Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Artigo Cientifico, Praticas Complementares e Quimioterapia
Artigo Cientifico, Praticas Complementares e Quimioterapia
Artigo Cientifico, Praticas Complementares e Quimioterapia
Background
an is the founder of The DoctorHealer Network in England (headquartered in London), is in private practice,
and works at a clinic and day hospital in Medford, New
Jersey. He is a wholistic psychiatrist whose range of treatment
blends elements from intuitive and spiritual awareness, spiritual
healing (e.g., Reiki and Therapeutic Touch), MBTs* (e.g., WHEE,
EFT ), chakra psychotherapies, transactional analysis, gestalt
therapy, hypnotherapy, meditation, imagery and relaxation (part
o f p s y c h on e u r o im m u n o log y ) , d r e am a n a ly s i s , a n d ot h e r
approaches to wellness.
Dan has taught this spectrum of methods internationally for
15 years to people who are involved in wholistic, intuitive, and
spiritual approaches to caring, health, and personal development. He believes that spiritual healing introduces subtle energy
medicine and spiritual awareness into integrative care and can
be appreciated best via experiential learning. He has also written
tapping the right and left sides of the body while reciting affirmations, as
described in the interview and at www.wholistichealingresearch.com/Articles/Selfheal.htm EMDR = Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing; stimulates the right and left sides of the body rhythmically to help the
brain reprocess traumatic experiences. EFT = Emotional Freedom Technique;
uses hand and finger tapping or pressing on acupoints on parts of the body,
w h i le r e pe at in g af fi rm a tio n s as se lf - h eal in g to r el iev e s tr e ss ; s ee
www.emofree.com for more information on this technique.
130
The Interview
Russ Mason: How would you define spiritual healing?
Dan J. Benor: I take the term spiritual healing from common
usage in the United Kingdom, where I lived and worked for 10
years. Other names for spiritual healing include psychic, psi,
mental (used for many years in the Index Medicus), faith, and
paranormal healing; biological psychokinesis; and distant mental
influence on living systems, to mention only a few.
I often refer to this simply as healing, but want to be clear
that I am not merely discussing healing on physical and psychological levels. I prefer the term spiritual healing because I find
that involvement in healing has opened meand many others
to a personal spiritual awareness.
For scientific purposes, spiritual healing is a systematic, purposeful intervention by one or more persons aiming to help
another living being (person, animal, plant, or other living system) to improve their conditions by means of focused intention,
hand contact, or movements of the hands near the body. Spiritual
healing is brought about without the use of conventional energetic, mechanical, or chemical interventions. Some healers attribute
spiritual healing to God, Christ, other higher powers, spirits,
universal or cosmic forces or energies; biological healing energies
or forces residing in the healer; psychokinesis (mind over matter); or self-healing powers or energies latent in the healee.
RM: How does the healing actually occur?
DJB: Healing occurs on many levels, including body, emotions, mind, relationships with other people and the environment, and spirit.
By the way, I am not promoting a religious belief, nor do I feel
my views are the only way of understanding healing. I respect
the views of others to hold their own explanations of healing.
There are two broad categories of healing. In the first, prayers
or meditation for the ill persons return to health are conducted
either by an individual or a group. The healer, or healers, may be
at the side of the healee or may be many miles away. The second
form of healing involves some variation of a laying-on of hands.
Healers place their hands either on or near the body and may
move them slowly or in sweeping fashion around the body.
131
S p ir itu a l h e a lin g w o r k s
w ell a s a c om plem ent to
m o s t o t h e r t h e r a p ie s a n d
m ay, in fact, be a part of
m any therapists interven tions e ve n w ithout th eir
awareness.
RM: Can you explain
what actually happens during spiritual healing?
D JB : H eale rs report that
several interpenetrating, subtle e ne rgy fie ld s su rrou nd
t he physical body. They
claim that the physical body
is an expression of the states
of these energy fields, each Dan J. Benor, M.D., Medford, New
Jersey.
of which is distinctly related
to an aspect of being (physical, emotion al, mental, and
spiritual). The fields are said to be hierarchically organized. The
emotional and mental fields can, therefore, also influence the
physical body.
These subtle energy fields extend to various distances from the
physical body. Though only a few sensitive people are able to
perceive these subtle energies as visual halos or auras of color
around the body, many people can sense them with their hands.
One has only to hold ones hands near each other and then move
them slowly apart and back together to sense these. About 90
percent of doctors and nurses I have instructed in workshops on
healing are able to perceive these, and 2575 percent of general
audiences can do so as well. (The lower percents are among academics and others who have difficulties in letting go of thinking
about what they are doing in order simply to do it or be with it
and let their bodies experience these energies.)
The human body is a very sensitive instrument for the perception of subtle energies. This presents problems of noise in perceiving and interpreting human reports. There is also a wide
variability in healers subjective experiences of perceiving and
directing energies. Most people who are gifted with healing are not
academically or research oriented. These problems have contributed to the difficulties of science in accepting reports of healers.
Though these bioenergy experiences may seem strange, early in the
1900s, Albert Einstein theorized that matter and energy are interchangeable, and quantum physics has amply verified this. Similarly, we can see that energy medicine and allopathic medicine simply
represent the two sides of Einsteins equation, E = mc2.
RM: Why is it difficult for many practitioners in allopathic
medicine to accept this kind of healing as a valid treatment
option?
DJB: Modern science went throug h a similar process with
quantum physics. Some of the observations of modern physics,
which relate to the energy side of the equation, are counterintuitive to conventional physics, and to everyday, common sense.
