Randy Chapel

PO Box 711419
Mt. View, Hawaii 96771
November xx, 2015
President Barack Obama
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20500
Dear Mr. President,
April 28, 2008
Letter to Senator Barack Obama:
I would like to request that the Spellings administration be reminded
of their duties and to provide to me the requested materials I have
requested since February regarding the concluded investigation upon
the national and regional accreditation agencies, and to contact the
school to endeavor to obtain the materials I have repeatedly requested
for over two years as provided under the law. (A128)
April 4, 2011
Letter to President Obama, Eric Holder:
However, I have reached my limit at this point. I have now lost
everything as a result of the corrupt actions by Western Seminary, ATS
and NWCCU, three insurance companies and the ongoing negligence
of duty and malfeasance by the former USDE administration. The
evidences overwhelmingly demonstrate that the Spellings
administration covered for the school and accreditors (ATS and
NWCCU) and the Departments own negligent and malfeasant actions
while using taxpayer money. I have lost my house, my possessions and
my wife is divorcing me and I will not be able to see my only child
my sonas a result. My wife made clear in her UK court filings that
she is taking this step as a direct result of my case. Last summer I
nearly committed suicide. I really cannot deal with this much longer.
Mr. President, you called for a spirit of cooperation and openness to
prevail. I previously extended understanding toward Secretary Duncan
and the Department with regard to producing the materials I seek via
the FOIAmaterials we already know existdespite the
unpleasantness contained in those documents. I prefer to note the
agencys successful transparency and the rule of law. I prefer to note

the Departments exhaustive introspection regarding problems created

by Margaret Spellings political choices that negatively impacted
higher education and my life. I need Secretary Duncan, as a reformer
and the top education administrator in the nation, to make changes that
prevent this sort of thing from ever happening again to any student or
family.
I am prepared to engage in a constructive conversation and reasonable
solutions, but I will need the materials I am seeking by way of my
FOIA request to do this.
Mr. President, I know you have many very important national affairs to
conduct on behalf of the welfare of this great nation. Will you please
mention to your friend Secretary Duncan (when it is convenient) that I
really need my FOIA request to be completed very soon (see Mr.
Holders memo section: Working Proactively and Promptly), so I can
file my last remaining documents with the agency for my pursuit of
justice on behalf of all students and their families? (A127)
May 31, 2011
Letter to President Obama, Eric Holder:
We are damaged. Our son, Randy Chapel, has now lost everything
as a result of the corrupt actions of Western Seminary, ATS and
NWCCU, three insurance companies, their attorneys, the arbitrator who
ignored state and federal laws over Western, and the ongoing
negligence and malfeasance by the former USDE administration. The
USDE could have prevented the continued destruction on May 8,
2008when Asst. Secretary Diane Auer Jones cited ATS and
NWCCU for 34 CFR 602.20 and 602.23. But she stopped short of total
accountability by omitting the 34 CFR 602.22 noncompliance that Mr.
Mula stated was already determined on January 2, 2008, The evidence
overwhelmingly demonstrates the Spellings administration covered for
the school and ATS and NWCCU. Randy lost his house, his
possessions, and his wife is divorcing him and he will not be able to see
his only childour grandsonas a result. His wife made it clear in her
UK divorce filings that she is taking this step as a direct result of the
lawsuit whereby Randy was set up for more retaliation via FERPA
violations, conflicts of interest, and USDE ongoing negligence of duty.
I will be 61-years-old this year and Carol will be 71 in August. We
used up our life savings and took loans out on our house to help our son
against ten years of abuse by Western against Randy. Carol witnessed
Randy degrade after the USDE refused to reply to Carol and Randys
pleas for help about Westerns FERPA violations. Carol experienced
deep emotional despair and frequent nightmares last summer after

