Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Overall View On The Tradition of Tapping Palm Trees and Prospects For Animal Production
Overall View On The Tradition of Tapping Palm Trees and Prospects For Animal Production
Volume11,Number11999
Overallviewonthetraditionoftappingpalmtreesandprospectsforanimalproduction
ChristopheDalibard
InternationalRelationsService,MinistryofAgriculture,Paris,France
"Neera[sapextractedfromBorassusflabellifer]canbeconvertedintoJaggerysweetas
honeyitself.ThisJaggeryissuperiortocaneJaggery.CaneJaggeryissweet,butPalm
Jaggeryissweetanddeliciousitcanbeproducedworthcroresofrupees.PalmGur
givesmineralsaltstoo.DoctorshavetoldmetoeatJaggeryandIalwayseatPalmGur.
NaturehasmadethisproductinsuchawaythatitcannotbemanufacturedintheMills
itisproducedintheCottages.WheretherearePalmtrees,thisJaggerycanbeeasily
produced.AndhraDeshahasthousandsofPalmtreesthere,Jaggeryisproducedin
everyhamlet.Thisisthewaytobanishpovertyfromtheland.Thisalsoisanantidoteto
poverty."MahatmaGandhi[Fromaspeechdeliveredattheopeningofthevillage
industryexhibitioninBrindawanBihar(3May1939)]
Abstract
Palmtreeshaveprovedtobeefficientconvertersofsolarenergyintobiomassinmostagroecologicalzonesofthetropicalworld.Mosttappedpalmtreesgivesasapveryrichinsugar(10to20%).Forseveral
millennia,manyspeciesofpalmtrees(includingcoconut)havebeenusedforsugarproduction.HighlysophisticatedtechniquesoftappingweredevelopedthroughthecenturiesinAsia,AfricaandAmerica.High
yieldsofsugarwereobtainedfrompalmsthatcouldcontinueforuptoahundredyearsofproduction.Oneofthemainconstraintsonproductioninrecenttimeshasbeentheincreasinglackoffuelneededfor
processingpalmsapintosugarandthepricethereof.Nevertheless,sincetrialsoffeedingpigswithfreshsugarpalmsapweresuccessfullyinitiatedinanFAOprojectinCambodia,therehasbeenrenewedinterestin
tappingpalmtreesforsaptobeusedasfeed.AthoroughreviewoftheliteraturehasshownthatintensivepigrearingbasedonpalmsaphasalreadybeenpractisedbytheIndonesiansforcenturiesandwasfoundtobe
averyefficientsystemforintensifyingagricultureinsomehighlypopulatedislands.Intoday'seconomy,developinganimalproductionusingpalmsapasthemainsourceofenergyinthedietlooksverypromising:
thelandcouldsustainhigherpopulationdensitiesthroughtheintensificationofcropandanimalproductionwithinsustainableintegratedsystemsforsmallfarmers.
Keywords:sugarpalm,tapping,sap,livestock,feed
Foreword
Therecentdocumentationoftheveryhighpotentialofthesugarpalm(Borassusflabellifer)asasourceofdigestibleenergyforpigproduction(KhieuBorinandPreston1995)hasfocussedattentiononthepalm
speciesingeneralandtheirmultipurposeusesinparticular.Thisreviewdemonstratestheenormousamountofknowledgethatexistsonthetappingofpalmsanduseofthesap,includingthefatteningofpigsdone
traditionallyforcenturiesincertainislandsinIndonesia.Itisclearthatmostoftheinformationisderivedfromindigenoussourcesandthatpalmcultivationhasplayedamajorroleinpovertyalleviationthroughout
thetropics.Theneglectofthisspeciesbyresearchers,otherthanformonoculturalexportpurposes(eg:coconuts,datesandpalmoil),isareflectionofthereductionistthinkingthathasprevailedinagriculturalscience
duringthelast50yearorsoyears.Itishopedthisreviewwillreviveinterestinthepalmspeciesatatimewhenefficientcaptureofsolarenergyandenvironmentalfriendlinesscharacteristicssharedbymostofthe
palmspeciesarereceivingpriorityasindicatorsofsustainablefarmingsystems.
...TheEditors
Introduction
Palmsarebelievedtobeamongtheoldestfloweringplantsintheworld(Redhead1989).Forcenturies,manypalmspecieshavebeentappedthroughoutthetropicalworldinordertoproducefreshjuice(sweet
toddy),fermenteddrinks(toddy,wine,arak),syrup("honey"),brownsugar(jaggery)orrefinedsugar.Oneofmankind'sfirstsourcesofsugarwasprobablyArengapinnata(Redhead1989).Evidenceoftheuseof
BorassusflabellifersugarinIndiahasbeenreportedbytheGreekhistorianMegasthenes,ambassadortothecourtofChandragupta,inthe4thcenturyBC.Hindusknewhowtoextractitabout4,000yearsago
(Ferguson1888,citedbyFox1977).JaggeryandtreacleextractedfromCaryotaurenssapinSriLankahasbeenanimportantsourceofsugarfromantiquity(Dissanayake1977).InAfrica,themaintraditionaluseof
palmsapisforwineproduction.IthasbeenreportedinEgypt(datepalm)longbeforethebirthofChrist(Barreveld1993)andontheGuineacoastbyearlynavigatorsinthe15thcentury(SodahAyernorand
Matthews1971).
Mosttappedpalmtreesdonotonlyproducesapbutaremultipurpose(ediblefruits,buildingmaterials,fuel,fibres,wax,etc.)andtheirsocioeconomicimportancecanbecriticalfortheruralpoor:Ghandiusedtocall
Borassusflabellifer,aremedyagainstpoverty.ATamilclassicalpoem(TalaVilasam)composedbyArunachalaminTamilNaduisentirelydedicatedtothegloryofthistreeandenumerates801articlesmadefrom
itsvariousparts(Rangaswami1977Kovoor1983).Anotheroutstandingexampleisthecoconutpalm,forwhicheverypartisused.ThistreeiscalledinIndia"TreeofHeaven","Mankind'sgreatestproviderinthe
tropics","Treeoflife",etc.(Rangaswami1977).Thereareatleast1,000usesforthecoconutpalm(Dissanayake1986).Nypafruticansisalsoanoutstandingproviderofvariousproductswhichareessentialto
everydaylivingandthereforeissaidtobethemangrove'scounterpartofcoconut(Quimbo1991).Palmtreesarealsooftenassociatedwithcropsandpastures.
Thescopeofthispaperisfocusedonpalmtreesthataretraditionallytappedorwithapotentialfortappinginanondestructivemanner,guaranteeingsugarproductioninthelongrunwithinsustainableproduction
systems.Sugarproductionfromthefruits(asfromdatesofdatepalm)orfromthestarchaccumulatedinthepithofthestem(asforsagopalm)isnotreviewedhere.
Rationale
Theoretically,theadvantagesoftakingthesugarsfromthesapbeforeitgoestothefruitsareobvious.Thesesugarsareinterceptedbeforebeingusedintheproductionofthenonediblepartssuchashuskincoconut,
whichrepresents35%ofthefruit(Rangaswami1977),andintheproductionofediblematerialthroughchemicalreactionswhichimplyaloss,mainlyaconversionofsugarintooilasforcoconutandoilpalm.Itis
thereforemoreprofitablefromthepointofviewofedibleenergyproductiontotapapalmforthesapratherthanallowingthepalmtoproducefruits.Similarly,itwasdemonstratedthat,inthecontextofharvestable
energyfromthecoconutpalm,theamountofenergyharvestedinthesap(throughproductionofethanol)couldbe5to7timeshigherthanfromtheoilofthenuts(coconutoilismixedwithdieselfuelina510%
blendaspartofanationalenergyprograminthePhilippines)(Banzon1984).
Table1:Yieldsofalcoholfuelfromdifferentsources(HamiltonandMurphy1988)
Sourceofalcoholfuel
Sweetpotato
Tappednipah
Tappedcoconut
Tapioca
Sugarcane
Annualyield(litres/ha)
6,75018,000
6,48015,600
5,000
3,2408,640
3,3506,700
Comparingfivesourcesofalcoholfuel,HamiltonandMurphy(1988)emphazisetheinterestofnipahintermsofyield(Table1)andmanagement:tappingiseasycomparedtococonutthelandisproperlyusedand
theenvironmentprotectedastherearenowastestogetridofasbagasseinthecaseofsugarcane.
Physiology
Itispossibletoobtainasugarysolutionbytheexcisionofthemeristeminnearlyallpalms(Tuley1965a).Basically,starchreservesfromthetrunkareconvertedtosugarandaretransportedupwardstowardthestem
apex(Fox1977).AlthoughthisistrueinthecaseofCorypha,otherexplanationsareneededforpalmssuchascoconutwhichdoesnotaccumulatestarchinitstrunk(Reijne1948citedbyVanDie1974).Pethiyagoda
(1978)describestheupwardstreamasawateryliquidcontainingdissolvedsaltsabsorbedfromthesoil,andthedownwardstreamasacomparativelyrichmixtureoffood(principallysugars)manufacturedinthe
leaves.Thesapflowisinterceptedbyinjuringfibrovasculartissuesoftheapexoroftheinflorescence.Nevertheless,thisauthorrecognizesthatthelargevolumeofexudateproducedduringtappingandthehigh
sugarconcentrationclearlyindicatethatthematerialisdrawnfromstoredresourcesandisinexcessofcurrentlysynthesisedsugars.
VanDie(1974)considersthatthebleedingsapofCocosnuciferaandArengasaccharifera,andprobablysomeotherpalmstoo,mayberegardedasthemobileaqueousphaseofthesievetubesystemofthesetrees,
flowingtoanartificialsink,thebleedingsite.However,therateofbleedingfromasingleinflorescenceisseveraltimeshigherthantherateofassimilateflowintoasinglebunchduringfruitformation.Theoriginof
thelargeflowofsapthatoccursinatappedtreeisnotyetclearlydemonstrated.ThisisalsothecaseforBorassusflabelliferwherewaterfromrootabsorptionappearsquiteinsufficient(Kovoor1983).Nypafruticans
sapyieldishigherincloudyweather,anditisclaimedthattranspirationcompeteswithsapyieldbutispartlycompensatedbyvariationinsugarcontent(Hinchy1938acitedbyHamiltonandMurphy1988).
Pethiyagoda(1978)suggeststhatthereisasteepriseinrespirationwhichoccurswheneverthereisarapidsolubilisationandmovementofmaterialsfromsitesofstoragetothepointsatwhichtheyareneededsuchas
duringseedgermination,floweropeningandfruitripening.Thisphenomenoncanbefostered,heightenedandsustainedbymanipulativeprocesses,theuseofgenerallyyounggrowingsites(merismatictissues)and
theactoffresheningthewound.Preliminarystudies(notpublished)citedbyPethiyagoda(1978)showaconsiderablyincreasedrespirationbyfragmentsofcoconutinflorescencedrawnfromstimulatedspadices.
InCambodia,arecentstudyonBorassusflabellifershowsthatthereisnosignificantdifferencesbetweendaysintheyieldofjuiceanditsBrixvalue,butdifferencesforthesetwoparametersarehighlysignificant
betweenfarms,monthsandsexofthepalmtree(fortheBrixbetweenmaleandfemale,thedifferenceissignificantinsteadofhighlysignificant).Duringtheproductionseason,juiceflowsignificantlydecreasesas
theBrixsignificantlyincreases.Sapflowishigherduringcoolnights(KhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin1996).
Tappingisgenerallypractisedtwiceaday.Forexample,inthecaseofthecoconuttree,thescarshealandthesapflowstopswhenslicingisnotdoneforoneortwodaysand2weekswouldbenecessaryforrestoring
thesapflow(Levang1988).
Location,productsandtappedpartsofpalms
Annex1listsmorethan30differentpalmspeciesthataretraditionallytappedinpartsofthetropicalworld.Thiswascompiledfrommorethanahundredreferencesonpalmsintheliterature.Manyreferencesare
severaldecadesoldasthereisnotmuchrecentliteratureonthissubject.ThemajorpartoftheinformationwasfoundonpalmsthataretappedintheOldWorld,withmoreorlessasmanydifferenttappedspeciesin
AsiaandinAfrica.VerylittleliteratureseemstobeavailableontappingpalmtreesintheNewWorld.InAmericaandAfrica,itseemsthattappingpalmshasbeenpractisedexclusivelyormainlyforwine
production,whereasinAsiathesapisusedeitherasfreshjuiceorprocessedintoalargearrayofproducts(wine,arak,sugar,vinegar,etc.).Annex1alsoshowsthattherearetappedpalmspeciesadaptedtoalmostall
agroecologicalzonesofthetropicalworldfromtidalareasandswampstodesertsandmountains.
Sapcomposition
Mosttappedpalmtrees(Table2)giveasapveryrichinsugar(10to20%accordingtospeciesandindividualvariation)whereasthemapletree,tappedforsugarproductioninNorthAmericagivesasapcontaining
only3%ofsugar(Annett1913).Gibbs(1911)citedbyVanDie(1974)hasreportedastrikingresemblanceindrymatter,sucrose,andashcontentofthebleedingsapfromthepalmspeciesinvestigatedbyhim(Cocos
nucifera,Arengasaccharifera,NypafruticansandCoryphaelata).SugarsfrompalmtreessuchasPhoenixsylvestrisandBorassusflabelliferarereportedtobemorenutritiousthancanesugar(Rangaswami1977
Roy1951citedbyMorton1988).Somemedicinalvalueisalsooftenreported:itisthecaseforthesugarfromBorassusflabellifer(Rangaswami1977).InMadagascar,Cocosnuciferasapisusedagainstnephritis
andbladderinfections.
Table2:DataonthecompositionofsapandjaggeryfromBorassusflabellifer
Productandreference
Freshsap[1]
Freshsapbeforecooking[2]
Freshsapstabilizedwithsodiumbenzoate[2]
Specificgravity
1.07
pH
6.76.9
6.00to4.00
6.45
Nitrogen
0.056g/100cc
Protein
0.35g/100cc
0.10to0.20%
0.10%
Totalsugar
10.93g/100cc
14.00to9.40%
15.78%
Sucrose
12.30to8.50%
15.04%
Reducedsugar
0.96g/100cc
0.80to3.50%
0.62%
Fat
Mineralsasash
0.54g/100cc
0.10to0.30%
0.17%
Calcium
Trace
Phosphorus
0.14g/100cc
Iron
0.4g/100cc
Copper
VitaminC
13.25mg/100cc
VitaminB1
3.9IU
VitaminBcomplex
Negligible
References:[1]PaulasandMuthukrishnan1983acitedbyDavisandJohnson1987[2]Romera1968[3]Roy1951citedbyMorton1988.
Jaggery[3]
1.04%
76.86%
1.66%
0.19%
3.15%
0.861%
0.052%
11.01mgper100g
0.767mgper100g
BorassusflabelliferfreshsapisagoodsourceofvitaminBcomplex(Chopraetal1958citedbyMorton1988)anditcontainsascorbicacid(Dissanayake1986).100litresofsapgive78kgofsugarand8kgof
molasses(PaulasandMuthukrishnan1983acitedbyDavisandJohnson1987).Asthesapfromthemorningcollectionhasbeenproducedatlowertemperaturesthantheonecollectedintheevening,itisless
fermentedandthereforecontainsmoresucrose(Romera1968).ArecentstudyinCambodiashowedthatsucrosecanrangefrom66to94%orfrom51to81%oftotalsolidsinthejuicerespectivelyinJanuaryorin
April.Glucoseandfructoselevelsincreasedduringthesameperiod(KhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin1996).InthecaseofBorassusaethiopium,sapcompositionofthemorningcollectionmarkedly
differsfromtheeveningcollectionandalsosapcompositiondiffersonthelevelofcuttingoftheterminalbud,losingitstastewhenitsbaseisreachedthesapalsocontainslesssucrosethanBorassusflabellifersap
(Portres1964).InBurma,thetappersdistinguishupto6differentqualitiesofsapaccordingtothetappingstageandthesexofthetree(Lubeigt1979).
TheCaryotaurenssapalsoconsistsalmostentirelyofsucrosewhichisrapidlyfermentedandinverted(Dissanayake1986).ItspHis6.5anditcontainstracesofacids,0.34%ofreducingsugarsandatotalsugar
between1516%(Theivendirarajahetal1977).Thejaggeryhasthefollowingcomposition:76.683.5%sucrose,0.760.9%reducingsugar1.651.98%ash1.792.27%proteinand6.68.34%pectingums
(Dissanayake1977).FreshsapofcoconuthasapHequalto6andaBrixof17(NaimandHusin1984).Itcontains12to18%sugar(mainlysucroseandsmallamountsofglucose,Norrisetal(1922)citedby
Grimwood1975),0.5%ash,2%organicsolids(Nathanael(1960)citedbyGrimwood1975)andsmallamountofvitamins,suchas1630mgofascorbicacidper10ml(Banerjee(1935)citedbyGrimwood1975).
Coconutsugarcontains0.5to1.3%protein,72to88%oftotalsugar,57to81%sucrose1.3to2.5%totalmineralsand5to10%humidity.ThefreshsapoftheAfricanoilpalmcontains9.6to10.6%ofsucrose.
Glucoseandfructosearemuchbelow1%(EzeandUzoechiOgan1988).SprechervonBernegg(1929)citedbyVanDie(1974)reports14%totalsugars.ThesapisalsorichinvitaminB(particularlyB12)andin
sulphurproteins(Hartley1977Tuley1965a).ThesapofPhoenixsylvestrisisagoodsourceofvitaminsoftheBgroupandcontainsinadditionanappreciableamountofascorbicacid(Rangaswami1977).
Managementoftappedpalmtreesandyieldsofsugar
Themanagementofpalmtreesforsapproductionvariesverymuchaccordingtospecies(SeeAnnex2).Nypafruticans,Phoenixsylvestris,Elaeisguineensis,RaphiahookeriandCocosnuciferacanbetappedata
ratherearlyage,respectivelywhenthetreesare4,5,6,7and7yearsold(CrevostandLemari1913Abedinetal1987Essiamah1992Profizi1988Levang1988).Ontheotherhand,manyyearsareneededbefore
tappingCaryotaurens(10to15),Borassusflabellifer(15to30)orCoryphaelata(20to100)(Redhead1989,Fox1977).
