Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ubermensch Vijecnica by KEVIN ROSS
Ubermensch Vijecnica by KEVIN ROSS
Ubermensch Vijecnica by KEVIN ROSS
the Ashes
national archives, copies of all newspapers, periodicals, and books published in Bosnia,
and the collections of the University of Sarajevo was set ablaze. Across the river, a piece
of shrapnel punched through Kanita Focak s living-room wall and struck her husband
Goldshmied in the stomach. The Faruks, Kanita and Goldshmied had met in the Sarajevo
Library. They were later married, and now were
seeing the library in a ball of flames from the
windows of their home.
up, he told Kanita.
mid-19th century they began great debates over the idea of the class struggle.
Contemporary analysis on the creative destruction cycle of the bermensch evolves
even further; Nietzsche expanded on this idea in Thus Spake Zarathustra (1883-85),
stressing that an ideal future society would need creators who were unafraid of
constructing a world amid the ashes of the former one.
bermensch, the creator and the destructor are working in a constant cycle. Whatever,
or whoever started this idea of creative-destruction, what has happened to the Vijenica
is summed up best by this concept of the bermensch, in that the library has overcame
many conflicts and out of the ashes of war and ethnic intolerance it has emerged stronger
and more resilient than ever before. The translation of Nietzsche s bermensch simply
Creative Destruction in Economics: Nietzsche, Sombart, Schumpeter. Hugo Reinert, Cambridge University & Erik
S. Reinert. Forthcoming in Backhaus, Jrgen and Wolfgang Drechsler (editors): Friedrich Nietzsche 1844-2000:
Economy and Society, Series The European Heritage in Economics and the Social Sciences, Boston, Kluwer.
2
IN PRINT: On Sherman and Creative Destruction in Atlanta by Nick Kahler. September 23, 2014
http://burnaway.org/sherman-creative-destruction-atlanta/
Very
Focak, a Catholic, was in the library when she met Goldschmied Faruk, a Muslim ten
years her senior who became her lover. When it rained, they met in the reading room;
when the sun shone, they met in the resplendent marble entranceway. Both their families
http://www.vijecnica.ba/
Impossible to turn the page SDDEUTSCHE ZEITUNG MUNICH BY FLORIAN HASSEL. TRANSLATED FROM GERMAN
BY ANTON BAER.
4
build the City Hall Vijenica they experienced what is called lightly, osnian
stubbornness . Such an enormous building had never been before seen in Sarajevo.
Neither had such power of a ruling monarchy ever expressed itself in such prominent
architecture. And the building site was in the exact location of the property of an old man
called Benderija. Old Man Benderija was a resident citizen of Sarajevo and had built his
home on the banks of the Miljacka River some years earlier. He did not want to allow the
builders to demolish his house and take his land away from him for any reason. The
house was his internal peace, he would not let his home go. The pleading took months,
the architects and the mayor bargained with Benderija, He still would not budge, and the
pressure from Vienna was building. After long negotiations, the stubborn man said that
he would give up his property only if he was compensated with a bag of golden coins,
and secondly, his house was to be moved brick by brick to the other side of the river. The
Mayor and the builders had no choice. They did exactly what the old man requested
reassembled brick by brick, timber by timber, tile by tile in 1895 to make way for the
construction of the Vijenica. In 1997 Inat Kua was turned into a lovely traditional
Bosnian restaurant.
Benderija
that
the
its construction.
submitted the preliminary design in 1891. Pak also had previously worked on other
buildings of great significance in Sarajevo, one being erijatska sudaka kola The Sharia
School) in the same pseudo-Moorish style of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. Pak did not
want to accept the request of Minister Benjamin Kalaj to make the City Hall a very large
http://www.inatkuca.ba/
Vije ica. Original Faade Elevation designed by Karl Pak. 1887. Later Modified by Alexander Wittek.
