Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 53

Prebiotic effect

in the healthy infant recent update

yvan.vandenplas@uzbrussel.be

Outline of presentation

1. Window of opportunity

2. GI flora composition in infants


3. Prebiotic OS and infections
4. Prebiotic OS and allergy
5. Prebiotic OS and gut immune function
6. Conclusion

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

The burden of suboptimal breastfeeding in the US: a pediatric cost analysis.


Bartick M. Pediatrics. 2010;125:e1048-56

Pediatric diseases for which the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality
reported risk ratios that favored breastfeeding:
necrotizing enterocolitis, otitis media, gastroenteritis,
hospitalization for lower respiratory tract infections,
atopic dermatitis, sudden infant death syndrome,
childhood asthma, childhood leukemia, type 1 diabetes mellitus,
and childhood obesity.
If 90% of US families could comply with medical recommendations to breastfeed
exclusively for 6 months, the US would save $13 billion per year and prevent an
excess 911 deaths, nearly all of which would be in infants
($10.5 billion and 741 deaths at 80% compliance).

Manado prebiotic 2011

The first few years in life is a


Window of Opportunity* for:
Physical growth and development

(e.g. weight & height gain)

Cognitive development
(e.g. semantic fluency, language, non-verbal learning,
attention, problem solving, IQ)
Emotion and social development
(e.g. emotional control, behavioral adaptation, social interaction)
*A period of time in which suitable action can achieve success (critical periods)

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

The first few years in life is a vulnerable period, in which a childs


immature immune system is constantly exposed to
over one billion of germs per year.
A child with a poor immune system will be more vulnerable to infection,
including respiratory tract infection, otitis media* and gastroenteritis
(causing diarrhea).
A child with frequent infections and diarrhea will miss the window of
opportunity to develop his full potential.

*otitis media = middle ear infection


5

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Ulijaszek S. Transdisciplinarity in the


study of undernutrition-infection
interactions.
Coll Antropol. 1997 Jun;21(1):3-15.

Manado prebiotic 2011

Key Takeout:
Infections can lead to appetite lose,
malabsorption and elevated metabolism of
energy and other nutrients

16-7-2011

Poor immune system affects the Window of Opportunity for:

Physical Growth and Development


Under-nutrition

has negative impact


on physical growth2
High
incidence of
diarrhea &
infection

Poor
immune system

Manado prebiotic 2011

Infection

& diarrhea lead to appetite


loss, nutrient loss, malabsorption and
increased metabolism of energy &
nutrients1,2

Undernutrition

Repeated diarrhea
impairs weight &
height gains, and
physical
development1

Window of Opportunity

16-7-2011

Poor immune system affects the Window of Opportunity for:

Cognitive Development

Infection & diarrhea lead to appetite loss,


nutrient loss, malabsorption and increased
metabolism of energy & nutrients1,2

High
incidence of
diarrhea &
infection

Poor
immune system

Under-nutrition

has negative impact


on cognitive
function2
Under-nutrition

Likely due to the compounded effects


of otitis media (middle ear infection) discomforts & poor hearing that
deter the learning process.

Repeated diarrhea
impairs cognitive
development1
Otitis media
affects language
and literacy skill
development3
Children with otitis
media have poorer
attention skills5
Window of Opportunity

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

First few years of life

= Window of Opportunity and also the Vulnerable Period


Poor immune system (with frequent infection & diarrhea)
affects the window of opportunity

??? How can a prebiotic combination


have a role in immune-modulation ???

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Outline of presentation
1. Window of opportunity

2. GI flora composition in infants


3. Prebiotic OS and infections
4. Prebiotic OS and allergy
5. Prebiotic OS and gut immune function
6. Conclusion

10

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

The GUT: A Complex Organ


60 -70% of immune cells

Surface of approximately
300m2
Manado prebiotic 2011

100 million neurons

100 trillion bacteria


Gut Microbiota
11

Intestinal Flora Development

prepartal

birth

Oral inoculation
with maternal
intestinal/vaginal
flora

4 days

20 days

4-6 months

Dietary influence

Breast-fed:
Bifidobacteria-dominated flora

aseptic

Weaning:
Transition to adult-like
flora

Diverse flora

Formula-fed:
Diverse flora
After Stark & Lee, 1982; Heine, 1998; Harmsen et al., 2000
Manado prebiotic 2011

Oligosaccharides in human milk


Br J Nutr 1999; Ped Clin N Am 2001; J Clin Gastroenterol 2004

13

Unique for human milk


Partially digested,
act as prebiotic stimulating bifidogenic flora
At least 130 different structures
Changing composition between mothers,
during lactation, during breastfeeding
Some resemble epithelial pathogen receptors

