Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 50

Energy Management

Opportunities
Reduce Energy Intensity and
Carbon Emissions by Changing the
Way You Use Energy

This document was specifically prepared to aid Tech Resources clients that wish to inform their customers about available
energy management solution options that these customers may wish to consider. Any other use of this material (in whole or in
part) is not allowed without the expressed written consent of Tech Resources, Inc., 2025 Riverside Drive, Columbus, OH 43221.

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

Energy Management

Mike Carter
Mark Farrell

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

Energy Management Benefits


Bottom line cost savings today!
Energy
Maintenance

Reduced noise levels


Better indoor air quality
Reduced air emissions

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

Energy Management Opportunities

Basics
Energy Management
Insulation
HVAC
Lighting
Heating Systems
Motors
Transformers
Compressed Air

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

Energy Efficiency Basics


Power versus Energy
Kilowatt (kW) is a measure of power, like the
speedometer of your car that records the
rate at which miles are traveled.

A bigger engine is required to travel at a faster rate.


Peak power demand is usually measured as an average
over a 15-minute period.
Spikes and surges from motor startup and other short-term
anomalies have little influence on peak demand.

Kilowatt-hour (kWh) is a measure of energy/load


consumptionsimilar to the odometer on your car
which measures miles traveled.

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

Energy Efficiency Basics


Power versus Energy (contd)
Energy Cost = Energy Consumption x Unit Cost =
kWh x $/kWh

A 113-Watt four-lamp light fixture costs about $66 annually


when operating 16 hr/day (113 W x 5,840 hr x $0.10/kWh
1,000 W/kW)

Motor power (kW) = Horsepower x 0.746/efficiency


A 10 HP motor = 10 HP x 0.746/0.90 = 8.3 kW
A 10 HP motor costs about $4,850 annually (8.3 kW x 5,840 hr
x $0.10/kWh) when operating 16 hr/day

Pay the price for improved energy efficiency!

The operating cost over the lifetime of a motor or light fixture


can far exceed the original purchase price.

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

Energy Basics

Load Factor
Ratio of average load over peak load
LF = kWAvg/kWP = kWh/hrs kWP
Assume 30-day billing

(30 x 24 hrs = 720 hrs)


10,000 kWh load
21 kW peak
LF = 10,000/720 21 kW
LF = 66%

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

Energy Basics
Peak Demand Curtailment
Separate loads into three categories:

Life, health, and safety-driven


Mission critical
Non-critical

Start by considering curtailment of non-critical loads

Non-safety lighting
HVAC

Consider installing sub-metering to identify high


intensity loads

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

Energy Basics
Power Factor
Real/active power (kW) does real work
Reactive power (kVAR) bound up in magnetic fields
Apparent power (kVA) must be supplied by utility to
accommodate reactive component
PF = kW/kVA
kVA2 = kW2 + kVAR2
(kVA) = (kW) + (kVAR)
= (75) + (75) = 11,250
Apparent Power = 11,250 = 106 kVA
Then: Power Factor = kW/kVA = 75/106 = 70.8%

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

Energy Basics

Power Factor
Add capacitance to correct power factor
Does not change demand (kW) or save much
energy (kWh)

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

10

Energy Basics

Carbon Footprint
Metric tons (2,205 lbs or 19,550 ft3) of CO2
Natural

Gas - 12 lbs CO2/ccf


Electricity - 0.95 lbs CO2/kWh
Carbon = CO2 3.67 (100 tons CO2 = 27 tons C)
Pine trees can absorb roughly 1 metric ton of carbon per
acre per year

Direct emissions from company-owned stacks


Indirect emissions from travel

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

11

Corporate Energy Management


Key Components of Energy Management
Commitment by upper level management
Clearly stated goals on energy efficiency, waste
reduction, and sustainability
Delegation of responsibility and accountability to the
appropriate personnel
Sustained tracking and assessment of energy use and
technology application
Continuous investigation of potential energy reduction
projects

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

12

Corporate Energy Management


Energy Information Systems
Measure and Evaluate

Knowledge is power
If you can't measure it, you can't manage it!"

