Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BelAir Ericsson Wi-Fi RFQ Technical Responses Final
BelAir Ericsson Wi-Fi RFQ Technical Responses Final
Technical Responses
To
Ericsson
TECHNICAL SPECFICIATION
FOR WI-FI MODULE RFP
Document Date:
Document Version:
Security Status:
13 November, 2011
Final, v1.0
Confidential
Contact:
Kevin Cordell
Vice President WW Channels
Phone: +1.443.398.6693
Email: kevin@belairnetworks.com
David Park
VP System Architecture
Phone: +1.613.852.1967
Email: dpark@belairnetworks.com
1 of 48
13 November, 2011
Table of Contents
Table of Contents .......................................................................................................................... 2
Table of Figures ............................................................................................................................ 3
Summary....................................................................................................................................... 5
1 General requirements (Section 1.0) ...................................................................................... 6
1.1
Regulatory requirements (Section 1.1).......................................................................... 6
1.2
Interoperability (Wi-Fi alliance certification program) (Section 1.2) ............................... 8
1.3
Quality (Section 1.3) ...................................................................................................... 9
2 Mechanical requirements (Section 2.0) ............................................................................... 11
2.1
Mechanical design (Section 2.1) ................................................................................. 11
2.2
Environment (Section 2.2) ........................................................................................... 13
2.3
Antennas (Section 2.3) ................................................................................................ 14
2.4
Cable / Connectors (Section 2.4) ................................................................................ 16
2.5
Test Point (Section 2.5) ............................................................................................... 16
3 Electrical requirements (Section 3.0) .................................................................................. 18
3.1
Power consumption (Section 3.1) ............................................................................... 18
3.2
Power supply (Section 3.2) ......................................................................................... 19
3.3
Control interface (Section 3.3)..................................................................................... 20
3.4
Communication interface (Section 3.4) ....................................................................... 20
4 Radio requirements (Section 4.0) ....................................................................................... 21
4.1
Transmitter output power (Section 4.1) ....................................................................... 22
4.2
Transmitter spurious emission (Section 4.2) ............................................................... 23
4.3
Receiver blocking (Section 4.3)................................................................................... 26
5 Transmission requirements (Section 5.0) ........................................................................... 31
5.1
Authentication (5.1) ..................................................................................................... 31
5.2
Topology and link discovery (Section 5.2)................................................................... 32
5.3
Tunnels, Security and Encryption (Section 5.3) .......................................................... 32
5.4
QoS (Section 5.4) ........................................................................................................ 33
5.5
Transport Configuration (Section 5.5) ......................................................................... 34
5.6
Access Gateway Address from Small-RBS (Section 5.6) ........................................... 35
5.7
GPS positioning (Section 5.7) ..................................................................................... 35
5.8
Status messages (Section 5.8) ................................................................................... 39
5.9
Wi-Fi as backhaul (Section 5.9) .................................................................................. 39
6 MMI requirements (Section 6.0) .......................................................................................... 40
6.1
Button and LED-indicators (Section 6.1) ..................................................................... 40
6.2
Messages to cellular (Section 6.2) .............................................................................. 40
7 Security (Section 7.0) .......................................................................................................... 41
8 Test and verification (Section 8.0)....................................................................................... 43
8.1
Wi-Fi-module production test (Section 8.1) ................................................................. 43
8.2
Wi-Fi-module type approval (Section 8.2) ................................................................... 44
8.3
Small-RBS verification (Section 8.3) ........................................................................... 44