Thenumberofyearsapalmtreecanbetappedisalsoverydifferentdependingonthespecies.CoryphaelataandRaphiahookeriflowerjustonce.Theywillproducesaponlyforafewmonthsbeforedying(Fox
1977Profizi1988).ArengapinnataandCaryotaurenswillproducesapforseveralyears,withlargeinterruptionsinthecaseofCaryotaurensasitflowersonlyeverytwoorthreeyears(Redhead1989Dissanayake
1977).Otherpalmtreeswillproducesapformuchlongerperiods:10to15yearsforElaeisguineensis,morethan20yearsforCocosnucifera,50yearsforNypafruticansandPhoenixsylvestrisand30to100years
forBorassusflabellifer(Adand1954Levang1988Magalon1930Abedinetal1987Lubeigt1977).Somespeciesareabletoproducesapallyearround:Arengapinnata,Cocosnucifera,Elaeisguineensisand
Nypafruticans(Mogeaetal1991Rangaswami1977Tuley1965aKiew1989).BorassusflabelliferandPhoenixsylvestrisproduceonlyseasonally(CrevostandLemari1913Annett1913).
Mosttappedpalmtreesgivesasapveryrichinsugar(10to20%accordingtospeciesandindividualvariation).Theyieldsarehighlyvariableaccordingtothespeciesandtheirmanagement.InthecaseofBorassus
flabellifer,thefemaletreescangiveasmuchas50%moresapthanmaletrees(Lubeigt1979).Underpropermanagement,themaintappedpalmspecies(Arengapinnata,Borassusflabellifer,Cocosnuciferaand
Nypafruticans)canreachyieldsofabout20tonnesofsugarperhectare(VanDie1974WatsoncitedbyKiew1989).Comparedtosugarcaneproduction(515tonnesofsugar/ha/year),theBorassusflabellifertree
canreach18tons/ha/yearunderrainfedconditions(KhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin1996)andthecoconuttree19tons/ha/year(Jeganathan1974).Accordingtoestimates,Elaeisguineensisproduces
muchlesssugar(1.2tonneperhectare,Udom1987)but,asithasneverbeenexploitedforsugarproductionbutonlyforwineproduction,therearegoodprospectsforobtainingmuchhigheryieldsinaproduction
systemorientedtowardssugarproduction.
Methodsofpalmtappingandsappreservation
Thetechniquesfortappingpalmsarenumerousandcanvarydrasticallyfromonecontinenttoanother,asdemonstratedbythecaseofBorassusaethiopiuminAfricaandBorassusflabelliferinAsia.Refined
techniquesoftappingtheinflorescenceofthelatterarecompatiblewithproductioninthelongterm.DestructivetechniquesareusuallypractisedontheterminalbudofB.aethiopiumandareoftenresponsibleforthe
deathofthetreewithinafewmonths.AstappingismainlydoneinAfricaforwineproduction,theuseoftheAsiantechniqueinAfricawouldpermitsapproductionthroughouttherainyseasonwhereaspalmwineis
drunkmuchmoreduringthedryseason(Portres1964).TheAfricanoilpalmisusedinAfricaforproducingwinemainlythroughtwodifferenttechniques:oneisdestructive(incisionofstemapexoffelledpalm)
andispreferredinGhanatheotherisnotdestructive(excisionofmaleinflorescenceandsometimesoffemaleinflorescenceaswell)andhasbeendevelopedwhereeconomicconsiderationshaveforcedthepeopleto
preservetheirpalms,e.g.ineasternNigeria(Hartley1977).
Tappingcanbepractisedaftercuttingdownthetrees.Otherwise,exceptforNypafruticans,whichistrunklessanddevelopsitsinflorescenceataheightofabout1m(HamiltonandMurphy1988),otherpalmtrees
havetobeclimbedfortappingastheirterminalbudsandinflorescencesarelocatedatthesummitoftheirtrunkwhichisoftenover10mhigh.Theexcisionoftheterminalbudofstandingtreesisquiteharmfulsince
tappedpalmsneverresumevigorousgrowth.Iftheterminalbudisonlyperforated,thenthetreeswillshowmalformationinsubsequentleaves,flowersandtrunkgrowth(Kovoor1983).Nevertheless,ithasbeen
observedthatmultistemmedtreessuchasHyphaenecoriaceaandPhoenixreclinatainsoutheasternAfricagenerallyrecoppiceaftertapping,althoughtappedstemsdieunlesstappingisstoppedbeforetheapical
meristemistotallydestroyed(Cunningham1990).Theverylowyieldsofsapfromthesetreesareinterpretedasaresultofoverexploitation.Cunningham(1990)suggeststhatifpalmsizeclassesshiftedtotheextent
thattherewasagainahighproportionofmaturefruitbearingpalmsinthepopulation,theninflorescencetappingcouldbepractisedasHyphaenecoriaceaisanannuallyfloweringpalm.
Themostadvancedmethodoftappingisthatappliedtotheinflorescencespadixwhichguaranteesahighyieldforlongperiodswithoutaffectingthewellbeingofthetree.Itonlyentailsasacrificeofabunchoffruit
inthecaseoftappingfemaleinflorescences.TappingtheinflorescenceispractisedthroughoutS.E.Asiaonallspeciesoftappedpalmtrees(Kovoor1983).Twofeaturesarecommonintapping:manipulative
treatmentorpreparation(applicationofchemicalsandsubstanceofplantorigin,twisting,distortion,kneading,pounding,bruising,beatingortapping)necessaryasapreludetocopiousandsustainedsapflow,and
renewingtheexudingwoundbyshavingoffathinsliceoftissueonceortwiceaday(Pethiyagoda1978).Tappingisanart:sapyieldsdependontheskillsofthetapper(KhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin
1996CoconutResearchInstitute1967).
Onceextracted,sugarcaneorsugarbeetjuicesareimmediatelyprocessedforsugarproduction.Inthecaseofpalmsugar,asthesapflowisslow,intermediatestoragebeforecollectionisnecessary:thejuiceisleftfor
aminimumof10hoursattemperaturesaround300C,withhighhygrometryandhighcontaminationswithnaturalyeasts,bacterialandfungalspores(Romera1968Pethiyagoda1978).Usually,ifthesapisusedfor
sugarproduction,itwillbecollectedtwiceadayasfermentationshavetobeavoidedasfaraspossible.However,theinclusionofanantifermentingagentisusual(Kovoor1983):traditionallylimeandbarkorleaves
(richintannins)fromvarioustreespeciesareused.Thevesselsareregularlycleanedandrinsedwithwaterandsometimessmoked.Sugarisproducedbyboilingthesaptoevaporationuntilasufficientlythicksyrup
isobtainedoutofwhichsugarwillcrystallizeoncooling(Kovoor1983).AstudyconductedonBorassusflabelliferandCaryotaurenssapbyJoachimetKandiah(1938)citedbyDissanayake(1986)showsthatlimed
potsinhibitfermentationandinversionofsucrosebetterthansmokedpotsthelattertechniqueiseffectiveonlyforaperiodof3to4hoursaftercollectionfromthetree.
Methodsofpalmtappingandsappreservationforthemainspecies:
Arengapinnata(Syn.:A.saccharifera)
Therearesignificantdifferencesbetweenthemethodspractisedbythedifferenttribes(Mogeaetal1991).Tappingisgenerallydoneonthemaleinflorescencespadix(Redhead1989Friedberg1977).Infact,thesap
fromfemaleinflorescenceisofinferiorqualityandthespadixrequiresmoreeffortduringpreparation(Mogeaetal1991).Awoodenmalletisusedforslowlyhittingseveralminutesadaythetrunkbeneathandabove
thestemoftheinflorescencewhileswingingitbeforeincision(Friedberg1977).Thetappercleansthemaleinflorescencestalkfromitsbractsassoonastheflowersarenearlyopen.Thecleanstalkisthenslowly
beatenforseveralminuteseachdayforabout2or3weeksatadistanceofabout4560cmfromthestalkbase,untilthestalkbecomesswollenlaterthestalkiscutattheswollensection.Thesapiscollectedina
bamboopipe.Ineverytapping,theapexofthestalkissliced1to5mmdependingonthepretreatment.Anothermethodconsistsofsplittingthestemoftheinflorescenceinto2partsandinremovingsecondarystems
exceptthelastfourthataregroupedintoabamboorecipientwherethejuicewillfallthefoursecondarystemsextremitiesarecutandthenbruisedwithwoodplierstwiceadayduring5daysthetwofollowingdays,
theyareputinabamboorecipientcontainingonelitreofwater,thenexttwodays,theyarebruisedagainandthentheproductionstarts(CrevostandLemari1913).Thesimplestmethodconsistsininsertinga
bamboopipeintothebaseofthemaleflowersandtocollectthesapintoagourd(Redhead1989).Theclosertothegroundthemaleinflorescencearises,thesmallerusuallytheamountofsapitproduces(Mogeaetal
1991).InsomeplacesofSulawesi(Indonesia),ArengapinnataandArengawightiiarecutdown,theleavesareloppedandthetrunkisslicedatintervals(Kovoor1983Pethiyagoda1978).
Arengapinnatatappingisaverylabourintensiveactivity.Itisdoneaccordingtoaveryregularworkingscheduleforthegenerallytwiceadayactivity.Beatingandpreparationof20inflorescencestalks(ofwhich
1216willproduceeachfor4months)takessome2.5hourseachday.Onehealthypersoncantap1216treesonthebasisofan8hourworkingday,ormoreifthetreesarecloseenoughtogofromonetotheotherby
jumping.Ontheaverage,apersontapsabout10treesand10workersarenecessaryperhectare(Mogeaetal1991).Tappingmustbedonedailyotherwisethesapflowwilldiminishrapidlyastissuehealingoccurs.
Toslowdownsapfermentation,thecontainerissterilizedwiththesmokeofawoodfire(Mogeaetal1991).
Borassusaethiopium
InBanfora(BurkinaFaso),thetechniqueinvolvesthelateralportionoftheyoungstemanddoesnotkillthetree(Redhead1989).Ahole(10cmdiameter)ismadeabovetheleavecrowninordertoreachtheextremity
oftheterminalbudwhichisessentiallymadeofsofttissuesoftheyoungleaves.Theterminalbudisperforatedsuperficiallyandhorizontallyandthesapiscollectedinacalabashthroughaguttermadeofayoung
foldedleaveputattheperipheryoftheterminalbud(Portres1964).Aheapofleavesisputontheentryoftheholetoprotectthecutbudfromdesiccationandinsects.Theperforationisrefreshedtwiceadayaslong
asthetreelookshealthy.Oncethetreelooksexhausted,theperforationislefttohealandnewleaveswillcomebutthetrunkwillremainstuntedanddeformed(Bellouard1950).
InIvoryCoast,inthepast,maletreesonlyweretappedasfemaletreeswerepreservedforguaranteeingregeneration.Atreewithamarkedbulgeandattheendofitsdevelopment(ataheightof68monthetrunk)is
preferredasitensuresregularity,goodquantityandqualityofthesap.A"ladder",madeofrattancreeper,bambooorrachisofRaphiasp,istiedtothenortheastsideofthetrunk.A"safetybelt"madeofrattan
creeperisalsousedbytheclimberwhileworkingatthetopofthetree.Theleavesarecutexcept2to4sixmontholdleavesonthesouthwestwhichservefordrawingthesapupwardsand2or3petiolesarealsoleft
toserveasaseat.Oneortwotopyoungleavesoftheterminalbudarepreserved.Oneortwodayslater,alateralwindowismadeinthenortheastpetioleinordertoassessthelevelofthebasisoftheterminalyoung
leave.Theterminalbudwillbesectioned10cmbelowthejunctionpetiolelimbofthemoreinternalterminalleave(neithertoolowtoavoidshorteningtotalperiodofproduction,nortoohighasitwilldelayprofuse
sapflow).Allyoungleavesabovethispointaredelicatelycutwithoutdamagingtheterminalbud.Thewindowisenlargedandtheterminalbudsectionedwithaslightslopetowardstheentranceofthehole.Itis
closedandprotectedtoavoidinsectsanddesiccation.Thefollowingdaytheterminalbudiscutagainwithmoreslopetowardsthewindow.Aguttermadefromaleaveisputandgoestoacalabashandtheprotection
isputagain.Thentwiceaday,theterminalbudiscut24mmfurtherandthesapcollected(Portres1964).
InotherAfricanregions(asinSenegal),thetreesareoftentappedtodeathafterseveralmonths.Usedfortheleavesduringthefirstyears,thetreesarethentappedoncetheyhavereached23mhigh.Theheartis
reachedwithaknifeattheleveloftheterminalbud.Ahole,30cmlong15cmbroadand10cmdeepismade.From1to6litresofsap(thereismorecollectionofsapduringthecoldmonthsandwhenthereisfog)will
becollectedeverydayduring4to6months(Bellouard1950Giffard1967).Anothertechniqueconsistsinbruisingandcuttingbuncheswhichisharmlessforthetrees(Chevalier1930).
Borassusflabellifer
Variousmethodsareusedtoclimbthetree(sixrecordedbyKovoor1983),usingankleloops,aerialropewaysbetweentrees,hoopbelt,rivetedbamboo,mobile49mlongladdersandfixedonesontheupperpartof
thetrunks,notchesinthetrunk,etc.TappingtechniquesofBorassusflabelliferaresimilartothatofcoconutexceptforslightdifferences.Sapiscollectedtwiceadayinallcases.Insomecountries(Cambodia),
differenttongsareusedaccordingtothesexofinflorescenceandstageoftapping(Kovoor1983).
InSriLanka,fourdifferentmethodsareusedaccordingtothesexandageoftheinflorescence(Kovoor1983):
Twoweekoldmaleinflorescences:theyarecleanedfromtheiroutersheathsandlefttodryfor3daysthenafreshsurfaceiscutdailyandabout1litreofsapisobtaineddailyforoneandhalfmonths.
Onemontholdmaleinflorescences:allitsspikes(12)arepressed,strokedandgrouped3to6togethertobefittedtoapot.
Youngfemaleinflorescences:themainaxisisstruckwithanironrodtosoftenthetissuesandaforkisusedtocrushthenodeswherefruitswouldarise.
Twotothreemontholdfemaleinflorescences:theyalreadybearfruitswhicharesliceddaily.
InUpperBurma,the8monthdurationtappingseasonconsistsin3tappingphaseswhichalsoincludespecificoperationssuchasfourdifferenttappingtechniques,twoforbothmaleandfemaletrees(Aubert1911).
InCentralBurma,sapcollectioncanbecontinuedallyearroundbutwithlowyieldsbetweenNovemberandJanuary(Lubeigt1977).InCambodia,ifatreestartsgivingmanyinflorescencesatthesametime,someof
them(1to7accordingtotree,climateandlocation)willreceivetheusualtreatmentwhiletheotherswillbeslicedandcrushedfor58daysandthenpreserved(3to5months)forjuicecollectionsomemonthslater
(KhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin1996).Claypots,bamboosinternodes,calabashesorleafbucketsareusedforsapcollection.
Anothertappingtechniqueisasfollows.Theinflorescenceisbruisedinitsparticularstageofgrowththroughbeatingandcrushingitwithwoodentongs.Thenitisboundinto"torches"andtappedbycuttingoffthe
bandagedtips(Redhead1989).Amalletisusedforslowlyhittingseveralminutesadaythetrunkbeneathandabovethestemoftheinflorescencewhileswingingitandfinallypinchingitbeforeincision.Anew
incisionismadeaftereverycollection(Friedberg1977).ThemethoddescribedbyCrevostandLemari(1913)forArengapinnataisalsopractisedonBorassusflabellifer.
Inordertoslowdownthefermentationofthesap,thevesselsaresmokedandcoatedwithlime(Redhead1989).Barkorleavesfromdifferentspeciesarealsoused:Schleicheraoleosabarkorleaves(Friedberg1977
Kovoor1983),ShoreacochinchinensisbarkinCambodia(CrevostandLemari1913Kovoor1983),ShoreaobtusainBurma,ShoreatalurainThailand(Lubeigt1977),Voticahermandianabark(Magalon1930),
Launaeacoromandelicadriedbark,Anacardiumoccidentaleleaves(Kovoor1983),VateriaacumintabarkorCyminosmapedunculata(Dissanayake1986).Thesepiecesofbarkarefinelystampedandaddedtoeach
receivingbucket(Fox1977).Tkatchenko(citedbyKovoor1983)hasfoundthat5to7goflimeperlitreconservethesapquitesatisfactorilyformorethanadayagainstfermentation.InRotiisland(Indonesia),the
tapperusesforeveryproducingpairofrachillaeasetoftwoleafbuckets.Twiceaday,hebrushestheinsideandcleanswithwatertheleafbucketsfromwhichhehasjustcollectedthesapandwhicharegoingtodry
asheplacestheotherleafbucketofthepairforthefollowingsapcollection.Thisisreputedtoslowdownthefermentationofthefreshjuicewithoutchangingitstasteaswoulddolimeorbarkadditives(Fox1977).
InUpperBurma,theearthenvesselsusedforsapcollectionreceivespecialtreatment.Beforebeingusedforthefirsttime,theyarewashedandexposed,stillwet,withtheiropeningstowardsafiremadeofdried
branchesandleavesforabout10minutes.Thentheyarechangedtwicedailyaftereverysapcollection.Theyarebroughtbacktothehouseandwashedanddriedandjustbeforereplacingthemonthetree,afewchips
ofthebarkofShorearobustaareputinthevessel(Aubert1911).
Caryotaurens
Theinflorescenceinitsparticularstageofgrowthisboundintoa"candle"formandtappedbyrepeatedlyslicingofftheendofthecandle(Redhead1989).Thebruisingtechniqueissimilartotheoneusedfor
Borassusflabellifer(Magalon1930).InSriLanka,thetechniquehasbeendescribedindetailsbyDissanayake(1977):"Whentheflowerappears,itistappedbeforeitreachesmaturity.TheartoftappingaCaryota
urensflowerisverymuchavillagecraftrequiringahighdegreeoftraditionalexpertise.Alongbamboopoleiserectedalongthetrunkwithsuitablesupporttoreachthecrown.Theselectedflowerispreparedfor
tappingfirstbybeatingitwithastoneorwoodandthentiedwithastringinseveralplacestokeepitinpropershape.Aconcoctionmadeofherbs,ashandsaltisthenappliedtotheendoftheflower,whereafine
angularslashismade.Tappingbegins34daysafterthisapplicationabigearthenpotisplacedattheendoftheflowertocollectthesap."
ThemostcommonmethodsusedinSriLankatopreventfermentationofthesapare:liningtheinsideofthecollectingpotwithfreshlimeplacingVateriacopalliferabark,CareyaarboreabarkorAchronychia
laurifolialeavesinacleanpotbeforeitisusedforcollectingsap(TheivendirarajahandJeyaseelan1977).Studiesshowedthatlimeisthemosteffective,nextVateriacopalliferabark,followedbyCareyaarborea
barkandAchronychialaurifolialeavesVateriacopalliferabarkcouldbeusedaseffectivelyaslimetopreservesweettoddyfor39hours(TheivendirarajahandJeyaseelan1977).