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

The Specific GOS/FOS Prebiotic Mixture:


Mimicking Size, Linkage, partly Building Blocks and Prebiotic function of HMOS

90 % scGOS:

low molecular weight (short chain)


Galacto-OligoSaccharides
(enzymatic from lactose)

[Gal( 1-]1- 4 3/4/6)Gal( 1-4)Glc


Lactose

10% lcFOS:

high molecular weight (long chain)


Fructo-OligoSaccharides
(fraction from chicory)

[Frc( 2-]n>8 1)Frc(

-1)Glc
Sucrose

Manado prebiotic 2011

Why is this Prebiotic Combination so Special ?


GOS
Comprise the most natural lactose-derived oligosaccharide
Showing the lowest incidence of side effects (gas production /
bloating) compared to similar short-chain oligosacharides
lcFOS
Comprise a more slowly fermentable substrate to allow
fermentation all over the full length of the large intestine

Extensive portfolio of experimental research and clinical studies


15

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Intestinal Flora
of Breast- and Formula-fed Infants
Formula-fed infant

100

% of total faecal micro-organisms

% of total faecal micro-organisms

Breast-fed infant
90

80
70
60
50
40

30
20

Bifidobacteria

90

E. coli
80

Bacteroides

70
60
50
40
30
20
10

10
0

100

10

15
Days

20

25

10

15
Days

20

25

According to Harmsen et al., 2000


16

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Reduction of potential pathogens


- Term Infants after 6 weeks-

Proportion of total bacteria [%]

18
16

Prebio Combination Formula (n=16)


Standard Formula (n=18)

p < 0.05

14
p < 0.05

12
10

p < 0.05

8
6
4
2
0

E. Coli

Clostridia

Eubacteria
Knol et al., 2003

17

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Distribution of the Lactobacillus Species (6 Weeks)

Breast-fed
Manado prebiotic 2011

scGOS/lcFOS
Formula

Standard
formula
Haarman. M & J. Knol. 2005. AEM (72): 2359

Distribution of the Bifidobacterium Species (6 weeks)

Breast-fed

Manado prebiotic 2011

scGOS/lcFOS
Formula

Standard
formula
Haarman. M & J. Knol. 2005 AEM (71):2318

Intestinal Flora Development

prepartal

birth

Oral inoculation
with maternal
intestinal/vaginal
flora

4 days

20 days

4-6 months

Dietary influence

Breast-fed:
Bifidobacteria-dominated flora

aseptic

Weaning:
Transition to adult-like
flora

Diverse flora

GOS/FOS Formula-fed:
Bifidobacteria-dominated flora
Manado prebiotic 2011

Effect of a whey-predominant starter formula containing


LCPUFAs and oligosaccharides (FOS/GOS) on GI comfort
Vivatvakin B. Asia Pac J Clin Nutr. 2010;19:473-80

Single-centre, DBPCR trial in full-term infants (n=144)


1 to 4 months old
Group of exclusively breast-fed infants: reference (n=80)

Hard stools
Soft stools
% bifidobacteria

Experimental
7.5
82.3
78.1

Control
0.7 %
90.8 %
63.7

BF

p
p<0.001
p<0.05

74.3

Gastric transit time


59.6
61.4
55.9
Intestinal transit time (data not shown) closer to that of the breast-fed group.
Growth parameter values were similar for all groups.
Manado prebiotic 2011

Effect of a milk formula with prebiotics on the intestinal microbiota


of infants after an antibiotic treatment.
Brunser O. Pediatr Res. 2006;59:451-6

RDBPC clinical trial, 140 infants (1-2 years)


after a 1-wk amoxicillin (50 mg/kg/d) for acute bronchitis
3 weeks; >500 mL/day formula with prebiotics
(Prebio 1 70/30 inulin/FOS; 4.5 g/L) or control
Fecal samples:
day -7 (beginning AB)
day 0 (end of AB / before formula)
day 7 and day 21
fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) and flow cytometry
Amoxicillin total fecal bacteria (<.00001) but E. coli (<0.02)
Bifidobacteria
prebiotic
control
Day 0 8.17 + 1.46 8.22 + 1.24
Day 7 8.54 + 1.20 7.95 + 1.54
0.014
NS
Lactobacilli
similar tendency // other bacteria unaffected
22

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

A randomized, double-blind, controlled trial of the effect of prebiotic


oligosaccharides on enteral tolerance in preterm infants (ISRCTN77444690).
Modi N. Pediatr Res. 2010;68:440-5.