xv

Randy disappeared intending to commit suicide. Randy complains of

nightly nightmares and depression. When Randy returned last fall, we
worked diligently to help him get back on his feet to confront the
Department and its failures.
Mr. President, you called for a spirit of cooperation and openness to
prevail. We (Carol, Randy, and I) are prepared to engage in a
constructive administrative conversation to find reasonable solutions to
these problems, but we will need the materials we are seeking by way
of our FOIA requests to do it. We ask that our FOIA requests also be
searched under the Privacy Act and under the intent of both Memos for
FOIA transparency. We are aware that dis- coverable materials for
administrative claims should be released, and our requests under FOIA
should be processed on that basis. Please see McClellan Ecological
Seepage Situation v. Garlucci, 835 F.2d 1282 (9th Cir. 1987) (requests under FOIA for information to be utilized in a tort claim cannot
be denied on the basis that there is a com- mercial interest). Hernandez
v. U.S., 1998 WL 230200 (E.D. La.) (both USPS accident report and
USPS driver's personnel file (Privacy Act) must be released).
Mr. President, we know you have many very important national affairs
to conduct on behalf of the welfare of this great nation. Will you please
mention to your friend Secretary Duncan (when it is convenient) that
we really need our FOIA requests to be completed very soon (see Mr.
Holders MEMO section: Working Proactively and Promptly), so
Carol can file her last remaining documents with the Department for
our pursuit of justice on behalf of all students and their families?
(A126)
September 1, 2011
Letter to President Obama, Eric Holder, Arne Duncan, Phil Rosenfelt, Kathleen
Tighe and (James A. Scharf):
This has cost me everything I have and everyone close to me. I have
been stripped to nothing so that the cover up by the Republican Margret
Spellings administration, ATS, NWCCU and Western Seminary can
continue. The White House knows about the damage inflicted upon me
by the negligence of duty described in the Federal Torts Claims Act
documents you received from me in July.
Today my wife divorced me as a result of the ongoing delays, fraud,
and outcomes caused by the governments negligence of duty about
which my government refuses to turn over FOIA records. I was told I
will not see my 2 12 year old son, my only child, until he is an adult. I
cant fathom the depth of your love for your two daughters, but you

surely must understand what it means to be cut off from your child or
to not have a father. My wife divorced me because I have been fighting
for my civil rights that I have been repeatedly denied since 2002.
The public has a right to know who or what is influencing its
government concerning this corruption that has had such an impact on
human life. Open Records and Freedom of Information laws are critical
to ensuring a transparent and accountable government, yet it is the
entrenched and dysfunctional employees at the U.S. Department of
Education that want these records kept covered up. Taxpayers deserve
to know how their hard- earned tax dollars are spent. The public
deserves to have transparent and accountable leaders and an
explanation with the records sought as to why public money is being
used to cover up for a pastor who molested a girl, Section 504 fraud,
FERPA violations, and academic fraud, and so on all in the name of
earning an education.
These ongoing tortuous acts against my life need to stop and I am
asking you that this request be upheld. It is not reasonable that any
American go through what I have and I really would like this to end.
(A124)
September 14, 2011
Letter to President Obama, Eric Holder, Arne Duncan, Phil Rosenfelt, Kathleen
Tighe and James A. Scharf:
Instead, I have lost everything
now. I have lost my house, my land
and everything else. My wife has
divorced me because of the time,
effort and cost all of this has taken.
She has informed me that I will not
see my two-and-a-half-year-old
son until he is an adult. She and her
family are beyond pissed. My
family is beyond pissed. The
USDOE, with ATS, NWCCU and
Western Seminary have destroyed
every aspect of my life and future.
I will not live the governments lies
that are being forced on me. I was
not put on this earth to live this lie.
The USDOE made this personal
and the USDOE is forcing this to
end in tragedy. Our nation has a

xvii

right to know what the

Republican Margret Spellings
administration did and will do to
favor special interest groups
against a student, a whistleblower
and his family, and the length they
will go to screw anyone who stands
up against it.
You want time? Beg my wife to
reconsider divorcing me and to not
withhold my son from me due to
lawsuits defending my inalienable
right to life, liberty, and my pursuit
of happiness, and please call my
little son and explain why his
government is withholding records
that demonstrate government fraud
that harmed and destroyed his
family:
+4401733358431
Susan.Chapel@gmail.com
The continued failure of the USDOE to produce records as required
under the FOIA will be seen unfavorably by the public and the Court
against the USDOE and other government officials who know that the
USDOE is willfully withholding records in order to cover up
negligence of duty and malfeasance that damaged me and my family.
The failure of the USDOE to produce records is an undeniable fact.
Several of the FOIA requests can never be produced, because records
that justify the USDOE, ATS, and NWCCU do not exist, which is an
undeniable fact that will be highly unfavorable against the USDOE.
Those facts will be construed by the public, by the Court, and by the
media as a deliberate and willful cover up against the public welfare,
since those willful acts to damage us required forethought against my
family and meand against We the People;
Respectfully, I cannot agree to an additional thirty-day extension, and it
is reasonable to conclude that no one in my position would entertain it
at this point. The USDOE provided Western Seminary full rein to
screw me over and Western did exactly thatcontrary to state and
federal laws, against accreditation standards, and against its own
Articles of Incorporation and against its school policies and its so