Cocosnucifera
InSriLanka,segmentsofcoconuthuskaregenerallyfastenedallthewayupthetrunkforclimbingthecoconuttreealooproundtheanklesisusedsometimes(CoconutResearchInstitute1967).InsouthSumatra,
simplenotchesarecarvedinthetrunk.Theinflorescenceinitsparticularstageofgrowthistapped(Redhead1989).Thedevelopmentoffemaleflowersinsidethespathe(about60cmlong)causesaswellingatthe
basisofthespathe.Theappearanceoftheswellingistakenasthecorrectstagefortapping.Theinflorescenceselectedfortappingisfirsttrained,byagentleuniformbeatingalloverthespathe,twiceaday,inthe
morningandintheevening,thespathebeingwoundaroundwithastrongcoirorcoconutfibrestringtopreventitfrombursting.Afteraweek'sbeating,about710cmofthetipofthespatheiscutoff.Onthethird
day,thecutendiscarefullypounded(CoconutResearchInstitute1967).Beatingiscontinuedforaboutaweek,whileanearthenpot(inSriLanka)orabambootube(Thailand)ishungfromthespadixtocollectthe
oozingliquidfromthecutsurface(Grimwood1975).Thefreeendofthespadixisgraduallybentdown(CoconutResearchInstitute1967).Ifthetreesaretappedforsweetjuice,theyarecollectedinthemorning
(Rangaswami1977).Thesapgenerallybeginstodripafter1215days,orupto35afterthebeginningofthetappingprocessaccordingtothetapper'sskill,seasonalconditionsandnatureofthepalm.Thenslicing
about2mmandcollectingsaparedonetwiceadaywhiletappingandbruisingoperationsarediscontinued(Nathanael1970,citedbyKovoor1983CoconutResearchInstitute1967).Nevertheless,lighttappingofthe
endofthespathewithamalletmaybecontinuedandtheslicedsurfaceofthespatheissometimessmearedwithamixtureofbruisedleaveswhichcontainssaponinandstimulatesthesapflow(Child(1964)citedby
Grimwood1975).Asinglespathewillbetappeduntilitisreducedtoastumpabout1015cminlength.Aboutthreeweeksbeforereachingthispoint,anotherspatheispreparedinordertoensurecontinuityofsap
productionwithoutanybreakforaperiodofoneyearongoodpalms(Nathanael(1970,citedbyKovoor1983).
AccordingtoRedhead(1989),coconutsaptobeusedforjaggeryiscollectedinthemorningsonly,incleanvesselscontainingafermentationinhibitorsuchaslime.InThailand,thebarkofVateriaacuminataor
Shoreataluramaybeadded.Theslicedsurfaceofthespathemightalsobedaubedwithlime(Levang1988).InIndonesia,theearthenwarepotsaresterilizedinanakedflameandaboutateaspoonfull(5g)offinely
cutchipsofVateriaacuminatabarkisadded(Purnomo1992).InMalaysia,aquarterofthecontainerisfilledwithamildsolutionoflimewatertogetherwithdriedlatexfrommangosteenbark(NaimandHusin
1984).
Coryphaelata(Syn.:C.utan)
Theentiregrowingpointoftheterminalinflorescenceisexcisedjustbeforethedevelopmentoftheinflorescencestarts(Redhead1989Kovoor1983VanDie1974).Ashallowdepressionisscoopedoutatthetopof
thenakedstem,andthejuiceiscollectedfromthedepression(Redhead1989Kovoor1983).InRoti(Indonesia),thetechniqueconsistsinbreachingtheinflorescence(Fox1977).Incisionsoftheflowerstalkarealso
reported(Pethiyagoda1978).
Elaeisguineensis
ThemostcommonmethodinWestAfrica,andparticularlyinIvoryCoastandGhanaisdestructive.Justbeforethefructification,theyoungtreeisfelleddownbylooseningtherootswithaspadeandpullingdown
thetree.Foroldertrees,thetrunkiscutat3060cm.Allfrondsinthemerismaticregionareremovedafteroneortwoweeks.Acavityismadeintheterminalbud.Itiseitherarectangularwellabout7.5cmdeepwith
aroundholeboredinitsfloororabowlshapedhollow10cmx9cm,abouttwothird(15cm)thediameterofthestemindepth.Abrandisputinitinordertoactivatethesapflowandreducetheinfestationofthewell
byinsectsandtheirlarvae,bacteria,mouldsandyeasts.Collectionofthesapstarts2to4dayslater,usingabamboogutter(15cmlong)whichgoesintoacontainer(calabash)underthestem.Itisdonetwiceaday:
eachtime,thetappercutsawayfromtheterminalbuda1mmlayeroftissueandflareswithfirethestemsurfacearoundthetappingwound.Thesapflowlasts1to2months(BlancPamard1980Kovoor1983
Essiamah1992Hartley1977SodahAyernorandMatthews1971).AlessdestructivemethodispractisedinNigeria(Igbos)andconsistsinpiercingthestemofthestandingtreeuptothebud(Tuley(1965)citedby
Kovoor1983).AdetaileddescriptionisgivenbyEssiamah(1992).Severalleavesarecutoffthesideofthestem.Arectangularhole(8cmx510cm)iscutinthestemtoadepthofabout30cmormoreaccordingto
thesizeofthepalmtree.Asuctionpipemadeofbambooisusedtocollectthesapintoajughungonthestem.Asthesapflowisveryintense,thetappermustclimbthetree3timesadaytocollectit.Eachtime,he
cutsawayathinlayeroftissuefromthewoundsurfaceinadownwarddirection.Thelengthoftherectangularholecanthusextendto30cmormoreaccordingtothedurationofsapflow.Thetreedies2or3weeks
afterbeingtapped.InMadagascar(Sakalava),theterminalbudisalsoincised(Decary1964).
Anondestructivemethodconsistsintappingthemaleinflorescences(SprechervonBernegg1929,citedbyVanDie1974).ItisespeciallypractisedbytheJorubasinNigeria,butitisalsofoundinBeninandIvory
Coast.IthasbeendescribedindetailbyEssiamah(1992)andSodahAyernorandMatthews(1971).Allfrondsbelowanunopenedmaleinflorescence(beforethedifferentiationoftheflowerspikesstarts)arecutoff
andtheleafsubtendingitisremovedtoobtainaccesstotheinflorescenceenclosedinitsspathes.About7.5cmabovethebaseofthemaleinflorescence,aneattriangularholeismadeinthefrontspathe(about2.5to
6cmdeepinthemainstemofthespadixand2.5cmonthesides).Theholeisthencoveredandthefollowingdayafunnelofsmallbamboo(16cmlongand2cmindiameter)isinsertedinthecutinsuchaposition
thatthesapflowsintocalabashes(vessels).Toensurecontinuousflow,theholeisextendeddownwardsbyremovingadailysliceofabout3mm.Thetappingisstoppedwhenthebaseofthemaleinflorescenceis
reached.Thesapiscollectedmorningandeveningandanewslicetakenateachcollection.Palmtreestappedinthismannersetfruitonetotwoyearsaftertapping(SodahAyernorandMatthews1971).InCasamance
(Senegal),theDiolauseasimilartechniquebutbothmaleandfemaleinflorescencesareused.Whilepreparingtheinflorescence,itsstemiscoveredwithamattressofleaveswhichisstruckvigorouslywiththehead
ofanaxeinordertostimulatethearrivalofthesap(Adand1954).
Hyphaenecoriacea
ThetechniqueisdescribedindetailsbyCunningham(1990).Palmclumpsareselectedandlargestemswithintheseclumpsarepreparedfortappingafterburningeachclumptoremoveundergrowthandleafspines.
Selectedstemsaretrimmedtoinitiatesapflowusingarazorsharpbushknifewhettedagainstastickkeptforthatpurpose.Thestemandyoungleafbasesarecutataslightangletoguidesapontoaleafgutterand
intotheclaycollectioncontainer.Bytheendofthetappingperiod,theseyoungleafbaseshavebeenremovedbytrimming2to3timesperdayovera5to7week'speriod.Thereforetheterminalbudiscuttodeath
ofthestembuttheclumpsurvives(Cunningham1990).
Hyphaenethebaica
InDjiboutiandEritrea,theterminalbudisoftencuttodeathofthestem(Jahiel1993Fanshawe1966).AsHyphaenethebaicaisamultistemmedpalm,thispracticedoesnotmeanalwaysthedeathoftheclump.
Thereisalsoalessdestructivetechnique.Theselectedstemiscleanedfromallleaves.Thenonlythebasesofthefutureleavesarecutbutnottheterminalbuditself.Newcutsarepractisedupto4timesadayfora
coupleofweeksandgenerallystoppedbeforereachingtheterminalbud.Sometapperswillreachthisterminalbudinordertogetmoresapbeforehavingtoprepareanothertree(Audru1985).
Jubaeaspectabilis
Thetreeisfirstfelled,theleavesloppedandthetrunksliceddailyoveraperiodofsixtoeightweeksduringwhichthebleedingsapiscollected(Pethiyagoda1978).Darwin(1860,citedbyKovoor1983)reported
yieldsofaround400litres.
Mauritiaflexuosa(Syn.:M.vinifera)
Thepalmsarecutdown,defoliatedandscorchedforincreasingsapflow.Thesapistappedfromtheinflorescencestalksorbyholesmadeintothetrunkduringthedevelopmentofinflorescences(Kovoor1983
Pethiyagoda1978).
Nypafruticans
Thestalkoftheinflorescenceiscutataproperstage(Redhead1989).Nevertheless,pretreatmentofthestalkispossibleatvariousstagesofinfructescencedevelopmentfromfloweringtomaturefruitingstages.
Plantsatmorematurestagesrequirelongerperiodsofpretreatmentthanatyoungstages.Kiew(1989)characterizestheproperstageasfollows:thefruitingheadiswelldevelopedbuthasnotbeguntodarken.
Spathesandbractsatthebaseofthefruitheadarecleanedoff(Davis1988).Thefruitingheadisfirstoscillatedgently,thenwithincreasingseverityuntilafter3weeks,itissubjectedtoviolentshaking(Watson1928,
citedbyKiew1989).AccordingtoDennett(1927),thisoperationpreventsthecellsfromhardeningandatrophyingasthestalkmatures.Thestalkkeepssoftandsupplecomparedtoanontreatedstalk.Studyingthe
labourcosts,thesameauthorfoundthat3weekswasthemostprofitabledurationforthistreatment.Thebruisedinflorescenceistappedbylighthammeringandbyincisingthetissuesabovethebruisedportionas
closeaspossibletotheyoungfruit.Thealmostfullgrownfruitheadiscutaway(HamiltonandMurphy1988).Eachdayaftercollectingthejuice,athinsliceofabout2mmisremoved.Cuttingtoolsaredisinfected
sinceflowisreducedbybacterialgrowth(HamiltonandMurphy1988).Sapflowdependsmainlyonpriorpreparationofthestalk:ifnoneisdone,flowwillbelowandwilllastonlyafewdays.Thebaseofthestalk
iskickedinmostcountrieswherethistreeistapped.InPapuaNewGuinea,asophisticatedprotocolhasbeendevelopedbyPivke(1985):bendingthestalk12timesinonedirectionpattingthelengthofthestalk
backwardsandforwardswiththebarehands64timeskickingthebaseofthestalk4timesandrepeatingthis4timesaweek.Yieldsof1,800ml/day/treeoveramonthwerereachedinintensivelytreatedyounger
agedstandswhereasonly155ml/day/treewereproducedwhenthetreatmentwasdoneonlyonceaweek(Pivke1985).InthePhilippines,thescheduleofkickinglastsfor3monthsand10daysperpalm:oncea
weekduringthefirstmonthafterflowering,twiceaweekduringthesecondmonth,onceeverytwodaysduringthethirdmonthandfinallydailyfor10days(Melana(1980,citedbyHamiltonandMurphy1988).
Tappinglifedependsonthelengthofthestalkwhichcanvaryalot:0.6to1minthePhilippines,1.4minSumatraand1.9minPapuaNewGuinea(HamiltonandMurphy1988).Toslowdowntheveryrapid
fermentationofthesap,thebamboorecipients(2litrescapacity)arewashedwithlimeandwater(Redhead1989CrevostandLemari1913).
Phoenixdactylifera
Theentiregrowingpointiscutoffandashallowdepressionisscoopedoutatthetopofthenakedstem.Thejuiceiscollectedfromthedepression(Redhead1989Kovoor1983).Anothertechniqueconsistsincutting
offthefronds:exudationofsapoccursinthecavitycreatedbydefoliation(Pethiyagoda1978).Tappingadatepalmisasevereinterventionasitdeprivesthepalmofmostofitsleavesandfoodreservesgreatcareis
requiredduringthetwicedailyscarring,becauseifitiscarriedontoofar,thepalmwilldie.Every20daysorso,thecone,canalandspoutarereadjusted.Aftertappingiscompleted(uptothreeorfourmonths),three
tofouryearsareneededforthetreetobeabletobearafullcropoffruitagainandfiveyearsbeforetappingitagain(Barreveld1993).UsingtheIndianmethodoftappingforPhoenixsylvestrisonPhoenix
dactylifera,Barreveld(1993)reportedinferiordailyyieldsbutconsideringthatannualtappingwouldbepractisedinthiscase,therewouldbehigheryieldsofsappertreeoveraperiodof3to4yearsnevertheless,
labourhoursinvolvedperunitsapharvestedisdefinitelyhigher.
Phoenixreclinata
InIvoryCoast,thetreeiscutdownanduprooted,allleavesareremovedandtheterminalbudiscut.Acavityismadeinwhichabrandisputinordertoactivatethesapflow.Collectionofthesapstarts3to4days
laterthroughagutterlinkedtoacalabash.Collectionisdonetwiceaday,eachtime,theterminalbudisfurthercut.Itlasts1to2months(BlancPamard1980).Anothertechniqueconsistsinincisingthelateral
portionoftheyoungstem(Redhead1989).InsoutheasternAfrica,thesametechniqueasdescribedbyCunningham(1990)forHyphaenecoriaceaisused.
Phoenixsylvestris
Thestemispierceduptotheterminalbud(Kovoor1983).InBangladesh,theoldestleavesareremovedattheendofOctoberononesideofthepalmtreealongabout35cm.Thebasesofthepetiolesandthesheaths
arecarefullyremoved.Atrianglepieceofbark(pointdownwards)iscutbutgreatcaremustbetakennottoexposethesapsupplyinginnerzone.Aweeklater,asthefinecoveringofsofttissuesgetsalittlehardened
andbeginstocrack,thiscoveringisremovedwithoutdamagingtheinnerzone.Thencomesarestof12to14daysafterwhichalateralincisionisdoneinthetriangle.Thesapexudingfromthescoopedsurfaceisrun
throughabamboospoutintoavessel.Anewincisionismadethe2followingdaysandthenthereisa4dayperiodofrestandthesamecycleisrepeateduntiltheheartisreached.Thefollowingyear,thesame
treatmentisdoneontheothersideofthetreewhichgivesazigzagconfigurationtothetrunktappingcanbepractisedeveryyearforseveraldecades(averageof25years)(Fealy1925Annett1913Barreveld1993).
Inordertoslowdownthefermentationofthesap,theearthenvesselarecoatedwithlimeinBangladesh,theyarewellsmokedeverymorning(Annett1913).
Raphiahookeri
InsomepartsofNigeria,thepalmsarecutdownandscorchedforincreasingsapflow(Kovoor1983).ThesapcanalsobecollectedfromtheupperstempiercedtodeathasitiscurrentlypractisedinWestAfricathe
methodisthesameastheonedescribedforoilpalmsbyIgbosinNigeria(Tuley1965,citedbyKovoor1983Essiamah1992).Thetappersextractthesapjustbeforetheappearanceofthespadixandtappingisdone
onfloweringtrunks(Profizi1988).InCameroon,thebaseofthetreeissplitbeforefruitproduction(Fyot1973).
Multipurposeuses
AsdescribedinAnnex1,mostpalmtreeshavemultipurposeuses(seealsothereviewbyJohnson1997).Theseusesarenotalwayscompatible.Sapproductionisatitsmaximumjustbeforeorduringfruitformation,
whenstarchesinthestemareconvertedintosugarswhichenterthesapandflowtothesiteoffruitformation.Tappingthetreecompeteswiththeproductionoftheripeningfruit(Redhead1989).Nevertheless,some
speciescanbeexploitedforbothfruitandsap,butthetreesmightdieprematurelyinthecaseofoverexploitation(Redhead1989).TappingBorassusaethiopiumimpedesfruitproductionandisdetrimentaltothe
qualityofthewoodcollectingyoungleavesreducessapyields(Bellouard1950).InMaduraisland(Indonesia),pruningtheBorassusleavestwiceayearwilldrasticallyreducethejuiceproducinglifeofthetreefrom
3040yearsto810whilemoderatepruningwillstillpermit2030yearsofjuiceproduction(Fox1977).Nypafruticansimmatureleavesarecutforcigarettepapers,matureleavesforthatchbutharvestingleaves
reducestheyieldofsugar(Kiew1989).InIvoryCoast,theAfricanoilpalmistappedbeforefructificationwhichkillsthetreewithinoneortwomonths(BlancPamard1980).
Tappingcanalsostimulatefruitproduction:ayoungcoconutpalmtappedduring612monthsforsugarproductionwillthenproducemorenuts(Magalon1930Fealy1925).Thishasbeenclearlydemonstratedby
Mathes(1984):low(inregardtonutproduction)yieldingpalms,aftertapping,hadafruitproductionthreetimesthatofthehighyieldingpalms,anddoublethatoftheveryhighyieldinguntappedpalms.Atechnique
calledsequentialcoconuttoddyandnutproductionhasbeendevelopedinthePhilippinesattheDavaoResearchCentre.Thefirsthalfofthespatheistappedandthesecondhalfisleftforfruitproductionasfemale
flowersthatdeveloptomaturenutsaresituatedinthislowerportion.Nutandcoprayieldsareabout50%lowerthannontappedpalmshowever,thistechniquehasbeendemonstratedtobeveryfeasibleandhighly
profitableforsmallproducers(MaravillaandMagat1993).
Arengapinnatacanbetappedwhentheyarebetween1215andmorethan30yearsoldthentheycanbecutforsagoproduction(Sumadi1988).Nevertheless,inWestJava,wheresagoisobtainedfromtrees1012
yearsold,notappingwillbedonepreviously,farmersarguingthatitwouldreducethequantityofstarchinthetrunk(Mogeaetal1991).InEasternNigeria,oilpalmsthathavebeenabandonedasuneconomicbunch
producersusuallygivegoodeconomicreturnsforwineproduction(usinganondestructivetappingtechniqueonmaleinflorescences)beforeoldplantingsareclearedandreplanted(Tuley1965a).