8.4
Small-RBS type approval (Section 8.4) ....................................................................... 46
8.5
Small-RBS production test (Section 8.5) ..................................................................... 46
9 Summary ............................................................................................................................. 47
2 of 48
13 November, 2011
Table of Figures
Figure 1: Wi-Fi Certificate for the BelAir20E/EO ........................................................................... 9
Figure 2: Wi-Fi Certificate for the BelAir100NE/SNE .................................................................... 9
Figure 3: 10cm x 20cm Wi-Fi Module Conceptual Layout ....................................................... 11
Figure 4: Wi-Fi Module Total Thickness ..................................................................................... 12
Figure 5: BelAir DRUe Card Thermal Interfaces ......................................................................... 12
Figure 6: BelAir100SNE Chassis Thermal Interfaces ................................................................. 13
Figure 7: Wi-Fi Module 3x3 MIMO Antenna ................................................................................ 14
Figure 8: 5 GHz Antenna Elevation Radiation Pattern ................................................................ 15
Figure 9: 5GHz Antenna Azimuth Radiation Pattern .................................................................. 15
Figure 10: 2.4GHz Antenna Azimuth Radiation Pattern ............................................................. 16
Figure 10: RF filtering architecture for co-location ...................................................................... 21
Figure 12: RF filtering specifications ........................................................................................... 22
Figure 11: NMS map screenshot ................................................................................................ 36
Figure 12: Detailed NMS screenshots ........................................................................................ 36
Figure 13: BelView Business Intelligence Module ...................................................................... 38
Figure 14: BelView Synthetic Client ............................................................................................ 38
Figure 15: BelView Heat Maps ................................................................................................... 38
Figure 16: Wi-Fi-Module Production Test Setup ......................................................................... 43
Figure 17: Receive Sensitivity Test Setup .................................................................................. 45
Figure 18: Small-RBS Wi-Fi Throughput Test Setup .................................................................. 45
Figure 19: Proposed Test Setup for Production Testing of Integrated Wi-Fi Module.................. 46
3 of 48
13 November, 2011
Protected by U.S. Patents: 7,660,559; 7,545,782; 7,171,223;7,164,667; 7,154,356; 7,030,712; D501,195; 7,433,343; 7,162,234;
7,433,361. Patents pending in the U.S. and other countries. BelAir Networks, the BelAir logo, BelAir200, BelAir100, BelAir20,
BelView and BelView NMS are trademarks of BelAir Networks Inc.
4 of 48
13 November, 2011
Summary
This document includes responses to requirements outlined in the Ericsson Technical
Specification for Wi-Fi-Module RFQ, Document No. 2/1056-FCP 121 8519 Uen, Rev A, 201110-28.
Each section represents the section from the Ericsson requirements document and the section
heading numeration is identical to the Ericssons original document. Original Ericsson
requirement text is in italic. BelAir responses begin with ANSWER: followed by compliancy
status. Additional solution description as applicable is also included.
BelAir has presented a compliant response to Ericssons requirements.
5 of 48
13 November, 2011
6 of 48
13 November, 2011
emission specifications at 4W EIRP in 2.4GHz. BelAir has also provided pricing for alternate
models that meet a 1W EIRP and 100mW EU specified EIRP.
Radio
EMC
Safety
RF Health/SAR
Fully Compliant
Fully Compliant
Fully Compliant
Fully Compliant
Fully Compliant
Fully Compliant to EN
50385, which calls for EN
50385, that uses ICNIRP
guidelines
7 of 48
13 November, 2011
Fully Compliant
Fully Compliant
Fully Compliant
Fully Compliant
Fully Compliant
Fully Compliant
Fully Compliant
8 of 48
13 November, 2011
9 of 48
13 November, 2011
The above should be interpreted as a really low return rate the first 5 years. After this time, the
product is exchanged.
We are considering not repairing faulty units, just replacing them. This means that we will only
send back faulty units for root-cause analysis in order to improve product quality.
ANSWER: Fully Compliant
BelAirs Hardware return rate is typically well under 0.5% for our cards and we have over 9
years of experience of shipping carrier grade outdoor Wi-Fi cards to base this on.
For example, BelAirs last 12-month return rate for our 802.11n full FCC specification MIMO 4W
EIRP outdoor card is 0.09%. This is a strong indicator of the high quality built into our designs
and product lines as these products are deployed in harsh environments worldwide and subject
to extremes of temperature, humidity and vibration.
