Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BAIN BRIEF The Power of Focus PDF
BAIN BRIEF The Power of Focus PDF
The authors are partners with Bain & Company. Tim van Biesen leads the rms
Americas Healthcare practice from New York. Todd Johnson, also based in
New York, is a member of the Global Healthcare practice. Patrick OHagan is
a member of the Global Healthcare practice and works from Bains Boston ofce.
Category Leadership IndexSM is a trademark of Bain & Company, Inc.
CONMED, for example, competes in multiple categories and is a distant follower in nearly all of them. In
contrast, Medtronic (prior to acquiring Covidien) enjoyed
industry-leading economics in part due to its commanding leadership in spine and cardiac rhythm products.
This conclusion, which Bain recently also found to be
true in the pharmaceutical industry, 1 raises critical
See the Bain Brief New paths to value creation in pharma, by Nils Behnke, Michael Retterath, Todd Sangster and Ashish Singh, 2014.
SM
R =0.09
R2=0.51
Novartis/Alcon
Novartis/Alcon
Medtronic
Zimmer
Medtronic
Becton,
Dickinson
Becton,
Dickinson
Johnson
&
Johnson
Biomet
EBIT
margin
Covidien
St. Jude
Medical
EBIT
margin
Abbott
Biomet
Covidien
Stryker
Smith &
Nephew
C. R.
Bard
Boston
Scientific
$10B
medtech
revenues
CONMED
Johnson
&
Johnson
Abbott
Stryker
Smith &
Nephew
C. R.
Bard
Boston
Scientific
Zimmer
CONMED
RMS=1
$10B
medtech
revenues
CLI score=1
Notes: Bains Category Leadership IndexSM score is the revenue weighted average of a companys relative market share (RMS) in the categories in which it plays; excludes
categories such as capital equipment (e.g., MRI machines) and commodities (e.g., latex gloves); RMS and EBIT margin are based on 2013 data for each companys medtech
business; company set is not exhaustive of all players in the medtech industry
Sources: EvaluateMedTech; HRI; Form 10-Ks; expert interviews; investor presentations
On the portfolio strategy front, CLI scoring forces companies to acknowledge where they are strong and weak
within properly defined categories. This can lead to
important trade-offs and possible divestitures in markets
where they have little chance of becoming leaders. CLI
can also provide a useful framework to compare various
portfolio moves, by assessing how each one might affect
the overall CLI score. In 2014, for example, Johnson &
Johnson sold its Ortho Clinical Diagnostics business
to the Carlyle Group. This move increased Johnson &
Johnsons overall CLI score because it erased the companys follower position in a market where it had limited
opportunity to achieve leadership.
There are some caveats to the analysis. First, some categories are inherently more profitable than others. For this
reason, a company with a lagging position in a premium
category can sometimes be as profitable as the leading
Figure 2: Zimmer boosted its Category Leadership Index score by acquiring Biomet
Zimmer
Zimmer + Biomet
Biomet
RMS
%
revenue
RMS
%
revenue
RMS
Change in
RMS
Hip
1.05
32%
0.70
43%
1.70
0.65
Knee
1.13
46%
0.34
30%
1.34
0.21
Extremity
0.99
5%
0.55
5%
1.55
0.56
Trauma
0.14
8%
0.16
17%
0.31
0.17
Spine
0.04
5%
0.04
4%
0.11
0.07
Other
0.11
4%
0.01
<1%
0.11
1.28
0.35
Category
Leadership
IndexSM
score
0.93
0.46
Notes: Illustrative example based on a global category with 2013 revenues; RMS is relative market share
Sources: EvaluateMedTech; HRI
Europe:
Asia-Pacic: