Professional Documents
Culture Documents
32 Samss 037
32 Samss 037
32 Samss 037
32-SAMSS-037
1 November 2011
Material Specification for the Manufacture
of Fiber Reinforced Plastic (FRP) Tanks
Document Responsibility: Materials and Corrosion Control Standards Committee
Scope
1.1
This document covers the requirements for specification of and the acceptance
conditions for raw materials, properties, and testing of materials utilized for the
factory manufacture of fiber reinforced plastic (FRP) tanks, for use above
ground or underground.
1.2
The FRP tanks made of polyester, vinylester or epoxy resin system reinforced
with glass fibers, carbon fibers, or their combination, manufactured by the wet
lay-up and/or filament winding processes. Constructions both with and without
a lining of thermoplastics are included.
1.3
This specification applies to stationary tanks used for the storage, accumulation,
or processing of corrosive or other substances at pressures not exceeding 15 psig
external and/or 15 psig internal above any hydrostatic head.
1.4
The process for the material specification and quality control tests according to
this document is shown in flowchart, Figure A of the Appendix A.
Any conflicts between this specification and other applicable Saudi Aramco
Materials System Specifications (SAMSSs), Engineering Standards (SAESs),
Standard Drawings (SASDs), or industry standards, codes, and forms shall be
resolved in writing, prior to submission of bids or start of related work, by the
Company or Buyer Representative through the Manager, Consulting Services
Department, of Saudi Aramco, Dhahran.
2.2
Direct all requests to deviate from this specification in writing to the Company or
Buyer Representative, who shall follow internal company procedure SAEP-302
and forward such requests to the Manager, Consulting Services Department of
Saudi Aramco, Dhahran.
References
Material supplied to this specification shall comply with the latest edition of the
references listed below unless otherwise noted:
3.1
Page 2 of 29
ASTM C582
ASTM D638
ASTM D648
ASTM D790
ASTM D2583
ASTM D2584
ASTM D 3299
ASTM D4097
ASTM D5083
Specimens
ASTM E84
European Standard
EN 59
EN 29092
EN 13121-1
GRP Tanks and Vessels for Use above Ground Raw Materials - Specification Conditions and
Acceptance Conditions
EN 13121-2
GRP Tanks and Vessels for Use above Ground Composite Materials - Chemical Resistance
EN 13121-3
GRP Tanks and Vessels for Use above Ground Design and Workmanship
EN 13121-4
GRP Tanks and Vessels for Use above Ground Delivery, Installation and Maintenance
ISO 178
ISO 306
ISO 472
ISO 527-2
Plastics - Determination of Tensile Properties Part 2: Test Conditions for Moulding and
Extrusion Plastics
ISO 868
ISO 1133
ISO 1163-1
Page 4 of 29
ISO 1887
ISO 1889
ISO 2113
ISO 2554
ISO 2559
ISO 2797
ISO 3344
ISO 3374
Reinforcement Products - Mats and Fabrics Determination of Mass per Unit Area
ISO 3915
ISO 6721-2
ISO 9073-1
Textiles - Test Methods for Nonwovens Part 1: Determination of Mass per Unit Area
ISO 9073-2
ISO 9073-3
Textiles - Test Methods for Nonwovens Part 3: Determination of Tensile Strength and
Elongation
ISO 9771
ISO 11357-2
ISO 11359-2
Underwriters Laboratories
UL 1316
Definitions
4.1
General
For purposes of this specification only, the following definitions apply:
Carbon fiber: fiber produced by pyrolysis of organic precursor fibers, such as
rayon, polyacrylonitrile or pitch, in an inert environment.
Chelating agents: organic compounds which act by temporarily complexing the
organometallic accelerator out of the reaction medium. Example, acetyl acetone.
Chemical protective barrier: either the corrosion-resistant barrier or the
thermoplastic liner (if used), whichever will be in direct contact with the fluid.
Corrosion-resistant barrier: the composite material layer of the tank that will be
in direct contact with fluid, it is comprised of an inner surface and interior layer.
Crosslinking: process which bonds one polymer chain to another, to form a
tridimensional polymeric structure.
Cure/Post cure cycle: time/temperature/pressure cycle used to cure a
thermosetting resin system.
Cure: chemical reaction resulting in crosslinking of thermoset resin.