Through continuous process improvements, BelAirs goal is to improve the reliability of our
products with each new release, while retaining their market competitiveness.
10 of 48
13 November, 2011
11 of 48
13 November, 2011
12 of 48
13 November, 2011
Thermal Interfaces
13 of 48
13 November, 2011
14 of 48
13 November, 2011
15 of 48
13 November, 2011
16 of 48
13 November, 2011
accessible from one side of the Wi-Fi-module. Mechanical tear down (removing a lid or similar)
is expected during the R&D testing.
ANSWER: Fully Compliant
BelAir products are designed with 0.8mm test points. The Wi-Fi Module test points will be
located on one side to facilitate accessibility. At the onset of this program, BelAir recommends
we hold a technical interchange session to discuss the exact locations of the test points. BelAir
will share our experience in the testing of signal integrity with Ericsson to ensure the correct test
approach is taken.
17 of 48
13 November, 2011
HigheroutputpowerrequiresmoreDCpower
Efficiencyofpoweramplifiersvariesfrom814%
Thereare2radios,eachwith3transmitchainsandtheradiosoperatesimultaneously.
Overall PCB power consumption has a direct effect on estimated Tx output power per chain for
the Wi-Fi card. The maximum DC power draw from the power supply occurs when both radios
are transmitting. However, radios do not operate with 100% duty cycle, so the average DC
power consumption is much less than the maximum:
80% Tx duty cycle is approximately the realistic maximum when running continuous
downstreamtraffic
1050%Txdutycyclewillmorecloselyreflectactualaveragepowerconsumptionofthemodule
Power supply must be capable of providing the peak current, but the average current should be
used to define the overall power and heat dissipation.
With the above defined, the following table (Table 1: DC Power) captures the power
consumption levels matched up to Transmit power levels options
18 of 48
13 November, 2011
Radio
Max
(peak)
DC
Power
Average
DC
Power
2.4GHz conducted
Tx Power per Chain
5GHz conducted Tx
Power per Chain
SoC/MAC
Internal PA
6.8W
4.4W
1517 dBm
(Total conducted
power 21.7dBm)
1012 dBm
Mid
Performance
External PA
14.7W
8.8W
1820 dBm
(total conducted
power 24.7dBm)
1719 dBm
High
Performance
External PA
28.1W
15.6W
2325 dBm
(total conducted
power 29.7dBm)
2224 dBm
Table 1: DC Power
19 of 48
13 November, 2011
20 of 48
13 November, 2011
GoodWiFiperformance
TheWiFitransmitterdoesnotdegradecellularradioperformance
TheWiFireceiverisnotdegradedduetocellularradioperformance
TheSmallRBSplatformisdesignedtocoveralldefined3GPPfrequencybandsbetween700MHzand2.7
GHz.ThismeansthattheWiFimodulemustbedesignedtohandlecoexistencewithall3GPPbands.
ANSWER: Fully Compliant
BelAirs Wi-Fi technology has industry leading performance. The cards are designed to ensure
that there is no interference from Wi-Fi to cellular or from cellular to Wi-Fi. All 3GPP bands have
been included in this analysis. BelAir already produces products that are co-located with
cellular basestations, including Macrocells and understands the requirements and designs
needed to achieve this.
Transmit Path
Wi-Fi chip has direct RF output
Filter 1 reduces out-of-band noise and spurious from chipset output so that they
are not amplified by the power amplifier
Power amplifier amplifies wanted RF signal
Filter 3 reduces power amplifier out-of-band noise and spurious signals in the
cellular bands so there is no interference to cellular Rx
Receive Path
Filter 3 reduces incoming RF out-of-band signals from the cellular Tx so that they
do not overload the LNA
21 of 48
13 November, 2011
Filter 2 provides additional out-of-band signal rejection to ensure that the Wi-Fi
chip Rx input is not overloaded so that there is no Rx sensitivity degradation
Location of Filter 2 could be moved ahead of LNA, but doing so reduces the Rx
sensitivity as the filter loss directly increases the receiver noise figure
A typical RF filter that is used on the card is shown in Figure 12: RF filtering specifications. Two
of these are used in cascade to achieve the required performance.
