Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2015 Minnesota SPJ Page One Program
2015 Minnesota SPJ Page One Program
of the
Society of Professional Journalists
presents:
Chris Newmarker
MNSPJ Chapter President
Student Scholarships
President's Award
Keynote
Gretchen Morgenson
Assistant business and financial editor
The New York Times
The Peter S. Popovich Award is given by the board of the Minnesota Society of
Professional Journalists annually to the person or organization that exemplifies the fight for First Amendment rights.
The award, MN SPJs most prestigious, honors the life of Peter Popovich, a MN
legislator, jurist, and tireless advocate for First Amendment rights.
Week in and week out, James Eli Shiffer's column in the Star Tribune, called
Full Disclosure, brings forth important information and insights on open
government and the public's right to know. Shiffer exposes government secrecy
and threats to freedom of information on topics such as the Department of
Corrections banning cameras in prisons. That ban, he eloquently argues,
"means that the nearly 10,000 inmates of Minnesota prisons will recede even
further from public view, their faces all but invisible."
As an editor for the newspaper, Shiffer has also helped reporters use records to
hold government agencies accountable for their actions. He is the team leader
behind Brandon Stahl's continuing coverage of child protection failures -stories that have led to substantial reforms -- and Jennifer Bjorhuss
investigation of the Iron Range Resources and Rehabilitation Board.
"James is the Star Tribune's most tireless advocate for access to government
records, especially the ones public entities would rather we not see or know
about," said Eric Wieffering, the Star Tribune's assistant managing editor for
news. "Time and again he helps citizens understand what they have the right to
know and, just as importantly, how the government or private interests have
restricted their access to information that should be public."
Keynote Speaker
Awards Presentation
We ask all winners, or a representative from the winning news outlet, to come
forward to accept their awards during the presentation.
Duplicate awards are available for purchase from MNSPJ. If you would like to
order a duplicate plaque or certificate, please contact us by
email at minnesota.spj@gmail.com.
Congratulations to all of the award winners!
Newspapers
Spot News
Spot News
"He was quiet and Details emerge in fatal West Duluth attack"
Judge's comments: A well-done portrait ofa misfit who lost it and killed randomly. Pluses: the
mental health component, comments from the neighbors, the store owners/patrons; good use of
statistics for perspective. For both the portrait and the straight-news story, a lot ofinformation
had to be gathered in a breaking-news situation.
Second Place: Jana Hollingsworth, Duluth News Tribune
Feature
Judge's comments: Very interesting feature topic, the pace ofthe story was well executed and
the quality ofwriting was excellent.
Second Place: Laurie Hertzel, Star Tribune
Feature
Judge's comments: Great capture ofmany voices relating the same story at the same time, with
effective insertion offacts and outside influences without imposing on the story.
Second Place: Nate Gotlieb, The Free Press
Enterprise/In-Depth
Judge's comments: Very definitive story on a complex issue. Very detailed. The reporters
scoured all the research.
Second Place: Richard Chin, St. Paul Pioneer Press
"Our Heroes"
Third Place: Chris Serres, Star Tribune
"Unchecked Care"
Enterprise/In-Depth
Judge's comments: Kirsti Marohn and David Unze have woven together a remarkable series by
turns haunting and poignant. Through deeply reported personal stories, they reveal the
breadth ofthe crisis facing Americas veterans. An important subject and a model series,
beautifully written and executed.
Second Place: John Lundy, Tom Olsen, Duluth News Tribune
Investigative
Judge's comments: A quick, sharp lead pulls the reader into this detailed story. It took a lot of
work to piece together this complex puzzle.
Second Place: Jesse Marx, Allie Conti, City Pages
"American Hustle
"
Investigative
Judge's comments: This is a huge amount ofresearch with very readable details that enhanced
the overall issues. Mind-boggling data on highest-paid board directors is graphed out in a very
accessible format. Starting offwith Robert Millers situation gives us an immediate way of
relating to the topic. This is a very compelling package at a time when income inequity is
reported regularly nationwide.
Second Place: Kirsti Marohn, St. Cloud Times
Business
Judge's comments: Puts a face on a painful phenomenon, that I'm sure a lot ofpeople think is
apocryphal.