Roleinsustainableintegratedproductionsystemsandintheprotectionoftheenvironment
TherearevarioustypesofpalmcropassociationsinBangladesh.PhoenixsylvestrisandBorassusflabellifercanbothbeassociatedwithseveralofthefollowingcrops:rice,wheat,chickpea,mustard,jute,lentil,
potato,linseed,wintervegetablesandsugarcane(Abedinetal1987).Palmtreesoftenhaveadvantagescomparedwithothercropsasfarassustainabilityisconcerned:inpartsofwestJavawhereArengapinnatais
stilltendedingroves,soilsappearmuchmorestableandproductiveofothercropsthanwherecassavaiscultivated(Dransfield1977).Furthermoretheadvantagesofthistreeareitsgreatecologicaltolerance,its
abilitytogrowandstabilizeunproductiveerosionpronesitessuchassteepdrylandslopes(e.g.,coffeeorchardsonstonyslopesinNorthSulawesi,Mogeaetal1991),itspotentialtogrowonalmostanytypeofsoil,
toincreasesoilfertilityandwaterconservation,itsgreattoleranceofaccidentalburning(theonlysurvivingtreeintheMinahassa,Sulawesi,aftervolcanicactivity),therelativelyfastgrowthrate,thefactthatitneeds
almostnomaintenanceandusuallydoesnotsufferfromanyseriouspestsordisease,andthewiderangeofsecondaryoralternateproductsobtainable.Arengapinnataisconsideredasoneofthemostdiverse
multipurposetreespeciesandthemostimportantsugarpalmofthehumidtropicsafurtheradvantageisthatthistreegrowswildinmanyplaces(Mogeaetal1991).
BorassusflabelliferisoftenplantedonboundariesofpaddyfieldsinCambodiaandIndia.Theeffectsofshadingonunderstoreycropsarelikelytobenegligibleduetothesmallsizedcrownsandtothelargespace
(1015m)betweentrees(JambulingamandFernandes1986).InCambodia,ricecultivationandBorassusflabellifersugarproductionareassociatedinmanyareas:anaveragefamilyowns2425Borassusflabellifer
treesand22.5haricefield(Romera1968).Thistreethrivesinreputedlythepoorest,infertileandaridregions.IncentralBurma,afterayearofdrought,itstillcanproducesapduringayearbuttheyieldwill
decreaseandtheflowwillfinallystop(Lubeigt1977Lubeigt1979).Italsosuffersremarkablylittlefromprolongedflooding.Itisextraordinarilypestanddiseaseresistant,requiringlimitedmeansofcultivationif
any.Asitgrowsinsandyplains,itisusedforblockingerosionandfixingdunes,thankstoitsdeeprootsystem(Kovoor1983).Itisalso,likeCoryphaelata,afireresistantpalmthatispioneerspeciesonregularly
burntlandsuchasthoseexploitedbytheslashandburntechnique(Ormeling1956,citedbyFox1977).Theyoungtrees(upto15to40years)areusedinBurmaaswindbreakinareascroppedwithgroundnut
(Lubeigt1977Lubeigt1979).ItplaysamajorroleinSavuandRotiislands(Indonesia)wherethesoilfertilityisacrucialconstraint.Thetraditionalslashandburnsystem,whichiscurrentlypractisedin
neighbouringislands(TimorandSumbaforexample),hasbeenreplacedbysemipermanentgardeningthroughtheuseoflargeamountsofoldBorassusleavesthatareburntinthefields.Thispermitsfertilegardens
tobekeptinthevicinityofthehouses.Animalmanureisalsousedinselectedgardens.Inadditiontoanintensivepigrearing,theseislandsarealsofamousforhavingwelldevelopedgoatandsheepherdsandfor
havingkeptwaterbuffalowhereasinneighbouringislandsthesehavebeendisplacedbyBalicattle.GardensareeasilyfencedwithpalmleafstalksbutinmanycasesinSavu,animalsarepennedorcorralledand
fieldsareleftunfenced.Thereforethesetwoislandswhicharedrier,morewindsweptandmoreerodedthatlargerneighbouringislands,havebasedtheirmainrelianceonpalmutilizationintegratedwithwetrice
cultivation,dryfieldcultivation,gardening,herdingandfishing.allthesecomponentsoftheintegratedfarmingsystemsvaryinproportionaccordingtoareaandyearsandshowthegreatsenseofadaptabilitythat
thesepeoplehavereached.Whereashungerperiodsandfaminesusedtooccurfollowingdroughtsinneighbouringislands,calculationswerealwaysmadeinSavuandRotiinorderthatfailedcropscouldbealways
replacedbyotherfoods,Borassussaporsyrupbeingtheultimateonethatwasnevermissing(Fox1977).Borassusforestspossessapotentiallyuniquepatternofnutrientcycling,whichenablesthemtosupport
relativelyproductiveandstableformsofagricultureaswellastocontributetorecoveryofdisturbedsites(Anderson1987).
InthePeruvianAmazonia,Mauritiaflexuosaconstitutesdensepopulationsinseasonalswampforestsonwaterloggedsoilsoronsandysoils,whicharegenerallyconsideredasunfitforagriculture(Kahn1988).
Unlikesugarcane,Nypafruticansdoesnotcompetewithothercropsforagriculturallandexceptwheretotalreclamationisundertakenonmangroveland(HamiltonandMurphy1988).
Socioeconomicaspectsoftappingpalmtrees
Nowadays,thefivemajoreconomicpalmsoftheworldarecoconut(Cocosnucifera),Africanoilpalm(Elaeisguineensis),date(Phoenixdactylifera),betelnutpalm(Arecacatechu)andpejibaye(Bactrisgasipaes).
Evenifthethreefirstspeciesmentionedarecurrentlytapped,thisremainshighlymarginalintheireconomicrole.
Intheyear1910,93%ofthetotalamountofalcoholandalcoholicbeveragesproducedinthePhilippineislandswasprocessedin68distilleriesfrom90millionslitresofthesapexudingfrompalmtrees(mainlynipah
andcoconutpalms)thisindustrywasconstantlyincreasingandnipahpalmwasconsideredthecheapestsourceofalcoholintheworld(Gibbs1911).Besidesthis,therewasalsoaverylargeconsumptionof
undistilledpalmsap.InBurma,duringthebeginningoftheseventies,upto28millionbottleofarakmadefromBorassusflabellifersapwerecommercializedperyearthroughshopsandbars,whichmeansabouta
bottleperinhabitant(Lubeigt1979).In1969,palmwineproducedinNigeriawasestimatedatroughly2millionmetrictons(FMANR1974,citedbyOkereke1982).Inthiscountry,thetradeinpalmwineprovidesa
sourceofincome,notonlytothetappersthemselves,butalsotoawiderangeofmarketintermediaries(Okereke1982).ThespeciesofRaphia(R.hookeri,R.vinifera,R.sudanica)areveryimportantintheeconomy
ofthevillagesaroundtheswampsinWestAfrica(SouthernBeninandNigeria):mostofthepeopleusesthefruitsandtheleaves,andpalmwineismadefromthesapwhichisconsumedfreshordistilled(Profizi
1988Tuley1965b).PalmwineisalsostilllargelyproducedandcommercializedinIvoryCoastwhereitprovidesgoodopportunitiesofemployment(BlancPamard1980).InmanypartsofNigeria,andotherpartsof
WestAfrica,theoilpalmssurroundinglargetownsareregularlytappedforwineproduction.Itisanindustryofconsiderableeconomicandnutritionalimportancewhichsatisfiesasteadymarketintheseareaswhere
higherreturnsareensuredusingoilpalmforwineproductioninsteadofoilproduction(Hartley1977).InSouthEasternAfrica,palmwinetappingofHyphaenecoriaceaandPhoenixreclinataisalabourintensive
activity(highdensitiesofsmallpalmswithlowyields)providingasubsistenceincometogetherwithpastoralismandgatheringofwildfruits(Cunningham1990).
AsestimatedbyPethiyagoda(1978),intheearlydecadesofthiscentury,inSouthEastAsiancountries,hundredsofthousandsoftonnesofsugarwereproducedannuallythroughthetapping,mainlyofArengasp,
Borassussp,Cocossp,NypaspandPhoenixsp.Between10and17%(estimateof480,000tonnesofpalmsugarin1911)ofIndia'ssugarwasproducedfrompalms(Annett1913).InBangladesh,theindustryofsugar
madefromPhoenixsylvestrisisanoldoneanddatesugarwasreportedaslargelymanufacturedandexportedattheendoftheeighteencentury.Inthemiddleofthelastcentury,afterslaveemancipationmeasures
graduallydecreasedthesuppliesofsugarfromtheWestIndies,arapidriseindatesugarproductionoccurred.In1849,onefifth(10,000tonnes)ofthewholeannualquantityofsugarexportedfromIndiatoEngland
wasdatesugar(Annett1913).
Palmtapperscanbeeitherprosperousoramongthepoorest:thisismainlyrelatedtothetreeandlandproperty.InSavuisland(Indonesia),tappingisanactivityamongothersandtappersowntheirlandandtrees.In
UpperBurma,mosttappersarelandlessandthepalmtreesarethepropertyofawelloffminoritywhichgetsonethirdofthesapproduced(Aubert1911).InSriLanka,theartoftappingCaryotaurensandmaking
jaggeryhasbeenrecognizedasanimportantfunctiontowarranttheexistenceofaseparatesubcastewhichstillexiststoday(Dissanayake1977).InthelowrainfallGangesfloodplainofBangladesh,juiceextraction
fromPhoenixsylvestrisandmolassesmakingsupportaspecialgroupoftechnicians,whoareusuallypoorfarmers(Abedinetal1987).Arengapinnata,throughproductionandprocessingofitssapandsagoensures
increasedfarmers'incomesandruralemploymentopportunities(Sumadi1988).InWestJava,itcontributeswidelytothedailylifeofmanyvillagersforwhomitisalsoaconsiderablesourceofincome.InNorth
Sulawesi,thedowryisstillpayableintheformofanumberofsugarpalms,indicatingthegreateconomicvalueplacedonthesetrees.There,anaverageof6fullygrownpalmscanprovideagoodincomeforone
family(Mogeaetal1991).InthePhilippines,mostcoastalfarmersdependonNypafruticanssapproductionfortheirincome(Quimbo1991).In1986,118tonnesofNypafruticanssugarvaluedatM$237,464was
exportedfromMalaysia(Kiew1991).InSarawak(Malaysia),nipahtappingiscarriedoutasacottageindustryandprovidesalivelihoodtoagroupofpeoplewhohavenoothermeansofearningaliving(Pearce
1991).InmanyAsiancountries,theuseofthismultipurposepalmtreecontinuesandinsomeplaces,theyhavebecomethebasisforcottageindustriesandcommercialoperation.AccordingtoKiew(1991),coconut
palmsugarisstillforsaleineverygroceryshopinpeninsularMalaysia.Recently,somelargescalecommercialinteresthasdeveloped:inparticular,thehighcostoffossilfuelandfertilizerhasinitiatedanewlookat
thefuelalcoholandsugarpotentialofpalmtrees(HamiltonandMurphy1988).
PalmsofthegeniusBorassuscomesecondonlytothecoconutinthepalmpopulationoftheworldandtheyspantwocontinentsacrossagoodthirdoftheequator(Kovoor1983)wheretheyhavebeentappedfor
centuries.Kovoor(1983)notesthatthesimplerationaleofavoidingsinglecropeconomiesbyallpossiblemeansisbyitselfsufficienttofosterthesystematiccultivationandexploitationofthispalm.Generally
speaking,itisthepoorandthelandlessthatbenefitmostfromtheBorassuspalm(Fox1977).InIndia,itistappedbymembersofthelowestcastesanditplaysanimportantroleintheeconomyoftheruralpoor,
especiallyindroughtproneareas(Rangaswami1977).InTamilNadu,itprovidesfarmerswithacashincomethroughoutthedryseasonwhenthereisnocroponthefieldsandwhendemandforonfarmlabourislow
(JambulingamandFernandes1986).Ferguson(1850,citedbyFox1977)givessomedetailsontheimportanceofthistree:"ItisnotthewholesomenessornourishingqualitiesoftheedibleproductsoftheBorassus
flabellifertreethatmakeitsoimportanttotheinhabitantsofIndiabutsimplythefact,thatthousands,perhapsmillionsofthepeoplecanprocurethesefromtheirBorassusflabellifergroves,orpurchasethemfora
lowratefromtheirneighbourswhilstRiceandotherarticlesoffood,arefrequentlysoexpensiveastobeplacedbeyondtheirmeans.TheBorassusflabellifertreeis,inthisrespect,whatthePotatohassolongbeen
tothepoorIrishandScotch".InBurma,halfofthesugarconsumedinthecountrycomesfromBorassusflabellifer(Lubeigt1977).InUpperBurma,thetappersformaspecialclass,theprofessionishandeddown
fromfathertoson,requiringlongtrainingandgoodskills.Themenonlyaretappersbutallthefamilyisinvolvedinsapcollectionandprocessing.Thelifeishard,badlyremuneratedandattendedoftenwithsad
accidents(Aubert1911).SeveralhundredthousandsofpeopleliveonBorassusflabelliferinCentralBurmaandmorethanonemillionforallBurma(Lubeigt1977Lubeigt1979).Thislimitsthedriftfromtheland.
BorassusflabelliferisalsoimportantintheBurmesemythology:theKingAnoratha(10441077),founderofthefirstgreatBurmeseEmpire,hadfourclosepaladins,oneofthemwellknownforhisconsiderable
strengthdemonstratedbyhisabilitytoclimbonethousandsugarpalmtreesinasingleday(Lubeigt1979).InIndonesia,thousandsofpoorfamiliesintheMaduraandSundaislandgroupmaketheirlivingfromthis
palmbecauseofitsmultipleuses,thesweetsaprepresentingitsmosteconomicallyvaluableproduct(Davis1988).IntwoIndonesianislands,RotiandSavu,studiedbyFox(1977),thepopulationsdependfortheir
survivalonutilizationoftheBorassus.Thereisanearlytotalexploitationofthistreewhichisharvestedfordailyneedsandwhichconstitutesthepivotofacomplexdiverseeconomy.ThepotentialissuchthatFox
notesthattheprecisecarryingcapacityofthiseconomicadaptationtopalmutilizationremainsunknown.RotineseandSavuneselivelargelyfromthesugaroftheirtrees:freshsapthroughouttheproductionseasonor
dilutedsyrupotherwiseisconsumedseveraltimesaday,ofteninplaceofanysolidfood.Fox(1977)notesthatitcanbeliterallysaidoftheRotineseandSavunesethattheyarefed,equipped,attired,buried,and
rememberedaftertheirdeceasebytheproductsoftheirpalms.Greaterspecializationhasaccompaniedincreaseofpopulationdensity:asBorassustappingisalabourintensiveactivity,andaslongasthereare
sufficientpalms,newlabourisabsorbed.ButinsomeareasinSavu,wherethepopulationdensitiesarethehighest,nativepalmswerenotsufficientandthereforepeoplehaveplantedclustersofpalmsinfenced
enclosures,whichinturnpermitsincreasedefficiencyintappingandfurtherintensifiesallthecomponentsoftheintegratedsystemsguaranteeingbetteryields.SomeRotineseandSavuneseestablishedthemselvesin
partsofSumbaandTimorislandswheretheyreproducedtheirtraditionalfarmingsystembasedonBorassusandbecameeconomicallystrongerthanthenativepeople(Ormeling1956,citedbyFox1977).Borassus
palmsareessentialbuffersforensuringfoodsecurityofmanypeopleinAsiawhendroughtsoccurandothercropsfail(Fox1977).InCambodia,whereBorassusisassociatedwithrice,ifthericeyieldsarelow,the
harvestofBorassussapisincreased(Romera1968).There,theareaswhereBorassusflabellifertreesaremorenumerousarealsoareaswithhigherpopulationdensities.Borassusflabellifersugarproductionis
essentialfortheruralcommunityhavingreachedacertaindensity.Oncefuelwoodbecomesscarce,immigrationstarts(Romera1968).Sugarpalmsyrupproductionisstilltodaythemainactivityinmostofrural
Cambodiaafterricegrowing(KhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin1996).InthecaseofBorassusflabelliferandCaryotaurens,themostimportantandprimarymaterialistheirsap,andwhileotherproducts
ofthesepalmshavebeenreplacedbysubstitutes,jaggeryandtoddystilldemonstratecostadvantagestothecommunitieswhousethem(Dissanayake1986).
Originofthedeclineinpalmtreetappingactivity
Oneofthemainreasonsforthedeclineofsugarproductionfrompalmtreesistheincreasinglackoffuelwoodanditsincreasingprice.SugarproductionfromArengapinnatarequires23m3woodfor100to120kg
ofsugar(Mogeaetal1991).InSouthSumatra,3to4kgofdryclovetreeleavesor0.02m3ofdurianorheveawoodarenecessarytoprepare1kgofsugar(Levang1988).InMaduraisland(Indonesia),thecostofthe
firewoodforproducingBorassussugaramountstoathirdofthepriceofthesugar(GebuisandKadir1928,citedbyFox1977).InCambodia160to200kgoffuelwoodarenecessaryformaking35kgofsugar
(Lubeigt1977Romera1968)andthisisthemostexpensivecomponentinthecostofsugarsyrupproduction(KhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin1996).There,Borassusflabellifersugarmakinghasbeen
responsibleformajorforestcuttingandthissugarisnotproducedanymoreincertainruralareasbecauseofthelackoffuelwood.Ontheotherhand,themarketforfreshjuiceisverylimitediftheareaisnotcloseto
acity(Romera1968).InUpperBurma,thesugarindustryfromBorassusflabelliferconsumesalargeamountoffuelandhasforcenturiesledtoindiscriminateforestcutting.Insomeareas,fuelfordomesticuseis
evenbecomingscarce(Aubert1911).InBurma,everytapperusesabout3tonnesoffirewoodperyear4.4kgareneededperkgofpalmsugar(Lubeigt1979).InCentralBurma,thepriceoffuelwoodisrapidly
increasingandtapperscanhardlyaffordit(Lubeigt1977).ThisfuelproblemstartedtobecomecrucialinBurmaattheendofthefiftieswhenthegovernmentinitiatedmeasurestoenforceprotectionoftheforest
(Lubeigt1979).