called religion.
This tortuous period of my life needs to stop. The government needs to
find some other American to screw over. (A120)
April 2, 2012
Letter to President Obama, Hillary Rodham Clinton, Valerie Jarrett, Eric Holder,
Arne Duncan, Robert Mueller, Melinda Haag, Robin C. Ashton, Laurie O.
Robinson, Robert L. Listenbee, Catherine Connell McSherry:
We are tired of being bullied, harassed and threatened for standing
up for our civil rights, for our refusal to go along with corporate and
educational fraud perpetrated against us that was designed to cover up
criminal activities, insurance fraud, money laundering, and government
fraud.
My son has lost everything for standing up and refusing to go along
with others. He has lost his home, his land, and his things. He is
divorced because his British wife did not understand an Americans
compelling sense to fight for his civil rightshis life, liberty, pursuit of
happiness. He has not seen his American son since Nov, 2010, because
his British wife is withholding little Joel from our son, in spite of the
requests by the U.S. Embassy in London for her to reestablish
communications between my son and Joel.
We refuse to be part of the cover up the government condoned and has
perpetuated by withholding records from us after they rubber stamped
accreditation agencies who condoned the original cover up that
Western Seminary demanded. (A123)
April 2, 2012
Letter to President Obama, Hillary Rodham Clinton, Valerie Jarrett, Eric Holder,
Arne Duncan, Robert Mueller, Melinda Haag, Robin C. Ashton, Laurie O.
Robinson, Robert L. Listenbee, Catherine Connell McSherry:
My complaint about the misconduct by Assistant United States
Attorney, James A. Scharf relates to my FOIA requests that underscore
fraud, academic fraud, negligence and abuse during the Spellings
administration that is now in full cover up mode by the U.S.
Department of Education by your friend, Arne Duncan. I know it is
embarrassing to learn and have evidence that Spellings conducted her
administration poorly and was motivated to cover up her failures.
This needs to end Mr. President. This needs to be resolved, and I need
your help for a resolution that does not require us to just move on, or

xix

continue to force us to tolerate multiple fronts of fraud. I should not be

paying taxes for Mr. Scharfs salary to bully and emotionally abuse me
and my family for seeking FOIA records. In fact, I should never have to
file a tort case. Randy has spent one-fourth of his life dealing with the
immoral and unethical demands by Western Seminary, ATS and
NWCCUand the USDOEin which they sought to entangle Randy
and me. He is not well his mind is harmed, and he suffers from
clinical depression and PTSD. I fear this is going to end tragically. If
this ends in tragedy, then it will be linked to you, Eric Holder, and Arne
Duncan, for defaulting your responsibilities.
PLEASE correct the government corruption that condoned
unlawfulness by Western, ATS, and NWCCU. Please show America
that what Western Seminary has done does not represent the kind of
American values we hold dear. Please keep your word. (A084)
April 2, 2012
Letter to President Obama, Hillary Rodham Clinton, Valerie Jarrett, Eric Holder,
Arne Duncan, Robert Mueller, Melinda Haag, Robin C. Ashton, Laurie O.
Robinson, Robert L. Listenbee, Catherine Connell McSherry:
Thus, I am writing to ask for your help, Secretary Clinton. Your
diplomatic skills, along with those of President Obama and Congress
made a world of difference in other circumstances of parental
alienation such as for the American father, David Goldman, of New
Jersey, and his 9-year-old son, Sean Goldman, who was held and
alienated from his father.
(http://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2009a/12/134047.htm)
It is completely understandable that the Allisters dont understand
America, much less Americas government, but it doesnt excuse them
of actions to alienate Joel from Randy and alienate Randy from Joel.
They have used to their advantage the Western fraud that the
government supports to the governments advantagethus, the U.S.
Attorney, James Scharf, told me its time he [Randy] moves on. It
would be hard to find any community in America what condones the
actions and beliefs of Western (or Mr. Scharf), and it is likely equally
hard to find a community in England that would condone such
unconscionable acts and beliefs as well. However, because the
government wants to cover up its own negligence, the failures by the
Spellings administration to correctly oversee accreditation agencies,
our government has dumped this whole mess on Randy and destroyed
his life, his marriage and his father-son relationship regardless of the
governments accountability. These are not American values we can be
proud ofand I am not pleased, and I am sure many in America and

England will be equally displeased.