Second Place: Jim Spencer, Star Tribune
Business
Judge's comments: What does it take to commission a new skyscraper for a big city? More than
many might imagine, as this deep dive into the anatomy ofhigh-rise office construction makes
clear. Smart layout, clever cover art, deft use ofgraphics all help to show -- not just tell -what's going on or not going on on the Twin Cities skyline.
Second Place: Michelle Miron, St. Croix Valley Lowdown
Sports Story
Judge's comments: This story made me feel like I was right there in the middle ofeverything. I
learned a lot and was entertained at the same time. Very nice work.
Second Place: Andy Greder, St. Paul Pioneer Press
Sports Story
Judge's comments: I loved the intensity ofthis story. I could feel everything, from the
excitement to the confusion to the thrill ofvictory. Very nicely done.
Second Place: Michelle Miron, St. Croix Valley Lowdown
"Crackerjack Lumberjack"
Third Place: Roger Bergerson, Park Bugle
"The man who put the ice in the fairgrounds Coliseum reminisces"
Judge's comments: Chris Riemenschneider takes the reader on the road with Minnesota
musicians in this piece about Trampled by Turtles and the music scene. He enriches and
expands the story by layering candid conversation with the band members as well as the crew,
humanizing the effort ofmaking music and a living simultaneously. Distinctive photography
supports the reporter's illustration ofvarious gigs and the band's travels. Readers are also
clearly directed to a photo gallery and video. A great example ofcontemporary storytelling.
Second Place: Amy Carlson Gustafson, St. Paul Pioneer Press
Judge's comments: This is an intriguing and compelling look at one womans faith journey and
how she expanded her vision to include others. The growth ofthe radio program and getting a
National Humanities Medal shows that her vibe resonates with the public.
Second Place: Michelle Miron, Forest Lake Lowdown
Column
Column
Judge's comments: Clever and breezy. It blew me away. Manages to capture years ofevents,
good and bad, in a few hundred words leaving behind a memorable story well-told.
Second Place: Jennifer Koski, Post-Bulletin
Editorial
Judge's comments: The fairest way to judge was to consider only the first editorial, even though
I found the entire series compelling. Very well written, filled with stark facts and picturepainting details that tell the story and no doubt inspired action to fix Indian schools in
Minnesota.
Second Place: Pat Effenberger, St. Paul Pioneer Press
Editorial
Judge's comments: This is an outstanding delineation ofgovernment meetings and how they
more and more are closed to the public that the government officials serve. The editorial is
Government Service 101 for elected officials, and a rebuke to lenient lawyers whose attitude
is Its OK to discuss this in private. A signed editorial is to be commended and sets an
example ofthe kind ofresponsible transparency called for in the editorial. Kudos.
Second Place: Joe Spear, The Free Press
Judge's comments: Very creative way to lay out the graphics and really depict what is going on
in the piece.
Second Place: Jake Schreiber, Finance & Commerce
Page Design
All Newspapers
First Place: Derek Simmons, Star Tribune
"May 21: Super Bowl 2018 announcement, Sports cover"
Judge's comment: What a fun sports front -- especially for a May newspaper. This view of
frozen tundra ... wait, that's the wrong team ... oficy midwinter must have been particularly
eye-catching in May. Smart idea to play the rest ofthe page simple to keep the focus on the
illustration.
Second Place: Ben Ramsden, Kim Johnson, Clare Kennedy, Mark Reilly, Minneapolis/St.
Paul Business Journal
Headlines
Judge's comments: This entry shows skill at a variety oftypes ofheadlines: the serious
headline for a large project about a tragedy that resulted in the death ofa child, a light
headline on a story about an out-of-place hummingbird, and a bright headline, despite an
extremely tight count, on a "talker" ofa story about the NYT's 50-state Thanksgiving feature.
Second Place: Tim Whitecotton, St. Paul Pioneer Press
Headlines
Judge's comments: Excellent play on words, very fitting for the story.
Best Issue
Judge's comments: Lots to read. Definitely a two-cups-of-coffee Sunday paper. Maybe a three.
