Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Agent Orange in Korea - FPIF
Agent Orange in Korea - FPIF
Agent Orange in Korea - FPIF
Whistleblowers have unearthed the widespread use of Agent Orange by the U.S. military in Korea.
ByGwynKirk(http://fpif.org/authors/gwynkirk/)andChristineAhn(http://fpif.org/authors/christineahn/),July7,2011.
Share
Print (http://www.printfriendly.com/print?url=http%3A%2F%2Ffpif.org%2Fagent_orange_in_korea%2F)
In May, three former U.S. soldiers admitted to dumping hundreds of barrels of chemical substances,
including Agent Orange, at Camp Carroll in South Korea in 1978. This explosive news was a harsh reminder to South
Koreans of the high costs and lethal trail left behind by the ongoing U.S. military presence.
We basically buried our garbage in their backyards, U.S. veteran Steve House told a local news station in Phoenix,
Arizona. A heavy equipment operator in the Army, House said he was ordered to dig a ditch the length of a city block to
bury 55-gallon drums marked with bright yellow and orange labels: Province of Vietnam, Compound Orange. House
said that the military buried 250 drums of defoliants stored on the base, which served then as the U.S. Army Material
Support Center in Korea. Later they buried chemicals transported from other places on as many as 20 occasions,
totaling up to 600 barrels.
This stuff was just seeping through the barrels, said Robert Travis (http://news.blogs.cnn.com/2011/05/20/agentorange-buried-in-s-korea-vets-say/), another veteran now living in West Virginia. There was a smell, I couldnt describe
it, just sickly sweet. Immediately after wheeling the barrels from a warehouse at Camp Carroll, Travis developed a
severe rash; other health problems emerged later (http://www.kpho.com/story/14906593/valley-veteran-blows-whistleon-burial-of-agent-orange). He said there were approximately 250 drums, all OD (olive drab) green with a stripe
around the barrel dated 1967 for the Republic of Vietnam.
A third soldier, Richard Cramer (http://www.kpho.com/story/14906593/valley-veteran-blows-whistle-on-burial-of-agentorange) of Illinois, said that his feet went numb as he buried barrels of Agent Orange at Camp Carroll. He spent two
months in a military hospital and now has swollen ankles and toes, chronic arthritis, eye infections, and impaired
hearing. If we prove what they did was wrong, says Cramer, they should fess up and clean it up and take care of the
people involved.
The three veterans are now seriously ill. Steve House (http://news.blogs.cnn.com/2011/05/20/agent-orange-buried-in-skorea-vets-say/) suffers from diabetes and neuropathy, two out of 15 diseases officially linked to Agent Orange. This is a
burden Ive carried around for 35 years, House, aged 54, told Associated Press reporters. I just recently found out that
I have to have some major surgery If Im going to check out, I want to do it with a clean slate.
Korea United. The U.S. camp is situated just 630 meters away from the Nakdong River, says Chung, which is the water
source for major cities like Daegu and Busan.
Cancer rates in the Chilgok area near Camp Carroll were up to 18.3 percent higher than the national average between
2005 and 2009, according to Statistics Koreas website (http://english.irib.ir/analysis/commentaries/item/74967-usadmits-dumping-dangerous-chemicals-in-s-korea?tmpl=component&print=1), and mortality rates for nervous system
diseases were above the national average.
The joint ROK-U.S. team is using ground-penetrating radar and electrical resistivity devices at 41 sites since the news
broke in late May. According to a team official, the USFK is not just worried about dioxin, but other toxic and
carcinogenic materials, which soil and water tests can detect. Indeed, investigation of an underground stream and
groundwater near Camp Carroll has shown traces of PCE
(http://english.chosun.com/site/data/html_dir/2011/06/17/2011061700328.html), a known carcinogen that attacks the
nervous system and can cause reproduction problems. The Chilgok regional government sealed the well upon learning
from the joint Korea-U.S. team that the amount of PCE exceeded the level for acceptable drinking water.