22 of 48
13 November, 2011
If, for pricing or power consumption reasons, Ericsson desires to have a lower powered card,
BelAir has also proposed a moderate power (1W EIRP, 20dBm conducted per chain) and a low
power (100mW EIRP, 17dBm per chain) card as part of this proposal. BelAir will work with
Ericsson to deliver the optimal blend of power and performance. In the interest of having a
single worldwide card we, would propose the higher power card initially.
SpuriousemissionrequirementinadditiontoregulatoryrequirementsstatedinChapter1isshownin
Table9andFigure1.RequirementsforcoexistencewithWiFi@5GHzisnotincludedandmustbeadded
byvendor.
23 of 48
13 November, 2011
24 of 48
13 November, 2011
25 of 48
13 November, 2011
26 of 48
13 November, 2011
27 of 48
13 November, 2011
28 of 48
13 November, 2011
29 of 48
13 November, 2011
30 of 48
13 November, 2011
Certificate
Presharedkey
Anyothermethod
ANSWER: Fully Compliant
The Wi-Fi Module will support the following encryption and authentication protocols, on a per
SSID basis.
WPAEnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPTLS
WPAEnterpriseAES802.1xEAPTLS
WPA2EnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPTLS
WPA2EnterpriseAES802.1xEAPTLS
WPAEnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPTTLSMSCHAPv2
WPAEnterpriseAES802.1xEAPTTLSMSCHAPv2
WPA2EnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPTTLSMSCHAPv2
WPA2EnterpriseAES802.1xEAPTTLSMSCHAPv2
WPAEnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPPEAPv0EAPMSCHAPv2
WPAEnterpriseAES802.1xEAPPEAPv0EAPMSCHAPv2
WPA2EnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPPEAPv0EAPMSCHAPv2
WPA2EnterpriseAES802.1xEAPPEAPv0EAPMSCHAPv2
WPAEnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPPEAPv1EAPGTC
WPAEnterpriseAES802.1xEAPPEAPv1EAPGTC
WPA2EnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPPEAPv1EAPGTC
WPA2EnterpriseAES802.1xEAPPEAPv1EAPGTC
WPAEnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPFAST
WPAEnterpriseAES802.1xEAPFAST
WPA2EnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPFAST
WPA2EnterpriseAES802.1xEAPFAST
WPAEnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPSIM
WPAEnterpriseAES802.1xEAPSIM
WPA2EnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPSIM
WPA2EnterpriseAES802.1xEAPSIM
WPAEnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPAKA
WPAEnterpriseAES802.1xEAPAKA
WPA2EnterpriseTKIP802.1xEAPAKA
WPA2EnterpriseAES802.1xEAPAKA
WEP
WPAPersonalPSK
WPA2PersonalPSK
31 of 48
13 November, 2011
In addition, all BelAir APs self-authenticate to the BelAir8000 and BelAir4000 Controllers using
an X.509 certificate; this is part of the BelAirOS operating system firmware which is common to
all BelAir products. The Wi-Fi Module will contain the advanced BelAirOS operating system
and hence will support this functionality.
If certificate is supported, state also if it is possible to revoke and install new or additional
certificates after the module has done the initial authentication.
ANSWER: Fully Compliant
The current release supports pre-shared certificates. The following release (Q1 2012) will allow
for certificates to be managed by a trusted CA and will enable time based and revoking of the
default certificated.
The Wi-Fi module must also support Ericsson proprietary extensions of LLDP using Ericsson
LLDP TLVs, and discovery methods.
ANSWER: Fully Compliant
BelAir will work with Ericsson to define and implement the proprietary extensions to LLDP.
32 of 48
13 November, 2011
Home Agent (HA), such as in 4G. The primary and back up MIP HAs are connected in the core
network via conditional access gateway(s) to the internet. BelAir APs provide MIP Foreign
Agent (FA) functionality together with a PMIP agent to enable standard IP clients to connect to
the network. Thus yielding mobility between disparate systems such as Wi-Fi to 4G
(LTE/WiMax) or to 3G (HSPA/HSPA+).