Access to real-time energy consumption/demand and cost data


across multiple plants and facilities

Plan

Benchmark
Against yourself
Against similar facilities

Prioritize solutions

Implement

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

13

Insulation
Insulation has diminishing returns
R-value is resistance to heat flow (additive)

R-7 + R-21 = R-28 (4 times R-7, and 75% better than R-7)
R-7 + R-49 = R-56 (8 times R-7, but only 12% better than R-28!)

U-value is conductance of heat; inverse of R-value


U(R-7) = 1/7 = 0.143
U(R-56) = 1/56 = 0.018 (87% less than R-7)
U(R-21) = 1/21 = 0.048 U(R-28) = 1/28 = 0.036 (75% less than R-7)

Insulating Value
U-Value (Btu/ft.2 F hr)

0.300

R-3.5

0.250
0.200
R-7

0.150
0.100

R-14

R-28

0.050

R-56

0.000
0

10

15

20

25

30

R-Value

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

14

35

40

45

50

55

60

Insulation
Insulate steam pipes with at least " insulation
For a 350F process steam pipe, savings are $5,000 for 2"

dia. and $10,000 for 4" dia. pipe


Diminishing returns for insulation
thickness > "

Type

Fiberglass

2.2-3.1

Vermiculite/perlite

2.4-2.8

Polystyrene

4.0-5.0

Polyurethane
Polyisocyanurate

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

15

R-value per inch

6.0
6.0-7.1

HVAC
Implementation

Load (kWh)

Peak (kW)

Temperature Setback

Economizers

Heat/Energy Recovery Ventilators/Wheels

Chiller Water Temperature

New HVAC Equipment

Geothermal Heat Pump

Air Doors/Curtains

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

16

HVAC
Temperature Setback/Setforward
Save 3% per F per 24 hrs
72F 68F (4F) for 12 hrs
saves 6%

Economizers Bring in Cool Outside Air


Typical 2 to 5 year payback for economizers
Most appropriate for large systems
(>5 tons in West and >11 tons in Midwest)
Not very effective in high humidity climates

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

17

HVAC
Heat Recovery Ventilators
Can recover about 60% to 70% of heat in exiting air
A solution to ASHRAE 62 IAQ requirements

Photo source: George Retseck Illustrations

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

18

HVAC
Energy/Enthalpy/Desiccant Wheels
Can recover about 70% to 80% of the energy in the
exiting air and deliver that energy to the incoming air.

Desiccant wheels are most cost effective in climates with


extreme winters or summers, and where fuel costs are high.

In mild climates, the cost of the additional electricity


consumed by the system fans and drum motor may
exceed the energy savings from not having to condition
the supply air.

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

19

HVAC
Narrow Your Chiller Water Temperature Set Points
Typical conditions are chilled water temperature of 42F
and condensing water temperature of 80F to 85F.

2% savings per F that chilled water temperature is raised


5F to 10F increase is possible; more may cause damage and
reduce cooling capacity (ton rating)

Efficiency benefits from lowering condensing water


temperature are offset by increased fan and pump
operation, along with reduced cooling capacity.

Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) and oversizing the cooling


tower can help

The larger the system, the greater the net energy savings

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

20

HVAC
Upgrade Older HVAC (10 to 15 years)
Chillers: 0.8 kW/ton 0.5 kW/ton (37% less!)
Unitary rooftop: 1.5 kW/ton 1.2 kW/ton (20% less!)

Geothermal or Water-Source Heat


Pump
Roughly 30% savings compared to

AC/Boiler or AC/Furnace
combination
Geothermal requires higher capital
investment and requires significant
amounts of real estate
New construction accommodates
verticals and pond loop

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

21

HVAC
Use Air Doors/Curtains
A door 14 feet wide and 11feet high, indoor
temperature of 70F, outdoor temperature of
20F, zero wind velocity, loses 600,000
Btu/h at a cost of roughly $7 per hour

Any wind at all triples the loss!