132
133
because I have to consult with parents, teachers, school coun selors, and pediatricians, as well as pharmacists and managed
care companies; and I can do all of this in addition to speaking
with the children.
I constantly sought to develop ways of providing psychotherapy along with the medications but was unable, within my limited
timeframe, to use the psychodynamic approaches I was taught as
a psychiatric resident. EMDR was a blessing to me as well as to
my clients. I was able to use EMDR with children who had posttraumatic stress disorders, because children respond very quickly
to this approachnot having barnacles on their problems like
adults do. I also used EMDR to de-stress myself!
As I usually see children with their parents, I also taught the
more stable parents to guide their children in doing the EMDR. If
the children were mature and responsible, I encouraged them to
practice the eye movements on their own, at home or at school,
whenever they were upset. This was very helpful, for instance,
with nightmares, when traumatic memories were stimulated by
current stresses or where excessive angers erupted.
I still was concerned, however, that there might be intense emotional releases during EMDR sessions at home, which could be
retraumatizing. I then learned to use the EFT of Gary Craig and
other meridian based therapy approaches. In EFT and related therapies, one taps or presses a finger at a series of acupuncture points
on the face, chest and hand, while reciting an affirmation. Because
EFT works more rapidly than EMDR and does not evoke intense
emotional releases, EFT can be used as a self-healing technique.
RM: How do the other physicians at the clinic and hospital
view your practice of EMDR and EFT?
DJB: I had difficulty introducing EFT in my work settings.
EMDR has an extensive research base to confirm its efficacy in
treating post-traumatic stress disorders. On the basis of my certification in EMDR, I was able to obtain official permission from
the administrators where I work to use this with their clients.
Because EFT has no research base, they would not grant me perm is sion to use it. I g ave this a hard think , then turne d it
around, and now call it an affirmation technique. No one has
faulted me for using affirmations in therapy and they never mind
what clients do with their hands on their own bodies while they
recite the affirmations.
134
RM: Tell us about the WHEE technique.
DJB: In an introductory workshop by Asha Nahoma Clinton
(on Seemorg Matrix Therapy), Asha observed that alternately
tapping the eyebrow points across the bridge of the nose while
reciting the affirmation works just as well as the entire series of
EFT points. So, ever-conscious of my time limitations, I immediately started e xp loring a hybrid approach which combined
aspects of EMDR and EFT. I call it the Wholistic Hybrid EMDR
and EFT, or WHEE. EMDR suggests the use of a butterfly hug
as one of its self-treatment interventions, particularly for children. The arms are crossed so that the patients hands rest on his
or her biceps muscles, and the patient alternates tapping on each
arm with his or her hands. Instead of tapping at the eyebrows, I
often have children and parents use the butterfly hug with the
affirmation. Many find the self-hug comforting in addition to
being highly effective in combination with the affirmation.
RM: Has it been successful?
DJB: Oh yes, WHEE has been hugely successful for several reasons. It takes a fraction of the time that EFT and EMDR require. It
allows for much greater flexibility in working on target problems
within the session because it is so rapid. If the child is successful but
the parent is not, or vice versa, there is plenty of time to explore
alternative target symptoms or alternative methods of addressing
them. It is better accepted and the compliance outside the therapy
room is much higher because of this simplicity. It works marvelously well and rapidly on pains and is excellent for allergies, though it
may take several days to be effective for the latter. Because it is so
simple to do, it is also tremendously empowering and satisfying.
RM: What kinds of affirmations that you use in the WHEE
technique?
DJB: A generic affirmation adapted from EFT is: Even though
I have this (anxiety, panic, fearone has to be specific about the
nature of the problem), I completely and totally love and accept
myself, and know that God loves and accepts me completely,
wholly, and unconditionally.
A patient may, of course, use whatever other strong positive
statements suits that patient best.
Prior to doing this self-healing technique, it is helpful to assess
how strong one feels the negative feeling that he or she wants to
address. The most commonly used gauge is the Subjective Units
of Distress Scale (SUDS), where one rates distress on a scale from
0 (not bothering you at all) to 10 (the worst it could possibly feel).
After tapping for a few minutes, the patient checks the SUDS
again. The number will usually go down. He or she repeats the
assessing and tapping until it is zero. Then one can build up a
positive affirmation to replace the negative, simply stating the
positive as one taps. If the numbers dont shift after one has
tapped, one can give oneself a gentle massage on the releasing
spot, located just below the collar bone at its midpoint. No affirmation is needed here. Then the block is released and the patient
returns to tapping.
135
RM: How does one learn to do this most effectively?
DJB: Any form of spiritual healingwhether it is Therapeutic Tou ch or Reiki or oth er approaches involves getting in
touch with your intuitive awareness. So studying and practicing under a mentor, or going through a training program, can
b e e n o r m o us l y h e lp f ul. P a r t o f th is p r oc e s s is e s p e c ia lly
important to a practitioner, because all of us have some murkiness in our pasts. But, in order to help others, its important to
know how to clear out this murkiness, so it doesnt get in the
w ay. For me, personally, I have to say that, for any kind of
interaction with another person, healing is a part of it.
RM: Thanks, Dan, for a really informative and enlightening
interview. My mom is feeling much better now.
n
DJB: Thank you, I enjoyed talking with you today.
To order reprints of this article, write to or call: Karen Ballen, ALTERNATIV E & COMPLEM ENTA RY TH ERAPIES, Mary Ann Liebert, Inc., 2
Madison Avenue, Larchmont, NY 10538-1961, (914) 834-3100.