Feature on the dangers ofATV riding, especially on kids, must've surely sparked conversation
all over the state. But the stories about millennials lack ofphone skills, VA clinic irregularities,
and the economic impact ofMayo Clinic expansion made for a compelling front page. Inside
piece on the Northstar line another worthy read. And ofcourse enough U ofM Gopher
coverage to satisfy the most rabid fan.
Best Issue
Judge's comments: Crisp layout. Crystal clear photograph. Clever graphics. But the Oct. 10
issue isn't just pretty. Lead story on latter-day power broker Louis Jambois ofthe St. Paul Port
Authority offered a deep nuanced look at how the subject makes important decisions in ways
that may seem mysterious to the public he serves. An impressive forceful product.
Magazines
Magazine
First Place: Doug Hennes, St. Thomas Magazine
"Malone: A Priest in Full"
Judge's comments: This piece gets to the heart ofwho John Malone is and has always been. A
good profile story should be able to explain why a person chooses to do what he or she does,
and this nailed it. It was a well-rounded reporting piece, which included interviews with
family, friends, and peers, nestled in with smart anecdotes that showed (not told) what the
subject is about. The piece was an enjoyable read, and brought to light someone who clearly
deserves the recognition. The photographs were stunning as well and the one ofhim holding
the Groucho glasses just added that extra humorous detail to remind readers he is no ordinary
priest.
Second Place: Joanna Takes, Woodworker's Journal
Magazine
First Place: Burl Gilyard, Twin Cities Business Magazine
"Banking on Minneapolis"
Judge's comments: A well-written story with reporting that incorporates all relevant parties.
The strong lead provides a clear visual, the writing is crisp and clear, the quotes add
dimension. The piece includes sidebars that bring added context to the reader's understanding
ofthe story.
Second Place: Tad Simons, Twin Cities Business Magazine
"Blue Note"
Third Place: Jennifer Koski, Steve Lange, Lena Valenty, Rochester Magazine
"Life Lessons, Olympics Style"
Best Department
Magazine
First Place: Jennifer Koski, Rochester Magazine
"Random Rochesterite"
Judge's comments: The questions are clever and fun, and the subjects are deserving. This is a
fun read. It reminded me that everybody has a story to tell.
Best Column
Magazine
First Place: Steve Lange, Rochester Magazine
"Oddchester"
Judge's comments: This column is real, honest, quirky and moves gracefully without trying.
Second Place: Jennifer Koski, Rochester Magazine
Best Cover
Magazine
First Place: Dana Croatt, Minnesota Parent
"Birthday Bliss"
Judge's comments: The design and cover lines give a mom many reasons to purchase this issue
or open up and read ifa subscriber solely based on the cover. Right offthe bat it promises to
help readers with three main struggles a mom goes through: Getting the kids to school on
time, knowing what to do in case her child is every bullied, and throwing a child the best
birthday bash she can dream of. The use ofcolors is eye-grabbing, and it doesn't hurt that the
cover model is adorable. I also enjoyed reading a tidbit about her, making the issue feel more
personal, as ifshe is someone growing up in my neighborhood.
Second Place: Twin Cities Business
Magazine
First Place: Sara Klomp, Mike Ekern, St. Thomas Magazine
"Immigrant Impact"
Judge's comments: Beautifully laid out and told through visuals, very moving.
Second Place: Jamie Klemmensen, Ken Klotzbach, Rochester Magazine
Best Issue
Magazine
First Place: Twin Cities Business
"November edition"
Judge's comments: Starting with the look and feel ofthe issue, the cover design is fantastic and
I appreciate the use ofwhite space and variety in layouts and fonts, making it easy to read one
page to the next. The use ofinfographics and illustrations are smart. It also offers a great
variety ofcontent with catchy headlines, and topics are ofboth local importance but does a
nice job oftying it to national significance (and vice versa). Overall, an enjoyable and
informative read.
Second Place: Rochester Magazine
"March 1, 2014"
Third Place: Brian Brown, St. Thomas Magazine
"Fall 2014 edition"
Television
Spot/Breaking News
Spot/Breaking News
Judge's comments: A compelling and unnerving story, with 911 recordings, photos and
interviews woven effectively throughout. A viewer service.