Air door recovers 75% of heat loss
1 to 2 year payback possible ($3,500 cap. + $100 op.)
Exhaust fans (negative pressure) and wind tunnel
effect are problems

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

22

Lighting
Implementation

Load
(kWh)

Peak
(kW)

Replace T12 with T8 or T5

Replace Metal Halide with T8 or T5HO

Replace Incandescent with CFL

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

23

Lighting
Replace existing T12 fluorescent lamps with T8 fluorescent lamps (up
to 30% savings).
Four-lamp T12 versus T8 Fixtures
Lamp Type

Fixture
Watts

Fixture
Lumens

LPW

F32T12

148

9,120

62

F32T8

113

10,600

94

No magnetic ballasts for new installations sold or manufactured after


March 2005.

More stringent magnetic ballast performance requirements after July


2009.

No magnetic ballasts manufactured for replacement after June 2010.


2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

24

Lighting
Super T8 lamps, with high-efficiency ballasts, are high lumen (>3,000
versus 2,850 std.) and extended life (>24,000 versus 20,000 hrs std.)
products.

Only saves energy when combined with a lower ballast factor ballast.
Type

Initial
Lumens

Initial
Watts

Ballast
Factor

Fixture
Lumens

Fixture
Watts

T8

2,950

33

0.85

2,496

28

Super T8

3,200

34

0.78

2,496

26

Group relamping recommended at 60% to 80% of rated life.


Every 2 to 3 years for 20,000 hour fluorescents
Can be 30% to 40% cheaper to group relamp due to labor savings

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

25

Lighting
Metal Halide (MH) versus Fluorescent for Highbay
Probe start (PS) MH with low lumen maintenance (<65%) is best target for
replacement

The lumen maintenance of metal halides can decrease to 45% during its
lifetime, whereas fluorescents maintain 90% to 95% in optimal conditions.

Compare 320 W PS MH with 20,000 EOL lumens and six F32T8 with
18,000 EOL lumens at 220 system watts

Lumen output of fluorescents declines with heat/cold

Compact Fluorescent Lighting (CFL)


You get the same or more light output (lumens) with a
75% energy reduction and over six times the rated life!

Energy savings far outweigh difference in lamp price


Use reflector flood CFLs in recessed can lights
Issue of mercury content can be addressed
2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

26

Heating Systems
Implementation

Load (Btu)

Load (kWh)

Peak (kW)

Waste Heat Absorption Chillers

Industrial Heat Pumps for Drying/Heating

Radio Frequency/Microwave Drying/Heating

Gas Burner Air:Fuel Ratio

Modern Gas Burners/Controls

Steam Traps

Stack Heat Recovery

Infrared Booster Heaters

Induction Process Heating

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

27

Heating Systems
Measuring Boiler Efficiency
Fuel-to-steam efficiency is the best efficiency metric

Boiler output (Btu)/boiler input (Btu)


Accounts for both combustion and thermal efficiency, radiation, and
convection losses

Efficiency mainly influenced by boiler design

Number of passes more important than add-on (turbulator)


Burner/boiler compatibility (accounts for geometry, heat transfer, and so on)
Burner controls (independent control of fuel and air is best)
Heating surface (square feet/boiler HP; 5 ft2/HP is desired)

Other factors

Flue gas temperature directly correlates with efficiency


Fuel hydrogen/carbon ratio (fuel oil > natural gas)
Excess air (10% to 12%)
Ambient temperature (every 40F ~ 1% efficiency change)
2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

28

Heating Systems
Proper Boiler Air:Fuel Ratio
Combustion Efficiency of Natural Gas
Excess %

Temp. F (Flue-Comb.)