Randy has lost everything in his life. His house; his things; his land;
everything. What Randy has suffered and is dealing with is
unbelievable and surreal. He doesnt have money to hire an attorney,
which allowed the Allisters to manipulate the Court with
misrepresentations. If it was not for the recent action by the U.S.
Embassy, continued obstruction and no knowledge by Randy (and us)
about Joel would have occurred. Can you please help American
grandparents who desire to know and communicate with their
grandson, and an American daddy who desires to communicate with his
beloved son? (A083)
April 2, 2012
Letter to President Obama, Hillary Rodham Clinton, Valerie Jarrett, Eric Holder,
Arne Duncan, Robert Mueller, Melinda Haag, Robin C. Ashton, Laurie O.
Robinson, Robert L. Listenbee, Catherine Connell McSherry:
I am a woman, a mother, and a grandmother. I am not chained to
the sink, barefooted, illiterate, or need a man to do my thinking for me.
Before Mr. Scharf was born, I had successfully graduated from college
while I was married with three children. I paid my own college tuition
with money I had worked for myself. I bought my own car and I earned
two lifetime teaching credentials. I am now nearly 72-years-old, a
retired teacher, and if necessary I just might beat Mr. Scharf in an arm
wrestling contest due to chopping my own wood since 1977. I have
been dealing with this case for the last eleven years, and my son has
been dealing with this case for one-fourth of his life.
Since 2010, I have experienced intense emotional anguish concerning
the potential that my son might fatally perish as a result of the
governments corruption and ongoing cover up rather than accountably
coming clean about its negligence of duty. Ive had horrifying
nightmares about the destruction perpetrated by Department employees
cooperating with accreditors whose goals are to force my son and me to
accept their unconscionable and unlawful acts to help Western
Seminary conceal fraud and a child molester as the only way my son
could finish his education.
The record is very clear regarding the emotional damage and trauma
Randy has suffered, while Dale and I have extending ourselves out
completely in order to deal with the current issues and to keep Randy
afloat. This has taken my savings. Dale has no savings and we are
defending justice only on our small retirement, because we are not
going to accept the Obama administration robbing us of our civil

xxi

liberties.
I feel helpless and angry due to being treated this way. I feel angry that
my family is being treated this way by the government, not only by Mr.
Scharf, but that government leaders would rather bear their teeth at me,
an old lady victim, rather than hold government, accreditation, and
school people responsible for their unlawful actions.
Ultimately, this is going to end badly. Destroying someones life leaves
people depressed and suicidal. That is what Western did, that is what
ATS did to help its member school (Western Seminary), and that is
what the government has done with taxpayer money. I fear Randy
wont make it and this mega-corruption will cost his life. He has
nothing to live for. Based upon the malice conducted against me by
U.S. Attorney, James Scharf, I expect that this may be intended by the
government to end tragically rather than doing whats right and
enforcing federal regulations which is also linked to Western, ATS, and
NWCCU. People can only be pushed so far. Randys damages are
immense. Randy has nowhere to move on to, and corrupt government
acts working to divide us were a very bad choice.
I respectfully request appropriate disciplinary action be taken
concerning Mr. Scharf who abused me. I request intervention by the
Office of Professional Responsibility in order to prevent additional
abuse against me (and my son and family) in the future by Mr. Scharf.
Because if this continues, most of all against a mentally and
emotionally shattered and beat up person like Randy, I will not be
responsible for what happens. Thank you in advance for your attention
to the urgency of my request due to my age, due to my sons condition,
and due to the necessity for Mr. Scharf as a paid government employee
to conduct himself in a lawfully professional manner toward me and
my family. The Obama administration needs to find some other family
to abuse. (A103)
July 2, 2012
Letter to President Obama, Robert Mueller:
No student and their family should have to endure the corruption
being forced on me, my son Joel, my ex-wife Susan and her family the
Lord Bishop Donald Allister, Janice Allister, MD., John and Rosie, my
parents Carol and Dale and my extended family. This lawsuit, while
seeking damages regarding what we have endured, also aims to provide
a citable case for the welfare of the People. (A125)
May 13, 2013