Inthecaseofwineproducingpalmtrees,thedeclineoftenoccurredunderreligiousorcolonialpressurewithintheframeworkofageneralpolicyaimedatpreventingpeoplefromdrinkingalcoholicbeverages.Thus,
tappingofBorassusaethiopiuminAfricamainlydoneforwineproductionhasbeendisruptedwhereverMuslimreligionhasbecomedominant.ThishappenedinpartsofSenegalwherethecatholicsereerhadto
leavetheirfieldstoMuslimwolofcomingfromthenorth.Before,inthecatholicsereerareas,somepeoplewerefullyemployedastappingprofessionals(Niang1975).InIvoryCoast,theFrenchcolonialpressure
triedtodiscouragetheproductionofpalmwine.In1914,intheBaoulregion,theaverageconsumptionofpalmwinewas135litres/man/yearbut2yearslatertheFrenchgovernorforbademakingand
commercializingpalmwine(whichwasalsomadefromtheAfricanoilpalmandPhoenixreclinata)exceptforfamilyconsumptionandtraditionalevents(BlancPamard1980).InMadagascar,makingwinefrom
Raphiaruffiaalsousedtobeforbidden(Decary1964).InSriLanka,a10thcenturyrockinscriptionprohibitsroyalofficersfromdemandingtoddyfromvillagersorengaginginillicittrade(Dissanayake1977).
Centurieslater,undercolonialruleandthereafter,therewasalsoageneralbanontheproductionandsaleoftoddyatvillagelevelthevillageheadmenandthelocalconstabularywhoenforcedtheseregulationswere
sorepressivethatveryfewvillagerswouldhavetakentheriskoftappingCaryotaurensevenformakingjaggeryandtreacle(Dissanayake1977).
InAfrica,somedestructivetechniquesoftappingwereresponsibleforthedisappearanceofthetreesinsomeareas.InIvoryCoast,Portres(1964)mentionedthehighconsumptionofpalmwineandthenumerous
specializedbarsalongtheroadsandinthevillages,allthisofferingalotofemploymentopportunities.Thepalmwinebecameverypopularasthroughbettermeansofcommunication,itcouldbemadeavailable
throughoutthecountry.Thetreesdisappearedinentireareaswithin10yearsasthetechniquesusedfortappingtreesweredestructiveandregenerationoftreeswasneglected.
Inmanyplaces,socioeconomicchangeswereresponsibleforthedeclineinpalmtreetappingactivity.InIvoryCoast,theimportantmovesofpopulationinthefifties(settlerssettingupcoffee,cocoa,rubbertrees
andoilpalmplantations)werealsoresponsibleforlossoftraditionalcodesofmanagingthetreesandlesslongtermconcerns.Thusthetraditionaltechniqueoftappingonlymaletreesandkeepingfemalesfor
regenerationwasabandoned(Portres1964BlancPamard1980).Inmanyareasofthiscountry,wineproducingpalmtreeswerereplacedbyrubbertreesandoilpalmsundertheFrenchcolonialpressure.In1940,in
Burma,theareasplantedwithBorassusflabelliferwerereducedbymorethanonesixthbecauseofthemilitaryoperationsconsecutivetotheJapaneseinvasion(Lubeigt1979).InCambodia,thedeclineofthe
productionofBorassusflabellifersugarstartedin1955withtheendoftheexportsofsugartoVietnamandtheincreasingconsumptionofimportedcanesugar:Borassusflabellifersugarpricescollapsed(Romera
1968).InSriLanka,undercolonialruleandthereafter,widespreadcultivationofcoconutasanexportedorientedcropdrasticallychangedthelocaleconomyandimportedsugarbecamecheaper(Dissanayake1977).
InPeninsularMalaysia,swampareasweredrainedforcoconutplantationswhereNypafruticanswasbeforepredominant(Kiew1989).Fishponddevelopersalsofoundgreatprofitsinvariousfishpondoperations
madepossiblebyconvertingmangroveswamps,includingNypafruticansareas,forfishproduction(Encendencia1985).
Tappingsugarpalmsisverylabourintensive.Itmustbedonedailyotherwisethesapflowrapidlydiminishesastissuehealingoccursandrestartingthesapflowrequireslongandhardwork.Whenevereasierand
betterpaidjobswereavailable,tappingwasgivenup.TheemergenceoftheoileconomyinMalaysiahascollapsedtheindustryofalcoholfromNypafruticanssap(labourtooexpensive).Duringthecolonialperiod
inIndia,BorassustapperswererecruitedintheBritishplantationsabroad,particularlyontherubberandoilpalmestateswheretheirskillscouldbeeasilyadaptedtothoserequiredforthesetrees(Fox1977).
Inmanycountries,incomparisontoothercropsorcommodities,thereisagenerallackofinterestshownbythedecisionmakersaboutthesocioeconomicpotentialoftappingpalms.Noneorlittleresearch,selection
ofhigheryieldingvarietiesortrainingandextensionservicesarefundedandthetappersareseldomexposedtotechnologicalinnovationsiftheydonotgeneratethembythemselves.
Originofthenewinterestforpalmtreetappingactivity
Intoday'seconomy,theprofitabilityoftappingpalmsforsugarhassometimesimproved:thisisthecaseforcoconutandCaryotaurensinSriLanka.Inthemidseventies,withcontinuingforeignexchangecrises,a
reductionintheimportofsugaroccurredandwasimmediatelyfollowedbyasuddenriseinitsprice.Thegovernmentwasthenforcedtorelaxtheoldcolonialregulationsandinmanyareas,palmsugaragainbecame
alowcostsourceofsugar(Dissanayake1977).InpartsofSouthSumatra(Sriwangi),tappingcoconutforsugarproductionis8to10timesmoreprofitablethansellingnuts.Onefamilyisratherwelloffwith35trees
andin1987,morethan40%ofthefamiliesoftheareawereinvolvedintappingastheirmainsourceofincome.Theiraverageearningsweremorethantwicethoseofneighbouringareaswherecoconuttappingwas
notpractised.Atapperearnsperdaytwicetothreetimesmorethanafieldworker,thatistosayaboutwhatearnsacarpenterorabricklayer.Animportantadvantageforthetapperisthathehasadailyincome
throughouttheyear.Thisgiveshimaneasieraccesstocreditfacilities(Levang1988).InSriLanka,about0.5%(i.e.2,025ha)ofthetotalsurfaceforcoconutlandistappedfortoddybyatleast5,000tappers
(Abeysekera1979).InthePhilippines,asequentialcoconuttoddyandnutproductionsystemcanprovidethesmallscalecoconutfarmerswithincomesnearly10timeshigherperhectareandperyearcomparedtothe
traditionalpracticeofproducingnutsonly(MaravillaandMagat1993).Inthiscountry,aprogrammelabelledas"EstablishmentofBuriPlantationforTechnologyDevelopmentandEmploymentGeneration"is
promotingthemultipurposesugarproducingpalmtreeCoryphaelatainordertostimulatethecottageindustry(Abrenillaetal1988).InNigeria,anoilpalmestateislikelytobebetteroffdevotingallitsresourcesto
theproductionof9,770litres/ha/yearofoilpalmwinethanproducing10tonnesoffreshfruitbunchperhectareperannum.Furthermore,asoilpalmwineproductionismorelabourintensivethanfreshfruitbunch
production,tappingoilpalmtreesforwineislikelytocreatemorejobsthanharvestingfruitbunches(Udom1987).
Producingsugarforpalmtreesthatcanbetappedallyearround(likecoconutandNypafruticans)isanadvantagecomparedtotheseasonalproductionofsugarfromsugarcane.Productionisnotinterruptedby
replantingandrotationandthecontinuousproductivitymeansnodisplacedlabour,whichisamajorproblemincaneeconomy.Furthermore,thereisnobagassedisposalproblemandthereisnoexpensivecrushing
milltomaintain(HamiltonandMurphy1988).Ontheotherhand,themaindrawbackistheneedforfirewoodorotherfuel:forexample,thedeadleavesfromNypafruticansusedasfuelarefarfrombeingsufficient
tomakesugarfromthesapofthistree.Palmtreesthatproducesugarseasonally,likePhoenixsylvestrisfromNovembertoMarch(coldweather)andBorassusflabelliferfromApriltoSeptember(hotweather)would
growverywellsidebysideassuggestedbyAnnett(1913)inBangladeshandwouldensurecontinuoussugarproductionallyearround.
InLatinAmerica,themostabundantpalm,Mauritiaflexuosa,hasaconsiderablepotentialfromaneconomicdevelopmentstandpointasitisasourceofmanydifferentproductsamongwhichpalmwineshouldbe
promoted(Johnson1997).InatentativelistofpalmswithdevelopmentpotentialcompiledbyJohnson(1997),itisinterestingtonotethatforaboutoneoutoftwopalmsofthelist,thesapisamajorproduct.
Industrializedprocessingofthesap:
BorassusflabellifersugarproductionisindustrializedinSriLanka(Morton1988).InIndia,differentproductsfromthesapofthistreeareindustriallyprocessed:sapassoftdrink(600,000bottlesin19821983in
Madras),chocolatebars,candies,applejam,mixedfruitjamandpalmsyrup(DavisandJohnson1987).InWestAfrica,thesealedbottlingofpalmwinefromtheAfricanoilpalmisbeingundertaken(Bassir(1968,
citedbyHartley1977).InCameroon,in1969/1970,theconsumptionoflocallymadeorimporteddrinksamountedto405millionlitresoutofwhich280millionlitreswerepalmwine.In1971thefirstindustrialized
unitwithacapacityof1,000litres/dayofRaphiaspwineinsealedbottleswassetup(Fyot1973).InGhana,thepalmwineindustry(largedistilleriesinthecitiesandsmallscalefactorieslocatedinvillages)wasalso
ofgrowingimportancewiththedeclineinthepalmoilindustry(SodahAyernorandMatthews1971).
Prospectsforincreasingsugaryields
Asstatedbefore,comparedtosugarcaneproduction(515tonnesofsugar/ha/year),theBorassusflabellifertreecanreach18tons/ha/yearunderrainfedconditions(KhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin1996)
andthecoconuttree19tons/ha/year(Jeganathan1974).Nevertheless,thepotentialofincreasingsugarproductionfrompalmtreesislikelytobemuchhigherthanfromsugarcaneasmuchlessresearchhasbeen
devotedtopalmtreesinthisrespect.
Indigenousknowledgeisavailableincountriesthathavehadalongexperienceintappingpalmtrees.Thetappergenerallymakesaselectionbeforestartingtapping:hechoosesthetreesthat,accordingtohis
experience,shouldfulfilthefollowingobjectives:highsapyieldreducedtimebetweencommencementofworkinganinflorescenceandthefirstflowofsapmaximumvolumeofsapsustainedforaslongas
possiblehealthandwellbeingofthetreemaintainedduringtapping(Pethiyagoda1978).
Tallvarietiesofcoconuttreesyieldtwiceasmuchsapasdwarfpalmsandaremoreresistanttopestsandtodroughtsandwindsbecausetheirrootsystemismoredeveloped(Jeganathan1974).Considerablevariations
occuraccordingtotapper'sskills,day,season,prevailingweather,spadix,natureofthepalm,localityandmanure(Pethiyagoda1978).Aperiodof31daysofsapflowperspatheistheaverageinSriLanka.There,
coconutpalmscanbetappedthroughouttheyearaslongasrainfallissatisfactoryandeverypalmisrestedfor4monthsayear(CoconutResearchInstitute1967).Elsewhere,itispossibletoencountersituations
wheretreeshavebeencontinuallytappedformanyyearswithoutapparentilleffects(Pethiyagoda1978).Thereareconsiderablyvaryingestimatesofdailysapyields:from0.9to15litrespertree.Thesameoccurs
forsugarconcentrationofthesap(from4to22%):thelowerconcentration(4%)isrelatedwiththehigheryield(15litres).Thehighyieldingcoconuttreeswithregardtotheproductionofnutsarenotnecessarilythe
bestsapyielders(Pethiyagoda1978).Nathanael(1956)citedbyPethiyagoda(1978)liststhefollowingcriteriaforpromisingsapyields:shiny,pliableleaflets,longinternodes,uniforminflorescenceproductionand
thinnerinflorescencesheaths.InSriLanka,throughhybridizationworktoidentifythemostpromisingspecieswithregardtonutproduction,ahybridbetweenatallvariety(Typica)andadwarfone(Pumila)was
foundtobethebest.ItssapproducingcapacitywasstudiedlaterbyJeganathan(1974):onthebasisof158treestothehectare,thedailysapyieldperhectarewas346litres(with15%sugarasforTypicasap)forthe
hybrid,whileitwas247forTypicaandonly74forPumila(with247treestothehectareforthislattervariety).ThedifferencebetweenthehybridandTypicawasmainlyduetothehigherproductionofspadicesin
thehybrid(17.7peryearagainst11.7forTypica)whichsupersedesthelowerandshorterproductionofeveryspadixforthehybrid(45litres/21days)comparedtoTypica(nearly50litres/31days).
Theimpactofmanuringonsapyieldsisreportedtobehighforcoconutsbutscientificdataarescarce.TheSriLankanCoconutResearchInstituteispresentlydoingsomeresearchandarecentsurveyhasidentified
thefollowingfactorsaffectingtoddyyields:moisturestress,failuretoapplyamulcharoundthemanurecircle(2maroundthepalm),nutritionaldeficiencies,rainstorms,winds,lackofexperienceandshortageof
skilledtappers.Afertilizermixturehasbeendevelopedfortoddytappingpalms:rockphosphate(4partsbyweight),potassiumchloride(18parts),dolomite(8parts).2to3kgofthismixturearegivenperpalmper
yearaccordingtosoiltypeandclimaticconditions600gureaand1kgagriculturalsaltarealsogivenperpalmperyearwithanincreaseof50%forthehigherproducingpalms(CoconutResearchInstitute1986).
SelectionandbreedingoftheAfricanoilpalmforhighsapyieldsandhighconcentrationofsugarhavenotyetstartedonalargescale.Itislikelythatyieldimprovementresearchwillproducevarietiesthatwillyield
morethan100litresofsapperpalmandmorethan14,800litresperhectareperannum(Udom1987).ItisabsolutelyessentialformosttappedpalmspeciesinAsiatohaveasophisticatedpreparatoryphase,
sometimescontinuedthroughoutthetappingperiod,inordertoensurehighyieldsofsap.Itinvolvesallsortsoftechniquessuchasbending,kicking,hammering,kneading,bruisingtheinflorescenceanditsstalk.
SuchapreparatoryphasehasnotbeenreportedinAfricafortheAfricanoilpalmanditislikelythatsouthsouthtransferoftechnologycouldpermitamajorincreaseinsapproductionfromthistree.
Differentmanagementtechniquespermitincreasedsugarproductionfrompalmtrees.Nypafruticansproducesmoreinflorescences(andpotentiallymoresap)whenthestandsarekeptthinnedofoldleaves.Sap
productioncanbeimprovedbywiderspacingbetweentreesthaninwildalmostpurestandsofNypafruticans:from2,500/hadownto500orlessbyremovingtherhizomesoftheothersplantstopreventthemfrom
regenerating(HamiltonandMurphy1988).InthePhilippines,Quimbo(1991)developedanew,highlyprofitablemethodoftappingthatincreasesthesapyieldfromlessthan60,000litres/hatomorethan100,000.
Thistechniqueconsistsinusingclenchedfistsaspressureapplicator,whichloosensthesilicaandcrystallikedepositsinthetrachealelementsofthepeduncle,thusenhancingfreesapflowatasimilarratebutfor
muchlongerperiods(111daysinsteadof60days).Treatmentcouldalsobereducedfrom94days(ofwhich52contactdays)to43days(ofwhich22contactdays)withtotalsapyieldstillhigheronaperplantbasis.
SimilarlyinPapuaNewGuinea,Pivke(1985)hasdevelopedasophisticatedprotocolofpretreatmentthatpermitsmuchhighersapyields.
ForArengapinnatainNorthSulawesi,a10x10mspacingproducedthehighestyieldsofsap(Sumadi1988).HighyieldingstrainsofArengapinnatahavebeenisolatedintheintensivesugarpalmcultivationin
Minahassa,NorthSulawesi(Mogeaetal1991).Thetrees,withanaverageof19m(upto25m)aremuchhigherthanelsewhere.NearTomohon,atanaltitudeof700800ma.s.l.,thesapproductionamountsto1215
litresaday,containing1215%ofsugarwithconsiderablylongertappingperiods(612months)foreachinflorescence(normallymorethan1mlong).Asuperiorsugarpalminthislocationproducesallyearroundan
averageof30litresaday(Mogeaetal1991).
DailyBorassusflabellifersapyieldsaveragebetween6and10litrespertreebutcanbeaslowas1litreorashighas20litrespertree(Paulas(1983TjitrosoepomoandPudjoarinto1983,citedbyKovoor1983).This
canbeexplainedbygeneticandenvironmentalfactors.Moresappertreecanbeobtainedifeachinflorescenceproducesmore,overalongerperiod(skilloftheoperator),iftherearemoreinflorescencesinagiven
time,iffloweringstartsonyoungertreesandlastslonger(geneticfactors)andiftheresponsetotappingishigher(geneticfactors)(Kovoor1983).Borassusaethiopiumiscommonlytappedforwineproductionin
westAfricabuttheproductionofsugarhasneverbeenrecorded.Nevertheless,ithasagoodpotentialforsugarproductionand,inareaswheresugarcanedoesnotgrowifnotirrigated(Sudaneseareaswithlongdry
season),thistreecouldreplaceitforsugarproduction(Chevalier1930).
Researchisneededtoassesstherelativeimportanceofgeneticvsenvironmentalvstechnologicalfactorsinordertoestablishapriorityagendaforincreasingsapproductionandsapqualityeitherthroughbreeding
programmesormanagementtechniquesoracombinationofboth.
Prospectsforfacilitatingsapcollection
Formostnondestructivetappingtechniques,ahighdegreeoftraditionalexpertiseisneededandwherethistechniqueisnottraditionallypractised,greatdifficultiesmightbeencounteredintrainingpeople.Usually,
thefatherteacheshissonaboutpalmtappingduringaverylongperiod.Inthecaseofthehighsugarproducingpalms,reducedheightwouldbeamuchappreciatedcharacteristicdecreasinglabourtime,effortand
risks.Unlikethecoconut,dwarfmutantsandraceshavenotbeenreportedtooccurinthecaseofBorassusflabellifer(Kovoor1983).Thismaybeattributedtothelackofsystematicresearch.Analternativewouldbe
toselectthemostprecocioustrees(thatstartfloweringataverylowheight)asprecocityisagenetictrait(Kovoor1983).