Air

Oxy

200F

600 F

9.5

2.0

85.4%

76.0%

28.1

4.0

84.7%

74.0%

81.6

6.0

82.8%

68.2%

Efficiency improvements
82.8% 85.4% = 2.6%
68.2% 76.0% = 7.8%

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

29

Heating Systems
Upgrade to Modern Burners

Motor-controlled flue gas recirculation dampers


Swirl vanes
Turbulence enhancement
Premixing chambers
Leak-tight modulating air dampers
Tangential diluent injection
Rotating concentric blade air registers
Fuel atomizers
Venturi tube air registers
Tapered burner tiles with baffles

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

30

Heating Systems
Use Electronic Burner Controls (typical savings)
Linkless burners have no backlash (1%)
Increased turndown (5%)

Burner on/off cycles and their associated cold air purges also
will be reduced

A second PID control (10%)

Some electronic fuel:air ratio controls have two internal


proportionalintegralderivative (PID) modulation circuits.
If a plant does not run continuously then this second PID
controls setpoint can be used to switch the boiler to a lower
steam pressure or hot water temperature during periods of
reduced activity.

Adaptive oxygen trim (2% to 3%)

Large boilers only (>$100,000 fuel per year)

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

31

Heating Systems
Use Electronic Burner Controls (contd)
Fan speed control

With mechanical cam control and with basic electronic fuel:air


ratio controls, processors sacrifice combustion efficiency at
low fire to achieve an improvement in burner turn-down.
By adding fan speed control, burner turn-down can be
increased without compromising efficiency, and additional fuel
savings can be achieved.

Boiler sequencing (lead/lag) control and


communication software

Boiler sequencing control enables the plant operator to achieve


better utilization and additional energy savings are possible.

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

32

Heating Systems
Fix Broken Steam Traps
One 1/8" diameter stuck-open steam trap
orifice on a large boiler can cost $1,000 (15
psig) to $5,000 (140 psig) per year in increased
natural gas consumption

1 lb/hr ~ 1,000 Btu/hr

There are Several Ways to Test Steam Traps


Plugged traps are cool while operating and leaking traps are
hot. Use a non-contact, infrared thermometer.
In acoustic testing, an inspector listens for the variances in the
acoustic patterns of working or failed traps.
The electronic procedure typically involves touching the trap
on the downstream side with the instruments contact probe
and adjusting the sensitivity to better hear the flow.
2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

33

Heating Systems
Stack Heat Recovery
Each 40F reduction in stack
temperature results in a 1%
improvement in efficiency.

Preheating combustion air


A 200F air preheat saves 5%

Best applications >900F stack temperature

1,000F 800F results in 5% savings

Recuperators, regenerators, and heat exchangers


Infrared Booster Heaters
Reduces curing times of coatings by 25% to 40%
Best in conjunction with convection and for
thin simple shapes
2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

34

Heating Systems
Absorption Chillers
Fueled by waste heat but high
capital costs

Best for high peak demand


charges, CFC or HCFC
environmental concerns, waste
heat temperature >270F and
>500 tons capacity

Yazaki Energy Systems (Plano, TX) and Thermax


(Piscataway, NJ) claim to have low temperature (185F
to 203F) absorption chillers (20 to 30 ton max
capacity)
2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

35

Heating Systems

Industrial Heat Pumps


Process

Key Enabler

Applications

Separation

Reduced column pressure enables distillation


at low temperatures

Propane/propylene,
butane/butylenes

Concentration

Low (<50F) temperature lift results in gentle


evaporation cycle

Beer, sugar solutions, milk and


whey, juice, steep water, syrup
and radioactive waste.