Curing agent: catalytic or reactive agent that, when added to a resin, causes
crosslinking.
Design Engineer: engineering company responsible for specifying design
requirements on the tank data sheet. It is also referred to as engineering contractor.
E-glass: a grade or type of glass fiber normally used to reinforce FRP tanks,
consisting mainly of SiO2, Al2O3 and MgO.
Page 6 of 29
Epoxy resins (EP): thermoset resin containing the oxirane (epoxide) reactive
group. Crosslinking occurs at these sites through addition of amines, Lewis
acids/bases and anhydrides. Examples, diglycidyl ether of bisphenol A,
diglycidyl ether of bisphenol F.
Fiber-reinforced plastic (FRP): plastic-based composite that is reinforced
with any type of fiber, not necessarily glass.
Glass transition temperature (Tg): temperature at which amorphous polymer
undergoes a marked change in properties on passing from the rubbery to glassy
state.
Gel coat: a thin layer of resin on the surface of a laminate that may or may not
be reinforced with a glass or a synthetic fiber.
Inhibitors: chemical agents which react with the curing system to slow down
the curing of the resin.
Initiators: generally organic peroxides which break down liberating radicals
initiating radical crosslinking process. Examples, Methyl ethyl ketone peroxide
(MEKP), Cumene hydroperoxide (CuHP), Dibenzoyl peroxide (BPO), acetyl
acetone peroxide (AAP), Cyclohexanone peroxide (CHP), etc.
Laminate: compilation of laminae of resin reinforced with fibers which are
fabricated during the manufacturing process of the tank. The laminate
constitutes the wall thickness structure of the tanks and their properties are
defined in Section 6 of this document.
Manufacturer: company responsible for the design, fabrication and testing of
tanks in accordance with this Specification. It is also referred to as Fabricator.
Maximum design temperature, Td: maximum temperature for determination
of the partial design factor, A2, as defined in EN 13121.
Maximum temperature, Tm: temperature given by the resin supplier or the
thermoplastics supplier referring to a specified fluid.
Organometallic accelerators: the primary agents which accelerate the
breakdown of the initiator to achieve a sufficient rate of generation of radicals.
Owner: Saudi Aramco organization which will utilize the tank and specify the
process requirements.
Post cure: the application of heat to take the resin crosslinking to a final stage.
Promoters: improve the reaction efficiency of the accelerators.
Page 7 of 29
Units
Description
C
g/10 min
%
MPa
Flexural strength
t
ShD
MPa
-
Tensile strength
Shore Hardness D
Et
Ef
CSM
GRP
ECTFE
FEP
FW
PFA
PP-B
PP-H
PP-R
PVC-U
PVDF
WR
CRL
VL
TPL
g/ml
MPa
MPa
-
Density
Modulus of elasticity in tension
Modulus of elasticity in flexure
Chopped strand mat
Glass-fiber Reinforced Plastic
Ethylene-chlorotrifluoroethylene copolymer
Fluorinated ethylene-propylene copolymer
Filament winding
Perfluoro-alkoxy copolymer
Polypropylene, block polymer
Polypropylene, homopolymer
Polypropylene, random polymer
Polyvinyl chloride, unplasticised
Polyvinylidene fluoride
Woven rovings
Chemical Resistant Layer
Veil Layer
Thermoplastics Liner
Page 8 of 29
Raw Materials
5.1
Resins
a)
The resins used for FRP tanks are liquid or liquefiable, thermosetting in
nature and cured by molecule crosslinking (polyaddition or
polycondensation) with or without curing agents (initiators,
accelerators/promoters).
b)
The resin supplier shall state in the resin technical data sheet the name,
type of resin, resin group and resin typical properties. Properties of UP
and VE resins are published in Table 1.
c)
The tank manufacturer shall verify that the resin conforms to the property
values of color, viscosity, nonvolatile content and gel time as established
in the resin manufacturer technical data sheet.
d)
Only resins with an HDT of at least 82C (180F) per ASTM D648 with a
1.8 MPa (264 psi) loading and a 3.2 mm (18 in) specimen shall be used.
e)
The tank manufacturer shall verify resin meets the chemical resistance
requirements given in EN 13121-2.