building because of the contextual site in which the building was to be built. Nevertheless
Pak came up with the triangular plan of the building, it s massing, it s central atrium,
and a wonderfully embellished faade and elevation drawings. However, his plan for
Vijenica was initially rejected after he refused to modify the intricate details of the
ornamentation to suit Kalaj. Construction was then turned over to Alexander Wittek, an
Austrian who acted as the primary architect during building and who was largely
responsible for decorative elements that we see today, he took over the plans that were
made by Pak and redesigned the ornamentation and made minor modifications to the
corner towers. In essence, the building went on to be constructed in the manner initially
conceived by Karl Pak. Under the watch of Alexander Wittek, the Vijenica began to
really take shape. His designs were inspired by the Cairo Mosque of Sultan Hasan II,
taking many cues from its red and yellow striped polychromy, the ornamented parapet,
and elaborate stone carved moldings.
It is
will
return
to
Sarajevo.
International
Chess
is not a surprising fate for an architect to be driven to madness by a building; Wittek died
in a lunatic asylum in Graz in 1894
http://dbpedia.org/page/Alexander_Wittek
iril s uncle
Dr. Francis Ivekovi and cousin Dr. John Broz were the creators of
the Croatian dictionaries. 7 iril finished elementary school and
secondary school in Varazdin and Zagreb, respectively. His uncle
iril Metod Ivekovi
1864 - 1933.
Croatian Architect.
Dr. Francis Ivekovi sent him to study at the Higher Trade School
in Vienna. In 1896 he was appointed rchitect of Divine Worship
and later designed the Dalmatian governor's office in Zadar . This
was the beginning of his most productive period when he spent a quarter century acting
as an architect, conservator, archaeologist, restorer, and finally as a photographer. In
1899 iril became a corresponding member of the Central Commission for the Study and
Maintenance of Historical and Artistic Monuments in Vienna. After the First World War and
the collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire, Zadar came under Venetian rule and in
1920 the architect moved to Zagreb. There he became a professor of architecture at the
Technical University. Ivekovi was the final architect to work on Vijenica and saw it
through to completion. He also designed the City
Hall in rko, a town in northern BosniaHerzegovina that sits on the southern banks of the
Sava River. The town hall in rko has striking
similarities to the Vijenica, giving an architectural
gesture to its capitol. iril Metod Ivekovi lived
iril Metod
The
Choteks, though noble in their own right, were not one of these families. Although
Sophie was a lady-in-waiting to the Archduchess Isabella, Duchess of Teschen, this did
not put her in dynastic rank to meet the approval of Franz Joseph. Deeply in love, Franz
Ferdinand refused to consider marrying anyone else and had to seek endorsements to be
able to legally marry his Bohemian bride. Pope Leo XIII, Tsar Nicholas II of Russia, and
the German Emperor Wilhelm II all made representations on his behalf to Emperor Franz
Joseph of Austria, arguing that the disagreement between Franz Joseph and Franz
Ferdinand was undermining the stability of the monarchy. The two were married in the
1900
Zkupy
at
Reichstadt,
now
province
of
spectators, drew his pistol, and at a distance of about five feet, fired twice into the open
car. Franz Ferdinand was hit in the neck and Sophie in the abdomen. Sophie said to her
http://www.zakupy.cz/
would
last
four-and-a-half
million
million
violent
revolution
in
the Ottoman Sultan that was known as the Great Builder of Sarajevo. He founded many
institutions including the Madrassa, many Mosques including the one that would later
become the Gazi Husrev-Beg Library, the Bezistan, and many bridges that cross the
Miljacka River. Gazi Husrev-Beg was also known as the greatest benefactor of Sarajevo
through what he bequeathed, his patronage, and his endowment. He devoted his entire
life and legacy to the building and urbanization of the city. Filled with noble love for the
common good and progress of the people he was entrusted with, and from whom he
descended, he unselfishly sacrificed his enormous wealth on the building of magnificent
structures for various purposes which transformed Sarajevo into the largest trading, craft,
cultural, educational, and military center at the crossroads of East and West. Before Gazi
Husrev-Beg there were no Christian Churches in Sarajevo.