IPSec and L2TPv3 are part of BelAirs roadmap and will be available in BelAirOS release 13 in
Q2 2012.
In summary, the BelAirOS is a flexible tunneling and encapsulation engine that can be
provisioned on a per Virtual AP basis.
Regarding MACSec IEEE 802.1AE, BelAir recommends holding a technical interchange session
with Ericsson to understand the use cases in which this type of protocol is required. Given the
Wi-Fi Module will be internally co-located with Ericsson equipment within the Small-RBS, and
communicating via a SGMII interface, BelAir believes man-in-the-middle attacks would be
highly unlikely. BelAirOS supports encrypted tunnels to the Wi-Fi controller so all user and
management traffic is already protected. However, should the need for 802.1AE over SGMII be
required, BelAir will work with Ericsson and provide the most optimized implementation of the
protocol.
Backgroundtraffic
Bestefforttraffic
Videotraffic,TIcircuitemulation
VoiceoverIP(VoIPtraffic)
BelAir will work with Ericsson to define the details of the most appropriate end-to-end QoS
scheme to meet the overall system requirements. BelAirOS has an integral per
user/interface/VLAN rate limiter that can be used to implement several of the functions outlined
below. BelAirOS supports inside to outside marking of packets. BelAir shaping operates in-line
When payload encryption is used the original Diffserv marking must be copied to the outer IP
header.
The QoS scheduler must support Modified Deficit Round Robin (MDRR) or similar with one lowlatency queue.
33 of 48
13 November, 2011
The total available bandwidth for a logical or physical interface must be possible to configure to
a lower value than the actual interface speed, using interface rate limit, and the scheduler must
be able shape the traffic to this rate.
It must be possible to change the rate of the shapers without interrupting traffic.
Optionally the meters and shapers may be configured with a committed information rate CIR
and excess information rate (EIR) and do Diffserv coloring based on a Two-Rate Three-Color
Marker according to RFC 4115.
It should be possible to dynamically change the QoS parameters using Ericsson proprietary
extensions of LLDP.
34 of 48
13 November, 2011
configurations can be reverted. Software download is in-service. Upon agreement with the
customer, BelAir can preload a basic test version of the firmware in the active bank to allow for
customer specific production type testing, with the other bank loaded with the full BelAirOS.
Once initialization testing is complete, the operator can retrieve the BelAirOS firmware from the
second bank and re-initialize the module with the OS uploaded.
BelAir will work with Ericsson to define the correct LLDP commands that will allow the
configurations of all required parameters via that protocol.
BelAir Wi-Fi modules can also be accessed and configured locally or remotely using the
following configuration interfaces:
CLI(viaTelnet/SSH)
SNMPinterface(SNMPv2candv3)
Webinterface(usingHTTPorHTTPS)
BelAirdevicesalsohaveTR069support.
35 of 48
13 November, 2011
Access Points can be fully auto discovered and will automatically connect to the core network
without pre-provisioning. During system installation and commissioning a field technician may
also connect locally to a wireless node for management purposes via the line interface or the
access radio module. Once the network is up and running, the network operations center (NOC)
36 of 48
13 November, 2011
can manage the node remotely via the DOCSIS modem, Ethernet line interface or the wireless
backhaul radio network.
BelAir wireless node management functions are fully interoperable with many third-party
standards-based solutions and allow direct connection to the APs, including:
BelView NMS is built on a scalable data collector/server and client/server design that supports
as many as 50,000 access points; each server supports up to ten java clients and hundreds of
web clients for multi-user, multi-site management, and uses a database to store and export
network management information. For each 5,000 APs under management a data collector
machine is added. Users can be assigned different access privileges according to their network
operations role. BelView NMS runs on Microsoft Windows XP, Linux and SUN Solaris; clients
and servers can run on different operating systems. It offers a broad range of local and remote
node management features via SNMP, including:
BelView supports advanced provisioning of access points with templates and service profiles
enabling easy provisioning of SSIDs for different service and for wholesale partners.