Letter to President Obama, Valerie Jarrett, Eric Holder, Arne Duncan, Robert
Mueller, Melinda Haag, Robin C. Ashton, Laurie O. Robinson, Robert L.
Listenbee, Catherine Connell McSherry:
Your administration, and specifically, Eric Holder and Arne
Duncan, could have at any time enforced government regulations
against ATS, NWCCU, and Western Seminary, but they and their staff
outrageously refused. Instead, your administration chose to cover up
educational fraud by ATS, NWCCU, and Western Seminary that
Margaret Spellings condoned in 2008 and fight me and my parents in a
no holds barred fight with public money.
By not enforcing laws that protect students like me, your administration
destroyed my life, and damaged people in my life who I love (my son
Joel, my now ex-wife Susan Allister, my parents and extended family
and the parents of my ex-wife Donald Allister, Bishop of
Peterborough, his wife Janice and their extended family). The Allisters
are not even Americans, yet your administration used public money to
damage all of our lives so that no one would find out about the
outrageous government corruption and educational fraud under
Spellings. Obviously, the Allisters dont want to be involved with
anyone who the government has spent hundreds of thousands, if not a
million dollars or so demonizing because it must be true if the
government will go to the length it has against Randy!
What did we dome, my family, Susan and her familyto deserve to
be treated this way?
What did we do to justify your administration doing what it has done
and continues to do?
What did my four-year-old son Joel do to deserve to be treated this way
by his American governmentfor his entire life and future to be
treated as acceptable collateral damage in order to cover up
government corruption and educational fraud?
I have lost everything in my life: my house, my land, my education, my
future, my family--everything and everyone dear to me, because your
administrations priority was to cover up government corruption and
educational fraud by false and misleading statements, while
psychologically torturing and emotionally water boarding me to the
point of irreparable harm.
With all due respect Mr. President, when will this reach the outrageous
level? Because I really would be interested to know.

xxiii

Your administrations handling of this case has completely destroyed

my life, and significantly damaged the lives of others.
How many lives must be damaged by your administrations acts to
cover up government corruption and educational fraud? (A006)
November 12, 2014
Letter to President Obama, Valerie Jarrett, Eric Holder, Arne Duncan, Robin C.
Ashton, Laurie O. Robinson, Robert L. Listenbee, Catherine Connell McSherry
and every U.S Attorney in each district of America (except Guam & Puerto
Rico):
Your Administration knew or had the information to know,
including you Mr. President, including you; that what Margaret
Spellings had done had no legal support, let alone the actions of ATS,
NWCCU and Western Seminary. The U.S. Constitution, Congress, and
State of California have never empowered either accreditation agencies
(20 US Code 1099b) or schools to trump the U.S. Constitution or a
state constitution, federal or state laws, or decisional cases.
Your administration used public money to defend and cover
up the corruption and fraud of the Religious, because their
dishonesty intersected with the governments need and priority
to cover up government corruption and failures within the
Department of Education.
Your administration has violated my civil rights at every turn, covered
up or destroyed material so that it cannot be uncovered, threaten
people, misled the public and the courts, used public money to bully
and beat me up, financially breaking my family while using public
money, used and manipulated Susan and treated Joel as a pawn, among
many more things.
Because I would not capitulate to the government corruption and
educational fraud, your Administration embarked on a path, which
retaliated against my family and me using deception, and force, thus
causing irreparable damage. It is one thing for your Administration to
go out of its way to demonize me and destroy my life, but it is another
to take it out against my wife and our son. What your Administration
has done is wicked and incredibly fucked up, Barack. The ultimate dick
move done on a family to my wife and our child.
Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that
matter. - Martin Luther King, Jr.

