Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 92

Mechanical Engineering - 22.

321 Design of Machinery

Chapter

ANALYTICAL
LINKAGE SYNTHESIS

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 1

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.0 Introduction
Fundamentals of Position Analysis Established

Can now Analytically Synthesize Linkages


Use an Algebraic Procedure

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 2

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.1 Types of Kinematic Synthesis


Function Generation the correlation of an input
function w/ an output function in a mechanism
Path Generation the control of a point in the
plane so that it follows some prescribed path
Motion Generation the control of a line in the
plane so that it assumes some sequential set of
prescribed positions

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 3

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.2 Two-Position Synthesis for Rocker


Output
Example 3-1 showed a simple graphical technique for
the design of a non-quick-return Grashof fourbar
linkage to drive a rocker through an angle
- Rocker excursion should not exceed 180o
- Best to keep excursion to under 120o for min
transmission angle of 30o

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 4

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Consider doing an analytical determination of


link lengths for the driver dyad
- First choose a suitable location on Link 4 to
attach Link 3, e.g. Point B

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 5

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 6

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 7

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.3 Precision Points


Precision Positions or Points
The prescribed points or positions for
successive locations of the output link
(coupler or rocker) in the plane

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 8

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Number of equations limits the number of


precision points that can be synthesized
For example,
Fourbar linkage can synthesize up to:
5 precision points for motion or path
generation (i.e. coupler output)
7 points for function generation
(i.e. rocker output)

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 9

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

- 2 or 3 points set of linear equations


- 4 or more points

set of nonlinear equations


need to use a computer program,
e.g. MathCAD or Matlab
Caveat:
May still have intermediate toggle points

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 10

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.4 Two-Position Motion Generation


Analytical Synthesis

by

Consider a fourbar linkage in one position


1. With a coupler point located at a first
precision point P1
2. A second precision point P2
3. Rocker input is to go through an angle 2

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 11

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

4. Angle of the coupler at each precision


position is defined by the angles of the
position vectors z1 and z2
5. The angle corresponds to 3 in
Position 1
6. The angle 2 denotes a change in
orientation in going from the first to
second precision position.
Note: Figure 5-1 is schematic and
dimensions are unknown at this early
point in the problem
Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 12

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 13

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Problem Statement
Design a fourbar linkage which will move a line on
its coupler link s.t.
1. A point P on that line will first be at P1 and later
at P2 and
2. Rotate the line through 2 between those two
precision positions
Find:
Lengths and angles of the four links
The coupler link dimensions A1 P1 and B1 P1 as
given in Fig. 5-1
Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 14

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 15

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 16

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 17

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 18

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 19

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 20

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 21

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 22

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 23

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 24

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 25

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 26

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.5 Comparison of Analytical and Graphical


Two-Position Synthesis

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 27

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 28

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 29

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.6 Simultaneous Equation Solution


Analytical synthesis leads to set of
simultaneous equations.
2-Position Synthesis 2 Equations
3-Position Synthesis 4 Equations
Several solution approaches:

Spreadsheet (e.g. Excel)


MathCAD or Matlab
Calculator
Longhand by Gaussian elimination method

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 30

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 31

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 32

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 33

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 34

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 35

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 36

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.7 Three-Position Motion Generation by


Analytical Synthesis
Same basic approach as defining two
dyads at each end of the fourbar linkage
A pair of dyads for each precision point
Problem Statement
Design a fourbar linkage which will:
1. Rotate a line on the coupler through 2 and 3
to precision points P1 and P2, respectively
2. Point P is on the coupler line
Find Lengths and angles of the four links and coupler
dimensions A1P1 and B1P1
Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 37

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 38

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Solution Process
Locate Global reference frame at P1
(for convenience)
As was done for the two-position synthesis,
first solve for the LHS and then repeat for
the RHS
Can write two vector-loop equations for
each side

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 39

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 40

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 41

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 42

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 43

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 44

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 45

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 46

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Summarizing:
Infinite number of solutions
Designer must check to see if linkage is feasible
Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 47

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.8 Comparison of Analytical and


Graphical Three-Position Synthesis

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 48

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 49

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 50

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 51

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 52

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.9 Synthesis for a Specified Fixed Pivot


Location
Common problem as the available locations for
fixed pivots in most machines are limited
Our 4 free choices will be the x and y
coordinates of the two fixed pivots
Approach Nonlinear equations containing
transcendental functions of unknown
angles.
As before:

The solution process must be


applied for the LHS and then the RHS

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 53

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 54

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 55

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 56

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 57

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 58

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 59

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 60

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 61

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 62

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 63

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 64

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 65

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 66

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.10 Center-Point and Circle-Point Circles


If we could find the loci of all possible
solutions to the three-position synthesis
problem.

