix of credit risk

Exposure ($)

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Exposures

Total

CAR 1

Capital

Corporate
Loan Portfolio

Bank B

Bank A

Previous CAR: No Differentiation

For what matters.

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

ILLUSTRATIVE

Under previous Capital Adequacy rules, both portfolios


would require the same amount of minimum regulatory capital

($)

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Total

CAR 1

Capital

Basel II

Capital

Corporate
Loan Portfolio

Exposures

Bank B

Bank A

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

ILLUSTRATIVE
AIRB Approach

Basel II: Risk Sensitive, More Capital

For what matters.

The strategic implication is that banks with riskier portfolios


will have higher minimum regulatory capital requirements

($)

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Basel II Glossary: Credit Risk Capital

The Basel II Framework allows the use of bank-specific


estimates of risk components in determining the capital
component for a given exposure:
Probability of default (PD)
Exposure at default (EAD)
Loss given default (LGD)
Effective maturity

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

10

Firm-size adjustment for Small Medium Enterprises (SME)

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Basel II Glossary: Credit Risk Capital


Expected Loss (EL) = PD * EAD * LGD

Unexpected
loss

SAS Global Forum 2009

11

Unexpected Loss (UL) calculated using sophisticated Basel II


formulae incorporating PD, EAD, LGD
Loss
99.9th percentile
of loss

Probability of Default

Expected loss

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

minimum regulatory capital is a function of the calculation


of unexpected loss (UL) and expected loss (EL)
For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

some capital relief for credit risk


mitigation (e.g., collateral)

SAS Global Forum 2009

12

banks can use external credit ratings

more gradations of risk

similar to existing BIS88

STANDARDIZED APPROACH

Basel II: Three Options for Credit Risk

Standardized
Approach

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

More Stringent Qualifying Criteria

For what matters.

More Sophistication and Risk Sensitivity

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

SAS Global Forum 2009

13

expected Minimum requirement for


internationally active banks

supervisors provide estimates for:


Loss Given Default (LGD) and
Exposure At Default (EAD)

banks use their own estimates of:


Probability of Default (PD)

based on internal data and risk ratings

FOUNDATION INTERNAL RATINGS


BASED APPROACH (FIRB)

Basel II: Three Options for Credit Risk

Foundation
Internal Ratings
Based Approach

Standardized
Approach

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

More Stringent Qualifying Criteria

For what matters.

More Sophistication and Risk Sensitivity

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

banks use their own estimates of:


Probability of Default (PD)
Loss Given Default (LGD)
Exposure at Default (EAD)

complex and internationally active


banks encouraged to move to this
approach

SAS Global Forum 2009

14

based on internal data and risk ratings

ADVANCED INTERNAL RATINGS


BASED APPROACH (AIRB)

Basel II: Three Options for Credit Risk

Advanced
Internal Ratings
Based Approach
(AIRB)

Foundation
Internal Ratings
Based Approach

Standardized
Approach

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

More Stringent Qualifying Criteria

For what matters.

More Sophistication and Risk Sensitivity

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

SAS Global Forum 2009

15

Supervisor expects all major


Canadian banks to implement
AIRB

Banks must have a robust


system in place to validate the
accuracy and consistency of:
- rating systems,
- processes, and
- estimation of all relevant
risk components

Banks must meet broad


risk-quantification standards
for own estimates of PD,
LGD, EAD

Basel II: Three Options for Credit Risk

Advanced
Internal Ratings
Based Approach
(AIRB)

Foundation
Internal Ratings
Based Approach

Standardised
Approach

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

More Stringent Qualifying Criteria

For what matters.

More Sophistication and Risk Sensitivity

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Basel II Glossary: Exposure Classes

CORPORATE
SOVEREIGN
BANK
RETAIL
Residential Secured
Qualifying Revolving Retail
All Other Retail
EQUITIES (non-traded)

under the IRB approach, banks must categorize banking-book


exposures into broad classes of assets, specifically:

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

16

the work here was focused on ensuring that the identifiers to


classify exposures were available, accurate, complete, and
persistent in the source data

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Basel II Glossary: Exposure Types

additional granularity of reporting using counterparty type

Other Retail

Qualifying revolving retail

Residential secured

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

Drawn

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

Undrawn

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

Repo style
transactions

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

OTC
derivatives

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

Other

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

xxx

TOTAL

ILLUSTRATIVE

Corporate

xxx

xxx

xxx

Credit Exposures
by type for the period ending...