Devicesforsaferandmoreefficientwaysofclimbingpalmtreeshavebeeninvented:onebyDavis(1984)citedbyDavisandJohnson(1987)anotherwasdevelopedbythePalmyraDevelopmentBoardofSriLanka
and,usingit,thetapperwouldbeabletotapabout100treesaday,morethantwicethepresentaverage(Dissanayake1986).TheergonomicproblemsoftoddytappershavebeenreviewedinSriLankabyAbeysekera
(1979).
HybridizationoftheAfricanoilpalmwiththeAmericanspecies,Elaeisoleifera,whichhasacreepingtrunkandbetterresistancetodisease(Kahn1988)couldproduceaproductivevariety,easytotapbecauseoflow
andstableheight.
Prospectsforanimalproductionwithinsustainableintegratedfarmingsystems
Storageofsapatlocallevelisnotpossibleasfermentationrapidlyoccursevenifdelayedbysomechemicalagents.Fermentedsapisnotsuitablefortheproductionofgoodqualitysugarandthisusuallylimitsthe
expansionofpalmsugarmakingatvillagelevel.Processingsapintogoodqualityjaggeryisalsoadifficultandtimeconsumingtask:upto16hoursperdayinCambodia(KhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin
1996).Italsorequiresanexperiencedandskilledworker,oftenawoman(stirring,removingoffroth,maintainingtheappropriatetemperature,etc.).Thisisalsoamajorbottleneckwhichlimitssapprocessing
(Dissanayake1986).Furthermore,inmanycountries,productionandsaleoftoddyisprohibitedbyregulationsandsomerawmaterialiswasted(Dissanayake1986).AccordingtoMogea(Mogeaetal1991),Arenga
pinnatainNorthSulawesi(Indonesia)couldconsiderablycontributetotheincreaseofthelocalincomesandprovidemanyjobopportunitiesiftheproblemsduetotheenormousamountsoffuelwoodrequiredfor
makingsugarandthelimitedmarketingpossibilitiesoftheproductscouldbesolved.Itisdifficulttobringthefreshsapandthepalmwinetotheremotemarketswhereastheneighbouringonesareoftensaturated.If
thesugarisbettercommercialized,thenthefuelconstraintacutelyoccurs.InRotiandSavuislands(Indonesia),thetappersclaimthattheycouldtap20to30Borassustrees,butrarelydoesanyonetapmorethan10to
15atanyonetimeascookingthesaptoproducesyrupisthelimitingfactor(Fox1977).Thereisahugepotentialforcapitalisingonunderexploitedsugarpalmtreeswhicharenotusedbecauseofthelackof
fuelwoodformakingsugarorthelimitedmarketingpossibilities.InCambodia,twosurveysconductedin1938and1960showedthatrespectivelyonly26%and30%oftappablepalmyratreeswereactuallytapped
(Romera1968).InSriLanka,onlyabout2%ofthetotalareasuitablefortappingisreportedtobeactuallytapped(Sivilingam1983,citedbyDissanayake1986).IncoastalNigeriaandCameroon,Nypafruticans
whichwasintroducedearlyinthiscentury,hasnaturalizedandisunderutilized(Johnson1997).Therefore,thereisanichefordiversification.Inthesecases,thesapcouldbeusedforanimalproduction.Present
labourconstraintscanbeovercomethroughtheuseofclimbingdevicesthatenablethetappertotaptwiceasmanypalmtrees(Dissanayake1986).
Ontheotherhand,meatdemandisincreasinginmanydevelopingcountriesaspopulationgrowsandlivingstandardsimprove:inthecaseofCambodia,thepigpopulationisincreasingatarateof16.6%peryear
(Devendra1993,citedbyKhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin1996).Insteadofpreparingsugarfromthesapofsugarproducingpalmtrees,thesapcanbedirectlyfedtotheanimalsandprovidemostofthe
energyneededinthediet.ThishasbeendoneforcenturiesintwoIndonesianislands,RotiandSavu.TheyhaveacomplexdiverseeconomythathasBorassusasthecentreandwhichincludesasmallscalesemi
intensiveorintensivepigrearingcomponent(78pigsperhousehold).InaBorassuseconomy,pigsareaprimemeansofconvertingpalmproductstoprotein.Pigsarefedfreshsapthroughoutmostofthetapping
seasonandthereforefattenduringthedryseasonwhileotherlivestockusuallyloseweight.Inaddition,pigsoftenreceivetheresidue(froth)andspillfromthesyrupcookingprocess.Duringtherainyseason,theyare
frequentlyfedsyrupmixedwithwater(nevertheless,whenCoryphaelataisavailableasinRoti,peoplewillgenerallyfavourstheuseofitssagoaspigfeedinsteadofpalmsyrup).Foxconcludesinthesewords:
"BorassussyrupandfruitconstitutetheprimaryfoodforpigspigsinturnareaprincipalmeansbywhichSavu'spalmeconomyisabletosupportitsdensepopulationpigsandpalmsgotogetherand
onecanviewpigsasareasonableindicatorofpalmutilization".Thisisfurtherdemonstratedbythestrongcorrelations(muchhigherthanforotherlivestockspecies)betweenpigandhumanpopulationsinthe
differentareasofthesetwoislands.Theareaswherethepopulationdensitiesarehighest,aretheareasofmostintensivepigrearingpigsalsorepresentingthehighestproportionsofthetotallivestock(Fox1977).
CaptainJamesCook,sailingwestfromNewGuineastoppedattheSavuislandfrom17to21September1770,atthehighpointofthetappingseason.Hereportedinhisbook"Voyages"detailedinformationonthe
useofBorassus.Inthisparticularyear,thecropswerereportedtohavefailed.Thereforethemaximumharvestofsapwastakingplaceinordertosecure6to8monthsfoodsupply.Despitethisthreatenedfood
securitysituation,Cookwitnessedthatsyrupwasgiventopigsandusedevenforotheranimalproduction:"Ihavealreadyobserved,thatitisgivenwiththehusksofricetothehogs,andthattheygrow
enormouslyfatwithouttakinganyotherfood:weweretoldalso,thatthissyrupisusedtofattentheirdogsandtheirfowls..."(CookcitedbyFox1977).
TheauthorofthispaperspentaweekinRotiinmidNovember1997.Itwasattheendofalongandseveredryseason(duetoElNio).AsRotiisthemostsouthernIndonesianisland,itgetstheshortestrainyseason
ofthecountry.Borassustappingisstillpractisedeverywhereontheisland.Tapperswereinterviewedintwoplaces,aMuslimfishingvillageonthenortheastcoast(Papela)andaChristianvillagealongabeachon
thesouthwestcoast(Nemberala).Freshsapisstillcommonlyusedforanimalproduction.Pigsarefedwithfreshsaptwiceaday,justaftersapcollection(earlymorningandatdusk).Whenfreshpalmsapisnot
available(rainyseason),palmsyrup(onelitreofsyrupcomesfrom4to5litresofsap)isdilutedwithwatertofeedthepigs.Thequantityofpalmsapgivenperpigperdayvariesaccordingtotheavailabilityofother
feeds.Herearetwoexamplesofadailypigdiet,respectivelyduringtherainyseason,inPapela,andduringthetappingseasoninNemberala:threemeals,eachoneincludingonelitreofsyrupdilutedintwolitresof
waterandabout170gofricetwomealsperday,eachoneincluding1.5litreoffreshsapandchoppedmeatfromabouttwoandhalfcoconuts.Apartfromthesefeeds,thepigsgenerallysatisfythegreatestpartof
theirproteinneedsthroughscavengingonthebeach,especiallyatlowtide.Thepigsspendalldaysandevenpartofthenight,digginglongditchesinthesand,goingfarfromtheseashoreandclosetothecorralreef
andturningoverthestonesineverypoolaccessibleatlowtide.Theygetcrabs,snailsandvariousothershells,smallfishes,seacucumbersandseaweeds.Thepigsaresoldonthemarketoncetheyareaboutoneyear
old,weighingaround40kg.Thepoultryalsodrinksthepalmjuice.InNemberala,thejuiceisalsogiventothedogs.Everydoggetsaboutalitreofsapperdaysharedinthreemeals.Theotherpartofthedietismade
ofrice,fishandmeatwastesandbones.Apartfromguardingthehouse,theuseofthedogisforitsmeatasitisstillatraditionalfoodforthenonMuslimpeopleoftheisland.Themalesaregenerallyslaughtered
whentheyarearound2yearsold.
TrialsonfeedingpigswithpalmjuicehavebeeninitiatedrecentlyinCambodiawithintheframeworkofanFAOTechnicalCooperationProject(FAO1995).Pigswererearedfrom20to80kg,withADGof356g
usingthefollowingdailydiet:approximately8kgofpalmjuice156gofprotein(fromsoyabean),lime,saltand500goffreshwaterspinachperday.Twelvefarmswerestudied.Takingintoaccountthepriceof
fuelwood,theprofitpertreeperdaywasnearly14timeshigherwhenthejuicewasusedforfeedingpigsinsteadofmakingsugarsyrup(KhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin1996).
Usingfreshsapforfeedinganimalswillavoidburninglargequantitiesoffuel.Nevertheless,aspartofthisfuelgenerallycomesfromthepalmtreeitself,itmightbepossibletomakesyruporsugarthatwillbeeasy
topreserveandthatwillbelaterfedtotheanimalswhenthesugarproductionseasonisover.Ifthisisnotpossible,sapproductioncanbeentirelyusedasfreshjuiceforfeedingfatteninganimalsandthefattening
cyclecancoincidewiththesometimesrathershorttappingseason.Thiscaneasilybedonewithpigsandducks.Apartfromgivingalotofaddedvaluetothesap,thisalsopermitsthesmallfarmers,whousuallyhave
verylowstoragecapacityforsyruporsugar,toavoidsellingsapatlowpriceduringthetappingseason.Sap,syruporsugarcouldalsobeusedasemergencyfeeds,replacingotherfeedswhoseproductionhasbeen
compromizedbydroughtsorothercalamities,whenevernecessary.
Tobalancemonogastricdietsbasedonsugarpalmjuiceorsyrup,agoodsourceofproteinisrequired.Assoyabeanishardlyavailableatareasonablepriceinmanytropicalareas,somealternativesourcesofprotein
areneeded:possiblesourcesincludecassavaleaves,sweetpotatoesleaves,foddertreeleaves,aquaticplants(duckweed,Azolla),wholesoyaplantatmilkygrainstageandfishwastes.Properuseandmanagementof
thesedifferentalternativesourcesofproteincancontributetoreducingpollution,increasingcarbonsinksanddecreasingerosion.Animalfeedingsystemsbasedonpalmjuice/syrupfavourkeepingtheanimalsin
confinementinsteadofgrazingorscavengingsystems.Thisprotectstheenvironment,limitsthedisseminationofcontagiousdiseasesandalsooptimizestheintegrationoflivestockwithinanintensivefarmingsystem
(Figure1).Manurecanbeprocessedthroughabiodigestor,producingtheenergyforfamilycookingneeds,andtheeffluentcanbeusedasafertilizereitherforcropsorforfishponds.
Ruminantsalsobenefitfromthesugarpalmtrees.AsmentionedbyKhieuBorinandPrestonduringtheSecondFAOElectronicConferenceonTropicalFeeds,Borassussapandthescumobtainedduringsapcooking
aretraditionallyusedforsofteningricestrawusedforcattlefeeding(especiallydraughtanimals)inCambodia(Speedyetal1997).Cattlearealsofedwithmaturefruitsorpartsofthemthatarenotusedforhuman
consumption.DuringhisstayinRoti,theauthorofthispaperdidnotgetanytestimonyrelatedtofeedingfreshsaporsyruptotheruminants.Nevertheless,thegoatsgetthefoamproducedduringthesapcooking.
Greentwigswiththeirleaves,takenfromthetreethatalsoprovidesthefirewoodusedforcookingthesap,areslightlycookedtogetherwiththesapandusedtoremovethefoam.Then,theyareimmediatelygivento
thegoats.Thankstothisfeed,thegoatswerestillinaverygoodbodyconditiondespiteofthefactthatitwastheendofalongandseveredryseason.
Thepotentialoffeedinggoatsandcowswithpalmsapasthemainsourceofenergyformilkproductionshouldbeinvestigatedaswellasthesourceofnitrogen(nonproteinnitrogenandbypassproteins),minerals
andfibretocompletethediet.Incidentally,tappingpalmtreeswillalsoalwaysofferaneasysourceofsugarforbeeswhichwilltendtospontaneouslyharvestallwastedsugar.Honeyproductionisthereforeincreased
inareaswherepalmtreesaretapped(Fox1977).
Conclusion
Borassuspalmsarethemostnumerouspalmsintheworldafterthecoconutpalm(Fox1977).Despitethis,theyareamongtheleaststudiedofallthepalmspeciesintheworld.Asformanyothersugarproducing
palmtreessuchasCaryotaurens,verylittleisknownabouttheireconomicpotential(Dissanayake1977).Thislackofinterestcanbeexplainedduringcolonialhistorybythefactthat,fromthecolonizer'spointof
view,itwasmucheasiertosetup,manageandcontrollargesugarcaneplantationstoproducesugarthantouseexistingscatteredpalmtreesthathadbeenmanagedforcenturiesbythelocalpeople,oftenwithina
subsistenceeconomy.Besidethis,thesetreesareoftenassociatedwiththepoor.Thefactthattheirjuicequicklyfermentsandmakesalcoholmadetappingactivitiesundesirabletogovernments,andalsoforthe
Hindus,BuddhistsandMuslimsorthodoxes(Fox1977).
Nevertheless,therearemanygoodargumentsforrevitalizingknowledgeandresearchonsugarproducingpalmtrees.Consideringtheirmultipurposeuses,theycancontributeinmanywaystothesustainabilityof
integratedfarmingsystems.Forexample,inIndonesia,Mogea(1991)suggeststopromoteanddevelopthroughresearchprojectsthreeparticulartaxawithinthenativepalmresources.Twoofthemhavesugarastheir
mainproduct:ArengapinnataandBorassusflabellifer.Assugarproducingpalmtreesareoftenthemainsubsistenceresourceforthepoorestpeople,improvingthewaythesetreesareusedwillcontributetothe
alleviationofpoverty.Palmtapping,especiallyasfaraswildandsemiwildspeciesareconcerned,isanactivitythatdoesnotrequirecapitaltostart.Inhighlypopulatedruralareas,itcanbeamajorsourceofself
employmentforthepoorestpeopleandavoidmajordriftsfromtheland.Inthecaseofcoconut(inSriLankaforexample)orAfricanoilpalm(inColombiaandNigeriaforexample),withthelowandunpredictable
worldpricesofcopraandpalmoil,ithasbecomeincreasinglydifficultforsmallfarmerstodependontheirproduction.Thisencouragesattemptstofindotherwaysofusingthesetrees,includingdiversificationfor
bettersustainabilityofthesystem.Sugarproductionandanimalproductionarealternativestoconsiderifmarketscanbedevelopedfortheseproducts.
Whenselectingpalmssuitableforsmallfarmers,itisimportanttoconsidertheamountofknowledgeavailableaboutthecandidatespecies.Agoodindicatoristhedegreetowhichapalmhasbeendomesticated.
Generally,themoreadvancedthestageofdomestication,theeasierthespeciescanbecultivatedsuccessfully(Johnson1987).Consideringthehighcostanddurationofadomesticationprogram,inthecaseofnon
domesticatedsapproducingpalms,itissuggestedtoevaluateandselectonefordomestication(Arengapinnata,CoryphaumbraculiferaandC.utanarestrongcandidates)whereastheotherspeciesshouldbe
consideredformanagementimprovement(Johnson1997).
Futureresearchonusingpalmtreesapforanimalproductionshouldconsiderthefollowingissues:
Assessmentofexistingstandsofwildpalms(Nypafruticans,Borassussp.,etc.)andtheeconomicprospectsfromtappingthesetrees.
Assessmentoftheeconomicpotentialofpalmtreesselectedovercenturiesforsapproductiontobeusedinotherregions:BorassusflabelliferfromCambodiaorIndonesiacouldbeinstalledinAfricawhere
ecologicalconditionsaresimilarArengapinnatafromNorthSulawesicouldbeinstalledonunproductiveerosionpronesoilsinLatinAmericaCaryotaurenscouldbedevelopedinmarginallands.
Identificationofcriteriaforproperselectionofindividualstobetappedandforrecognizingtheproperplantstageforinitiatingsuccessfultappingoperations.
Physiologyoftheproductionofsapflowandprecisesignificanceofthevariousactsthatconstitutetheartoftappinginordertodevelopimprovedtechnologiesforincreasingsugaryields(techniquesof
tapping,frequency,fertilization,treespacing)andtooptimizetheuseoflabour.
Selectionofearlyfloweringpalmtrees.
Improvedtechnologiesforsafelytappingtrees.
Techniquestopreservethejuiceandavoidfermentation.
Identificationofproductionsystemswithpalmtrees,cropsandanimals:accordingtothepresenteconomicandenvironmentalchanges,assessmentoftherelevanceoftappingsugarpalmtreesforanimal
productionincomparisonwithenergyproduction(ethanol)orotherproductions(coprafromcoconutoroilfromoilpalm).
Whatisneededisathoroughfieldsurveyreviewingindetailallindigenousknowledgerelatedtotappingpalmtreesforsugarandanimalproduction.Thiswouldpermitamajorbreakthroughforassessingthefuture
potentialofthesetreesandforsharingtechniquesandexperiencesbetweenregionsandcountries.Manyruralareasarelikelytobenefitfromanewsourceofselfemploymentandsustainableincomeoncethe
potentialoftappingpalmtreesforsugarandanimalproductionhasreceivedthefullattentionitdeservesfromdecisionmakersthroughfundingresearch,selection,technologyimprovement,trainingandextension
andsmallcreditforfarmers,
References
AbedinZ,AktarS,HaqueFandAlamS1987UsesofMultipurposeTreesontheSmallFarmsoftheLowRainfallGangesFloodplainSoilsofBangladesh.In:ProceedingsofaninternationalworkshopheldinPataya,Thailand,25November1987,pp.
3147.
AbeysekeraJDA1979Someergonomicproblemsamong(coconut)toddytappersinSriLanka.In:ProceedingsoftheFifthJointErgonomicSymposium.Wageningen,Netherlands1418May1979.pp112114.
AbrenillaCG,PabloNRandPolinagMA1988BuriPlantation:towardsasustainableindustryCanopyInternational14(6):911.
AdandA1954LevindepalmechezlesDioladelaCasamanceNotesAfricaines61:47.
AndersonAB1987Managementofnativepalmforests:acomparisonofcasestudiesinIndonesiaandBrazil.In:Agroforestry:realities,possibilitiesandpotentials[editedbyGholzH.L]Dordrecht,Netherlands.155167.