After covariate adjustment,


significant benefit from trial formula in principal secondary outcome
(proportion of time between birth and 28 d/discharge that a
total milk intake of 150 mL/kg/d was tolerated)

with increasing infant immaturity


(2.9% improved tolerance for a baby born at 28-wk gestation and
9.9% at 26-wk gestation; p < 0.001)

but decreased or no benefit in babies >31-wk gestation.


Prebiotic supplementation appears safe
and may benefit enteral tolerance in the most immature infants.

Manado prebiotic 2011

A specific prebiotic mixture added to starting infant formula has


long-lasting bifidogenic effects.
Salvini FJ. Nutr. 2011 (in press)

Prebiotic supplementation resulted in


more fecal bifidobacteria (P < 0.0001)
and lactobacilli (P = 0.0044)
compared with the placebo group.
These differences between the groups
were maintained during the
second half of the first year
without any prebiotic supplementation.

Manado prebiotic 2011

Outline of presentation
1. Window of opportunity

2. GI flora composition in infants


3. Prebiotic OS and infections
4. Prebiotic OS and allergy
5. Prebiotic OS and gut immune function
6. Conclusion

25

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Reduction of infections during the first 12 months of life


(intervention during the first 6 months of life)
overall infections

50

GIT-infections

URTI
Standard (n = 104)
Prebio Combination (n=102)

Standard (n = 104)
Prebio Combination (n=102)

Standard (n = 104)
Prebio Combination (n=102)

50

50

40

40

n=47

40
P < 0.01

30
20

30
20

n=21

10

10

30

n=30
P = 0.07

n=14

20
10
n=4

P = 0.18

n=1

0
Babies with 1 infection episode

0
Babies with 1 URTI episode

Babies with 1 GITI episode

Arslanoglu et al. (2007) J Nutr 137: 2420-2424


26

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Reduction of infections during the first 12 months of life


(intervention during the first 6 months of life)
recurrent URTI

diarrhea

50

Standard (n = 145)
Prebio Combination (n=136)

Standard (n = 145)
Prebio Combination (n=136)

50

antibiotic courses
Standardl (n = 145)
Prebio Combination (n=136)

50
n=49

40

40

40

P < 0.05

30

n=34

P < 0.05

30

n=35

P < 0.05

30
n=30

20

20

20
n=19

n=17

10

10

10

Babies with 1 diarrhea episode

Babies with > 3 URTI episodes

Babies with >2 antibiotocs courses

prebiotics 2010

Bruzzese et al. (2006) JPGN 42: E95


27

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Reduction of infections during the first 24 months of life


(intervention during the first 6 months of life)

Overall # URTI epidsodes


per child

Overall # infection
episodes per child

Standard (n = 68)
Prebio Combination (n=66)
5.9

Standard (n = 68)
Prebio Combination (n=66)

Overall # antiobiotic
prescriptions per child

Standard (n = 68)
Oligosaccharide
Prebio
Combination (n=66)
Mixture (n=66)

P < 0.05

P < 0.01

3.3

P < 0.01

3
2.7

2.1

2
1.8

Arslanoglu et al. (2008) J Nutr 138 : 1091-1095


28

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Enteral supplementation with oligosaccharides decrease


serious infectious morbidity in preterm infants
Westerbeek 2010, AJCN 91 (3): 679-686

Manado prebiotic 2011

Outline of presentation
1. Window of opportunity

2. GI flora composition in infants


3. Prebiotic OS and infections
4. Prebiotic OS and allergy
5. Prebiotic OS and gut immune function
6. Conclusion

30

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Microflora and Development of Atopy


Analysis of intestinal flora of 76 infants at high risk of atopy at 3
weeks and 3 months of life
Infants grouped at age of 12 months as atopic if at least one
positive skin prick test
Colonisation with
Bifidobacteria at 3 weeks

Atopic

Non-atopic

180 x

Clostridia at 3 weeks

9.3 x

Ratio Bifidobacteria to Clostridia

107
107

610 x 107

P
< 0.11

3.3 x 107

< 0.05

= 0.03

Kalliomki et al., 2001

Relation between intestinal microflora and maturation of


human immunity to a non-atopic mode?
31

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

A mixture of prebiotic oligosaccharides reduces the incidence of


atopic dermatitis during the first six months of age.
Moro G. Arch Dis Child. 2006;91:814-9

Manado prebiotic 2011

36
p=0.014

30

P<0.001

24
18
12

23.1%
mean
(95% CI)