Sovereign

xxx

xxx

(Canadian $ millions)

Bank

xxx

SAS Global Forum 2009

xxx

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Total Gross Credit Risk Exposures

For what matters.

17

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Data Maintenance Focus by Regulators

Implementation Note by the Canadian supervisor (OSFI),


Data Maintenance at IRB Institutions
provides general guidance on data maintenance
and principles to apply
supervisor will monitor ongoing data maintenance
compliance

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

Data Maintenance Principles include guidance on:


Senior Management Oversight Accountabilities
Data Life-Cycle Management

For what matters.

18

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

So, What Is the Prize?


regulatory compliance is critical

SAS Global Forum 2009

19

for CIBCs mix of business, using the Basel II AIRB approach


results in a small overall reduction of capital for credit risk

for line of business operations, ties the allocation and use


of regulatory capital to the risk profile of the business

promotes an enterprise-wide focus on the importance of


accurate and complete risk data

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

introduces formal requirements for back testing and


stress testing of rating systems and parameter estimates
to supplement and enhance existing practices

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Getting Started

CIBC Case Study

Developing Parameter Estimates

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

Calculating Basel II Regulatory Capital

For what matters.

20

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

CIBC Case Study: Where We Started

developed a broad understanding of the Basel II Framework


requirements
assessed what already existed, in terms of:
People
Processes
Data
Systems / tools

developed a gap analysis and secured senior management


support and funding for projects to close the gaps

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

21

strategy was to leverage existing capability, wherever possible

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

The Data Approach

use the Basel II Framework document to understand and


then define the mandatory risk data

create a logical model to consolidate and organise the data

determine where the data exists and identify any data gaps

enhance systems to collect and store the required data

harmonise different data definitions through the application


of business logic

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

implement a data maintenance framework to include:


risk data stewardship roles & responsibilities
data standards for accuracy, completeness, timeliness
data controls, measurement, and monitoring
data security and access
For what matters.

22

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

BORROWER
VOLUME

EXPOSURE
DIMENSIONS

ASSIGNMENT OF
RISK PARAMETERS

VIEW OF
CREDIT RISK

Hundreds of thousands

Large authorization /
outstanding balances per
borrower - multiple facilities

Assigned to each borrower

Borrower-centric
(across all org units and all
products)

CORPORATE, SOVEREIGN,
BANK, EXPOSURE CLASSES

Many millions

Small authorization /
outstanding balances

Assigned to each pool

Product-centric
(homogeneous pools)

RETAIL EXPOSURE
CLASSES

Different Credit Risk Data Challenges

RATING SYSTEMS

Requires sophisticated risk


rating systems

Requires less
complex credit
scoring

23

More straightforward

SAS Global Forum 2009

Challenging across exposure


classes and exposure types
CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

RECONCILIATION:
EXPOSURES TO G/L

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Key Challenges: Credit Risk Data


significant amount of data is required

require numerous feeds from different kinds of source


systems
state of current credit risk data

SAS Global Forum 2009

how to reconcile credit risk balances originating in these


disparate systems to the General Ledger

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

systems constraints / timing

For what matters.

24

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

What Data Do We Need?

SAS Global Forum 2009

25

ILLUSTRATIVE

decompose Basel II Framework clauses into mandatory


credit risk data for AIRB compliance

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Borrower / Guarantor
Effective
Borrower
Characteristics
Maturity
Default
Expected
Ratings
Loss
Facility Info
Economic
Loss History
External
Parameter
Collateral
Credit
Estimates
Characteristics
Basel II Capital
Assessments
(PD, LGD, EAD)
Calculations
Credit Risk
Exposures
Basel II
Mitigation
Exposure
Risk
Classes
Weighted Assets Borrower / Guarantor
Identity
(RWA)
Risk Rating /
Scoring Models

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

SAS Global Forum 2009

(3) booking,
managing
exposures,
and collateral
value

Credit
Adjudication

(2) approve
terms and
conditions
(e.g., limits,
default ratings)

Where To Look For The Data

Credit
Application

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Fulfillment
and
Operations

Analyze the
Credit Risk Data Lifecycle

(1) initial
data capture,
verification,
validation

For what matters.