AnnettHE1913ThedatesugarindustryinBengalAninvestigationintoitschemistryandagriculture.AgricultureResearchInstitute,Pusa,India,ChemicalSeriesII(6):281389.
AubertL1911ThemanufactureofpalmsugarinupperBurma.AgriculturalJournalofIndia.VI(4):369376.
AudruJ1985Restaurationetmeilleureutilisationdeshyphaenaiesd'AgnaetdeGalafi(RpubliquedeDjibouti).Paris,CIRADIEMVT.pp.117.
BalickMJ1990ProductionofCoyolWinefromAcrocomiamexicana(Arecaceae)inHonduras.EconomicBotany,44(1):8493
BanzonJA1984Harvestableenergyfromthecoconutpalm.EnergyinAgriculture,3:337344.
BarreveldWH1993Datepalmsproducts.FAOAgriculturalServicesBulletinNo101.FAO,Rome.pp.262.
BaumerM1995Arbres,arbustesetarbrisseauxnourriciersenAfriqueoccidentale.SrieEtudesetRecherches,n168169170.Dakar.endatiersmonde.ENDAEditions.
BellouardP1950LeRnierenA.O.F.BoisetFortsdesTropiques.14:117126.
BlancPamardC.1980Del'utilisationdetroisespcesdepalmiersdanslesuddu"VBaoul"(Cted'Ivoire).CahiersORSTOM,srieSciencesHumaines.(34):247255.
ChevalierA1930.LeBorassusaethiopumdel'AfriqueOccidentaleetsonutilisationRevuedeBotaniqueApplique.pp.649655.
CoconutResearchInstitute1967Toddytapping.Ceylon.LeafletNo.48.pp.13pp.
CoconutResearchInstitute1986SriLankaAdvisoryCircularNo.A4March.pp.8.
CrevostCandLemariC1913Cataloguedesproduitsdel'Indochine.IProduitsAlimentaires.GouvernementGnraldel'Indochine,pp.347352
CunninghamAB1990Income,sapyieldandeffectsofsaptappingonpalmsinsoutheasternAfrica.S.Afr.J.Bot.56(2):137144.
DavisTAandJohnsonDV1987CurrentUtilizationandFurtherDevelopmentofthePalmyraPalm(BorassusflabelliferL.,Arecaceae)inTamilNaduState,India.EconomicBotany,41(2):247266.
DavisTA1988UsesofSemiWildPalmsinIndonesiaandElsewhereinSouthandSoutheastAsia.AdvancesinEconomicBotany6:98118.
DecaryR1964LesutilisationsdespalmiersMadagascar.Journald'AgricultureTropicaleetdeBotaniqueApplique.XI(89):259266
DennettJH1927FinalObservationsontheNipahPalmasaSourceofAlcohol.TheMalayanAgriculturalJournal.XV(12):420432.
DissanayakeBW1977UseofCaryotaurensinSriLanka.In:FirstInternationalSagoSymposium.TheEquatorialSwampasaNaturalResource.Ed.TanK.Sarawak,EastMalaysia,Kuching1976.KualaLumpur.pp.8490.
DissanayakeBW1986Technoeconomicaspectsofproductionandutilizationoftworelatedpalmskitul(Caryotaurens)andpalmyra.ProceedingsoftheThirdInternationalSagoSymposium,Tokyo,Japan.pp.7585.
DransfieldJ1977DrylandSagoPalms.In:FirstInternationalSagoSymposium.TheEquatorialSwampasaNaturalResource.Ed.TanK.Sarawak,EastMalaysia,Kuching1976.KualaLumpur.pp.7683.
EncendenciaEM1985VersatileNipa:PotentialResourceforVariousEconomicNeeds.NSTATechnologyJournal/JulySept.pp.412.
EssiamahSK1992SappingofOilPalm(Elaeisguineensis,Jacq.)intheRainForestRegionofWestAfrica.Tropenlandwirt(Germany).93(2):123135.
EzeMOandUzoechiOganA1988Sugarsoftheunfermentedsapandthewinefromtheoilpalm,Elaeisguinensis,tree.PlantFoodsforHumanNutrition38:121126.
FanshaweDB1966TheDumPalmHyphaenethebaica(Del.)Mart.EastAfricanAgriculturalandForestryJournal.October1966:108116
FAO1995Pland'urgencepourlasauvegardedubtailauCambodge.Compterendufinaldeprojet.TCP/CMB/2254.FAO,Rome.pp.14.
FealyNE.1925QuelquesPalmiersexploitspourlaproductiondeSucre.RevuedeBotaniqueApplique&d'AgricultureColoniale.45:383387.
FoxJF1977HarvestofthePalm,EcologicalChangeinEasternIndonesia.HarvardUniversityPress,Cambridge,Massachusets,andLondon,England.pp.290.
FriedbergC1977LespalmierssucreetvindanslesudestasiatiqueetenIndonsie.Journald'AgricultureTraditionnelleetdeBotaniqueApplique,XXIV(4):341345.
FyotR1973Lavalorisationindustrielled'uneboissontraditionnelle:levindepalmepasteuris.TechniquesetDveloppement.LesProduits.8(10):2729.
GibbsHD1911ThealcoholindustryofthePhilippineIslands.I.Astudyofsomepalmsofcommercialimportancewithspecialreferencetothesapsandtheiruses.Philipp.J.Sci.Sect.A,6:99145
GiffardPL1967LePalmierRnierBorassusaethiopumMART.BoisetFortsdesTropiques.116:313.
GrimwoodB.E1975CoconutPalmProducts,Theirprocessingindeveloppingcountries.FAOAgriculturalDevelopmentPaperNo.99.FAO.pp.189192.
HamiltonLSandMurphyDH1988UseandManagementofNipaPalm(Nypafruticans,Arecaceae):aReviewEconomicBotany.42(2):206213.
HartleyCWS1977TheOilPalm(ElaeisguineensisJacq.).2nded.LongmansandGreenLondon.pp.600603.
JahielM1993LepalmierdoumHyphaenethebaica(L.)(Mart.).Flamboyant.BulletindeliaisondesmembresduRseauArbresTropicaux.28:410.
JambulingamRandFernandesECM1986MultipurposetreesandshrubsonfarmlandsinTamilNaduState(India).AgroforestrySystems4:1732.
JeganathanM1974Toddyyieldsfromhybridcoconutpalms.CeylonCocon.Q.25:139148.
JohnsonDJ1987PalmsasMultipurposeCashandSubsistanceTreeCrops.In:ProceedingsofaninternationalworkshopheldinPataya,Thailand,25November1987,pp.222236.
JohnsonDJ1997Nonwoodforestproducts:tropicalpalms.RAPPublication1997/10.FAO,Bangkok.pp.166.
KahnF1988EcologyofEconomicallyImportantPalmsinPeruvianAmazonia.AdvancesinEconomicBotany6:4249.
KhieuBorinandPrestonTR1995ConservingbiodiversityandtheenvironmentandimprovingthewellbeingofpoorfarmersinCambodiabypromotingpigfeedingsystemsusingthejuiceofthesugarpalmtree(Borassusflabellifer).LivestockResearch
forRuralDevelopement(7)2:http://www.cipav.org.co/lrrd/lrrd7/2/5.htm
KhieuBorinB1996Astudyontheuseofthesugarpalmtree(Borassusflabellifer)fordifferentpurposesinCambodia.M.Sc.ThesisSwedishUniversityofAgriculturalSciences,Uppsala.pp.67.
KiewR1989UtilizationofPalmsinPeninsularMalaysia.MalayanNaturalist43(1&2):4367.
KiewR1991PalmutilizationandconservationinPeninsularMalaysia.In:PalmsforhumanneedsinAsia.PalmutilizationandconservationinIndia,Indonesia,MalaysiaandthePhilippines.Johnson,D.J.(Ed).WWFProject3325.WWF&IUCN.
Rotterdam,pp.75130.
KovoorA1983Thepalmyrahpalm:potentialandperspectives.FAOPlantProductionandProtectionPaperNo52.FAO,Rome.pp.77.
LevangP1988Lecocotierestaussiuneplantesucrire.Olagineux,43(4):159164.
LubeigtG1977Lepalmiersucre,BorassusflabelliferL.,sesdiffrentsproduitsetlatechnologieassocieenBirmanie.Journald'AgricultureTropicaleetdeBotaniqueApplique.XXIV(4):311340.
LubeigtG1979Lepalmiersucre(Borassusflabellifer)enBirmaniecentrale.PublicationsduDpartementdeGographiedel'UniversitdeParisSorbonne.No8.Paris.pp.197.
Magalon,M1930Contributionl'tudedespalmiersdel'Indochinefranaise.Paris,pp.185191.
MaravillaJNandMagat,SS1993Sequentialcoconuttoddy(sap)andnutproductioninLagunatallvarietyandhybridcoconutsPhilippineJournalofCoconutStudiesXVIII(2):715.
MathesDT1984Effectofextractionofinflorescencesapandtheremovalofimmaturefruitbunchesontheproductionoffemaleflowersincoconut.SriLanka.COCOS,2:4447.
MayPH,AndersonAB,BalickMJandFrazoJMF1985SubsistenceBenefitsfromtheBabassuPalm(Orbignyamartiana).EconomicBotany,39(2):113129.
MogeaJ1991Indonesia:Palmutilizationandconservation.In:PalmsforhumanneedsinAsia.PalmutilizationandconservationinIndia,Indonesia,MalaysiaandthePhilippines.Johnson,D.J.(Ed).WWFProject3325.WWF&IUCN.Rotterdam,pp.37
73.
MogeaJ,SeibertBandSmitsW1991Multipurposepalms:thesugarpalm.AgroforestrySystems13:111129.
MortonJF1988NotesonDistribution,Propagation,andProductsofBorassusPalms(Arecaceae).EconomicBotany,42(3):420441.
NaimSHandHusinA1984CoconutPalmSugar.In:CocoaandCoconuts:ProgressandOutlook.Ed.E.Pushparajah&ChewPohSoon.KualaLumpur1517October1984.pp943946.
NiangM1975LeRnierdanslaRgiondeThisEtudegographique.NotesAfricaines.147:7782.
OkerekeO1982ThetraditionalsystemofoilpalmwineproductioninIgboEzelocalgovernmentareaofAnambrastateofNigeria.AgriculturalSystems.9:239253.
PivkeAEA1985Tappingpracticesandsapyieldsofthenipapalm(Nipafruticans)inPapuaNewGuinea.Agriculture,EcosystemsandEnvironment.13:5972.
PearceKG1991PalmutilizationandconservationinSarawak(Malaysia).In:PalmsforhumanneedsinAsia.PalmutilizationandconservationinIndia,Indonesia,MalaysiaandthePhilippines.Johnson,D.J.(Ed).WWFProject3325.WWF&IUCN.
Rotterdam,pp.131173.
PethiyagodaU1978Coconutinflorescencesap.PerakPlanters'AssociationJournal.Malaysia.pp.8691.
PortresR1964LePalmierRnier(BorassusaethiopumMart.)danslaprovinceduBaoul(Cted'Ivoire).Journald'AgricultureTropicaleetdeBotaniqueApplique.XI(12):499515.
ProfiziJP1988SwampyAreaTransformationsbyExploitationofRaphiahookeri(Arecaceae)inSouthernBenin(WestAfrica).HumanEcology16(1):8794.
PurnomoH1992SugarComponentssofCoconutSugarinIndonesia.ASEANFoodJournal.7(4):200201.
QuimboLL1991IncreasingNipaSapYieldThroughImprovedMechanicalTapping.Technology!PCARRD.ThePhilippines.XIII(4):pp.16.
RangaswamiG1977PalmtreecropsinIndia.OutlookonAgriculture(UK).9(4):167173.
RedheadJ1989Utilizationoftropicalfoods:trees.In:FAOFoodandNutritionPaperNo47:3.FAO,Rome,pp.52.
RomeraJP1968LeBorassusetlesucredepalmeauCambodge.L'AgronomieTropicale.8:801843.
SodahAyernorGKandMatthewsJS1971TheSapofthePalmElaeisguineensisJacq.asRawMaterialforAlcoholicFermentationinGhana.TropicalScience.XIII(1):7183.
SpeedyAW,DalibardCandSansoucyR1997Livestockfeedresourceswithinintegratedfarmingsystems.SecondFAOElectronicConferenceonTropicalFeeds.http://www.fao.org/waicent/faoinfo/agricult/aga/agap/frg/
StewartL1994AguidetoPalms&CycadsoftheWorld.Angus&Robertson.Sydney,pp.244.
SumadiG1988Arengapinnata:APalmforAgroforestry.In:ProceedingsofaninternationalworkshopheldinPataya,Thailand,25November1987,pp.149150.
TheivendirarajahK,DassanayakeMDandJeyaseelanK1977StudiesontheFermentationofKitul(Caryotaurens)SapCeylonJ.Sci.(Bio.Sci.)12(2):147150.
TheivendirarajahKandJeyaseelanK1977AnEvaluationoftheMethodsEmployedinthePreservationofKitulSap.CeylonJ.Sci.(Bio.Sci.)12(2):150155.
TheivendirarajahK,JeyaseelanKandPuvirajasingamV1979SomeAspectsofFermentationofCoconut(CocosnuciferaL.)Sap.CeylonJ.Sci.(Bio.Sci.)13(1&2):7987.
TuleyP1965aStudiesontheproductionofwinefromtheoilpalm.J.NigerianInst.OilPalmRes.4:284289.
TuleyP1965bTheproductionofRaphiawineinNigeria.Explagric.I:141144.
UdomDS1987Economicsofoilpalmwinetapping.NigerianJournalofPalmsandOilSeeds.VIII(1):5677.
VanDieJ1974ThedevelopingfruitsofCocosnuciferaandPhoenixdactyliferaasphysiologicalsinksimportingandassimilatingthemobileaqueousphaseofthesievetubesystem.ActaBot.Neerl.23(4):521540.
VenncioMachadoJ1974ProduoeindustrializaodederivadosdecocoemMoambique.Agron.moamb.,LourenoMarques,8(1):6169.