Second Place: Boyd Huppert, KARE
"Return to Hanoi
Third Place: Devin Bartolotta, Chuck Sibley, KTTC-TV
"No takers for Southeast Minnesota town's free residential lot program"
"
Feature
Judge's comments: This is one ofthe sweetest, quietest broadcast features I've ever seen. It took
a simple story and made is something more, an ode to those moments in life and those special
people who come along too infrequently. There were other strong features in this field, but this
one stands out by the way the journalists stood back and let the story flow on its own.
Second Place: Adrienne Broaddus, KARE
Feature
Judge's comments: This light feature was just the right length and a good mix ofinformation,
visuals and light-hearted commentary. I've never been to Minnesota, but after watching this
feature, I found myselfheading to Mapquest.com to see what it would take to take this day out
onto a trip I have to make to the state next summer.
Second Place: Mary McGuire, Chuck Sibley, Noel Sederstrom, Fox 47 News/KTTC
Newscenter
"First In Flight"
Judge's comments: Patrick Ziegler, brain injury survivor ofthe Fort Hood sniper, and his wife
talk about not only the encouraging story ofhis recovery but also about the challenges with
movement and with behaviors that result from brain injuries. With an excellent explanation
ofthe story and medical issues, fabulous supporting visuals/footage, sound and graphics, this
report bolsters Zieglers touching quote: Sometimes I dont like looking at reality. It's a reality
we need to see.
Second Place: Jennifer Mayerle, Sean Skinner, WCCO-TV
Judge's comments: This beautifully filmed video tells the story ofa sick child, and how her
family's fight to save her intersects with the politics ofmarijuana legalization and medical
marijuana legislation. This compelling video shows how human lives are affected in times of
political and social change.
Second Place: Laurie Stribling, Glenn Kellahan, WDIO/WIRT
"Survivor Strong"
Third Place: Devin Bartolotta, KTTC-TV
"Tale of Two Cities: Cleveland and Rochester"
Investigative
Judge's comments: In sticking with the story, going out to significant locations, Tom Lyden and
Brian Wiedeke give a report that rebukes the county attorneys position that he lacked
evidence. The report shows credible witnesses. The multi-part segments advance each part of
the story, with the young witnesses, interviews with law enforcement, and explanations ofthe
nuances oflaw which, essentially, continue the victimization ofthe girls and women in Victor
Barnards group. This is an outstanding example ofreporting for the public good and the
attempt to seek justice for those who can't successfully access the system.
Second Place: Tom Lyden, Tyler Dammerville, Brian Wiedeke, KMSP-TV
"Insider Threat"
Third Place: Jennifer Mayerle, Tom Aviles, WCCO-TV
"Detecting Danger"
Investigative
Judge's comments: This was a very competitive category. All three entrants are praiseworthy.
The first place entry demonstrates perseverance. The reporter and the station leave no loose
ends in a complex story that certainly, at times, must have been quite frustrating, with no
promise ofthe positive resolution they ultimately discovered.
Second Place: Laura Lee, KAAL TV/ABC 6 News
Newscast
Judge's comments: The show consistently covers difficult issues with sensitivity and balance,
while using good storytelling to maintain viewer interest.
Newscast
Judge's comments: The camerawork on the blizzard aftermath was exceptional. Every shot
was interesting and fresh. Big snowstorms are a recurring event, but the stafftold the story
with vigor.
Radio
Spot/Breaking News
Radio
First Place: Newsroom staff, MPR News
"Officer Patrick shot and killed"
Radio
First Place: Trisha Volpe, Laura McCallum, Will Lager, Manda Lillie, MPR News
"Focus on concussions transforms high school football in Minnesota"
Judge's comments: Well-researched presentation ofan important topic.
Feature
Radio
First Place: Marisa Helms, KFAI-FM
Judge's comments: Excellent writing and production. Great storytelling that pulls listeners in!
Second Place: Britta Greene, KFAI-FM
Radio
First Place: Dan Gunderson, Kate Smith, MPR News
"Rail safety"
Investigative
Radio
First Place: Catharine Richert, Elizabeth Stawicki, Bill Catlin, MPR News
"Management, technology failures, miscommunication plagued MNsure
"
Judge's comments: Compelling narrative draws listeners in to the story ofhow the problems
with MNSure evolved. A great investigative piece!