Monitoring
and
Reporting

ILLUSTRATIVE

26

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Risk
Weighted Assets
(RWA)

Risk
Calculations
(PD, LGD, EAD)

SAS Global Forum 2009

27

ILLUSTRATIVE

Basel II
Regulatory
Capital

Mandatory Credit Risk Data

How Do We Organize The Data?

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Risk
Weighted Assets
(RWA)

Risk
Calculations
(PD, LGD, EAD)

Risk Rating /
Scoring Models

Parameter
Estimates

SAS Global Forum 2009

28

ILLUSTRATIVE

Basel II
Regulatory
Capital

Mandatory Credit Risk Data

How Do We Organize The Data?

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Risk
Calculations
(PD, LGD, EAD)

Risk Rating /
Scoring Models

Economic
Loss History

External
Credit
Assessments

29

ILLUSTRATIVE

Basel II
Regulatory
Capital

SAS Global Forum 2009

Parameter
Estimates

Mandatory Credit Risk Data

How Do We Organize The Data?


Borrower /
Guarantor
Identity
Borrower /
Guarantor
Characteristics
Facility
Details

Credit Risk
Mitigation

Risk
Weighted Assets
(RWA)

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Instrument
Balances

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

What We Learned About Our Data


the most challenging task was mapping data
there was no common data model
there were some data breaks
we didnt have granular enough historical data
data definitions were inconsistent

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

as the parallel year progressed, we measured success by the


reduction in the use of defaults for RWA calculations

For what matters.

30

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Risk Rating /
Scoring Models

Risk
Calculations
(PD, LGD, EAD)

Economic
Loss History

31

External
Credit
Assessments

Basel II
Regulatory
Capital

SAS Global Forum 2009

Parameter
Estimates

using Residential Mortgages


as an example

Case Study #1: Parameter Estimation


Borrower /
Guarantor
Identity
Borrower /
Guarantor
Characteristics
Facility
Details

Credit Risk
Mitigation

Risk
Weighted Assets
(RWA)

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Instrument
Balances

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Overview: Parameter Estimation

risk rating systems rank order the quality of individual credit


risk exposures and groupings of exposures

there are three important dimensions:


the risk of the borrower defaulting (PD)
factors specific to individual transactions to estimate
the economic loss, given default (LGD)
the calculation of exposure amount at default (EAD)

the estimates for PDs need to be long-run averages of the


actual one-year default rates

LGDs must be developed from historical losses and recoveries

SAS Global Forum 2009

32

these parameters must be good predictors of future loss events

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

banks are expected to reflect conservative estimates


For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Key Challenges: Parameter Estimation

required history (at least one full economic cycle) not readily
available for some required attributes

scarcity of CIBC-specific default data (e.g., Sovereigns, Banks)


granularity of data not always available

persistence of key data over time due to systems changes

requires unique analytical skill sets to build parameter


estimation models

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

33

parameter estimation models must be independently validated

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Developing Retail PD Estimates

Basel II requires banks to pool retail exposures with similar risk


characteristics and estimate the Probability of Default (PD)

Transaction Metrics
Pool Pool Pool Pool Pool Pool
1
2
3
4
5
n
Borrower Metrics

Transaction Metrics
Pool Pool Pool Pool Pool Pool
1
2
3
4
5
n

PD

SAS Global Forum 2009

34

Analytic Engine:
determines pools
forecasts PD for each pool
revises pools to ensure
appropriate Capital
stress testing

each individual exposure within the pool then acquires the


parameters of the pool to which it belongs

Historic Portfolio
Performance Data

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Historic Economic Data

For what matters.