(http://www.boston.com/news/world/asia/articles/2005/02/27/vietnamese_seeking_redress_from_us_in_agent_orange_suit/)
reports strong evidence that exposures to herbicides is associated with five serious diseases, including Hodgkins
disease and a form of leukemia and suggestive evidence that herbicides might cause birth defects and cancer. A
major factor limiting serious research into dioxin contamination is the high costs. According to Dreyfuss, it cost $600 to
$1000 to test one single soil or tissue sample for tiny traces of Agent Orange dioxin.
Since 1981, U.S. veterans of the Vietnam War who were exposed to dioxin have been entitled to register with the
Veteran Administrations Agent Orange Registry. Of the nearly 3 million U.S. soldiers who served in Vietnam,
approximately 300,000 veterans are on the list and entitled to free annual health exams. In a 2003 article in the San
Francisco Chronicle (http://articles.sfgate.com/2003-04-21/news/17487148_1_dioxin-levels-defoliants-agent-orange), David
Perlman wrote that more than 22,000 vets have successfully claimed disability and are entitled to free long-term
treatment for a variety of disorders that are presumptively caused by exposure to dioxin. Compensation has ranged
from $104 to $2,193 a month.
U.S. veterans have attempted to sue the manufacturers of Agent Orange for compensation. In 1984, seven U.S. chemical
companies agreed to settle a suit brought by U.S. veterans in 1979. In making this settlement, the companies refused to
accept liability, claiming that the scientific evidence did not prove Agent Orange was responsible for the medical
conditions alleged. By 1997, 291,000 U.S. veterans had received a total of $180 million dollars over a period of 12 years.
My brother was given $362, and me, I was given $60, recalls U.S. veteran George Johnson. My brother has never been
able to have kids.
South Korean veterans who served in the Vietnam War also attempted to sue Agent Orange manufacturers. In 2006, the
Korea Times (http://www.organicconsumers.org/monsanto/orange060216.cfm) reported that the Seoul High Court ruled
that Dow Chemical and Monsanto should pay $63 billion won ($62 million) to a group of 6,700 Korean veterans who
first filed lawsuits against the company in 1999. However, this ruling is largely symbolic since the Korean authorities
cannot force the companies to comply.
When asked why he came forward now, Steve House said, Ive wanted the government to take care of this nightmare
Ive had to live with for the last 30 years. I dont want to poison kids or anything, and I dont want to hurt GIs.
For House and other vets, also at issue is the question of medical compensation. According to the U.S. Veterans Affairs
website (http://www.publichealth.va.gov/PUBLICHEALTH/exposures/agentorange/korea.asp), Veterans who served in
or near the Korean Demilitarized Zone (DMZ) anytime between April 1, 1968 and August 31, 1971 and who have a
disease VA recognizes as associated with Agent Orange exposure are presumed to have been exposed to herbicides.
These Veterans do not have to show they were exposed to Agent Orange to get disability compensation for these
diseases. Veterans like House, however, who were exposed to Agent Orange after this time period, or in other parts of
Korea outside of the DMZ, are not considered eligible for disability compensation.
Although more information is likely to emerge from the joint U.S.-R.O.K. investigation in the coming weeks, both the
U.S. and Korean public must ask and demand answers to many urgent questions. What happened to the barrels of
Agent Orange and contaminated soil at Camp Carroll? How much dioxin and other contaminants have leached into the
soils surrounding Camp Carroll and other U.S. military bases? Will the U.S. government provide medical assistance and
financial compensation to the veterans who handled a substance that was known to be toxic in 1978? Who will
compensate the Korean people who may have been exposed to these contaminants that the U.S. military knew of as
far back as 1992, but never told the So.uth Korean government
Based on the experience of thousands of U.S. vets and civilians who live around U.S. bases in this country and
overseas even routine military operations can have serious long-term costs to human health and the environment.
Without adequately addressing its toxic legacy in South Korea, the U.S. military continues to take fertile land to expand
and create new bases, as it did in seizing rice paddies from farmers in Pyongtaek. The ROK-U.S. naval base now under
construction on Jeju Island will have a devastating impact on the islands marine ecology, affecting fishermen and
women sea divers who depend on the clean sea for their livelihood, and the Korean people who rely on the ocean for
seafood. The blind rhetoric of national security must no longer trump human security, certainly not when the U.S.
military isnt even willing to provide adequate medical care to its own veterans and protection to the Korean people
they are purportedly in Korea to defend.