Note:
5.2
f)
g)
h)
i)
Curing Agents
5.2.1
The cure system supplier shall state the compatibility of the curing
system with the resins, give recommendations on the quantities and
Page 9 of 29
b
c
UP
UP
UP
UP
VE
UVE
VE
7A
7B
Epoxidised-Novolak
Methacrylic-/Acrylic acid
Ethylenedicarbonxylic
acids
Ethylenedicarbonxylic
acids
Dipropoxy-Bisphenol A
(min. 90 mol-%)
Dialkoxy - Bisphenol A
(min. 90 ml-%), Alkoxy
(meth)acrylate
Ethylenedi-carbonxylic
acids
Bis (hydroxymethyl)tricyclodecan
Methacrylic-/Acrylic acid
Isophthalic acid,
Ethylenedicarbonxylic
acids
Epoxidised Bisphenol A
Standard glycolsa
Standard glycolsa
Type of acids
50
50
55
55
45
55
50
50
50
150
120
110
130
120
120
140
120
85
120
105
90
110
90
90
110
90
82
75
75
75
60
50
65
75
50
60
2.5
3.5
4.0
2.0
1,5
3.0
3.0
1.5
2.0
t
%
min
130
130
130
110
100
110
120
75
90
f
MPa
min
Ethylene-, 1,2-propylene-, diethylene-, dipropylene-, neopentylglycol, 1,3-butanediol 1,4-butanediol and corresponding halogenated
glycols
May also contain cyclic unsaturated hydrocarbons.
Related to the sum of the diol components
UP
2B
Standard glycols a, b
Type of glycols
Content
Tg HDT t
of styrene
C
C MPa
mass-%
min min min
max.
b)
UP
2A
Resin Resin
Group Type
Page 10 of 29
5.2.2
c)
d)
e)
f)
b)
c)
Anhydride
65 (150)
Aliphatic Amine
93 (200)
Cyclo-Aliphatic Amine
110 (230)
Aromatic Amine
115 (240)
Page 11 of 29
5.3
d)
In each material data sheet(s), the material supplier shall state the
name and type of curing agent and the typical properties.
e)
The tank manufacturer shall verify that the curing agent conforms
to the property values of color, viscosity, gel time and anhydride
equivalent as established in the curing agent technical data sheet.
Reinforcing Materials
5.3.1
General
Reinforcing materials shall be made from different types of textile glass
in accordance with Table 3. Special arrangement of reinforcing material
should be specified taking into account requirements as defined in 5.2.2
to 5.2.5.
E-CR
AR
5.3.2
b)
5.3.3
5.3.4
c)
d)
The chopped strands mat supplier shall state the strand, structure,
binder and mass per unit area, the compatibility with the resin
system, the laminating process and the laminate design.
b)
Chopped strand mats shall be made of textile glass strand, cut from
25 to 50 mm in length, without orientation of strands, and mass per
unit area within 225 to 600 g/m2. Chopped strands mat typically
used are type E (electrical borosilicate) or ECR (electrical corrosionresistant) glass; 236, 354, or 472 g/m2 (0.75, 1, or 1.5 oz/ft2), with a
silane-type finish.
c)
d)
The tank manufacturer shall verify that the chopped strand mat
conforms to the property values of mass per unit area, thickness
and tensile strength as established in the chopped strand mat data
sheet.
b)
The fabric supplier shall state the linear density of yarns or rovings,
by ratio of mass of warp to weft, bidirectional or unidirectional.
Mass per unit area shall be within 240 to 1,200 g/m2. Woven
roving could be E glass, nominal 813 g/m2 (24 oz/yd2), 5 x 4 square
weave, with a silane-type finish.
Page 13 of 29
5.3.5
5.4
c)
d)
e)
f)
b)
c)
d)
e)
Additives
5.4.1
General
a)
b)
c)
5.4.2
Thixotropic Agents
Thixotopic agents such as fumed silica may be added to the resin up to
5% by mass, using a high shear stirrer, for viscosity control, provided it
does not interfere with visual inspection.
5.4.3
5.4.4
Conductive Fillers
a)
b)
Fire Retardants
Fire retardants such as aluminium trihydrate or antimony oxides may be
added to specified laminate layers to meet certain requirements for fire
resistance. No fire retardants other than those present in the fire
resistance test sample will be allowed to be used during fabrication of the
tank(s). The tank manufacturer shall demonstrate that the incorporation
of the fire retardant additives will not negatively affect the mechanical
and physical material properties.