Newscast
Radio
First Place: Wendy Wilde, Dave Williams, Dan McCargar, Pete Steiner, KTOE-AM
"May 13, 2014 newscast"
Judge's comments: Newscast is well-written and packed with information. Good use oftape.
Second Place: Rick Kupchella, BringMeTheNews
"BMTN Newscast"
Third Place: Rick Kupchella, Aaron Ziemer, Newsroom staff, BringMeTheNews
"BMTN Vikings News"
Online
Best Website
Online
First Place: Joel Kramer, Andrew Putz, Corey Anderson, MinnPost
www.minnpost.com
Judge's comments: Out ofall the entries, this website stood out, based on: *The clean and
easy-to-use navigation, specific to the navigation bar at the top ofthe site. *The easy-to-find
and simply designed social media icons located at the top right ofthe site. *The typeface/fonts
were clean, simple and easy to read. *The layout was intuitive, so I did not have to think too
much when I wanted to locate specific content, links, etc. There was enough whitespace so the
reader could visually separate stories/content, etc. *The site was visually appealing--it did not
overwhelm the reader with too much content and images like other sites did.
Second Place: Star Tribune
www.startribune.com
Online
First Place: Eric Golden, Star Tribune
"Protesters block I-35W in Minneapolis, get heard at City Hall
"
Judge's comments: Very thorough coverage both live and online story; paints an excellent
picture.
Second Place: Doug Grow, MinnPost
Online
First Place: MPR Newsroom, MPR News
"Betrayed by Silence"
Judge's comments: This was an easy decision. The Web page was beautifully presented with so
many links to intriguing stories I had a hard time deciding what to read first. First-rate
writing and reporting and a compelling subject matter. It's the whole package. Great work!
Second Place: Briana Bierschbach, MinnPost
Online
First Place: Jim Walsh, MinnPost
"Turn the radio on: one man's guide to the 22 best specialty shows on Twin Cities airwaves"
Judge's comments: I chose Jim Walsh's because it offered readers not only thoughtful direction
on available radio, but also direct access/links to the available radio shows which (I believe) is
one ofthe best uses ofonline media.
Online
First Place: Staff, Star Tribune
"All-Star Game multimedia coverage"
Judge's comments: In this competitive field ofentries, the All-Star Game package created a
narrative using a wide range ofperspectives to maximize this collaboration in multimedia
storytelling. The staffutilized multiple tools including photo galleries, video, player maps and
the interactive live blog and the you be the manager game to cover many stories within the
story through different media. The coverage optimized layers ofthe All-Star Game from
historical references to the game itself. An ambitious endeavor using intentional strategies to
collect, connect and tell the story.
Second Place: ReneeJones Schneider, Jenni Pinkley, Deb Pastner, Derek Simmons, Star
Tribune
Judge's comments: Garvin's Twitter account included the most embedded videos (using Vine
and other vendors) and Instagram links. Also, he had the most retweets (RTs) from other
individuals, which showed how interactive/engaged he and his followers were. *He leveraged
the platform the best/most out ofthe three entrants (this speaks to the "innovation" criteria)
and posted a broad range ofstories for his followers. He also engaged them with personal
information/tweets and photos offamily members and friends.
Second Place: Michael Russo, Star Tribune
@russostrib
Third Place: Briana Bierschbach, MinnPost
@bbierschbach
Online
First Place: Jay Gabler, Luke Taylor, Leah Garaas, Andrea Swensson, Minnesota Public
Radio / The Current
Judge's comments: Out ofall the entries, this organization seemed to be the most engaged
with its followers and dedicated to customer service/communication. There were many @
replies to individual Twitter followers who experienced issues with links, etc. Also, there were
many embedded Twitter references to other related Twitter accounts. Also, there were many
links to its audio streaming website, some links to Meerkat and a fair number ofretweets
(RTs). I also thought the team used Twitter well by posting March Madness "Brackets" for
musicians (vs. basketball teams). This seemed to be a clever and innovative concept
leveraged.