Christine Ahn is the executive director of the Korea Policy Institute and a columnist for Foreign Policy In Focus
(http://www.fpif.org), and Gwyn Kirk is a member of Women for Genuine Security and a contributor to FPIF.
Issues: Health (http://fpif.org/issues/health/)
Regions: Asia & Pacific (http://fpif.org/regions/asia-pacific/), South Korea (http://fpif.org/regions/south-korea/)
Tags: Agent Orange (http://fpif.org/tag/agent-orange/), military (http://fpif.org/tag/military-2/), South Korea
(http://fpif.org/tag/south-korea/), veterans (http://fpif.org/tag/veterans/), Veterans Administration
(http://fpif.org/tag/veterans-administration/)
73
13Comments
ForeignPolicyInFocus
Recommend 9
Share
1790
Login
SortbyBest
Jointhediscussion
Mcblue21 3yearsago
Iwasstationedinkorea1968andagainin1971.Havehadanagentorangephysical.IhaveIschemicheartdisease,diabetesandi
havebeentold3areasonmyleftlungmaybelungcancer.AftercominghomeIdevelopedlargeboilsandleasionsonmyleftside
ofmybody.Ihonestlybeleiveitwasusedalloverkorea.
2
Reply Share
John>Mcblue21 ayearago
IwasstationedatOsanAFBinKoreafrom6971.Ihavemanyofthesameproblems.Iwastoldtheentireperimeterofthe
basewashandsprayedafterthePueblocrisis.Therewasnovegetationontheperimeterofthebase.Itoohavemanyof
thesameproblemsandjusthadahearttransplant.
Reply Share
EdwardSurprenant ayearago
IwasstationinkoreaatCAMPHUMPHREYSFROM1970TO1972.Inthespringof1971iseenROK'SOR(KATYSA'S)spraying
aroundtheairfieldfence.AshorttimelaterweweretoldnottodrinkanywateroreatanyfoodinthevillageANJEONGRI..
Waterbagswereputuparoundthehangerareaattheairfieldandcompanyarea.Ashorttimeafterthesprayingallthefoliage
wasdeadaroundthefenceareaandsomeofthericefieldsIhavetype2diabetesmelliyus,heartproblem,andparkinsondisease
myemailesurprenant@cfl.rr.com
1
Reply Share
Byrongross 3yearsago
Isthereanyonewhoknowsifagentorangewasusedinkoreaandwhenandwhere.
1
Reply Share
John>Byrongross ayearago
SawbarrelsofitunloadedoffC123'satOsanAFB.
Reply Share
PhilDavis>John 9monthsago
IsawthemsprayingAgentOrangebyplaneENEofthelandingstripOSAN19741975.Alsosawbarrelsbeing
buriedNEofCampCarroll1974.
Reply Share
Hotlitesaz 3yearsago
iwasinfantryintheDMZinfeb1968andihaveCOPDandbronicasthmaandtheykeepsayingsowhat.ipatroledinthefields
thatweresprayedandthisarticleproveswhatithought.i'mapatriotalso,butitsuresucks.America,weneedtothinkabout
whatwedobeforewedoit.nomoreofourboysshouldbepoisoned.
1
Reply Share
Fpence662 3yearsago
IservedonaHawkMissilecompound80milessouthwestofSeoulin1969and1970.Oursitedidnothaveanyvegetationandit
wasknownthatherbicideswereused.ImovedbarrelsofchemicalsatASCOMCityinSeptemberof1969,beforebeingsenttomy
dutystation.Idevelopedaacneproblemshortlyafterthesedetails.Itgotsosevereitleftscarsonmyface.In2009theVAalso
toldmethatIhaveChronicLymphocyticLeukemia.Ithinkthereisaconnectionfrommytimein1969,servinginKorea.The
VAhastoldmeproveit!