Over
restored,
and
renovated
with
and
acquisitions
stretching
back
Muvekkit is cited as
using a rational approach, using various sources for instance, in oriental languages,
which up until now has been largely unheard of in the academia of osnia s past as most
records were of western accounts. Muvekkit published works in Zagreb, Belgrade, and
Sarajevo in his time and created a compendium that has not until recently received the
recognition it deserves. He even is writing in Turkish and refers to the Ottoman Empire
in his manuscripts as Occupied osnia , giving credence to his connectedness to his
homeland and its historical record. His account of events throughout the Balkans are
priceless and immeasurable. He scribes his accounts in the History of Bosnia through an
entire slew of battles, invasions, and peace treaties giving detailed accounts from an
objective eye. He ends in the late 18th century in the 4th and final volume, following with
a glossary, index, and references.9 Aside from his love of history and of Bosnia, Muvekkit
9
The chronicle of Muvekkit, Tari-I Bosna. Enveri Kadic. editor of Muvekkit Manuscripts. 1999
https://www.scribd.com/doc/123057171/Muvekkit-prikaz-knjige
A Muvekithana,
10
by
different
orchestrators
into
The Vijecnica was badly damaged during the ethnic conflict that tore apart Yugoslavia
following the collapse of the Berlin Wall. The musical score became associated with the
building and together they both gained notoriety as icons of survival. A 1992 picture
shows Vedran Smajlovic - The Cellist of Sarajevo - playing his instrument amid the
blackened ruins in tie and tail became a symbol of the tragedy of conflict. 11 The cellist
stayed in Sarajevo for the same reason as the night watchman from the Congo did, he
10
NBC News.com - Two Decades After Being Shelled, Sarajevo's Vijecnica Is Reborn. BY ALASTAIR
JAMIESON
11
On that hot August day in 1992, printed pages were flying around in flames, crossing the
Miljacka River and landing as ash in people s gardens.
As Nietzsche said,
Live
Dangerously! Build your cities on the slopes of Vesuvius! Send your ships into uncharted
seas! Live at war with your peers and yourselves! Be robbers and conquerors as long as
you cannot be rulers and possessors, you seekers of knowledge!
12
Library is indeed one great seeker of knowledge and has seen, lived through, and
survived war. Dr. Jahic s niece wrote him letters during the siege, she recalls,
My favorite letters were those I wrote to my uncle Mustafa. part from being one of the
rare family members from Bosnia who I really remembered, his stories were also unlike the
others; they werent strictly about the details, the pure water/milk/heating/shelter concerns
of those who were just surviving. From my grandmother, I would learn that he was saving
books old ones, ones written in unreadable Arabic letters. He and his wife, a doctor,
would leave their two infant children in the house (located at the first line of defense
between the Army of Bosnia and the Serbian army) to go about their duties. One saved
lives, or hoped to do so; the other went around the city carrying books and manuscripts
from one location to the other.
13
12
Nietzsche. The Gay Science: With a Prelude in German Rhymes and an Appendix of Songs. Cambridge
University Press, 2001.
13
KOSOVO 2.0 - LOST & FOUND: THE RESCUE OF SARAJEVOS OLDEST LIBRARY
BY SUMEJA TULIC - JANUARY 20, 2014
14
extinguishing the flames impossible, but braving a hail of sniper fire, librarians and a
dozen citizen volunteers formed a human chain to pass books out of the burning
building. Together, they carried some 100,000 books from the burning building, in spite
of 90% of the libraries archives being lost, this was
a
huge
accomplishment.
Bombarded
with
saved.
14
not have access to electricity and water all day, every day. The war was still ongoing.
They rigged up the machine to be able to run on two car batteries in the event of a power
outage. The Library cleaning staff would
run to the river constantly to bring back
water for the holding tanks attached to the
machine. When Mohamed arrived, they
asked his professional opinion how long
it would take to copy the books all 15,000
of them?