Second Place: Staff, Star Tribune
Online
First Place: Molly Bloom, Curtis Gilbert, Bob Medcraft, Sam Heyn, MPR News
"Choo Choo Bob explains the Southwest light rail line conundrum"
Judge's comments: Clever, fun and educational, this video report presents the variety of
infrastructure options and objections in a clear, effective way. It's so good, even the
government can understand all the aspects ofthe lightrail issue.
Second Place: Ben Garvin, St. Paul Pioneer Press
Online
First Place: Bob Collins, MPR News
NewsCut: http://blogs.mprnews.org/newscut/
NewsCut understands its audience, and you can tell by the topics it chooses to cover and the
number ofcomments it receives from readers. But the more impressive thing about NewsCut
is it follows blog best practices, making the text briefand right to the point, using good images
and incorporating aspects ofsocial media, with catchy headlines and clean design making it
easy and enjoyable to read.
Second Place: Julio Ojeda-Zapata, St. Paul Pioneer Press
Online
First Place: Ron Meador, MinnPost
Earth Journal Blog: https://www.minnpost.com/earth-journal
Judge's comments: Columns employ a great combination ofdata and what it means for the
environment. Also, the travel pieces are both informative and entertaining.
Second Place: Eric Black, MinnPost
Photography
Best News Photography
Judge's comments: Crisp clear photos capture the sadness and griefin the hearts offriends,
families and brothers. Effective without being intrusive.
Second Place: Elizabeth Flores, Star Tribune
Judge's comments: Winter in the Arrowhead The Radiant North Shore is absolutely jawdropping stunning. The dew drops on the spiders web are so unique as to be almost impossible
to comprehend and have the look ofa molecular wonder. The ice cave is awesome.
Second Place: Ben Garvin, St. Paul Pioneer Press
Judge's comments: This portrait immediately illustrates the topic. Its a strong and compelling
image that makes you want to know more about Kat Perkins.
Second Place: Nancy Kuehn, Minneapolis/St. Paul Business Journal
Judge's comments: These are all fantastic. They tell a great story, and the first one is so
intense. It's thrilling and scary at the same time.
Second Place: Carlos Gonzalez, Star Tribune
Special Awards
Young Journalist of the Year
Special Awards
First Place: Briana Bierschbach, MinnPost
Judge's comments: A natural talent with strong writing and storytelling skills, who was able to
take hyperlocal topics and make them fun and interesting and easy to understand. The
writing was at once narrative and explanatory, but not forced at all. Consistent and strong.
The MinnPost found a good one.
Special Awards
First Place: Chris Serres, Star Tribune
Judge's comments: Deep dives into the complex healthcare industry, with a focus on how
problems affect everyday people. An impressive string ofreports.
Special Awards
First Place: MPR Newsroom, MPR News
"Betrayed by Silence"
Judge's comments: An outstanding culmination ofa year ofwork that demanded attention
and got action. It's radio reporting at its best.
Special Awards
First Place: Jeffrey Meitrodt, Mike Hughlett, Star Tribune
"Risky Riding"
Judge's commentsThough there was only one entry in this category, that did not detract from
this investigation. It took an issue hiding in plain sight and spelled out the danger in countless
ways. The statistics, anecdotes and writing were impressive.
Founded as Sigma Delta Chi in 1909, the Society of Professional Journal- ists is
the oldest, largest and broadest-based organization of journalists in the U.S.
The Minnesota Chapter was founded in 1956. Chapter member- ship totals
about 160. In 1998 and 2011, the Minnesota Pro chapter was named national
large chapter of the year and was one of three finalists in 2014. The chapter has
also been honored for its efforts in FOI advocacy, chapter programming and
member communications.
SPJ provides a wide variety of professional development programming at the
local and national level, including annual national and regional confer- ences as
well as monthly programs sponsored by MN SPJ. Locally and nationally, SPJ is
working hard to ensure a free flow of information, fighting battles for freedom
of information and First Amendment rights.
SPJ promotes excellence in journalism through its local journalism awards
programs, such as the Page One Awards, as well the national Sigma Delta Chi
awards for professional journalists and The Mark of Excellence awards for
collegiate journalists.
Stay in touch