Special intumescent coatings can also be utilized to improve the fire
resistance of the material utilized to manufacture the tank.
5.4.5
5.4.6
Paraffin Wax
a)
b)
Page 15 of 29
5.4.7
Ultraviolet Absorbers
When required, ultraviolet absorbers may be incorporated into the
laminate or outer layers, in accordance with the supplier's
recommendations (usually used at a level of less than 0.5% by mass).
5.4.8
Pigments
Pigments are permissible only in the outer resin surface and - if required
- shall be applied after visual inspection has been carried out.
5.4.9
General
a)
PVC-U
Chlorinated Polyvinylchloride in
accordance with ASME RTP-1
CPVC
PVDF
Ethylene-chlorotrifluoroethylene
copolymer in accordance with
EN 13121-1 or ASME RTP-1
E-CTFE
Fluorinated ethylene-propylene
copolymer in accordance with
FEP
Page 16 of 29
5.5.2
Perfluoro-alkoxy copolymer in
accordance with EN 13121-1 or
ASME RTP-1
PFA
Ethylene-tetrafluoroethylene in
accordance with ASME RTP-1
ETFE
Polytetrafluoroethylene in accordance
with ASME RTP-1
PTFE
HDPE
b)
The lining material shall be selected on the basis of its ability to meet
the requirements for service conditions including permeability,
environmental stress cracking, mechanical properties, bond strength
to laminate and fabricability (forming, welding) per EN 13121-2 and
EN 13121-3, or ASME RTP-1.
c)
All parts of the lining shall be manufactured from the same grade of
material.
d)
The thermoplastic lining supplier shall state that the specific linings
meet the chemical resistance requirements given in EN 13121-2.
e)
Liner Thickness
a)
b)
Thickness of Sheets, mm
PVC-U
3.0 to 4.5
CPVC
3.0 to 4.5
PVDF
2.4 to 4.0
PP-H,-B,-R
3.0 to 6.0
Page 17 of 29
5.5.3
5.5.4
Thickness of Sheets, mm
1.7 to 2.5
PTFE
2.5 to 4.0
HDPE
3.0 to 6.0
b)
c)
The tank manufacturer shall verify that the liner material conforms
to the property values of dimensions, mechanical and thermal
properties as established in Table 5.
Welding consumables
All welding rods shall be of the same or compatible grade of material of
the lining and shall not impair the performance of the lining.
5.5.5
Dimensional stability
In order for the lining to retain its dimensional stability during heat
forming and welding, the thermoplastic lining material shall conform to
the requirements for heat reversion as specified by the material supplier.
Tensile
Strain at
Break
EN ISO
527-2
(%)
15
15
> 50
> 50
> 50
80
200
300
300
250
250
Modulus of
Heat
Linear
Elasticity in Shore D Deflection Thermal
Tension
Hardness Temperature Expansion
EN ISO EN ISO 868 EN ISO 75- ISO 11359527-2
2c
2
(MPa)
(C)
(C)
3000
80
75
75
3000
--102
120
1200
65
50
180
700
60
45
180
700
60
45
180
2000
80
90
130
1700
75
75
80
350
55
50
100
300
60
60
140
1656
--104
80
450
--221
120
Page 18 of 29
---
22-31
>500
1100
---
85
150
[1]: Relevant ASTM standard test methods shall be used for suppliers following ASTM/ASME documents.
Laminate Requirements
6.1
General
The laminate properties specified in this section will be used as baseline for the
quality control test to be conducted on the final material produced during the
manufacture of the tank. The quality control tests should be carried out
according to Section 7 of this specification.
If the laminate properties are defined by conducting tests from prototype
samples, these tests can be conducted by the liner supplier, tank manufacturer or
independent testing laboratory.
The quality of lamination work depends on the skill, knowledge and experience
of the laminator. Periodic assessment of the skill of the laminator is essential for
the assurance of the quality of the lamination work. The methodology to assess
the the knowledge and skills of laminators who are required to carry out work on
FRP tanks is described in ASME RTP-1 Mandatory Appendix M-5 or
EN 13121-3 Annex E. All laminators shall have documented experience as a
laminator or have completed a training course. The tank manufacturer shall
demonstrate that their laminators have been trained and certified by either of the
assessment procedures mentioned above.