15
reading many of the books as he was working with them. In a Diary of Mustarfa Baseskja
in an entry from 1801, he remembers reading, I am going to tell you some things about
the city of Sarajevo, for as we know, what has been written endures and what has been
remembered fades.
In December of 1995 ill Clinton s voice came across the airwaves in Sarajevo saying,
Whatever their ethnic groups, the overwhelming majority of Bosnian citizens, and the
citizens of Croatia and Serbia want the same thing. They want to stop the slaughter, they
want to put an end to the violence and war, they want to give their children and
grandchildren the chance to lead a normal life. Today, Thank God, the voices of those people
have been heardfter nearly four years of two hundred fifty thousand people killed, two
million refugees, the Presidents of Bosnia, Croatia, and Serbia have reached a peace
agreement to end the war in Bosnia.
16
With the siege over, Dr. Hadiosmanovi returned to her home to find it had been
wrecked by Serbian soldiers. Her favorite dress was riddled with bullet holes. Almost
nothing remained intact. And yet, in a heap of books, she found the manuscript. The
very next day she returned Muvekkit's History of Bosnia to the Gazi Husrev-Beg Library
and presented it to Dr. Jehic. He was overwhelmed. 10,000 manuscripts and rare books
belonging to the Gazi Husrev-Beg library were saved during the siege of Sarajevo
15
16
Speech by President Bill Clinton on the Dayton Peace Agreement signed in Paris on December 14, 1995.
Another of
th
museum curator during World War II and even spent some time in Vienna for an expert
assessment.17 The book is under a tight lock and key somewhere in Sarajevo but no one
is privy to its real whereabouts except when it is revealed on rare occasions from time to
time only to prove its existence. An ABC correspondent did just that in a Sarajevo Special
17
http://www.haggadah.ba/
destructive".
destruction and destruction allowing for creativity. During the rise of the Vejinica from
the ashes as it was being restored, the building hosted
many open houses and exhibitions in which the
library became full of contemporary art, music and
wine.
18
19
Concert in the At iu
of Vije i a
ABC News. Nightline. Searching For Hope: The Sarajevo Haggadah. 1996.
On the Genealogy of Morality, or On the Genealogy of Morals, subtitled "A Polemic" 1887
legacy
is
worth
invigorated by the beautiful art and music installations that were exhibited against the
backdrop of the war-torn architecture. Upon completion The Vienna Philharmonic
Orchestra gave a concert at the Vijenica s Grand Opening in 2014. French President
Franois Hollande, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, and Austrian President Heinz
Fischer were in all attendance. Franz Welser-Mst conducted the orchestra playing
Emperor Quartet by Haydn and the Fate Song by rahms.20 Angela Merkel said that
the international community, after the general elections in Bosnia and Herzegovina, will
encourage the political process and that in light of the Berlin Conference, the Western
Balkans will be supported with assistance by the German government. There is still much
work to be carried out.
20
nine times
is
one
of
Smajo
the
key
iconic building, one of the most important objects from the legacy of the AustroHungarian period in our region."21 The architects said it took them time to hunt down
documents, photos, and details of the building in order to copy the original 19th century
pseudo-Moorish construction.
the building is
back, exactly the way it was before the Serb shelling destroyed it in 1992.
22
Smajo s
21
http://www.sarajevotimes.com/
The first Monograph on the Sarajevo City Hall Presented. DECEMBER 20, 2014
22
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/
Reconstruction of Sarajevo Library nearing end By ASSOCIATED PRESS
invisible during the time when the City Hall stood in ruins.
They were working hard
to reconstruct the intricate
details of all the fine
moldings and carvings of
the
library s
intricate
is
"For three
restoration
Nearly every piece of carved stone was damaged to some degree. Architects used electronic modeling to assist
in restoring the intricate details.
had to explore and search for this grandeur that you see."23 The pair worked continuously
from 1996 to 2008 to develop the entire project of City Hall. They collaborated during the
implementation phase of the project and both participated as supervisors.