Borrower Metrics

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

SAS Global Forum 2009

35

Basel II Definitions: Probability of Default (PD)

Probability of Default (PD) is a measure of the likelihood of an


uncertain future event.

the Basel II Residential Mortgages Exposure Class includes


mortgages for:
single-family homes, whether they are owner-occupied or not
multi-family buildings with maximum of 4 units

Basel II definition of default (clauses 452-453), either or both of:


obligor is past due 90 days on credit obligation to the bank
the bank considers the obligor unlikely to pay credit
obligations in full

Basel II time horizon (clause 466) specifies historical observations


of at least five years

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Basel II data sources (clause 464) specifies banks must regard


internal data as the primary source of information for estimating
loss characteristics
For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Creating Pools for Residential Mortgages

Internal
source data

Current

ILLUSTRATIVE

Owner-occupied /
mixed

LTV > 0.x

Rental property

Pool F

36

Pool E

SAS Global Forum 2009

Pool D

LTV <= 0.x

through analysis, we derived the key available risk factors


we pooled mortgage loans on the following criteria:
arrears status in bands, e.g., current, 1-29 days delinquent, etc.
Loan-To-Value (LTV) ratio
Occupancy Status, e.g., rental, owner-occupied, etc.

1-29 days
delinquent

Pool C

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Pool B

30-59 days
delinquent

Pooling for Residential Mortgages

60-89 days
delinquent

Pool A

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Meeting the Basel II Requirements

To conform to the Basel II requirements, we ensure that:

SAS Global Forum 2009

37

1. The pools clearly differentiate the PDs (clause 401)


PD in one pool should not significantly intersect with others

2. Each pool contains enough borrowers and defaulted borrowers


to allow for meaningful quantification and validation of loss
characteristics at the pool level (clause 409)

3. PD pools display sufficiently homogenous behaviour over time


subject to policy changes, etc.

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

4. If any pool would have a PD less than 3 basis points, we assign


the Basel II floor of 3 basis points (clause 331)

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

ILLUSTRATIVE

Reviewing the Historical Performance Data

For what matters.

38

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Next Steps Deriving the PDs

for each Residential Mortgages pool, data was analyzed to produce


lower quartile, median, and upper quartile values

0000.00
0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

Max

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

Adjusted
PD

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

PD
Estimate

00.0

00.0

00.0

00.0

00.0

00.0

Average
Balance

ILLUSTRATIVE

A
0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

PD (bps)

B
0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

Min

C
0000.00

0000.00

0000.00

Std

0000.00

0000.00

Mean PD

0000.00

SAS Global Forum 2009

0000.00

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Pool ID

For what matters.

39

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Next Steps Implementing & Monitoring

statistical analysis was performed to test for:


meaningful distribution of borrowers across pools
homogenous behaviour within pools
trending
adjustment needed for sampling error(s)

we derived our estimate of long-run average PD for each pool


we tested the accuracy of our predictions

we implemented the PD model into production for calculation


of Risk Weighted Assets (RWAs) for Residential Mortgages

we monitor and analyze the observed default rate over time


against the estimate

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

40

reports to senior management highlight performance over time


For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Risk Rating /
Scoring Models

Risk
Calculations
(PD, LGD, EAD)

Economic
Loss History

41

External
Credit
Assessments

Basel II
Regulatory
Capital

SAS Global Forum 2009

Parameter
Estimates

Case Study #2: Calculating Risk Weighted Assets


Borrower /
Guarantor
Identity
Borrower /
Guarantor
Characteristics
Facility
Details

Credit Risk
Mitigation

Risk
Weighted Assets
(RWA)

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Instrument
Balances

For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

The Road to Basel II Risk Weighted Assets

minimum regulatory capital under Basel II is based on the


calculation of Risk Weighted Assets (RWAs)

RWAs are calculated according to established mathematical


formulae utilizing PDs, LGDs, EADs, and in some cases,
maturity adjustments

Sourcing, processing, and reconciling data in order to calculate,


store, and report on RWAs for the calculation of minimum
regulatory capital is the core of the Basel II data challenge

The Basel II Capital Adequacy Requirements (BCAR) Return


provides Canadian regulators with quarterly status on the
Banks capitalization in relation to the risks it has assumed

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

42

In Canada, the minimum ratio for Total Capital to Risk Assets


and Total Assets is 8%
For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

staging areas

Economic
Capital
calculation
engines

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Business
Rules

Risk
Analytics
Models

RETAIL &
WHOLESALE
CREDIT
RISK DATA
WAREHOUSES

RWA
calculation
engines

SAS Global Forum 2009

Business Intelligence Layer

Direct
Feed to
Regulators

Other
Applications
& Models

Reports

Views

ILLUSTRATIVE

Credit Risk Data Architecture Overview


Party
Reference
Data
G/L
Balances &
Hierarchies

Credit
Application &
Adjudication
Account
Management
& Monitoring
Transaction
Systems

External
Ratings

For what matters.