6.1.1
General
The chemical protective barrier shall be selected in accordance
with the requirements of EN 13121-2. The chemical barrier
construction shall not be considered in any strength, or stability
calculation.
6.1.1.2
Page 19 of 29
6.1.1.3
a)
b)
Thermoplastic Liners
a)
b)
c)
7.0
CPVC
7.0
PVDF
5.0
3.5
5.0
d)
6.1.2
Structural Layer
a)
b)
the tanks, body shell, bottom and top head. The properties are
defined below.
6.1.3
c)
d)
Outer Surface
a)
Page 22 of 29
6.1.4
b)
c)
d)
Where the final lay-up is exposed to air, full surface cure shall be
obtained by applying to the final layup a coat of paraffinated
(waxed) resin that, when cured, passes the acetone test per
ASTM C582, Section 9.2.2. Other techniques such as sprayed,
wrapped, or overlaid films are also acceptable methods to attain
surface cure, provided the surface resin under the film passes the
acetone test.
b)
6.1.5
The heat deflection temperature of cured resin system used for the
reinforced laminate shall be at least 20C higher than the design
temperature of the FRP tank.
Only resins with HDT of at least 82C (180F) per ASTM D648
with a 1.8 MPa (264 psi) loading and a 3.2 mm (18 in) specimen
shall be used.
Flammability
When required or specified, the external surface layer(s) of the tank shall
be modified to fulfill the required surface spread of flame characteristic.
The material shall show flame spread rating from 0 to 25 which
represents Class 1 rating for fire resistant material per ASTM E-84.
6.1.6
Electrical Resistivity
Where the build-up of static electricity may cause problems, the surface
resistivity of those parts of the tank or vessel in contact with the fluid
Page 23 of 29
shall not exceed 106 , or the volume resistivity 106 m, when tested in
accordance with ISO 3915 test method.
6.1.7
Post-Curing
a)
b)
The tank manufacture shall have written procedures for the postcuring process of the FRP tank.
c)
Temperature
C
Time
Hours
70 (-3/5)
6 (-1/+2)
70 (-3/5)
10 (-1/+2)
80 (-3/5)
6 (-1/+2)
70 (-3/5)
12 (-1/+2)
80 (-3/5)
8 (-1/+2)
Raw Materials
7.1.1
7.1.2
7.1.3
b)
c)
d)
These tests shall be performed on one random sample from each lot
or batch of material received from a supplier. If any containers or
packages are damaged, then the contents of each damaged
container shall be rejected.
Reinforcing Material
a)
b)
c)
Thermoplastic Liners
a)
b)
7.2
This section specifies the minimum requirements for the inspections and
tests that are to be performed by the tank manufacturer or an independent
testing laboratory on the laminate according to the requirements of
Section 6.1.2 of this specification.
b)
The tank manufacturer shall verify that the laminate was fabricated
according to a given design parameters and drawings. The following
inspections and tests should be conducted according to ASME RTP-1 Part 6.
Resin cure. The test shall be conducted on the internal and external
surfaces of the tanks according to ASME RTP-1/Section 6-910.
Barcol hardness shall not be lower than 90% of the value specified by
the resin supplier for a clear resin casting and according to the value
specified in Section 6.1.2.
Page 26 of 29
Documentation
8.1
8.2
certified as required in Section 7.1, including tests report forms for all tests
performed on all lots or batches of materials used during fabrication.
1 November 2011
Revision Summary
New Saudi Aramco Materials System Specification.
Page 28 of 29
Appendix
AA
Flowchart
forfor
Material
Selection
Criteria
Qualification
Testing
Appendix
Workflow
the Material
Selection
andand
Testing
of FRP Tanks
Yes
Tank Design
32-SAMSS-002
By: Manufacturer
No
Quality Control Test Raw Materials
Section 7.1, 32-SAMSS-037
By: Manufacturer
New Batch
Raw Materials
Yes
Tank Manufacture
By: Manufacturer
No
Quality Control Test Laminate
Section 7.2, 32-SAMSS-037
By: Manufacturer
Tank Rejection
Yes
Figure A Workflow for the Material Selection and Testing of FRP Tanks
Page 29 of 29