We would then have an overview


of the potential locations of the
ends of the vectors

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 67

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Consider holding one of the free choices,


say 2, at an arbitrary value, then solve
Equations 5.25 and 5.26 for 3 = 02.
A circle will be generated
Circle is locus of points for roots of
for the chosen 2
O2 coincides with the root of
Hence, called a Center-Point Circle
Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 68

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 69

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Next consider the vector


Hold 2 constant at some arbitrary angle
Let 3 = 02
A circle of all possible locations of the
root of
for the given 2 chosen.
As
is fixed to the tip of
which in
turn describes a circle about pivot O2.
This locus is called the Circle-Point Circle
Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 70

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

The x,y components of vectors


and 5.26

and

are defined by Equations 5.25

(5.25)

(5.26)

Negating the x,y components of


the circle-point circle

will give the coordinates of points on

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 71

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

The x,y components of N=-Z-W define the points on the O2 center-point


circle for any assumed value of 2 as 3 is iterated thru 02
Vector W is calculated using angles 2 and 3 and vector Z using angles 2
as 3
The process is repeated for the RHS
Note: There are an infinity of solutions because one angle is being
chosen arbitrarily
A computer program can help in making reasonable choices

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 72

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Fig. 5-9 shows the circle-point and center-point circles for the Chebychev straight-line
linkage for choices

Two larger circles are the center-point circles for the potential locations of
the fixed pivots O2 and O4

The two smaller circles define the loci of the possible moving pivot locations

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 73

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 74

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.11 Four- and Five-Position Analytical


Synthesis
Can use same basic technique as was used for
2- and 3-position analytical synthesis
Let angles be designed k, k and k
where k=2n
and where:
k
denotes the precision position
n
represents the number of
precision positions for which we
are solving
Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 75

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 76

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 77

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.12 Analytical Synthesis of a Path


Generator with Prescribed Timing
Can use same approach for path generation w/
prescribed timing
Here we specify angles 2 and 3 of the input
rocker to define timing
Thus, the free choices are now 2 and 3
Use the same Equations 5.25, 5.26, 5.30 and 5.31
Can be extended to as many as 5 precision points

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 78

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.13 Analytical Synthesis of a Fourbar


Function Generator
Can still use a similar approach as was used for
the synthesis of path generation
In this case, we do not care about the motion of
the coupler
Coupler only exists to couple input link to output
link
Coupler is simply a line from A to P
P is simply a coupler point which happens to
coincide with the pin joint
P has a simple arc motion
Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 79

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Function generator uses Link 2 as the input link and


takes output from Link 4.
Relationship between the angles of Links 2 and 4 is the
function generated.
The function is then:
NOT a continuous function. Holds only for the n discrete
points specified.
Linkage must satisfy
Once again, write vector loop equations.
Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 80

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 81

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 82

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 83

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 84

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 85

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

5.14 Other Linkage Synthesis Methods

Many other techniques for the synthesis of


linkages have been discovered in recent years

Most are involved and mathematically cumbersome


Only a few admit a closed-form solution
Most require an iterative numerical solution

Table 5-5 summarizes some of the existing


fourbar linkage synthesis methods divided into
three types

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 86

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 87

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

1. Precision
A method that attempts to find a solution
which will pass exactly through the desired
precision points but may deviate from the
desired path between these points

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 88

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Limited to matching a number of points


equal to the number of independently
adjustable parameters that define the
mechanism e.g.
Fourbar linkage 9 parameters.
For up to five precision points, equations
can be solved for without iteration.
For 6 to 9 points an iterative is required to
solve the equation set.
Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 89

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

The 9 parameters are:


- 4 link lengths
- 2 coordinates of the coupler point
with respect to the coupler link
- 3 parameters which define the
location and orientation of the fixed
length in the global reference frame

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 90

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

2. Equation
Methods that solve the tri-circular, trinodal
sextic coupler curve to find a linkage that will
generate an entire coupler curve that closely
approximates a set of desired points on the
curve.
3. Optimized
An iterative optimization procedure that
attempts to minimize an objective function that
can be defined in many ways.

Allow larger numbers of points to be specified


then do the precision methods.
Limited only by computer time and round-off error.
Convergence depends on good initial choices.

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 91

Mechanical Engineering - 22.321 Design of Machinery

Copyright 2008 Department of Mechanical Engineering - University of Massachusetts Lowell

Chapter 5 - 92

You might also like