What could my family and me have done to deserve such malevolence

by the United States of America and your Administration? The
destruction of my family and me is your legacy before the nation, not
Transparency and the Rule of Law will be the Touchstones of this
Presidency.
As Eric Holder is responsible for the governments litigation strategy
(28 U.S.C. 516, 519), which eviscerated my family, my life and my
liberties, you, as President are responsible for those under you. You are
ultimately responsible for allowing and covering for the Religious to
commit unspeakable evil against my family, me and others.
No God condones this terror. No grievance justifies these actions.
There can be no reasoning, no negotiation, with this brand of evil.
The only language understood by killers like this, is the language
of force President Barack Obama regarding religiously
motivated fanatics - ISIS on Sept 24, 2014.
As the evidence demonstrates in this document, I have every right to
seek justified retaliation against these religious terrorists. Not a single
school of the other 259 ATS schools, not a single instructor from any of
those schools has spoken up against what Western Seminary et al,
Daniel Aleshire and Jeremiah McCarthy have been doing. We are not
simply fighting religiously motivated fanatics in the Middle East, the
fight is here in America with the Religious these right-wing
extremists, who see themselves above the law in every way, who
demand to be treated differently because they claim superior morality
or religious exception. These people are not godly and there is no way
that any true god, if such actually existed, would condone what they are
doing. They dont represent good-natured people, that fill our places of
worship, that seek to do good in their communities. The Religious I
have fought, they are of the darkest evil mankind can muster and you
and your Administration protected them with the publics money
because their corruption intersected with the governments
malevolence. (A121)
April 12, 2015
Letter to President Obama, Valerie Jarrett, Sally Yates, Leslie Caldwell, Arne
Duncan, Loretta Lynch, Robin C. Ashton, Laurie O. Robinson, Robert L.
Listenbee, Catherine Connell McSherry, Ron Taylor, Steve Korch, Gary Tuck,
Bert Downs, Randal Roberts, Rob Wiggins, Sanda Elman, M. James Sawyer,
Daniel Aleshire, Dale Wilson, Carol Nye-Wilson:
You got what you wanted - Catastrophic Personal Injury

xxv

And for those who claim to be "Christian", there is nothing about

Christianity in what you have done, or continue to do.
You have completely destroyed everything in my life and everything I
will ever be. I have spent basically a 1/3 of my life being screwed over
by Western Seminary and 10 years of my life being screwed over by
the United States of America / Obama Administration (6 + years).
All of you, have done everything possible you could, to eviscerate my
life, while promoting false and misleading statements, that you knew at
the time they were being made were false, misleading and had no
evidence to back it up and no law to support. The record is clear, the
history of this case betrays these facts. Say what you want, many
people now have the facts and evidences and just because you ignore or
promote false and misleading statements, doesn't mean that the facts
and evidences go away or don't exist.
.... it is not like you can just erase them away as some people do to
cover what they have done .....
Because of what you all have done, I will spend the rest of my life
being screwed over time and time again over this. I am 48 years old. I
have no interest spending the rest of my life, being America's bitch or
living out your insane need to screw my family and me over.
I have stated, and I will reiterate it here, I have every right to seek
justified retaliation for what you have done to my life and family. I
want to assure all of you reading this -- including you Mr.
President, Sally Yates, Leslie Caldwell, Loretta Lynch, that those
involved at Western Seminary will pay a significant price for what they
have done, what they continue to do and for what they did with the help
of others to destroy my family and life at all costs, while manipulating
3rd parties to conduct as much evil as they possibly could against us.
(A129)
Mr. President, what is America to infer about this disastrously mishandled
situation by your Administration?
Exactly why is it so important to beat the crap out of a student and his family,
his mother in her 70s and his 100% disabled and retired army officer father for
refusing to go along with government corruption and educational fraud
purposely aimed to cover for political insiders and the reprobate Religious
leaders in America? Like when does it make sense to use and instruct a gaggle
of government attorneys to obstruct justice and abuse power consuming public
money while in public office, all the while vilifying a person to the point of

destroying his life, future and family for not going along with the racketeering
scam?
No matter how hard the Religious and the political insiders have tried, the public
is going to find out what was done to my family and me. United States v. Smith,
776 F.2d 1104, 1114 (3d Cir. 1985) ([T]he public has a substantial interest in
the integrity or lack of integrity of those who serve them in public office.).
I am simply going to take matters into my own hands.
Sincerely,
/s/
Randy

xxvii