1
Reply Share
kimchiman13 16daysago
Subject:AgentOrangeKorea
Subject:AgentOrangeKorea
WhereistheTruth?
Feb2015,IwasattheVAHospitalin
Marion,ILgettingshotstomyrightkneeandhipsattheOrthopedic
Clinic.AsIwasdiscussingsomeofmyotherissueswithmylimbs,
theyproceedtoclaimthatIprobablehaveneuropathyinmyhandsand
possiblefeet.GoingtorecommendmetoaNeurologistforthatand
someotherissues!NeuropathyisanothersymptomofAgentOrange
Dioxins,inlessthenayearIhavebeendetectedwith3A.O.
Illnesses!
Ontopofthat,Ihadaanother
veteranoftheKoreanDMZcontactmeaboutA.O.Heserveduponthe
DMZonly8788.Heexplainedtomethathisnursementiontohim,
askingifhebeenincontactwithAgentOrangewhatsoever!Hedid
notevenknowthatA.O.wasusedinKorea.Whenthenursemention
it,hestarteddoingsomeonlineresearchandrealizethathis
serviceinKoreaquitepossibleputhimincontactwithA.O.
seemore
Reply Share
Brian 3yearsago
IamBrianMcEwan,andwasstationedatCampHumphreysandamlookingforanyotherVetwhowasstationedatCamp
Humphreys6970.IwasanMPin728th7thdiv.amnowsufferingwithCLLarethereanyofyououttherewhoalsoescourted
orwitnessedanyROK'ssprayingthedefoliants?Pleasecontactmejackandfrostys@optonline.net.IamfightingwiththeDOD
anditseemsthatIamhittingbrickwalls.
Reply Share
MJds 3yearsago
Yes,upontheImjinriverandbythecitizenscontrolarea1968to1971.
Reply Share
Barbergoss 3yearsago
IservedatCampCarrollKoreain1989.Ihaveallthesymtomsofagentorangepoisoning.Theburialsitewas2feetfrommy
IservedatCampCarrollKoreain1989.Ihaveallthesymtomsofagentorangepoisoning.Theburialsitewas2feetfrommy
placeofduty.Iaman11yearvet.TheonlyhopeyouhaveisthethanksandsupportofthepeoplearoundyouthatsaysTHANKS
foryourservice.TheArmywillneveradmitthismistakeuntilweredead.Butidontgiveadamn.Ilovemycountry.Iwoulddoit
again.Iamatruepatriot.
Reply Share
IkhwanKim 4yearsago
IwonderitmightbecomeaflashpointforallotherUSalliestoponderUSbasesinitsterritories.ItwilllikelyreigniteantiU.S.
basemovementinadjacentcountriesaccordingtotheresultoutofthejointinvestigation.
Reply Share
WHAT'STHIS?
ALSOONFOREIGNPOLICYINFOCUS
10ThingstoKnowAbouttheGOPsIranLetterSponsor
6commentsamonthago
TheGulfCooperationCouncilCluelessAboutNew
SecurityMeasures
AvatarRegulatorScoutIwishyouwouldtry.Theseterroristsfriends
ofyoursareacanceronhumanityandneedremovedASAP.The
1commentamonthago
StrengtheningMultilateralDefenseofHumanRightsin
theAmericas
FootingtheBillWhileIsraelThumbsItsNose
8comments9daysago
AvatarLuisOneofthebiggestconnedjobofthetwentiethcentury
wastheestablishmentofthestateofIsraelbyEuropeanZionist.
They
AvatarHelgaFellayYouareabsolutelyright.Whatyouforgotto
mentionwastheUSsupported"BlueCoup"attemptwhich
happenedonly
Subscribe
AddDisqustoyoursite
Privacy
AvatarteeveeWhyistheHouthirebellionillegitimate?Yemenhas
beensubjugated,subvertedandberatedbytheGCC.Itisa
1comment4daysago
ForeignPolicyInFocusAprojectoftheInstituteforPolicyStudies(http://ipsdc.org)
ContentunderaCreativeCommonsAttributionlicence(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/us/)