Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Affirmative Action Quotas Are Outdated
Affirmative Action Quotas Are Outdated
Affirmative Action Quotas Are Outdated
Quotas are not only unfair, but extremely expensive for our economy.
The State Department is finding out how unfair and complicated quotas can
be. It has tried, in recent years, to help equalize their work force by
hiring more minorities and lowering its original standards. In an effort
to recruit black males, the State Department "established a 'near pass'
category for blacks" (Gedda, 1996, p. A25). This policy allowed blacks who
did not pass their written examinations to be chosen over whites who had
higher percentages on their test. From this policy imposed by the State
Department has come a lawsuit by a white male on the basis of reverse
discrimination.
While the State Department continues its troubles with quotas, our
economy also suffers. A 1993 article in the National Review stated that "
in 1991 the direct and indirect cost of quotas...amounted to between $112
and $115 billion. While the 'opportunity cost'...amounted to at least 4
percent of 1991 GNP (Counting Cost, 1993, p. 18). Another example of
expensive Affirmative Action is being felt by the government itself (which,
in essence, is the tax payer). Congress examined student loan defaults
across the nation. Their answer to the problem was to cut federal loans to
"colleges whose students tended to default. However, 'historically black
colleges and universities are exempted,'...creating a minority right to
default" (Roberts & Stratton, 1995, p. 44). Who gets to pay for the
defaulted loans by the black colleges? The American tax payer-both black
and white.