The latest BelView business intelligence module supports an easy to use web dashboard that
gives the network operator detailed and summary views of the activity and usage on their
network by SSID. BelView also supports synthetic clients that enable detailed monitoring of
actual end user experience.
37 of 48
13 November, 2011
38 of 48
13 November, 2011
FullyShared
PointtoMultipoint
Star
PointtoPoint.
39 of 48
13 November, 2011
40 of 48
13 November, 2011
41 of 48
13 November, 2011
DHCPexhaustiondetection.Count#ofDHCPrequests/second;ifabovesetthresholdthen
alarm.ThiswarnsofDHCPattacks.
NAVattackprotection.NAV=networkaccessvector(itisthelengthofairtimerequestedin
thepacket.Somemaliciousclientsrequestexcessiveairtimewhichblocksotherusers.
MICkeyattackcountermeasures.MICisapartofkeyencryptionequationforTKIP.The
usersendsmanysequenceofMICandthepeerrespondswitherrcodes.Thisallowsa
malicioususertodeterminethepresharedkey.
SecureGW.OnlyacceptframesfromdefaultGW(sourceMACmustbedef.GWMAC).
AutosecureGW.ComparebindingofGWIPwithGWMAC.Mustmatch,elserejectpacket.
OA&M.Managementinterfaceblockingfromairinterface.
42 of 48
13 November, 2011
Calibration of transmitter
Verification of the EVM and transmit power level
Verification of receive functionality
Figure 18 shows a proposed test setup that is very similar to what is currently in our production
environment.
43 of 48
13 November, 2011
Once the production test has been completed, the BelAirOS firmware can then be loaded into
the active bank for normal operation. This can be done remotely of locally.
WiFiperformancewhencellularradioisused
CellularradioperformancewhenWiFiisused
44 of 48
13 November, 2011
The Wi-Fi Module will have undergone a series of BelAir Product Verification (PV) testing, which
will include interfaces (communications, data, mechanical, power, etc) testing, either through
emulation or via a Small-RBS-prototype (TBD).
To support the Small-RBS verification activities, BelAir will make available a low level test
software load that will enable non-standard functionality, including the continuous transmission
of the radios, either individually or simultaneously. This will facilitate the cellular radio and Wi-Fi
radio performance testing
To measure receive sensitivity, BelAir proposes a test set as per Figure 19.
45 of 48
13 November, 2011
Figure 21: Proposed Test Setup for Production Testing of Integrated Wi-Fi Module
46 of 48
13 November, 2011
9 Summary
BelAir Networks has delivered a comprehensive and technically accurate proposal that complies
to all of Ericssons Wi-Fi Module requirements. BelAirs proposal for a Wi-Fi card delivers
industry leading radio performance: standards based 3*3 MIMO with beamforming and full
ability to be co-located with a cellular radio.
BelAirs proposal is fully compliant with Ericssons specifications
BelAir also delivers a full suite of advanced carrier grade software used by Tier 1 service
providers worldwide to deliver 3G/4G offload and carrier Wi-Fi. Our extensive experience in
delivering radios that meet the relevant regulatory emissions specifications at full power (4W
EIRP) as well as our experience of delivering Wi-Fi while co-located with cellsites has been
used to ensure that these cards will exceed the needs of Ericsson.
BelAir has a suite of advanced network management and Wi-Fi controller products that would
be part of the overall solution offer. BelAir also delivers a wide range of carrier Wi-Fi products
for indoor and outdoor use that are widely deployed and field proven by Tier 1 carriers and that
would enable Ericsson to deliver their customers a comprehensive solution.
Should we be selected, we look forward to being Ericssons long term partner on this project.
47 of 48
13 November, 2011
www.belairnetworks.com
End of Document
48 of 48
13 November, 2011