Drying

Upper temperature limit; Slow dry time desired;


Continuous operation

Lumber and paper

Dehumidification

High temperature air used for drying; Slow dry


time desired

Brick, ceramics

Space Heating

Higher thermal efficiency than other furnaces

Shop, warehouse

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

36

Heating Systems

Radio Frequency/Microwave
Process

Key Enabler

Applications

Pre-drying

Selective heating (water only) to avoid product


damage; Speed

Fiberglass packaging and mats;


Dyed yarn spools; Ceramic
fiberboard, powder, and extrusions

Post-drying
(20%->8%)

Low final moisture content; Uniform (small


temperature gradient) heating; No surface
crust

Foods such as cookies, potato


chips, and pasta; Dry pet foods;
Polyurethane foam

Tempering

Volumetric heating; Speed

Frozen meats; Room temperature


bacon; Chocolate

Cooking

Reduce drip loss (water, fat, nutrients, and


flavor)

Sausage, bacon

Curing

Uniform heating; Precise temperature control;


Speed

Adhesives for wood and laminates

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

37

Heating Systems

Induction
Process

Key Enabler

Applications

Metallurgical processing
(Hardening, Tempering,
Annealing)

Selective heating; Speed;


In-line continuous process

Gear teeth; Cutting blades;


Pulleys; Axles; Camshafts;
Galvanized sheet

Preheating prior to deformation


(Forging; Swaging; Upsetting;
Bending; and Piercing)

Reduced scale formation;


Speed

Turbine engine blades; Billets; Mill


rolling of slabs and strips

Melting

Speed; Flexibility

Steel; Iron; Copper alloys;


Aluminum; Zinc

Brazing and Soldering

Localized heating; Precise


temperature control and
uniformity

Dissimilar materials; Carbide tips;


Turbine blades; Eyeglass frames

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

38

Motors and Transformers

Implementation

Load
(kWh)

Replace motors

Use variable speed drives

Right size the motor

Disconnect unused transformers

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

39

Peak
(kW)

Motors
Repair or Replace Motors
Replace motors <40 HP
Replace if cost of rewind >65% of new motor
Replace motors last rewound before 1980
Variable Speed Drives/Adjustable Speed Drives
Best for variable torque loads often found in variable flow

applications (pumps, fans, and blowers) and greater than


2,000 hours operation
Horsepower varies as the cube of speed/flow
Cut speed/flow by 50%, you cut energy consumption by
nearly 90%! (0.5 x 0.5 x 0.5 = 0.125)
Converts 60 Hz to 120 to 400 Hz in pulse width modulation

Pulse-width modulation most common


Current-source inverter used for 100+ HP motors
2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

40

Motors
Right Size the Motor
Motor efficiency plummets at <40% rated load
Premium Efficiency Motors
Good motor efficiency varies
from about 85%
( 1 HP) to 95% (>75 HP)
NEMA Premium Efficiency
motors are 1% to 3% basis
points more efficient than
baseline (EPACT 1992)

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

41

Transformers
Transformer Losses
Remove power from unused transformers
No load losses (NL)

Caused by the magnetizing current


to energize the core

Do not vary according to the loading


on the transformer

<0.5% of rating (for example,


roughly 125 watts on a 50 kVA
transformer)

Full load losses (FL)

Heat losses, or IR losses, in the


winding materials

Roughly 5x NL losses (600 watts on a 50 kVA transformer)

High-Efficiency Transformer

Paying a little more upfront ($400 to $4,000) leads to long term


savings (>$20,000 for a 1500 kVA transformer)

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

42

Compressed Air
Implementation

Load
(kWh)

Only use when there is no other option

Fix leaks

Right size

Use variable speed compressor motor drives

Peak
(kW)

Implement heat recovery


Use two-stage, lubricated or centrifugal

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

43

Compressed Air

Compressed Air energy cost for 6,000 hrs


at $0.10/kWh = $125/CFM
At 4 CFM/HP, a 250 HP compressor costs about $125,000 annually

Only use compressed air when it is absolutely


necessary!