One of the City Halls most recent achievements has been the first ever monograph,
published in 2014 by the Vijenica architects themselves, studio URBING. In cooperation
with the administration of the City of Sarajevo, URBING compiled the stunning work
Vijenica , signed by the authors closely related to the project of reconstruction of the
23
http://sarajevo2014.com
This years inners of recognitions and City of Saraje o of a ards - 06.04.2014.
architects
during
We visited a
that
have
some
documents, and finally we managed to find the original project of the construction of the
City Hall, from the period 1892 till 1896. The original three architects alone represented
Austria, Croatia, and the Chzech Republic; the original construction was adminstered
from Vienna which commissioned artisans and craftsman from numeerous additional
cities. The architects discovered that much of the origianal marble of the atrium detailing
was quarried in Macedonia. Thus, we were in possession of that vast and exclusive
material that says a lot about this building, and it was logical that put it all in a
monograph.
24
24
http://www.sarajevotimes.com/
This years inners of recognitions and City of Sarajevo of awards. DECEMBER 20, 2014
screenplay,
journals.
and
travel
on
the
25
in 2014.
of
Conferences
diplomacy
reconciliation.
on
international
and lectures on
the
Mulaomerovi. The award was received by Smajo s son Nedad who said, My Father
left behind a beautifully restored City Hall and many other valuable works of
architecture . Smajo Mulaomerovi died in 2011. Stressing satisfaction obtaining this
award, architect Ferhad Mulabegovi emphasized the fact that, unfortunately, during the
18 years of rebuilding Vijenica, many experts did not anticipate a happy ending. He
underlined that the construction of the City Hall was one of the most expensive and the
most monumental undertakings since the Austro-Hungarian rule. "We are pleased with
30 | bermensch Vije ica
the City Administration and 18 years of work, and if we managed to revive from ruins
the [genius loci] - spirit of that time using modern techniques, then we are all happy,"26
26
Sarajevo2014.com - This years inners of recognitions and City of Saraje o of a ards. 6.04.2014
Although the Vijenica has been fully restored, it is only being used
for its original purpose, as a City Hall. None of the National Library s holdings are there,
only politicians. Amra Resitbegovic is a Librarian employed by the National Library of
Bosnia-Herzegovina, which no longer exists. She says she continues to go to work every
day because she too has a duty to fulfil. She is not getting paid. She laments, We lost
colleagues in the war and we lost our status as the
National Library.
understand that. If they don t accept how important culture is for the next generation
and for normal life, the state of our library will remain as bad as the state of our
country.
27
27
Deutsche Welles. Bosnia-Herzegovina: The rescued books of Sarajevo | European Journal production
panoramic views of the city of Sarajevo, but also a symbol. This bermensch restoration
of the Vijenica Rathaus is perhaps the most important project in the post-war period in
Sarajevo and the Bosnian state.
monument of Bosnia and Herzegovina. For some it is a symbol of suffering but also of
the rise of the indestructibility of Sarajevo. And regarding the books
survived will forever be a momentum and provide a lasting legacy that will forever
endure. The books that perished will truly be lamented, but they are survived by a great
many others that have an even greater story waiting to be told. Perhaps a statement by
the night watchman Abbas Lutumba Husein sums it up best when he said, No matter
how you approach a book, the book accepts you.
Site Section. KEVIN ROSS LIKINS. Thesis Presentation of Balkan Reconciliation Centers that inspired this follow-up article. SCAD. 2011.
2.
Mula Mustafa Baeskija (1731 1809) Bosnian chronicler, diarist, poet, calligrapher, janissary..Pg. 21
3.
Gazi Husrev-Beg (1480 1541), Provincial Ottoman Governor of Bosnia, Patron, and
Great Builder of Sarajevo.Pg. 12
4.
5.
Archduke Franz Ferdinand (1863 1914), Heir to the throne of Austro Hungarian Empire.........Pg. 9
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
Alexander Wittek (1852 1894), Austrian Architect and Chess Master... Pg. 6
24.