Annex1:Location,management,productsandtappingtechniquesoftappedpalmsspecies
Latinname
(Commonnames)
Acrocomiaaculeata
Acrocomiamexicana
Arecacatechu(Arecapalm,betel
palm,arecanut)
Regionsandmanagement
Products
LatinAmericaandtheCaribbean(Haiti)[32]
Honduras[37]
Wine[32]
Wine[37]
Tropicalrainforestto900mS&SEAsia:India,IndonesiaImprovedcultivatedpalm[1]
Sugar(jaggery),freshjuice,toddy
Tappedparts
Terminalbudonfelled
trees[37]
SameasforArenga
pinnata
seedasmasticatory,edibleheart,leavesforthatch,leafsheathsforhats,containers,
trunkforwood,dyesource,etc.[1]
Arengapinnataorsaccharifera
Tropicalrainforestintodryforestto1,200mS&SEAsia:India,Thailand,Cambodia,Malaysia,Indonesia(N Sugar(jaggery),freshjuice,toddy[1],vinegar[2]starchfromtrunk(sago),
Male(andrarely
(Sugarpalm,toddypalm,lontar)A. Sumatra,WJava,EBorneo,NSulawesi),PhilippinesUnimprovedcultivatedormanagedpalm[1]Strong
seawaterresistantfibrefromleafsheath,edibleheart[1],ediblefruits,leavesfor
female)inflorescence
undulatifoliainBorneoA.tremula candidatefordomestication[32]
roofing,formakingbrooms,matting,baskets,cigarettepapers,etc.[3]
spadixorsecondary
inthePhilippines
stems
Arengawightii
SAsia:endemictoIndia(Kerala,Karnataka,TamilNadu)[32]
Toddy[32]
Peduncle[32]
Attaleasp
CentralandSAmerica[38]
Freshjuice,wine[38]
Terminalbud[38]
Beccariophoenixmadagascariensis CentralMadagascar(1,000m)
Freshjuiceleaves:hats[4]
Betsimisaraka:trunk
[4]
Borassusaethiopium
Tropicalsavanna[1]From500(even200ifsuperficialwateralsotreebenefittingfromdewsandfogs[5])to Wine,freshjuice,vinegar[34]potentialforsugarproduction[7][8]whichis
Terminalbud,lateral
(Africanpalmyra,Africanfanpalm)1,300mmyearlyrainfallwith6to8monthsofdryseason[6]Africa:Senegal(This,Casamance),Gambia,
deniedby[9]edibleimmaturefruit,terminalbud,youngrootsandgerms,leaves portionofyoungstem
Guinea,IvoryCoast,BurkinaFaso(Banfora),Cameroon,GabonSemiwildorwildpalms[1]Candidatefor
forthatch,weaving,woodforbuilding[1][7]
orbunches
domesticationwithagroforestrypotential[32]
Borassusflabellifer(Sugarpalm
Tropicalforestintosavannato750m[1]EastAfrica:ZanzibarAsia:PersianGulf,coastlineofIndia,SriLanka,Sugar"candy",jaggery,toddy,palmjuice,arak,vinegar,yeastforbread[11]edible Inflorescencespadix,
tree,fanpalm,palmyrapalm,toddy Bangladesh,Burma,Thailand,Malaysia,Indonesia(Borassussundaicus(lontarpalm)[10])Laos,Cambodia,
fruitsandshoots,leavesformanuscripts,timber,fuel,buildingmaterial,canoe,fan spatheofmaleand
palm,desertpalm,lontarpalm,
Vietnam,ChinaUnimprovedcultivatedormanagedpalm[1]Candidatefordomesticationwithagroforestry [12],fromleafstalk:fibre(exportedfromTamilNaduto40countries[13]),fences femaletreesorfruits
brabtree,rondier)
potential[32]
[10]leavesforthatch,weaving[1]
Borassusmadagascariensis(Rnier Alongrivers[4]Madagascar
Wine
Inflorescencespadix
Malgache)
[4]
Calamusvanuatuensis
Pacific:endemictoVanuatu[32]
Sap[32]
Stem[32]
Caryotaurens(Indiansagopalm, Tropicalrainforest,especiallyprimaryforest[1]to1,500m[14]Asia:India,SriLanka,Indonesia,Malaysia,
Honey,sugar(jaggery),freshjuice,toddy[11]Priceofsugarabout50%over
Inflorescencespadix
toddypalm,kitulpalm,fishtail
CambodiaSPacificUnimprovedcultivatedormanagedpalm[1]Domesticationpotentialinagroforestry
Borassusflabelliferandalsohigherpricethancoconut[15]fibrefromleafsheath,
palm,caryotapalm)C.cumingiiin systems[32]
starchfromtrunk(sago),seedschewedassubstituteforbetelnut,edibleheart[1]
thePhilippines
[11]
Tropicalrainforest,coastalareasto300mEAfrica:MozambiqueAsia:SouthernIndia,SriLanka,Thailand, Sugar(jaggery),freshjuice(occasionallytappedinMozambique[16]),wine,arak, Unopenedflower
Cocosnucifera(Coconutpalm)
Cambodia,Malaysia,Indonesia(CentralJava),PhilippinesPacificislandsImprovedcultivatedpalm[1]
vinegaredibleoil,fruit,heart,leavesforthatch,weaving,trunkforwood,etc.[1] spathe
Immatureinflorescence
Coryphaelataorutan(Bajurpalm, SEAsia:Indonesia,PhilippinesUnimprovedcultivatedormanagedpalm[1]StrongcandidateformanagementPhilippines:fermenteddrink,vinegar,muscovadosugar[17]sago,clothes,hats,
growingpointor
Buripalm,sabalpalm)
ordomesticationwithagroforestrypotential[32]
furniture,ropesfromleaffibre,fencesfromleafstalks,woodforbuilding[10]
flowerstalks
Tropicalrainforestto600m
Coryphaumbraculifera(Talipot
Sugar,wine[1]starchfromtrunk,leavesformatting,paper[1]
S&SEAsiaUnimprovedcultivatedormanagedpalm[1]Strongcandidateformanagementordomestication
palm)
withagroforestrypotential[32]
Felledorstandingtrees
Elaeisguineensis(Oilpalm,African WAfrica:CapeVerde,Senegal(Casamance),Guinea,Ghana,IvoryCoast,NigeriaMadagascar[4]Indonesia Wine,strongalcohol(over80%)[18]edibleoil,heart,leavesforthatch,weaving, terminalbudormaleor
oilpalm)
[6]Improvedcultivatedpalm[1]alsowildinNigeria[31]
petiolesforfencing,construction[1],medicinalandcosmeticuses[19]
maleandfemale
inflorescences
Gronophyllummicrocarpum
SEAsia:Indonesia(Moluccas)[35]
Sapstarchleavesforthatch[35]
Inflorescence[35]
Hyphaenecoriacea
SEAfricaMadagascar[32]
Wine
Terminalbud
Hyphaenepetersiana
SWAfrica:Namibia[32]
Wine[32]
Flowerbud[32]
Terminalbudorbasis
Hyphaeneshatan
Madagascar
Wine
oftheinflorescence[4]
Hyphaenethebaica
Semideserts&desertsofEAfricato600m[1]:Djibouti[20],Eritrea[21]Unimprovedcultivatedormanaged
Terminalbudoronly
Wineediblefruitandheart,fruitformedicinaluse,leavesforweaving[1]
(Doomordumpalm,gingerbread palm[1]Candidateforimprovedmanagement[32]
futureleaves
palm)
Jubaeaspectabilis(ChileanWine
Chile
Wine
Trunkoffelledtrees
Palm)
Mauritiaflexuosa(Swamppalm,
Tropicalrainforest,areassubjecttofloodsNorthernSAmerica(Bolivia,Brazil,Colombia,Peru,Venezuela) Wineedibleoil,fruit,heart,starchfromtrunk,leaffibreforrope,petioleforcork, Trunkorinflorescence
moriche,buriti,muriti,aguaje,fan
[32]Semiwildorwildpalms[1]
trunkforwood[1]
stalkoffelledtrees
palm)
Freshjuice,toddy,arack,sugarandvinegarediblealmonds,saltfromthepetiole
Tidalareas(salttolerant)Asia:India,SriLanka,Bangladesh,Burma,Thailand,Cambodia,Malaysia,Indonesia,
Nypafruticans(Watercoconut,nipa
andstemashes,frondforthatchingandweaving[11][1][36],cigarettepaper[24],
PhilippinesPacificMainly,wildalmostpurestands[22]Unimprovedcultivatedormanagedpalm[1],also
Inflorescencespadix
palm,apungpalm)
leavesmadeintoshinglesforroofingandwallingpurposes,hats,mats,raincoats
managed:plantedpurestandsreplantingnotnecessary[23]Candidateforimprovedmanagement[32]
[25]
Stumphollowedout
Orbignyamartiana(BabassuPalm) WiderangeofedaphicandclimaticconditionsTropicalLatinAmerica:Brazil[33]
Winefruitassourceoffood,feed,oilandcharcoaledibleheartsaltfromburnt
afterfellingthetree
stemsleavesforthatch,weaving[33]
O.cohune
O.cohuneinHonduras[37]
[33]
Phlogapolystachya
Madagascar[4]
Freshjuice,wine
Trunk[4]
Subtropicalsemidesertanddesert[1]NAfrica:Tunisia,EgyptSAsia:India[34]Improvedcultivatedpalm Wine,arack,sugarediblefruit,leavesforthatch,weaving,trunkforwood,etc.[1] Terminalbudoronly
Phoenixdactylifera(Datepalm)
[1]
[34]
defoliation
Terminalbudorsideof
Phoenixreclinata(Dwarfdate
Palmgur,wineediblefruitandheartveryresistantbuildingmaterialthatch,
SEAfricanearthecoast[26]WAfrica:CapeVerde,Senegal(Casamance),IvoryCoast[6][19][27]
youngstemor
palm,raffiapalm)
weavingbagsandmats,sponges,toys[19][34]
inflorescence[32]
Phoenixsylvestris(Wilddatepalm, Tropicalrainforestto1,500mSAsia:India,BangladeshWAfrica:IvoryCoastUnimprovedcultivatedor
Wine,sugar[32]ediblefruit,fuel,mat,buildingmaterial,fencing[12]leavesfor Terminalbudorsideof
toddypalm,silverdatepalm)
managedpalm[1]Bangladesh:plantations[28]Domesticationpotentialwithinagroforestrysystems[32]
weaving[1]
youngstem
Terminalbudonfelled
Pseudophoenixekmanii
Caribbean:DominicanRepublic[32]
Wine[32]
trees[32]
Terminalbudonfelled
Pseudophoenixvinifera
Caribbean:DominicanRepublic,Haiti[32]
Wine[32]
trees[32]
Raphiahookeri,
R.vinifera,
R.palmapinus,R.regalis,
Tropicalrainforest,swamps,areassubjecttofloods[1]WAfrica:IvoryCoast,SMali,SBurkinaFaso,Benin,
Terminalbudonfelled
Nigeria,EasternCameroun[8][29]R.hookeri:SBenin:wildstandsthatdonotneedreplantationwhenadult Freshjuice,wine,strongalcohol[30][32]ediblefruit,oil,leavesforfibre,thatch, treesorterminal
treesaretappedcultivationalsopractised[30]R.ruffia:WetareasofMadagascar[4]Semiwildorwildpalms petiole,leafrachisforbuildingmaterial[1]
inflorescenceon
R.sudanica,R.ruffia(Raffiapalm, [1]Candidatesforimprovedmanagement[32]
Africanpiassava,Africanwine
palm,RattanPalm)
standingtrees
References:[1]Johnson1987[2]Davis1988[3]Sumadi1988[4]Decary1964[5]Niang1975[6]Giffard1967[7]Bellouard1950[8]Chevalier1930[9]Portres1964[10]Fox1977[11]Redhead1989[12]Abedinetal1987[13]Jambulingam
andFernandes1986[14]Rangaswami1977[15]Dissanayake1986[16]VenncioMachado1974[17]Abrenillaetal1988[18]Essiamah1992[19]BlancPamard1980[20]Jahiel1993[21]Fanshawe1966[22]HamiltonandMurphy1988[23]
Encendencia1985[24]Kiew1989[25]Quimbo1991[26]Cunningham1990[27]Adand1954[28]Annett1913[29]Fyot1973[30]Profizi1988[31]Okereke1982[32]Johnson1997[33]Mayetal1985[34]Baumer1995[35]Mogea1991
[36]Pearce1991[37]Balick1990[38]Stewart1994.
Annex2:Productionparametersofmaintappedpalmspecies
Ageoffirst/lasttapping
(years)Heightoftree
Arenga
36l/dayperpeduncle(2to4canbetappedinatree, From512to2to5years
pinnataor eachfor1to4months[1])11to16.5%0.4kg/day later[2][4][1]7to1520m
saccharifera [2][3][4]NorthSulawesi,goodtrees:35to40l/day [1]
[5]
Latinname Litresofsap/treeSugar%Sugar/tree
Borassus 5to6l/day2months/yearthroughbruisingand
10to20mhigh[11][9]
aethiopium cuttingbunches[7]100l/tree/year[8]IvoryCoast
andSenegal:200to300l/treeonlyduringonemonth
with912lpeakonthe20estday[9][10]Upto20%
[50]
Borassus
flabellifer
Caryota
urens
Cocos
nucifera
Corypha
elataor
utan
FrequencyoftappingSeasonDuration
Sugar/haTree/haWorkneeded
Oncetotwiceaday[2][1]2to9withaverage5months Indonesia:3kg/day/ha(256trees/ha)[5]
[2][4]allyearroundinEastKalimantanandNorth
PureplantationinNorthSulawesi:20,000kg/year
Sulawesi[1]
(80kg/tree/year)[6]
Twice(IvoryCoast)tothreetimes(Senegal)aday[11] 500trees/ha[12]
4to6monthsbeforedeath[11]8monthsifclayeyor
claysiltedsoils[11]Senegal:allyearroundbuton
differentareas:plateauinrainyseasonlowareascloseto
forestindryseason[9]betteryieldsattheendofthedry
season:FebruaryandMarch[10]
3l/daythefirst3monthsand1.5the3last8to20% 2030to5060yearsold[2] Onceortwiceaday[2][13]
1,500kgwith250300trees/ha[7]100trees/hainTamilNadu[22]Madura(Indonesia):
0.5to0.25kg/day[13][14][12][15][16]
1517to45withoptimum
70kg/yearpergoodtreeplantedat6minterval[23]Cambodia:70kg/tree/year(42kg
2533inBangladesh[20] (nightcollection=twicethedaycollection[23])
sugar&28kgmolasses)[16]Cambodia:if200trees/ha:18,000kg/year[18]Upper
150l/tree/year[3]
Burma:upto80to100years
Burma:averagetapper:4050treestwice/day:malesduringfirstpartof8monthseason,
ofproduction[21]From10 5months,every3rdyearrested[2]Mar.toOct.inUpper femalesduringsecondpart[24]Cambodia:goodtapper:2530treestwice/day
6065kgsugar/tree/year[8]
Burma[24]Nov.toAprilMayinCambodia[13]Jan.to (4x2hrs/day)[16]
12mto2030m[14][22]
Burma:from45mwhen15 MayinTamilNadu[22]Dec.toJuly[16]Outerarcof
370400l/femaletree/year[12]
thelesserSundaislands(Indonesia):dryseason(Apr.to 20treestwice/dayifassistantatthebaseofthetree[18]
20yearsold[21]
Nov.with2peaks,oneinAprilMayandahigheronein
5to10l/dayaveragewithminimumof1and
Sep.Oct.)[23]
maximumof20(Paulas1983,Tjitrosoepomoet
Pudjoarinto1983citedby[17],[18])11to20l/day
inIndonesia[51]
Borassusmadagascariensis:1l/dayduringoneweek
[19]
5to27l/day(upto60)[2][25][3][26]1516%
1015to210yearslater[2]
including9.8to13.6%sucrose[15][14][26][27]
[14](flowersonlyevery23
years[26])1520m[14]
muchshorter/Borassus
flabelliferwhenstarts
flowering[15]
1to1.5l/day[14]1l/day/spadix[25]SriLanka:0.9
to1.5l/dayallyearround(Nathanael1955citedby
[6])[28]SouthSumatra:5to15l4to6%
SouthSumatra:7yearsEast
0.44kg/day[29]9.5to18%[25][14](Norrisetal.
Java:duringmorethan20
(1922)citedby[28])SriLanka:2.2l/dayduring14
years[29]2030m
monthsfromhybrid(TypicaxPumila)[30]Malaysia:
17%sucrose[31]SriLanka:1622%sugar[32]
Assumption[33]:30kg/year
20l/dayfor34months[49]Upto45.2l/day[34]
Flowersoncewhen20over
17%sugarSeveralhundredsofkgofsucroseto
100yearsoldanddies[23]
death[6]2,699lduring132days(Gibbs1911cited
2040m[35]
by[34])
Felledtree:34l/day[10]
14%SprechervonBernegg1929citedby[6]
dependsonnumberofmaleinflorescencesavailable: 6to10ormoreyearsfor
felledtreetechnique[34]
Senegal(Casamance):5l/dayforatreewith8
Twiceaday[26]
110kgofsugar/tree/year[26]
36months[26]
Throughouttheyear[14]
averageof2spathes(upto3)tappedsimultaneouslya
newfloweringaxisproducedeachmonth[29][33]
Assumption[33]:4,448kg/ha(148trees)SriLanka:Tallvariety(Typica):13,590kg/ha
(158trees/ha)Dwarfvariety(Pumila):3,950kgsugar/ha(247trees)hybridof2:
19,027kg/ha[30]2530trees/tapper/workingdayifpalmsnotconnected7590ifpalms
connected(Nathanael1970citedby[17])about5hrs/day/35trees[29]
Twicedaily[2]
Twice(IvoryCoast)tothreetimes/day[10][34]
3134kgsucrose/semiwildoilpalm/year(SprechervonBernegg1929citedby[6])
2weeksto4monthsonfelledtrees[34]Nigeria:yields
highestatthebeginningofrains(increasedphysiology >450kg/year(150trees)[38]Nigeria:1,200kg/yearwhenmaleandfemaleinflorescences
inflorescences(4femalesand4males)[36]149
Elaeis
guineensis l/month(Hartley1977citedby[34])1112%[37]
Hyphaene
thebaica
MaleInflorescenceofpalmsthatdonotproduce
enoughfruitsforoil:26l/tree/year(about0.2l/day)
[38]
Senegal(Casamance):10to activityinMarchApril)andendofrains(moremale
15yearsofproduction[36] inflorescencesfortappinginOct.Nov.)([38],Hartley
1977citedby[34])Senegal(Casamance):Octoberto
710m[36]
June(dryseason)saplessconcentratedduringrainy
season[36]allyearround(4to5months/tree)[38]23
weekspermaleinflorescence[47]
Upto4l/day[40]
Upto30m[40]
Jubaea
340to450ltodeath[17][33]
spectabilis
Upto4times/day1425daysandthen2.5yearrest
beforenexttapping[40]
tapped(148trees)[39]Ghana:20to100treestappedtodeathperfarmerperseason
Nigeria:estimateof14/22treestappedpertapperperworkingdayof5/8hours
respectively(maleandfemaleinflorescences):onehectareof150treesrequires2tappers
asonlyonethirdofthepalmsaretappedatanyonetimeaverageof11mn/treetwicea
day[39]
From2025to4050trees/tapper[40]
Once/daySeveralweeks[17]
3,000kg/year([2][25])to10,000kg/year(2,000plants)[13]Gibbscitedby[4]3,800to
45to55[13][25]
4,500kg/year(2,500plants,700750sapproducing)[42][43]PeninsularMalaysia:
0.6to1.8l/day[3]0.5l/day/fruitingheadforabout1
Oncetotwice(forhighyieldingtrees)daily[2]
20,300kg/year(500plantswith2stalkstappedperplant/340days/year)Watsoncitedby
monthupto26fruitingheads/tree,ofwhich2can Trunkless:theinflorescence
Nypa
betappedatanyonetime[41]43l/year12%[25] iscarriedonastalkborneon [41][43]6months(3months/treebetweenJuly&Dec.) [41]Sumatraestate:22,400kg/yearasaconservativeestimate(Johnstoncitedby[43])
fruticans
0.5to3l/day1415%36to40l/tree/year[42]
therootstockandsticksout [13]throughouttheyear[41]Malaysia:allyearround PapuaNewGuinea:28,000kg/yearif50%ofpalmsfloweryearlyandmeantappingperiod
of100days[48]Sumatraestate:38workers/10haplot:30ontapping/collecting,5on
ofthegroundtoaheightof (Dennett1927acitedby[43])
1417%(Halos1981citedby[43])
maintenanceandpreparationofstalksthroughkicking,etc.,2onsyruptransportandone
about1m[43]
overseer(Johnstoncitedby[43])
19l/dayfromanotchinthestem(Bose1927citedby
Phoenix
40to50yearsofproduction Twicedaily[2]AutumninMediterraneanregions[50]
[34])9l/nightduring50nights[50]810l/day(500
dactylifera
[50]
Warmseason,onceeveryfiveyearsfor3to4months[52]
tomorethan1,200l/tree)10%1kg/day[52]
Phoenix
Saprichinsugar[10]
10m[10]
reclinata
Bangladesh:from56to55
years,optimum1525[20] Oncedaily[44]Bangladesh:fromNov.toMarchwith Bangladesh:>8,000kg/year(1,250trees)[44]20treespreparedin1h20'[42]5060
Phoenix
10to40kgsugar/tree/year[3][42][44]10to14% [44]
sylvestris
greateryieldsinmidwinter[44]
trees/day/tapper300400/year[44]
Raphia
hookeri
2l/day[45]
0.5to1016m[44][14]
Flowersoncewhen710
yearsoldanddies47mup Twicedaily[45]
to8m(orless)[46]
Raphia
2l/day[19]
Madagascar:Trunkincised(45cmdeep)[19]
ruffia
References:[1]Mogeaetal1991[2]Redhead1989[3]Johnson1987[4]Davis1988[5]Sumadi1988[6]VanDie1974[7]Chevalier1930[8]Bellouard1950[9]Portres1964[10]BlancPamard1980[11]Niang1975[12]Giffard
1967[13]CrevostandLemari1913[14]Rangaswami1977[15]Dissanayake1986[16]Romera1968[17]Kovoor1983[18]KhieuBorinandPreston1995KhieuBorin1996[19]Decary1964[20]Abedinetal1987[21]Lubeigt1977
[22]JambulingamandFernandes1986[23]Fox1977[24]Aubert1911[25]Magalon1930[26]Dissanayake1977[27]Theivendirarajahetal1977[28]Grimwood1975[29]Levang1988[30]Jeganathan1974[31]NaimandHusin
1984[32]Theivendirarajahetal1979[33]Pethiyagoda1978[34]Essiamah1992[35]Abrenillaetal1988[36]Adand1954[37]EzeandUzoechiOgan1988[38]Tuley1965a[39]Udom1987[40]Audru1985[41]Kiew1989[42]
Fealy1925[43]HamiltonandMurphy1988[44]Annett1913[45]Fyot1973[46]Profizi1988[47]Okereke1982[48]Pivke1985[49]Johnson1997[50]Baumer1995[51]Mogea1991[52]Barreveld1993.
Gototop