Data Integration Layer (various ETL tools push/pull)

43

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

final reconciliation of
all risk assets

ILLUSTRATIVE

General Ledger

reconcile balances of
retail assets to
General Ledger

RWA calculator engine


for all retail assets and
pool summaries

SAS Global Forum 2009

analytic engine to assign


retail assets into pools

assign retail assets to


Basel II Exposure Class

reference data

The Process for RWAs Retail Credit Risk


extract monthly source
data for all retail assets
as at month-end

staging area
data validation

Parameter tables
(PD, LGD, EAD)

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

creation of BCAR and


other regulatory reports

For what matters.

44

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Org

Org
BOA

Account

BOA

Account

SubAcct
CustGrp

CustGrp

For what matters.

Balance

Balance

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Credit Risk data warehouses


Other Risk Data Attributes

Finance systems
Other Financial Attributes

SAS Global Forum 2009

reconciliation is required for all Basel II Exposure Classes and


Exposure Types (drawn, undrawn, other off-balance sheet)

SubAcct

Reconciliation To The General Ledger


Product
Accounting
Code block
Product

45

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Org

Org
BOA

Account

BOA

Account

SubAcct
CustGrp

CustGrp

For what matters.

Balance

Balance

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Credit Risk data warehouses


Other Risk Data Attributes

Finance systems
Other Financial Attributes

SAS Global Forum 2009

Challenges:
source systems are not unique by Basel II Exposure Class
ensuring accurate booking of transactions across multiple source
systems

reconciliation is required for all Basel II Exposure Classes and


Exposure Types (drawn, undrawn, other off-balance sheet)

SubAcct

Reconciliation To The General Ledger


Product
Accounting
Code block
Product

46

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Analysis and Reporting


multiple business stakeholders have regulatory and
management reporting needs for credit risk data

Regulators require specific credit risk reports quarterly,


due 30 days after fiscal quarter-end:
BCAR (Basel II regulatory capital)
NCR (new credit risks)

Board of Directors and senior management oversight

Line of Business Analysis of:


exposures, risk calculations (e.g., EAD, EL, RWA, etc.)
risk profiles - ODR/LGD distributions, etc.
portfolio metrics geographic, industry, etc.

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

SAS Global Forum 2009

Performance measurement of risk analytics models for


continuous improvement
For what matters.

47

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

SAS
Enterprise
Miner
Risk
Analytics
Models

RETAIL
CREDIT
RISK DATA
WAREHOUSE

SAS
Enterprise
Guide
SAS
DI Studio
Business
Rules

SAS
Enterprise
Guide

SAS
Risk Dimensions
RWA
calculation
engines

SAS Global Forum 2009

Reports

Other
Applications
& Models

Direct
Feed to
Regulators

SAS
OLAP
Studio

48

Analytic Cubes / Marts

SAS Platform for Retail Credit Risk


ILLUSTRATIVE

staging areas

Economic
Capital
calculation
engines

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

Business Intelligence Layer

Party
Reference
Data
G/L
Balances &
Hierarchies

Credit
Application &
Adjudication
Account
Management
& Monitoring
Transaction
Systems

External
Ratings

For what matters.

Data Integration Layer (various ETL tools push/pull)

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

Summary

under Basel II AIRB, a bank will be able to self-assess and


report minimum regulatory capital for credit risk

SAS Global Forum 2009

49

approval and ongoing compliance is dependent upon banks


demonstrating the integrity of their risk rating methodologies
and data used to calculate regulatory capital

senior management has accountability for establishing and


monitoring the enterprise-wide observance of the risk data
management framework

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

the payback on the Basel II investment comes from the


use of the new regulatory capital information for businesses
to more effectively manage risk
For what matters.

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

For what matters.

SAS Global Forum 2009

While we are well on our way


at CIBC, the journey continues

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

50

Financial Services

SAS Global Forum 2009

For what matters.

Thank You

SAS Global Forum 2009

contact: rick.miller@cibc.ca

CIBC 2009 All Rights Reserved

51

You might also like