If possible, switch to motors, mechanical actuators, and other means


to accomplish the same function

Leaks often account for 20% to 30% of compressor


output
A 1/32" leak in a 90 psi compressed air system would cost
approximately $185 annually

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

44

Compressed Air
Compressors operate at highest efficiency at full load
or off
Optimum controls results in big savings
For example, at 50% full-load flow, kW input varies from 51% to 83%.
Percent kW Input at Operating Capacity
for Lubricant-Injected Rotary Screw
% FullLoad Flow

Load/No-load
(5 gal/cfm)

Modulation

Variable
Displace

Variable
Speed

90%

95%

97%

92%

91%

80%

92%

95%

83%

81%

70%

85%

90%

78%

71%

60%

78%

85%

68%

61%

50%

72%

83%

63%

51%

40%

63%

80%

60%

42%

Source: Improving Compressed Air System Performance: A Sourcebook for Industry, DOE

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

45

Compressed Air
Variable speed is best applied to compressors that
operate primarily as trim units, or as single units with
loads below 75% to 80% demand
Below 85% loading, variable displacement units
become less efficient than variable speed, and are
very poor at loads below 50%

Reducing system pressure by 10 psi saves 8% to 10%


Use " diameter hose for >3 HP tools or >50' lengths

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

46

Compressed Air
Heat Recovery
Air-cooled compressors offer recovery efficiencies of
80% to 90%

Ambient atmospheric air is heated by passing it across the


systems aftercooler and lubricant cooler.
As a rule, approximately 50,000 British thermal units per hour
(Btuh) of energy is available for each 100 cfm of capacity (at
full-load).
Air temperatures of 30F to 40F above the cooling air inlet
temperature can be obtained.
Space heating or water heating.

Water-cooled compressors offer recovery efficiencies


of 50% to 60% for space heating only.

Limited to 130F

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

47

Compressed Air
Reciprocating air cooled compressor has lowest first cost, but is
inefficient
Spend a little more for a two-stage unit and achieve better efficiency
Lubricated compressors are often more efficient than a similar nonlubricated unit, but they contribute oil content to the system and may
impact the compressor air quality
Air Compressor Efficiency Benchmarks
Reciprocal

Rotary Screw

Centrifugal

Air
cooled

Water
cooled

Water
cooled

Lubricated

Lubricated

Nonlube

Units

SingleStage

SingleStage

TwoStage

SingleStage

Two-Stage

TwoStage

BHP per 100


CFM

26-32

25

19-22

23-26

20-22

20-26

22-27

kW per 100
CFM

22-27

21

16-18

19-22

17-18

17-22

18-22

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

48

<250 HP

Questline

Go to www.questline.com
Provided by:
Tech Resources
2025 Riverside Drive
Columbus, OH 43221
800-824-0488
mcarter@questline.com

This document was specifically prepared to aid Tech Resources clients that wish to inform their customers about available
energy efficient options that these customers may wish to consider. Any other use of this material (in whole or in part) is not
allowed without the expressed written consent of Tech Resources, Inc., 2025 Riverside Drive, Columbus, OH 43221.

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

49

Whats Next?
If you would like more information about the four strategies to increase cash flow,
contact your local Manufacturing Extension Partner.
Arizona Manufacturing Extension Partnership
California Manufacturing Technology Consulting
Maryland Technology Extension Service
Montana Manufacturing Extension Center
The Oklahoma Manufacturing Alliance
Rhode Island Manufacturing Extension Services
South Carolina Manufacturing Extension Partnership
Texas Manufacturing Assistance Center
University of Tennessee Center for Industrial Services
This document was specifically
prepared to aid Manufacturing
Extension Partnerships and their
customers. Any other use of this
material (in whole or in part) is not
allowed without the expressed written
consent of Tech Resources, Inc.,
2025 Riverside Drive, Columbus, OH
43221.

2009 Tech Resources, Inc.

West Virginia Manufacturing Extension Partnership

50

You might also like