9.8%

6
0

mean
(95% CI)

Standard
(n=24/104)

Prebiotic
(n=10/102)

Bifodobacteria count (log cfu/g stool)

cumulative incidence of atopic dermatitis

Atopic Dermatitis and fecal bifidobacteria


in high-atopy risk Infants at age 6 months

18
15
12

P<0.001

10.28
8.65

median (IQR)

median (IQR)

3
0

Standard
(n=44)

Prebiotic
(n=50)

Moro G et al. (2006) Arch Dis Child 91: 814-819


33

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

The protective effect of reduction of atopic dermatitis


lasts beyond the intervention period
30
p < 0.05

Cumulative incidence of
atopic dermatitis (%)

Scored by SCORAD index

20

HA formula with
GOS/lcFOS
(n=68)

25.0%

Control
HA formula
(n=66)

10

12.1%

0
Arslanoglu et al., 2007

Reduced incidence of atopic dermatitis during 24 months follow-up


of infants at risk of developing an allergy
after 6 months feeding a GOS/lcFOS supplemented HA formula
Manado prebiotic 2011

Reduction of further symptoms


20

20
p < 0.05

HA formula with
GOS/lcFOS (n=68)

10

Incidence [%]

Incidence [%]

p < 0.05

Control
HA formula
(n=66)

6.3%

HA formula with
GOS/lcFOS (n=68)

10

17.6%

Control
HA formula
(n=66)

0.0%

11.8%

Bronchial symptoms

Acute Allergic Cutaneous reactions

Arslanoglu, Moro et al 2007

Reduced incidence of further symptoms during 24 months follow-up


of infants at risk of developing an allergy
fed 6 months with a GOS/lcFOS supplemented HA formula
35

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Reduced occurrence of early atopic dermatitis because of immunoactive


prebiotics among low-atopy-risk infants.
Grber C. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2010;126:791-7

Study population

1187 healthy term infants without family history of atopy


1130 infants intention-to-treat analysis
IMMUNOFORTIS+ : 414
control:
416
Breastfeeding:
300
835 infants per protocol
IMMUNOFORTIS+ : 292
control:
300
breastfeeding:
243

Manado prebiotic 2011

Reduced occurrence of early atopic dermatitis because of immunoactive


prebiotics among low-atopy-risk infants.
Grber C. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2010;126:791-7

Results
Safety of IMMUNOFORTIS

Safety confirmed
Febrile episodes
Lower in IMMUNOFORTIS + group at 6 months
No difference at 12 months
Low incidence in both groups
Dilution effect of IMMUNOFORTIS +
during 2nd half year of life

Manado prebiotic 2011

Reduced occurrence of early atopic dermatitis because of immunoactive


prebiotics among low-atopy-risk infants.
Grber C. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2010;126:791-7

Results

Atopic dermatitis
At 12 months lower incidence of AD

In control group:
earlier occurrence of AD

Manado prebiotic 2011

Synbiotics prevent asthma-like symptoms in infants with atopic dermatitis


van der Aa LB. Allergy 2011;66:170-7

Manado prebiotic 2011

Outline of presentation
1. Window of opportunity

2. GI flora composition in infants


3. Prebiotic OS and infections
4. Prebiotic OS and allergy
5. Prebiotic OS and gut immune function
6. Conclusion

40

Manado prebiotic 2011

16-7-2011

Alterations of bacterial communities (Dysbiosis) is


associated with diseases (IBD, IBS, allergy, obesity, ...)

Manado prebiotic 2011

Round et al Nature Rev Immunol, 2009; 9: 313-323

Bacteria Support Gut Barrier and Immune Function


Gut microbiota help support gut barrier function:
Mucin production
Permeability
Gut microflora help support the adaptive immune response:
Generate IgA activity (humoral)
Balance in T helper cell subclasses (cellular)

Manado prebiotic 2011

Composition and function of the Intestinal Flora


Health promoting functions

Harmful/pathogenic effects
Production of
toxins.
Diarrhoea /
obstipation
Infections
Liver damage
Cancer
Encephalopathy

Production of
carcinogens
Intestinal
putrefaction

Ps-Aeruginosa

Proteus

Inhibition of
growth of
exogenous and/or
harmful bacteria

Staphylococci

Clostridia
Veillonellae

Enterococci
E. coli
Lactobacilli

Streptococci
Eubacteria
Bifidobacteria

Bacteroides

Stimulation of
immune functions
Aid in digestion
and/or absorption
of food
ingredients/
minerals
Synthesis of
vitamins

11
Gibson, GR & Roberfroid, MB; 1994
43

Manado prebiotic 2011

Number/g faeces Log 10 scale

16-7-2011

Fecal secretory IgA is increased in healthy infants who receive a


formula with GOS/lcFOS
PAMJ Scholtens. J Nutr 2008;138:1141-7
Fecal sIgA
at age wk 8 and wk 26 of life
mg/g wet feces

2
1,6
P < 0.001

1,2
0,8
0,4
0

44

wk

wk

Standard (n=24)
Manado prebiotic
prebiotics
2010 2011

wk

wk

12

wk

16

wk

20

wk

26

Prebio Combination (n=22)

Reference (n=31)

16-7-2011

Outline of presentation
1. Window of opportunity

2. GI flora composition in infants


3. Prebiotic OS and infections
4. Prebiotic OS and allergy
5. Prebiotic OS and gut immune function
6. Conclusion

45

Manado prebiotic
prebiotics
2010 2011

16-7-2011

Microbiota

Inflammation

46

Manado prebiotic
prebiotics
2010 2011

Immune system

16-7-2011

SUPPLEMENTATION OF INFANT FORMULA


WITH PROBIOTICS AND/OR PREBIOTICS: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW
AND COMMENT BY THE ESPGHAN COMMITTEE ON NUTRITION
ESPGHAN Committee on Nutrition: C. Braegger, A. Chmielewska, T. Decsi; S. Kolacek,
W. Mihatsch, L. Moreno, M. Piecik; J. Puntis, R. Shamir, H. Szajewska, D. Turck, J. van Goudoever.
JPGN 2011;52:238-50

Based on this review, available scientific data suggest that the


administration of probiotic- and/or prebiotic-supplemented formula
to healthy infants is safe with regards to growth and adverse effects.
The safety and clinical effects of one product should not be
extrapolated to other products.

Manado prebiotic 2011

Prebiotics in infant nutrition


Effect on GI flora composition and development
Effect on GI metabolites (pH, SCFA)
Prevention of adhesion of pathogens
Tolerance and safety
Induction of specific and unspecific immune response
and maturation of immune system

Reducing infections and allergic manifestations


Concept of Immune-Programming

Prebiotics are not generic / GOS/lcFOS is specific


48

Manado prebiotic
prebiotics
2010 2011

16-7-2011

Cost-effectiveness model for a specific mixture of prebiotics in The Netherlands.


Lenoir-Wijnkoop I. Eur J Health Econ. 2010

Infant formula with prebiotics (IMMUNOFORTIS())


additional cost of 51 /year
increase in Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALY) of 0.108,
when compared with no prebiotics.
Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of 472 .
This study shows that the favourable health benefit of the use of a
specific mixture of prebiotics results in positive short- and long-term
health economic benefits.
In addition, this study demonstrates that the use of infant formula with
a specific mixture of prebiotics is a highly cost-effective way of
preventing atopic dermatitis in The Netherlands.
Manado prebiotic 2011

Probiotics and prebiotics in pediatrics.


Thomas DW. Pediatrics. 2010;126:1217-31

Prebiotics are supplements or foods that contain a nondigestible food


ingredient that selectively stimulates the favorable growth
and/or activity of indigenous probiotic bacteria.
Human milk contains substantial quantities of prebiotics.
there may be some long-term benefit of prebiotics for the
prevention of atopic eczema and common infections in healthy infants.

Confirmatory well-designed clinical research studies are necessary.

Manado prebiotic 2011

MY FOOD MATTERS,
THANK YOU!

51

Manado prebiotic 2011

Manado prebiotic 2011

The combination of GOS/lcFOS induces


a beneficial immunoglobulin profile
in infants (age 6 months) at high risk for allergy
Total IgE

CMP-specific IgG1

Data represent individual


results and median of
the placebo group (n=43) and
the GOS/lcFOS group (n=41)
** p<0.01; * p<0.05
Standard
HA formula
(n=35)

HA formula
with GOS/lcFOS
(n=33)

Standard
HA formula
(n=35)

HA formula
with GOS/lcFOS
(n=41)

Van Hoffen et al., 2008

The serum samples are from a subgroup of the Moro-Arslanoglu study

53

Manado prebiotic
prebiotics
2010 2011

total IgE, IgG1, IgG2 and IgG3, ~ no effect on IgG4


CMP-specific IgG1
DTP-specific Ig levels were not affected !
(hexavac vaccination was at age 3 months)

16-7-2011

You might also like